The Project Control Framework Handbook v2 April 2013
The Project Control Framework Handbook v2 April 2013
abbreviations ECI
HA
Early contractor involvement
Highways Agency
HIB Highways investment board
HPB Highways programme board
IA Investment authorisation
The Department for Transport’s investment
IAF
appraisal framework
ICF The Highways Agency’s investment control framework
MAC Managing agent contractor
MM Managed motorways
MM-ALR Managed motorways - all lanes running
MP Major Projects (directorate)
NDD Network Delivery and Development (directorate)
NetServ Network Services (directorate)
NSIP Nationally significant infrastructure project
PCF Project control framework
PICG Project investment control group
RCC Regional control centre
RPA Risk potential assessment
RTMC Regional technology maintenance contractor
SGAR Stage gate assessment review
SHARE The Highways Agency’s document management system
SofS Secretary of State (for transport)
SRO Senior responsible owner
TechMAC Technology managing agent contractor
TM Traffic Management (directorate)
<< <<
Contents Acronyms & About this About the project Major road The Major Projects Products and Tips for the consistent & How stages Project assurance Roles & Project handover Annex A - project
abbreviations handbook control framework projects lifecycle product matrices effective application of the PCF are managed & governance responsibilities and closeout control processes
THE PROJECT CONTROL FRAMEWORK HANDBOOK – V 2 – APRIL 2013 3
<< <<
THE PROJECT CONTROL FRAMEWORK HANDBOOK – V 2 – APRIL 2013 4
<< <<
Contents Acronyms & About this About the project Major road The Major Projects Products and Tips for the consistent & How stages Project assurance Roles & Project handover Annex A - project
abbreviations handbook control framework projects lifecycle product matrices effective application of the PCF are managed & governance responsibilities and closeout control processes
THE PROJECT CONTROL FRAMEWORK HANDBOOK – V 2 – APRIL 2013 5
<< <<
Contents Acronyms & About this About the project Major road The Major Projects Products and Tips for the consistent & How stages Project assurance Roles & Project handover Annex A - project
abbreviations handbook control framework projects lifecycle product matrices effective application of the PCF are managed & governance responsibilities and closeout control processes
THE PROJECT CONTROL FRAMEWORK HANDBOOK – V 2 – APRIL 2013 6
Contents Acronyms & About this About the project Major road The Major Projects Products and Tips for the consistent & How stages Project assurance Roles & Project handover Annex A - project
abbreviations handbook control framework projects lifecycle product matrices effective application of the PCF are managed & governance responsibilities and closeout control processes
THE PROJECT CONTROL FRAMEWORK HANDBOOK – V 2 – APRIL 2013 7
Options Development Construction • Projects may drop out of the lifecycle at any
point up to the commitment to invest if they fail
Commitment
to invest value for money, affordability or other criteria
Commitment
to investigate
Roles and responsibilities for
Figure 2: The three phases of the PCF
major projects
Options phase – identifies the preferred road • During the options phase the senior responsible
solution to the transport problem. By the end of the owner is DfT for those projects with more than
phase there is certainty that, for example, the
one route option. For single option projects this
project will involve widening along a specific route.
role may be assigned to the Highways Agency.
Development phase – focuses on the design of the
preferred solution taking it through the necessary • If a project progresses into the development
statutory processes up to the point where a phase the Highways Agency becomes the
decision to commit to invest in building the road senior responsible owner (if they are not already)
solution can be made.
and continues this role in the construction phase.
Construction phase – is where the road solution is
built, handed over for operation and the project is • The project sponsor and project manager roles
closed down. are constant throughout the three phases. The
project sponsor is always DfT, the project
manager is always a Highways Agency role.
<< <<
Contents Acronyms & About this About the project Major road The Major Projects Products and Tips for the consistent & How stages Project assurance Roles & Project handover Annex A - project
abbreviations handbook control framework projects lifecycle product matrices effective application of the PCF are managed & governance responsibilities and closeout control processes
THE PROJECT CONTROL FRAMEWORK HANDBOOK – V 2 – APRIL 2013 8
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
Strategy, Statutory Construction,
shaping and Option Option Preliminary procedures Construction commissioning Closeout
prioritisation identification selection design and powers preparation and handover
<< <<
Contents Acronyms & About this About the project Major road The Major Projects Products and Tips for the consistent & How stages Project assurance Roles & Project handover Annex A - project
abbreviations handbook control framework projects lifecycle product matrices effective application of the PCF are managed & governance responsibilities and closeout control processes
THE PROJECT CONTROL FRAMEWORK HANDBOOK – V 2 – APRIL 2013 9
Major 1
Identify options to be taken to public consultation
Projects Option
identification
Assess options in terms of environmental impact, traffic forecasts and economic benefits
lifecycle Refine the cost estimate of options (including an allowance for risk)
Carry out public consultation including exhibitions
2 Refine the cost estimate for preferred option (including allowance for risk)
Option
Refine the environmental impact assessment, traffic forecasts, and economic benefits
selection
following public consultation if required
Produce an outline business case
Contents Acronyms & About this About the project Major road The Major Projects Products and Tips for the consistent & How stages Project assurance Roles & Project handover Annex A - project
abbreviations handbook control framework projects lifecycle product matrices effective application of the PCF are managed & governance responsibilities and closeout control processes
THE PROJECT CONTROL FRAMEWORK HANDBOOK – V 2 – APRIL 2013 10
The Publish notice of acceptance of Planning Act 2008 draft development consent order
and application (or notice of draft Highways Act 1980 orders if the scheme is below the
Major threshold for a NSIP) and environmental statement as appropriate (exhibitions may be
considered for Highways Act 1980 orders)
Projects 4
Arrange public inquiry for Highways Act 1980 orders (if required)
Under the Planning Act 2008 the Planning Inspectorate will decide on the preliminary
lifecycle Statutory meeting and examination of the application for development consent. We will need to
procedures register and comment as an interested party (the developer)
and powers
Present evidence and rebuttals to objections for Highways Act 1980 orders at inquiry
The Planning Inspectorate panel or inspector will make recommendations to the
Secretary of State
Issue secretary of state’s decision letter confirming whether orders/development
