Role of Actuaries in Insurance
Role of Actuaries in Insurance
1
Study of the Role of Actuaries in Insurance
2
Study of the Role of Actuaries in Insurance
WHO IS AN ACTUARY?
Actuaries are -
To do their work, actuaries must have a high level of technical knowledge. For
example, they need to understand the nature of insurance, the risks inherent in
different types of assets, the ways in which statistical models can be used, and
3
Study of the Role of Actuaries in Insurance
the legal and regulatory constraints that apply to the business. Their work often
affects many stakeholders, so they must be able to balance different interests and
observe high ethical standards in doing so.
Although the actuarial profession has existed for many years, it is not a large
profession and, therefore, is not well known by members of the general public.
In fact, there are many countries in which no actuaries reside. Actuaries have
traditionally worked primarily in the insurance and pension industries, and
mostly in countries where those industries are well established. In the insurance
industry, actuaries can be involved in all types of insurance: life or nonlife; and
direct insurance or reinsurance.
4
Study of the Role of Actuaries in Insurance
From the fall of Rome, however, it took mathematics and business theory more
than 1,000 years to catch up to the point wherein they could be advanced further.
Edmund Halley was best known for discovering of the comet that now bears his
name. However, he also helped found modern actuarial science. In 1693, Halley
made a study of the population in the German town of Breslau. Through careful
recording of births, deaths and the aging population, Halley compiled a
"mortality table." That bit of mathematics, using probability theories developed
just a few decades before, allowed Halley to accurately predict the likelihood of
a given person dying in any given year. That, in essence, is the very foundation
of the life insurance industry. By the ability to predict life expectancy, Halley
was able to determine how much to charge a given person in premiums to cover
burial costs.
The term "actuary" was coined in London in 1762 by the Equitable, which first
used scientifically calculated premium rates. The Secretary to the Board of the
Equitable was given the title “Actuary”, based on the Latin actuarius, who was
the business manager of the Senate in ancient Rome, and kept the daily verbatim
record there. In 1775, William Morgan FRS was appointed as the Actuary of the
Equitable. Since he was himself an excellent mathematician, he took over the
role of premium calculation and financial manager and became the first actuary
in the sense we know it today.
Thus, the actuarial profession was formally established in 1848 with the
formation of the Institute of actuaries (London). At one point of time it was the
only institute it the world to conduct the professional exam. Over the years,
actuarial associations were established in several other European countries, in
the United States, Australia and Japan. In 1895, the first International Congress
of Actuaries was held in Brussels, and the International Actuarial Association
(IAA) was formed.
6
Study of the Role of Actuaries in Insurance
IN INDIA
8
Study of the Role of Actuaries in Insurance
Only if a local actuarial association imposes requirements that cover at least the
following topics is it eligible for full membership of the IAA:
• Financial mathematics
• Economics
• Accounting
• Modeling
• Statistical methods
• Actuarial mathematics
• Professionalism.
9
Study of the Role of Actuaries in Insurance
Skills required
10
Study of the Role of Actuaries in Insurance
The actuarial control cycle shows that, within the business environment, there
are many interrelated factors that affect the ability of an insurer to generate and
maintain sufficient capital to ensure that it can meet its obligations to
policyholders.
The diagram is circular because each element has an effect on the next, and
analysis of the results provides necessary input to future developments along the
entire cycle. The professionalism of the actuaries involved is an essential
ingredient in the successful operation of the cycle.
11
Study of the Role of Actuaries in Insurance
Risks
Insurers are subject to many types of risk, not only those against which they
insure policyholders, which are called underwriting risks. Other types are credit,
market, liquidity, and operational risks. The objectives of an insurer are to
understand the nature and extent of the risks to which it is subject and to manage
those risks effectively. Actuaries are often involved in the risk assessment
process. They identify the specific risks that can affect insurers and consider the
relevance of those risks to a particular insurer. They seek to quantify the most
relevant risks, and use this information to assess the potential effect of those risks
on the insurer‟s financial situation.
