Tesla Management Analysis
Tesla Management Analysis
Introduction
Who is Tesla Motors?
Snapshot
History
Leadership
Organizational Structure
Culture
Innovation
Corporate Social Responsibility
Social Role
IT Strategy
Strategic Management Analysis
PESTEL Analysis
Porter Five Forces Analysis
SWOT Analysis
Recommendations
References
Introduction
Greetings!
We are pleased to share our strategic management
analysis of Tesla Motors, an inspiring company with a
bold vision: to “accelerate the world’s transition to Sheryl
Dhruv Manas
sustainable energy” (Tesla, n.d.). (Qianru)
Parekh Thakre
Wang
In this report, we provide an in-depth picture of Tesla’s
operations, followed by a comprehensive analysis of the Tesla’s Corporate Social I am now a big fan of
We got to know a true
landscape Tesla faces at present. We conclude with Responsibility is what I Tesla.
leader.
several strategic recommendations for Tesla. admire.
Tesla Motors, Inc. is an American automaker In April 2015, Tesla also announced its residential
under the leadership of Elon Musk. The company and commercial power solutions—Powerwalls
marked its entry into the automotive market with and Powerpacks (Riley, 2015).
the Roadster sportscar, a completely battery-
As of today, Tesla manufactures the majority of Model X
powered vehicle. The company developed its own
its cars in Fremont, California, with another
power storage technology in the form of
assembly location in the Netherlands to serve the
lithium-ion batteries for the Roadster, and it
European market. In 2014, Tesla announced its
became the first-ever car that can go up to 200
massive plans to build its own Gigafactory in
miles on the strength of a single charge. Tesla
Nevada for the production of car batteries and
launched the Model S luxury sedan in 2012, which
other power solutions. The Gigafactory is under
earned a five star safety rating and went on to
construction with a $5 billion investment jointly
become world’s best selling plugin vehicle by 2015
made by Tesla and Panasonic. Once fully
(Baer, 2014). As of November 2016, 150,000 units
operational, the facility will be able to produce 36
of the Tesla Model S have been sold worldwide,
GWh of clean electricity to charge the batteries
and the mass-market Model 3 is expected in 2018
that will eventually be used in cars, Powerpacks
(Hanley, 2015). Tesla also has a chain of Model 3 (expected 2018)
and Powerwalls (Tesla, n.d.).
Supercharger stations across the United States,
parts of Europe, and Australia, where the cars can
be charged by their owners at no cost; chargers in “We're running the most dangerous experiment in history right now,
the network have the ability to give a 60% battery which is to see how much carbon dioxide the atmosphere can handle
boost in just 20 minutes (Tesla, n.d.). before there is an environmental catastrophe.”
— Elon Musk
Snapshot
Tesla CEO Elon Musk has a clear vision of Elon musk’s leadership traits are a mix
accelerating the world towards sustainable of opinionated and adaptable leaders,
sources of energy. This vision is clearly reflected in putting him in the quadrant of the most
all the work he does, whether at Tesla Motors or successful and continuously innovating
the other companies he leads—like SolarCity leaders like Steve Jobs. While he has
(recently merged with Tesla; Stewart, 2016) and has a strong persona reflecting his
SpaceX. To evolve and contribute towards the opinions, he is adaptable in nature and
mainstream usage of sustainable energy, Musk ready to accept the many failures in the
has been the central force developing process of innovation—which is the
cutting-edge technologies by employing the best most significant trait of
minds in the field. He has heavily invested human transformational leadership. stalwart
capital and money into developing these in-house
technologies, whether it is high-efficiency cars or
establishment of the Tesla Gigafactory. Musk
leads by example: he has created several
companies that showcase success in such a short
time that he is definitely among the top leaders in impartial opinionated
the world. Musk’s creativity and transformational
leadership has played a pivotal role in the success
and progress of Tesla, which is now seen as the
world’s most prominent brand in the automotive
industry.
