GD&T - Training - Part 1
GD&T - Training - Part 1
Tolerancing
ASME Y14.5-1994 & 2009
Training Plan: Session I
• Basics
• Drawings
• Views
• Dimensioning and Tolerancing:
• Concepts and Dimensioning Rules
• Symbology
• Fundamental Rules and Principles
• Datum System
• Form Controls (Straightness, Flatness, Circularity, Cylindricity)
• Orientation Controls (Perpendicularity, Parallelism, Angularity)
Learning Rules
• Knowledge: • Analysis:
• Memorize • Identify and sort out relevant facts
• Remember • Synthesis:
• Comprehension: • Combine and Develop
• Interpret and assimilate • Evaluation:
• Application: • Judge value of results. Define a
• Use for problem solving meaningful conclusion
• Notes or Specifications
• Monodetail
• Multidetail
• Cast or Forged Part
• Machined Part
• Sheet Stock Part
• Inseparable Assembly
• Layout
Drawing Elements
• Drawing Format
• Title Block
• Revision Block
• Views and View Types
• Notes and Symbols
• Annotations
• Dimensions
• Tables
• Miscellaneous Drawing Elements
Drawing (Sample)
Drawing Format
Title Block
Revision Block
Views
Notes
Miscellaneous Elements
Views and Projection Systems
• First Angle Projection. Used in Europa and other
places following ISO Standards
• Third Angle Projection. Used in Americas
Views and Projection Systems
• Auxiliary Views
• Drawn on projection
planes other than the
principal projection
planes
• May use section lines
View Types: Section Views
• Show internal features of parts
• Use hashing where solids are cut
• Exceptions may be: shafts, fasteners,
rivets, keys, ribs, webs, and spokes
• Types:
• Full
• Half
• Offset
• Broken-Out
• Revolved or Removed
View Types: Others
• Broken Views
• Partial Views
• Detail Views
Dimensioning and Tolerancing
ASME Y14.5-1994/2009
3/24/2021
Foreword
• When applying GD&T the first consideration is to establish a datum
reference frame based on the function of the part in the assembly with
its mating parts. After the datum reference frame is established, the
form of the primary datum feature is controlled, followed by the
orientation and/or location of the secondary and tertiary datum
features. After the datum features are related relative to each other, the
remaining features are controlled for orientation and location relative to
the datum reference framework.
3/24/2021
Foreword: Key Points
• First:
• Establish Datum Reference Frame (e.g. Datums A, B & C)
• Based on Function
• Second:
• Form Controls for Primary Datum
• Later:
• Orientation / Locations for Secondary / Tertiary Datums
• Control remaining features using this hierarchy:
• Size
• Location (Position, Concentricity, Coplanarity)
• Orientation (Perpendicularity, Parallelism, Angularity)
• Form (Straightness, Flatness, Circularity, Cylindricity)
24/03/2021
Dimensioning and Tolerancing
Concepts and Dimensioning Rules
ASME Y14.5-2009, Section 1
3/24/2021
Dimension
3/24/2021
Types of Dimensions
24/03/2021
Application of Dimensions
• Alignment: For uniformity
• Spacing: No less than 10mm from part to dim, and no
less than 6mm between dimensions
• Crossing: Avoid
• Reference Dimensions: Parentheses
• Overall Dimensions: Only if important. If intermediate
define overall, reference
• Diameters and radii: Symbol precede
24/03/2021
Application of Dimensions
24/03/2021
Application of Dimensions (Leaders)
24/03/2021
Application of Dimensions (Holes)
Application of Dimensions (Holes)
Application of Dimensions (Holes)
Dimensioning Rule 1
• Each dimension shall have a tolerance, except:
• Reference
• MAX
• MIN
• Stock
• Threads (Not in Standard Rule)
• Gauges (Not in Standard Rule)
• Tolerances can be applied directly, in a note, or in the drawing format
Dimensioning Rule 2
3/24/2021
General Symbology and Concepts
General Symbology and Concepts
Symbols: Modifiers
• Projected tolerance zone
• Changes the location of the tolerance zone on the
part.
