Reuse of Tyre Steel Fibres As Concrete Reinforcement
Reuse of Tyre Steel Fibres As Concrete Reinforcement
Civil Engineers
Engineering Sustainability 157
September 2004 Issue ES3
Pages 131^138
Paper 13733
Received 04/03/2004
Accepted 20/07/2004
Keywords:
Kypros Pilakoutas Kyriacos Neocleous Houssam Tlemat
concrete technology/recycling of
Professor of Construction Innovation, Marie-Curie Post-Doctoral Research Fellow, Research Scholar, Centre for Cement and
materials/waste management &
Centre for Cement and Concrete, Centre for Cement and Concrete, Concrete, Department of Civil and
disposal
Department of Civil and Structural Department of Civil and Structural Structural Engineering, The University of
Engineering, The University of Sheffield, UK Engineering, The University of Sheffield, UK Sheffield, UK
Engineering Sustainability 157 Issue ES3 Reuse of tyre steel fibres Pilakoutas et al. 131
managed according to regulatory controls, until they are
physically reused.13,15 This naturally increases the cost of tyre
recycling and prohibits the entry of new players into the
industry. It is noted that the European Council has recently
requested the European Commission to consider the revision of
the Waste Framework Directive to clarify the legal distinction
between waste and non-waste.16 This may in due course have a
favourable effect for the waste management of tyres.
The steel extracted after the second stage of shredding and the
resulted in the application of environmental controls on the use final stage of grinding differs in quality. The former contains
of tyres for energy recovery. The main outcome of these large pieces of rubber as well as much of the textile wire in
controls was the short-term reduction in the use of tyres for long lengths. The cord is sometimes undamaged, but much of it
energy recovery.13 The
implementation of the EU
End-of-life Vehicle14 Direc-
tive is expected to increase
further the amount of used
tyres that would have to be
reused or recycled, as this
directive aims at ambitiously
high rates of vehicle recovery
and recycling.
132 Engineering Sustainability 157 Issue ES3 Reuse of tyre steel fibres Pilakoutas et al.
has deteriorated into individual wires. The latter is much finer,
comprising mostly thin individual steel wires, but still contain-
ing around 10% rubber and fluff.
Engineering Sustainability 157 Issue ES3 Reuse of tyre steel fibres Pilakoutas et al. 133
plastics), as long as it is upgraded to high-grade carbon black.22
134 Engineering Sustainability 157 Issue ES3 Reuse of tyre steel fibres Pilakoutas et al.
illustrate the commercial
potential of RSF. The first
product was a precast RSFRC
slab (Fig. 8) used for drainage
cover. The design of the slab
was based on that of a rein-
forced concrete slab of an
existing drainage system.32
This product was chosen
because the design of the
reinforced concrete slab was
fairly complex owing to the
configuration of the drainage
holes. The use of steel fibre
reinforced concrete (SFRC) in
such geometrically complex
elements simplifies their
design and offers savings in
the assembly and placing of
Fig. 7. Flexural behaviour of steel fibre reinforced concrete prisms the reinforcement. The
mechanical behaviour of
three slabs reinforced in dif-
ferent ways (RSFRC contain-
One of the main problems encountered when mixing RSF in ing SRSF, RSFRC containing PRSF, and slurry-infiltrated
fresh concrete is the tendency of the fibres to ball together, concrete reinforced with SRSF) was examined. Central-load
which spoils the concrete. RSF have irregular geometrical bending tests were performed to determine whether the slab
properties, and if they originate from the shredding process, would satisfy the loading conditions adopted for pavements by
they often contain rubber particles on their surface (Fig. 6). BS EN 124.33 The first two types of slabs passed the B125
loading condition (125 kN point load), whereas the slurry-
One of the main objectives of the research was the development infiltrated slab satisfied the C250 condition (250 kN point load).
of appropriate concrete mixes and the optimisation of fibre This demonstrated the commercial potential of suitably
length distribution so as to maximise the amount of fibres in a designed RSFRC slabs in drainage applications such as car
given mix. This involved the examination of the properties of parks, carriageways, and hard shoulders for all types of
concrete at fresh and hardened states. The slump test and the vehicles.
concrete compressive and flexural strengths were evaluated by
using standard tests.6,8 The results showed that the addition of SFRC has high energy-absorption capacity, which makes it
moderate amounts of RSF improved both the concrete’s ideal for high-impact and explosive loading and, hence, a high-
compressive and flexural strength. However, as the amount of impact resistant slab was the second product developed (Fig. 9).
fibres increases further, the compressive strength decreases due The slab was cast with slurry-infiltrated concrete that contained
to an increase in air entrapped in concrete. The research a high volume of SRSF. The slab was successfully tested to
findings suggested that the maximum RSF content (by weight), impact loading, and preliminary analysis indicated that it could
which could be effectively used in concrete, was 6% and 2% for be successfully applied as wall panelling in security-sensitive
the PRSF and SRSF respectively. Standard bending tests on buildings or as a crash barrier in carriageways.