Actuaries also participate in managing the risks. For example, they may
determine how much risk an insurer can afford to retain on each policy, design
a reinsurance program to deal with excess amounts of risk, and negotiate the
terms of reinsurance contracts with the reinsurers.
In recent years, a growing number of companies in a wide range of businesses
have appointed chief risk officers and adopted an approach known as enterprise
risk management (ERM). In the insurance business, the chief risk officer is often
an actuary.
Design
Insurers seek to design products that will meet market needs. For example,
individuals might be willing to buy a product that would insure them against the
risk of unemployment, but if the insurance covered situations where an
individual quit voluntarily, it is unlikely that the risk could be managed by the
insurer. Of course, products must also be designed to in a way that they can be
12
Study of the Role of Actuaries in Insurance
priced appropriately, from the perspectives of both the insurer and its
policyholders.
Actuaries often play important roles in the product design process. They assist
in identifying market needs, for example, through the analysis of sales patterns,
competitors‟ products, and social and demographic trends. They work with
others, such as marketing, underwriting, and investment experts, on product
design teams. Their work can involve assessing the feasibility of product design
features suggested by others, as well as proposing alternatives for consideration.
Pricing
There are many factors that must be considered when calculating premium rates
that can be expected to produce profits. The costs of the benefits provided by the
product design must be estimated, including not only basic claims costs but also
the potential costs of any guarantees and options provided to policyholders.
Expenses must be accounted for, including commissions,
13
Study of the Role of Actuaries in Insurance
underwriting costs, other policy administration costs, and overhead costs. The
prices must reflect the rates of return that the insurer expects to earn on the
investment of premiums, as well as expectations about the willingness of the
policyholders to continue paying premiums and maintain their policies in force.
To the underlying cost factors mentioned above must be added the need to
produce a reasonable profit margin. In many jurisdictions, insurers are required
to maintain capital at levels that are related to the risks inherent in the policies
they have underwritten. Even in the absence of such requirements, sound
business practice dictates that insurers have adequate capital to support the risks
they have assumed.
Actuaries are often heavily involved in the pricing process, particularly for long
term life insurance products. They develop assumptions for the various cost
factors, taking into account the design of the product, the insurer‟s past
experience with similar products, the experience of other insurers, and
expectations of future demographic and economic conditions. Actuaries use
models to project future cash flows from the product, solving for the premium
rates that will produce the desired profit margins.
However, rarely does the actuary‟s job end there. The calculated premium rates
might be uncompetitive, at least for some potential policyholders, or outside of
the constraints set by regulation. In such cases, the actuary may need to adjust
the premium rates, for example, lowering them at some ages and raising them at
others, or modify features of the product design. The actuary also needs to test
the sensitivity of the profit margin to variations in the cost factors. If
14
Study of the Role of Actuaries in Insurance
profitability is too sensitive to certain factors, the product design may need to
be changed or an additional premium charged for the risk involved.
Liabilities
Actuaries select appropriate methods for valuing the various types of obligations.
They establish assumptions for the parameters that will affect the value of the
obligations. Economic, demographic, and business conditions change over time,
and information becomes available about the experience of the business that an
insurer has underwritten. Therefore, the assumptions used in calculating
technical provisions often differ from those used in the pricing process, and may
change over time. Actuaries must ensure that the policy and claims data used in
the calculations is as complete and accurate as possible. They prepare models
that incorporate the methods and assumptions they have selected and apply these
models to the data to calculate the technical provisions.
Assets
15
Study of the Role of Actuaries in Insurance
evaluate actual performance with reference to those targets. Some actuaries work
in the investment operations of insurers, selecting investments and managing the
mix of investments in the portfolio.
Actuaries are often responsible for modeling the asset and liability cash flows,
and assessing the effects of various risk factors on the results. They develop
techniques and measurement tools that can be used in the ALM process to reduce
the effects of these risks. For example, a basic approach to ALM involves
measuring the average duration of expected liability cash flows and investing in
a portfolio of assets that has the same average duration.