• It projects the tolerance zone so that it exists
above the part.
• It extends beyond a feature by a specified
distance..
Symbols: Modifiers
• Tangent plane
• Denotes that only the tangent plane of the
toleranced surface needs to be within this
tolerance zone.
Symbols: Modifiers
• Diameter symbol
• Used two ways
• Inside a feature control frame as a modifier to
denote the shape of the tolerance zone.
• Outside the feature control frame, to denote the
feature
Symbols: Modifiers
• Radius and controlled radius
• A radius is a straight line extending from the center
of an arc or a circle to its surface.
• A controlled radius is a radius with no flats or
reversals allowed.
• Always used outside the feature control Frame.
Symbols: Modifiers (Radius)
• Contour defined by radius dimension
Symbols: Modifiers
• Reference
• Simply the method of denoting that information is
for reference only.
• The information is not to be used for
manufacturing or inspection.
Symbols: Geometric Characteristics
• Fourteen symbols used in the language of geometric
tolerancing.
• Divided into five categories: form, profile, orientation,
location, and runout.
3/24/2021
Types of Tolerance
• Limit Tolerance
• Plus / Minus Tolerance
• Equal Bilateral
• Unequal Bilateral
• Unilateral
Tolerance Types
Limits
24/03/2021
Tolerance Notes
• All limits are absolute
• Tolerances need to have the same amount of decimals
• Exception: Basic dimensions and Geometric Tolerances can have
different number of decimals
• Coating: Applicability (Before or After) needs to be specified
Dimensioning and Tolerancing
Dimensioning Ambiguity
Coordinate Dimensioning
• Coordinate Dimensioning
• Square or rectangular tolerance
zones
• Fixed-size tolerance zones
• Ambiguous instructions for
inspection
Coordinate vs Geometric Tolerancing
Coordinate Dimensioning
Geometric Dimensioning
Chain Dimensioning
Tolerance Accumulation
•Tolerance Stack Up analysis are based on this
•Direct effect is by Chain Dimensioning
24/03/2021
Chain Dimensioning
X Y
Distances
6 + 10 + 10 = 26
Tolerances
.05 + .05 + .05 + .05 = .20
24/03/2021
Baseline Dimensioning
X Y
Distances
-10 + 36 = 26
Tolerances
.05 + .05 = .10
24/03/2021
Direct Dimensioning
X Y
MAX = 36.05
MIN = 35.95
24/03/2021
Exercise: Calculate
YES NO
13.52001
A
93.9999
B
6.27001
C
40.1999
D
16.80
E
KEY ELEMENTS
Key Elements: Features and Features of Size
(FoS)
• Feature
• Any surface on a part
• Feature of Size
• Cylindrical or Spherical Surface, or set
of two opposed elements or parallel
surfaces.
• Can be used to establish an axis,
median plane, or centerpoint
• Is associated with a size dimension
Features
Feature of Size (FoS)
The specified size limits of mating part features are intended to produce a particular type of fit.
• Clearance fit.
• When the specified size limits of mating part features always result in clearance at assembly.
• Interference fit.
• When specified size limits produce interference at assembly mating part features.
• Transition fit.
• When mating part features do not fit together in their maximum material condition, but do fit at
some points as they approach their material condition.
Fits (Between Material Conditions)
Material Conditions
• Geometric tolerances are often specified to apply at MMC when the function of a FOS is
assembly.
• Geometric tolerances are often specified to apply at LMC to insure a minimum distance
on a part.
? ? ?
?
?
Exercise: Define
? ? ?
? ?
Inspection of Features of Size (FoS)
• When inspecting a FOS controlled by
Rule#1, both its size and form need to be
verified.
Inspection of Features of Size (FoS)
• This rule is referred to as the “Individual Feature of Size Rule”. It is a key concept
in geometric tolerancing.
• Rule #1 is a dimensioning rule used to ensure that features of size will assemble with one
another.
