PROGRAM NOTES

Introduction
The main purpose of this work is to provide program notes for all
my compositions, or, to be precise, all those I consider worthy of
retention. Others not mentioned here have been withdrawn, and I do
not wish them to be performed. I have not provided details here
for the theatrical works in the Patria cycle, but have merely
listed them in the order in which they were composed. They have
been discussed in detail in the book Patria: The Complete Cycle
(Coach House Books, Toronto, 2002).
The works are listed chronologically by the year in which they
were composed or completed. An index will list the works
alphabetically giving the number of each work for easy reference.
In an appendix, I will provide a list of errata in all published
scores, at least those errors that performances have revealed to
date.
I am frequently asked by performers and publicists to provide
program notes to my works. Some works have notes in the scores,
others do not. In this catalogue I shall say something about each
work, so that the collection as a whole could be taken as an
evolution of my thinking as a composer.
A word of warning. I am not always careful about bibliographical
details such as dates of composition or performance. This
information is presumably accurate in Stephen Adams biography up
to 1981, when the book went to press.1 One might expect this list
to have been updated by some ambitious doctoral candidate at one
of the Canadian beaneries, but these students are evidently
applying their talents to more glittering projects.
See: Stephen Adams, R. Murray Schafer, Canadian Composers 4,
University of Toronto Press, 1983, Appendix 1 Compositions of R.
Murray Schafer.
1

If Canada were another country, the composer might not be so much

alone. An assumption that the nations lustre might be enhanced by
autochthonous musical creativity would result not only in more
income for the creative personality (perhaps even a living wage)
but would also stimulate musical services of benefit to the
circulation of his or her creations.
Through most of my musical life I have been my own music copyist,
editor, publisher, publicist, agent and promoter there being no
publishers of serious music in Canada, no serious music
periodicals, few serious staff music critics on the major
newspapers, little serious study of Canadian music in our
universities, no serious commitment to Canadian music by our major
performing organizations, no policy on the presentation of serious
Canadian music on radio or television... which is why the present
document or any other attempts to present, publicize or preserve
Canadian music must be the result of personal incentive.
The works below are listed by the date composed. I have given each
work a number for convenience. I can only hope that this present
document may help to correct the hundreds of inaccuracies
currently appearing on the Internet referring to or featuring my
music: He has written over 70 works... he is the author of
three string quartets, etc.
Following Adamss example, entries will provide the following
information where applicable: title, date of completion, duration,
instrumentation and publisher.
Publishers addresses:
Arcana Editions, R.R.2 Indian River, Ontario K0L 2B0 Canada; Fax:
(705) 760-9778; Website: www.patria.org/Arcana.
Universal Edition, 38 Eldon Way, Paddock Wood, Kent, TN12 6BE,
England; Fax: (01892) 836038.

ALPHABETICAL INDEX OF COMPOSITIONS

Adieu Robert Schumann 42
Alleluia 106
Apocalypsis: Part 1: Johns Vision 46
Apocalypsis: Part 2: Credo 46
Arcana 35
Beautiful Spanish Song 92
Beauty and the Beast 53
Beyond the Great Gate of Life 33
Brbeuf 10
Buskers 68
Canzoni for Prisoners 12
Concerto for Accordion and Orchestra
87
Concerto for Flute and Orchestra 63
Concerto for Guitar and Orchestra 81
Concerto for Harpsichord 3
Concerto for Viola and Orchestra 101
Cortge 44
Le Cri di Merlin 74
The Crown of Ariadne 47
The Darkly Splendid Earth: the Lonely Traveller
The Death of Shalana 122
The Death of the Buddha 77
Deluxe Suite for Piano 96
Divan i Shams i Tabriz 28, 33
Dream Passage 24
Dream Rainbow Dream Thunder 72
East 37
Epitaph for Moonlight 21
The Falcons Trumpet 94
The Fall Into Light 114
Felixs Girls 51
Fire 69
Five Studies on Texts by Prudentius 13
Flew Toots for Two Flutes 120
3

83

Four-Forty 107
From the Tibetan Book of the Dead 23
Gamelan 49
A Garden of Bells 62
The Garden of the Heart 55
The Geography of Eros 15
Gita 20
Gitanjali 84
Hear Me Out 50
Hymn to Night 43
Imagining Incense 111
In Memoriam Alberto Guerrero 8
Isfahan 123
Jonah 48
Kinderlieder 6
Ko wo kiku 67
Letters from Mignon 65
Loving 17
Lustro 33
Magic Songs 78
Manitou 93
A Medieval Bestiary 97
Minimusic 25
Miniwanka 32
Minnelieder 5, 71
Music for the Morning of the World 29, 33
Music for Wilderness Lake 52
A Music Lesson 2
Musique pour le parc Lafontaine 86
No Longer than Ten (10) Minutes 27
North/White 38
Okeanos 31
Once on a Windy Night 95
Partita for String Orchestra 11
Patria No. 1, Wolfman 39
Patria: The Epilogue: And Wolf Shall Inherit the Moon
4

117

Polytonality 1
Protest and Incarceration 9
Psalm 34
Rain Chant 112
Requiems for the Party Girl 18
Scorpius 82
Seventeen Haiku 103
Shadowman 109
Six Songs from Rilkes Book of Hours 124
Snowforms 61
Sonatina for Flute and Harpsichord (or Piano) 7
Son of Heldenleben 22
The Star Princess and the Waterlilies 66
Statement in Blue 16
String Quartet No. 1 26
String Quartet No. 2 (Waves) 40
String Quartet No. 3 57
String Quartet No. 4 79
String Quartet No. 5 (Rosalind) 80
String Quartet No. 6 (Parting Wild Horses Mane)
String Quartet No. 7 104
String Quartet No. 8 110
String Quartet No. 9 119
String Quartet No. 10 (Winter Birds) 121
Sun 58
Sun Father, Earth Mother 64
Tantrika 70
Tanzlied 118
La Testa dAdriane 45
Theseus 60
Thunder: Perfect Mind 115
Three Contemporaries 4
Three Songs from the Enchanted Forest 91
Threnody 19
Train 41
Trio for Violin, Viola and Cello 125
5

89

Tristan and Iseult 88

Two Songs from the Spirit Garden 99
Untitled Composition for Orchestra No. 1
Vox Naturae 100
Wild Bird 102
Winter Solstice 113
Wizard Oil and Indian Sagwa 54
Wolf Music 116
You Are Illuminated 105
Zoroaster 30

14

1.

Polytonality, 1952; 4 min; pno; Arcana.

My first independent musical enthusiasm (that is, independent of

the repertoire chosen by my piano teachers) was for the
unsophisticated music of Les Six, with Jean Cocteau as their
pamphleteer. In Rapelle lOrdre Cocteau said, Musical bread is
what we want. In other words, simplicity. Aim sharp and shoot
fast was another of his maxims. Les Six sought to do just that
and I loved the ingenuousness of their style, Milhaud and Poulenc
in particular.

Polytonality is an obvious silhouette of Poulenc but, suppressing

some immature attempts to imitate Mozart, it is the first
composition Ill let stand.
2.

A Music Lesson, 1953; 4 min; voice, pno; Arcana.

The didactics of Cocteaus maxims plus Stravinskys notion of

music as a non-emotional medium are the influences in this little
opus, written when I was twenty. The first performance was at a
young composers workshop in Toronto. I accompanied Phyllis
Mailing (later to be my wife) with as deadpan a sound as the piano
could produce. Afterwards I mouthed Stravinskys credo on
emotionless music. Is that the way you feel about it? someone
asked from the audience. Thats how I feel, I said. Everyone
laughed. I have never forgotten the humiliation of that day.
3.

Concerto for Harpsichord and Eight Wind Instruments, 1954; 21

min; hpscd, 2 fl, ob, cl, bass cl, 2 bn, hn; Arcana.

The Harpsichord Concerto was written in the winter of 1954-5, my

last year of study with John Weinzweig. I was also studying
harpsichord at the time and had become fascinated with the
contrapuntal and rhythmic possibilities of the instrument. Wind
instruments were chosen for the accompaniment rather than the more
traditional strings because of their incisive clarity in
contrapuntal textures. My aim was to compose a two-dimensional
study. Depth was not so much a concern as surface etching. I had
7

developed an enthusiasm for the early etchings of Paul Klee at the

time, and dedicated the second movement to his memory.
The style of the work reflects my sustained interest in Les Six
and the neo-classicism of Stravinsky (with a couple of conspicuous
thefts from Da Falla and Janacek). The generosity of John
Weinzweigs teaching shows in that the piece does not mimic his
style. He never expected his students to copy him, unlike many
other notable teachers. John was also instrumental in arranging
the first performance-recording of the work by recommending it to
the International Service of the CBC in Montreal.
The first movement begins as a toccata, which is interrupted,
first by a march-like section and then by a chorale. The second
movement consists of a series of free variations on the chorale
theme. Beginning in a subdued manner, it rises to an astringent
climax in which the theme is stated in biting staccato chords
separated by long rests. From this point the movement moves
backward to the peaceful material of the opening. The final
movement is bright and transparent, a sort of Mediterranean
baroque, with snatches of Scarlatti woven into a lively polytonal
and polyrhythmic counterpoint.
The Concerto was my first attempt to write a long piece and, of
course, suffers from the same deficiencies as countless other
attempts by young composers. The principal problem in extending
music into longer forms is in the bridging of ideas. This is
particularly conspicuous in the first movement, where the toccata
is interrupted without warning by the march and then the chorale,
neither of which bear relationship to the opening material and
merely detract from the momentum of the movement. Some years after
it was written I abbreviated the first movement, which was too
long, though the faults I mentioned are still evident.

4.

Three Contemporaries, 1956; 10 min; medium voice, pno; Arcana.

The subjects of these songs, written in Vienna, were Benjamin

Britten, Paul Klee and Ezra Pound. The Britten song is a short
biography of the composer with a deadpan neo-classical
accompaniment. I sent a copy of it to Britten requesting a
meeting. He wrote back, and eventually we did meet when I
interviewed him for the book British Composers in Interview
(Faber, 1963).
The text for the Klee song comes from the composers diaries,
which I was trying to read in German. The style is
expressionistic, reminiscent of the young Schoenberg but much less
dense.
The Pound text is my own and is a bitter satire on Pounds
incarceration at St. Elizabeths Hospital in Washington after his
famous trial for treason. Pound was an early enthusiasm of mine,
and I wrote an article on him about this time, later published in
The Canadian Music Journal (Summer 1961). In the same magazine
(CMJ, Summer 1958, p. 55) John Beckwith reviewed the 1958 concert
at which Three Contemporaries was premiered by Phyllis Mailing and
Weldon Kilburn. Three Contemporaries was the success of the
concert, and is as original a work as this commentator has heard
from the pen of any Canadian lately. Shortly after this concert,
I decided to return to Europe, where I remained for another couple
of years, mostly in London.
5. Minnelieder, 1956; 29 min; mezzo-soprano, wind quintet;
Arcana.
This cycle of thirteen songs was written in 1956 while I was in
Vienna. I was trying hard to learn German, mostly by reading
novels and poetry, and this led me back to the Minnesinger (German
minstrels) of the eleventh, twelfth and thirteenth centuries.
Minne is the medieval German word for love, and the poems of
the period, like those of the French troubadours, deal with love

in all its states: impassioned, unfulfilled, bruised, unrequited,

jealous, etc.
At the University of Vienna I met a scholarly woman who offered to
teach me Mittelhochdeutsch. The only English she could speak was
Anglo-Saxon, and for some reason known only to academics she was
engaged in translating Beowulf into medieval German. But she was a
generous teacher, and from her I learned both the vocabulary and
the presumed pronunciation of the ancient language. The
translations of the texts, given in the printed score, are mine.

Minnelieder is the only early composition of mine that still

receives fairly regular performances and has been recorded several
times. Some critics have noted traces of Mahler, which is quite
possible, considering the despairing nature of some of the texts
and the loneliness of my first year in Vienna. (See Appendix for
corrections to score.)
6.

Kinderlieder, 1958; 17 min; soprano, pno; Arcana.

Most of the texts for Kinderlieder are by Bertold Brecht, the

socialist poet and dramatist. Two of the texts (5 and 9) are
German nursery poems. My faith in socialism was strong at this
time; in fact a year after these songs were written I was to visit
several East-European communist countries, which discouraged any
enthusiasm I might have felt for the more extreme forms of
socialism without damaging my faith in a welfare state that looks
after all its people, including artists. (See Appendix for
corrections to score.)
7.

Sonatina for Flute and Harpsichord (or Piano), 1958; 10 min;

Arcana.

My friend, the flutist Bob Aitken, was only nineteen when I wrote
this little sonatina for him, but he was not the first to perform
it. The first performance took place in London in 1959, while I
was living there. I remember the harpsichordist very well. Celia

10

Bizony was a voluptuously senescent woman whose florid caressing

of the harpsichord keys prevented her small, indulgent audience
from discerning whether they were listening to Scarlatti or
Chopin. In Madame Bizonys whirling presence all music was
delirious, and I believe the little premire was quite successful,
though I have no memory of a flute player being present.
8.

In Memoriam Alberto Guerrero, 1959; 8 min; str orch; Arcana.

The Chilean pianist Alberto Guerrero (1886-1959) settled in Canada

in 1919, where he became a leading exponent of Debussy, Ravel and
their contemporaries, as well as a celebrated piano teacher. His
most famous student was Glenn Gould (who took pains to ignore his
teachers influence, preferring that the world should know him as
an autodidact), but he also taught other important Canadian
musicians including John Beckwith and Bruce Mather. I studied with
him for about a year in 1959. He knew I would never become a
pianist and our lessons usually consisted of talks about
philosophy (I recall discussing Comte, Husserl and Sartre with
him) or the modern painters and poets, particularly the French,
who were his favourites. He was one of the few musicians from whom
a student could get a vista of ideas beyond music, and it was with
great regret that I learned of his death while I was in Europe in
1959. In Memoriam was written in November of that year.
Evidently this is the only composition I wrote in 1959. During
this period I was attempting to support myself as a freelance
radio producer and music journalist. To be frank, I was not sure I
wanted to devote my life to music composition. I was considering a
career in writing or the media. It would still be a few years
before music would dominate my life.
9.

Protest and Incarceration, 1960; 13 min; 2 songs, mezzosoprano and orch; ms.

In 1959 I visited several countries behind the Iron Curtain

(Hungary, Romania, Bulgaria, Yugoslavia), ostensibly as a radio

11

producer and folk music enthusiast, though my real purpose was to

experience communism first hand. My socialist leanings helped to
procure the necessary visas, by no means easy in those days. This
is not the place to describe that eventful trip except to say that
a young Romanian woman exposed the dismal side of communism by
reading me some poems then circulating on mimeographed sheets by
anonymous or incarcerated poets, and since she was a student of
English, translating them for me.

Protest and Incarceration is a setting of two of these poems. It

is my first attempt to write a sustained atonal work, but has only
been performed once (March 10, 1968, by Phyllis Mailing with the
CBC Toronto Orchestra), and I am not sure whether it deserves to
be performed again. Failing the music, here are the texts.
PROTEST
Birthday Wishes for a Dictator
What shall I bring you for your birthday?
I know not what to give.
Bruised upon my bones, my skin alone do I have.
Since I have sighed in the yoke,
Since I have pulled in the harness,
All that was plenteous has melted away as snow.
The darkness deepens,
The nails upon my hands grow long with retribution.
Grow, my timid voice,
Grow as a daemon,
Grow as a great bird,
Gather in your flight,
And bring to the oppressor
The cry of orphans,
The suffocating voice of mothers, drowned with grief,
Hate of the whole country, rise up now,
Muster your curses,
Doom this day!
12

Curse it with fire and brimstone for the savage beast that it
bore,
The beast that would overthrow the world with his horns!
Now you must grow, my voice, little by little,
Like the spring grass, in volume increasing
As down the mountainside it falls.
Swell out of the forest,
Swell from the felled woods,
Grow out of the deserted villages,
Grow out of the ruins,
Grow from the depths of dungeons,
Where all that still lives is about to die!
INCARCERATION
Sunday... Tuesday... Friday...
Empty days, without form...
A great fog over the landscape...
I stand in time, terribly naked,
My soul in liquid eternity,
like an atoll in an ocean, beaten by waves...
Tuesday... Monday... What day is it?
My week is dead amassment,
My months pass through no calendar,
Sunday... The devil take you!
Stinking days! Stagnant days!
Here in the jaws of eternity, who shall count...
10. Brbeuf, 1961; cantata for baritone and orch; Arcana.
St. Jean de Brbeuf, the first missionary among the Hurons, came
to Canada in 1625. He spent a winter in the woods with tribes near
Qubec City and the following spring he paddled up the long
waterway to establish his mission on Georgian Bay, Lake Huron. He
was martyred there in 1649 by the Iroquois.
In constructing the libretto I drew on Brbeufs own account of
his voyage up the St. Lawrence to establish his second Huron
13

mission (1643), as described in Volume 8 of Rlations des Jsuites

the official report sent annually by the North American Jesuits
to France. I also incorporated into the work several of the
saints visions and premonitions of his own martyrdom, as
collected from other sources. The result is a descriptive
narrative of a spring canoe trip up the Great Lakes, interrupted
by a series of hallucinatory outbursts.
I had been looking for a cantata subject with a Canadian theme,
but it was Harry Somers who suggested Brbeuf, one day while we
were walking together in the Jardin des Tuileries in Paris.
Returning to London, I prepared the libretto and wrote the work
quickly, May 1-30, 1961.
Brbeuf was an important work for me, first of all because of its
length and its emotional complexity, but also because it was the
first time I tackled a Canadian theme, and that was something
destined to grow in future years. I drew an excellent cover for
the score and published a thousand copies of it, but the work has
only been performed twice to date (2001).
11. Partita for String Orchestra, 1961; 8 min; Arcana.
Two works for string orchestra were written in 1961, of which this
is the only survivor. A much more complex Dithyramb was also
completed; but I later withdrew it and the score has been lost or
destroyed.
The Partita is atonal, but its most significant feature is that
each of its four movements is twice the length of its predecessor:
the first movement is a mere thirty seconds, the second a minute,
the third two minutes and the last four minutes. With a stipulated
thirty-second pause between them, the whole work should be eight
minutes. There is nothing remarkable about this but it reflects
the influence of the material Peter Racine Fricker had me studying
at the time.

14

I had gone to Fricker, not because I felt the need of a teacher,

but merely to comply with the conditions of a Canada Council grant
I had received. Fricker understood this. We met in pubs mostly.
But the contemporary and medieval works he set me to analyse had a
decisive influence on the works I now began to compose.
12. Canzoni for Prisoners, 1962; full orch; Arcana.

Canzoni for Prisoners was my first purely orchestral work, written

in 1961-62. The prisoners I had in mind were prisoners of
conscience that is, non-violent objectors in any land who are
imprisoned merely for their beliefs. I had become a founding
member of Amnesty International, the organization devoted to
ridding the world of this intolerance. The issue had been brought
close to me, having visited several communist countries, though no
country is free of this injustice since rulers everywhere would
like to mute the opposition.
The work consists of five interconnected sections performed
without a break. It is based on a series of seventy-six notes,
which forms the material from which each section is constructed.
This work, and several others that immediately followed it, were
very much influenced by my discovery of the music of the
fourteenth-century composer-poet Guillaume de Machaut. Machauts
techniques were rigorous and mathematical, but his music is daring
and at times ecstatic, more so because of the constraints out of
which it seems to burst. I would like to think that this spirit
invades Canzoni for Prisoners freedom bursting out of
constraint.
The first performance was given in 1963 by the Montreal
Symphony Orchestra in a concert sponsored by the Canadian League
of Composers. I remember the enthusiasm of Serge Garant, whom I
met for the first time then. He had been a member of the program
committee and had argued vigorously for the inclusion of Canzoni
over the offerings of older, more conservative members.
15

I also remember something that today seems ridiculous, almost

funny. Canzoni contains several slow glissandi in the string
section. At the first rehearsal the concertmaster came up to me
and said: Monsieur Schafer, evidently you know nothing about the
violin. You cant be in two places at once. Which note do you wish
us to play? I told him I wanted the strings to start on one note
and slowly slide to the next over the allotted time. But
Monsieur, he said, raising his violin to demonstrate, either you
are in this position or you are in that position. Which position
are we in? I repeated my wish. He brusquely turned and called to
the orchestra, No glissandi! Of course what I had written was
technically possible, but the concertmasters traditional training
blocked his mental comprehension and made it impossible for him to
execute. It shows something of the difficulties of presenting new
music at the time.
When I walked on stage to take a bow, the applause trickled out
just as I was shaking hands with the conductor, Victor Feldbrill.
I made the long exit in silence, except that as I passed the
violin section I was greeted with a long sotto voce hiss.
13. Five Studies on Texts by Prudentius, 1962; 10 min; soprano, 4
fl; Arcana.
The texts for these songs are taken from Prudentiuss Scenes from
History (Tituli Historarium) and were intended to accompany
paintings of important biblical events on the walls of churches in
the Middle Ages. The five episodes chosen here form a miniature
Bible in themselves, from the story of Adam and Eve to the
revelation of John, with the birth of Christ occurring in the
centre.
All five studies are canonic; some quite strict, others quite
free. Sometimes the voices of the canon are distributed between
two instruments. This is the case in the second song where a
three-part rhythmic canon at the distance of one bar over a
16

melodic canon at the unison is distributed between two pairs of

flutes in alternate corners of the room. Each of the songs is
characterized by a restricted set of intervals: for instance, in
Adam and Eve the intervals are a perfect fourth, a minor second
and a minor third plus their inversions, while in Moses has
received the Law the intervals are a minor third, a major third
and a major seventh, and so forth.
The composition is intended for spatial performance with the
singer on stage and the flutes in the four corners of the room.
The spatial movement of the music is accordingly centrifugal in
Adam and Eve, diagonal in Moses has received the Law, and
circular in the crab canon The City of Bethlehem, which the text
describes as the centre of the world.
As for influences, the discipline of the work was prompted by my
admiration for Guillaume de Machaut. I had also heard a cycle of
songs by Luigi Dallapiccola for voice and clarinets that I found
inspiring. It was Peter Racine Fricker who turned me towards
Prudentius. He had also set some of his texts.
14. Untitled Composition for Orchestra No.1, 1963; 5 min; chamb
orch; Arcana.
This short, simple, quiet piece is another of several works
inspired by the rigorous techniques of the fourteenth-century Ars
Nova composers. It is a canon at the unison in perpetual
diminution, that is to say, each new entry is faster than its
predecessor. The quiet nature of the piece and its brevity
distinguish it from its predecessor, Canzoni for Prisoners, with
which it is, nevertheless, related.
15. The Geography of Eros, 1963; 10 min; soprano, chamb orch;
Arcana.
The following is the complete program note that accompanied the
premire of The Geography of Eros on a Ten Centuries Concert

17

(April 5, 1964) in Toronto. Ten Centuries Concerts was begun by a

group of Toronto composers and musicians to introduce both new and
little-known ancient music to the public. (See my article Ten
Centuries Concerts: a recollection in On Canadian Music, Arcana
Editions, 1984.)

