Current Technologies and Trends in The Development of Gyros Used in Navigation Applications - A Review
Current Technologies and Trends in The Development of Gyros Used in Navigation Applications - A Review
ISBN: 978-1-61804-018-3 63
Recent Researches in Communications and IT
fiber optics, laser, radioactive isotope sensors, polarized [28].Anyway, IFOGs continue to advance in force on the
sensors and so on. market, and have reached practicability in lower performance
The main errors in inertial navigation systems are the areas, especially in tactical and commercial applications.
incorrect start of the navigation system, the imperfections of The traditional FOGs have fiber optical coils about two
the gravity model used in applications, and the imperfections inches in diameter and are used in tactical grade applications,
of gyros sensors and accelerometers [10]. The result is so with a relatively low level of performance required.
detrimental to the useful signal obtained at the sensor outputs, With help received from the researchers in the field of
signal that is then supplied to the navigator. For the gyros, interferometry, FOG interferometers came to compete with
whose major errors are in measuring angular rates, the largest RLG technology in high precision applications, precise aiming
errors are caused usually by a bias instability (measured in of telescopes, imaging systems, and antennas, or for strategic-
deg/hr for gyro bias drift, and scale-factor stability (which is grade navigation of submarines at a reasonable manufacturing
usually measured in parts per million (ppm) of the sensed costs with the parameters: bias stability less than 0.0003°/ h,
inertial quantity). The navigator will become more expensive ARW (angular random walk) of less than 0.00008°/h1/2 and
the smaller the inertial sensors are and the better the scale factor error less than 0.5 ppm [37], [38].
instruments quality, and the greater the precision of the Research in the field of fiber optic gyros, similarly to those
navigation solution. [10]. of RLG, aimed at decreasing the size and manufacturing costs
In recent years, in the inertial detection, three major at an approximately constant level of performance, if not
technologies led to significant advances in military and better. Development of miniaturized FOGs was based on the
commercial applications. These are the Ring Laser Gyro (since technology achievements brought by the telecommunications
~1975), Fiber Optic Gyros (since ~1985), and MEMS (since industry [28].
~1995). An important innovation was the discovery of photonic
crystal fibers (PCF Fibers crystal photon) that have been a
II. OPTICAL GYROS very important step towards the next generation of IFOG
The Ring Laser Gyros (RLG) have entered the market only instruments, the PC-IFOG.
in 1980’s even if in 1963 was first demonstrated in a square The introduction of PCFs in IFOG applications brings
configuration. Mechanical gyroscopes dominated the market significant advantages to this field, such as the significant
and the RLG were required in military applications, because reduction of bend losses and fiber size compared to the
these are ideal systems for high dynamics strap-down inertial conventional optical fiber, minimizing the fiber optic coil
navigation, used in extreme environments. The RLG has diameter, the possibility of incorporating a dispersion
excellent scale-factor stability and linearity, negligible compensation in the existing PCF, with the effect of reducing
sensitivity to acceleration, digital output, fast turn-on, excellent the spectral distortion, guiding light through this type of fiber
stability and repeatability across the range, and no moving allows the use of a mid-infrared optical wavelength [40].
parts. Present day RLG’s (Ring Laser Gyros) is considered a A next step in FOG miniaturization is the development of a
matured technology and its development efforts are to reduce monolithic optical chip, containing both the light source and
costs more than to increase its performance. [4] - [6], [14], detector and the modulation. At this point, there are
[18], [28]-[34]. technological problems related to dispersion limitation.