consent are to be confirmed as published in draft, rejected or amended
Confirm orders/development consent and respond to any high court challenges (if any)
Obtain approval to any advance works or advance statutory undertakers diversions
Agree costs of construction with the contractor. If ECI is procurement method, agree
5
final target cost
Construction
Produce the final business case
preparation
For Planning Act 2008 schemes place details of land to be acquired on deposit and
publish a notice to say where these can be inspected
Obtain notice to proceed
Issue notices to treat and enter take possession of land
6 Complete detailed design
Construction,
Construct and commission scheme
commissioning
and handover Hand over asset for operation with as-built drawings and health and safety file
Open scheme to traffic
Agree final account with contractor
7 Contractor completes outstanding works (or re-work)
Closeout Complete a review of project delivery
<< Complete POPE process <<
Contents Acronyms & About this About the project Major road The Major Projects Products and Tips for the consistent & How stages Project assurance Roles & Project handover Annex A - project
abbreviations handbook control framework projects lifecycle product matrices effective application of the PCF are managed & governance responsibilities and closeout control processes
THE PROJECT CONTROL FRAMEWORK HANDBOOK – V 2 – APRIL 2013 11
lifecycle 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
Statutory Construction,
Option Option Preliminary procedures Construction commissioning Closeout
identification selection design and powers preparation and handover
Community Examination
consultation by
and Planning
application inspectorate
Options for for and Road opened
public consultation development decision by
consent* SofS*
Project Preferred route Commitment Close out
initiated announcement to construct
* Nationally significant infrastructure projects only. For projects under the threshold, Highways Act 1980 and Public Inquiry processes will apply.
<< <<
Contents Acronyms & About this About the project Major road The Major Projects Products and Tips for the consistent & How stages Project assurance Roles & Project handover Annex A - project
abbreviations handbook control framework projects lifecycle product matrices effective application of the PCF are managed & governance responsibilities and closeout control processes
THE PROJECT CONTROL FRAMEWORK HANDBOOK – V 2 – APRIL 2013 12
The Variations to the Major Projects lifecycle NB Single option projects must meet the above
criteria and should not be confused with projects
The PCF is designed to be used flexibly and a
Major revised lifecycle commencing in PCF stage 3
that require land take or an environmental
statement but only have one viable option.
Projects preliminary design has been developed for use
on single option projects. A revised product The projects that are therefore most likely to fall
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
Strategy, Statutory Construction,
shaping and Option Option Preliminary procedures Construction commissioning Closeout
prioritisation identification selection design and powers preparation and handover
Figure 5: The revised lifecycle for single option projects (assuming no land take or need an environmental statement)
<< <<
Contents Acronyms & About this About the project Major road The Major Projects Products and Tips for the consistent & How stages Project assurance Roles & Project handover Annex A - project
abbreviations handbook control framework projects lifecycle product matrices effective application of the PCF are managed & governance responsibilities and closeout control processes
THE PROJECT CONTROL FRAMEWORK HANDBOOK – V 2 – APRIL 2013 13
Contents Acronyms & About this About the project Major road The Major Projects Products and Tips for the consistent & How stages Project assurance Roles & Project handover Annex A - project
abbreviations handbook control framework projects lifecycle product matrices effective application of the PCF are managed & governance responsibilities and closeout control processes
THE PROJECT CONTROL FRAMEWORK HANDBOOK – V 2 – APRIL 2013 14
<< <<
Contents Acronyms & About this About the project Major road The Major Projects Products and Tips for the consistent & How stages Project assurance Roles & Project handover Annex A - project
abbreviations handbook control framework projects lifecycle product matrices effective application of the PCF are managed & governance responsibilities and closeout control processes
THE PROJECT CONTROL FRAMEWORK HANDBOOK – V 2 – APRIL 2013 15
product Generally, the person producing the product is free to choose who and how the product is produced
provided it meets the criteria set out in the product definition
Produces the
matrices product
However, if a product has a mandatory process then that process must be followed. Evidence that the
process was followed must be gathered and retained
In most cases the project manager is responsible for ensuring products are produced
Every product has one single point of accountability and therefore one single sign-off
Is accountable
The person signing off the product is accountable for the product being fit for purpose. This means that the
for the product has:
product and
– Been produced in line with the product definition content and quality criteria
signs it off
– Identified consultees have been properly consulted
Consultation must take place as part of product development and evidence of consultation must
be retained
There are two types of consultation:
Must be For technical / operational approval
consulted – The consultee is asked to quality assure certain technical or operational aspects of the product and give
approval. This includes for example, approving appraisal of the road solution by colleagues in the
in the Highways Agency network services directorate. However it also includes approval of other aspects such
production as traffic management plans
of the – The product cannot be signed off as complete unless it has been approved by the identified consultees page 21.
product For comment
– The consultee is asked to review the product and provide any comments
– These comments do not have to necessarily be acted upon. Whether they are taken into account is the
decision of the person accountable for the product but reasons why should be documented
The product is distributed when sign off is complete.
<< <<
Contents Acronyms & About this About the project Major road The Major Projects Products and Tips for the consistent & How stages Project assurance Roles & Project handover Annex A - project
abbreviations handbook control framework projects lifecycle product matrices effective application of the PCF are managed & governance responsibilities and closeout control processes
THE PROJECT CONTROL FRAMEWORK HANDBOOK – V 2 – APRIL 2013 16
product
Produced The product is produced for the first time in the project lifecycle
matrices The product is updated with up to date information but no new analysis, for example, the risk management
Updated
plan is continually updated throughout the project lifecycle
As a project is developed and designed further analysis takes place reflecting the impacts of that design.
