Education Loan Repayment and Performances: The Malaysian Graduates Perspectives
Education Loan Repayment and Performances: The Malaysian Graduates Perspectives
net/publication/318900340
CITATION READS
1 2,668
6 authors, including:
Kamisah Ismail
University of Malaya
17 PUBLICATIONS 55 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
All content following this page was uploaded by Edward Sek Khin Wong on 04 August 2017.
provided by the National Higher Education Fund minimize and address loan defaulters. By
Corporation (PTPTN) (Zainal and Ismail, 2012). achieving the understanding of graduates towards
The increase in number of students and the repayment of the loans, it can help PTPTN to
higher learning institutions has resulted in a replenish their funds for future generation.
shortage of scholarships that are available to the PTPTN has coordinated many efforts to achieve
students by the relevant agencies. This has this goal. Among the initiatives taken includes
created a gap solved only by the government engaging with the public / students, as well as
providing education loans to the students. This giving discounts to graduates with consistent
financial aid has become a necessity for students repayment. This also includes the recently
who wish to continue their studies (Abu Bakar et proposed of blacklisting loan defaulters under the
al., 2006). Despite the government efforts to Bank Negara's Central Credit Reference
help students in achieving tertiary education, Information System (CCRIS) (Ghazali, 2013).
many students tend to take it for granted. As the This would require new measures and
numbers of borrowers grow, the repayment from commitments from all relevant parties to
graduates is very much lower than expected. transform and ensure that the National Higher
PTPTN has a number of 11,956 borrowers in 1997 Education Fund Corporation is sustainable for
and the amount of borrowers has been future generations. Therefore, this study will
increasingly year-by-year. The number of identify the factors that influence the repayment
borrowers since that time has become RM 1.69 intention of education loans among graduates in
million (cumulative) as of 31 December 2010, and Malaysia.
the total amount of PTPTN loans is a cumulative This study seeks to answer the following research
RM 37.4 billion. questions:
This has come to no surprise, as PTPTN has been What are the factors influencing intention of
the driver for students to seek higher level of loan re-payment among graduates?
education in Malaysia. Despite the fact, it is Do the graduates’ attitudes and perceptions
actually public financial educational assistance, towards PTPTN loans and the repayment of
this does not mean that students who borrowed PTPTN loans affect the intention to pay?
from the PTPTN will expect a full subsidy from
the government. This would mean that no one has Literature Review
to repay the loan. If this were the case, there is no
Tertiary Education
need for the establishment of PTPTN and a free
The importance of higher or tertiary education
education system would prevail. Borrowers need
institution to the development of the nation and its
to remember that the fund needs replenishment or
well-being is essential to become a high impact
else it will create burdens and consequences in the
nation. Thus, the affordability of tertiary
future.
education to people from all backgrounds is
According to Ismail, Serguieva, and Singh
important to achieve this vision. Many
(2011), Malaysia is one of the countries that have
governments all over the world have faced such
a high loan default rate. Although recent trends
an issue. The level of education debt differs a lot
are showing an increase in repayments, it is still
depending on the type of institution a particular
not enough to sustain the funds required for the
student is attending. According to Zainal and
future. The inadequacy of repayments may result
Ismail (2011), those students who attend private
in stricter rules and regulation by the four
colleges and universities borrowed the most
policymakers and it might cause major changes to
amount of loan with an average of RM 53,750 and
789 Volume 2 Issue 6 June 2017
DOI: 10.18535/afmj/v2i6.05
Page : 788-797
Edward Wong Sek Khin1, Account and Financial Management Journal ISSN: 2456-3374 2017
Impact Factor: 4.614
[T yp e text] [T ype tex
RM 31,324 respectively. These figures are most when he or she has a debt load that is above 8 %.
likely to increase year by year as mentioned by The study also found that students that have a high
Benjamin et al. (2011), a study showed in the educational debt have lower salaries in average
USA tuition fees and other fees have been compared to other students. Therefore, the
increasing much faster than the cost of other amount of default can be a good gauge when
goods over the last decade or so. The predicting the amount of repayment.
combination of rising costs of higher education
and the higher costs of living will make education The Link between Attitudes towards Education
loans a necessity. Such prospects are worrying Loan Repayment.
and most likely the prediction is that this will TRA contains two essential variables, Attitude
continue in the future. and Perception of loan repayment as a burden
towards loan repayment intention. A student’s
Theory of Reasoned Action (TRA) attitude is the individual's positive or negative
TRA is a model for the prediction of behavioral feelings (evaluative affect) about loan repayment.
intention, spanning predictions of attitude and The users’ desirability and salient beliefs will
predictions of behavior. The subsequent construct their feelings towards the loan and
separation of behavioral intention from behavior predicts a user’s intention (Ismail et al., 2011). As
allows for explanation of limiting factors on observed, attitudes have the incentives to repay
attitudinal influence (Ajzen, 1980). Fishbein in loan. These observations suggest the following
1975 and Ajzen developed this model in 1980 that hypothesis
led to the study of attitudes and behaviors. This Hypothesis 1: Attitude towards education loan
research applied the TRA model in order to repayment has a positive relationship with
investigate the process that leads to the decision of intention to repay PTPTN loan.
whether or not to repay a certain loan. The TRA
states that the direct forerunner of the decision is
The link between awareness of PTPTN by the
loan repayment intention. This will later
media towards education loan repayment
translates to actual behavior of repayment of loan Ismail et al. (2011) explained that the students are
depending on the degree of the student’s managing their awareness on the loan issues can
evaluation that perceives it as negative or positive. ensure the efficient use of the money borrowed
during their studying years as well as after
Attitude of Students toward PTPTN Loan graduating. Issues created by the media have a
Repayment and Intention to Pay positive relationship with loan repayment.