• When rule # 1 applies, the maximum boundary (or envelope) for an external FOS is its MMC.
The minimum envelope for an internal FOS is its MMC.
• To determine if two features of size will assemble, the designer can then compare the MMCs
of the features of size. The Y14.5 definition for rule #1 is shown below:
• Rule #1: where only a tolerance of size is specified, the limits of size of an individual feature
prescribe the extent to which variations in its geometric form, as well as in its size, are
allowed.
• In industry, Rule #1 is often paraphrased as “perfect form at MMC” or the
“envelope rule”.
Rule #1: Concept and Application
Rule #1: Concept and Application
Override of Rule #1
Tolerance?
Boundary Conditions
• Bonus tolerance
• Is an important concept in dimensioning parts.
• Can reduce manufacturing costs significantly.
• Is an additional tolerance for a geometric control.
• Whenever a geometric tolerance is applied to a
FOS, and it contains an MMC or LMC modifier, a
bonus tolerance is permissible.
Bonus Tolerance
• Set of symbols and rules that communicates to the drawing user how
dimensional measurements are to be made.
• Allows the designer to specify in which sequence the part is to contact
the inspection equipment for the measurement of a dimension.
• Allows the designer to specify which part surfaces are to contact the
inspection equipment for the measurement of a dimension.
Datum
• May be:
• A plane
• A maximum material condition boundary (MMC concept)
• A least material condition boundary (LMC concept)
• A virtual condition boundary
• An actual mating envelope
• A mathematically defined contour
Application
• We use Datum Feature Simulators
Datum Feature Simulator
Implied Datum
• Planar Surfaces
• Add a Leader
• Place on Extension Line
• Leader triangle can be filled or clear.
Datum Specification
• Angular Surfaces
• Same as planar
• Angle must be basic, so it needs a
geometric tolerance
Datum Specification
• Cylindrical Features
• Axis of feature
• It means 2 plane intersection
• Needs an extra control
Datum Specification
• Features of Size
• For cylindrical features (holes, shafts) it is the same 2
plane intersection
• For widths, it is a mid plane
• Requires LMC, or MMC. Else, it applies RFS
Datum Referencing
MMC
RFS
MMC
Exercise: Datum Specification
Exercise: Datum Specification
FOS Datums RFS
FOS Datums MMC
FOS Datums LMC
Material Condition and Precedence
FOS Datums
• The leader line from the symbol specifies whether the datum target exists on the
surface shown or on the hidden surface side of the part.
• If the leader line is solid, the datum target exists on the surface shown.
• Leader dashed denotes that the datum exists on the hidden surface.
Application
Application
Application: RFS Centerplane
Application: RFS Axis
Datum Shift
3/24/2021
20-Nov-15
Form Controls
• Straightness
• Defines how much a line element can vary from a straight line.
• Flatness
• Defines how much a surface can vary from its perfect plane.
• Circularity
• Defines how much circular elements can vary from a perfect circle
• Cylindricity
• Defines how much a surface can vary from a perfect cylinder
Form Controls
• Used to define the shape of a feature in relation to
itself
• Therefore, they never use a datum reference.
• Cylindrical surfaces can have three different form
characteristics
• Straightness
• Circularity
• Cylindricity
Form Controls
Flatness
• Is the condition of a surface having
all of its elements in one plane.
• A flatness control is a geometric
tolerance that limits the amount of
flatness error a surface is allowed.
• It consist of two parallel planes
within which all the surface
elements must lie.
Flatness
• This distance between the parallel planes is equal to the flatness control
tolerance value.
• Flatness is measured by comparing a surface to its own true counterpart.
• In the case of flatness, the first plane of the tolerance zone (theoretical
reference plane) is established by contacting the three high points of the
controlled surface.
• The second plane of the tolerance zone is parallel to the first plane and offset
by the flatness tolerance value.
Flatness
• A flatness control is always applied to a planar surface.
Therefore, it can never use a MMC or LMC modifier.
• Flatness cannot override Rule #1.