The Geography of Eros is an aria for soprano and percussion

instruments. It was written last winter in Newfoundland while I
held the position of Artist in Residence at Memorial University in
St. Johns. The work bears the subtitle: from an untitled
composition editing unit eight. That untitled composition might
eventually bear a remote similarity to opera. Remote, I am
inclined to think, because the completed work I envision would be
too diffuse to fit even the loosest definition of that genre.
Visual images and spoken and written texts would form as important
a part of the composition as the music. However, since very little
of this work has yet been committed to paper, further prognosis
here would be untimely and possibly embarrassing.
More immediately, Geography bears a definite relationship to my
Five Studies on Texts by Prudentius (for Four Flutes and Soprano),
first performed last year. Geography is an antipode to Prudentius.
Prudentius was one of the strictest works I ever composed. By
contrast, Geography is completely free and almost contrivedly
athematic. The text for Prudentius was religious, narrative and
descriptive; the text for Geography is lyric, incantatory and
sexy. Both spiritually and musically Geography was a necessary
reaction to the rigorousness of Prudentius.

Prudentius was written for no singer in particular. After several

singers had declared it unperformable, Mary Morrison performed it.
After hearing her performance I immediately wanted to write
another work especially for her voice. Geography is that work.
Although in recent years most instruments have been exploited to
the limits of their sound-producing capabilities (often with
18

freakish results), the one instrument that has undergone little or

no exploitation at all is the human voice. Today much is made of
the difficulties of modern vocal music, the fragmentary
Webernesque line with its angular and ecstatic leaps; yet this
type of vocal technique is little more than an elaboration of
Wagner and represents but one of many traditions of vocal
technique available. For one thing, we have today two mutually
exclusive traditions in the classical singer and the jazz or pop
singer. The folk singing of numerous cultures shows us further
techniques. Here we learn the effectiveness of such devices as the
yodel, the glottal stop, the expressive use of quarter-tones,
unusual forms of vibrato and the production of whistling, clicking
and other sounds. A whole new world of vocables remains to be
explored by the classical composer.
Mary Morrisons interest in jazz and pop music (her husband, Harry
Freedman, began his musical career in jazz) made it possible for
me to include in Geography a certain number of vocal
embellishments characteristic of that field. My own study of
certain forms of folk music, particularly that of the Balkan
minstrels, has led to other incorporations which have by now, I
feel, become part of my own musical language.
The text for Geography is my own and consists of phrases and words
drawn at random from adolescent love poems. Textual obscurity is
partly intentional. Flavours are sought suggestions and
mysteries; meaning is ancillary. I wanted to create an aura in
half-lights, allusions, confused vibrations and nocturnal
thoughts, to decorate the experience of physical love with a net
of sounds and word-sensations.
Formerly The Geography of Eros was called Primavera, and in a way
it was inspired by Botticellis painting of that name or more
especially by one of the young ladies in it, though I do not find
her sexy. But there is something about that painting that suggests

19

to me a nascent and insouciant erotic sensitivity, with just the

right touch of lasciviousness.
This brings up a further aspect of Geography. Like many of my
recent works, Geography has undergone a number of transformations
before reaching its present state. It began as a haphazard
collection of poetical fragments, cut out and strewn on a page a
verbal collage, if you like. Later it became a large decorative
pen drawing in which the drama and dynamics of the poem-fragments
assumed graphic shapes. This in turn suggested its musical
dimensions, and it is in this form that it remains at present. In
the back of my mind, however, I see the possibility of its
ultimate performance being somehow the sum total of all its forms
and taking place in surroundings more like those of an art gallery
than a concert hall.
All these observations are, nevertheless, tentative, and much
everything depends on the relationship of Geography to the other
units of that larger composition I referred to at the beginning.
It is my plan to compose that work in a number of self-contained
editing units, which might be performed independently, but
always keeping the ultimate large-scale architecture in view.
However, for the moment Geography will have to be judged on its
independent merits.
16. Statement in Blue, 1964; 5 min; youth orch; Arcana.
In the summer of 1964 I was invited to join the teaching staff of
the North York Summer Music School to teach a class called
Musicianship, and was given a free hand to engage students in
discussion, exercises and improvisation. It was here that I began
to develop my ideas in musical creativity for young people, later
published in a series of pamphlets and eventually collected in The
Thinking Ear. I believed that music education without creativity
is sterile. My own dismissal from the music education program at
the University of Toronto in 1955 had proved that, but it took me
ten years to develop a counter program.
20

In the fall of 1964 I was chosen as one of fourteen composers to

write compositions for schools in a program sponsored by The
Canada Council and administrated by the Canadian Music Centre.
Statement in Blue was written at this time. It is the first of
several pieces in which young performers are required to
participate in shaping the music.
The score is graphic so that the notes chosen are free. A series
of shapes and suggestive words help stimulate the imagination.
Actually the piece could be performed tonally or atonally at the
discretion of the performers and the guiding teacher. It is
intended for a beginners orchestra of young performers but has
also been performed by adult orchestras of amateurs.
17. Loving, 1965, 75 min; 4 voices, 2 actors, dancers, chamb orch,
tape of electronic and pre-recorded sounds; Arcana.

Loving was composed in 1963-65 while I was Artist in Residence at

Memorial University in Newfoundland. The Geography of Eros and
some other sections of the work had been completed when Pierre
Mercure phoned with a proposal that Loving be commissioned for
production on television. The only complication was that it would
have to be produced in French since the producer would be the
French network of the CBC.
I went to Montreal and met with Pierre and Gabriel Charpentier.
The result was that we decided to make Loving a bilingual
production so that it could be broadcast on both the French and
English networks. And so its official title became Loving/Toi. But
the production was never completed and it was shown in an
abbreviated version. The story of why this occurred has never been
told before. For what its worth, this is what happened.
From my diary, Montral, June 8, 1965:
Much trouble. Pierre behaving strangely. Very nervous.
Domestic split imminent. Gabriel worried too. Pierre
21

drinking heavily, missing deadlines in rehearsals and

failing to check with technical people.
A few days later Pierre disappeared. Total chaos at Radio Canada
as rehearsals and technical affairs were rescheduled. Then, one
day Pierre called saying he wished to see me alone. I went to the
hotel address he gave me. He was behaving very strangely. He said:
You see, I rumple the bed up so they will think I sleep here, but
I dont sleep here. I begged him to return and he promised to do
so the next day. But the next day no one saw him. He called again
and asked me to come, now to a different hotel. This time his
supervisor came with me.
The room was dark. Pierre was wearing sunglasses. Before we could
say anything he took us by the arm and led us around the room
where he had pinned up cartoons from the daily papers. Look at
this one, isnt it funny? And now over here... Finally we sat
down and his supervisor gently persuaded Pierre that he needed
medical attention.
The problem now was what to do with the production. Eventually it
was decided that all the music would be recorded since the singers
and musicians had been contracted. The visual images would have to
be added later, after Pierres recovery.
Montral, July l2, 1965:
Too fatigued to write anything about the taping of Loving
yesterday. Satisfactory and even good in places. Assemble
and listen to tapes tomorrow objectively. Kind letter from
Pierre with apologies.
Pierre returned to the CBC in the fall of that year to add the
visuals. As I was then teaching at Simon Fraser University, I
couldnt be present. He called me one day and said the work was
complete and he was going to France for a holiday. In January 1966
he was killed in an automobile accident in France.
22

During my next visit to Montreal I saw what Pierre had done. There
were some beautiful scenes and experimental effects little-known
in television at the time. But the work was only about forty-five
minutes long. Nearly half an hour of music had been omitted. When
the work was shown on the English network of the CBC I was asked
to introduce it and speak about Pierre. Neither then nor until now
was the complete story of the production ever revealed.
(For a discussion of Loving see Patria and the Theatre of
Confluence, Arcana Editions, pp.13-26. The libretto is printed in
R. Murray Schafer: A Collection, Arcana Editions, pp. 49-64.)
I have waited since 1965 for a stage production of Loving. It
could easily be done since the resources are not extravagant and
projections could be used for dcor. About 1978 a concert version
was undertaken by Robert Aitkens New Music Concerts and toured
from Toronto to Ottawa, Montreal and Halifax. But Canada has no
interest in reviving its cultural history. It seeks to live
exclusively in the present tense and a work performed once is
simultaneously dead.
18. Requiems for the Party Girl, 1966; 19 min; mezzo-soprano,
chamb orch; Arcana.
This work, written for Phyllis Mailing and consisting of ten short
arias, was later to become the source of Patria 2, the first of
the Patria works to be completed. The narrator is a young woman,
very disturbed, describing various states of her existence
including, at the end, her own suicide. It is a serial piece and
uses for the first time the all-interval row that occurs in all
Patria works:
C natural, B natural, C sharp, B flat, D natural, A natural,
D sharp , A flat, E natural, G natural, F natural, F sharp.

23

(For an analysis of the work see: Bruce Mather, Notes sur

Requiems for the Party-Girl, Les Cahiers canadiens de musique,
Spring-Summer 1970, pp.91-97.) (See Appendix for corrections to
score.)
19. Threnody, 1967; 18 min; youth orch, choir, narrators, tape;
Arcana.
The texts, spoken by the young narrators in Threnody, are eyewitness accounts by children of the atomic bombing of Nagasaki on
August 9, 1945. The orchestra and choruses illustrate this
terrifying scene.
I had received a commission to write a piece for the Vancouver
Junior Symphony Orchestra shortly after arriving to teach at Simon
Fraser University. I wanted to write a piece for those young
performers that would make them think about social issues. The
Cold War was in high gear in 1967 and the stockpiles of nuclear
weapons were rapidly growing. I knew that these extremely graphic
accounts of suffering and death would affect both the performers
and their parents, forcing them to consider seriously the
consequences of nuclear war. Since there were numerous passages
where the performers were required to create their own music to
the accompaniment of particular texts, they had a more serious
role to play than if they had just inherited a ready-made
expression from the composer.
There were tears after the performance. But I also remember one
man coming up to me defiantly and saying, Wed drop it again! It
bothered me for months that a work devoted to the cause of peace
should have provoked such angry sentiments. But thank God, no
atomic bombs have been dropped since. (See Appendix for
corrections to score.)
(See also the article Threnody in The Thinking Ear, Arcana
Editions, pp.277-81.)

24

20. Gita, 1967; 14 min; choir SATB, 3 tr, 3 hn, 3 trm, tuba, tape;
Universal.

Gita was commissioned by the Fromm Foundation for performance at

the Tanglewood Festival in August 1967. The inspiration to choose
the Bhagavad-Gita for a text came to me one crystalline January
morning during a walk in the cold air of Isle Bzard, near
Montreal. I was visiting a friend and had been reading the Gita
the night before. The passage on serenity and the forces ranged
against it (II 55-64) had left a deep impression. That morning I
imagined a choir, as serene as newly-fallen snow, being hectored
by a group of brass instruments. The choir would sing in the
original Sanskrit, aloof and victorious.
The work employs the all-interval Patria tone row. For a brief
moment towards the end of the tape of electronic sounds there is a
short choral section from one of the motets in the Geistliche
Chormusik (1623) of Heinrich Schtz: Denn Jesus Christus, Gottes
Sohn... It seemed appropriate that the most serene figure ever
seen on earth should blend with the ancient Hindu text.
The same work was eventually to form the concluding scene of
Patria 1: Wolfman in which the innocent young girl (Ariadne)
touches the heart of the immigrant Wolfman.
21. Epitaph for Moonlight, 1968; 6 min; choir SATB; Berandol and
Universal.
One of my exercises for children was to ask them to invent
onomatopoeic words in their own secret language that sounded like
the thing they represented: raindrops for instance, or bells or a
sneeze or a kangaroo. Once I asked some eleven-year-olds to invent
some words for moonlight. Here are their words:
SLOOFULP
NESHMOOR
SHALOWA

25

NU-U-YUL
NOORWAHM
MAUNKLINDE
SHIVERGLOWA
SHEELESK
MALOOMA
SHIMONOELL
The words were so beautiful I decided to set them to music. The
piece was written in graphic notation but it is also an eartraining exercise, for the singers must pitch the notes by
interval from the preceding notes, so that one performance does
not differ from another to the extent one might expect. People who
dont read music are always delighted to discover that this is the
first piece they are able to follow because the graphic shapes
correspond so closely to the musical sounds.
Curiously enough, I once planned to destroy this
thinking that it had served its purpose. But the
Canadian Music Centre, Henry Mutsaers, pulled it
destined for the furnace. Im glad he did. It is
known choral piece.

little piece,
librarian at the
out of the pile
probably my best-

Why did I call it Epitaph for Moonlight? In 1969 American

astronauts landed on the moon to the excitement of the whole
world. But something died then. No longer would the moon be a
numinous and mythogenic symbol; it threatened to become a piece of
property covered with neon. That hasnt happened yet, but in
todays polluted cities with their twenty-four-hour glare, no one
even notices the moon anymore. The moon is dead. I saw her die.
22. Son of Heldenleben, 1968; 11 min; full orch, tape; Universal.
One day in 1967 I received a telegram from The Montreal Symphony
Orchestra. It read: Congratulations! Have been awarded commission
by the MSO. Wire acceptance immediately. I wrote back that,
flattered as I was by their surprising offer, no discussion had
26

yet taken place concerning the length of the piece, the deadline
date, and of course, the fee they were offering.
I have always liked the music of Richard Strauss. And one evening,
just after the details had been worked out with the MSO, Jack
Behrens and I were listening to Strausss tone poem Don Juan,
counting the number of erections of the main theme. The next
morning I awoke knowing that I wanted to do a rewrite of one of
Strausss poems. This was not a particularly original idea.
Several composers had done rewrites of classical works.
Nevertheless, I knew what I wanted to do, and the work I chose was
Ein Heldenleben (A Heros Life). The hero of this work is not just
Strauss, but it is Man at the centre of the universe, dominating
all other living creatures. I saw Heldenleben as a typical
exhibition of the nineteenth-century concept of progress and human
imperialism, and so Son of Heldenleben would have to be, to some
extent, a send-up of Strausss ideas.
Asked to provide a program note for the concert, I knew I couldnt
explain why I was defacing Strausss glorious, empurpled
masterpiece, so I wrote a preposterous one-line program note as
follows:
Who, having forgiven the grammatical difficulties of its
polyglottal title, can surrender himself to speculations of the
possibility that the hero may indeed have had a son, may,
recalling the old heros majestic presence, at first rejoice in
the simple news of rebirth, shortly thereafter, however, to
ponder the matter and its grave consequences, at first, perhaps
in an opacity of Freudian imagery, seeing by no means an
innocent resurrection of a great man in a quite natural filial
disguise, but rather a jealous competition for possession of
the mother-wife (who in our case would be none other than
Madame Strauss) but these people would be badly mistaken, for
I have no designs on the fair lady; and equally mistaken would
be those who see the attempt to reconstruct a great narrative
27

masterpiece as an act of crude plagiarism, for the question of

the prior discovery of ideas rests on the very disputable
philosophy of time as a rectilinear development, so that if one
could be persuaded to accept another idea of time say a
circular time as conceived by the Greeks the question of
plagiarism has no meaning, or at least can be argued to work in
both directions, so that the son and the father are
interchangeable, which is to say, and I am sorry if the idea
appears offensive to some people, that Strauss may indeed have
borrowed numerous musical ideas from me (though if this is the
case he has rather discourteously admitted nothing about it);
and thus I would ask you, dear reader, to speculate with me
momentarily on the inspiring case presented to us by Jorge Luis
Borges in his story of Pierre Menard, who devotes his life to
the noble occupation of reconstructing the vast story of Don
Quixote word for word, exactly as Cervantes gave it to us, for
here, as Borges is concerned to make clear, the question
transcends the copyright of ideas; Menard is not copying
Cervantes, he is laboriously discovering his thought-path word
by word so that in the end the reader must decide for himself
the intriguing question of whether the precisioned work of
Menard would perceptibly resemble the original, or perhaps be
its negative image, that is to say, a transposition of figure
for ground or vice versa, so that in our own case we might,
taking Strausss Heldenleben as a model, set about to fill in
the interstices between the notes of the original masterpiece,
thus rendering the whole picture palpable and thereby saying
some things left unsaid by Strauss; an activity which would,
however, leave us with a puny thread for a fabric during those
frequent passages where Strausss texture is distinctively fat
(Strauss having apparently wished to hog as many notes as
possible for himself) if I am not overbearing in applying
these porcine metaphors to the memorable masterpiece I have
chosen as my model; and accordingly, abandoning this approach
altogether, I developed at length another of which it is now my
purpose to inform my dear readers, and if they are capable of
28

following my thought-excursion, I am confident that they will

find this interpretive approach the most profitable; for this
method rests on the identification of the memorable tune as it
winds its way slowly, ever so slowly, through the combustions,
clouds and constellations of sound which surround and adorn it,
and having once firmly grasped it in the minds ear, never to
relinquish hold of it, but rather to hear it as a melodious
Ariadnes thread and guide through the labyrinthine corridors
of this orchestral minotauromachy, for any listener having
accomplished this will now immediately realize that, his memory
having been stimulated by the thought of Ariadne, he will be
thinking of none other than the hero Theseus himself, who, with
Ariadnes precious thread-gift like a borrowed theme which one
both possesses and does not possess but certainly cannot
disown, proceeds throughout the time and space of darkness
until at last he meets face to face the dreaded Minotaur, there
to do combat with him in the echoing corridors of Minoss
dreaded palace, until the monster is dead at his feet and he,
exhausted totally, goes home to bed (that is, to the delicate
bed of his beloved Ariadne) knowing that he has after all had
an experience which he will not directly forget.
The Ariadnes thread of Son of Heldenleben is the opening sixteenbar melody of the Strauss tone poem, rhythmically augmented
(almost exactly) at the rate a half note per sixteenth note in the
original score. Around this cantus firmus groups of instruments
dance and pulse atonally. There are occasional references to other
Strauss melodies from Heldenleben and a final swelling up of the
main theme at the end, before it is cut short by an electronic
chord. Owing to the inclusion of a tape of electronic sounds, I
decided to notate the entire score in 4/4 time with the metronome
set at sixty.
I sent the entire package, score, tape and program note off to the
MSO and heard nothing for some time. Then one day I got the
summons to come to Montreal to meet Maestro Franz Paul Decker, one
29

of those majestic foreigners to whom we have entrusted all our

major orchestras. I went (at my own expense) and waited outside
the door until Maestro could spare the time to see me. Everywhere
Decker goes he is followed by two stooges who punctuate all his
statements with Cest juste or Cest a. You know, Mr.
Schafer, only last veek ve are performing zee rrrreal Heldenleben!
Now zis... foolish joke vil not reflect vell on us, not at all.
Cest juste, etc. First I vould ask you to consider changing ze
title, No. But zis is impossible title! Impossible,
impossible, echo the two stooges. Audience vill laugh, but ze
vill not be laughing at me, ze vill be laughing at you, Mr.
Schafer. At you, at you, cest juste, cest juste!
At one point one of the stooges asks Maestro whether he would like
a cup of coffee; then goes and returns with (so help me) three
cups of coffee, which they drink. It then emerges that Decker
hasnt looked at the score yet. He opens it and asks, Vat is zis
at bottom of page?
Thats the notation for the tape of electronic sounds. I sent it
to you four weeks ago.
I have no tape recorder.
Thats right, Maestro has no tape recorder.
Cest juste, cest a.
Well, get him one, I announced with sudden impatience.
A very strange thing happened at the first rehearsal. The MSO
manager, Pierre Bique, came up to me and said, Monsieur Schafer,
Maestro is ill today. You will have to take the rehearsal.
Me? Im no conductor. The orchestra will kill me.
Then we will have to change the program and perform
Tschaikovskys Francesco da Rimini.
Ill do it. And I stepped up to the podium. With the
concertmaster beside me we began the rehearsal.
Theres a mistake in my part, says the bassoonist. And in
mine, says the clarinetist.

30

I know theyre trying to unnerve me but I address their concerns

patiently and accurately, scarcely looking at the score. The
atmosphere calms down, grows intensive. Everyone works hard. By
the time we get to the outbreak of the Heldenleben theme in its
original form I am sweating enthusiastically.
A break. And then what happens? Maestro miraculously appears and
without a word to me, steps up on the podium. Obviously one of the
stooges had called to tell him that the piece wasnt that
difficult and the orchestra wasnt in revolt.
The night of the concert, Montreal is hit with a blinding
snowstorm. The concert is cancelled. The premire will take place
tomorrow. The next evening I am to fly to England. I go to the
airport. The flight is delayed one hour, two hours, four hours....
I phone Istvn Anhalt to see how things went. He is ecstatic. He
reports that he listened with four ears and all ears enjoyed it.
And finally: A few years after the printing of Son of Heldenleben,
Strausss publisher in Munich got in touch with Universal Edition
in Vienna, demanding royalty compensation for borrowing the
Strauss theme. Eventually a deal was struck by which 50 percent of
all performance royalties go to the Strauss heirs; but I doubt
whether theyve been able to buy much beer with the proceeds.
23. From the Tibetan Book of the Dead, 1968; 8 min; soprano, choir
SATB, fl, cl, tape; Universal.
The text chosen for this work occurs at the beginning of the death
process as recorded in The Tibetan Book of the Dead.
O nobly-born, the time has now come for thee to seek the
Path. Thy breathing is about to cease. Thy guru hath set
thee face to face before the Clear Light [O Ariadne]; and
now thou art about to experience it in its Reality in the
Bardo state, wherein all things are like the void and
cloudless sky, and the naked, spotless intellect is like
31

unto a transparent vacuum without circumference or centre.