Fiber optic gyros (FOG) are also a mature technology and The passing of optical rotational devices in the MEMS
were originally designed as a low-cost alternative to the RLG. domain was realized through the Integrated Optics Gyro, also
Surprisingly, today they complete RLG’s both in terms of called optical gyro on a chip. IOG is nothing else than a gyro -
manufacturing costs, as well as that of performance, gaining an optical waveguide gyro, based on the Sagnac effect,
prominence in a series of military and commercial applications obtained by combining MEMS technology with the
[36]-[39]. The studies provide that the developments in solid- possibilities offered by the integrated optics.
state optics and fiber technology could lead to 0.001-deg/h Fig. 1 shows all the on-chip components of an IOG and a
performance in miniature design. close-up of an optical waveguide. As we can see, two beams of
In 1976, IFOG feasibility was demonstrated when an light travel in opposite directions around a waveguide ring
interference pattern (Sagnac effect) was discerned from light resonator [40]. To access the class of precision of the inertial
traveling CW and CCW around an optical fiber, at the navigators (0.01 degree/ h and 0.01 grad/ h ½ ARW), IOG
University of Utah [3]. The advantages IFOG has over the devices must be placed in a waveguide with losses below
RLG are that the light source does not require high voltage; the 0.001dB/cm. A research direction imposed by the IOG
broadband light source prevents backscatter so there is no performance improvement is in finding technological solutions
lock-in at low input rates; it has the potential for lower cost to slow the propagation of light through the wave-guide, to
and lighter weight [6]. obtain ultra-sensitive optical gyros, studies for this purpose
IFOG (interferometric fiber optic gyro) has not yet replaced being carried out [44], [45].
RLG in production due, in particular, to the existence of a In the 1980s, the Hemispherical Resonant Gyro was
large part of the infrastructure created specifically for RLG's developed, a vibratory high performance gyro; the inertial
ISBN: 978-1-61804-018-3 64
Recent Researches in Communications and IT
sensing element is a fused-silica hemispherical shell coated of the sensor entails decreased sensitivity, increased noise and
with a thin film of metal. HRG advantages are related to the decreased ability to control the sensing elements. In addition,
fact that it is very light, compact, operates in vacuum and has the change in Young’s Modulus of silicon is ~ 100 ppm/°C,
no moving parts. Its life cycle is limited only by the electronic which leads to concerns regarding the thermal sensitivity.
components, which are redundant [6].
ISBN: 978-1-61804-018-3 65
Recent Researches in Communications and IT
Prize 2005) today is possible to have precise control on the Today we can trap and manipulate, as we need, a very large
internal and external of freedom of atomic matter. Those huge quantity of identical atoms.
progresses led to application of ultra cold matter in fields such There are two perspectives in trapping neutral atoms: the
as precision measurements, matter wave interferometry and interaction of an optical field with the atomic induced electric
applications in quantum information processing [49]. dipole moment or the interaction of a magnetic field with the
The atom interferometers are very similar in their basic atomic magnetic dipole moment. The most analyzed method of
principle with the optical interferometers. The difference is optical trapping is the optical lattice [54]. Optical lattices can
that the optical wave is replaced with the matter-wave be loaded with many atoms coming from a laser-cooled
represented by the atoms. ensemble or from a BEC [55].
Today, the laser interferometers prove to be the most
B. Superconducting Atom-Chips
precise measurement instruments for a variety of applied
sciences and engineering. Among them, there are micro- Superconductor technology resulted from the merger with
positioning and distance measurements or the measurement of atom optical systems. This will allow a new generation of
inertial forces such as accelerations or rotations. Laser essential experiments and new applications, possibly resulting
gyroscopes make use of the well-developed technologies of in the pairing of quantum solid-state devices with neutral
lasers and precision optical elements. However, in comparison atoms. These can be used for quantum state transfer between
to optical interferometers, atom interferometers have the solid-state and atomic systems or quantum information
potential to achieve sensitivities several orders of magnitude processing. The so-called 'atom chips', which are micro-
higher for some applications [50]. They may also enable structured surface trapping and manipulation devices, have
interferometry measurements not possible with optical proven their great capability and flexibility in the field of ultra-
interferometry. An impressive list of high-precision atom cold atom experiments over the previous period. These
interferometry measurements of fundamental constants, atomic elements allow the generation of steep trapping potentials
properties, inertial forces, and rotations has been performed using current carrying wires or permanent magnetic structures,
[49].Also in this domain, atom interferometry, Martin L. Perl as well as micro-optical devices. Additionally, the
(from Kavli Institute for Particle Astrophysics and Cosmology, manipulation of neutral atoms with micro-structured elements
SLAC Linear Accelerator Laboratory Stanford University) is promising for the goal of achieving systems suitable for the
together with some collaborators constructed an atom quantum information processing.