Experience analysis
16
Study of the Role of Actuaries in Insurance
When discussing the previous elements of the actuarial control cycle, the need
for an actuary to make assumptions about factors that will affect the future
profitability of an insurer has been mentioned several times. In setting the
assumptions, it is important to have both information about past experience with
respect to each of the factors and knowledge of changes in the environment that
might result in future experience being different than that of the past. Analysis
of past experience provides information about what has happened, including
trends that might continue into the future.
Profitability
17
Study of the Role of Actuaries in Insurance
Actuaries are involved in the analysis of profitability in several ways. They can
determine the sources of profits or losses. In some cases, actuaries calculate the
present value of anticipated future profits of the insurer, referred to as embedded
value. Actuaries develop dividend and bonus scales for participating or with-
profits business, and present their recommendations to the board of directors for
approval.
18
Study of the Role of Actuaries in Insurance
actuaries can help to assess whether the business should be run off or sold to
another insurer. In such transactions, as well as situations when an insurer is
changing its form of organization from mutual to shareholder-owned or vice
versa, actuaries are often required to assess the effects of the transaction on
policyholders and provide assurance that no class of policyholders will be
disadvantaged because of the transaction.
Solvency
Actuaries are experts who are experienced in examining and assessing insurance
functions, stocks and underwriting techniques and offer complex assistance
regarding actuarial matters to policy investigators and other complex staff.
Actuaries work for Insurance coverage, Retirement living funds, General
insurance, Investments, Government and Instructors. Actuaries are experts in
20
Study of the Role of Actuaries in Insurance
the industry that evaluate the effect of various forms of possibility, in the past
determining the chance of failures and working to reduce their effect.
21
Study of the Role of Actuaries in Insurance
Reserving -in reserving they apply statistical techniques to assess the likely
outcome of general insurance liabilities, typically, and the provisions that are
needed for reporting purposes.
Rating -the pricing actuary assesses the frequency and average amount of
claims to estimate premiums.
Capital modeling -for capital modeling the actuary projects both the liability
and assets of insurers to assess solvency and future capital needs.
General insurance is broadly divided into two areas, personal lines and
commercial lines. Commercial lines products are usually designed for
22
Study of the Role of Actuaries in Insurance
relatively large legal entities. These would include workers' comp (employers
liability), public liability, product liability, commercial fleet and other general
insurance products sold in a relatively standard fashion to many organisations.
There are many companies that supply comprehensive commercial insurance
packages for a wide range of different industries, including shops, restaurants
and hotels. Personal lines products are designed to be sold in large quantities.
This would include motor insurance, household insurance, pet insurance,
creditor insurance and others.
BROKERS
For insurance brokerage the primary focus of the actuary‟s role is assisting the
broker in structuring an insurance program for the client. The broker is the
individual responsible for the solicitation of actuarial work from clients and
initiates the request to prepare an actuarial study for the client.
The communication between the broker and actuary is crucial in the preliminary
stage. The actuary needs to clearly identify how the client or broker is going to
use the study. The availability of a prior study may save significant time and cost
if loss and claim count development triangles have already been prepared. The
actuary needs a clear understanding of the client‟s business. The client‟s
stockholders annual statement is a good source of information. If the client is not
a publicly traded corporation, then any client promotional information can be
used. After gathering all needed information. The actuary should send a
confirmation memo to the broker outlining the project and including the expected
cost and anticipated completion date.
23
Study of the Role of Actuaries in Insurance
With the large amount of data available, more emphasis can be placed on the
client„s data and less on the industry data. Due to the large number of claims, it
is possible for the actuary to do more analysis that reflects the unique experience
of the client. Because of the emphasis on the client‟s data, the actuary may have
substantial direct contact with the client. An important use of the actuarial study
is the calculation of the appropriate accruals for the projected period and the
required reserves for prior periods.