adaptable
Leadership 2008
Martin Eberhard, founder
Marc Tarpenning, founder
Daryll Siry, chief of marketing
Musk’s communication style has been described as Jones, 2016). Meanwhile, after reports of low 2009
Michael van der Sanda, chief of marketing
authentic, down-to-earth, and exceptionally clear, contractor pay, UAW is attempting to unionize
Michael Donoughe, chief vehicle engineer
with four times more use of the present tense than production workers (Bloomberg View, 2016). 2010
average (Goldberger, n.d.; Crabtree, 2016; 2011
Tensions have also come to the surface in 2012
Schwartz, 2016). These traits help him rally people
Tesla’s supply chain. As a newcomer to the Ricardo Reyes, VP global communications
behind a very bold vision and motivate them to 2013
intricacies of automotive manufacturing, Tesla
pursue it. His aggressive focus, though, can make 2014
depends on suppliers to build its cars. In fact, Simon Sproule, head of comms. department left
him conflict- prone, blind to his employees’ hard
Tesla and would never have come into 2015
work, and defensive against complaints instead of
existence at as a company without Eberhard, 2016
learning from them (Vance, 2015; Newcomb, 2016). Michael Zanoni, VP finance
Tarpenning, and Musk’s diplomatic in-person
One apparent consequence of Musk’s style is efforts to persuade potential suppliers (Baer, James Chen, VP regulatory affairs
perpetual senior leadership turnover (Morrisson, Josh Ensign, VP manufacturing
2014). Recently, some suppliers have struggled Greg Reichow, VP production
2008; Volecker, 2009; Shall, 2016; Lambert, 2016; to meet Musk’s purposefully optimistic
Korosec, 2016, “Model 3 event”; Korosec, 2016, production targets, and the company Mobileye
“Tesla loses”; see sidebar). Such turnover is costly ended its relationship with Tesla by publicly TESLA’S SENIOR
(Lucas, 2013) for reasons including training costs, citing its concerns that Tesla’s deadlines posed
lost knowledge, and potential negative morale. a safety risk (Rosevear, 2016).
LEADERSHIP EXODUS
As another consequence, employee reviews are
frank about the long hours and poor work-life “Even by the turbulent standards of Silicon Valley's venture-funded
balance—though they overwhelmingly state that
startups, Telsa [has] garnered more than its share of attention for
the company’s mission makes the personal sacrifice
worthwhile (Glassdoor.com, n.d.; Indeed.com, n.d.; missteps, multiple CEOs, layoffs, and lawsuits … ”
(Voelcker, 2009)
Organizational Structure
Tesla Motors can be characterized as a company It has enabled Tesla to completely reuse its
that takes a proactive approach (Jones and recycled battery packs, only 10% of which could
George, 2016) its social responsibilities. Tesla is at be used before instituting the program; it has
the forefront of several pressing social causes. reduced the amount of batteries that go to
Thus far its short life as a company can be divided landfill; and, by using a new recycling technology
into two stages: environmental protection, and provided by Umicore, it has reduced at least 70%
energy conservation. of the normal CO2 emissions from the refining
process.
From 2003 to 2015, Tesla included the
responsibility of environmental protection in its In 2015, as Tesla realized the importance of
organizational strategies. In addition to lessening energy conservation to protecting the
the dependence of transportation on petroleum environment, it stepped into a second stage and
and manufacturing its own electric vehicles with directed its strategies toward new energy
zero emissions, Tesla also instituted a closed loop development. Tesla chose not to limit its vision in
for battery recycling to make its production applying new energy in auto market; rather, it Tesla’s closed loop battery
process more environmentally friendly (Kelty, plans to create a suite of integrated products that recycling process (Kelty, 2011).
