Well Control
Well Control
Appendix
2.1 Kicks and Blowouts
A kick is defined as an influx of formation fluid into the wellbore which is controllable at
surface.
a) the wellbore pressure (exerted at the depth of the formation in question) must be less
than the formation pressure
If a kick occurs, the priority is to prevent it from becoming a blowout where fluid flow is
uncontrollable at surface.
• Not keeping the hole full when tripping - When pipe is pulled out of the hole, the mud
level will drop due to the displacement of the pipe. As the mud level drops, so does
the hydrostatic pressure exerted by that mud column. If the displacement volume is
not replaced by mud and the mud level drops to such a level that the hydrostatic
pressure exerted at a particular depth falls below the formation pressure, an influx
may occur. This is the major cause of kicks.
• Lost circulation. If circulation is lost, the mud level will obviously drop, again causing
a decrease in hydrostatic pressure.
• Excessive ROP through gaseous sands - if a large quantity of gas is released into the
drilling fluid, the density of the fluid will be reduced, again causing a decrease in the
hydrostatic pressure.
2.1b Detecting Kicks
• Increased ROP, or drilling break, when drilling into a formation with increased
permeability/porosity - there is therefore the potential of an influx, so drill breaks
should always be flow checked.
• Increase in Mud Flow from the annulus. If the pump rate is constant, the flow out of
the hole should remain constant. An increase could be the result of formation fluid
feeding into the wellbore.
• Increase in Pit Levels. If the flow from the annulus increases, as described above,
more mud is leaving the wellbore than is being pumped into it. The pits lined up to
the hole will therefore show an increase.
• Gas or Water Cut mud causing a reduction in the mudweight. Gas will also obviously
be seen by detectors.
• Incorrect hole fill (ie the volume of mud required to keep the hole full is less than the
calculated volume) during a trip; this will normally be accompanied by excessive
swabbing.
It is very important, for the safety of the well, that these indicators be constantly
monitored and that any unexplained changes be checked by the driller.
If the changes are caused by an influx, or kick, the earlier that it is detected, the easier it
will be to control and resolve the situation.
The Datalog engineer should ensure that he/she updates the SCR pressures in the
QLOG Kick/Kill program every time that they are recorded by the driller.
MAASP
If a kick results in a well having to be shut in, the maximum shut in pressure seen at
surface (ie that won’t fracture the formation at the shoe) must be known.
Therefore, at the time of a LOT or FIT, the MAASP should be calculated and recorded
for incremental mud weights. When the heavier kill mud is circulated, we will then still
know the maximum pressure that can be allowed at surface.
Once a well has been shut in, the following data needs to be recorded:-
There are two types of shut in that can be performed by the driller:-
1) Soft Shut In - where the choke is open before shut in, to minimise the
shock exerted on the formation.
A Leak Off Test is performed by shutting the well in and, with a slow pump rate,
increasing the mud pressure in the annulus until mud is injected into the formation.
This is performed in order to determine the maximum pressure that can be applied to the
formation during the drilling of the next hole section. The zone directly beneath the
casing seat is assumed to be the weakest section of the future hole, since it is the
shallowest depth, therefore Leak Off Tests are usually performed after casing has been set
and a small interval of the next section has been drilled.
Surface
Pressure
Rupture Pressure
Leak Off Pres
Propagation Pressure
Three ‘Pressure Stages’ are evident, and it is the Operators decision as to which one will
be taken as the pressure on which to base calculations:-
1) Leak Off Pressure - when fluid first starts to inject into the formation at the start of
fracture.
2) Rupture Pressure - the maximum pressure the formation can sustain before
irreversible fracture, determined by a sharp drop in the pressure
being applied.
3) If no more pressure is applied at this point, most formations will recover to a certain
degree, and the Propagation Pressure is determined when the pressure becomes stable
again.
The big disadvantage of a LOT is that the formation is actually being fractured and
weakened during the test, and the risk is that it may be permanently weakened or that a
fracture may be opened.
Most operators therefore perform a Formation Integrity Test where the pressure is
increased to a pre-determined level and held for a period of time. This pre-determined
pressure will be gauged from previous well plans and will be determined as to be
sufficient for the largest pressure anticipated during the next hole stage. Since actual Leak
Off (or fracture) will not be achieved, there is a built in safety margin.
The maximum pressure that can be applied to the formation is termed the Fracture
Pressure.