At this moment, know thou thyself; and abide in that state.
(Trans. W.Y. Evans-Wentz, Oxford, 1960, p.91)
The choir sings this text in the original Tibetan, which was
chanted for me by a Tibetan Lama (W.G. Surkang) in residence at
the University of Seattle. I had in mind that the work would
eventually fit into Patria 2: Requiems for the Party Girl, which I
had begun to assemble. (See below: Dream Passage)
24. Dream Passage, 1969; 80 min; mezzo-soprano, choir, actors,
chamb orch, tape; CBC radio program.
I list this work simply because it was the prototype of Patria 2:
Requiems for the Party Girl (see item 36). In fact almost all the
material was there and so was the form. The work was commissioned
by a very adventurous director of music at the CBC, the like of
whom has long since disappeared. It was John Roberts who gave
Glenn Gould a studio and an engineer to make a whole series of
radio programs, and it was John Roberts who accepted my proposal
for an experimental program combining music, electronic sounds and
foreign languages. The foreign-language speakers were employees of
the CBCs International Service in Montreal. The music was
recorded in Vancouver, and I put it together in the Sonic Research
Studio at Simon Fraser University.
25. Minimusic, 1969; duration variable; any small combination of
singers or instrumentalists; Universal.

Minimusic is a chamber piece for five or six players. It is an

extension of the work I had begun in music education by conceiving
pieces that would stimulate creativity. The score consists of
thirty-seven boxes, three per page. When they are cut loose one
can proceed from box to box in a variety of directions. Each box
specifies a special effect, sometimes a calculated improvisation,
sometimes a response to another performer, so that the players or
singers must be constantly listening to each other. When

32

rehearsing it I would often clap my hands and ask any one of the
players to tell us which boxes the other players are playing. So
while the work stimulates spontaneity it is at the same time a
serious ear-training exercise.
I conceived
students at
hours a day
were bowled
long enough

the piece originally for a group of high school

a summer camp in Maryland. We worked on it a couple of
for a week before performing it. The camp instructors
over and asked to perform it. But they didnt practice
and the performance was unremarkable.

Perhaps the total number of boxes in the printed score leads to a

complexity beyond the skills of some performers. A reduced number
of boxes might result in a simpler and clearer performance.
26. String Quartet No.1, 1970; 16 min; Universal.
My first string quartet was commissioned by the Purcell Quartet of
Vancouver in 1970. I really didnt want to write a quartet at that
time, considering the medium pass. I recall leaving the
composition until the very last moment, when I shut myself in my
brothers apartment in Toronto while he was on vacation, and wrote
furiously, completing the work in about a week.
The quartet is in one movement though there are well-defined
sections. It is based on a series, though not a twelve-note
series, rather a chromatic scale which gradually opens to
introduce other intervals. The chromatic chord of the opening
defines the first section. It is as if the players are locked
together, trying frantically to break free. Finally freedom is
achieved by the second violin, introducing the second section, a
quiet and open-interval melody played by the first violin with
slowly shifting chords played by the other three instruments. A
phase-shifting pizzicato section leads to a long arching refrain
in unison and octaves played by all the instruments. It begins
very slowly and quietly, then gradually increases in tempo and
intensity until it reaches a fury that explodes into the opening
33

chromatic cluster again. The final section is a recapitulation of

all the preceding material, now in fragments, signalled by
irregular snaps on the cello. At the end, the cello snaps are
followed by periods of silence, as if the camera goes on
clicking even though the film has run out.

Note: The printed score (Universal Edition) contains several brief

cuts which have been omitted in the two recordings of the work to
date (by the Orford and Molinari quartets). Although I made the
original cuts, I now feel the work flows better when they are
restored. (See Appendix for corrections to score.)
27. No Longer than Ten (10) Minutes, 1970; 10 min?, full orch;
Arcana.
The title was derived from the wording of the Toronto Symphony
Orchestra contract commissioning the piece: It is agreed that the
work shall have a minimum duration of approximately seven (7)
minutes and no longer than ten (10) minutes. It was the standard
Canadian contract for what we composers came to call a pice de
garage, intended for performance while the patrons were parking
their cars.
Emile Durkheim has somewhere said that we define the law by
breaking the law therefore crime is necessary. No Longer than
Ten (10) Minutes defines the ritual of the concert by breaking it.
I have often wondered why a work of art must be finished and
framed, why, on the contrary, it might not proceed out of chaos,
gradually emerge into clarity, then return again to chaos.
The management of the TSO had informed me that the new work would
have the distinction of being first on the program when the
audience was fresh. I determined to screw them up by
agglutinating my piece to the next piece on the program so that
there would be no opportunity to open the doors between numbers,
and late-comers would have to wait outside until the intermission.
As the second number on the program was to have been Brahms Bb
34

minor Piano Concerto, played by Claudio Arrau, I was quite pleased

with this plan. My piece would be a vast introductory modulation
to it, and at the same time would leave the Brahms fans standing
in the foyer. I went around and carefully explained the situation
to all the ushers.

No Longer than Ten (10) Minutes begins out of the tune-up. The
conductor enters and begins beating time, but nothing much
changes; only gradually does the work gain definition. The climax
is reached after a long crescendo precisely at ten minutes. Then
the conductor signals the orchestra to cut and turns to leave the
stage. But the orchestra continues to hold the last chord, only
gradually fading down. Now the instructions are to go back to the
beginning of the crescendo if there is applause from the audience
and to continue repeating the crescendo to the climax for as long
as the applause continues. When the applause finally subsides, the
last desk of each string section is instructed to sustain very
softly a!dominant-seventh chord in the key of the following piece
until the conductor returns and gives the down beat.
Smelling trouble, the management altered the program, saving the
Brahms until after the intermission and substituting Kodalys
Peacock Variations.
The percussionists, who were my friends, were totally on side, but
the conductor, Victor Feldbrill, had reservations. He said, Its
a great idea Murray, marvelous, but theres just one thing when
do I return to take my bow? You dont, I replied. I think his
interest in my music, if there ever had been any, flickered out at
that moment.
The performance was hilarious. The orchestra tuned up. The
conductor entered. A smattering of applause. Only gradually did
the piece gain coherence. As ten minutes approached, the huge
crescendo of sound grew, and Victor managed to get it building up
effectively. When he turned to leave, the patrons, reacting
35

predictably, applauded, and the huge wall of sound began again.

Just to make sure that things went according to plan, I had
brought about thirty students from York University and instructed
them carefully to keep the waves of applause coming. Also, my
friend Arnold Rockman, anxious to demonstrate the Durkheim dictum,
had brought along another thirty students from his sociology
class, many of whom, to my delight, had come with garbage-can lids
and other objects to beat.
From my seat in the first balcony I could see everything. I stood
up, bowed and began to bravo vociferously. The percussionists
began a third crescendo. Rockman was now running around the upper
balcony leading the claque in more stormy rounds of applause. By
now several of us were bravoing at the tops of our voices. The
percussion rose to another climax. In the centre of the orchestra
I could see the puzzled faces of several violinists, continuing to
noodle their instruments, because the score required them to
continue playing, but not, of course, playing what I had asked
them to play. The audience had by now quite realised the
cybernated situation and were beginning to join in the fun too.
More crescendi from the orchestra. More applause. The off-stage
door opened a crack and I could see someone through the crack
gesticulating desperately towards the percussionists, trying to
get them to stop. It was the orchestra manager.
At length Victor Feldbrill returned, waltzing along, trying to
look normal and buoyant again. The regular subscribers applauded.
This triggered another final crescendo from the percussion but
Victor had by now reached the podium and plunged right into the
Peacock Variations. Kodalys music unfolded sullenly. It
occurred to me that the Kodaly should be renamed A Lot Longer
than Ten Minutes. It was curious how thoroughly contaminated it
was by my prelude, and I am sure every member of the audience must
have felt it, for there was a lot of shuffling and coughing.

36

Of course the critics

insincere. Not a word
Schafer gets it right
that I appeared to be
almost believed him.

were unkind. They attacked me for being

about the fraudulence of others. Bang,
over the head. One critic even suggested
finished as a composer. My poor mother

28. Divan i Shams i Tabriz, 1970; 23 min; full orch, 7 voices,

electronic sounds; Universal.
During a trip to Iran and Turkey in 1969 I discovered the writings
of Jalal al-Din Rumi, the thirteenth-century Sufi mystic, whose
work was to have a profound influence on me, affecting this and
several other works. The title is that of a collection of mystical
poems by Rumi, but the texts sung by the solo singers are from the
opening of the poets Masnavi and are sung in the original
Persian.
Shortly after returning from the Middle East I had met a young
Persian scholar, Guity Nashad, at the University of Chicago. A
rarefied romance developed between us and she provided the
original Persian texts and a lot of additional material about Rumi
and the Sufi tradition. We met only two or three times. I had
rented a cottage for the summer on Georgian Bay and it was there
that most of the Divan i Shams i Tabriz was written. When the
Ayatollah Khomeini returned to Iran, Guity also returned to
participate in the redemption of the country from iniquity. I
never heard from her again.
The Divan was soon to be followed by Music for the Morning of the
World and Beyond the Great Gate of Light to form Lustro, a work of
symphonic dimensions lasting over an hour.
The Divan opens with a great blaze of electronic sound through
which groups of instruments struggle to be heard. Over the first
page of this very graphic score I wrote a line from Rumi: A face
like fire... the soul was wailing, Where shall I flee?

37

After this fiery surge subsides, various groups of instruments and

voices begin to be heard from around the hall, at first quietly,
then gradually becoming stronger and more connected. After several
dramatic eruptions a long unison line binds all performers
together. The melody rises to a climax and sustains over a
repeated percussion motif, gradually fading away, and the work
ends with a tape-recorded nei (Persian flute) sounding as if from
nowhere.

Divan i Shams i Tabriz was commissioned by the Vancouver Symphony

Orchestra, though it was never performed by them. As mentioned,
there were to be groups of musicians situated throughout the hall
as well as on stage. This would involve removing some of the
seats. A dubious manager accompanied me with a seating plan
showing which seats belonged to regular subscribers. But we cant
move Mr. and Mrs. X! Theyve been patrons of the orchestra for
fifty years! I countered: Ive always wanted to move people with
my music and Im not going to give up now! But in the end a
confederation of pedestrian regulations and managerial timidity
defeated the planned premire. The English conductor was visibly
relieved. His program of hatching Edward Elgars cuckoo eggs would
go undisturbed for another season.
Divan i Shams i Tabriz was eventually performed with the two
accompanying movements in Toronto in 1973.
29. Music for the Morning of the World, 1970; 28 min; soprano,
electronic sounds; Universal.
The text sung by the singer is a conflation from different poems
and discourses by Jahal-al-Din Rumi. The work is contemplative
with ecstatic outbursts. It takes the form of an extended
meditation for solo voice, surrounded by a four-track electronic
accompaniment. At the beginning of the performance the lights are
slowly extinguished to total darkness. The soloist lights a single
candle, the only illumination for the aria, and extinguishes it at

38

the conclusion, invoking a mood of spiritual transcendence,

appropriate to the Rumi text.
30. Zoroaster, 1971; 45 min; 150-voice choir

(divided); Arcana.

Like many of my works from this period, Zoroaster is a setting of

religious texts of mystical character, this time from the ZendAvesta of Zoroaster and other works inspired by his teaching. The
arrangement suggests a history of Zoroastrianism, originally a
proud monotheism, which later broke into a confused polytheism
full of magic formulas and practices. In the composition the
pantheon of the gods is united again at the close under the
supreme authority of Ahura Mazda.
The work begins in total darkness. The choristers slowly enter,
humming the tone of Cosmic Unity. As the work unfolds, the chief
priest, Srosh, leads the singers in the worship of Ahura Mazda.
Candles are lit to celebrate the coming of light. When Srosh
collapses, the forces of the evil god Ariman temporarily take
over, performing blasphemous rituals, but with Sroshs return
these are swept away in a final chorus of jubilant voices and
bells.
My original idea was for Zoroaster to be performed without an
audience as a celebration for singers alone. In this sense it was
an early prelude of the epilogue to Patria: And Wolf Shall Inherit
the Moon.

Zoroaster (originally entitled In Search of Zoroaster) was

commissioned by Dartmouth College for performance by the Dartmouth
Glee Club (with audience) in 1972.
31. Okeanos, 1971; 90 min; quadraphonic tape; Arcana.

Okeanos is a study in sound of the symbolism of the sea, using

natural and electronic sounds with voices reciting texts by many
authors Homer, Hesiod, Melville, Pound who have written about

39

the sea. The work was composed by Bruce Davis, Brian Fawcett and
myself in the Sonic Research Studio at Simon Fraser University.
The Greeks had two words for ocean: pontos was the navigable sea
and okeanos the wild, untamed, stormy ocean. When I first
approached the CBC with the idea of creating a portrait of the sea
in sound and words, I was asked how long the program would be. I
thought twenty-four hours would be suitable. How could we suggest
the limitless magnitude of the ocean in a stingy half-hour show?
We were eventually given ninety minutes, and the CBC attempted
something I believe they had never done before: they broadcast the
program quadraphonically by using the stereo systems of both
networks (1972).
32. Miniwanka, or The Moments of Water, 1971; 4 min; choir SA or
SATB; Arcana.

Miniwanka is an imitative piece, describing the various states of

water. In this sense it is a sequel to Epitaph for Moonlight. The
text consists of words for rain, stream, waterfall, lake, river
and ocean in several North-American Indian languages. It is not a
difficult piece and can be performed by a childrens choir or by a
mixed choir, as explained in the score.
The first performance of Miniwanka was given by the Childrens
Opera Chorus of Toronto conducted by Lloyd Bradshaw, who sent me
an amusing account of a command performance before Queen Elizabeth
and Prince Philip during their visit to Toronto in 1973.
Conversation between the Queen and Lloyd Bradshaw, on
presentation of the score of R. Murray Schafers Miniwanka to
Her Majesty.
Mayor Crombie introduced Lloyd Bradshaw to the Queen.
The Queen said: How do you do Mr. Bradshaw?
Lloyd said: How do you do Your Majesty?
Lloyd looked at the Queen.
40

The Queen said: They were singing Indian words, were they
not?
Lloyd said: They were Indian words describing the forms of
water, such as rain, stream, lake, waterfall, and so on.
There was a pause.
Lloyd filled it with When we sang this out-of-doors once
before, it brought on a rainstorm. Im glad that it didnt do
that today.
Pause.
Lloyd continued with We thought you might like to see the
score since the notation is not traditional.
Whereupon Lloyd showed the score to the Queen.
The Queen said: Oh yes, I saw some of the children moving
like that.
Lloyd replied: That is the storm at sea, and those are the
chords demonstrating it.
There was a brief pause, then Prince Philip said, Will you
please extend our congratulations to the choir, and Lloyd
said, I will, thank you.
That seemed to be the cue to end the conversation so Lloyd
turned and left the platform as he had been instructed.
33. Lustro, 1972; 70 min; full orch; 8 voices, electronic sounds;
Universal.
Comprising three works, Divan i Shams i Tabriz, Music for the
Morning of the World and Beyond the Great Gate of Light, the first
performance of Lustro was given in Toronto, May 31, 1973,
conducted by Marius Constant.

Beyond the Great Gate of Light was commissioned by the CBC in 1971
in order to complete the mystical triptych by bringing back the
orchestra and singers who had been silent during the middle
movement. As in the Divan i Shams the orchestra is spread in the
auditfindorium as well as on stage. The final movement follows
Music for the Morning of the World without pause as the lights are
slowly restored to the hall. As the title suggests, the final
41

movement is a paean of praise to light in which the seven singers

in the hall join the soloist on stage in a text by the great
Bengali poet Rabindranath Tagore: Alo amar alo ogo bhubonbhora
Light, my light, the world-filling light, from the poets
famous collection Gitanjali. I was to turn to this beautiful poem
again many years later, setting it in English, but here it is sung
in the original Bengali. After a lengthy introduction, the
tonality settles into a shifting G major triad in both the
electronic tape and the orchestra while the singers embellish it
singing the complete Tagore poem.
The immediate inspiration for the work was the death of an elevenyear-old boy, Stevie Mailing, the nephew of my wife Phyllis
Mailing, who sang the solo part at the premire.
34. Psalm, 1972; 9 min; for large choir SATB, also playing
percussion instruments; Arcana.

Psalm is a setting of Psalm 148. It was commissioned by the

Cathedral Church of the Redeemer in Calgary, but I dont think
they ever performed it. I revised it in 1976 and later
incorporated it into Apocalypsis. It is a joyful, almost militant
song of praise to the Lord in which the singers clap, snap their
fingers, stamp and even play a variety of percussion instruments.
35. Arcana, 1972; 17 min; 14 songs for middle voice and chamb orch
(or full orch); Universal.

Arcana derives its name from its text, which is in Middle Egyptian
hieroglyphs, and was discovered near Memphis by the Arabian
explorer Al Mamun at the beginning of the ninth century. The
fragmentary text is remarkable because it bears little
relationship to any other surviving Egyptian hieroglyphs of the
period; but it seems to possess a religious significance and
perhaps relates to the secret initiation ceremonies conducted in
the labyrinth by the Egyptian priests. It was translated for the

42

composer by Professor D.B. Redford of the Department of Near

Eastern Studies, University of Toronto.
The compositional method was as follows: each phoneme of the text
was given two notes within a range of two octaves, including a few
quarter tones. Thus each phonemic element always has the same note
or notes associated with it. Often the singer sings one of these
notes while the instruments play the other. The frequency with
which each phoneme recurs in the text gives the melodic line its
character, even a sense of tonality. Motives result from
frequently repeated digraphs and trigraphs.
The accompaniment is never free but forms words on its own. When
the singer sings I search for the formula of six words, (Song 4)
the instruments scurry about trying out various combinations of
letters which may provide the formula the singer is seeking. In
the song entitled When the labyrinth is deciphered it will
disappear, (Song 12) the orchestra elucidates the compositional
method by singing or speaking the phonemes and playing the
appropriate notes simultaneously.

Arcana was commissioned as the test piece for the Montreal

International Competition 1973, which that year was for singers.
The composer was asked deliberately to avoid setting a text in a
contemporary language, which, it was felt, might give singers of
particular nationalities an advantage over others.
The text in English is as follows:
1. I have become an enchantress (enchanter).
2. The poison of the serpent spreads throughout my body.
3. I purify my God with my tongue.
4. I search for the formula of six words.
5. I have closed the passage of the lips and opened the secret
way.

43

6. One of us is a phantom. I do not know which of us is a

phantom.
7. You will eat no opium tonight.
8. Questions for midnight.
9. I am dreaming the world away to escape the four dimensions.
10. The more the seekers, the fewer the finders.
11. Whomsoever deciphers the labyrinth will be my friend.
12. When the labyrinth is deciphered it will disappear.
13. Many sacred fires are profane.
14. He comes with a sword and dismembers me according to the laws
of harmony. His eyes are as blood. He tears my flesh with his
teeth. I am transfigured.
The above notes are from the printed score. Of course, the text
was not discovered by the explorer Al Mamun. I wrote it, or
adapted it from spurious magical sources and had Don Redford
translate it into (not out of) ancient Egyptian. Many of the songs
were taken over for Patria 4: The Black Theatre of Hermes
Trismegistos, where they are sung by Melusina and Ariadne.
36. Patria 2: Requiems for the Party Girl, 1972; 80 min; mezzosoprano, choir SATB, actors, dancers, chamb orch, electronic
and pre-recorded sounds. For information see: Patria: The
Complete Cycle (Toronto, 2002).
37. East, 1973; 9 min; orch; Universal.

East is a meditation on a text from the Isha-Upanishad.

The self is one. Unmoving it moves faster than the mind. The
senses lag but self runs ahead. Unmoving it outruns pursuit.
The self is everywhere, without body, without shape, whole,
pure, wise, all-knowing, far-seeing, self-depending, alltranscending. Unmoving it moves far away, yet near, within
all, outside all.

44

The work employs the same technique I had used in Arcana where the
letters of the text are each assigned a different note. In this
case I used a quarter-tone scale for the twenty-four letters that
appear in the English translation. Recurring groups of letters
therefore take on the character of short melodies. The forty-eight
words of the text are punctuated by forty-eight gongs sounding
approximately every ten seconds, and the orchestra hums the same
pitches to form a quiet meditation. I had also positioned some
instrumentalists at the back of the hall and on the corners of the
stage, asking them to pivot as they played, like slowly-circling
dervishes. This provoked the conductor, Mario Bernardi, to say:
We cant have the orchestra spread as you want it because the
next piece on the program is Mozart and we have to have the right
seating for Mozart. I told him to ignore whatever staging
presented problems and he was greatly relieved. The rehearsal went
well, and the orchestra took it on tour to Europe, though I dont
know whether the staging was observed. In any case, it was the
first of several works Mario Bernardi would commission for the
National Arts Centre Orchestra over the next few years.
38. North/White, 1973; 9 min; full orch, snowmobile; Universal.

North/White was commissioned by the National Youth Orchestra of

Canada. Here is the original program note:
I call this piece North/White because, like white light,
which is composed of all visible frequencies, it combines all
the producible notes of the symphony orchestra from the
deepest to the highest instruments.
The North is not described by the adjective pretty and
neither is this piece. North/White is inspired by the rape of
the Canadian North. This rape is being carried out by the
nations government in conspiracy with business and industry.
The instruments of destruction are pipelines and airstrips,
highways and snowmobiles.