2011). This recycling loop takes used lead-acid provide clean energy to residential, commercial,
batteries, separates them into coin-sized and industrial markets.
component parts, then sorts, re-processes and
finally reuses the purified lead in battery “If something is important enough, even if the
manufacturing. The recycling program has
valuable outcomes in terms of environmental odds are against you, you should still do it.”
protection. — Elon Musk
Corporate Social Responsibility
Tesla’s energy conservation stage started by bringing An important lesson we learn from Tesla is
solar power into people’s daily life with the how it perfectly combines organizational
Powerwall, a rechargeable lithium-ion battery development and implementation of social
product that stores and provides electricity to homes responsibilities. When focusing on electric
and small businesses (Riley, 2015). With the vehicles manufacturing, Tesla combines the
Powerwall, people could sustainably use solar power: responsibility for decreasing environmental
they store the surplus electricity produced by the pollution with its strategy of expanding market
solar panel system during a sunny day, and use it at share in the automotive industry. It aims at
night or in a rainy day when there is not enough developing cars with more outstanding
electricity generated. After that, Tesla unveiled performances than gasoline cars, in order to
another energy product—the Solar Roof—that works encourage customers to purchase great cars
directly with the Powerwall to collect solar power that happen to be electric. In this way, its
and convert it to electricity. Moreover, in order to market share increases and emissions from SolarCity
(2016)
deepen its expertise in the energy field, Tesla gasoline cars are reduced simultaneously.
Solar Roof
purchased SolarCity in November (Stewart, 2016) And, after entering the energy industry, Tesla (2016)
and consequently strengthened its capability to has developed an integrative product chain PowerWall
(2015)
integrate electric vehicles, Powerwall, and Solar that could greatly increase its profit margins
Roofing in an end-to-end energy plan. It has while, at the same time, providing society with
proposed very specific details in the plan, including a conveniently packaged way to utilize solar
embedding the solar panel system in walls by taking power.
advantage of Tesla’s manufacturing strength. When
Tesla’s idea is realized, humans will move a major
step forward towards independence from fossil fuel.
Social Role
Tesla is an excellent example of the potential for a technological innovation in charging and energy Musk attributed the low market share of
company to have a major impact on society by storage. According to FreshPatents (n.d.), Tesla electric vehicles to closed patents that hold
tackling ambitious problems. has applied for over 200 patents between 2010 back and limit innovation (Masnick, 2015).
and 2016, almost all of which depends on the Therefore, Tesla hopes to move barriers
As a pioneer in the automotive industry, Tesla is
efforts of its R&D teams. Tesla’s innovation is that lie in front of startup peers who have
very strictly focused on innovation to the extent
recognized by the public, as well as being named been struggling to innovate technology and
that it ignores short-term losses and often misses
the number one Innovative Company by Forbes in establish a quickly-evolving platform of
product launch deadlines. It has even worked to
2015 and 2016. technologies in order to encourage and
improve seemingly less needed technologies—for
compel industrial development. Tesla also
instance, autonomous falcon wing doors—to In addition to promote innovation inside the
hopes to promote the involvement of more
appeal to customer desires for convenience and organization, Tesla also contributes to innovation
traditional automotive manufacturers in the
breathtakingly well-designed products. CEO Elon in the entire industry. In 2014, Tesla announced
electric vehicle market.
Musk is often criticized for decreasing the profit that it would make its patents ‘open source’ by
margin by spending an overwhelming amount of sharing them with its peers and promising not to
costs on R&D (AmigoBulls, n.d.). According to the initiate patent lawsuit against anyone who wants
newest statistic, Tesla’s expenses on R&D has to use their technology (Musk, 2014). Musk
surpassed 200 million dollars in the third quarter recognized that there is only a tiny proportion of
of 2016, which represents 10% of its quarterly electric vehicles in the automotive market, while
revenue and one third of its gross profit the enormous amount of gasoline cars
“Tesla is not just an automaker,
(AmigoBulls, n.d.). Nevertheless, with its heavy flooding into the market year after year
investment, Tesla has acquired unparalleled has become the largest barrier to but also a technology and design company
strengths in both quantity and quality of developing transport independent from with a focus on energy innovation.”
fossil fuels and reducing carbon emissions. — “About Tesla” (n.d.)