Refined Refining a product means adding detail as a result of further improved analysis to a product.
For example, a cost estimate is progressively refined across the project lifecycle.
A review is carried out to confirm whether the product might need to be updated or possibly refined –
although it is generally expected that no action is required and review does not mean re-write.
Reviewed
For example, client scheme requirements generally remain stable throughout a project but it may be
necessary to amend them in the event of any scope changes.
Figure 6 (page 17) shows an extract of the project control framework matrix.
<< <<
Contents Acronyms & About this About the project Major road The Major Projects Products and Tips for the consistent & How stages Project assurance Roles & Project handover Annex A - project
abbreviations handbook control framework projects lifecycle product matrices effective application of the PCF are managed & governance responsibilities and closeout control processes
THE PROJECT CONTROL FRAMEWORK HANDBOOK – V 2 – APRIL 2013 17
product 0
Strategy,
1 2 3 4
Statutory
5 6
Construction,
7
The columns across the top of the product matrix requirement of each specific product at each
show all of the stages of the PCF. Users should individual stage.
read down the page to establish which specific
Some products may be a requirement of one stage
products are required at each individual stage and
only and others may be a requirement of multiple
whether they are to be produced, reviewed, refined
stages depending on their purpose. The product
or updated (page 16).
requirements of each PCF stage are summarised
The rows down the left hand side of the product into product checklists, which are used as part of
matrix show all of the products within the PCF. the planning process and stage gate assessment
Users should read across the page to establish the reviews (page 25).
<< <<
Contents Acronyms & About this About the project Major road The Major Projects Products and Tips for the consistent & How stages Project assurance Roles & Project handover Annex A - project
abbreviations handbook control framework projects lifecycle product matrices effective application of the PCF are managed & governance responsibilities and closeout control processes
THE PROJECT CONTROL FRAMEWORK HANDBOOK – V 2 – APRIL 2013 18
Products Product flexibility teams should review each product and establish for
their own specific project whether it is:
All products in the project control framework are
and mandatory and must be produced. The project a) required
<< <<
Contents Acronyms & About this About the project Major road The Major Projects Products and Tips for the consistent & How stages Project assurance Roles & Project handover Annex A - project
abbreviations handbook control framework projects lifecycle product matrices effective application of the PCF are managed & governance responsibilities and closeout control processes
THE PROJECT CONTROL FRAMEWORK HANDBOOK – V 2 – APRIL 2013 19
and asking for comments on them. • Think carefully about what outcomes products
are designed to deliver, not just when they need
effective The PCF is there to help project managers
manage projects and the products are live
to be produced
• Produce and sign off products during the stage
application documents designed to help projects to progress
and for the range of issues identified in the
wherever possible to avoid a last minute rush in
the run up to the stage gate assessment review
of the PCF documents to be managed. Those people that
embrace the PCF and get the most out of it take • Remember that the PCF did not introduce
a deep interest in what’s in the products, whether anything new – it merely formalised all of the
existing documentation (much of it relating to
they are an acceptable standard and what issues
statutory processes) that was being produced
are being identified which need to be managed.
anyway
They do this with a forward looking sense of what
are the pitfalls and issues ahead which we need to Please don’t
address now? • View the PCF as a hindrance or a box ticking
If the PCF is approached as a paper based exercise
exercise where products are simply ticked off and • Apply it too rigorously or get bogged down in
put on the shelf, it will not be used in the way that is the detail – you will not fail a SGAR for
intended and no value will be added. producing a product in the wrong sized font
If users see themselves as mere post boxes • Focus solely on achieving a successful outcome
sending products to consultees for comments and at SGAR as although this is important, it should
back again to their consultants, they will miss the not be driving the project. Projects plans should
point that the aim of the PCF is to empower project set out how project objectives will be delivered
within the scope in the most cost effective and
teams and aid delivery, not to unnecessarily hinder.
appropriate manner using the PCF products to
assist in the process, not simply when products
will be produced. Successful SGAR outcomes
will then follow as a result
<< <<
Contents Acronyms & About this About the project Major road The Major Projects Products and Tips for the consistent & How stages Project assurance Roles & Project handover Annex A - project
abbreviations handbook control framework projects lifecycle product matrices effective application of the PCF are managed & governance responsibilities and closeout control processes
THE PROJECT CONTROL FRAMEWORK HANDBOOK – V 2 – APRIL 2013 20
Contents Acronyms & About this About the project Major road The Major Projects Products and Tips for the consistent & How stages Project assurance Roles & Project handover Annex A - project
abbreviations handbook control framework projects lifecycle product matrices effective application of the PCF are managed & governance responsibilities and closeout control processes
THE PROJECT CONTROL FRAMEWORK HANDBOOK – V 2 – APRIL 2013 21
Contents Acronyms & About this About the project Major road The Major Projects Products and Tips for the consistent & How stages Project assurance Roles & Project handover Annex A - project
abbreviations handbook control framework projects lifecycle product matrices effective application of the PCF are managed & governance responsibilities and closeout control processes
THE PROJECT CONTROL FRAMEWORK HANDBOOK – V 2 – APRIL 2013 22
Tips for the product is still fit for purpose and does not require
any further updating, time, money and effort should
changes, they are publicised in both regular PCF
newsletters and on the version control log.
consistent not be wasted re-writing it.