45

But more than the environment is being destroyed by these

actions, for, just as the moon excursions destroyed the
mythogenic power of the moon (it ceased to be poetry and
became property), Canadians are about to be deprived of the
idea of North, which is at the core of the Canadian
identity. The North is a place of austerity, of spaciousness
and loneliness; the North is pure; the North is
temptationless. These qualities are forged into the mind of
the Northerner; his temperament is synonymous with them.
There are few true Canadians and they are not to be found in
cities. They do not sweat in discotheques, eat barbecued
meat-balls or watch late movies on television. They do not
live in high-rise apartments, preferring a clean space to the
smell of neighbours spaghetti.
But these few remainders from an authentic time are
apparently to be sacrificed and the North, like the South and
the West and the East, is to be broken by men and machines.
That, at least, is the design which the little technocrats of
progress have planned. They seek not only to civilize the
North but to civilize the imagination of the North. They do
not realize that when they chop into the North they chop up
the integrity of their own minds, blocking the awe-inspiring
mysteries with gas stations and reducing their legends to
plastic dolls.
The idea of North is a Canadian myth.
Without a myth a nation dies.
This piece is dedicated to the splendid and indestructible
idea of North.
The real idea for North/White came to me during a polar flight
from Europe to Vancouver over Greenland and Baffin Island. The
46

myriad tints of green and blue in the ice caps suggested a full
chromatic spectrum of white sound that would be filtered to reveal
certain changing hues. I decided to place a snowmobile in the
percussion section as a symbol of noise and pollution generated by
technology. While this attracted a good deal of press attention at
the premire, North/White has rarely been performed, and never by
a major orchestra. The reason: capitalist patrons might find it
insulting.
North and East are the only directions that interest me: the East
for sunlight, warmth, history and mythology; the North for purity
and austerity. For me the West is just cowboys and chopsticks, and
the South symbolizes tropical humidity and laziness. And so,
having written East and North/White, I let matters stand.
39. Patria l: Wolfman, 1974; 90 min; soprano, choir SATB, actors,
chamb orch, electronic and pre-recorded sounds; Arcana. For
information see Patria: The Complete Cycle (Toronto, 2002).
40. String Quartet No. 2 (Waves), 1976; 19 min; Arcana.
In the course of the World Soundscape Project we recorded and
analyzed ocean waves on both the Atlantic and Pacific coasts of
Canada. The recurrent pattern of waves is always asymmetrical but
we noted that the duration from crest to crest usually falls
between 6 and 11 seconds ninety percent of the time. Only ten
percent of the time are they of longer or shorter duration. It is
this wave motion that gives the quartet its rhythm and structure.
The listener will readily hear the dynamic undulations of waves in
this piece, and as the piece develops several types of wave motion
are combined. Aside from this, I have sought to give the quartet a
liquid quality in which everything is constantly dissolving and
flowing into everything else. That is to say, the material of the
work is not fixed, but is perpetually changing, and even though
certain motivic figures are used repeatedly, they undergo
continual dynamic, rhythmic and tempo variation. Although the work

47

has waves as its theme (or rather its form) no program is

intended. (See Appendix for corrections to score.)
41. Train, 1976; 19 min; youth orch; Arcana.
In the days when Canada still had an efficient passenger train
service from coast to coast I often took the train from Vancouver
to Toronto or Montreal, a three-and-a-half day trip each way. It
gave me a good opportunity to relax and think. For many years, in
fact, I refused to fly at all as a protest against the noise
pollution of the aviation industry.
In those days the CPR printed a schedule showing the distance
between stations and the altitude of each station. This was the
inspiration for Train, which was composed during a trip from
Vancouver to Montreal. It was intended for a student orchestra and
had to be quite simple.
The total distance (4,653 km) determined the duration, with each
1,000 km taking up a minute of the piece. The station stops were
punctuated by the percussion. Stations passed at night were played
on bell instruments (lights in darkness), while stations passed
during the day were played on drums and wood instruments.
Generally the size of the city determined the loudness of the
playing, but I also tried to give a personal impression of each
place: thus, ugly cities got dissonant sounds.
The string instruments provided the altitude, soaring from sea
level up the Pacific mountains at first, then leveling off across
the Prairies, becoming bumpy over the Canadian Shield before
descending again to sea level at Montreal.
The brass and woodwind are offstage performing the distinctive
Canadian train whistle, tuned to sound an E-flat minor triad with
a fundamental at 311 Hertz. In fact, one might say that the levelcrossing signal of the Canadian train, consisting of two longs, a
short and a long is the most distinctive Canadian soundmark,
48

though with tunnels and overpasses it is disappearing in cities.

But country people still know it well. And, incidentally, it
rhymes rhythmically with the opening of the Canadian National
Anthem.
42. Adieu Robert Schumann, 1976; 20 min; contralto, full orch,
pno, pre-recorded pno; Universal.

Adieu Robert Schumann was one of the first works written after I
left teaching at Simon Fraser University in British Columbia and
moved to the farmhouse in Monteagle Valley (Ontario). The
commission was to write a piece for Maureen Forrester and came
from John Roberts, then Director of Music at the CBC. I was glad
to have it since from this point on in my life I was going to have
to rely on commissions and short teaching or lecturing invitations
for all my income.
The composition is concerned with the last days of Robert
Schumann, from the time of his first hallucinations until his
death in the Endenich asylum in 1856. The narrator is Clara
Schumann, and the text consists of selections from her diaries,
freely adapted. Passages of many of Schumanns own compositions
are incorporated into the total work, in particular, sections of
several of his Lieder, as well as fragments from the piano pieces,
Carnival and Kreisleriana. The quotations have been introduced to
suggest the conflicts in his mind during the days of his final
collapse. There are also signature motives: CA for Clara and BbE
for Robert a device of which Schumann was especially fond.
I included a backstage piano piece in the middle of the work,
playing the melody Schumann wrote down the night of his first
dramatic hallucination the melody he claimed was dictated to him
by the angels.
During his illness, Schumann kept hearing the note A ringing in
his ears, and so towards the end of Adieu Robert Schumann the note
A is increasingly stressed in the orchestra. While Clara sings an
49

obligato to the song Dein Angesicht, which is in D-flat major, the

A-natural sustains, distorting it strangely. The song fades. Only
the A remains, and Clara is alone.
When the work was performed by the Bonn Symphony, I visited
Endenich and, with the help of the curator, prepared a German
version of the text directly from Claras diaries. This is given
in the Appendix.
43. Hymn to Night, 1976; 16 min; soprano and chamb orch (or full
orch), tape delay and recorded sound; Universal.
The text for Hymn to Night comes from Novalis, one of my favourite
German authors. The poem begins with a paean to light before
turning to the holy, ineffable night and the eternal sleep that
accompanies it. A recording of an Aeolian harp was added to the
orchestra to help create the mood. Many are the descriptions and
wild imaginings suggested by this instrument in the writings of
Romanticists such as E.T.A. Hoffmann, Novalis and Berlioz. Placed
outdoors and set in motion by the wind, it sighed like a
mysterious stranger in a breeze but wailed painfully in a storm.
It was precisely the right instrument to accompany the nocturnal
voyage of the soul depicted by Novalis.
Additionally I worked out a system for a twofold tape delay on the
voice, four and six seconds after the live voice had sung certain
lingering phrases.
I remember the night I began work on Hymn to Night. I couldnt
sleep and got up to read something. Novaliss poem was close at
hand and before I had even finished reading it I had set the first
stanzas to music. It was one of those rare experiences when music
surges out unstoppably. The whole work took form that night.

Hymn to Night is to be incorporated into Patria 7: Asterion. (See

Appendix for corrections to score.)

50

44. Cortge, 1977; 15 min; orch; Universal.

I have never been very happy with a seated orchestra. When the
National Arts Centre commissioned East I had moved some of the
players to the corners of the hall and had them pivoting as they
played in order to deflect the sound. With Cortge I decided that
the entire orchestra would be in motion. The work would begin out
of darkness with only the conductor and timpanist on stage, the
latter giving a slow ceremonial beat for the entry of the string
players, moving in slow precision, one step to each timpani
stroke. I thought the image of the players in black suits would be
enhanced if they all wore white face masks, so I requested this.
And after the violinists had slowly raised their instruments to
play, they would suddenly begin to spin like dervishes. Other
instruments, clarinets and oboes, would emerge from the wings and
come down the aisles from the back of the hall passing phrases
across to one another. Later the brass would enter doing a
quickstep march and the bassoon players would perform a little jig
together. After it was all over, the orchestra would slowly leave
the stage as if it had all been a dream, and the lights would fade
to darkness.
To their credit, the National Arts Centre went along with the
plan. The masks were ordered and rehearsals began. But a chance
remark by the conductor, Mario Bernardi, that the tune played by
the goose-stepping brass resembled the Nazi national anthem (it
didnt) shocked the largely-Jewish violin section and the union
threatened a walkout. There were articles about it in the press
and I was asked to comment, but as I had not yet arrived in Ottawa
I had no idea what the problem was.
Eventually the matter was resolved. I personally directed the
staging and tried to get the strings to move as gracefully as
possible. The work was a huge success with the audience, and
always has been if the precise instructions in the score are
followed. (See Appendix for corrections to score.)

51

45. La Testa dAdriane, 1977; 14 min; soprano, free-bass

accordion; Arcana.
For some time my friend Joe Macerollo had been after me to write a
piece for accordion. Simultaneously Mary Morrison wanted a new
piece for voice. But her voice was past its prime and I resisted
until it struck me that I could put these two misfits together
in a kind of carnival attraction. What resulted was the first
piece of what was eventually to grow into Patria 3: The Greatest
Show.
The accordionist, dressed in a tattered tuxedo and top hat, opens
with a happy tune to attract an audience. Behind a curtain he
claims to have the bodyless head of a woman, saved at the instant
before death and preserved by the fantastic art of leger demain.
When he pulls the curtain of his little booth, we do indeed see a
womans head on a table without a body. She appears to be
sleeping, but the barker awakens her with music and she sings a
strange aria of gurgles, trills, whispers and pops, finally ending
in laughter that descends into weeping before she subsides again
into her comatose state. In vain the showman tries to revive her
with his accordion. Finally he pulls the curtain shut. The show is
over.
46. Apocalypsis: Part 1: Johns Vision, 1977; 65 min; solo actors,
singers and dancers, choirs (SA, TB, 2 SATB, boys, speech),
winds, brass; Arcana.
The first part of Apocalypsis describes John of Patmos vision of
the end of the world, as described in Revelation. To depict this
epochal event I knew I would need enormous forces. For two or
three years I had been involved in the Dayspring Festival at
Metropolitan United Church in Toronto, and it was to this church
that I made my proposal. My idea was that the new work would be
undertaken by a consortium of churches, each providing choirs,
soloists, actors and volunteer help of all kinds as they were
able.
52

We were off to a good start; women were sewing banners, and choirs
and dancers were rehearsing in various church basements when the
minister at Metropolitan left for a new appointment. His successor
had no interest in the arts; the Dayspring Festival withered, and
my hair was turning grey trying to keep the momentum going. When I
began to receive angry letters from church wardens about untidy
rehearsals, and one of the ministers complained that the
Apocalypse was not Christocentric(!), I knew that my original
production plan would have to be given up.

Apocalypsis: Part 2: Credo, 1976; 48 min; 12 SATB choirs, double

basses, filtered bells pre-recorded; Arcana.
In the book of Revelation the end of the world was to be followed
by the founding of the New Jerusalem, but the Bible is meager on
details. It was left to the Renaissance painters to illustrate the
happy singing and harp-playing survivors of the destruction, and
from them I drew the notion of a vast choral work and began to
hunt for a suitable text, eventually discovering a description of
the universe by Giordano Bruno, the sixteenth-century Italian
philosopher and astronomer, that was very close to my own belief
and so, in adapting his text, I decided to call the work Credo.
My diary note shows that I had begun work on Credo in February
1976 (at the same time as I was composing my second string
quartet). My musical inspiration was Thomas Talliss 48-part motet
Spem in alium, a copy of which I had in hand; but Credo would be
much longer, consisting of twelve Invocations proclaiming Lord
God is Universe together with twelve Responses defining what this
implied, and corresponding to the twelve gates of the New City,
each inlaid with a different precious stone. In fact, I gave the
twelve choirs the names of these stones and planned to have them
totally surround the audience so that the sound could be passed
around or across the hall from one choir to another.

53

At first I worked on graph paper and I recall how giddy I felt

with the mathematical plan I had conceived for this enormous
undertaking. From my diary:
The feeling is by no means unpleasant, rather like a slightly
drunk sensation in which the eyes wont come to focus on
anything but look straight into the distance... At the
beginning the nude white page dances before the thought and
away from it. At the end it leaves the fingers all scratched
and grubby... the debris of a struggle with some archangel;
yet this twisted wreckage gives me a certain satisfaction,
really the only satisfaction in this unsatisfactory world, in
which we can only brandish the scars of impossible hopes.
I once had a dream in which I was standing on a stepladder putting
the final touches on a choral piece that seemed to reach to the
heavens. Credo was that work.

Credo received a performance by the Mendelssohn Choir before the

staged production of Apocalypsis. This was to be a CBC broadcast,
without audience. In retrospect it was a very funny event, though
it didnt seem so at the time. For whatever reason, the producer,
Clark Kent, failed to tell me when the taping was to take place.
When I called him he hummed and hawed and finally said it would be
best if I didnt attend. I hit the roof and demanded to be there.
I suspected that the conductor, Elmer Iseler, preferring dead
composers, had asked for me to be locked out. Anyway, I was
allowed to attend provided I sat quietly and promised that I would
in no way interfere with the proceedings. They had decided to
record the work in short sections, leaving the tape of bells to be
mixed in later. To help Elmer keep to the timing a lighted stop
clock had been rigged up, but he ignored it. Elmer came into the
recording booth after each take and announced whether it was good
or not, looking out of the corner of his eye to detect whether I
agreed; but when I once said I thought it could be improved, he
ignored me and went on to the next section.
54

We ran out of time with three sections still to be recorded. Elmer

came into the studio with the choir managers and said: Go and
tell the choir that the conductor is prepared to continue but only
if every member agrees to stay. While this was being done his
wife, Jessie, massaged his shoulders and someone brought him a
bottle of pop. The managers returned delightedly and said that
everyone would stay. Elmer, however, was not pleased. You used
the word demanded, he said, I did not say demanded. So they
had to go out again and repeat the request in a mollified manner.
Finally, after wasting half an hour we were able to continue,
completing the taping at close to midnight.
I worked hard to edit in the bell track, which was almost
impossible because Elmers timings were totally askew. Strangely,
Credo was never broadcast and I was never able to find out why.
Clark Kent had produced another donut.
The full production of both parts of Apocalypsis was given in
London (Ontario) in November 1980. The performers included the
sound poets bp Nichol, Paul Dutton and Steve McCaffery, who helped
create their own parts as John, Archangel Michael and the
Antichrist, respectively. Numerous local choirs were involved, and
the musicians were from Orchestra London and the University of
Western Ontario. I directed the staging of the work myself. Two
performances were given and were sold out. Strangely, I was told
that had we given a third performance we would have made money for
the University. Certainly we would have filled Centennial Hall,
the huge horseshoe building where the production took place. The
story of how the CBCs Superman, Clark Kent, tried to sabotage
this production is not worth telling, though I have not forgotten
it.
In true Canadian fashion, Apocalypsis has never been repeated,
though Credo was revived in 2001 in Toronto, without staging.

55

47. The Crown of Ariadne, 1978; 20 min; harp, perc; Arcana.

The harpist Judy Loman had been asking me to write a harp work for
some time. It was Toru Takemitsu who suggested that such a work
might include bells, played by the harpist. Judy and I quickly set
to work devising ways for the harpist to play a variety of bells
and several other small percussion instruments together with the
harp.
At the time I was beginning to plan Patria 5: The Crown of
Ariadne, which would tell the story of Theseus and Ariadne, the
Minotaur and the Labyrinth. The work would be a dance drama and
Ariadnes instrument would be the harp. The various titles of the
movements indicate Ariadnes involvement in the story.
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.

Ariadne Awakens
Ariadnes Dance
Dance of the Bull
Dance of the Night Insects
Sun Dance
Labyrinth Dance

In 1995, at Judys request, I added another movement (between 4

and 5) called Ariadnes Dream.
48. Jonah, 1979; 40 min; choir SATB, actors, children, fl, cl,
organ, perc; Arcana.
A year or two after moving to Monteagle Valley, my wife and I
began to attend the Lutheran Church at Maynooth. When the pastor
discovered I was a musician, he persuaded me to form a choir. A
choir practice was called and four or five people showed up, only
one of whom claimed to be able to read music. I began by teaching
them hymns, concentrating on proper breathing and accurate pitch.
I also taught those who wanted to learn to read music. The choir
grew. A year or so later the girls from the Catholic church wanted
to join us and actually did so. We were now singing plainsong in

56

Latin and simple motets in German. We decided to make the core

choir non-denominational and the Maynooth Community Choir was
born.

Jonah was first performed by the Maynooth Community Choir in

Christ Lutheran Church, Maynooth, on August 29 & 30, 1979. It was
a community undertaking, involving about forty people. Considering
that the total population of the Maynooth area is probably about
two hundred, the per capita participation in this cultural
endeavour probably exceeded the national average.
Jonah is based on the well-known Bible story. Much of what
developed was improvised into existence by the participants. The
sailors built up their conversation with Jonah from
improvisations, and the storm at sea was created the same way. The
kings speeches and the text of his song were written by twelveyear-old Tony Fitzgerald, who played the king. Terry Wilton, who
played Jonah, modelled his speeches over basic material I had
sketched out. With the exception of two borrowings from hymn
tunes, the choral music is mine, though since its conception
depended on the capabilities of the choir, most of it was written
or revised during actual rehearsals.
The detailed story of the creation of Jonah is told in Jonah and
the Maynooth Community Choir, in The Thinking Ear, pp. 302-317,
Arcana Editions.
49. Gamelan, 1979; 3 min; choir SATB or SASA or TBTB; Arcana.

Gamelan was written for a small group of singers, members of the

Maynooth Community Choir who used to gather in various homes to
sing madrigals.
The Balinese have a pentatonic scale (C D F G Bb) with the names
dong, deng, dung, dang, ding, clearly imitative of the sounds of a
gamelan orchestra with the hard attack and the ringing of gongs
and idiophones.
57

I decided to create this little piece using the Balinese names for
the tones as a text and attempting at the same time to suggest the
rhythms and sounds of the gamelan orchestra. It has proven to be
one of my most popular pieces, and with the current rage for world
music, I notice that it sometimes appears on programs as an
authentic example of Balinese choral style!
50. Hear Me Out, 1979; 5 min; 4 voices; Arcana.
Written for a group of soloists from the Maynooth Community Choir,
Hear Me Out was first performed in Maynooth in July 1979 on the
same program with Gamelan. The text consists entirely of wellknown aural figures of speech, juxtaposed in ridiculous and often
humorous ways. Somewhere between music and theatre, Hear Me Out
invites a wide range of interpretations.

51. Felixs Girls, 1979; 14 min; 9 songs for vocal quartet and/or
choir SATB; Arcana.
In 1954 I was given a large number of poems and aphorisms by the
Polish-Jewish immigrant poet Henry Felix. From these I selected
nine, each of which describes a feminine type. There are girls
here from the Middle East, Central Europe, France, England and
America, presented with biting wit and sarcasm. The music
accordingly shifts in style for each song from a Lutheran hymn
to jazz, to a French folk song, to expressionism.

The popularity of this little collection of satires has been

substantially diminished by the reluctance of modern women to see
anything humorous about themselves.
52. Music for Wilderness Lake, 1979; 15 min; 12 trombones around a
lake; Arcana.

Music for Wilderness Lake is the first of my environmental

compositions. The two sections are called Dusk and Dawn, and my
58

idea was that we would play Dusk as the sun was setting, then camp
at the lake and play Dawn as the sun rose the next morning. I had
arranged for the work to be broadcast on CBC Radio and recorded on
film.
The lake was not far from my farm, and the time was mid-September.
After a rehearsal in my barn, we drove to the lake in the late
afternoon and performed Dusk in the evening. I conducted it with
coloured flags from a raft in the centre of the lake, from where
the CBC was also recording it. The flags were necessary because of
the distances separating the players (500 metres or more), but
actually the score is written in such a way that the players take
cues from each other aurally most of the time.
The next morning I drove back to the lake at 4:30 a.m. The
performers were just up and were slapping themselves to keep warm.
The boatmen were ready to ferry them to their positions with the
first glimmer of dawn. The recordists began to take up their
positions in canoes, looking fantastically surrealistic with their
wind-socked microphones rising above the gunwales as they paddled
silently in the misty water.
We were just ready to run when the mist rolled in and we had to
delay the performance for an hour. But finally the mist rose to
reveal a sunny morning. The whole experience was very beautiful
and very strange with the mist drifting across the water and the
trombone chords slowly circling and rising over the hills.
Since we were recording simultaneously from the raft and from
canoes moving about the lake, we were able to mix the takes to
zoom in on different soloists so that within a second or two we
could hear them from the distance to close up or in reverse. I
think this panning and zooming at such great distances must have
been a first for sound recording, but, of course, most of the
effect was lost when it was all mixed onto the optical film track.

59

While it was not performed very frequently, some unusual

performances of Music for Wilderness Lake have taken place, once
on a lake in the centre of an urban park in Wiesbaden (Germany)
and once on the Amstel river in Amsterdam, with the audience
standing on the bridges while I was on a tug boat in the centre of
the river.
53. Beauty and the Beast, 1979; 28 min; contralto, string quartet;
Arcana.

Beauty and the Beast was written mostly in the brief spell of a
week in November 1979. The performer was to be Maureen Forrester
and Montreal was to be the venue of performance, so I had my
friend Gabriel Charpentier prepare a French version of the text,
and the score is therefore printed in both English and French.
Madame Leprince de Baumonts story is considered a childrens
fairy tale, but like many fairy tales it has a deep psychological
significance as well. Thus we see how, at the outset, the young
virgin (Beauty) lives contentedly at home under the protection of
her father, whose powers to care for her are, however, weakening.
The moment comes when she must leave home; her father knows this
and even to some extent assists in her departure. When she leaves,
she encounters another kind of male personality: Beast, whose
bristling masculinity immediately threatens her. Even though Beast
appears to have attractive qualities beneath his frightening
appearance, Beauty fears him and flees back to the protective care
of her father. But her subconscious mind (i.e., the figures in her
dreams) forces her to realize that she cannot remain here but must
return to Beast and tame his brutish masculinity with her love. As
soon as this is done, Beast is transformed into a charming prince,
and the two lovers embark on their life together as young adults.
At the time I wrote Beauty and the Beast I was beginning to create
a variety of pieces for Patria 3: The Greatest Show, and I

60

intended that Beauty would eventually be incorporated into that

work.

