A Qualitative Study of Social Media
A Qualitative Study of Social Media
Introduction
Through the rise of Web 2.0, social media greatly improve society
because people can now gain advantages which they cannot get before its
existence. Users are able to use social media to act and react to what is
happening around them; for instance, giving responses to the tragedy
around them without depending on third persons for media access
(Dijkmans, Kerkhof, & Beukeboom, 2014). Social media users take
advantage by using their smartphone and get the information based on the
news spreads world-wide (Best & Maier, 2007). By using social media,
teenagers and college students are able to entertain themselves as they have
Twitter, Facebook, Instagram, Instant Messaging (LINE, WhatsApp,
KakaoTalk, and We Chat). Some studies had proven that social media
provide the advantages and disadvantages. The most common disadvantage
of the use of social media is cyberbullying in teenage life. Cyberbullying is
commonly viewed as a negative effect of social media. It is one of
technology abuse in communication (Roberto, Eden, Savage, Ramos-
Salazar, & Deiss, 2014). The most common type of cyberbullying is
sending the inappropriate message via instant messaging, blog, or Short
Message Service (SMS) to tease or hurt people (Stuck, 2011). Another
disadvantage of social media is the identity theft or identity fraud which is
defined as a crime in which someone or a group takes ones’ identity or
personal data deceptively. This crime is usually used for an economic
benefit or economic gain (Justice, 2017). Since the identity theft is
A Qualitative Study of Social Media for English Learning
Based on the data regarding the most popular social media used by
the active users, Facebook tops the list. It has more than 6 million active
users per-month. It had 1.94 billion income in March 2017 and 2.01 billion
in June 2017. These days, Facebook reaches 2.3 billion active users as Mark
Zuckerberg announced through his personal account on June 27, 2017. The
second most popular social media is Instagram. It has 1.5 billion users. The
third is YouTube with 800 active users (Kallas, 2018). Kallas (2018) also
mentioned that the users of social media are mostly teenagers.
The teachers and learners who use social media to learn English as
the second or foreign language believe that social media make the lesson
inside and outside the classroom becomes more effective and easier
(Chartrand, 2012). Even though some people find difficulties in learning a
language, using social media to improve ones’ second language is a good
idea (Mubarak, 2016). The students will develop their new grammar,
vocabularies, or even improve their listening and writing skills. They will
read the post-caption and photos on Instagram, the tweets that are posted
on Twitter, the conversation with the native speakers by having chats on
WhatsApp and LINE, or watching the videos delivered in English that are
available on YouTube (Al-rahmi, Othman, & Musa, 2014).
3
4 | Part I Social Media for Learning
observation (Gikas & Grant, 2013;Hyoungkoo Khang & Ye, 2012; Horne
& Murniati, 2016). The writer selected university students as the
participants of her study because the participants of the previous studies
were mostly from high school and primary school students (Mubarak,
2016). The previous studies claimed that social media were helpful to
improve their English especially in communication and language learning
(Tezci, 2011). Another previous studies on social media for language and
business relation selected businessmen and businesswomen as the
participants to figure out how social media help them in some aspects, such
as; marketing, communication, public relations, advertising, and
broadcasting (Khang, Ki, & Ye, 2012).
Literature Review
Perception
Perception is a psychological aspect which humans usually feel. It
happens when humans responding the phenomena around them. According
to Cohen (1966) in Ekalestari, Azmi, & Puri’s study (2018), perception is
defined as someone’s cognitive primary form and contact towards the
tragedies around them. Perception is also known as conceptual process, a
defect in a sensory, and conceptual process.
According to Underwood & Teresi (2002), perception is related to
the people’s experiences of responding something. They see something
happens around them, process an opinion and being a perceiver. It also takes
part in making a conclusion whether ones like or dislike something.
There are four conditions which people can possibly build a perception:
a. An object that makes people feel or perceive something.
b. A relationship which happens between one and another.
c. An available situation surrounds someone who perceives and feels
something and produces a response.
A Qualitative Study of Social Media for English Learning
Social Media
Social media are tool which help communication easier. Now, the
term of social media changes as Web 2.0 which technically has a different
pattern in the online environment based on O’Reilly (2005). To summarize
all those perceptions and the previous studies, Greenhow (2011) states that
social media are able to be used as the second language learning tool
especially in collaborative learning with other students and the teachers.