Major Projects’ instruction
and The PCF sets out the quality standard for what
needs to be produced but there should be no issue MPI-02-09-2012
effective if products are produced to an even higher
standard if the project warrants it and it is
PCF users are reminded of the contents of
MPI-02-092012 review of the project control
application providing value for money, for example more
time spent on producing the risk register may
framework which actively encourages PCF users to:
of the PCF ultimately result in greater cost savings. The key is • Trim away the fat from their products and avoid
waffle and duplication
to ensure that both the SRO and DfT project
sponsor are content with whatever has been or • Use the client scheme requirements as a central
will be produced. summary document to significantly reduce the
size of some products and avoid having to
It is important not to make SGAR packs too over
repeat the same background over and
complex. SGARs are not the place to present
over again
products as they should all have been signed off
in advance of the meeting and there is no need for • Version control their documents and tell each
them to be expensively bound and laminated. The individual reviewer why their comments are
key SGAR document is the PCF product checklist important and what benefit their views will add to
and this usually consists of a handful of pages only. the product
Paper copies of the product matrix, individual • Use the origins of PCF products to clarify why
product description pages or templates should each product is required and where it originates
not be printed or stored electronically for future from, often legislation or guidance
use as this creates version control issues and risks
obsolete templates being used. The PCF is a live
electronic site that is updated frequently and
users should check back regularly to ensure that
their products match the latest descriptions and
templates. To help users keep track of any
<< <<
Contents Acronyms & About this About the project Major road The Major Projects Products and Tips for the consistent & How stages Project assurance Roles & Project handover Annex A - project
abbreviations handbook control framework projects lifecycle product matrices effective application of the PCF are managed & governance responsibilities and closeout control processes
THE PROJECT CONTROL FRAMEWORK HANDBOOK – V 2 – APRIL 2013 23
stages Identify which products need to be produced during the stage by completing a product checklist
are Plan:
Ensure that the IT system PowerSteering is updated so that the product requirements match the most
recent version of the product matrix
managed before the Identify any products that are not appropriate to the project and record justification for not producing
stage
Produce a plan (in the widest sense) for the production of the products
Agree the plan with the senior responsible owner and the DfT project sponsor
Produce products
Do:
during the Consult on the products
stage
Get product sign-offs
Review delivery of products against plan and account for any variance
<< <<
Contents Acronyms & About this About the project Major road The Major Projects Products and Tips for the consistent & How stages Project assurance Roles & Project handover Annex A - project
abbreviations handbook control framework projects lifecycle product matrices effective application of the PCF are managed & governance responsibilities and closeout control processes
THE PROJECT CONTROL FRAMEWORK HANDBOOK – V 2 – APRIL 2013 24
<< <<
Contents Acronyms & About this About the project Major road The Major Projects Products and Tips for the consistent & How stages Project assurance Roles & Project handover Annex A - project
abbreviations handbook control framework projects lifecycle product matrices effective application of the PCF are managed & governance responsibilities and closeout control processes
THE PROJECT CONTROL FRAMEWORK HANDBOOK – V 2 – APRIL 2013 25
governance been followed Who attends the stage gate assessment review?
• The project is ready to proceed to the next Attendance at the stage gate assessment review
stage, subject to investment authorisation should be as follows:
Senior responsible owner
It is an evidence-based review that is intended
to draw on documentation and activities that the Highways Agency project manager
project team have already produced. DfT project sponsor
All projects must complete a stage gate Highways Agency major projects portfolio office
assessment review: representative
• At the end of every project stage as part of the
Senior users (as appropriate)
managing stage boundaries process (page 54)
Highways Agency project team representatives
• Every 12 months if a project stage is planned to
(as appropriate)
last more than 18 months (see tips for a
successful interim SGAR on page 30) Stage gate assessment review attendance may
only be delegated in exceptional circumstances
• Prior to seeking investment authorisation to
with the agreement of the senior responsible owner
move into the next phase (page 35)
and cannot be undertaken by correspondence.
All stage gate assessment reviews must be
planned at the project outset and must be
included in the project schedule and project
management plan.
<< <<
Contents Acronyms & About this About the project Major road The Major Projects Products and Tips for the consistent & How stages Project assurance Roles & Project handover Annex A - project
abbreviations handbook control framework projects lifecycle product matrices effective application of the PCF are managed & governance responsibilities and closeout control processes
THE PROJECT CONTROL FRAMEWORK HANDBOOK – V 2 – APRIL 2013 26
<< <<
Contents Acronyms & About this About the project Major road The Major Projects Products and Tips for the consistent & How stages Project assurance Roles & Project handover Annex A - project
abbreviations handbook control framework projects lifecycle product matrices effective application of the PCF are managed & governance responsibilities and closeout control processes
THE PROJECT CONTROL FRAMEWORK HANDBOOK – V 2 – APRIL 2013 27
Contents Acronyms & About this About the project Major road The Major Projects Products and Tips for the consistent & How stages Project assurance Roles & Project handover Annex A - project
abbreviations handbook control framework projects lifecycle product matrices effective application of the PCF are managed & governance responsibilities and closeout control processes
THE PROJECT CONTROL FRAMEWORK HANDBOOK – V 2 – APRIL 2013 28
Do not proceed to next stage until required products and Products critical to the successful delivery of the project
Red/ actions have been completed are incomplete
Amber The outcome of further work cannot be predicted or
Then repeat the stage gate assessment review delivery is in doubt
Factors critical to success cannot be resolved or outside
Red Do not proceed – stop
actions require the project to stop at that point
<< <<
Contents Acronyms & About this About the project Major road The Major Projects Products and Tips for the consistent & How stages Project assurance Roles & Project handover Annex A - project
abbreviations handbook control framework projects lifecycle product matrices effective application of the PCF are managed & governance responsibilities and closeout control processes
THE PROJECT CONTROL FRAMEWORK HANDBOOK – V 2 – APRIL 2013 29
<< <<
Contents Acronyms & About this About the project Major road The Major Projects Products and Tips for the consistent & How stages Project assurance Roles & Project handover Annex A - project
abbreviations handbook control framework projects lifecycle product matrices effective application of the PCF are managed & governance responsibilities and closeout control processes
THE PROJECT CONTROL FRAMEWORK HANDBOOK – V 2 – APRIL 2013 30
Project Gateway reviews • Time and cost targets have a realistic basis
A Gateway review is a 'peer review' in which • Lessons are learned
assurance independent project managers from outside the
• The project team are gaining input from
project use their experience and expertise to
and examine the progress and likelihood of successful appropriate stakeholders.