This program will read and record the pressure changes realtime and, at the end of the
test, will calculate the fracture pressure and equivalent mudweight. By default, the casing
pressure sensor will be the one monitored for pressure readings, so you should ensure that
the test is being conducted on the same manifold as your sensor.
Required information:-
Sampling interval, ie how often data will be recorded. Input by the user, typically 5
seconds.
TVD - taken from realtime system hole depth - this may need to be edited for the depth of
the test
Mud Density - taken from the realtime system - this may need to be edited to show the
value determined by the mud engineer and thus the value to be used for calculations.
Pump number to use - the pump output can then be determined from the pump data file.
Volume or Time - the parameter that the pressure will be plotted against. If Mud Pump is
selected above, you can select either volume or time so that the pressure will be plotted
against either the mud volume pumped or time; if Auxiliary is selected, you have to select
time here, since you will not have a stroke indicator.
Once all the data has been entered, press F3 to start. The program will then start
collecting data based on the sample interval selected.
Once the test has finished, press any key to stop the data acquisition.
Press F7 to calculate. The program will determine the maximum pressure recorded, and
from that it will calculate the Fracture Gradient in terms of Equivalent Mud Density.
Beware that the ‘Fracture Pressure’ quoted is the maximum Applied Pressure recorded
during the test, not the actual Fracture Pressure.
MAASP is defined as the maximum pressure that can be exerted on the formation (when
the well is shut in) without risk of fracturing the formation at the weakest zone. This zone
is normally assumed to be the interval directly beneath the last casing shoe although this
is not necessarily true.
MAASP is directly related to the density of the mud in the annulus between the weak
zone and the surface. It will only change as fluid density changes. It is normal practice
therefore, that when a Leak Off test is performed, the MAASP is recorded for that test
and mud density, and for incremental increases in the mud density.
At the LOT, the MAASP is clearly the pressure that is imposed at the surface, during the
test, that leads to the leak off.
After that, MAASP is defined as the difference between the maximum fracture pressure
at the shoe and the mud hydrostatic at the shoe.
Hence:
Metric equation:
A Formation Integrity Test was performed at a shoe depth of 8800 ft (TVD 8502 ft)
The mudweight during the test was 9.6 ppg, and for the purposes of the test, surface
pressure was held at 3000 psi.
At 10000 ft ( TVD 9620 ft ), the mud density has to be raised to 10.2 ppg.
An FIT is performed at 4000m (3850m TVD) with a mudweight of 1100 kg/m3. The
pressure is held at 20000 Kpa.
1150 kg/m3
1200 kg/m3
1250 kg/m3
2.4 Well Control Methods
Concurrent
• Similar to Wait and Weight method, except that the kill circulation is begun
immediately with partially weighted mud.
• The influx is circulated out to surface with the partially weighted mud.
• During the previous circulation, kill mud is continually prepared. The procedure is
repeated with the new incremental mud weight.
• Repeat this procedure until the well is completely killed.
2.5 Well Control Calculations
a) Kill Mudweight
The circulation pressures are used in each well kill method when the kill mud is being
circulated from the surface to the bit.
When the kill mud is being circulated from the surface to the bit, the starting pressure
should be at the ICP and the pressure when the mud is at the bit should be at the FCP.
During this time, the pressure will be reduced in a step down fashion.
With continued circulation of the kill mud, when the mud is returning to surface (ie
bringing the influx to surface), the pressure is maintained at the FCP.
Well Kill Circulation using ICP and FCP
ICP
constant FCP
FCP
f. Gradient of Influx
psi/ft KPa/m
The formation pressure can be directly calculated from the shut in pressures at surface:
The hydrostatic pressure due to the formation fluid is calculated from the influx
gradient and the influx height
ie the density of mud for which the resulting hydrostatic pressure during shut in would
cause the formation at the shoe to fracture.
ppg = applied Leak Off Pressure (psi) + mud hydrostatic at shoe (psi)
TVD of shoe (ft) x 0.052
kg/m3 = applied Leak Off Pressure (KPa) + mud hydrostatic at shoe (KPa)
TVD of shoe (ft) x 0.00981
A kick is taken while drilling a 12 1/4” hole at 7500 feet (MD and TVD).
The present mud weight is 10.2ppg
A leak off test performed with 9ppg mud gave a leak off pressure of 1500psi.