Since people are easy to make a new social media account, students
who are interested in learning language using Social media are able to create
their own understanding (Gikas & Grant, 2013). However, as cited in Madni
(2014), Social media provides different impacts for the users. Therefore,
those who learn language from Social media will get different perception
and information.
5
6 | Part I Social Media for Learning
Similarly, people tend to talk with their surroundings using social media.
Sometimes, they do not need to talk to each other directly face to face,
they just need to get online on Skype to have video or conference calls
with each other. Ones can also be in touch with social media because of
their various hobbies, like music, sports, or cooking. Therefore, social
media also allow the users to upload and download pictures and videos
aimed at showing other users the current activities that happen around
the people.
3. Social Interaction
As human being, we should socialize with each other. Nowadays, social
media enable people to interact and communicate with those who use
social media. Instead of the mobile phones and websites, Social media
are available every time people need to use them. The various Social
media platform like Facebook, Twitter, Youtube, and Instagram support
people to interact with people surrounding them. A user can add or invite
more friends into their network and share with them by sending
messages.
Users can also meet foreigner on social media with the same interest and
make new friends from all around the world. People can also use this
networking-sites for their daily conversation today. Users believe that by
using social media, communication becomes easy as they freely used and
registered. People can also get feedback easily from other users. They
are also able to see some advice or information regarding some topics
which are updated on social media. Hence, an individual in social media
can be an influencer for other users since people can connect each other
on social media. Social media can also be used as the easiest
communication tools to interact with other.
4. Get Empowered
As mentioned in the previous point, a user can be influencer for other
users. It happens because most people always share their activities, like
holiday, education, and hobbies into social media. If the situation is bad,
the whole network will be influenced by it. Thus, it is very easy to get
affected by other users’ influence in Social media. However, social
media provide the users to be more selective and smart.
7
8 | Part I Social Media for Learning
1. Cyber Bullying
Cyber bullying is defined as bullying using phones, internet, and other
technology tools which happens in the cyber world or digital age (Smith,
2008). Another definition is also stated by Obar & Wilman (2015) that
actually cyberbullying is a direct attack sent to other users by one user.
They who usually do this are students in Senior High or College. It is
carried by the doers which the victim cannot directly defend themselves.
Cyberbullying is also known as an aggressive action and unforgettable
for the victim. It brings more harm than good and affects the mental and
psychological health for those who get bullied (Li, 2005).
2. Identity Fraud
Identity theft which is also known as identity fraud becomes one of the
most famous cybercrimes which happen in the online environment. As
stated by Justice (2017), the viticms of identity fraud are more than the
suspects. Identity fraud is aimed at having ones’ identity such as bank
account, social media personal password, and another account which is
personal. Usually, people do this crime to gain some benefit in economic
field.
By this crime, researchers also concluded that there are many social
networking sites have millions of registered users, for instance, Youtube
and Instagram. On their registered accounts, people usually share their
photographs, videos, and contact with their friends. By that way, identity
fraud happened not only for stealing their account but anything that the
users share. Identitiy fraud happens since the social networking sites
increase higher than the previous years. The more it becomes popular,
the more people get attracted for criminals in the cyber world (Bilge,
Strufe, Balzarotti, & Kirda, 2009).
3. Unproductivity
Social media lead to unproductivity because more than million social
media users tent not do anything while they are getting online. They
become unproductive since they spend their time more than 18 hours
online (O'Keeffe & Clarke, 2011). According to their studies, the users
who called themselves unproductive are usually the teenagers. The users’
parents choose not to warn them doing another activity rather than just
getting online. Hence, social media sometimes leave a bad impression
for the parents whose children cannot be selective and choose the right
time to get online.
A Qualitative Study of Social Media for English Learning
9
10 | Part I Social Media for Learning
Methodology
To address research questions which were what social media that
they usually used the most to learn English and how they used their social
media in their learning process, the writer employed qualitative study whose
purpose was to explore and understand the meaning of individual’s thoughts
about human problems (Miller & L., 2000). Therefore, the writer collected
the qualitative data to get in-depth the information about students’ thoughts
about this study.