Beauty and the Beast is a miniature opera for solo voice with
hand-held masks. The work has successfully been presented like
this by numerous performers. I say successfully even though the
work has seldom been favoured by critics. On one occasion a
Lesbian critic for the Globe and Mail attacked me for resurrecting
this nasty anti-feminist story and suggested that my name should
be excised from all music encyclopedias throughout the world.
In the Greatest Show the work is performed in the Rose Theatre,
one of the restricted entertainments to which one must win
admission by playing a game or in other unorthodox ways, and it
amused me enormously to see quite ordinary people competing
furiously to win entry to an entertainment that, under normal
circumstances, they would never attend. (See Appendix for
corrections to score.)
54. Wizard Oil and Indian Sagwa, 1980; 14 min; speaker, cl;
Arcana.
This humorous work recreates an old-time medicine show in which
the speaker, alias Johnny Mailloux, endeavours to sell a cure-all
called Wizard Oil, while the clarinettist, alias Chief Sam
Padoopi, dressed in Indian costume, endorses the product with his
playing and occasional dancing.
The work was originally written for the poet bp Nichol and was
performed several times by him before his early death. Like many
other pieces of the time, it was eventually incorporated into
Patria 3: The Greatest Show.

61

55. The Garden of the Heart, 1980; 24 min; mezzo-soprano, full

orch; Arcana.
The inspiration for The Garden of the Heart was a description of a
paradise garden from the thirty-fourth night of the Thousand and
One Nights. I had used this description before in the novel
Ariadne, where I had copied it out in swirling arabesques. This
time the description became the basis for a narrative: a woman has
returned to the garden where she and her lover used to meet,
knowing she will die there, and beseeching her lover to return one
last time to listen to her voice in the dancing water of the
fountain.

The Garden of the Heart was written for Maureen Forrester, who
was, by this time, past her prime, but would, I hoped, give the
vocal line just the right touch of senescence to stimulate
sympathy in the same way as the declining voice of Julius Patzak
singing Mahlers Das Lied von der Erde resulted in a better
recording of that decadent work than any other made since.
I first composed the vocal line from beginning to end. I intended
the accompaniment to consist entirely of the same material with
the instruments anticipating and recalling phrases sung by the
singer, overlapping and underweaving like the arabesques of
Persian art. I wanted the score to shimmer like a garden full of
flowers and birds and fountains, surging forward to greet the
singer then hesitating and falling back to make room for other
voices. The orchestration of this piece is one of the most
delicate and sensuous I ever achieved. The work was written over
the summer of 1980 when the birds in Monteagle Valley were at
their most joyful, and the evening air was filled with the scent
of the earth. (See Appendix for corrections to score.)
56. Patria Prologue: The Princess of the Stars, 1981; 80 min;
soprano, 3 actors, 6 dancers, 2 choirs SATB, 12
instrumentalists, canoeists. For information see: Patria: the
Complete Cycle (Toronto, 2002).
62

57. String Quartet No. 3, 1981; 30 min; Arcana.

When I began the third string quartet I had the notion to join it
somehow to the second, and this idea was to be sustained through
the composition of the next five quartets, giving them an
organized unity.
At the end of the second quartet the three upper players have left
the stage, leaving the cello alone. The third quartet begins with
a long cello solo, referring back to material the cellist had
played at the end of the previous work, most significantly a very
slow rendition of the song of the White-Throated Sparrow, a bird
commonly heard all summer long in the woods around my Monteagle
Valley farmhouse. The other three instrumentalists begin playing
from places backstage and in the hall where they had gone at the
end of the second quartet and gradually return to join the cellist
on stage.
The second movement is fast and rhythmic and includes
vocalizations reminiscent of oriental gymnastic exercises. I have
always been amazed at the physical energy required by string
players during vigorous playing and decided to allow them to
release this energy by making vocal sounds similar to those in
karate.
The final movement is a long, quiet meditation in unison, at the
conclusion of which the first violinist slowly rises, repeating a
simple phrase over and over, and departs backstage, carrying the
phrase into the distance so that in the end we dont know whether
we are still hearing it or if it is only lingering in our memory.
This was the first instance in my work of what I might call
phantom sounds, that is, sounds that seem to remain in a space
from which they have departed, a sensation of significance in
later works, such as the aubades and nocturnes written for the
Wolf Project.

63

58. Sun, 1982; 9 min; choir SATB; Arcana.

Sun was commissioned by the Mendelssohn Choir for the opening of

Roy Thomson Hall, Toronto, in 1983. The text consists of words for
sun in forty different languages, beginning in Japan and
travelling across Asia, Africa and Europe to America.
I did not attend the premiere of Sun in Roy Thomson Hall. I had
requested an opportunity to hear the work in preparation but the
conductor, Elmer Iseler, ignored my requests until the dress
rehearsal, when he welcomed me like a brother in front of the
multitude, had a chair brought out for me to sit in next to his
podium, told me to interrupt him whenever I felt like it, as the
choir would be immensely grateful to hear pearls of wisdom from a
living composer and then totally ignored me. In any case,
nothing much seemed wrong with the piece, so at the conclusion of
the run-through I shook his hand, the choir applauded, and I
retired.
In slightly different forms Sun reappears during the arrival of
the Sun Disc in The Princess of the Stars and again during the
invocation to the sun to warm the earth in Patria 10: The Spirit
Garden.
59. Patria 6: RA, 1983; 10 hrs; 25 solo singers, actors and
dancers, male chorus, chamber orch including Middle Eastern
instruments; Arcana. For information see: Patria: The
Complete Cycle (Toronto, 2002).
60. Theseus, 1983; 18 min; harp, string quartet; Arcana.

Theseus was commissioned by the wonderful harpist Judy Loman.

Having written The Crown of Ariadne for her, I decided to make
this a companion piece, and, in fact, some of the Ariadne music is
revived in Theseus. The piece also contains a descending series of
notes, S (E flat) C H (B natural) A F E, as a kind of signature, a
device Shostakovich was also fond of; and, in fact, the

64

Shostakovich influence is easily detectable in Theseus. Later I

orchestrated the work and incorporated it into Patria 5: The Crown
of Ariadne, where it almost assumes the importance of a harp
concerto. (See Appendix for corrections to score.)
61. Snowforms, 1983; 7 min; choir SSAA; Arcana.
Sometimes I have given children sight-singing exercises in which
they are asked to sing drawings or the shapes of the distant
horizon. Snowforms began as a series of sketches of snowdrifts,
seen out the window of my Monteagle Valley farmhouse. I took these
sketches and traced a pentagram over them. The notes of the piece
emerged wherever the lines of the sketch and the stave crossed. Of
course I modified the drawings as necessary since the work is
primarily a piece of music and only secondarily a set of sketches.
I printed the work so that the shapes of the snow were in white
over a pale blue background.
The text consists of Inuit words for various kinds of snow:
apingaut, first snowfall; mauyak, soft snow; akelrorak, drifting
snow; pokaktok, snow like salt, etc.
The entire piece is soft, and I wanted the voices to slide from
note to note just like falling or drifting snow. Snowforms is
related to Epitaph for Moonlight, Miniwanka and Sun; they are all
descriptions of nature. Later I was to add Fire, A Garden of Bells
and Once on a Windy Night as further celebrations of natural
phenomena. As the urban populations of the world grow, the forces
and charms of nature are more distanced from increasing numbers of
people. But I do not write such works out of nostalgia; they are a
very real part of my life.

Snowforms was actually preceded by a much more complex work of the

same name which was performed once by the Vancouver Chamber Choir,
but I am glad I withdrew it, substituting this simpler and purer
expression of one of natures most beautiful elements.

65

62. A Garden of Bells, 1983; 10 min; choir SATB; Arcana.

In A Garden of Bells I had in mind a scene which does not really
exist; a soniferous garden filled with bells of all shapes and
sizes, through which the traveller might wander at leisure, and be
entertained by a tintinnabulation of sounds, not loud but
beckoning, sometimes near, but more often far, like the voices of
distant friends, which soft breezes barely bring to the ears.
Some of the bell words that make up the text are those of real
languages: Sinhalese, Spanish, Serbo-Croatian, Hungarian,
Indonesian and Swahili. Others are onomatopoeic inventions by
friends and members of the Vancouver Chamber Choir for whom the
work was written.
63. Concerto for Flute and Orchestra, 1984; 25 min; fl, full orch;
Arcana.
The Flute Concerto was written for my friend Robert Aitken, who
gave the first performance with the Montreal Symphony Orchestra.
The Maestro, with a capital M, was Charles Dutoit, who treated the
work as a pice de garage, placing it at the beginning of the
program and insulting Bob Aitken by following it with the Schumann
piano concerto played by some headliner pianist.
I have never wasted my time kissing the feet of conductors, though
I am always willing to explain my ideas whenever required, and so
when Dutoit summoned Bob and me to a preliminary meeting in
Montreal, I went.
I have a vivid memory of him waltzing into the room on his
platform shoes saying, Eet is clear, Mr. Schafer, zat you are not
a conductor. Please (passing me the baton) show me za way to
conduct eet. He was referring to the last movement which is in
very fast five-eight time. Bob murmured in the background, Just
beat one to the bar. Dutoit wheeled about, Eh? Mr. Aitken would
prefer to conduct eet.

66

There was no further discussion and after the one and only
rehearsal the Maestro hurried offstage without consultation. I
didnt attend the premiere, which was a great success even
though the last movement was too slow.
64. Sun Father, Earth Mother, 1984; 15 min; solo voice; Arcana.
In the fall of 1984 I went to St. Gallen, Switzerland, to live
with the singer Eleanor James, and the first piece I wrote there
was Sun Father, Earth Mother. That summer I had been at Banff,
where we were planning a production of The Princess of the Stars
in the Rocky Mountains, and had been researching a variety of
lakes, some with amazing echoes. I wanted to write a work
celebrating those echoes and created a text that would help to do
that.
O Sun
Father,
Light of the World,
I come to you,
I sing to you,
My spirit soars,
I am one with you.
Earth Mother,
Cradle of the World,
I come to you,
I sing to you,
My spirit clings,
I am one with you.
When the singer sings I come to you... I am one with you. the
song echoing back would blur the distinction between soundmaker
and the soundscape, as if the mountains and the forest were
addressing the singer as much as the other way around. I wanted to
create the impression that the whole universe is full of
67

mysterious and supernatural presences, each with its own voice

awaiting evocation.
Years later when I was in the Andes in Argentina a peasant was to
say to me: The mountains have no voice, but we give them a voice
by calling to them.

Sun Father consists of nine invocations. In addition to the sun

and earth the singer sings to the moon, to the stars, to the
mountains, to the birds, to the fish, to the forests and to the
animals. In each case the singers voice folds into the echoes,
amplifying and modifying them.
In the summer of 1985 I made a recording of the work with Eleanor
James in the Rocky Mountains, in which she moved to a different
location for each song, singing skyward, or through forest
tunnels, across a lake, into a stream, mixing with the dawn birds
and distant animals...

Sun Father has also been sung by a soprano and mezzo-soprano

alternating, some distance apart. In any case, it needs the
participation of the natural environment and should be kept out of
concert halls.
65. Letters from Mignon, 1984; 25 min; mezzo-soprano, full orch;
Arcana.
Everyone has heard of Mignon, the enigmatic young girl of Goethes
novel Wilhelm Meisters Lehrjahre. She appears to have come from
the south and sings several famous poems such as Kennst du das
Land... which have been set to music by several celebrated German
composers. In the novel, Wilhelm Meister buys her freedom from a
troupe of circus tight-rope dancers and in return she follows him
devotedly but in the end mysteriously dies. There is little doubt
that she loved Wilhelm Meister though the exact nature of their
relationship is never fully revealed.

68

In these letters we imagine Mignon in all her girlish womanhood

pouring out her affection for the man she loves.
That was the program note that accompanied the premiere given by
Eleanor James with the Calgary Philharmonic in 1987. The texts
might have bewildered the audience, for passages in Italian and a
very curious German are mixed in with the English. In fact, the
Letters from Mignon were letters from Eleanor to me. We were
celebrating our love for the first time in public with only the
barest of disguises. John Roberts, who attended the performance,
likened them to Wagners Wesendonk Lieder, and he was right, since
Mignons letters had inspired me in the same way Matilda
Wesendonks poems had inspired Wagner.
66. The Star Princess and the Waterlilies, 1984; 15 min; narrator,
contralto, childrens choir SA, perc; Arcana.
The Star Princess (contralto soloist) visits a world populated by
children to ask them whether the stars might come to live on
earth. The children help her to find the right place, in this
little music drama for childrens choir, soloist and narrator.
The Star Princess is the same Princess of the Stars who appears in
the prologue to Patria. At one point, in the early stages of
planning And Wolf Shall Inherit the Moon, I thought of transposing
the whole work to the forest, but good sense prevailed. It is
better left in the concert hall.
67. Ko wo kiku (Listen to the Incense), 1985; 30 min; full orch;
Arcana.

Ko wo kiku was commissioned by the Kyoto Community Bank for

performance by the Kyoto Symphony Orchestra in celebration of the
thousandth anniversary of the founding of Kyoto, the ancient
capital of Japan. It was hoped that the composition would have
something to do with Kyoto and to assist in the inspiration
process, I had been invited to spend a week in Kyoto in 1984,

69

hosted by the Bank and filled with visits to shrines, palaces,

gardens and excellent restaurants. This was my first visit to
Japan and I found it incredibly exotic. Toru Takemitsu had also
been invited to write a celebratory piece, and he helped interpret
this strange culture to me. (In fact, Toru had recommended my name
for the commission.)
One of the activities planned by the Bank was the ancient ceremony
known as Ko wo kiku. Like its companion, the tea ceremony, it is
both complex and simple. Small jars of burning incense (Ko) are
passed about, each bearing a different name and odour. As the
title of the ceremony implies, the incense may also be listened to
by moving the jar towards the left ear before it is passed on. The
ceremony is truly synaesthetic since the various types of incense
bear visual titles such as The river in the mist, or Cherry
blossoms falling...
I resolved to write an impressionistic piece suggesting various
kinds of incense and to actually incorporate the incense ceremony
in the performance. Beginning with the conductor, incense jars
would be passed through the orchestra from player to player and
each player would enter according to the inspiration received from
the perfume. The four contrasting movements bear the titles
Sagano, Nonomiya, Shigure and Higashiyama.
I returned to Kyoto in 1985 for the premiere of Ko wo kiku,
conducted by Seiji Ozawa. Having spoken frankly about various
conductors attitudes to my music, I would like to say what a
pleasure it was working with Seiji Ozawa. Before the first
rehearsal he said, Let me have this rehearsal to sort out problem
areas. Make your notes and well meet after to discuss them.
After the first rehearsal we went to his dressing room and he
listened to all my comments. He also asked questions about tempi
or dynamics and was respectfully frank about awkward passages he
was finding difficult to comprehend. Of course his respect for the
contemporary composer stemmed from his longstanding friendship
70

with Toru Takemitsu, but through that friendship it extended to us

all. Seiji Ozawa was also the only conductor who ever invited me
out to dinner, both in Kyoto and again in Boston, when he
performed the piece with the Boston Symphony.
68. Buskers, 1985; 12 min; fl, vln, vla; Arcana.

Buskers was commissioned by Robert Aitken for performance on a New

Music Concert in Toronto in 1986. When the commission came I was
busy completing Patria 3: The Greatest Show and decided to write a
piece that could be incorporated into that work.
The three buskers are Man (violin), Life (flute) and Death
(viola). The Man, dressed in a tattered tuxedo, enters and places
his top hat, upside down, before the audience. He plays. He looks
in his hat. Nothing. He plays again. In the distance Death is
heard, mocking him. The Man rushes off in pursuit. Life enters,
plucks a flower from the hat, plays a pretty solo and departs. The
Man returns, visibly older, more stooped, and plays a lament while
Life and Death duet off stage. Eventually Life and Death return to
accompany the Man in a vigorous finale. They have made their peace
together.
69. Fire, 1986; 4 min; choir SATB; Arcana.

Fire is yet another in the cycle of short choral works dealing

with the various elements of nature that I have written over the
years. Fire is a short spectacular piece in which the choir
accompanies itself with wooden or metal clackers.
70. Tantrika, 1986; 15 min; mezzo-soprano, perc; Arcana.
Tantra is a cult of ecstasy, focused on a vision of cosmic
sexuality. A tantrika is an adept in the arts of Tantra, one who
successfully attains sadhana, the ultimate knowledge through
meditation combined with sexual rites.

71

The text for Tantrika consists of words associated with the

Tantric arts. I wrote the work for Eleanor James, accompanied by
percussion instruments. The premiere took place at the Sound
Symposium in St. Johns, Newfoundland, in 1986. I later
incorporated the work into a production of Zoroaster in Toronto
(2001), where Tantrika becomes the temptress Jahi.
71. Minnelieder, 1986; 30 min; mezzo-soprano, full orch; Arcana.
This is an orchestration of my Minnelieder, originally written for
mezzo-soprano and woodwind quintet in 1956. Nothing has been
substantially changed, but I added one new song, Unter den
Linden, to a text by Walter von der Vogelweide. This version of
the Minnelieder was prepared for Eleanor James, who performed it
with the Quebec Symphony Orchestra in 1986. While the chamber
version of Minnelieder continues to get performances, it does seem
strange that the orchestral version does not.

72. Dream Rainbow Dream Thunder, 1986; 12 min; full orch; Arcana.

Dream Rainbow Dream Thunder is a fantasy for orchestra, derived

for the most part from a single evenings improvisation on the
piano. Although I dont normally compose at the piano, I sometimes
find late evening inspirations helpful in releasing ideas. These
will then be worked out in detail the next morning at the drawing
table.
On the occasion when I improvised what I subsequently notated in
this piece, I was living in Switzerland. I had just returned with
Eleanor James from a visit to Neuschwanstein, King Ludwigs castle
in the Bavarian mountains. Rain and mist shrouded the mountain as
we hiked up to pay our respects to this strange edifice, conceived
out of love for the music of Wagner. Wagner is detectable in my
improvisation, but so are a lot of other influences. I dont think
it matters much. Dream Rainbow Dream Thunder joins yesterday with
days of long ago and tomorrow with days that will never be.

72

__________________________________________________________________
Note: Richard Wagner was fifty-one when he was rescued by King
Ludwig of Bavaria who from then on sponsored his music dramas.
I was fifty-three when for a brief moment I thought I had met my
benefactor. A Halifax lawyer, Brian Fleming, had made a fortune on
the stock market. One day he came to see me and told me he had
always wanted to do something important for music and asked me
what grand project Id like to undertake. I told him about the
incomplete Patria cycle, mentioning in particular Patria 5, the
dance drama on the story of Theseus, Ariadne and the Minotaur,
which I was then thinking about seriously. He was fascinated,
particularly because his wife had been a professional ballet
dancer. Where do we start? he asked. I told him Id like $5,000
and Id begin work at once. He wrote me a cheque and invited me to
spend a week in his beautiful Halifax home. We visited beaches in
search of the ideal one for The Crown of Ariadne, since I wanted
it to be performed at the edge of the ocean. I went home thinking
my fortune had been made and set to work.
About three months later I received a strange letter accusing me
of having deceived him, claiming we had talked about a short work
for indoor performance by a small dance company. He wanted his
money back. I sent it to him. Somewhat later I learned that he was
experiencing significant financial problems.
________________________________________________________________
73. Patria 3: The Greatest Show, 1987; 3 hrs; about 150 actors,
singers, dancers, musicians and carnival people; Arcana. For
information see Patria: The Complete Cycle (Toronto, 2002).
74. Le Cri de Merlin, 1987; 17 min; solo guitar; Arcana.
Many are the stories told of Merlin, wizard at King Arthurs
court. He was alleged to be the offspring of a virtuous woman and
an incubus, which accounts for his amoral character. Among other
endowments, says Bullfinch, he had the power to transform
73

himself into any shape he pleased. At one time he appeared as a

dwarf, at others as a damsel, a page, or even a greyhound or
stag. After serving King Arthur, it is said, he returned to the
forest with the fairy Viviane and was never seen again. His cries
were still heard but were increasingly less understood as society
gradually exchanged its faith in magic for faith in technology.

Le Cri de Merlin was written for Norbert Kraft. I recall visiting

him at his cottage in Muskoka to discuss the piece, and sitting
outside enjoying the carolling of the birds as the sun set. I
thought of the distant cries of Merlin in the darkening forest.
That would have been the right place to perform the work, but
Norbert wanted to tour with it and record it. We then decided to
make a tape of the birds and play it back with the guitar during
the final moments of the piece. My hope is that every performer of
Le Cri de Merlin will record the birds of his or her native land
and play them at the end as a testament to the strange and
wonderful voices of nature everywhere.
75. Concerto for Harp and Orchestra, 1987; 28 min; harp, full
orch; Arcana.
I began the harp concerto in California in the spring of 1987,
while I was teaching a term at San Diego State University. It was
a strange experience. I recall the evening I arrived, walking down
one of the main streets of San Diego looking for a place to eat. I
decided any restaurant with tablecloths would do. I never found
one. I never found my students in the class either; they were
always at the beach. There was a pool outside my apartment and all
day long long-legged girls lay in deck chairs, reading books on
sociology and wiggling their painted toes. The university was only
a few blocks away and I used to walk up to my windowless office
and brood while someone next door whacked Rachmaninoff on the
piano. Perhaps this explains why the harp concerto, which the
Toronto Symphony had commissioned for Judy Loman, was giving me so
much trouble.