According to Ismail et al. (2011), the problems in Therefore, the following hypothesis is developed:
regards to attitude towards loans is seldom
touched and understood. This is mainly due to Hypothesis 2: Awareness of PTPTN issues
research on attitude were more focused in the field created by the media has a positively relationship
of psychology, and not on finance or debt with intention to repay PTPTN loan.
management. Graduates that have debts are
facing difficulties in making repayment of their The link between perceived affordability of
education loans. What becomes a serious issue is repayment after graduating towards education
that they are servicing other debts as well (Zainal loan repayment.
& Ismail, 2012). As mentioned in a previous The third hypothesis accommodates the
study by Price (2004), a student is a loan defaulter incorporation of perceived quality and
affordability of living after graduating. It refers to
790 Volume 2 Issue 6 June 2017
DOI: 10.18535/afmj/v2i6.05
Page : 788-797
Edward Wong Sek Khin1, Account and Financial Management Journal ISSN: 2456-3374 2017
Impact Factor: 4.614
[T yp e text] [T ype tex
the effects of any diminishing in the quality of ‘Perception of Loan Agreement’. The ‘Intention to
living to cope with the affordability of repaying repay PTPTN Loan’ has been identified as the
the loan. In other words, borrowers are more dependent variable. The SPSS was used to
likely to prioritize which of the factors in their analyze the data gathered from the respondents
lives that is more important, i.e., spending or and the standard multiple regression was applied
repayment; this includes mortgages, car loans, and to study the relationships between each other.
other costs incurring life-style decisions.
Hypothesis 3: Perceived affordability of
repayment after graduating has a positively
relationship with intention to repay PTPTN loan.
H1: Attitude towards education loan repayment RQ2: Do the graduates’ attitudes and
has a positive relationship with intention to repay perceptions towards PTPTN loans and the
PTPTN loan. Supported repayment of PTPTN loans affect the intention
H2: Awareness of PTPTN issues created by the to pay?
media has a relationship with intention to repay A Graduate’s attitude and perceptions towards the
PTPTN loan. Not Supported (Not Significant) PTPTN loan does affect the intention to repay.
H3: Perceived affordability of repayment after PTPTN needs to find ways to minimize the
graduating has a relationship with intention to negative perception associated with loan
repay PTPTN loan. Supported repayments. One of the possible ways is through
H4: Perception towards loan agreement has a collaboration with the other organizations or
relationship with intention to repay PTPTN loan institutions of higher learning in Malaysia, as well
Supported. as providing incentives, a more flexible repayment
schedule and taking sterner actions would
This research revealed that four of the determining
certainly deter defaulters and encourage more
factors that concern the attitude towards an
people to repay their loans
education loan repayment and perception of
affordability of loan repayment, will affect the
quality of life after graduation and perception Implications of these Research Findings
The findings from this study have revealed the
towards loan agreement. All of these independent
influencing factors of loan repayment intention. It
variables were supported the effective and
is hoped that the findings could assist the National
efficiency of education loan repayment program.
Higher Education Fund Corporation (PTPTN), to
further understand the borrower’s insights in
RQ1: What are the factors influencing intention
repaying the loans. PTPTN benefits would in
of loan repayment among graduates?
terms of the following:
There were three factors that influenced the
intention of loan repayments among graduates. a) The information would be useful to the
The factors identified are: attitude towards corporation to work together with the institutions
education loan repayment, the perception of of higher learning to carry out seminars, talks and
affordability of a loan repayment affects the other programs to change the mindset of the
quality of life after graduation and the perception students.
towards loan agreements. The perception of b) The policy makers and management of PTPTN
affordability and understanding the loan (Corporation) could the terms and conditions of
agreement was identified as the most crucial the loan agreement so that the students do not feel
factors that influenced a graduate’s intention of the immediate burden of repayments after
loan repayment. Therefore, it is important for graduating.
PTPTN to ensure that when making the loan to
explain to borrowers the terms regarding the loan c) PTPTN would be able to develop a more
agreement. PTPTN must spend more effort either comprehensive strategy to suit the market
to educate or simplify the agreement or both, so expectations and ensuring that the amount of loan
that borrowers understands the loan contract. approved is adequate for borrowers.
PTPTN must also educate students the From the Ministry of Higher Education point of
implications for failing to repay the loans. As for view, the findings from this study could assist in
students, proper financial planning is important to the formulation and implementation of new
ensure that they are not trapped in debt. financial policies and the aid in the direction of
794 Volume 2 Issue 6 June 2017
DOI: 10.18535/afmj/v2i6.05
Page : 788-797
Edward Wong Sek Khin1, Account and Financial Management Journal ISSN: 2456-3374 2017
Impact Factor: 4.614
[T yp e text] [T ype tex
9. Sidin, S.M. and D. Zawawi (2002). The 10. Zainal, N. R. and Ismail, N. (2012), Debt
relationship between organizational Composition of University Graduates and
commitment and job performance Their Attitude towards Education Loan,
amongst executives in Malaysia. Journal of Asian Behavioural Studies,
Proceedings of the Asia Pacific Economics Volume 2, Number 6, July 2012.
and Business Conference, pp: 937-945.