An Analysis of Teachers' Strategies in Teaching Reading Comprehension of First Grade Students at SMK Swasta Tunas Karya Batang Kuis
An Analysis of Teachers' Strategies in Teaching Reading Comprehension of First Grade Students at SMK Swasta Tunas Karya Batang Kuis
*Khairunnisa
ABSTRACT
The objectives of this study were to investigate the strategies used by the English
teacher for teaching reading comprehension and to find out the reasons why
teacher used those strategies in teaching reading comprehension of first grade
students at SMK Swasta Tunas Karya Batang Kuis. This research used descriptive
qualitative method. The subjects of this study were two English teachers who
teach at SMK Swasta Tunas Karya Batang Kuis, Deli Serdang especially at first
grade students. The instruments of this study were recording, interview and
documentation. The findings found that, the first teacher used two strategies,
Scaffolding and QARs (Question Answer Relationship). Scaffolding strategy
student can develop about idea which readable by the student. QARs (Question
Answer Relationship), the teacher able to know how far their students understand
what the teacher has given to them. The second teacher used conventional
strategy. This strategy should be selected based on its appropriateness and
effectiveness to the learning process so that its use will enable the teacher to
explore the students‟ ideas and to help them read in a better way. Based on the
analysis inteview, the reason why teachers used those types of strategies on
students‟ reading comprehension were because to make the student understand the
reading text and the students guided to more focus on the text. To help their
students overcome difficulties in comprehending the texts, especially the various
aspects of reading such as the main idea, detailed information, making inferences
and noting references and also teacher could help students in developing the
meaning contained in the text reading so that students more easily understand the
contents of reading.
*Graduate Status
**Lecturer Status
1
I. INTRODUCTION
A. The Background of the Study
In learning English, there are four skills that should be mastered by the
students. They were speaking, writing, reading, and listening. It is better for
English learners to master in all those skills, but the fact is different. Many
English learners are not master in all of those skills, for example, some English
learner are good in writing skill, but are not for reading skill. The other example,
some English learners are good in speaking, but are not well in listening. It means
that those English learners have different abilities in acquiring language.
2
times, the teacher becomes their parents who lead them in teaching and learning
activity. The teacher has to have a strategy to make the students ready to read. By
applying the correct strategies in teaching and learning process, the teacher are
able to evoke the student‟s confident to read correctly.
1. Skill
a. Reading
b. Types of Reading
Reading activities can be done at school, at home and at work or wherever
the readers want. In order to acquire reading skills the students should read
different kinds of reading text such as intensive reading, extensive reading,
reading aloud, and silent reading.
1) Intensive Reading
Intensive reading occurs when the learner is focused on the language
rather than the text. It involves learning new vocabulary, studying the
grammar and expression in the text, translating the passage or other tasks that
involve the students in looking intensively (inside) the text. In other words,
students need to read carefully to understand the meaning of the text
accurately.
3
2) Extensive Reading
According to Mikulecky (2008:3) extensive reading is a highly
individualized approach to reading improvement. Students select their own
books and read at their own pace. The teacher should guide students to select
books at a level of comprehension that allows for comprehensible input. The
emphasis is on the quantity of books read and the students‟ enjoyment of their
books. Students are never tested formally on their extensive reading.
3) Reading Aloud
Wilson (2006:6) states that reading aloud has a remarkable effect on
children. It enhances children‟s skills, interests and development in many
ways that reach far beyond just improving their own reading interests and
abilities. One of the main intentions of reading aloud is to recognize the
sounds of words; however, teachers may also vary their activities to develop
their students‟ reading comprehension. The teachers may ask some questions
after the students have read the text. When one student read aloud, the teacher
asks the other students to pay attention to the text rather than just listen to how
their friend reads. This will assist the students in finding the meaning of the
text.
4) Silent Reading
This type is done by student in the class, they are supposed to read the
passage silently the main purpose of this reading is how the students can
obtain the information from the printed page efficiently, rapidly and fully
understand.
c. Reading Comprehension
Reading comprehension is the ability to read text, process it, and
understanding its meaning. Reading comprehension is defined as the level of
understanding of a text or meaning. This understanding comes from the
interaction between the words that are written and how they trigger knowledge
outside the text or message. Westwood (2008:31) reveal that reading
comprehension can be defined as an active thinking process through which a
reader intentionally constructs meaning to form a deeper understanding of
concepts and information presented in a text.
4
The researcher assumed that reading comprehension is important to be
mastered for each of students, because it will improve their other English skill,
such as speaking and writing, this is useful for them, due to make them easy to
making communication in English either in oral written.