74

From my diary:
This business of writing for orchestra is so time consuming.
After the devotion of every available hour to the concerto I
am now in possession of forty pages of trash which is
supposed to be the first movement. Its triviality astounds
me. Is it because I have grown tired of this instrument that
I am so bereft of ideas? Additionally it must be confessed
that the construction of a work which has as its sole purpose
the inflation of a soloists vanity disgusts me no end. Nor
is the harp particularly well-suited to this kind of boastful
display. It seems an effrontery to place before the orchestra
an instrument whose role has traditionally been little more
than the sonorous gush. Even half the orchestra, going about
their normal business, is enough to smother this little water
baby. An amplified harp is an obscenity but I may be driven
to that.
Eventually I did finish the harp concerto, and during the final
moments I did amplify the harp, giving the soloist the exquisite
pleasure of triumphing over the orchestra at full throttle. Of all
my concertos (and despite my disinclination towards the medium,
there were to be many more commissions for them) the harp concerto
has been performed most frequently and was, a few years later,
even adopted as the test piece for the Israel International Harp
Competition.
One bright event occurred while I was in San Diego. I won the
Glenn Gould Prize. Excitedly I told a colleague that with the
$50,000 I wouldnt have to teach for awhile, perhaps ever again.
Canadian dollars, he snivelled.
76. Patria 4: The Black Theatre of Hermes Trismegistos, 1988; 2
hrs; 7 solo singers, mixed chorus, 11 actors, chamb orch;
Arcana. For information see: Patria: The Complete cycle
(Toronto, 2002).
75

77. The Death of the Buddha, 1988; 15 min; choir SATB; Arcana.

The Death of the Buddha was written for the BBC Singers for
performance at the Toronto International Choral Festival in 1989.
The text comes from the Mahaperinibbana Sutta, one of thirty-four
discourses forming the Digha Nikaya, the earliest Buddhist canon
of sacred writings. It is a litany of Buddhas rising from one
state of trance to another until he finally passes into Nirvana.
I wanted the music to illustrate the passive quality of the text.
The sopranos and altos repeat a series of eleven notes, consisting
of an identical number of upward and downward intervals, which
undergoes continual modification by semi-tone augmentation or
diminution.
Beneath this line the basses sing eighteen evenly-spaced Oms and
hums. Om represents the ascent towards universality and hum is the
descent of universality into the depth of the human heart; 18 is
the number of dhatas or elements in the Buddhistic canon.
The tenors sing the text, rising and falling by semitone degrees.
The basses are accompanied by two pitched gongs that sound each
time they pronounce an Om or a hum. During the performance a bell
tree is sounded three times, once at the beginning, once in the
middle, and once at the end of the composition.
In conception The Death of the Buddha is related to Credo, which
is also rigorously structured according to numerical symbolism,
but it has nothing of the emotional power of the earlier work.
Among my many choral pieces it exists in a category of its own.
The austerity of the music and the motionlessness of the text
will, no doubt, continue to prevent The Death of the Buddha from
receiving many performances.

76

78. Magic Songs, 1988; 12 min; choir SATB or TTBB; Arcana.

Magic Songs leads us back to the era of tone magic, when the
purpose of singing was not merely to give pleasure but was
intended to bring about a desired effect in the physical world. In
spirit culture, everything has its voice, and the aim of the
singer is to unify himself with this voice, For anyone who knows
and can imitate the special sound of an object is also in
possession of the energy with which that object is charged... by
sound-imitation the magician (musician) can therefore make himself
master of the energies of growth, of purification or of music
without himself being plant, water or melody. His art consists
first of all in localizing the object in sound and then coordinating himself with it by trying to hit the right note, that
is, the note peculiar to the object concerned. (Marius
Schneider, Primitive Music, The New Oxford History of Music,
1966, Vol. 1, pp 43-4).
There are nine chants in the cycle:
1. Chant to bring back the wolf
2. Chant to make fences fall down
3. Chant to make fireflies glow
4. Chant for clear water
5. Chant for the spirits of hunted animals
6. Chant to keep bees warm in winter
7. Chant to make bears dance
8. Chant to make the stones sing
9. Chant to make the magic work.
The aim of these songs, with magic texts in a language spoken by
no human, is to restore aspects of nature which have been
destroyed or neglected by humanity. To the extent that the
performers and the audience believe in them, they will be
successful.

Magic Songs was commissioned by the male voice choir Orphei

Drnger of Sweden. I have heard the work sung by many choirs and
77

it is quite obvious whether the performers believe or not that

they can change the world with their voices. The modern belief
that the purpose of singing is merely to provide pleasure for the
ears inhibits the grander theme of Magic Songs. If choirs were to
sing them in the dancing light of campfires in the wilderness,
they would get closer to the magic power these songs can release.
In fact five of the songs are adaptations of chants I composed for
the Wolf Project and are sung in precisely this manner each year
during Wolf Week.
79. String Quartet No. 4, 1989; 25 min; Arcana.
I had just begun working on the Fourth String Quartet when Paul
Dutton called to tell me that our friend bp Nichol had died quite
suddenly. Having just seen him at a performance of The Greatest
Show a week or so before, hobbling on his crutches and obviously
in great pain, but cheerful as he always was, the news that he had
so quickly been taken from us affected me profoundly. I was alone
on the farm at the time, and as I worked I kept thinking of the
many times we had been together and the projects we had worked on.
Curiously, I had begun playing with a theme from The Princess of
the Stars, thinking to incorporate it in the new work when I
suddenly realized that it was part of the chant bp had delivered
in his performance of that piece at Banff three years before.
Aside from this, there is probably little in the work to remind
anyone of one of Canadas greatest poets, but the work is
dedicated to his memory with the hope that, wherever he is, it may
give him some pleasure.
In 1987 I had bought a farm near Indian River (Ontario) and had
been living there alone, which may also have influenced the lonely
mood of the Fourth Quartet. (See Appendix for corrections to
score.)

78

80. String Quartet No. 5 (Rosalind), 1989; 23 min; Arcana.

The Fifth String Quartet was commissioned for the Orford String
Quartet in 1989 by Toronto businessman Stan Witkin for the
fiftieth birthday of his wife, Rosalind. The work extends the
lyrical qualities already present in the Fourth Quartet: in fact,
it begins by repeating the final phrase of the previous work; but
it is really based on two themes, surrounded by numerous other
motifs: the first is a loose transcription of the howl of a wolf;
the second might be called the Ariadne theme, since it occurs in
The Crown of Ariadne (for solo harp) and also in Theseus (for harp
and string quartet). The work is in one continuous movement with
rapid changes of tempo and energy, ending with a final statement
of the Ariadne theme in which string harmonics and bowed
crotales provide a delicate and shimmering accompaniment.

The moods of the Rosalind quartet change constantly. I have no

idea whether they correspond to the moods of the woman for whom
the quartet was commissioned, since I scarcely know her. My
intention was to write a work that expressed the normal
existential shifts of mood we all experience every day. One moment
I am happy, the next reflective, then I am hungry or I get a
headache. And yet we are usually incapable of detecting the exact
instant when the change occurs. That is the kind of music I wanted
to write music that moves the listener from one state to another
without the listener detecting when or how the changes take place.
(See Appendix for corrections to score.)

81. Concerto for Guitar and Orchestra, 1989; 23 min; solo guitar,
chamb orch; Arcana.
Written for Norbert Kraft, the Guitar Concerto consists of
short movements, played without a break. While writing the
was conscious of the Fibonacci number series by which each
is the sum of the two preceding numbers, thus: 1, 2, 3, 5,
79

six
work I
number
8, 13,

21, 34, 55.... This series affected the shaping of the piece to a
certain extent and can be sensed immediately in the guitar line of
the opening toccata.
Of all my concertos, this is the most neglected, having only been
performed once, which is strange since I consider it to be better
than most twentieth-century guitar concertos. As one of the two
orchestras participating in the original commission, the Montreal
Symphony Orchestra was supposed to play it but never did. I
complained both to the MSO and to the Canada Council who imposed
this condition when they provided the funds, but I received no
satisfaction from either the commissioner or the patron. As a
result I prohibited any of my works from being performed by the
MSO, a resolution in force now for many years without grief to
either party.
82. Scorpius, 1990; 9 min; orch; Arcana.
Scorpius was commissioned by Alex Pauk for the Esprit Orchestra of
Toronto. As frequently happens, the publicity had to go out long
before the piece had been written. Pressed by Alex for a title I
said it would be called Brian Mulroneys Early Morning Whackoff.
As the worst prime minister Canada has ever had, Mulroney was
really getting on my nerves at the time with his unctuous and
empty chauvinism. Of course, that title was impossible. Alex
explained that the theme of the concert was outer space, so,
consulting our star-gazers manuals, we decided to call it
Scorpius. But when I thought about it, there was something
intriguing about the first title: the fast jerky rhythm, the
panting, the pauses for breath, renewed excitement and finally the
climax a dribble. Sometimes during rehearsals I divulge the real
title to the orchestra. The piece is always played better after
that.
But you cant print that in a program, so you better use this.

80

One of the advantages of living in the country is that one is less

troubled by noise pollution and light pollution. The dome of
escaped and unproductive light that arises over every city at
night is the visual equivalent of the swill and swell of ambient
noise released in the city by day. Night-time lighting has
expanded much faster than the population in Western countries; by
one estimate it has quadrupled in intensity every decade since
1960 as new human settlements are lit and overlit.
Like noise pollution, excessive lighting chokes off all
appreciation of distance. It shrinks the world; everything seen or
heard becomes finite, close and human-made. Only in the dark
country sky are the stars released to their infinity. They appear
so tiny; they make us feel smaller. They draw us into another
universe, one we will never dominate, or destroy or even
understand.
I have no idea why the present piece is entitled Scorpius, or what
its relationship might be to the constellation of stars which
barely rises above the southern horizon on summer evenings. With
Antares at its head, it appears vigorous a nd resilient, shaped
like a fish hook. Is that why my Scorpius is barbed and
unsettled? The Greeks said Scorpius stung Orion to death, since he
sets as Scropius rises. Am I trying to sting someone with my
Scorpius? Ill let the listener decide.

83. The Darkly Splendid Earth: The Lonely Traveller, 1990; 22 min;
solo vln, full orch; Arcana.
While I have written several concertos for solo instruments, I
have always been suspicious of the medium that entices flashiness
in the composer and meretriciousness in the performer, while the
loyal orchestra is reduced to enthusiastically applauding
everything uttered by the soloist.

81

I wanted to write a piece that would challenge these habits, so I

decided to let the orchestra and the soloist each go more or less
in their own way. Having given the work a title was helpful; the
orchestra would be the Darkly Splendid Earth and the violinist
would be the Lonely Traveller passing across its surface. The
result was a dual rhapsody in which the orchestra and soloist
would touch one another but never be controlled or influenced by
one anothers activities. I avoided fixed moods, galvanized
rhythms, rhetorical arguments and somnambulistic duets. I wanted
nothing of the so-called pathetic fallacy in which nature is
made to parallel human moods a favourite device of opera
composers: the heroine weeps and it rains, the hero draws his
sword and it thunders. I wanted the soloist to live a life of
isolation without reinforcement from the multitude, without the
idiotic imitations and repetitions found in all conventional
music. If there are friends in this music, they are remote. Only
at the close does a solo horn distantly echo a few phrases
pronounced earlier by the violinist. A friend?... Too late. The
soloist moves off into the twilight.
84. Gitanjali, 1991; 23 min; solo soprano and orch; Arcana.
This joyful work for lyric soprano and orchestra is a setting of
five of the poems from Rabindranath Tagores ecstatic collection
entitled Gitanjali. I had set one of these poems, Light, my
light, in the original Bengali in the third movement of Lustro
(1972). In fact I once had a recording of Tagore singing this and
other songs from Gitanjali, but my settings are very different.
Tagore translated Gitanjali into English, with help from W.B.
Yeats and advice from Ezra Pound. The success of the English
version won him the Nobel Prize for Literature in 1913; he was the
first non-European to win this prize, and when he heard the news
he said, So, they give it to a Hindu?
Of all my works for solo voice, Gitanjali is undoubtedly the most
ecstatic. The influence of Richard Strauss is perhaps more felt

82

than actually present in the tonalities of the songs. I wrote the

work for Donna Brown, a soprano with a serene and flexible voice.
The premiere was conducted by none other than my old friend Franz
Paul Decker, who wasted no time in insulting both Donna and me.
First he recalled Son of Heldenleben: Let me see... ven vas dat?
I did it in Montreal and in Rotterdam. It had a disgraceful
reception. Zay didnt like it at all! He then picked out some
passages in the new score that he thought should have been notated
differently. He tore into Donna when she hummed a wrong note. Do
you have perfect pitch? No! Shall we ask za composer what he
wants? He ought to know.
Donna sang the work three times: at the premiere in Ottawa, for a
CBC recording and with Esprit Orchestra in Toronto, but my hopes
for a wide acceptance of the piece were premature.
85. Patria 5: The Crown of Ariadne, 1991; 2 1/2 hrs; 8 solo actors
and dancers, extras, chorus SATB, full orch; Arcana. For
information see Patria: The Complete Cycle (Toronto, 2002).
86. Musique pour le parc Lafontaine, 1992; 25 min; 4 concert
bands; Arcana.
Le parc Lafontaine is about six blocks square in east Montreal
with large old maple trees and a spacious pond on one side. In
1992 there was a festival of new music and sound sculptures there,
and I was commissioned to write a piece. I chose to write for four
brass bands, and I wanted them to move throughout the park while
they played. Often they would split into sections so that all the
trombones would gather together or all the flutes and clarinets
would encircle the pond.

Musique pour le parc Lafontaine employs four fragments of material

that might be said to be part of the acoustic history of the park
and of Montreal. The military drumming at the opening of the work
is reminiscent of the year 1888 when the ground was first
83

purchased by the colonial government to be used as a military

training ground. More distant history is suggested by the
antiphony of the saxophones playing fragments of Indian melodies
as notated by Marc Lescarbot in his Histoire de la Nouvelle France
(Paris, 1609). This was the first attempt by a European to record
the music of Canadian Indians. The presence of the Calixa Lavalle
Pavillion in the park suggested a passing reference to this
composers most famous tune, the Canadian National Anthem; but an
older quotation comes from Montreals first composer, Charles
Ecuyer (born in 1758). This is from his Sanctus, not a
particularly inspired composition but suitable to my purpose since
I wanted the whole work to close on a quiet note to suggest that
whatever else a park may be, it is ultimately a sanctuary of the
natural environment and a token of the tranquility lost in modern
life. In this sense a park is always a sacred place.
87. Concerto for Accordion and Orchestra, 1992; 26 min; solo
accordion, full orch; Arcana.
The accordion concerto was commissioned by the Toronto Symphony
Orchestra. Following the success of the harp concerto and the
violin rhapsody I dared to suggest that I might write a new work
for my friend, the accordionist Joseph Macerollo, to coincide with
an international accordion convention to be held in Toronto in
1993.
The music director of the TSO at the time was the foreigner Gnter
Herbig. I hate zis instrument! was his first response. To be
frank, I was not sure myself whether this buffoon of an instrument
could be turned into an upstanding gentleman, but I knew how much
Joe would like just for once to put on his tuxedo without
everyone smiling or smirking. I managed to arrange a meeting for
us with the maestro, and when Joe illustrated the many tone
colours available on the free bass accordion, the maestros
antipathy cooled sufficiently so that I could begin work. A lucky
suggestion from the orchestra players that the new concerto might
feature instruments normally neglected in the concert repertoire
84

(contra bassoon, bass trombone and English horn) provided

precisely the colours that would blend best with the accordion,
and I was glad to favour these instruments in the orchestration.
The summer of 1992 was tumid with accordion-mania. Joe visited me
several times, tried out sections of the new work and showed me
some new effects he had devised. By October a very romantic yet
dignified concerto in three movements had been completed and was
successfully performed. I even received a note from Maestro Herbig
complimenting me on the work, though he never deigned to perform
it again.
88. Tristan and Iseult, 1992; 10 min; 6 voices (AATTBB); Arcana.
My search for a text for the work The Kings Singers had asked me
to write for them was long and seemingly futile, until one night I
found myself reading Gottfried von Strasbourgs Tristan in the
elegant translation made by Andrew Lang sometime towards the end
of the nineteenth century. Langs rather empurpled prose was very
different from Gottfrieds robust original in rhyming couplets of
medieval German, which I also had beside me. I once studied this
language and for a moment thought of setting the original text,
though a little reflection convinced me that the Kings gentlemen
might be happier to find themselves pronouncing Langs fine
English rather than Gottfrieds Mittelhochdeutsch not to mention
the opportunities for greater satisfaction among contemporary
audiences.
Everyone knows the story of the passion that arose between Tristan
and Iseult after they had drunk the love potion on their passage
from Ireland to Cornwall, where Tristan was to have delivered
Iseult to King Mark as his bride. Langs phrases rise and fall
here in a manner that suggests both the motion of the waves and
the swelling of passion, so that as I read the text aloud I felt
each phrase as a physiological unit, held together under a single
breath; and after two or three readings I found that I had
composed the entire story or rather it had composed itself
85

into a work for six interweaving voices, where rhythms, swellings

and contractions of the syllable or phrase were shaped into a kind
of triple counterpoint between breath, heart and waves. My diary
says that the work was composed August first and second, 1992, and
allowing for a little editing, which occurred after I had met the
performers and discussed the work with them, everything I have
described happened on those two summer days. In its simplicity
this Tristan and Iseult is closer to Gottfrieds original than to
Wagner.
89. String Quartet No. 6 (Parting Wild Horses Mane), 1993; 18
min; Arcana.
The quartet was originally inspired by watching my wife, Jean, do
Tai Chi exercises while we were vacationing in Costa Rica. Tai
Chi chuan is a set of physical exercises that employs flowing and
rhythmic movements with carefully prescribed stances and positions
suggesting modes of attack and defense. In origin it dates back to
medieval China, and although it is a martial art its real
inspiration derives from Taoist philosophy where Tai Chi (the
Great Ultimate) consists in effecting a balance between the yang
(active) and the yin (passive) principles of life.
The Tai Chi chuan set I used as my model contains a total of 108
moves. Each move is accompanied by a motif or cluster of motifs
drawn from the previous five quartets. In fact, there is scarcely
an extraneous note in the work that does not come directly from
one of the previous scores the only real exception being the
motif for the move entitled Ward Off Monkey, which will appear
in the seventh quartet. Though these fragments of material have
been connected differently, much will sound familiar to those who
know the other works. Several methods for binding the quartets
together have already been employed, and this is merely one of the
more meticulous.
I have always been interested in taking models from other realms
of experience and applying them to music. In this case we have a
86

kinaesthetic model with its own structure of repetitions and

variations guiding the shape of the music. The work could be
performed with or without the Tai Chi movements, that is, as an
accompaniment to them or as an abstract parallel in sound alone.
The Sixth Quartet was commissioned by Michael Koerner for his
wife, Sonja. The Koerners were to become generous patrons of my
music over the following years, commissioning Shadowman and FourForty as well as assisting in the production of The Princess of
the Stars and The Palace of the Cinnabar Phoenix.
90. Patria 9: The Enchanted Forest, 1993; 15 solo actors and
singers, childrens choir SA, girls choir SA, chamb orch;
Arcana. For information see: Patria: The Complete Cycle
(Toronto, 2002).
91. Three Songs from The Enchanted Forest, 1996; 15 min; treble
voices SA; Arcana.
The first of these three songs, Sweet Clover, is sung by Earth
Mother and the childrens choir at the beginning of The Enchanted
Forest.
The second song, Arianas Lament, is sung by the girls choir
after Ariana has been transformed into a birch tree.
The third song, Lu-li-lo-la, was originally written for Erkhi
Pohiola, director of the Tapiola Childrens Choir of Helsinki, on
the occasion of his retirement. I decided to incorporate it (in a
simplified version) during the long lantern-lit hike out of the
Enchanted Forest at the conclusion of the production.
92. Beautiful Spanish Song, 1994; 4 min; choir SA; Arcana.
This little piece for treble voices was written following a
workshop I gave to music educators in Costa Rica in the winter of
1994. One of the assignments to the class was to make a list of

87

what they considered the most beautiful words in the Spanish

language. Just previously I had been teaching a class of music
educators at Brandon University and had left them with the
assignment of listing the most beautiful words in English and
faxing it to us in San Jose. The list they sent was: luscious,
syphilis, moon, ocean, lilac, splash, kiwi, whisper, echo,
bumblebee, cigarette, tickle, zipper. I gave this to the Costa
Ricans and asked them to create vocal improvisations on these
words, most of which were unknown to them. As can be imagined,
some of the improvisations were quite strange and funny. When I
got back to Canada I decided to create a little piece employing
the Spanish words I had been given. I dont speak Spanish so what
came out was simply my reaction to the words as sounds. The result
was Beautiful Spanish Song. I imagine it may also be strange and
funny.

93. Manitou, 1994; 23 min; full orch; Arcana.

The commission for Manitou had been arranged by my friend Toru
Takemitsu for the International Program for Contemporary Music
Composition at Suntory Hall, Tokyo, and was premiered there in
1995 by the Tokyo Symphony Orchestra. The idea for the concert was
unique and could be repeated elsewhere. The commissioned work was
to be the centrepiece of the program; but the composer was to
choose the whole program, which was to consist of a composition
from past repertoire that had influenced him and a work by a young
contemporary composer of promise. I gave them the option of
performing Janaceks Tarus Bulba or Nielsons Inextinguishable
Symphony (they chose the latter); and for the young composer I
selected Chris Paul Harmon, who accompanied me to Tokyo.
For my own composition I wanted to create something with a
distinctly Canadian theme. Manitou is the Algonquin word denoting
the mysterious being who, for the woodland Indians of North
America, represents the unknown power of life and the universe.
Sometimes Manitou is associated with the sun to suggest
88

omnipotence, though, like the Christian God, he is unseen. When I

discussed native spirituality with a Manitoba Indian he kept using
the word monster to describe Manitou and mentioned that his
people used to believe that lightning was a serpent vomited up by
him.
I spent the winter months of 1993-4 in Manitoba, the province of
Canada that takes its name from this mysterious god. In Manitoba
the winters are long and harsh. Sometimes the thermometer remains
at twenty degrees or more below zero for weeks on end. But the
days are sunny, and over the relatively flat and treeless
landscape the skies seem enormous. It was during these times, in
the pleasant studio provided by Brandon University, that I
sketched out Manitou, and I have no doubt that the climate, the
geography and the mysterious being contributed strongly to the
shape and character of what was written there.
94. The Falcons Trumpet, 1995; 25 min; solo trumpet, solo soprano
(optional), full orch; Arcana.