Faculty of Language and Arts has 260 active students from batch
2014-2017. Using convenient sampling (Cohen, Manion, & Morrison,
2005), the writer recruited 130 from 260 students to participate in this study
with the level of confidence was 90%. The reason why the writer chose
Faculty of Language and Arts students was because the writer had access to
the participant. The writer knew them well and had already established good
rapport with them. Therefore, the writer was able to obtain good data,
especially qualitative data. Qu & Dumay (2011) stated that qualitative
researchers need to build rapport with their participants so that they could
get rich and in-depth the data. Moreover, the students in Faculty of
Language and Arts are social media users and have gadgets. Hence, they
had a lot of experiences in using social media for learning.
a. Instruments
For qualitative data collection, the writer interviewed five selected
students. Two students were in sophomore year, two students were in
junior year, and a student was in senior year. The interviewees were
social media users and students in Faculty of Language and Arts.
Therefore, they learned English as the foreign language. They also got
online when they had spare time since they were interested in social
media. They also had compatible devices to get online.
b. Research Procedure
For qualitative analysis, the writer recorded and transcribed
to analyze the data. The questions of the interview were used to
elicit information that students might miss from the survey. The
writer then transcribed and coded the interview. Coding is a process
in which a researcher assigns a code to facilitate qualitative data
analysis. A code is a word or a short phrase that are assigned in data
to capture the most salient information or keyword. Coding helps
researchers find conversation patterns in their transcripts in order to
summarize and categorize each student’s responses Saldana (2009).
Based on the interviews with the students, the writer found that all
of the students mostly chose Instagram and Youtube as platforms to learn
11
12 | Part I Social Media for Learning
English because they could find a lot of interesting pictures, sentences, and
videos which were delivered in English. The videos and pictures on
Instagram and Youtube were impressive since the students tended to learn
English audio-visually as stated by Jane, a junior,
Another opinion stated by Kunto when the writer was asking about
Youtube. He said he could find a lot of sentence and words which were
written and uploaded in English on Youtube. The writer asked him why he
usually found them on Youtube rather than on Instagram. Then, Kunto was
able to explain the reason.
A Qualitative Study of Social Media for English Learning
(Instagram has a lot of things to learn but Youtube has the most. It
happens because actually I watch English videos on Youtube.
Therefore, I listened to them (the Youtubers) talking using English
and read the fans’ comments in English. I read the comments and
watch the English videos very often on Youtube, Kunto, interview,
26 July 2018)
(On Instagram we can find a lot of accounts which provide you not
only to learn English. We can talk to another users using English by
leaving comments. We can also express our feeling by writing
caption or tweets. It can also improve our writing skill, Susi Gadis,
interview, 26 July 2018)
13
14 | Part I Social Media for Learning
… Aku dapat vocab baru, aku dapat cara berbahasa yang baru, aku
jadi tahu orang bule itu kalau ngomong gimana. Dari baca status,
caption, atau kata-kata lain. Tapi di sisi lain aku belum dapat
semua nya yang seharusnya aku gunakan untuk sekolah. (Risa
Karen, wawancara, 27 Juli 2018)
On Youtube, they could listen to the various English videos and read
the comments in English. On Instagram, they could read a lot of words and
sentences which were written in English. They also usually expressed their
feeling and current situation using English.
Kunto stated that actually he was curious about some difficult words
updated in social media especially Instagram. That curiosity appeared when
Kunto felt very afraid of making mistakes or errors when he wrote
something in social media. He said that those difficult words which were
found in social media were usually used to express or explain. He also
informed that actually he learned difficult words like verbs or adjectives
which he had never read before. After he got curious about those words, he
decided to find the meaning in the dictionary. The same response was also
stated by Susi Gadis. She reported about the learning process by using social
media.
15
16 | Part I Social Media for Learning
Misalnya nih aku mau upload foto di Instagram, nah aku bingung
kan mau nulis caption apa. Lantas aku cari di Google, tetep ngga
tau arti nya kan. Aku lari ke Google Translate. Setelah aku cari tahu
artinya, aku jadi tahu arti sesungguhnya dan aku belajar secara
otomatis. (Susi Gadis, wawancara, 26 Juli 2018)
Julia Lika also said the same thing about Google. She admitted that
she used to make some mistakes on social media but she always tried to
correct them after she found the right answer on Google.