prisms reinforced with PRSF, VSF or ISFs showed that a similar
behaviour is exhibited by all fibres, despite their big differences Another important task undertaken was the development of a
(see Fig. 7).10 general framework for design as well as simple guidelines for
the effective use of RSF in concrete.9 The framework of an
Two RSFRC demonstration products were also developed to existing design guideline, developed by RILEM34 for conven-
Engineering Sustainability 157 Issue ES3 Reuse of tyre steel fibres Pilakoutas et al. 135
tional rebar. It is anticipated that demand for steel fibre
reinforcement would increase, if prices decrease, new concrete
applications are introduced, and practising engineers are more
informed about the benefits of this type of construction.
Fig. 9. Prototype of high-impact resistant slab The reduced cost of reinforcement in concrete will benefit the
manufacturers and customers of such products. In addition,
environmental benefits will come from the reduction of tyre
tional SFRC, was considered. Following an examination of the by-products to landfill and reduction in the need for virgin
relevant literature,35,36 it was confirmed7 that this guideline steel fibres. A good market for used tyres will also reduce the
overestimates the bending resistance of SFRC due to a number problem of fly-tipping of tyres.
of issues not related to the fibre type (such as the test adopted
for the evaluation of flexural strength and the derivation of By-products of used tyres, such as RSF, are not considered15
concrete’s tensile stress block). It was suggested that the RILEM hazardous to human health and, in addition, steel fibres are
guideline could be used for the design of RSFRC, and new tests considered to be safer to handle than rebar because they are
have been proposed to improve the accuracy of predicting the part of the concrete mix, which is pumped into place. However,
bending resistance of SFRC. health and safety risks may exist when physically handling
concrete elements with RSF exposed on the surface. Hence,
guidelines related to these issues need to be developed.
5.2. Economic and other aspects
The current demand for rebars in concrete in the UK37 is about
The geometrical irregularity of RSF can be a potential market
1 million tonnes per year and 12 million tonnes per year in the
barrier and, hence, guidelines may be required for specification
EU.37 The cost for rebar is currently increasing due to the high
and testing prior to commercial use. Currently, the main
worldwide demand for steel (notably China) and it now stands
obstacle to developing RSF as concrete reinforcement is the
at over £350 per tonne. Steel fibres are a niche within the
lack of a simple and cost-effective process for sorting and
reinforcement market and, in the UK, this niche is estimated38
packaging the RSF. In addition, the legal uncertainty regarding
at 10 000 t per annum. As steel fibres are replacing rebars in a
the definition of waste may create problems to manufacturers
range of new applications (including suspended slabs), this
wishing to process RSF.
amount is projected38 to increase to 20 000 t by 2005 (150 000 t
per year in the EU). The UK price of industrially produced steel
6. DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSIONS
fibres (ISF) ranges from £450 to £10 000 per tonne. The value39
The waste management of used tyres is influenced by environ-
of RSF (as scrap material) ranges from £30 to £80 per tonne.
mental legislation and various techno-economic factors. Hence,
However, not all RSF are suitable as scrap feed and much ends
to develop economically viable and environmentally friendly
up in landfills.
end-of-life tyre processing businesses, it is necessary to develop
new markets which will use the by-products of used tyres as
Table 1 shows the amount of steel fibres that could be secondary raw materials.
potentially recovered in both the UK and EU. It is evident that
the potential supply of RSF would exceed the current demand Currently, there is a large variety of applications and products
for steel fibres; however, RSF will be offered to the market at a using rubber and carbon black recycled from tyres, but RSF are
range of prices depending on their properties. It is likely that used as scrap feed in steel manufacturing or end up in landfills.
most RSF will be priced below the market value of conven-
The authors demonstrated
that the use of RSF in con-
Description United Kingdom13: metric tonnes European Union12: metric tonnes crete leads to an increase in
concrete strength, ductility
Tyres Steel fibres Tyres Steel fibres and toughness. It is con-
cluded that the behaviour of
Total arising 481 500 72 225* 2 660 000 399 000* concrete reinforced with these
Material recovery 107 000 16 050* 558 600 83 790*
fibres can be comparable to
* Based on a steel content of 15% by weight. that of concrete reinforced
with industrially produced
Table 1. Potential annual amount of steel fibres recycled from used tyres steel fibres. The fibres could
therefore be used in a range
136 Engineering Sustainability 157 Issue ES3 Reuse of tyre steel fibres Pilakoutas et al.
of applications, such as foundations, impact barriers, drainage Civil and Structural Engineering, The University of
cover slabs and slurry-infiltrated concrete. RSF have the Sheffield, 2004.