The Falcons Trumpet was written for Stuart Laughton, who had been
a member of the Wolf Project for many years, and therefore shared
with me a love for the Canadian wilderness. Most of the work was
written while I was giving a course at the University of
Strasbourg and I have no doubt that my nostalgia for the Canadian
lakes and forests strongly influenced the conception of this
piece, in particular its unusual layout, with groups of
instruments spread on stage in the wings and in the auditorium
behind the audience. I had done this before (for instance, in
Lustro), but my intention was different here; I was trying to
catch something of the spacious resonance when a trumpet plays
across a lake at dawn or sunset causing the whole forest to echo
and vibrate. At the end of the work I added a soprano, Wendy
Humphries, another Wolf who frequently sang aubades and
nocturnes with Stuart (see Wolf Music) and also the Princesss
aria in The Princess of the Stars.

89

Of course, the sources of inspiration are never entirely pure, and

one day I found myself incongruously adding the sound of a
telephone in a Strasbourg bank to the texture, but it seemed
inoffensive, so I left it there among the birds of the forest.
95. Once on a Windy Night, 1995; 15 min; choir SATB; Arcana.
I wrote this piece for Jon Washburn and the Vancouver Chamber
Choir, who were celebrating their twenty-fifth anniversary in
1995. Over the years Jon had faithfully performed many of my
choral pieces and had introduced them to many other choral
directors through workshops and lectures.
Like many of my other choral pieces, Windy Night is an evocation
of nature. I had written about the sun, moonlight, fire, a garden,
water, and now I wanted to write about air. But the paradox about
air is that you only hear it when it moves, when it touches other
objects and sets them vibrating. So the subject had to be the
wind.
You want to write a piece about the wind: no easy task. You listen
to the wind. But what you write is not the wind, rather a piece of
music. Tear it up. Go and listen again. Still it is not the wind
that your composition expresses. Is it because you cant hear the
wind or because youre afraid to write down what you hear?
This ambivalence is in the character of the wind itself, for its
sound is devious. The Greeks imagined Typhoeus as a god with a
thousand heads, each with a different voice: dogs, bulls, lions,
snakes..., voices defying arrest or transcription.
I was trying to find a way to join breath sounds with sung notes
when I recalled a passage from Victor Hugos Les Travailleurs de
la Mer, where the poet conjures up a scale of values for the
various states of this equivocal noise. Hugos vocabulary is rich
and suggestive. I decided to borrow a few words or word fragments
to incorporate into the fabric of my own tone poem: rafale (gust),
90

bourrasque (squall), orage (storm), tourmente (gale), tempte

(tempest), trombe (whirlwind), and a few verbs: courent, volent,
sabattent, sifflent, mugissent. But these words just contribute
to the texture of Windy Night and are not intended to be
comprehensible in themselves.
96. Deluxe Suite for Piano, 1995; 13-14 min; Arcana.

Deluxe Suite for Piano was commissioned by the Canadian

Broadcasting Corporation for Janina Fialkowska, who premiered it
on January 14, 1997, in Toronto.
It is my first piece for solo piano since Polytonality, written in
1952. Although I studied piano in my youth, it never appealed to
me as a solo instrument after I began composing seriously. Perhaps
this was because I felt there was already enough repertoire
written for it.
I do occasionally improvise at the piano but have never written
anything down. The present suite has a lot of this improvisatory
quality about it. Although it is a suite in the sense that it
consists of contrasting movements it is also a rhapsody in the
sense that the movements are all connected, the mood shifting
sometimes gradually, sometimes suddenly. Within this framework
there are also several brief recurrences of material.
When I heard Janina play the piano, the word deluxe occurred to
me as appropriate to her powerful technique. Curiously enough, she
never played the Deluxe Suite for me before the premiere though I
had asked her frequently to hear it. As a result, several of the
tempi were wrong. Standing up from the piano after the premiere,
she shook her hands in front of the audience as if to imply,
thats enough of that. I think she was trying to be funny but it
didnt strike me that way,, and our meeting in her dressing room
after the concert was brief.
97. A Medieval Bestiary, 1996; 21 min; choir SATB; Arcana.
91

The texts of these songs are based on T.H. Whites translation of

a Latin bestiary dating from the twelfth century in Lincolnshire,
England, now to be found in the Cambridge University Library.
In the Middle Ages bestiaries were serious works of natural
history. They were anonymous compilations of what was known or
presumed about the characteristics and habits of animals, both
real and mythological. Because they were compiled by churchmen,
the behaviour of animals frequently seemed to point up an
instructive moral for humans. A modern audience may find these
connections strange or humorous; but at the time they were
intended in all seriousness.
The music roams through various styles (a technique I also used in
Felixs Girls). Leo the Lion is partly derived from Guillaume de
Machaut (with a flash of Mendelssohn in the middle). The
Elephant has the resonance of Russian Orthodox chanting. The end
of Castor the Beaver is reminiscent of Baptist gospel song. The
Weasel is Notre Dame style (i.e., 12th century), while The
Bonnaon veers into baroque and the finale returns to medieval
organum.
One wonders about the extent to which the authors and scribes of
bestiaries were conscious of the risks they were taking in some of
the associations they made, for instance, when they wrote: Jesus
Christ is also a unicorn, for in the psalms it is written: He
hath raised up a horn of salvation. This comes just after the
unicorn has jumped into the lap of a virgin and is followed by the
unicorn-Christ proclaiming I am the one.

A Medieval Bestiary was commissioned by the Uxbridge Chamber

Choir. It has received frequent performances by various choirs and
always works best when the choir acts out some of the texts while
singing. (See Appendix for corrections to score.)
98. Patria 10: The Spirit Garden Part 1: Spring, 1996; 2 hrs; 11
solo actors and singers, extras, adult choir SATB, childrens
92

choir SA, gardeners, orch. Part 2: Harvest, 1996; 45 min plus

banquet; 8 solo actors and singers, extras, adult choir SATB,
orch; Arcana. For information see Patria: The Complete Cycle
(Toronto, 2002).
99. Two Songs from the Spirit Garden, 1996; 6 min; childrens
choir SA; Arcana.
The two songs are entitled Raking Song and Spring Child, and
they come from Patria 10: The Spirit Garden. The work takes the
form of a ritual planting of a real garden of herbs and
vegetables. The Raking Song draws our attention to the
relationship between the planters feet and the soil. In many
languages, as widely separated as Latin and Chinese, the sole of
the foot is semantically related to the word planting, later
becoming season. The earth hears and feels the moving feet above
it and knows that soon it will be called on to be fruitful.
In Spring Child the children beg the spirit of spring to awaken
and join them in song.
100. Vox Naturae, 1996; 17 min; choir SATB; Arcana.
When Chifuru Matsubara asked me to write a piece for The Tokyo
Philharmonic Chorus, he suggested that the theme of the text might
be nature, and the language Latin.
I immediately thought of Lucretiuss long poem De Rerum Natura (On
the Nature of Things) which, as well as being one of the great
monuments of Latin literature, is also an explanation of nature
from the point of view of Epicurean philosophy.
In Book IV Lucretius describes the various senses and how they
operate. His discussion of how sound is engendered and heard is
especially interesting. For him, sound flows out of the speakers
or singers mouth to the listeners ear, not (as currently
believed) in the form of waves, but rather as a string of atoms.

93

Those that miss their mark are carried away by the breezes and
disappear unless they strike a surface that reflects them back,
sometimes in a muddled or distorted form. Today we reject the
atomic theory of sound, forgetting, perhaps, that light is
explained as consisting of both waves and particles, and there are
equations in which either theory can be made to work.
Lucretius was both a scientist and a poet. Having explained
matters scientifically, he extends his work in vivid poetry, for
instance, when he describes echoes as the voices of nymphs, satyrs
and fauns, led by the god Pan, mocking the world of humans from
hidden places. In moments like this his poetry is charged with a
fantasy seldom attained by others who have sought to explain the
world of nature.
My treatment of lines 549-595 of De Rerum Naturae is illustrative
in the same way Monteverdi and others frequently illustrated the
texts they employed. For this purpose three choirs are used: the
stage choir which states the scientific theories; a choir in the
hall, reflecting or distorting the statements of the stage choir
in illustration of the theory being described; and a backstage
choir of satyrs and nymphs.
For this reason I call the work Vox Naturae, literally the voices
of nature.
101. Concerto for Viola and Orchestra, 1997; 30 min; solo vla,
full orch; Arcana.
The best way to describe my Viola Concerto might be to quote a
couple passages from my diary, written while I was writing the
concerto.
June 11, 1997. Last night I took out the few sketches I had
made some months ago for the Viola Concerto. Though I had
carried a pleasant memory of them, I was surprised at how
inappropriate they now seemed. I was reminded of the foolish
94

statement in Chapter Two of Don Quixote, It was with great

contentment and joy that he saw how easily he had made a
beginning toward the fulfillment of his desire. Thats how I
had sustained the belief that the first four pages of the
concerto were valid. Really they were just a shot in the dark
that went nowhere. So this morning I sat down and tried to
begin again. That was a mistake. Its impossible to begin
something just because one wishes to begin it. So after an
hour of skirmishing I turned to other matters. But the day
amounted to nothing. I jumped from one thing to another every
half hour: wrote a letter, watered the garden, slept... all
the time haunted by the obsession that sooner or later I have
to make a valid start on this new work.
June 22. Plodding on with the Viola Concerto. Episodic is
the only word I can think of to describe it. Moments flash
past, moods change rapidly. Will any of them return. Why
should they? And so I let the work slide on without the
slightest idea of where it will go or what I am doing.
June 26. Chaotic would be a better word to describe the Viola
Concerto. I work at it ceaselessly and recklessly, diving
from one thought to another like a fugitive running to a
different hotel each night in an attempt to escape the law,
really half wishing he would be caught to put an end to the
squandering of energy. But the end will come, I can see it
now, about two weeks away, looming up with an appalling
display of tommy-guns and trumpets the final shoot-out
before the game is over. Then at least I'll put the first
trashy draft aside and return to civilian life for a while.
For diversion Ive been going through some old diaries. I
came across a little fragment, a squeaking sound I once heard
on a train with a kind of fractured rhythm; it amused me
enough to throw it into the concerto. (Its announced first

95

by the xylophone, then later taken up by the piccolo and

woodwinds half way through the piece.)
September 16, 1997. After the production of The Princess of
the Stars I returned home and at once set to work on the
Viola Concerto, though without enthusiasm, and only because a
deadline has to be met. Now, two weeks into it, I am still
dissatisfied. It seems to have disappeared into a fog,
without discernible outline or substance. Not only do I have
no idea where it is going, but I have no idea where it has
been, since I haven't even the curiosity to look back at what
has been written.
October 16, 1997. And so I have finished the rewrite of the
Viola Concerto, precisely one month from the day I
recommenced it. It is a long piece, half an hour, or perhaps
a bit more. There are a few moments of relaxation in it, but
with Rivka Golani as the soloist, I wanted to produce a
vigorous, sensual sound, for such is the personality of the
woman. Its as if she is coming at you all at once. I have
never known a musician so obsessed with her instrument. She
talks about her viola as if it were her lover, and her
appetite for new works is insatiable.
The whole work is based on a descending and ascending scale
announced quite simply in the opening thirty seconds. I adhered to
it vigorously, trying to find new ways of giving the sequence
rhythmic vitality. It is the only unifying device in what has
turned out to be a rather lengthy work.
102. Wild Bird, 1997; 7 min; vln and harp; Arcana.

Wild Bird was written for Jacques Israelievitch, for whom I had
written The Darkly Splendid Earth: The Lonely Traveller. It was
commissioned by his wife, Gabriella, for his fiftieth birthday. At
some point since wed last met he had begun to dye his hair a
rather vivid orange and this is what prompted the title.
96

103. Seventeen Haiku, 1997; 26 min; choir SATB; Arcana.

Seventeen Haiku was written at the request of Nobuyuki Koshiba for

the Japanese Choir Utaoni, which had previously won an all-Japan
choral contest singing my work Magic Songs. I thought it would be
interesting to set some poems in Japanese and began reading the
Manyoshu as well as the haiku poems of Basho, Issa and others.
Gradually I began to assemble a group of haiku, each of which
described an acoustic event: the singing of birds, crickets, the
wind, the tolling of a bell, the sound of a stream or fireworks at
a festival.
It occurred to me to ask the choir members to help me find
suitable haiku, and I also asked them to write some of their own
if they wished. From them I received not only a selection of
traditional haiku, but also twenty-nine new poems written
especially for the pleasure of the prospective composer. Many of
these new poems were chosen as well as more traditional haiku to
form a collection that takes us from sunrise through to sunset and
a festival after dark, closing with the stillness of night.
I wanted to set the poems in Japanese, a language I do not speak.
To make this possible I called on my friend, the Japanese composer
Komei Harasawa, who very generously prepared translations for me,
and read the poems on cassette. To him I am totally indebted,
though, of course, I accept full responsibility for any
misunderstandings or distortions in the settings.
One of the most pleasant times of my life was attending the allJapan choral contest where the Utaoni choir won the grand prize
for the second year in a row, this time performing Seventeen Haiku
and then travelling with them to Tsu City where they gave an
entire concert of Schafer choral works to a large and appreciative
audience. (See Appendix for corrections to score.)

97

104. String Quartet No. 7, 1998; 30 min; Arcana.

I had made sketches for a seventh quartet several years ago, but
the incentive to complete the work came when the Molinari Quartet
of Montreal dedicated themselves to performing all previous six
quartets and commissioned the Seventh.
My original conception was to write a work in which the individual
members of the Quartet would be in more or less continual motion
on and off the stage, sometimes playing together, sometimes
echoing one another from different points in the hall.
The commissioners suggested the incorporation of an obligato
soprano. At first I thought of having the soprano sing a wordless
melisma that would drift in and out of the instrumental texture
like a dreamers delirium, but the fortuitous discovery of some
texts by an anonymous twenty-one-year-old schizophrenic patient
changed my mind. The texts would give the singer a strong, if
confused, identity, providing a context for her irrational
appearances and disappearances during the work. I set these texts
with only a few slight changes and transposition of lines.
During early discussions with the Molinari group, who have taken
their name from Qubec painter Guido Molinari, we considered the
possibility of costumes in strong primary colours, similar to the
stripes of colour in Molinaris paintings. The following colours
were chosen:
First violinist:
Second violinist:
Violist:
Cellist:

red
blue
yellow
green

I decided that the singer should be dressed in white, a colour

associated with both the holy and the hospitalized. Thus the
performers became symbols of energy suggested by their colours. I

98

imagined the cellist, whose colour is green, symbolizing some kind

of forest numen, like Tapio of the Finnish Kalevala.
As mentioned, the score is full of suggested movements on and off
the stage by all the performers. To accomplish this, the cellist
would have to have some kind of harness for the cello that would
permit playing while moving. Extending the identification with
Tapio, and recalling that Tapio was a capricious spirit and often
appeared in different forms, I had the idea that the cellist might
wear some kind of headdress that would snap open at the back to
reveal a startling second face.
We had some difficulties before the premiere, which was to take
place at the Strings of the Future Festival in Ottawa in 1999. The
singer, Donna Brown, backed out, claiming it was unsuitable for
her voice. A substitute was found but we had to omit most of the
staging. Actually the quartet worked quite well with the singer
simply entering and departing while the string quartet remained
seated on stage.
The proper staging had to wait until the marathon concert in
Montreal (December 1999) when the Molinari Quartet performed all
seven quartets in one evening. In the staged version the
performers are in almost perpetual motion. I was struck by the
daring of certain moments, for instance, when no one is on stage
and the sound seems to drift in from nowhere, or the whirlwind
excitement when the four players are playing very rapidly in
unison, but from the four corners of the hall.
105. You Are Illuminated, 1999; 8 min; childrens choir SA;
Arcana.
Many years ago I set a text from the Bhagavad-Gita (II 55-64) on
the attainment of serenity. The piece was called Gita and it was
eventually incorporated into Patria I: Wolfman. That setting was
in the original Sanskrit. But I have often reflected on it, and

99

one day I decided to set it again, this time in English and for a
childrens choir. Of course it is above a childs level of
comprehension (but then so are many portions of the Mass that boy
sopranos and I was one used to sing every Sunday). I wanted
pure voices to explain the illumination to be obtained by
putting aside all desires. Eventually the work was incorporated as
unit 20 of The Fall into Light.
106. Alleluia, 1999; 6 min; choir SATB; Arcana.
One day I had a letter from Susan Frykberg, a composer I had known
only slightly in Vancouver, telling me that she had decided to
enter a nunnery. She had found God, and her revelation was so
clear and touching that I sat down and wrote this little Alleluia
for her, almost at one sitting.
107. Four-Forty, 1999; 29 min; string quartet, chamb orch; Arcana.

Four-Forty was commissioned for the St. Lawrence Quartet to

perform at the Vancouver Festival in August 2000. I was not very
excited at the prospect of setting a string quartet against an
orchestra. With the whole string section surrounding them, it
would be hard to give the quartet real definition and the
independence necessary for soloists. I decided that the members of
the quartet would obtain greater identity if they were to enter
individually, perhaps from different places. The work opens with
only the cellist on stage in front of the orchestra. After an
opening elegy, which quickly accelerates in tempo, the cellists
solo is echoed from the back of the hall by the first violinist,
who enters playing and moves down the aisle. The second violinist
is seated at the back of the string section and makes a startling
display of suddenly standing up and playing an extended solo. The
violist has been hidden in the percussion section playing a drum
until suddenly the drumstick is thrown away and a viola is
substituted. The theatricality of the first movement gives the
quartet the personality necessary to survive the next two

100

movements seated normally without being too submerged by the

orchestra.
The title Four-Forty came to me when I totalled up the number of
players that would be involved in the performance of the piece:
four soloists plus forty in the chamber orchestra accompanying
them. Since A440 is the frequency at which contemporary orchestras
perform, the note A becomes the anchor note of the entire
composition, returning frequently, right to the end of the piece
where it slowly evaporates in harmonics.
108. Patria 8: The Palace of the Cinnabar Phoenix, 2000; 2 hrs; 5
solo singers, actor, puppets, choir SA, chamb orch, including
Chinese instruments; Arcana. For information see: Patria: The
Complete Cycle (Toronto, 2002).
109. Shadowman, 2000; 36 min; 5 solo perc, full orch; Arcana.

Shadowman was written for the Nexus percussion ensemble and the
University of Toronto Symphony Orchestra. It was commissioned by
Michael Koerner. The piece celebrates soldiery, or rather the
futility of soldiery. The five percussionists are divided: two
players impersonate the Forces of Darkness; two the Forces of
Light; while one, dressed in a tattered military uniform,
impersonates the individual soldier as he drums his way through
victory and defeat on the battlefield.
The orchestra accompanies this crusade of courage and folly with a
number of tunes from military musical history. In the end, the
soldier, mentally deranged, plays a variety of toy instruments and
even tries to teach a teddy bear to play a toy drum. The valour
and pathos of soldiery is exemplified in the piece, but the antiwar theme is unmistakable throughout the work. To my regret, the
work has not achieved the popularity I had hoped for. We need more
anti-war demonstrations in music.

101

For a full discussion of Shadowman see the introduction to the

full score or the article printed in the collection Papers,
Arcana.
110. String Quartet No. 8,

2001; 23 min; Arcana.

One winter day in 2000 I was visited by Ellen Karp and Bill
Johnston who wanted to commission a piece to celebrate the
fiftieth wedding anniversary of Ellens parents, Fred and May
Karp. We discussed what might be suitable and I suggested the
possibility of a new work for the Molinari String Quartet, who had
just successfully presented the seven previous quartets on a
marathon concert in Montreal. They liked the idea and I began the
work during a sojourn in Munich.
I had no idea whether Fred and May Karp, whom I had not met, even
liked music, let alone the atrocious brand a contemporary composer
was likely to deliver. But imagining how much in love they must
have been at the time of their youthful marriage, and the
achievement of sustaining something of that romance over fifty
years, I planned a two-movement work. The first movement would be
lively and energetic and of course it would begin with the same
motif that had ended the seventh quartet. The second movement
would be slower and more gentle but with outbursts of passion.
Both movements would be based on the same material.
For the second movement I decided to double the quartet with prerecorded material, both to add to the richness of the texture, but
also to suggest memories of the past. As the playback of the
recorded quartet is behind the live group, and therefore a little
fainter, I hoped the distance would give something of the
sentimental experience of looking through an album of old
photographs.
111. Imagining Incense, 2001; 15 min; choir SATB; Arcana.

102

Imagining Incense was commissioned by the Toronto International

Choral Festival for performance by the Tokyo Philharmonic Choir in
June 2002.
Incense has a long and important history in Japanese culture.
There is even a ceremony known as Listen to the Incense (Ko wo
kiku), similar in its elaborate simplicity to the more famous Tea
Ceremony, both of which date from the fourteenth century. It was
the incense ceremony that served as the inspiration for the
orchestral piece Ko wo kiku that I wrote for the Kyoto Symphony in
1985.
In the sixteenth century a group of connoisseurs attempted to
describe the characteristics of the most popular kinds of wood
incense then in use:

manaka light and enticing a woman of changing moods

manaban sweet, coarse, unrefined a rather vulgar person
kyara gentle, elegant, dignified an aristocrat
sumotara similar to kyara but rather sour a servant disguised
as an aristocrat
sasora cool and sour a monk
rakoku sharp and pungent a warrior
It was these descriptions that inspired the six movements of
Imagining Incense. The piece is dedicated to the Tokyo
Philharmonic Choir and its conductor, Chifuru Matsubara.

112. Rain Chant, 2001; 8 min; choir SATB; Arcana.

In its simple form, Rain Chant is one of many songs from And Wolf
Shall Inherit the Moon, the Epilogue to the Patria cycle, where it
is sung on rainy days both to celebrate the rain and to encourage
it to pass. Perhaps it derives from a native American chant,

103

though I havent been able to trace it. Normally, I dont like

arrangements of folk songs because they always seem weaker than
the originals. But with time running out on a commission to
compose a piece to be sung by the Taipei Philharmonic Choir for
the World Symposium on Choral music (Minneapolis-St. Paul, 2002),
I broke my own rule and made an extended arrangement of the
original chant.