interferometer experiment. The purpose is to investigate the Researchers form Nanyang Technological University (NTU)
nature of dark energy and to search for unknown contents of laboratories, has begun a unique project investigating the
the vacuum using atom interferometry (a.k.a. “Dark Contents controlled interaction of superconducting quantum states with
of the Vacuum”). In this method, there are used two atom atomic quantum matter trapped on a superconducting atom
interferometers in order to eliminate the effect of earth’s chip. This chip uses a high temperature superconductor for
gravity and of various noise sources. The device is now under trapping and manipulating of the atomic states, which allows
construction. [53] for a simplified experimental setup with standard laser-cooling
New results in this direction could give new impetus to both and trapping techniques.
theories of modern physics and a new perspective of how we By using a high temperature superconductor, a completely
can see the Universe and its evolution. [48] new field has been opened, and the possibility to analyze each
The current state-of-art of atom interferometry: the atom physical system, solid state and atomic matter will be
interferometers obtained and proof-of-concept. Although gyros remarkable possibilities that will bring important contributions
and accelerometers are yet too voluminous, the miniaturization to the quantum computation [49].
seems feasible in the near future and is developing [31]-[34], C. Guided and free-space matter-wave interferometer
[41]. Today, using laser light interferometers, the most precise
Scientists from the international quantum physics measurements are achieved in a variety of applied sciences and
community are investigating novel ideas in the fields of engineering. Examples are micro-positioning and distance
coupled quantum systems including atomic matter, quantum measurements, or the measurement of inertial forces such as
information processing and precision measurements. rotations or accelerations. Laser gyroscopes make use of the
Research refers are related with: quantum registers for neutral well-established technologies of lasers and precision optical
atoms, interaction of superconducting microstructures with elements.
atomic quantum states, guided and free-space matter-wave Current applications focus on the achieving of guided
interferometry, and not only [44], [31]. interferometers, but in the future one important direction will
A. Quantum registers for neutral atoms be to realize improvements in currently used free-space atom
Quantum bits (also known as qubits) are trapped ultra-cold interferometers.
neutral atoms, utilized in quantum information processing. At this time, NTU research efforts are directed to obtain a
They are based on the simple quantum-level structure of atoms guided matter-wave interferometer that makes use of specially-
in conditions of good insulation related to the environment. designed superconducting elements on a chip [49].
ISBN: 978-1-61804-018-3 66
Recent Researches in Communications and IT
ISBN: 978-1-61804-018-3 67
Recent Researches in Communications and IT
Significant technological changes will blossom in the next [26] Systems Planning and Analysis, Inc. webpage: http://www.spa.com
[27] Systron Donner webpage: http://www.systron.com
few years as the multiple developments of MEMS, NEMS, [28] T.L. Grigorie, Strap-Down Inertial Navigation Systems, SITECH, 2007
micromachining, and biochemical technologies create a [29] N. Barbour, G. Schmidt, “Inertial Sensor Technology Trends”, IEEE
powerful confluence. MEMS inertial sensor development Sensors Journal, Vol. 1, No. 4, 2001, pp. 332-339.
continues to be a world-wide effort. The integrated optics gyro [30] A. Mignot, s.a. “Single-frequency external-cavity semiconductor ring-
laser gyroscope”. Optics letters, 2009, Jan. 1; No. 34(1), 97-9.
(IOG) is a true solid-state, optics-on-a-chip sensor, [31] T.L. Grigorie, R.M. Botez, “Modelling and numerical simulation of an
manufactured with MEMS, with the potential (theoretically) to algorithm for the inertial sensors errors reduction and for the increase of
provide navigation-grade performance or higher. This has the the strap-down navigator redundancy degree in a low cost architecture”,
Transactions of the CSME, Vol. 34, No. 1, 2010.
potential to be a gaining technology. [32] T.L. Grigorie, R.M. Botez, “The bias temperature dependence
If the space community at large is properly prepared and estimation and compensation for an accelerometer by use of the neuro-
equipped, the opportunity to design, develop, and use fuzzy techniques, Transactions of the CSME, Vol. 32(3), 2008.