A pit gain of 8 bbls was taken and the shut in pressures are SIDPP 280psi
SICP 330 psi
Kick Tolerance is the maximum formation balance gradient that could be safely
controlled without risk of shoe fracture, should a kick be taken at the present TVD with
the present mud density, and the well shut in.
It therefore represents the maximum formation pressure that could be safely controlled by
shutting the well in without causing fracture. Should a greater formation pressure be
expected, a new casing string would have to be set; the deeper shoe giving a greater
fracture pressure.
The weakest formation is again taken to be at the shoe, therefore the minimum fracture
gradient will be that calculated by the Leak Off test.
Worked Example:
Therefore, the maximum formation pressure at the current TVD and mudweight is equal
to 13.4 ppg EMW.
2.7 Trip or Safety Margin
A Trip Margin is the mud density required in order to provide a specific pressure safety
margin or desired overbalance over a given formation pressure.
Worked example:
This parameter is typically utilised to counter the reduction in mud hydrostatic caused by
swabbing when pulling pipe.
For example, if swab pressures of 100psi were being induced during tripping, the
mudweight required to give a trip margin of 100 psi over the formation pressure could be
calculated in order to prevent the hydrostatic pressure being reduced below the formation
pressure.
Exercise 2d Kick Tolerance and Safety Margin
The current drilled depth is 8000 ft (7920ft TVD) with a mud weight of 10.5ppg.
The last shoe depth is 4500 ft (4460ft TVD). A LOT was performed with 9.5ppg mud,
yielding a surface pressure of 2000 psi.
5. Assuming the formation pressure to be 10.0 ppg EMW, what mud density is required
to provide a safety margin of 300psi ?
The current depth is 3500m (TVD 3200m) and mudweight 1060 kg/m3.
An FIT was performed with mudweight 1050 kg/m3 to a surface pressure of 8000 Kpa.
Speed of Migration
How fast a gas influx is migrating up the well bore can be determined by monitoring how
quickly the pressure rises when the well is shut in.
eg depth 11000 ft
MD 11.1 ppg
pressure increase of 200 psi in 30mins
Gas expansion
Under normal conditions, as the gas rises up the annulus it will expand since the pressure
acting against the gas, ie mud hydrostatic, decreases with depth
:
When the annulus is shut in, the gas can continue to rise, to a point, but it cannot expand.
The increase in CSIP seen when the well is shut in indicates that gas is still feeding in to
the wellbore from the formation. When the total pressure acting on the annulus balances
the formation pressure, the CSIP will stop increasing.
As seen in equation 2.5i, the hydrostatic pressure due to the mud in the annulus is reduced
by the hydrostatic of the influx. The CSIP is therefore a measure of the difference
between the formation pressure and overall hydrostatic pressure (Mud Hyd - Influx Hyd).
When the influx is circulated out, expansion of the gas is prevented since the well is lined
up to the choke line. As the influx rises, a rise in annular pressure will be seen since the
gas cannot expand normally.
To maintain constant hydrostatic pressure as the influx is circulated out, mud will have to
be released from the annulus in order for the gas to expand.
Vmud = ∆P x Acap
mud gradient
where Acap is the annular capacity in the top section of the hole
The volume of mud that has to be released in order to return the pressure to normal
This would allow the gas to expand normally as it moves up the hole.
The extent at which the gas is allowed to expand has to be balanced with the pressure
increase in the event of not allowing expansion. If the shut in pressure was to approach
the MAASP, mud would have to be released from the annulus (ie open choke) to allow
the gas to expand thus reducing the pressure in the annulus.
A rough rule of thumb is that gas volume will double if the pressure is halved.
Worked example:
The increase in volume is therefore very significant. If no expansion was allowed, the
pressure would increase significantly and risk exceeding the MAASP, thereby fracturing
the shoe. Therefore, as a gas kick travels up the annulus, both casing pressure and pit
level (ie increased mud displaced due to gas expansion) must be allowed to increase ie
balancing expansion with pressure increase.
The relation between maximum volume increase and maximum casing pressure:
Worked Example :-
This program takes data both from the realtime system and from user input. Any data
taken from the realtime system can be edited if required.
Page 1 Data
Pump speed and pressure for Slow Circulation Rates. These should be performed
regularly by the driller and the mudlogger should update this program every time they are
performed. The pump output will be calculated automatically from the pump speed and
the output stored in Realtime-Pump Data. Use ‘enter’ to update the calculation.