Iya pernah, pastilah. Orang aku juga kalau salah gitu larinya ke
Google. Langsung tak Google Translate. Kalau aku ngga tahu
A Qualitative Study of Social Media for English Learning
Iya! Karena aku anak sastra Inggris aku jadi merasa terintimidasi.
Tapi it does not mean kalau aku ngga pernah update atau ngomong
pakai bahasa Inggris di social media ya. Kalau aku update, ya aku
bener-bener mikir gitu. Mesti lama banget mikirnya. Kayak sama si
DC, aku pernah nanya ke dia gara-gara aku pengen update pakai
bahasa Inggris di Instagram tapi aku takut salah. (Risa Karen,
wawancara, 27 Juli 2018)
Risa told her story that actually she was afraid of making mistakes
if she wrote or updated her status in English. She even needed her friend to
proofread them before she posted them. In her mind, she thought that she
was an English literature student. Thus, she believed that English
Department students should not do errors while writing or posting sentences
in English.
17
18 | Part I Social Media for Learning
whether he ever did mistakes on Social media or not, he said that he also
did.
(Yes, I did. But it was not that often. Maybe once or twice. It became
right since some people corrected me. If they had not, I would have
made the wrong sentence, Maxime Xavier, interview, 27 Juli 2018).
Susi Gadis was also stated the same thing related to the education
background,
Aku PD nya sih karena itu grammar nya ngga ribet. Tapi kalau
banyak banget kaya ada adjective clause, passive, active, semua
nyambung jadi satu, wah itu aku kadang bingung sendiri. (Julia
Lika, wawancara, 27 Juli 2018)
19
20 | Part I Social Media for Learning
Various language skills that students can learn from social media
In the interview session, the writer found what types of skill students
believed the most useful for them from the social media. They stated that
actually the social media could possibly improve both their receptive and
productive skills in learning process using social media. They also stated
that people who they followed on their social media account could be
beneficial. They believed that if the people whom they followed using
English for photo captions or comments, they would be able to acquire some
words or expressions.
When asked what types of skills students could improve from their
interaction on social media, students reported that they were able to learn
various English skills. However, what they acquired from the social media
did not always help them master advanced language skills such as academic
writing.
of Language and Arts need were actually academic reading materials for
TOEFL Test or another English test in advance. It also happened in Aforo’s
study (2014) about The Impact of social media in Academic Reading opined
that actually social media give impact to students’ English skills
improvement. However, in the conclusion, to improve academic reading
skill, social media did not give a positive impact. It happened because he
found that people could possibly write sentences in grammatically wrong on
social media.
(Reading does not affect too much. This is caused because the
content of the passages that I need is academic reading for TOEFL
Test. Vocabularies which I need are supposed to be higher than the
general vocabularies which I find on Social media. If it is only about
short story or novel, it will be fine. However, for the advance test
like TOEFL, Social media have not affected too much, Kunto,
interview, 25 July 2018)
(For reading, what we need is knowing how fast you read that
passage and how fast you understand the main point. By practicing
using social media, we will get used to it. Once, twice, three times,
21
22 | Part I Social Media for Learning
you will get used to it to practice your reading skill, Risa Karen,
interview, 27 Juli 2018)
Soalnya menurut aku, aku bisa belajar banyak dari orang luar
kayak grammar dan pronunciation. (Maxime Xavier, wawancara,
27 Juli 2016)
However, for Julia Lika, she stated that social media could improve
both listening and speaking. She tend to listen to the live news on Instagram
or Youtube and started to learn by imitating their speaking style. Other than
that, she also said that social media could also improve their writing skill.
Even though students reported that they could improve their skills
in their learning process, they admitted that teachers’ roles were really
important to them. They needed teachers to complete the lessons which they
got on social media and add the lessons which they did not get on Social
media. Since they learned English using Social media not on purpose, they
realized that the materials which they got were not enough.
The same statement was also delivered by Susi Gadis, Risa Karen, Kunto,
and Maxime Xavier. Some of them stated that,
Iya dong. Kalau cuma baca caption di social media doang, kita
ngga tau loh dia anak mana, background bahasa Inggris nya baik
atau engga. Even though dia native speakers atau bule, kan belum
tentu dia berbicara atau menulis dengan benar. Sama kayak kita
orang Indonesia, belum tentu kita ngomong bahasa Indonesia
dengan tatanan bahasa yang baik. Kenapa kita butuh dosen?