<< <<
Contents Acronyms & About this About the project Major road The Major Projects Products and Tips for the consistent & How stages Project assurance Roles & Project handover Annex A - project
abbreviations handbook control framework projects lifecycle product matrices effective application of the PCF are managed & governance responsibilities and closeout control processes
THE PROJECT CONTROL FRAMEWORK HANDBOOK – V 2 – APRIL 2013 31
<< <<
Contents Acronyms & About this About the project Major road The Major Projects Products and Tips for the consistent & How stages Project assurance Roles & Project handover Annex A - project
abbreviations handbook control framework projects lifecycle product matrices effective application of the PCF are managed & governance responsibilities and closeout control processes
THE PROJECT CONTROL FRAMEWORK HANDBOOK – V 2 – APRIL 2013 32
<< <<
Contents Acronyms & About this About the project Major road The Major Projects Products and Tips for the consistent & How stages Project assurance Roles & Project handover Annex A - project
abbreviations handbook control framework projects lifecycle product matrices effective application of the PCF are managed & governance responsibilities and closeout control processes
THE PROJECT CONTROL FRAMEWORK HANDBOOK – V 2 – APRIL 2013 33
Contents Acronyms & About this About the project Major road The Major Projects Products and Tips for the consistent & How stages Project assurance Roles & Project handover Annex A - project
abbreviations handbook control framework projects lifecycle product matrices effective application of the PCF are managed & governance responsibilities and closeout control processes
THE PROJECT CONTROL FRAMEWORK HANDBOOK – V 2 – APRIL 2013 34
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
Strategy, Statutory Construction,
shaping and Option Option Preliminary procedures Construction commissioning Closeout
prioritisation identification selection design and powers preparation and handover
Stage gate
assessment 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
reviews
Gateway
1 2 3a 3b 4 5a
reviews
Figure 7: Summary of stage gate assessment reviews and Gateway review points
<< <<
Contents Acronyms & About this About the project Major road The Major Projects Products and Tips for the consistent & How stages Project assurance Roles & Project handover Annex A - project
abbreviations handbook control framework projects lifecycle product matrices effective application of the PCF are managed & governance responsibilities and closeout control processes
THE PROJECT CONTROL FRAMEWORK HANDBOOK – V 2 – APRIL 2013 35
<< <<
Contents Acronyms & About this About the project Major road The Major Projects Products and Tips for the consistent & How stages Project assurance Roles & Project handover Annex A - project
abbreviations handbook control framework projects lifecycle product matrices effective application of the PCF are managed & governance responsibilities and closeout control processes
THE PROJECT CONTROL FRAMEWORK HANDBOOK – V 2 – APRIL 2013 36
Project Step 3
For projects expected to cost under £50 million
Responsibilities
The Highways Agency project manager is
assurance (IAF tier three) clearance is provided internally by
the Highways Agency. For projects expected to
responsible for obtaining all Highways Agency
internal clearances. The DfT project sponsor is
and cost over £50 million and under £200 million
(IAF tier two) clearance is provided by the
responsible for obtaining all DfT clearances and
coordinating all ministerial investment submissions.
governance highways investment board.
Step 3a
For projects £200 million or over (IAF tier one)
clearance is provided by DfT’s board investment
and commercial sub-committee and clearance
must also be sought from HM Treasury at entry to
the development phase and construction phase.
Step 4
Seek investment authorisation from the minister.
<< <<
Contents Acronyms & About this About the project Major road The Major Projects Products and Tips for the consistent & How stages Project assurance Roles & Project handover Annex A - project
abbreviations handbook control framework projects lifecycle product matrices effective application of the PCF are managed & governance responsibilities and closeout control processes
THE PROJECT CONTROL FRAMEWORK HANDBOOK – V 2 – APRIL 2013 37
governance
Pre-project Options Development Construction
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
Strategy, Statutory Construction,
shaping and Option Option Preliminary procedures Construction commissioning Closeout
prioritisation identification selection design and powers preparation and handover
Project
investment
control
group
ICF and
Highways
investment Investment Investment Investment
board re-authorisation (if required) re-authorisation (if required) re-authorisation (if required)
BICC and HM Treasury Only for projects over £200 million. Only for projects over £200 million.
Contents Acronyms & About this About the project Major road The Major Projects Products and Tips for the consistent & How stages Project assurance Roles & Project handover Annex A - project
abbreviations handbook control framework projects lifecycle product matrices effective application of the PCF are managed & governance responsibilities and closeout control processes
THE PROJECT CONTROL FRAMEWORK HANDBOOK – V 2 – APRIL 2013 38
Project Investment authorisation of 'suspended' schemes shall seek budget authority based on a fully
evidenced change request as follows:
From time to time it may become necessary to
assurance 'suspend' schemes due to funding, capacity or • If the change request for additional budget is
other constraints. Decisions to 'suspend' less than the available phase contingency
and schemes are made at the sole discretion of the (options or development), the SRO shall sponsor
a submission to the highways programme board
governance Department for Transport and are subject to
ministerial approval. (page 35)
At the point of suspension, a budget to meet any • If the change request for additional budget is
costs associated with the scheme during its greater than the available phase contingency
suspension and a time frame for re-appraisal of the (all phases), the SRO shall sponsor a
scheme will be set. submission to highways investment board
seeking investment re-authorisation by the
Suspended projects will continue to be subject to Secretary of State for an increase in the phase
regular reporting requirements and stage gate budget. The DfT project sponsor shall brief the
assessment reviews. SofS and secure final investment re-authorisation
For suspended schemes which are subsequently as necessary
re-instated, investment reauthorisation will All project investment re-authorisations must follow
be required. the guidelines laid down by the Highways Agency’s
investment control framework and DfT’s investment
Investment re-authorisation appraisal framework.