113. Winter Solstice was commissioned by Diane Loomer and Chor

Leoni of Vancouver with funds provided by The Canada Council for
the Arts for performance on December 21, 2001.
The original title was Chant to Bring Back the Light, but I
changed it in order to avoid confusion with The Fall Into Light,
which followed it two years later.
The words are suggestive of darkness and light. Some come from
real languages. Tatqiniqqaq is the Inuit word for the moon of the
shortest days. Noce oscura is Spanish for dark night; duister and
mrker are Dutch and Swedish words for darkness. Shadion is
suggestive of shadow. As for light, lustro and lumina are from
Latin, while alo amar is the opening, in Bengali, of Tagores poem
Light, my Light from Gitanjali.
I suggest that the first part of the chant be performed in
darkness or near darkness by two groups of singers, perhaps
entering from either side of the stage. The light could grow as
the chant develops.
114. The Fall into Light, 2002-3; 62 min; 6 choirs SATB,
childrens choir SA, 6 perc; Arcana.

The Fall into Light is a syncretic work based on texts

variety of sources, gnostic, hermetic and mystical for
part, but also with texts by Rilke, Nietzsche and some
reflections. The basic theme is Manichean, the fall of
104

from a wide
the most
personal
the soul

from its heavenly home of light to the darkness of the earth and
its attempt to escape from the archons who rule there and to pass
through the aeons of space back into the pleroma of light. The
direction of this passage may be up or down since the earth is
surrounded by starry light, hence the title. Since the soul in
Manichean thinking is also a drop of light, the whole work is a
study of light within darkness as well as darkness within light.
Sometime after Credo (the multi-choir second part of Apocalypsis)
was performed in Toronto in November 2000, the producer, Lawrence
Cherney, asked me to consider another large-scale multi-choir
work. His idea was to bring six of Canadas best professional
choirs together for a week of concerts, to culminate in a combined
event at which the new work would be the centerpiece. I began
writing The Fall into Light in November 2002 and finished it in
May 2003.
115. Thunder: Perfect Mind, 2003; 12 min; mezzo-soprano, orch;
Arcana.
Commissioned by the CBC, Thunder: Perfect Mind was written to fill
out the time on a proposed CD featuring Eleanor James singing two
of my other works for voice and orchestra, both written for her:
Letters from Mignon and the orchestral version of the Minnelieder.
The text of Thunder: Perfect Mind comes from a papyrus discovered
at Nag Hammadi, Egypt, in 1945. It is a revelation discourse
delivered in the first person by a female theurgist. The tone is
forceful throughout and full of deliberate antitheses and
paradoxes, viz.: I am the whore and the holy one, I am the wife
and the virgin. The text also contains exhortations to hear and
reflect on these antitheses, revealing that the narrator believes
herself to be, and wants us to believe her to be, a seer intimate
with all the incomprehensible forces of the cosmos. This seemed to
be a perfect text for the dramatic voice of Eleanor James, and I
wrote the piece quickly, finishing it just in time for her return
to Canada.

105

116. Wolf Music, 1991; variable instruments and durations;

Arcana.

Wolf Music is a collection of pieces for voice and various

instruments from Patria: The Epilogue: And Wolf Shall Inherit the
Moon. The various pieces in this collection are aubades and
nocturnes, performed in the forest or across the water either
early in the morning or late at night. They are not really
intended for concert performance, although some of them have been
performed this way.
Included in the collection are the following:

Aubade and Nocturne for solo trumpet

Aubade and Nocturne for solo clarinet
Aubade for two voices or trumpet and voice
Tapio for Alphorn or French Horn with echoing instruments
Departure for trumpet with echoing instruments
Sunset for natural trumpet
Aubade and Nocturne for solo flute
Aubade and Nocturne for solo voice
Ariadnes Aria for solo voice
Sun Father,Earth Mother for solo voice.
In Tapio and Departure the solo instruments lead, followed by the
others echoing fragments of phrases from different positions and
distances. In the Wolf Project this takes place in the forest for
Tapio and around a lake for Departure. The echoing instruments are
flute, recorder, clarinet, oboe and trombone but of course
others could be substituted.
Other music for instrumental ensemble, performed annually during
Great Wheel Day of And Wolf Shall Inherit the Moon, is reserved
for that occasion and is not intended for public performance.

106

117. Patria: The Epilogue: And Wolf Shall Inherit the Moon, 1988;
8 days; 64 adult members; Arcana. For information see:
Patria: The Complete Cycle (Toronto, 2002).
118. Tanzlied, 2003; 18 min; mezzo-soprano and harp; Arcana.

Tanzlied was written for mezzo-soprano Eleanor James and harpist

Judy Loman and was first performed at the Ottawa Chamber Music
Festival in July 2004.
The text of Tanzlied is from the Third Part of Friedrich
Nietzsches Also Sprach Zarathustra and is sung in German. In it
Nietzsche (Zarathustra) confronts and struggles with Life.
O Life, I looked into your eyes recently
My heart stood still with delight.
At my dance-maddened feet
You threw a laughing, questioning glance.
Twice you raised your rattle,
Then my feet tossed in a dancing rage.
Throughout the poem the narrator dances with Life, sometimes
advancing, sometimes retreating, as Life surges ahead down unknown
paths both ecstatic and mysterious.
This is a dance over hill and dale.
I am the hunter. Are you my dog or the game?
You malicious acrobat!
The singer stumbles, gets up and rushes on, sometimes whipping
Life mercilessly until Life cries out:
O Zarathustra, dont crack your whip so terribly.
You know: Noise kills thought!
And even now such tender thoughts are coming to me.
107

You know that I have been good to you, and often too good,
And the reason is that I am jealous of your wisdom.
Ah, this crazy old fool, Wisdom.
I know that you are thinking of leaving me soon.
Listenthere is a bell that sounds the hour at midnight
The final section of Tanzlied is peaceful. Zarathustra and Life
embrace one another and weep. To support this reconciliation I
have introduced some of Nietzsches own music, a very tender and
passionate music, inspired by his idol, Wagner.
The work ends with the twelve strokes of the midnight bell, while
the singer comments:
The world is deep. Deep is woe
Joy, deeper than hearts agony
All joy wants eternity; wants deep, deep eternity.
In 1889 Nietzsche suffered a mental collapse and spent the last
eleven years of his life insane.

119. String Quartet No. 9, 2004; 23 min; Arcana.

My ninth quartet was commissioned by Bill and Shirley Loeven for
performance at the New Music Festival in February 2005, sponsored
by the Winnipeg Symphony Orchestra. The performers were the
leaders of the string sections of the orchestra: Gwen Hobig and
Karl Stobbe, violins; Daniel Scholz, viola; and Yuri Hooker,
cello.
The quartet is in one movement and is predominantly elegiac in
character with abrupt outbursts of enthusiasm, stimulated by the
laughing and screaming voices of children, prerecorded in a
playground. I find the turbulence of childrens voices affects me
more strongly as I grow older, the happiness and the fear, the
sweetness and the cruelty.

108

The quartet opens with the Ariadne theme that may be found
embedded in several of the previous quartets as well as in other
works. This is followed immediately by a tranquil motif consisting
of a half note, two quarter notes and a whole note, over which the
recorded voice of a boy soprano is heard, slowly repeating and
expanding one of the principal themes of the eighth quartet.
The moods that follow are directly stimulated by the childrens
voices, and when they are not present the elegiac character
predominates, although the last appearance of the boy soprano at
the close stimulates a happy ending in a sped up version of the
halftwo quarterwhole note motif that introduced the work.
120. Flew Toots for Two Flutes, 2004; 5 min; Arcana.
This little piece for two flutes was written for my friend Bob
Aitken for performance on a celebration concert to mark his
retirement from the music department at the University of
Freiburg, Germany.
121. String Quartet No. 10 (Winter Birds), 2005; 17 min; Arcana.
My tenth string quartet (Winter Birds) was commissioned by Radio
France for the Molinari String Quartet, who has performed all of
my quartets on various occasions and has recorded the first eight
of them commercially for ATMA Classique.
The quartet was written during January and February 2005 at my
farm in central Ontario. This is the quietest time of the year,
with snowy fields outside my window and temperatures that descend
at night to 20 or 25 degrees below zero Celsius. There are few
birds at the feeders: chickadees and sparrows, and a few blue jays
and woodpeckers. As a result, the texture is thinner than in most
of the previous quartets. Occasionally there is a suggestion of
swirling snow or a flock of turtle doves. The wolf howl from the
Fifth Quartet is taken over and echoed by all the instruments as
109

if by a pack of distant wolves, and the strongest moment in the

work is a depiction of sunrise on the glistening snow at dawn.
122. The Death of Shalana, 2005, 12 min; Arcana.

The Death of Shalana was commissioned by Patria Music Theatre

Projects with funds provided by the Laidlaw Foundation for
performance in Metropolitan United Church in Toronto by
Soundstreams Canada in June 2005.
Shalana is the leader of the Human Clan in the Patria Epilogue:
And Wolf Shall Inherit the Moon. But Shalana has deserted the
Human Clan and gone to live in the forest with the other animals.
He dies in the forest, but his voice lives on and can be heard in
the wind and in the rain and in the changing seasons. Eventually
The Death of Shalana should be sung across a lake with the four
choirs on different shores.
123. Isfahan for three brass quintets, 2006; 12 min; Arcana.

Isfahan was commissioned by Soundstreams Canada with funds

provided by the Ontario Arts Council.
During a visit to Iran and Turkey in 1969, I spent several days in
Isfahan. One of the most beautiful buildings of that city is the
Shah Abbas Mosque, completed in 1629. But the building is not only
famous for its visual beauty since it also possesses a unique
acoustic effect. Standing directly under the main cupola a hand
clap will return precisely seven echoes. Move a step away in any
direction and a hand clap will return no echoes at all.
The memory of this experience returned to me when I visited St.
Annes Church in Toronto, proposed site for a concert of brass
music organized by Soundstreams Canada. Perhaps it was prompted by
the appearance of St. Annes, which is modeled on the famous domed
church of Hagia Sophia in Istanbul, now an Islamic mosque.

110

I wanted to create a piece configured around the number seven.

Seven tones and seven pulses. I wanted also to create a piece that
would linger in the space as if it belonged there and would remain
forever. Marshall McLuhan somewhere commented that the medieval
room was furnished when it was empty: that is, its sound would be
its furnishings. Architects once created with both stone and sound
in a manner that was planned, predictable and effective. It was a
glorious time for both architecture and music, and their
separation has left each discipline deficient and incomplete.
The three brass quintets in Isfahan are in different positions in
the church and each group will move to different positions during
the performance. Co-ordination is provided by a leader who signals
a seven-stroke motif from time to time on a slapstick or drum.
124. Six Songs from Rilkes Book of Hours, 2006, 20 min; Arcana.
These songs were commissioned by Stacie Dunlop, who had previously
sung in productions of Princess of the Stars and The Enchanted
Forest. The first performance was given by her and the Lands End
Ensemble of Calgary.
My interest in Rilke goes back a long time, to the days I spent in
Vienna (195557). One winter, in an attempt to escape the cold
(coal was very scarce at the time), I decided to go to Trieste.
There I stayed for a few months with an elderly Austrian woman who
was well-connected with the Austrian aristocracy, since titled
guests frequently descended to spend a few days with her. (At one
time I shared a bathroom with Prince Windischgrtz.) Another guest
was the Princess of Thurn und Taxis, whom I recognized immediately
since Rilkes Duino Elegies were dedicated to a woman of that
name. That was her mother. Rilke had stayed alone one winter in
the castle at Duino, a few kilometres from Trieste, and it was
there that he began the Elegies. The Princess invited me to visit
her in the castle an offer I regret I never took up.

111

When I was commissioned by Stacie Dunlop to write a work for her,

I immediately thought of Rilke, not of the Elegies but of the
collection of poems known as the Book of Hours. In these short
poems the moods vary a great deal. The dialogue with God continues
as it does in much of Rilke, but the texts are simpler and even at
times achieve a tone of levity that is rare in this poet.
I wrote the songs quickly, I would almost say, one every day,
which is certainly the way Rilke must have written these concise
but opalescent poems.
125. Trio for Violin, Viola and Cello, 2006, 15 min; Arcana.
Although I have written a number of string quartets, I had never
considered writing a trio until I received a commission from the
Arizona Friends of Chamber Music.
While a trio may seem to be a more balanced ensemble than the topheavy string quartet, it has never proved to be as popular. In
fact there is something unsettling about a trio, like a marriage
plus one a triad of tensions or at least that is the way I
found myself thinking about it when I began to write the piece.
Everything moves smoothly at the beginning; the violin plays a
melody in the Lydian mode to a simple accompaniment in the viola
and cello, but after a few bars the mood becomes agitated, and
remains agitated, except for a few quiet intervals, through most
of the single movement work. The climax is reached with a powerful
descending scale in the cello on the notes E-flat (s) C H (B
natural) A F E... followed by a surprising modulation into a
Gustav Mahler adagio, which leads back to the gentle opening theme
to bring the work to a peaceful close.

112

126.

Eleventh String Quartet, 2007; 24 min; Arcana

The Eleventh String Quartet was commissioned by the Lafayette Quartet. Unlike most of my
quartets, the Eleventh is divided into five distinct sections or movements, though I have
specified the duration of the pauses between them to create a feeling of continuity. There is
continuity in the music also since the work is dominated by a recurring theme of eleven notes
with the character of a passacaglia. It came to me one night in a dream, but I wouldn't be
surprised if it existed somewhere in Bach or as a Renaissance ground bass.

The first movement begins with Angst and passion on the solo violin; the other players
gradually join in, and the work takes on a rhythmic character in which the passacaglia theme is
repeated several times. In the second movement the same theme is sounded very softly over
which the viola plays an elegiac obligato. This leads directly into the third movement which is
a musical description of a sunset, from the sun's blazing descent into deep shadows as it passes
below the horizon. At the end, two loons fly over head into the darkening sky.

The fourth movement is a romance between the second violinist and the cellist, with some
excited emotions involving all the players. In the last movement the strings suggest the soft
throbbing of an Aeolian Harp. This instrument used to be placed in gardens where it would
catch the wind, producing an eerie chromatic wailing sound that infatuated the romanticists,
(Schumann, Berlioz, E.T.A. Hoffmann).

127.

The Children's Crusade, 2007; 90 Min; Arcana

The Children's Crusade was a commission from Soundstreams, Canada, or, to be more specific,
from its energetic Artistic Director, Lawrence Cherney. One day, in the summer of 2005,
Lawrence took me to see the quadrangle at University College in Toronto and asked me if I
could imagine creating a work for that space. The open quadrangle is surrounded by the tall
windows and stone walls of classrooms, with a raised walkway around a grassy centre, giving it
something of a medieval quality or at least the closest thing to the Middle Ages that one might

113

expect to find in Toronto. The walkway suggested a processional work and I immediately
thought of the Children's Crusade.

I sketched out a libretto and drew a series of charts showing how the story might be staged,
employing the balconies and towers of University College, as well as the belfry tower of the
adjacent Hart House. The audience would accompany the children on their journey, both
indoors and outdoors. Lawrence liked the idea but, unfortunately, University College did not.
Unshaken we decided that I should begin to write the work while the search for an appropriate
site went on.

There were two children's crusades, one originating in Germany and the other in France; both
took place during the year 1212, quite independently of each other. Both were inspirations of
children and both were dedicated to liberating the Holy Land with love rather than force. Both
ended in disaster.

I based my text on the French story which tells how a young boy named Stephen had a vision
about leading a crusade, went to see King Phillip and, although he was laughed at by the court,
nevertheless was given free passage to Marseilles when it was pointed out to the King that
Stephen's followers were mostly orphans and gutter children so that the proposed crusade would
result in a social cleanup.

The children walked to Marseilles where they expected the waves of the Mediterranean to part
as the Red Sea had parted for Moses. The chroniclers are not very precise about how many
children reached Marseilles but most mention a figure in the thousands. Of course, the waters
did not part and the crusade ended in disaster. Many of the children drowned; others were sold
into slavery, and many starved to death as they attempted to return home.

As I mentioned, I wanted the work to move from place to place and be accompanied by an

114

itinerant audience. I wanted also to mix medieval people into the audience: jongleurs, beggars,
lepers and dancers, such as we see in the medieval manuscripts and paintings of Breughel and
others thus placing the audience inside rather outside the set as in traditional opera and
theatre. The work was to become a spectacle from all angles with the actors mixing with the
audience above, below, far, near, and never from a fixed position.

128.

Duo for Violin and Piano, 2008; 18 min; Arcana

The work was commissioned by the CBC and the Tukamore Festival for Nancy Dahn and Tim
Steeves. This is a quite conventional piece, essentially tonal with a deliberately borrowed chord
sequence from Brahms Fourth Symphony in the second movement. And yet the piece seems to
live in a world of its own, with sudden rhythm changes and cascades of sound, like confetti
thrown in the air, and melodies not quite predictably harmonized. The third movement employs
aksak rhythms found in Balkan music and ends with an actual Romanian dance tune which I
accidentally heard on the radio, supporting a news event from somewhere between Bucharest
and Sofia.

129.

The Searching Sings, 2008; 3-4 min; Arcana

This is a setting for choir of a poem by my friend Rae Crossman. I believe the poem was
inspired by the experience we share as members of the Wolf Project (nickname for And Wolf
Shall Inherit the Moon, epilogue of the PATRIA cycle) which we have been performing each
summer for more than 20 years in the Haliburton Forest and Wildlife Reserve. Rae's poem, a
paean of praise for the wilderness, seemed to sing itself into existence and the work was written
almost at one sitting.

130.

Make Room for God, 2008; 5 min; Arcana

Make Room for God was commissioned by the Tangeman Sacred Music Centre at the College
Conservatory of Music, University of Cincinnati. I was asked to select a religious text for this
115

commission and while I could have chosen one of the many I have on file, I decided to write my
own. I imagined the choir inviting God to come and join them in their singing a whimsical
idea perhaps, but one that must surely be in the mind of all singers the moment they open their
mouths.

131.

Spirits of the House, 2008, 15 min; Arcana

Spirits of the House was commissioned by Michael and Sonja Koerner for the inaugural concert
in the Koerner Concert Hall of the Royal conservatory of Music in Toronto in September 2009.
Although I studied piano and composition in Toronto, my piano degree was with the Royal
Schools of London and my composition lessons were with John Weinzweig in the old Faculty
of Music building on College Street. Nevertheless, the rubicund old Conservatory building
was very familiar to me and I attended many concerts there during my student days and later.
I am not a spiritualist, but I have often thought, along with Madame Blavatsky and many others,
that sounds do not die but continue to echo forever in the dark spaces and starry skies. Then
could we imagine all the music that has been performed in the Royal Conservatory still
lingering between the rafters and the stones of this resonant building, so that with the
stethoscope of our imagination we might hear them still mingling together imperishably?
What I have written could be described as a quodlibet a musical form consisting of snatches
of various pieces strung together in a loose formation so that each piece rises momentarily, only
to be submerged again in a texture of new sounds. From the rafters and cellars of the old
building I have strung together fragments of pieces written by some of the Conservatory's most
celebrated composers and teachers over three generations, conjoined with thoughts and
reflections of my own.

The first work we hear is the final chorus from The Wreck of the Hesperus, a cantata based on
Longfellow's poem by Arthur E. Fisher (1848 1912). The work received its first performance
on the opening concert of Massey Hall in 1894. This is introduced by a suggestion of the storm
at sea that took the lives of all passengers and crew of the fatal ship.

116

A short interlude leads to the opening of a Sonata for Cello and Piano by Leo Smith
(1881- 1952), himself an accomplished cellist. The sonata is somewhat whimsically interrupted by the
Butterfly Waltz, a work by the pianist Ernest Seitz (1892 1978) who is best known as the
composer of the ballad The World is Waiting for the Sunrise. Seitz's work is quickly invaded
by a short snatch of Samuel Dolin's Prelude for John Weinzweig. I knew Samuel Dolin (1917
2002) as a diligent teacher of several well-known composers, including Brian Cherney, Moe
Kaufmann, Michel Lontin and Ann Southam, among others. This short piano piece echoes the
brevity of the Viennese atonal school that Dolin and Weinzweig were bringing to Canada in the
1950s.

Sir Ernest MacMillan (1893 1973) was better known as an organist and conductor than as a
composer. Perhaps the earlier compositions were more adventurous and interesting but, by the
time he was conducting the Toronto Symphony, his works took on a pompous diapasonal
quality that we were trying to escape. Typical is the anthem, The King Shall Rejoice in Thy
Strength, O Lord, which sounds like an exercise for the buttocks.

Another composer in the British tradition was Healey Willan (1880 1968) who is best known
for his choral music; and one of his most beautiful choral pieces is the anthem Rise Up, My
Love, My Fair One. We hear the work in the distance with a slight wash of sound from harp
and strings.

The last piece I chose was by my teacher John Weinzweig (1903 2006). It is an early work,
The Red Ear of Corn, which I remember hearing at its premiere as a ballet in 1949. John was
probably the first Canadian to regard himself as a composer rather than a musician who also
composed, and this new attitude made it possible for many of his students to take up composing
as a serious career.

My quodlibet ends abruptly in the middle of The Red Ear of Corn's Tribal Dance, vanishing
into a peaceful slumber, which is my last memory of John in the nursing home shortly before

117

his death. We had eaten a light lunch together with his wife, Helen, and I had accompanied
them upstairs and helped John into bed where he soon drifted off to sleep.

132.

Dream-e-scape, 2009; 18 min; Arcana

Dream-e-scape was written in a streak of twenty-six days, scarcely without looking back or
trying to remember what had been written the day before. I wanted to try to capture the dream
experience of incoherence in which everything is shifting and blurred together. Now we
witness one image, now another shocking, alluring, repellent, voluptuous, risible totally
without consistency or order.
Nothing in our education prepares us for a nightmare. And yet such an event may be more
memorable than anything experienced in our rational lives. Is there anything coherent in a
dreamscape? Yes, perhaps a few recurrent notes, an incipient melody or a monumental chord
from which the sleeper may awaken enriched by the experience or desperate to escape from the
memory of it.

118