A LOOK AT TESLA’S
IT Strategy
INFORMATION
Not only does Tesla bring a software development When it comes to IT, the core principles that drive
SYSTEMS
mindset to the car industry, but there are also Tesla’s strategy as told by the ex-CIO, Jay Vijayan Requirements
strong arguments to be made for calling Tesla (High, 2014) are: Management
itself an Information Technology (IT) company System (RMS)
(High, 2014). First, information systems (IS) are Speed and Agility
Information Flow across
Enterprise
routinely used in many core areas (see sidebar): Departments
Resource
Requirement Management Systems (RMS) and Closed Feedback Loop Seamless Vertical Planning (ERP)
with Customers Integration
Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP) Systems are Asset
used for planning and controlling functions. Management
Just like most automakers, Tesla relies on vendor
Asset Management & Facility Management System
software like FlexNet, Enovia, and Catia for
Systems are used to efficiently run factories and modeling and manufacturing cars. However, when Facility
manufacture the cars. vendors couldn’t provide an ERP solution to Management
integrate their store, manufacturing and retail System
Tesla retails its products through an online store
operations, a team of 25 engineers led by Jay Geographical
supported by an E-commerce System. Information
Vijayan built the system from scratch within four
Tesla’s products themselves have embedded IT. months. This impressive example of a build versus System (GIS)
Geographical Information Systems (GIS) and buy approach to IT is indicative of Tesla’s Product Data
Product Data Management Systems (PDMS) are flexibility, capability and commitment towards Management
used to enrich the customer experience and goals. (PDMS)
create a feedback loop, and PDMS enables
E-commerce
over-the-air updates to the cars’ software.
System
Strategic Management Analysis:
A review of Tesla’s challenges and opportunities
PESTEL Analysis
POLITICAL Tesla has an opportunity to strengthen SOCIAL Tesla has growth opportunities based on
its financial performance through incentives from the rising popularity of low-carbon lifestyles and
governments. Expanding free trade agreements increasing preference for renewable energy
open opportunities for Tesla to grow its (Kissinger, 2016). Moreover, Tesla has great
operations internationally. Tesla is expected to potential to boost its financial performance
increase their sales in environmentally friendly because of higher customer purchasing power in
countries like Norway, as these countries’ developing and developed countries.
governments provide more incentives to
TECHNOLOGICAL The high rate of technological
encourage Tesla to sell more cars there.
change presents opportunity for Tesla to enhance
ECONOMIC Tesla’s business performance its products’ technologies accordingly (Kissinger,
benefits from lower battery costs (Kissinger, 2016). However, the increasing popularity of
2016). The affordability of the company’s electric online B2B platforms and marketplaces have also LEGAL Tesla has opportunities to safely
automobile products will decrease manufacturing given increased opportunities to the car industry grow its business overseas, considering
costs and increase profitability. In relation, the that, in turn, have increased efficiencies and expansions in international patent law;
decreasing renewable energy costs make Tesla’s reduced costs. free trade protocols also help Tesla to
products more attractive, considering that their emerge in international markets.
ENVIRONMENTAL As awareness and support for However, dealership regulations are
business improves as renewable energy solutions
environmentalism increased, the company has causing problems as Tesla expands the
become more popular.
opportunities to promote its electric vehicles domestic market (Kissinger, 2016).
based on concerns on climate change, energy
saving programs, and rising standards for waste
disposal (Kissinger, 2016).
Porter Five Forces Analysis NEW
ENTRANTS
(weak
factor)
Tesla’s SUPPLIERS have a low level of forward
integration. This external factor refers to suppliers’
SUPPLIERS
limited control in the distribution and sale of their
(moderate
products. For example, some suppliers use third parties factor) Tesla already has a strong brand that NEW
to sell their materials to Tesla (Kissinger, 2016). In
ENTRANTS find difficult to match. In addition,
addition, most of these suppliers are moderately sized,
automobile manufacturing has high costs, which
thereby having limited influence on the automotive
impose a barrier to new firms.
industry environment.