• Flatness is a separate requirement and verified separately
from the size tolerance and Rule #1 requirements.
• Flatness is a refinement of the size limits
Flatness Definition
Application
• some examples
• For a gasket or seal
• To attach a mating part
• Sliding surfaces
• For better contact with a datum plane
• How do We manufacture it?
• Milling: .003 and above / Facing: .001
and above
• Grinding: .0005 and above / Lapping:
.0005 & below
Inspecting Flatness
Straigthness
Also, this
way
Cylindricity
• Is a condition of a surface of revolution in
which all points of the surface are
equidistant from a common axis.
• Tolerance zone of two coaxial cylinders
within which all points of the surface
must lie.
• The radial distance between the two
coaxial cylinders is equal to the
cylindricity control tolerance value.
• A cylindricity control is a composite
control that limits the circularity,
straightness, and taper of a diameter
simultaneously.
Cylindricity
Cylindricity
• Whenever Rule #1 applies, an automatic indirect
cylindricity control exists for its surface.
• When the diameter is at MMC, its surface must be
perfectly cylindrical.
• As the diameter departs from MMC, a cylindricity
error is permissible.
• The diameter must also be within its size
tolerance.
• The cylindricity control does not override Rule #1.
• The cylindricity control tolerance must be less
than the total size tolerance.
Inspecting Cylindricity
Also, this
way
3/24/2021
ORIENTATION CONTROLS
20-Nov-15
What are Orientation Controls
Orientation Controls
Method 1
Method 2
Concept, Rules and Applications
?
Requirements
20-Nov-15
Concept, Rules and Applications
Method
Concept, Rules and Applications
Angularity
on FOS
needs two
datum
references
20-Nov-15
Concept, Rules and Applications
Unless otherwise
specified, parallelism
is defined by limits of
size.
This is not very
good.
Parallelism to a Surface
Parallelism to a FOS
• Add a control to surface L that limits its perpendicularity relative to datums A & B to within 0.2
• Add a control to surface K that limits its parallelism relative to datum C to within 0.2
• Add a control to surface J that limits its angularity relative to datum D within 0.2
• Add a control to surface F that limits its flatness within 0.1
• Add a control to surface G that limits its perpendicularity relative to datum A within 0.6
• Add a control to surface P that limits its perpendicularity relative to datum C within a 0.2
cylindrical tolerance zone when the diameter is at MMC
• Add a control to surface M that limits its parallelism relative to datum A within 0.2. Use a tangent
plane modifier
• Add a control to surface N that limits its parallelism relative to datum B within 0.4
Session Summary
What did we learn?
Dimensions
Concepts
Datums
Summary
• Feature
• Any surface on a part
• Feature of Size
• Cylindrical or Spherical Surface, or set
of two opposed elements or parallel
surfaces. Can be Internal or External
• Can be used to establish an axis, Shafts
median plane, or centerpoint Keyways
Holes
• Is associated with a size dimension
Contain more than one feature
Summary: Actual Local Size
• Feature counterpart of
the smallest size. It
contacts the surfaces at
the highest points.
Summary: MMC & LMC
• Maximum Material Condition (MMC) • Least Material Condition (LMC)
• Consider that the part is the heaviest. • Consider that the part is the lightest.
• The largest shaft diameter or smallest hole • The smallest shaft diameter or the largest hole
diameter. diameter.
Fits (Between Material Conditions)
• Clearance fit
• Interference fit
• Transition fit
Summary: RFS
• Virtual condition
• Collective effects of MMC or LMC and the geometric tolerance for that material condition.
• Includes effects of the size, orientation, and location for the FOS.
• Inner boundary
• Smallest feature of size minus the stated geometric tolerance
• Includes any additional tolerance, if applicable.
• MMC for an internal feature or LMC for an external feature.
• Outer boundary
• Largest feature of size plus the stated geometric tolerance
• Includes any additional tolerance, if applicable
• LMC for an internal feature or MMC for an external feature
Summary: Bonus Tolerance