Investment re-authorisation is triggered whenever
The project sponsor and senior responsible owner
an exception report is produced (page 24).
will decide whether investment re-authorisation
should be sought immediately or deferred until a
When to seek investment reauthorisation
project is ready for a decision on whether it should
In the event of a project forecasting to exceed be allowed to proceed to the next stage.
its approved budget or deviating from the
agreed programme or scope, an investment As a general rule if the scheme is within three
submission paper should be raised to the project months of the planned completion of a project
investment control group. The project manager stage, investment re-authorisation may be deferred.
<< <<
Contents Acronyms & About this About the project Major road The Major Projects Products and Tips for the consistent & How stages Project assurance Roles & Project handover Annex A - project
abbreviations handbook control framework projects lifecycle product matrices effective application of the PCF are managed & governance responsibilities and closeout control processes
THE PROJECT CONTROL FRAMEWORK HANDBOOK – V 2 – APRIL 2013 39
<< <<
Contents Acronyms & About this About the project Major road The Major Projects Products and Tips for the consistent & How stages Project assurance Roles & Project handover Annex A - project
abbreviations handbook control framework projects lifecycle product matrices effective application of the PCF are managed & governance responsibilities and closeout control processes
THE PROJECT CONTROL FRAMEWORK HANDBOOK – V 2 – APRIL 2013 40
Roles There are five key project roles within the project
control framework:
• Being aware of the business objectives of the
project and ensuring that these are satisfied
and • Project manager • Ensuring that the project produces the required
products, to the required standard of quality and
responsibilities • DfT project sponsor
within the specified constraints of time and cost
• Senior responsible owner
• Establishing the project organisation, defining
• Project board roles and responsibilities and deliverables for
• Senior users each team member
The following sections set out the general • Performing project planning, monitoring and
responsibilities and accountabilities for each control on the project
of these roles. In addition, specific roles
associated with products are set out in the product • Establishing the safety ethic within the project
definitions (page 15). team and ensuring that the project complies with
safety regulations
Project manager • Providing a safe working environment for
The project manager is the individual responsible the execution of work directly under their
for managing the development and the delivery of responsibility
a project on behalf of the Highways Agency, under
• Ensuring that statutory processes are followed
remit from the DfT project sponsor and on behalf of
and appropriate consents are obtained
the senior responsible owner.
• Ensuring compliance with the Highways
The project manager leads and manages the
Agency’s standards and processes – including
project team with the authority and responsibility to
the project control framework and investment
run the project on a day-to-day basis.
control framework
The project manager is responsible for:
• Managing and administrating any consultant or
• Managing the project on a day-to-day basis supplier contracts
within the remit provided by the DfT project
sponsor and delegations provided by the senior • Managing project risks, including the
responsible owner development of contingency plans
<< <<
Contents Acronyms & About this About the project Major road The Major Projects Products and Tips for the consistent & How stages Project assurance Roles & Project handover Annex A - project
abbreviations handbook control framework projects lifecycle product matrices effective application of the PCF are managed & governance responsibilities and closeout control processes
THE PROJECT CONTROL FRAMEWORK HANDBOOK – V 2 – APRIL 2013 41
Roles • Initiating corrective action when necessary • Agreeing any changes to the client scheme
requirements document during the course of
• Reporting through agreed reporting lines on
and project progress
the project
• Commissioning the Gateway one review and
responsibilities • Managing project resources, including project
works contractors
liaising with the Highways Agency on the
implementation of the recommendations
• Ensuring that the DfT project sponsor has • Managing, and leading on, DfT’s assessment
relevant up to date information on the project
of the outline and final business cases for
and is involved in major decision making,
the scheme
including stage gate reviews
• Managing, and leading on, provision of
• Leading and directing a multi-discipline project
DfT comments on products for which DfT is
team which may consist of development, design
a consultee
and construction, commercial, planning, testing
and commissioning and support personnel • Receiving progress reports and exception
reports from the project manager and following
DfT project sponsor up as necessary
(This role is under review as at April 2013).
• Attending stage gate assessment reviews and
The DfT project sponsor is responsible for
being entitled to attend progress meetings and
representing DfT interests throughout the project
meetings of the project board. They are
life cycle. The project sponsor owns the transport
responsible for the outcome of the stage gate
problem that is being addressed and ensures that
assessment review for low risk projects during
the project provides an appropriate solution to that
the options phase
problem. There is only one DfT project sponsor for
any project. • Co-ordinating submissions to ministers
seeking investment authorisation and
The DfT project sponsor is responsible for:
re-authorisation throughout the project life cycle
• At the initiation of a project defining the project’s
objectives, scope and requirements, as set out • Assisting the project manager in the resolution of
in the scheme requirements document, problems, issues and change control
consulting as necessary with other potential
• Managing DfT's relationship with external
stakeholders
stakeholders with an interest in particular
<< • Agreeing the phase remit at the start of a phase schemes <<
Contents Acronyms & About this About the project Major road The Major Projects Products and Tips for the consistent & How stages Project assurance Roles & Project handover Annex A - project
abbreviations handbook control framework projects lifecycle product matrices effective application of the PCF are managed & governance responsibilities and closeout control processes
THE PROJECT CONTROL FRAMEWORK HANDBOOK – V 2 – APRIL 2013 42
Contents Acronyms & About this About the project Major road The Major Projects Products and Tips for the consistent & How stages Project assurance Roles & Project handover Annex A - project