The ability of the actuary to analyze the client‟s data is a critical role. The
process begins with the actuary analyzing the most recent evaluation of detailed
data for the client. The actuary needs to ascertain whether or not
24
Study of the Role of Actuaries in Insurance
allocated loss adjustment expenses are included and whether the losses are
limited to some amount or unlimited.
The analysis begins by segmenting the most recent evaluation of incurred losses
into ranges. The actuary examines this data to see if the losses fit the pattern that
the actuary would anticipate for this type of client. If the study has been prepared
in the past, then the actuary can compare policy periods at like periods of
development. This is extremely important for analyzing the most current period
and any possible changes in the initial reserving philosophy. The actuary‟s
experience can be used to analyze the loss distribution to determine whether the
claim reporting pattern, percentage of claims, and size and number of open
claims seem reasonable. This is information that can be very important to the
client and broker, especially when a client changes claims adjustment
organizations.
The actuary has the responsibility in the brokerage firm to keep the brokers
aware of changes in the actuarial environment. The medium to convey the
information can range from a phone call to a seminar. Some examples are:
25
Study of the Role of Actuaries in Insurance
The legislation requires the Appointed Actuary to carry out an annual valuation
of the liabilities of the long-term insurance business and to determine the surplus
in the long-term business fund available for distribution. The Appointed Actuary
must provide an annual certificate detailing the amount of the required minimum
solvency margin and certifying that the amount published as reserves in respect
of the liabilities of the long-term business constitutes proper provision for those
liabilities. The Appointed Actuary must
26
Study of the Role of Actuaries in Insurance
also certify each year that the data are adequate to support the valuation and that
the premiums charged have been adequate in relation to the corresponding
liabilities being taken on, having regard to the overall financial position of the
company.
The Appointed Actuary must be satisfied at all times that, if he or she were to
carry out a full actuarial valuation, the financial position would be satisfactory.
The formal published valuation takes place only annually, is submitted to the
supervisor six months after the date to which it relates, and may not be analysed
in detail until some weeks (or even months) after that. The Appointed Actuary,
on the other hand, is deemed to be in such a key position within the company
that he or she should have a good idea of what the position is at any particular
moment, and not just at year-ends. In order to be satisfied on this, the Appointed
Actuary has to monitor in detail all aspects which could impinge upon the
company‟s financial position, in particular:
product design
methods of marketing
volumes of business
premium rates
options and guarantees
surrender values and paid-up values
investments held and changes in investment policy
derivative exposures
current and likely future level of expenses
current and likely future tax basis
reinsurance arrangements
claims handling policy
27
Study of the Role of Actuaries in Insurance
The Appointed Actuary needs to be able to model the financial behaviour of the
company between valuations, so as to be able to estimate the effects of these
various factors on the overall financial condition and, in particular, on the
company‟s ability to meet (and continue to meet) the minimum solvency margin
requirement.
28
Study of the Role of Actuaries in Insurance
29
Study of the Role of Actuaries in Insurance
In particular and without prejudice to the generality of the foregoing matters, and
in the interests of the insurance industry and the policyholders, the duties and
obligations of an Actuary of an insurer shall include:--
30
Study of the Role of Actuaries in Insurance
31
Study of the Role of Actuaries in Insurance
32
Study of the Role of Actuaries in Insurance
The Actuarial Society of India (ASI), the only professional body of Actuaries in
India was formed in 1944 and was admitted as a member of the International
Actuarial Association (IAA), an umbrella organization to all actuarial bodies
across the world, in 1979. It was registered in 1982 under registration of
Literacy, Scientific and Charitable Societies Act XIII of 1960. Its objectives
include the advancement of Actuarial profession in India, providing
opportunities for interaction among members of the profession, facilitating
research, arranging lectures on relevant subjects and providing facilities and
Guidance to those studying for the professional Actuarial Examination.