1) Bottom-up Process
2) Top-down Process
5
3) Interactive Process
6
information through skimming and scanning activities. The students are also
guided to be familiar with some vocabularies included in the reading text.
This activity is done only to attract students‟ interest, motivation and
enthusiasm till the end of reading activity.
2) Whilst-reading activity
This activity is usually assumed as the core of reading process. The
students start to read the text and comprehend all information in the text. The
students are also guided to identify main ideas on each paragraph, grasp all
information comprehensively and try to make some clues of the
vocabularies. In this activity the teacher encourages the students to focus on
reading, so that the students will be easy to understand and know what they
have read so far.
3) Post-reading activity
It is the end of reading section. In this activity the teacher tries to
evaluate students‟ comprehension of the reading text. The evaluation
includes vocabulary, grammatical, meaning and summarizing of the author‟s
purpose. In addition, to know these items, the teacher gives an exercise
toward the students.
a. Scaffolding
Gasong, 2007 stated that scaffolding is a lesson in which students are
given some assistance during the early stages of learning and then reducing the aid
and providing opportunities for students. Scaffolding allows teachers help diverse
learner negotiate meaning and overcome difficulties in text-related learning
situation. Scaffolding is as a process whereby a student is helped to solve a
particular problem beyond its developmental capacity through the help of a teacher
or other person with more ability.
b. Think-aloud
Think alouds is a strategy that helps students on learning activities, aims to
recall more significant information from the texts given by the teacher. The ability
of teachers to transfer creativity Them and control the students in completing each
7
step of the way think alouds strategy in understanding reading texts and teachers
make their thinking explicit by verbalizing their thoughts while reading orally.
c. Reciprocal Teaching
Reciprocal teaching is a strategy that asks students and teachers to share
the role of teacher by allowing both to lead the discussion about a given reading.
Reciprocal Teaching involves four strategies that guide the discussion: predicting,
generating question, summarizing and clarifying. Reciprocal Teaching is a great
way to teach students how to determine important ideas from a reading while
discussing vocabulary, developing ideas and questions, and summarizing
information. It can be used across several content areas; it works particularly well
with textbooks and non-fiction text.
8
transcripts of teachers‟ interview. The sources of data were two English teachers
who teach at SMK Swasta Tunas Karya Batang Kuis, Deli Serdang especially of
first grade students.
The instruments of collecting data were camera recorder, voice recorder,
interview sheets and documentation. The camera recorder was used to record the
teaching reading comprehension process. The voice recorder was used to record
the interview with the teacher. The interview sheet was used to know the reasons
of why the teacher teach used the strategies in teaching reading comprehension to
the students. Documentation was used to obtain the information. Documentation
can be written or picture by someone.
The techniques of collecting data were recording, interview and
documentation. Recording was done during an interview and during teaching
learning process in the classroom. Recording can be handwritten notes, audio or
video recording. The recording do to know how the teacher‟s strategies in
teaching reading comprehension toward the students. The researcher record all the
teaching reading comprehension process then made it into transcripts. Interview
was done to collect the data of the reason why the teachers used strategies in
teaching reading comprehension to the students. The researcher prepared some
questions for the interview, in order to get the information related research
problem. The researcher prepared the concept of questions that asked the subject
and the researcher will made it into transcripts as the result of interview. The
documentation of this research includes; lesson plan, teaching material are useful
to describe the teachers‟ behaviour in the teaching process of reading
comprehension.
After collecting all the data, the data was analyzed by using descriptive
qualitative research. The result of interviews was analyzed by using analytical
method proposed by Miles and Huberman (1994). He stated that there are four
steps in analytical method; data collection, data reduction, data display, and
conclusion or verification.
Her name is Mrs. ES. The researcher found that there were two
strategies that the teacher used “scaffolding, and QARs (Question Answer
Relationship)”.
9
since the appearance of student‟s learning problem in the different situation
may need different treatment in solving it. The teacher using scaffolding
strategy because scaffolding strategy help the students to become more
independent learners during reading comprehension lesson and teacher used
this strategies because when the researcher observed in the classroom, the
researcher have analysis that the way teacher asked first to all the students
which words that they did not know in the text. So first, the students mark
some words that has not known before, after that the student asked to the
teacher that words have not known.
10
B. Discussion
Vacca & Vacca (1999:53) states that strategies in teaching reading
comprehension are Scaffolding, Think Aloud, Reciprocal Teaching, SQ3R and
QARs. Based on the data above, researcher found the first teacher, Mrs. ES used
two strategies that were scaffolding and QARs. The second teacher, Miss AA
used conventional strategy.