[33] T.L. Grigorie, “The Matlab/Simulink modeling and numerical
revolutionary, ultra-integrated mechanical, thermal, chemical, simulation of an analogue capacitive micro-accelerometer. Part 1: Open
fluidic, and biologic micro-systems can be seized. loop”, MEMSTECH Conference, 2008.
[34] T.L. Grigorie, “The Matlab/Simulink modeling and numerical
ACKNOWLEDGMENT simulation of an analogue capacitive micro-accelerometer. Part 2:
Closed loop”, MEMSTECH Conference, 2008.
This work was supported by CNCSIS-UEFISCSU, project [35] Northrop Grumman webpage: http://www.northropgrumman.com
PN II-RU, No. 1/28.07.2010, “High-precision strap-down [36] G. Pavlath, “Fiber Optic Gyros: the vision realized”, 18th International
Conference on Optical Fiber Sensors, Cancun, Mexico, 2006.
inertial navigators, based on the connection and adaptive [37] KVH Industries Inc., “An Update on KVH Fiber Optic Gyros and Their
integration of the nano and micro inertial sensors in low cost Benefits Relative to Other Gyro Technologies”, March 2007.
networks, with a high degree of redundance”, code [38] S. Divakaruni, S. Sanders, “Fiber Optic Gyros – A Compelling Choice
for High Accuracy Applications”, 18th International Conference on
TE_102/2010. Optical Fiber Sensors, Cancun, Mexico, 2006.
[39] T. Gaiffe, “From R&D Brassboards to Navigation Grade FOG-Based
REFERENCES INS: The Experience of Photonetics/Ixsea”, 15th Optical Fiber Sensors
Conference Technical Digest, pp. 1-4, vol. 1, May 2002.
[1] R. Osiander, M.A. Garrison, “Overview of Micro-electro-mechanical [40] J. Tawney, “Photonic Crystal Fiber IFOGs”, 18th International
Systems and Microstructures in Aerospace Applications”, 2006. Conference on Optical Fiber Sensors, Cancun, Mexico, 2006.
[2] Watch Time webpage: http://www.watchtime.com [41] T. Müller, et al., “Towards a guided interferometer based on a
[3] R. Osiander, M.A. Garrison, and J.L. Champion, “MEMS and superconducting atom chip”, New J. Phys., 10, 073006, 2008.
Microstructures in Aerospace Applications”, 2006 [42] S. Sanders, L. Strandjord, D. Mead, “Fiber-Optic Gyro Technology
[4] N.M. Barbour, R. Hopkins, A. Kourepenis, P. Ward, “Inertial MEMS Trends - A Honeywell Perspective”, 15th Optical Fiber Sensors
System Applications”, NATO RTO Lecture Series, RTO-EN-SET-116, Conference Technical Digest, pp. 5-8, vol. 1, May 2002.
Low-Cost Navigation Sensors and Integration Technology, 2010. [43] K. Hans, “A Submarine Navigator for the 21st Century”, IEEE PLANS,
[5] R.E. Hopkins, N.M. Barbour, D.E. Gustafson, P. Sherman, “Miniature Palm Springs, CA, April 2002.
Inertial and Augmentation Sensors for Integrated Inertial/GPS Based [44] J. Scheuer, A. Yariv, “Sagnac Effect in Coupled resonator Slow-Light
Navigation Applications”, NATO RTO Lecture Series, RTO-EN-SET- Waveguide Structures”, Physical Review Letters, Vol. 96, 2006.