potential for offering an environmentally friendly way of 11. DEPARTMENT OF TRADE AND INDUSTRY. Demonstrating Steel
dealing with tyre fibres, and provide a cheaper alternative for Fibres from Waste Tyres as Reinforcement in Concrete. DTI,
concrete reinforcement. Partners in Innovation Contract No. CI 39/3/684, cc2227,
2001. Available on the internet at: www.shef.ac.uk/
To facilitate the use of these fibres in concrete construction, it tyre-recycling.
is necessary to develop an inexpensive process for sorting and 12. EUROPEAN TYRE RECYCLING ASSOCIATION. The Used Tyre
packaging the fibres. Mountain. Available on the internet at: www.etra.eu.com,
2004.
7. ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS 13. USED TYRE WORKING GROUP. Sixth Report of the Used Tyre
The authors wish to acknowledge the Marie-Curie EU Com- Working Group. Available on the internet at:
munity programme ‘Improving Human Research Potential and www.tyredisposal.co.uk, 2004.
the Socio-economic Knowledge Base’ under contract number 14. EUROPEAN COMMISSION. Directive 2000/53/EC of the Eur-
HPMF-CT-2002-01825; the University of Sheffield for funding opean Parliament and of the Council of 18 September 2000
the PhD research; and the UK Government’s Department of on end-of-life vehicles. Official Journal of the European
Trade and Industry for the Partners in Innovation scheme Communities. 2000, L269, 34–42.
‘Demonstrating steel fibres from waste tyres as reinforcement in 15. HYLANDS K. N. and SHULMAN V. Civil Engineering Applica-
concrete’ (contract: CI 39/3/684, cc2227). tions of Tyres. Viridis Report VR5, Transport Research
Laboratory, Crowthorne, 2003.
REFERENCES 16. More Work Needed on European Waste Prevention Targets,
1. EUROPEAN COMMISSION. Council Directive 1999/31/EC of 26 June 2004. Available on the internet at:
April 1999 on the landfill of waste. Official Journal of the www.letsrecycle.com
European Communities, 1999, L182, 1–19. 17. USED TYRE WORKING GROUP. Fifth Annual Report of the Used
2. EUROPEAN COMMISSION. Directive 2000/76/EC of the Euro- Tyre Working Group, 2001. Available on the internet at:
pean Parliament and of the Council of 4 December 2000 on www.tyredisposal.co.uk
incineration of waste. Official Journal of the European 18. AMAT LTD. Advanced Molecular Agitation Technology,
Communities, 2000, L332, 91–111. 2003. Available on the internet at: www.amat-ltd.com
3. WANG Y., WU H. C. and LI V. C. Concrete reinforcement 19. KOHLER R. Cryogenic processing of scrap tyres. Polymer
with recycled fibers. Journal of Materials in Civil Engi- Recycling, 1996, 2, No. 2, 83–88.
neering (ASCE), 2000, 12, No. 4, 314–319. 20. INTEC. RC 400/5—INTEC’S High Technology Plant for the
4. Thin Wire Reinforcement for Concrete. British Patent Production of Ultra Fine Rubber Powders, 2003. Available
Application No. 0130852.7 filed by The University of on the internet at: www.intec-industries.com
Sheffield, 24 December 2001. 21. MORRIS J. W., GLAZER J. and CHAN J. W., Metallurgical
5. TLEMAT H., PILAKOUTAS K. and NEOCLEOUS K. Pull-out determinants of toughness at cryogenic temperature.
behaviour of steel fibres recycled from used tyres. Advances in Cryogenic Engineering, 1990, 36, Part B, 777–
Proceedings of an International Symposium on Celebrating 785.
Concrete: People and Practice, Dundee, 2003, pp. 175–184. 22. WILLIAMS P. T., BOTTRILL R. P., BRINDLE A. J. and CUNLIFFE
6. TLEMAT H., PILAKOUTAS K. and NEOCLEOUS K. Flexural A. M. The potential of pyrolysis for recycling used
toughness of SFRC made with fibres extracted from tyres. tyres. Proceedings of the International Symposium on
Proceedings of an International Symposium on Advances in Recycling and Reuse of Used Tyres, Dundee, 2001, pp. 187–
Waste Management and Recycling, Dundee, 2003, pp. 365– 202.