The second strategy was QARs. Mrs. ES asked this strategy was aimed
improve students‟ reading comprehension. It teaches students how to ask
questions about their reading and where to find the answers to them. It helps
students to think about the text they are reading and beyond it, too. It inspires
them to think creatively and work cooperatively while challenging them to use
higher-level thinking skills. The strategy was efficient to improve both the
students‟ reading comprehension skills and active participation in the teaching
learning process of reading. The specific strengths of QARs strategy were
helping the students to identify different levels of questions and the relationship
between questions and answers that made the students able to determine the
sources of information to answer the questions and activating the students to
participate in the teaching learning process of reading.
Based on the findings and discussion in the previous chapter, the following
conclusions are drawn:
11
1. There were two teachers as the data. The first teacher used two strategies,
they were scaffolding and QARs. Scaffolding is a process in which
teachers model or demonstrate how to solve a problem and then step back,
offering support as needed. QARs is a strategy to be used after students
have read. QARs teaches students how to decipher what types of questions
they were being asked and where to find the answers to them. The second
teacher used conventional strategy. Conventional strategy is textbook
centered, teacher dominant, exam-oriented. The emphasis here is mainly in
remembering and reproducing facts, principles and theories of learning.
2. From the teacher‟s interview, it can be found that the reasons why the
teacher of SMK Swasta Tunas Karya Batang Kuis using those strategies to
make the student understand the reading text and the students guided to
more focus on the text. To help their students overcome difficulties in
comprehending the texts, especially the various aspects of reading such as
the main idea, detailed information, making inferences and noting
references and also teacher could help students in developing the meaning
contained in the text reading so that students more easily understand the
contents of reading. Without using appropriate strategies, the purpose of
learning reading comprehension cannot be easily reached.
B. Suggestions
12
3. For other Researchers
a. The next researcher can conduct the research about the teacher
strategies that used by English teacher which important in teaching
and learning process. Therefore, that result will give more advantage
and easily applied in a larger area.
b. The researcher expects that there will be other researchers who
investigate other aspects relating to teachers‟ strategies, and hopefully
this research will be useful as a reference to their research. Besides, it
can also be used by them who carry out and develop similar study.
REFERENCES
Aebersold, J.A. & Field, M.L. 1997. From Reader to Reading Teacher: Issues
and Strategies for Second Language Classrooms. New York: Cambridge
University Press.
Allington, R. 2002. What I’ve learned about effective reading instruction: From a
decade of studying exemplary elementary classroom teachers. Phi Delta
Kappan, 83, 740-747.
Apsari, Yanuarti & Yana. 2015. Teachers’ Techniques and Problems in Teaching
Reading. Jurnal Ilmiah UPT P2M STKIP Siliwangi, 2 (2), 217-233.
Ary, D., Jacobs, L., Razavieh, A. & Sorensen C. 2006. Introduction to Research
in Education 7th ed. Wadsworth: Cengage Learning.
Aswan et al. 2010. Strategi Belajar Mengajar. Jakarta. Reneka cipta (2010).
13
Brown, H. Douglas. 2004. Teaching by Principles. New York: Longman.
Chastain, K. 1988. Developing Second Language Skills Theory and Practice, 3rd
ed. San Diego: Harcourt Brace Jovanovich.
Harmer, J. 2007. The Practice of Language Teaching, 4th ed. London: Pearson
Longman.
14
Miles, B. & Huberman, A. 1994. Qualitative Data Analysis Thousand Oaks,
California: Sage Publications, Inc.
Nunan, David. 1999. Second Language Teaching and Learning. Boston: Heinle &
Heinle Publisher
Nurhamidah, Siti, Syahid Muammar Pulungan, & Eka Sustri Harida. 2018. The
Analysis of Teachers’ Strategies in Teaching Reading Comprehension at
SMAN 2 Padang Bolak. Jurnal Penelitian Ilmu-Ilmu Sosial dan Keislaman,
4 (2), 299-311.
Paris, Scott. 2010. Teaching reading and viewing: Comprehension strategies and
activities for years 1-9. New York: Queensland Studies Authority.
Pearson, P.D. & Johnson. 1978. Teaching Reading Comprehension. New York:
Holt, Rinehart & Winston.
Sattar, Susan & Hadi Salehi. 2014. The Role of Teaching Reading Strategies in
Enhancing Reading Comprehension. International Journal of Current Life
Sciences, 4 (11), 10922-10928.
15
Slavin. R. E. 2000. Cooperative Learning: Teori, Riset, dan Praktik. Bandung:
Nusa Media.
Soedarso. 2002. Speed Reading : Sistem Membaca Cepat dan Efektif. Jakarta:
Gramedia Pustaka.
Westwood, P. 2008. What Teachers Need to Know about Reading and Writing
Difficulties. Victoria: ACER Press.
16