116, Low-Cost Navigation Sensors and Integration Technology, 2010. [45] B. Steinberg, “Slow-light waveguides with mode degeneracy: Rotation
[6] N.M. Barbour, “Inertial Navigation Sensors”, NATO RTO Lecture Induced Super Structures and Optical Gyroscopes”, 18th International
Series, RTO-EN-SET-116, Low-Cost Navigation Sensors and Conference on Optical Fiber Sensors, Cancun, Mexico, 2006.
Integration Technology, 2010. [46] T.L. Grigorie, “An optimization procedure for a fiber optic
[7] Advanced Photonix webpage: http://www.advancedphotonix.com accelerometer”. MEMSTECH Conference, 2007.
[8] Phone-or webpage: http://www.phone-or.com [47] R. Lungu, T.L. Grigorie, “Measurement of the accelerations using a
[9] QPhotonics webpage: http:// www.qphotonics.com fiber Bragg grating transducer”. The XXXII-th Scientific Session with
[10] G. Schmidt, “INS/GPS Technology Trends”, NATO RTO Lecture Series, International Participation, The Research Agency for Military
RTO-EN-SET-116, Low-Cost Navigation Sensors and Integration Techniques and Technologies, Bucharest, Romania,12-13 April, 2001.
Technology, 2010. [48] C. Dauwalter, J. Ha, “Magnetically Suspended MEMS Spinning Wheel
[11] L. Moody, “Sensors, Measurement Fusion and Missile Trajectory Gyro”, IEEE A&E Systems Magazine, Vol 20, No 2, Feb 2005.
Optimisation (PhD Thesis)”, Cranfield University, UK, 2003. [49] T. Mueller, R. Dumke, “Technology with Cold Atoms”, Innovation,
[12] Crossbow Technology webpage: http://www.xbow.com Vol.9, No.2, 2010.
[13] Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency MEMS webpage: [50] J.M. McGuirk, G.T. Foster, J.B. Fixler, M.A. Kasevich, “Method of
http://www.darpa.mil/MTO/ MEMS/ phase extraction between coupled atom interferometers using ellipse-
[14] Honeywell Avionics webpage: http://www.honeywell.com/sites/aero/ specific fitting”, Phys. Rev. A 65, 033608, 2002.
technology/avionics. htm [51] M. Kasevich, C. Salomon - Editors, Special Issue: “Quantum Mechanics
[15] Kionics webpage: http://kionix.com for Space Application: From Quantum Optics to Atom Optics and
[16] M. Kraft, “Micromachined Inertial Sensors State of the Art and a Look General Relativity”, Applied Physics B, Vol 84, August 2006.
into the Future”, University of Southampton, Higfield, Southampton. [52] M. Zhan, “Cold Atom Interferometry”, Journal of Physics: Conference
[17] KVH Industries webpage: http://www.kvh.com Series 80 (2007) 012047.
[18] A. Lawrence, Modern Inertial Technology: Navigation, Guidance And [53] R.J. Adler, “A terrestrial search for dark contents of the vacuum, such as
Control. Springer Verlag, New York, 1993 dark energy, using atom interferometry”, Stanford University, Stanford
[19] MEMS technologies for aerospace applications in Canada webpage: CA 94309, US, February 1, 2011.
http://www.cls3.ca/ mems/ [54] P.S. Jessen, I.H. Deutsch, “Quantum technology with cold atoms”,
[20] MEMS and Nanotechnology webpage: http://www.memsnet.org Advances in Atomic, Molecular, and Optical Physics, Vol. 37, B.
[21] MEMSIC webpage: http://www.memsic.com/memsic/ Bederson and H. Walther, Eds., Academic, San Diego, 1996.
[22] MSI Sensors webpage : http://www.cdiweb.com/icsensors [55] W. Bakr, A. Peng, M. Tai, J. Simon, J. Gillen, S. Folling, L. Pollet, M.
[23] MSISensors webpage: http://www.msisensors.com Greiner, “Probing the Superfluid-to-Mott-Instulator Transition at the
[24] SAAB Technologies webpage : http://products.saab.se Single-Atom Level”, Science 10.1126, 1192368.
[25] Silicon Designs webpage: http://www.silicondesigns.com
ISBN: 978-1-61804-018-3 68