374. 23. RODRIGUEZ I. M., LASESGOITI M. F., CABRERO M. A., TORRES A.,
7. NEOCLEOUS K., PILAKOUTAS K. and TLEMAT H. Design con- CHOMON M. J. and CABALLERO B. Pyrolysis of scrap tyres.
siderations on the use of steel fibres from waste tyres, as Fuel Processing Technology, 2001, 72, No. 1, 9–22.
reinforcement in concrete. Proceedings of the 1st Inter- 24. KISEr J. V. L. Scrap-tire pyrolysis—the impossible dream?
national Conference on Innovative Materials and Technol- Scrap, 2002, 59, No. 5, 34–41.
ogies for Construction and Restoration—IMTCR04, Lecce, 25. The rubber residence that breaks the mould. Daily
2004, 1, 611–619. Telegraph, 6 May 2003. Available on the internet at:
8. TLEMAT H., PILAKOUTAS K. and NEOCLEOUS K. Demonstrating www.telegraph.co.uk
steel fibres from waste tyres as reinforcement in concrete: 26. COLLINS K. J., JENSEN A. C., MALLINSON J. J., SMITH I. P.,
material characterisation. Proceedings of the 1st Inter- MUDGE S. M. and RUSSELL A. Scrap tyres for marine
national Conference on Innovative Materials and Technol- construction: environmental impact. Proceedings of the
ogies for Construction and Restoration, Lecce, 2004, 1, 172– International Symposium on Recycling and Reuse of Used
185. Tyres, Dundee, 2001, pp. 149–162.
9. EUROPEAN COMMISSION. Waste Fibre Recycling in Concrete; 27. GLENELG SCUBA. Glenelg Tyre Reef. Glenelg Scuba Diving,
Development of Design Guidelines. Programme ‘Improving Australia, 2004. Available on the internet at:
Human Research Potential and the Socio-economic www.glenelgscuba.com.au
Knowledge Base’, Marie Curie Individual Fellowship Con- 28. ENVIROPRODUCTS. Tyre Encapsulation Technology. Enviro-
tract No. HPMF-CT-2002-01825, 2002. products International Ltd, New Zealand, 2003.
10. TLEMAT H. Steel Fibres from Waste Tyres to Concrete; 29. AMIRKHANIAN S. Utilization of tyres in civil engineering
Testing, Modelling and Design. PhD thesis, Department of applications. Proceedings of the International Symposium
Engineering Sustainability 157 Issue ES3 Reuse of tyre steel fibres Pilakoutas et al. 137
on Recycling and Reuse of Waste Materials, Dundee, 2003, Execution and Evaluation of Round Robin Testing. Report
pp. 543–552. of subtasks 2.1 and 2.2, Brite-Euram project BRPR-CT98-
30. PAINE K. A., MORONEY R. C. and DHIR R. K. Performance of 0813: Test and Design Methods for Steel Fibre Reinforced
concrete comprising shredded rubber tyres. Proceedings of Concrete, project funded by the European Community
the International Symposium on Recycling and Reuse of under the Industrial and Materials Technologies Pro-
Waste Materials, Dundee, 2003, pp. 719–729. gramme (Brite-Euram II), 2002.
31. CHARLES LAWRENCE. Recycled Rubber: Applications, 2004. 36. HEMMY O. Recommendations for Finite Element Analysis of
Available on the internet at: www.clgplc.co.uk/rec_rub.asp FRC. Report of Subtask 3.5, Brite-EuRam project BRPR-
32. HODKIN AND JONES LTD. Decathlon—High Performance CT98-0813: Test and Design Methods for Steel Fibre
Drainage Systems, 2003. Available on the internet at: Reinforced Concrete, project funded by the European
www.decathlon-drainage.com Community under the Industrial and Materials Technolo-
33. EUROPEAN COMMITTEE FOR STANDARDISATION. Dully Tops for gies Programme (Brite-Euram II), 2002.
Vehicular and Pedestrian Areas—Design Requirements, 37. EURO-PROJECTS LTD. Section 10: marketing and costs. In The
Type Testing, Marketing, Quality Control. BSI, London, Development of Non-ferrous Reinforcement for Concrete
1994, BS EN 124. Structures. Project funded by DTI/EPSRC Link Structural
34. RILEM TC 162-TDF. Test and design methods for steel fibre Composites programme under contract IL 12/2/120: Euro-
reinforced concrete, sNE design method. Materials and crete—Development of Non-Ferrous Reinforcement for
Structures, 2000, 33, No. 226, 75–81. Concrete Structures, 1997, pp. 91–97.
35. BARR B. and LEE M. K. Interpretation in the Procedure of 38. BRC LTD. Personal communication, 2002.
Calculating RILEM TC-162 Beam Design Parameters; 39. Ferrous Scrap Metal Prices, February 2004. Available on
Definition of Round Robin Test, Preparation of Specimens, the internet at: www.letsrecycle.com
Please email, fax or post your discussion contributions to the secretary by 1 March 2005: email: kathleen.hollow@ice.org.uk;
fax: +44 (0)20 7665 2294; or post to Kathleen Hollow, Journals Department, Institution of Civil Engineers, 1^7 Great George Street,
London SW1P 3AA.
138 Engineering Sustainability 157 Issue ES3 Reuse of tyre steel fibres Pilakoutas et al.