abbreviations handbook control framework projects lifecycle product matrices effective application of the PCF are managed & governance responsibilities and closeout control processes
THE PROJECT CONTROL FRAMEWORK HANDBOOK – V 2 – APRIL 2013 43
<< <<
Contents Acronyms & About this About the project Major road The Major Projects Products and Tips for the consistent & How stages Project assurance Roles & Project handover Annex A - project
abbreviations handbook control framework projects lifecycle product matrices effective application of the PCF are managed & governance responsibilities and closeout control processes
THE PROJECT CONTROL FRAMEWORK HANDBOOK – V 2 – APRIL 2013 44
Contents Acronyms & About this About the project Major road The Major Projects Products and Tips for the consistent & How stages Project assurance Roles & Project handover Annex A - project
abbreviations handbook control framework projects lifecycle product matrices effective application of the PCF are managed & governance responsibilities and closeout control processes
THE PROJECT CONTROL FRAMEWORK HANDBOOK – V 2 – APRIL 2013 45
Contents Acronyms & About this About the project Major road The Major Projects Products and Tips for the consistent & How stages Project assurance Roles & Project handover Annex A - project
abbreviations handbook control framework projects lifecycle product matrices effective application of the PCF are managed & governance responsibilities and closeout control processes
THE PROJECT CONTROL FRAMEWORK HANDBOOK – V 2 – APRIL 2013 46
<< <<
Contents Acronyms & About this About the project Major road The Major Projects Products and Tips for the consistent & How stages Project assurance Roles & Project handover Annex A - project
abbreviations handbook control framework projects lifecycle product matrices effective application of the PCF are managed & governance responsibilities and closeout control processes
THE PROJECT CONTROL FRAMEWORK HANDBOOK – V 2 – APRIL 2013 47
<< <<
Contents Acronyms & About this About the project Major road The Major Projects Products and Tips for the consistent & How stages Project assurance Roles & Project handover Annex A - project
abbreviations handbook control framework projects lifecycle product matrices effective application of the PCF are managed & governance responsibilities and closeout control processes
THE PROJECT CONTROL FRAMEWORK HANDBOOK – V 2 – APRIL 2013 48
Project PCF stage 2 PCF stage 3 PCF stage 5 Minus 3 months Scheme completion Plus 3 months Plus 1 Plus 2 years Plus 3
and MP
MP/contractor
1 year Defects
period ends
MP/contractor
landscaping
closeout
contract ongoing
3 to 5 years
Project
closeout
Maintenance and Following project
operational handover and closeout NDD has
Construction and commissioning NDD*
certificate of full responsibility for
completion issued the new asset
*NDD responsible for maintenance
and operation of the new asset
Health and safety Technology Handover schedule *Liaison on: • Gateway • Part 1 claims - • Final account
review 4 SGAR 6 and
file and maintenance commissioning and permit to • As built 2nd notice agreed Stage 4 RSA
prior to as built
and repair plan connect first documentation • Part 1 • Project closeout (+36 months)
opening) documentation • Stage 4 RSA
first produced produced. claims (+12 months) report
strategy • Health and safety • Stage 3 and health and
Maintenance and
statement repair strategy file RSA (prior safety file • 1 year after POPE • Closure checklist
first produced statement refined to opening) • SGAR 7
• PICG stage 5a
Gateway review 5a
Contents Acronyms & About this About the project Major road The Major Projects Products and Tips for the consistent & How stages Project assurance Roles & Project handover Annex A - project
abbreviations handbook control framework projects lifecycle product matrices effective application of the PCF are managed & governance responsibilities and closeout control processes
THE PROJECT CONTROL FRAMEWORK HANDBOOK – V 2 – APRIL 2013 49
Managing
change
Managing
stage
boundaries
Contents Acronyms & About this About the project Major road The Major Projects Products and Tips for the consistent & How stages Project assurance Roles & Project handover Annex A - project
abbreviations handbook control framework projects lifecycle product matrices effective application of the PCF are managed & governance responsibilities and closeout control processes
THE PROJECT CONTROL FRAMEWORK HANDBOOK – V 2 – APRIL 2013 50
processes Ensure that the documentation used to initiate the Seeking authority to proceed
project is complete, consistent and of acceptable Obtain the authorities needed to proceed into the
quality. A checklist for this is provided on page 51. first stage of the lifecycle. The required authorities
are set out in the investment authorisation on
page 35.
<< <<
Contents Acronyms & About this About the project Major road The Major Projects Products and Tips for the consistent & How stages Project assurance Roles & Project handover Annex A - project
abbreviations handbook control framework projects lifecycle product matrices effective application of the PCF are managed & governance responsibilities and closeout control processes
THE PROJECT CONTROL FRAMEWORK HANDBOOK – V 2 – APRIL 2013 51
Annex A Accepting the project brief checklist Preparing for the first stage checklist
Review and confirm the acceptability of the
project following products which make up the project Preparing for the first stage
brief provided by the strategy, shaping and
control prioritisation process.
Register the project with the Major Projects
portfolio office
processes Accepting the project brief Complete a risk potential assessment for the
project and send the resulting score to the
Centre of Excellence
Client scheme requirements
<< <<
Contents Acronyms & About this About the project Major road The Major Projects Products and Tips for the consistent & How stages Project assurance Roles & Project handover Annex A - project
abbreviations handbook control framework projects lifecycle product matrices effective application of the PCF are managed & governance responsibilities and closeout control processes
THE PROJECT CONTROL FRAMEWORK HANDBOOK – V 2 – APRIL 2013 52
project some of these have specific products on the Requirements for controlling a stage
product matrix which are produced as part of the
control
Hold progress meetings and update the schedule
Major Projects lifecycle. at least once a month.
management activities that must be undertaken Monitor costs and manage against the cost plan
at least once a month.
as part of the stage. For example, holding project
progress review meetings. Actively review risks at least once a month.
The project manager must retain evidence that they Ensure that risk mitigations are reflected within the
project management plan (in the widest sense).
have undertaken these activities and this will be
reviewed at the stage gate assessment review at Ensure that the document management process
the end of the stage (page 25). has been followed (below).