SUBSTITUTE
The moderate availability of SUBSTITUTES S There are only a small number of significant
limits the influence of suppliers. In relation, (moderate COMPETITORS operating in the automotive market.
many substitutes have only a moderate level of factor) However, these firms are generally aggressive in
performance in satisfying customers’ practical innovating and promoting their products (Kissinger,
needs, thereby further limiting the threat of this 2016). Such conditions strengthen the effects of
factor against Tesla. competitors against Tesla.
Baer, D. (2014, November 11). The making Of Tesla: Invention, betrayal, and the birth of the Roadster. Business Insider. Retrieved from
http://www.businessinsider.com/
tesla-the-origin-story-2014-10
Bloomberg View. (2016, May 26). Worker discontent makes Tesla a union target. Retrieved from http://www.industryweek.com/labor-employment-policy/worker-
discontent-makes-tesla-union-target
Crabtree, J. (2016, August 2). Elon Musk’s vision is a masterclass in communication. Financial Times. Retrieved from https://www.ft.com/content/b5aebe64-5888
-11e6-9f70-badea1b336d4
Forbes. (n.d.). The world’s most innovative companies list. Forbes. Retrieved from http://www.forbes.com/innovative-companies/list/
FreshPatents. (n.d.). Tesla Motors Inc patents list. Retrieved from http://stks.freshpatents.com/Tesla-Motors-Inc-nm1.php
George, J. (2016, February 7). TESLA Motors - External analysis using PESTLE & Porter's 5 analysis. SpherePress. Retrieved from
http://spherepress.com/tesla-motors- external-analysis-using-pestle-porters-5-analysis/
Goldberger, C. (n.d.). Are Elon Musk's public speaking skills as visionary as his cars? Quantified Communications Blog. Retrieved from http://www.quantified
communications.com/blog/elon-musk-communication-analysis
Hanley, S. (2015). Pedal to the metal on Tesla Model 3 - Gas 2. Retrieved rom http://gas2.org/2015/10/19/pedal-to-the-metal-on-tesla-model-3/
High, P. (2014, November 5). Tesla CIO builds IT that keeps pace with its cars. CIO Insight. Retrieved from http://www.cioinsight.com/it-management/tesla-
cio-builds-it-that-keeps-pace-with-its-cars.html
Hitt, M. A., Haynes, K. T., & Serpa, R. (2010). Strategic leadership for the 21st century. Business Horizons, 53, 437-444.
Jones, G. R. & George, J. M. (2016). Contemporary management (9th ed.). New York City, NY: McGraw Hill Education.
Jones, M. (2016, February 10). Former Tesla Motors Inc. employee sparks Reddit debate about work. Retrieved from http://www.valuewalk.com/2016/02/
former-tesla-employee-reddit/
Kelly, A. (n.d.). Here is what Donald Trump wants to do in his first 100 Days. Retrieved from http://www.npr.org/2016/11/09/501451368/here-is-what-donald-
trump-wants-to-do-in-his-first-100-days
Kelty, K. (2011, January 26). Tesla’s closed loop battery recycling program. Retrieved from https://www.tesla.com/blog/teslas-closed-loop-battery-recycling-program
Kissinger, D. (2016). Tesla Motors, Inc. PESTEL/PESTLE analysis & recommendations. Panmore Institute. Retrieved from http://panmore.com/tesla-motors-inc-pestel-
pestle-analysis-recommendations
Kissinger, D. (2016). Tesla Motors, Inc.'s five forces analysis & recommendations (Porter's model). Panmore Institute. Retrieved from http://panmore.com/tesla-
motors-inc-five-forces-analysis-recommendations-porters-model
Kissinger, D. (2016). Tesla Motors, Inc. SWOT analysis & recommendations. Panmore Institute. Retrieved from http://panmore.com/tesla-motors-inc-swot-analysis-
recommendations
Korosec, K. (2016, March 16). Tesla's Model 3 event will have driveable prototypes. Fortune. Retrieved from http://fortune.com/2016/03/16/teslas-model-