Karena kita tahu background mereka adalah orang-orang yang
berpengalaman banyak dalam berbahasa Inggris. Mereka juga
memiliki pengalaman untuk membedakan mana yang benar dan
yang salah. Bukan masalah kewarganegaraannya, aku juga sering
tahu kok kalau bule grammar nya banyak salah, malah bagusan
orang Indonesia yang berbicara. Itu sebabnya kita butuh guru atau
dosen untuk mengajari dan memberi kita feedback. (Susi Gadis,
wawancara, 27 Juli 2018)
23
24 | Part I Social Media for Learning
Discussion
According to the overall data, the writer found that social media
were useful for students to learn English. Based on the result of qualitative
data, the students stated that leaning English using Social media was totally
fun. In addition, they also stated that actually Social media were the most
important tools which they needed to use while learning English outside the
classroom. They stated that social media provided captions, pictures, tweets,
video, and short movies to learn English. However, some of the students
admitted during the interview session that they still needed formal classes
to learn English more as their foreign language. This statement was in line
with Mubarak’s findings (2016), in which he found that it was normal if
students like to learn English as their foreign or second language through
A Qualitative Study of Social Media for English Learning
social media. However, they still needed sessions to learn English in a more
formal manner.
25
26 | Part I Social Media for Learning
Conclusion
The findings of this study also show that students get pleasure in
using social media platforms since they know that social media are
beneficial. They will use those platforms in the future. Additionally, the
most important factors like dictionary, Google Translate, teachers, and
friends play a big role in supporting students when they learn English as a
foreign language.
In sum, the writer created the model of the learning process through
social media in Figure down below:
language that appears in social media timeline, word dictions which they
read in the following’s post, and the videos which they watch on social
media. Even though there were several English skills which are not
improved completely, the students would like to keep on using social media
in academic environments. Therefore, the students have a big opportunity to
become an independent learner using social media. However, to avoid
negative contents which the students should not get in their learning process,
the students as smart users must be selective in using social media as a tool
to learn their foreign language.
Suggestions
27
28 | Part I Social Media for Learning
References
29
30 | Part I Social Media for Learning
O'Keeffe, G. S., & Clarke, K. (2011). Clinical Report the Impact of Social
Media on Children, Adolescents, and Families. American Journal of
the American Academy of Pediatrics, 800-806.
Omar, H. (2015). The Impact of Using Youtube in EFL Classroom on
Enhancing EFL Students' Content Learning. Journal of College
Teaching & Learning, 121-126.
Omar, H., Embi, M. A., & Yunus, M. M. (2012). ESL Learners’ Interaction
in an Online Discussion via Facebook. Asian Social Science
Journal, 67-74.
Qu, S., & Dumay, J. (2011). The Qualitative Research Interview. Qualitative
Research in Accounting and Management, 238-264.
Roberto, A. J., Eden, J., Savage, M. W., Ramos-Salazar, L., & Deiss, D. M.
(2014). Prevalence and Predictors of Cyberbullying Perpetration by
High School Seniors. Communication Quarterly, 97-114.
Saldana, J. (2009). The Coding Manual for Qualitative Research.
Washington DC: SAGE Publications.
Singhai, M. (2007). The Internet and Foreign Language Education: Benefits
and Challenges. The Internet TESL Journal.
Siniscalco, M. T., & Auriat, N. (2005). Quantitative Research Methods in
Educational Planning. Paris: UNESCO.
Smith, P. K. (2008). Cyberbullying: its nature and impact in secondary
pupils. London.
Sorensen, M. M. (2013). Student Attitudes toward Social Media Technology
as an Enhancement to Language Acquisition. Provo: Brigham
Young University .
Stuck, T. L. (2011). Technology and Bullying. Montere Bay: Capstone
Project and Theses.
Taprial, V., & Kanwar, P. (2012). Understanding Social Media. London:
London Business School.
Tezci, E. (2011). Turkish's Primary School Teachers' Perception of School
Culture Regarding ICT Integration. Educational Communication
and Technology, 429-443.
Underwood, L. G., & Teresi, J. A. (2002). The Daily Spiritual Experience
Scale: Development, Theoretical Description, Reliability,
31
32 | Part I Social Media for Learning