The Institute of Actuaries Of India (IAI or formally ASI) was initially started as
a non-examining body when Actuaries used to get qualified from Institute of
Actuaries or Faculty of Actuaries of UK. The Institute of Actuaries of India
started conducting Entrance Examinations in India for students of Institute of
Actuaries, UK, in 1975. In 1989, it started conducting examinations for its
33
Study of the Role of Actuaries in Insurance
Objectives
34
Study of the Role of Actuaries in Insurance
9. To extend and improve the data and methods of the Science which has its
origin in the application of the doctrine of probabilities to the affairs of
life and to consider all monetary questions involving, separately or in
combination, the mathematical doctrine of probabilities and the principles
of interest;
10.To plan, promote and provide for interaction amongst the members, to
arrange facilities for the reading of papers, the delivery of lectures, the
discussion of topics and for the acquisition and dissemination by other
means of useful information and knowledge connected with Actuarial
Science and other allied subjects with special reference to Indian
conditions;
13.To provide educational services and other facilities to those studying for
actuarial examinations;
15.To form and maintain either by itself or in collaboration with some other
Organization or organizations a library or libraries for use by members of
the Society;
19. To maintain contact and co-operate with other institutions in any part of
the world having objects wholly or partly similar to those of the Society
including by way of payment of subscription, enrollment as a member
thereof, and generally in such a manner as may be conducive to the
furtherance of the common objects as the Society may deem necessary;
20. To discuss and comment on the actuarial aspects of public, social and
economic and financial questions which from time to time may be the
subject of public interest;
21. To consider the actuarial aspects of legislation, existing and proposed, and
to take such action as is considered desirable;
36
Study of the Role of Actuaries in Insurance
22. To arrange for the compilation and publication of statistical data and of
actuarial tables based thereon;
23. To raise funds by subscription from the members of the Society and to
accept donations and bequests for all or any of the purposes of the Society;
and
24. Generally do all such things as from time to time may be necessary to
elevate the status and procure advancement of the interest of the
profession.
Apart from the traditional areas of life and general insurance, pension and
reinsurance, actuaries now act as consultants, investment advisers and risk
managers as well. ASI fellowships can be completed in 5-6 years' time. Actuarial
studies can be pursued alongside a full-time job. With about 6 years of
experience, a fellowship and work at a senior position, you can earn Rs 50 lakh
a year.
Actuarial Workspace
37
Study of the Role of Actuaries in Insurance
First, over 10,000 people in India are currently sitting for the actuarial exams.
As the result of the growth in the knowledge worker outsourcing industry, and
the privatization of the Indian insurance industry, actuarial studies are now much
more attractive to qualified students. Scarcity will be reduced as a result of this
increasing supply of expertise.
38
Study of the Role of Actuaries in Insurance
Leading companies will recognize that the traditional insurance product pricing
process can be separated into separate activities, some of which can be
outsourced. For example, the development of loss triangles and the updating of
price indications are examples of discrete, measurable work that can be
effectively performed remotely. Once these tasks are complete, internal actuaries
can then review them and make final, proprietary pricing decisions. Moving
the tactical work offshore lowers costs, and frees company resources to focus on
higher value activities.
There are barriers to this transition. Tradition and inertia will slow adoption. It
may take seven to 10 years, but the cost advantages and a need to redirect
company talent will eventually result in a shift the norm to a multi-source,
onshore/offshore actuarial model.
The growth in the Indian financial market is the major reason for the spurt in the
demand for actuaries. Apart from the traditional areas of life and general
39
Study of the Role of Actuaries in Insurance
insurance, pension and reinsurance, actuaries are now needed to play the roles
of consultants, investment advisers and risk managers as well. A number of
banks are planning joint ventures to set up insurance companies , which is likely
to raise the number of life insurance companies. The number of general
insurance companies is also expected to increase. The health insurance sector is
also expected to get a big dose of growth. Reforms in pension funds, whenever
they happen, are also expected to add to the demand. India has the potential to
emerge as a key actuarial back office in the BPO sector as well. A few companies
are already in the business of low-level calculations.