driveable-prototype/
Korosec, K. (2016, May 4). Tesla loses two more top executives. Fortune. Retrieved from http://fortune.com/2016/05/04/tesla-production-chiefs/
Kumparak, G., Burns, M., & Escher, A. (n.d.). A brief history of Tesla. Retrieved from https://techcrunch.com/gallery/a-brief-history-of-tesla/slide/24/
Lambert, F. (2016, April 13). Tesla loses another executive as its VP of Regulatory Affairs leaves [Updated]. ElectricTrek. Retrieved from https://electrek.co/2016/
04/13/tesla-executive-vp-regulatory-affairs/
Lucas, S. (2013, August 30). How much employee turnover really costs you. Inc. Retrieved from http://www.inc.com/suzanne-lucas/why-employee-turnover-is
-so-costly.html
Masnick, M. (2015, February 18). Elon Musk clarifies that Tesla's patents really are free; Investor absolutely freaks out. TechDirt. Retrieved from
https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20150217/06182930052/elon-musk-clarifies-that-teslas-patents-really-are-free-investor-absolutely-freaks-out.shtml
Meyer, P. (2016, July 27). Tesla Motors, Inc.’s organizational culture, characteristics (an analysis). Panmore Institute. Retrieved from http://panmore.com/tesla-
motors-inc-organizational-culture-characteristics-analysis
Meyer, P. (2016, July 26). Tesla Motors, Inc.’s organizational structure, characteristics (an analysis) Panmore Institute. Retrieved from http://panmore.com/tesla-
motors-inc-organizational-structure-characteristics-analysis
Morrisson, C. (2008, October 15). Elon Musk steps in as CEO at Tesla, lays off staff. VentureBeat. Retrieved from http://www.nytimes.com/external/venturebeat/
2008/10/15/15venturebeat-elon-musk-steps-in-as-ceo-at-tesla-lays-off-99182.html
Musk, E. (2014, June 12). All our patent are belong to you. https://www.tesla.com/blog/all-our-patent-are-belong-you
Newcomb, A. (2016, July 7). Tesla CEO Elon Musk fires back against 'BS' reports after autopilot crash. ABC News. Retrieved from http://abcnews.go.com/Technology/
tesla-ceo-elon-musk-fires-back-bs-reports/story?id=40399864
Nielson, J. (2016, April 8). Tesla Model 3: An integrative innovation case study. Retrieved from http://www.theinnovativemanager.com/tesla-model-3-integrative-
innovation-case-study/
Riley, C. (2015, May 1). Tesla's new product is a battery for your home. CNN. Retrieved from http://money.cnn.com/2015/05/01/technology/tesla-powerwall
-battery-product/
Rosevear, . (2016, September 15). Will other suppliers follow Mobileye and split with Tesla Motors? Retrieved from http://www.fool.com/investing/2016/09/15/
mobileye-we-quit-tesla-motors-because-of-safety-co.aspx
Schwartz, A. (2016, February 4). There's one simple reason why Elon Musk is so convincing. Business Insider. Retrieved from http://www.businessinsider.com/
why-elon-musk-is-such-a-great-communicator-2016-2
Shall, P. (2016, March 28). Is there something fishy at Tesla? Seeking Alpha. Retrieved from http://seekingalpha.com/article/3961463-something-fishy-tesl
Stewart, J. (2016, October 28). Tesla unveils its new line of camouflaged solar panels. Wired. Retrieved from https://www.wired.com/2016/10/tesla-unveils-new-
line-camouflaged-solar-panels/
Squatriglia, C. (2010, June 29). Tesla IPO raises $226.1M, stock surges 41 percent. Retrieved from https://www.wired.com/2010/06/tesla-ipo-raises-226-1-million/
Vance, A. (2015). Elon Musk: Tesla, SpaceX, and the quest for a fantastic future. New York City, NY: Ecco Press.
Volecker, J. (2009, October 2). More Tesla turmoil? Executive turnover continues. Retrieved from http://www.greencarreports.com/news/1036034_more-tesla-
turmoil-executive-turnover-continues