Managing documents
Managing
The approach to managing documentation needs
documents
to support the basic principles of project control
Managing framework. For example, that all evidence of
Planning
contracts product production and sign off is retained.
Producing Project managers have overall responsibility for
products
the management of documentation. They must
Assessing
and Managing ensure that:
reporting risk • Once a product is signed off and therefore
progress
completed that the product is ‘frozen’. This
Managing
costs means that no further changes can be made to
that product. Signed off products must be frozen
before a stage gate assessment review.
Figure 12: Controlling a stage
<< <<
Contents Acronyms & About this About the project Major road The Major Projects Products and Tips for the consistent & How stages Project assurance Roles & Project handover Annex A - project
abbreviations handbook control framework projects lifecycle product matrices effective application of the PCF are managed & governance responsibilities and closeout control processes
THE PROJECT CONTROL FRAMEWORK HANDBOOK – V 2 – APRIL 2013 53
<< <<
Contents Acronyms & About this About the project Major road The Major Projects Products and Tips for the consistent & How stages Project assurance Roles & Project handover Annex A - project
abbreviations handbook control framework projects lifecycle product matrices effective application of the PCF are managed & governance responsibilities and closeout control processes
THE PROJECT CONTROL FRAMEWORK HANDBOOK – V 2 – APRIL 2013 54
Preparing
for stage
end
Stage gate Seeking Gateway
assessment authority review
review to proceed
Preparing
for the
next stage Next stage
<< <<
Contents Acronyms & About this About the project Major road The Major Projects Products and Tips for the consistent & How stages Project assurance Roles & Project handover Annex A - project
abbreviations handbook control framework projects lifecycle product matrices effective application of the PCF are managed & governance responsibilities and closeout control processes
THE PROJECT CONTROL FRAMEWORK HANDBOOK – V 2 – APRIL 2013 55
Annex A Preparing for stage end checklist Preparing for the next stage checklist
project Preparing for stage end Preparing for the next stage
processes
of Excellence Centre of Excellence
Review the products produced against the Update the risk register, issues register, etc
baselined product checklist for the beginning of
the Stage
Identify which products must be delivered during
the next stage and complete the baseline dates of
Confirm that products are signed-off and the product checklist for that stage
supported by proof of consultation
Update and baseline the project management
Confirm that any variance in the products plan and project schedule for delivering those
produced is understood and can be justified products
Confirm that there is evidence that mandatory Provide copies of the baselined product
processes have been followed checklist, project management plan and project
Confirm that documents are properly stored in schedule to the Major Projects portfolio office
SHARE
Prepare and send out the stage gate assessment
Complete the product checklist for the current review submission pack
stage indicating dates of completion and
providing comment on any products not Hold the stage gate assessment review
yet complete
Produce any necessary investment submissions
Ensure there is evidence that the requirements of
(if needed)
Controlling a stage have been met
Review cost and time against the versions Complete a gateway review (if needed)
baselined at the start of the stage
<< <<
Contents Acronyms & About this About the project Major road The Major Projects Products and Tips for the consistent & How stages Project assurance Roles & Project handover Annex A - project
abbreviations handbook control framework projects lifecycle product matrices effective application of the PCF are managed & governance responsibilities and closeout control processes
THE PROJECT CONTROL FRAMEWORK HANDBOOK – V 2 – APRIL 2013 56
Any change, no matter how big or small must be: Before the change can be approved relevant
key stakeholders must be consulted on the
• Captured and assessed change. For example, if the change requires an
The starting point for any change is to increase in cost then those involved in the
complete a change request form. This form production and sign off for the scheme cost
records the nature of the change and assesses estimate will need to be consulted.
its impact on the project specifically in terms of
time, cost and scope. Changes must not be Any stakeholder with an interest in the project can
accepted unless a full impact assessment raise a change request. It is the project manager’s
(appropriate to the size of the change) has responsibility to ensure that all changes are
been completed. captured, assessed and escalated appropriately.
Assessing the impact must always also include Tolerances
whether the change affects products. This Tolerances for managing change will be set by the
includes whether products will require to be SRO at each stage as part of the management of
updated and the cost and time implications of the stage. These will be reported to the DfT project
doing this. sponsor and the Highways Agency major projects
All changes are also captured on a change log portfolio office to ensure a consistent approach
and every project must have and regularly across projects.
update the change log. The log not only records Anything above the project tolerances will
potential change but summarises its impact trigger an exception report (page 24). Where
(taken from the change request form) and this involves a departure from the original
monitors and tracks the change through to approval the project will also need to seek
implementation (if accepted). investment re-authorisation.
<< <<
Contents Acronyms & About this About the project Major road The Major Projects Products and Tips for the consistent & How stages Project assurance Roles & Project handover Annex A - project
abbreviations handbook control framework projects lifecycle product matrices effective application of the PCF are managed & governance responsibilities and closeout control processes
THE PROJECT CONTROL FRAMEWORK HANDBOOK – V 2 – APRIL 2013 57
Hand over any remaining as built drawings to • It would lower the overall risk profile of the
the operator project to manage it as separate and distinct
sub-projects
Hand over health and safety file to the operator
In such cases, a project may be divided into
Complete a project close out report and send to sub-projects at any stage or phase boundary with
the Major Projects portfolio office the agreement of the project investment control
group / the highways investment board as
Hold post project review
appropriate; although it would usually be sensible
Obtain final stage gate assessment certificate
to aim to split the project into sub-projects at
phase boundaries.
Each sub project is then taken forward
independently. This means that each sub
project has its own project schedule, risk register,
product checklist etc.
<< <<
Contents Acronyms & About this About the project Major road The Major Projects Products and Tips for the consistent & How stages Project assurance Roles & Project handover Annex A - project
abbreviations handbook control framework projects lifecycle product matrices effective application of the PCF are managed & governance responsibilities and closeout control processes
If you need help using this or any other Highways Agency
information, please call 0300 123 5000 and we will assist you.