Pump to use - ie which pump are they going to use to circulate kill mud.
Drillpipe and Annular Capacities - calculated automatically from hole and pipe
profiles.
Trip Margin - enter the required pressure if a certain overbalance on the kill mudweight
is required.
Down Strokes and Lag Strokes - calculated from the current profiles, but will only be
updated if the rig is circulating and the system is
registering pump strokes. Since, when running this
program, the well is likely to be shut in, you may have
to enter the correct strokes.
Depth of Last Casing Shoe - this will be taken from the hole profile but remember that
this will be measured depth. If the well is deviated, the
True Vertical Depth should be entered here.
Formation Fracture Gradient - taken from the last Leak Off or Formation Integrity
Test.
Page 2 Data
Shut in Pressures (drillpipe and casing) - these will be read from the realtime system,
but should be confirmed with the driller
when the pressures have stabilized.
Pit Volume Total - this should be the total of the pits that will be used to make up and
circulate the kill mud. This volume is required to determine how
much barite is required to increase the mudweight.
Total Vertical Depth - taken from the system (hole depth) but it will have to be edited if
the kick does not occur at the bottom of the hole.
Kill Method - 1 for Drillers, 2 for Wait and Weight, 3 for Concurrent
Stroke/MW increment
For the Drillers and Wait and Weight methods, this is the stroke increment for the
pressure step down when the kill mud is being circulated to the bit (as the kill mud goes
from surface to bit, the pressure should be reduced from the Initial to the Final
Circulating Pressure).
For the Concurrent Method, it is the incremental increase in mudweight that should be
entered - the program will then determine how many circulations will be required.
Options
F3 for Table:
For Driller/Wait and Weight methods, this will be a table of strokes vs pressure for the
pressure step down (Initial to Final) as the kill mud is circulated to the bit.
For Concurrent method:- for each circulation required, the final pressure is shown
F8 for Plot: Shows pressure reduction vs strokes for the above step down.
Exercise 2e Well Control
SIDPP (psi)
710
1035 CSIP (psi)
Shoe 10350ft MD
9800ft TVD
Pipe lengths: HWDP 490 ft
DC 750 ft
At 15670ft MD, a pit gain is observed. The pumps are stopped, and a total pit gain of
43bbls is taken before the well is shut in. The shut in pressures are recorded as shown.
7) Calculate the maximum allowable mud weight to avoid fracturing the shoe
13) Calculate the ECD while killing the well at 30 spm. Assume the annulus is
completely
displaced to kill mud.
19) For the present depth (15670ft MD) and the new kill mudweight, calculate the
maximum formation gradient (emw) that can be safely controlled without risk of
fracturing the shoe.
20) Before drilling ahead with this new mudweight, calculate the mudweight required
to produce a trip margin of 500psi.
SIDPP (KPa)
1500
1800 CSIP (KPa)
Shoe 1000m MD
1000m TVD Pipe capacities (m3):
DP 23.82
HWDP 1.13
DC 0.68
The well is being drilled with a current mudweight of 1045 kg/m3 when a 5m3 pit gain is
taken. The well is shut in and pressures recorded as shown above.
1. Calculate the surface to bit strokes
1) 4244 psi
2) 7244 psi
3) 0.852 psi/ft
5) 3000 psi
6) 4509 psi
7) 2735 psi
1. 41545 Kpa
2. 61545 Kpa
4. 20000 Kpa
5. 18111 Kpa
16223 Kpa
14334 KPa
Exercise 2c Well Control
5) 10.92 ppg
6) ICP = 500psi
FCP = 236psi
7) a) 1216
b) 3902
c) 5211
8) 106 feet
9) 0.058 psi/ft
10) gas
Exercise 2d Kick Tolerance and Trip Margin
1. 2000psi
3. 1767 psi
5. 10.73 ppg
7. 7809 KPa
8. 1309 kg/m3
Exercise 2e Well Control
1) 2240
2) 2123
3) 4888
4) 834.3 bbls
5) 266.6 bbls
9) 11.63 ppg
14) 75 mins
71 mins
2 hrs 43 mins
16) 685 ft
18) Gas
1. 1602
2. 7727
3. 4393
4. 20006 KPa
5. 2039 kg/m3
6. 1103 kg/m3
7. 4000 KPa
8. 2639 KPa
9. 9186 KPa
10. 114.7m