COMPARISONS ABROAD
Canada
Canada has adopted many of the features of the original U.K. Appointed Actuary
model, but has adapted the system to a different regulatory and legal
environment and has expanded the role to general insurance companies. Both
life and general insurance companies are required to appoint an actuary, and
there is a high degree of involvement by the Canadian Institute of Actuaries
(CIA), of which the Appointed Actuary must be a member in good standing. The
Appointed Actuary is responsible for the calculation of the risk-based capital
requirement (Minimum Continuing Capital and Surplus Requirement, or
MCCSR), and is also required to report to the Board of Directors regularly on
the results of dynamic capital adequacy testing (DCAT), along similar lines to
the dynamic financial analysis referred to above in the context of the U.K.
United States
40
Study of the Role of Actuaries in Insurance
The United States has not yet introduced a full appointed actuary system. On the
life side the role has changed in recent years from evaluating the liabilities in
accordance with regulatory norms to providing an opinion as to whether the
assets are adequate to cover the liabilities. Cash -flow testing, using prescribed
investment scenarios, is required to be carried out on a quarterly basis to ensure
that, on a realistic basis, assets equal to the statutory liabilities are sufficient to
enable policy benefits to be paid out. The actuarial profession has played a
significant role in the development of risk-based capital requirements, which
have been adopted in all U.S. jurisdictions. A number of states have also
introduced the concept of an “illustrations actuary” to ensure that excessive
benefits are not projected at the point of sale.
European Union
Germany
41
Study of the Role of Actuaries in Insurance
Italy
Italy has for some years had a requirement for an actuarial opinion on the
technical provisions of a general insurance company. This opinion has to be
provided to the auditor of the general insurance company, as part of the process
of establishing whether the accounts show a true and fair view of the financial
situation of the company. After several years of debate, it now seems that an
Appointed Actuary role will soon be introduced in respect of the life insurance
business.
Belgium has introduced its own version of the appointed actuary system, for both
life and general insurance companies. The Netherlands has a longer tradition of
actuarial professional responsibilities in the area of designing and pricing
products for life insurance and in respect of non-life reserving. The Dutch
actuarial profession (Het Actuarieel Genootschap) also has more experience than
most Continental European actuarial associations of developing postgraduate
education programs.
Japan
Japan had a tradition more closely akin to that of Germany, but has now
introduced a form of appointed actuary system (Hoken-Keirinin) as part of the
deregulatory modifications to the insurance law. The Institute of Actuaries of
Japan has issued a standard of practise which was strongly influenced by the
U.K. standard.
42
Study of the Role of Actuaries in Insurance
France
Switzerland
Other Countries
Outside Europe and North America, Australia and South Africa both have a
long-established professional role for the actuary in environments where
43
Study of the Role of Actuaries in Insurance
Hong Kong, Singapore and Malaysia have appointed actuary systems and place
considerable professional responsibility on the actuary.
Other countries in East Asia do not have a strong professional role for the actuary
and rely on more prescriptive regulation. This is also the case in most Latin
American countries and, to an extent, in the countries in transition in Central
and Eastern Europe. In most of the latter countries the actuarial profession has
recently undergone a rebirth and actuarial associations are still at an early stage
of development.
CONCLUSION
44
Study of the Role of Actuaries in Insurance
This project has attempted to describe some of the many roles an actuary plays
in an insurance firm. I believe and as shown in this project that an actuary plays
an important role in the insurance sector and that his work is indispensable. As
the market hardens the importance of the role of the actuary will increase.
An actuary is the technical expert on life insurance matters studying the mortality
of the insuring public, evaluating the financial condition of the insurer,
determining the policies to be offered and the premium to be charged,
determining the policies to follow in underwriting an investments of its funds,
deciding on the bonus that can be declared on the participating policies and so
on. A good actuary is a good economist, a good statistician and a good security
analyst.
45
Study of the Role of Actuaries in Insurance
BIBLIOGRAPHY
www.actuaries.org.uk
www.actuariesindia.org
www.beanactuary.org
www.actuarialpost.co.uk
www.worldbank.org
www.insurancenetworking.com
www.actuarialsociety.org
www.casact.org
46