Chapter 5
Chapter 5
Affective
Learning
Competencies
Overview
Affect desc_ribes a number of non-cognitive variables such as a
person's attitude, interests and values. Student affect is important
and teachers can help their students acquire positive attitudes.
According to William James Popham (2003), the reasons why it is
important to assess affect are: (1) educators should be interested i11
assessing affective vc![iables because these variables are excellent
predictors of students' future behavior; (2) teachers should assess
affect to remind themselves that there's more to being a successful
teacher than helping students obtain high scores on achievement
tests; and (3) Information regarding students' affect can help
teachers teach more effectively on a day-to-day basis.
In this chapter, the importance of affective targets, affective
traits and learning targets as well as affective domain of the
taxonomy of educational objectives will be discussed.
Section Intended Learning Outcome
At the outset of this section, you are expected to
be able to develop instruments for assessing affective
learning.
1
Assessment of Learning 2
Il'E,�GAG}
Besides stud_ents' academic performance, there are other dimensions of learners that
:-teed to be assessed·also. These are aptitudes and attitudes that are related to the acade.inic
achievement of learners (Tanner, 2001).
Information about learners' experiences with a subject or an .activity is on_ly part of
·.vhat is needed as input in order to explain their performance. In a class, it would be an
obvious evidence that experience appears to be consistent from student to stude_nt (since
:hey belong to the same class and were given the same activity), still some perform better
:han the others. And this difference among students needs to be-part of-th� information to
assess students better.
\.
The learners' attitudes toward academic tasks influence -t}:leir achievements (Harter,
1988; Lefrancois, 1994). Attitude is associated with what is called the individual's affectiye
domain, and affect adds a significant dimension to assessment. If there is a relatio�ship
::>etween how students feel about a task and their performance, it-is but necessary for
:eachers to assess affect and then do something to influence affect. It is not just to help
:he students like the activities they ·do but to do it better. Attitude measures are part of
:he broader category of personality measures. This area of assessment is significant sil}Ce
:nformation about personality characteristics gives more information that will help in
predicting how a particular set of learners will likely respond to certain learning situation.
:n the general psychology course, a more detailed study about personality is covered, but in
:his book the focus is its connection to school and learners' achievement.
The relevance of affective targets as regards assessment of learners' and facilitation of
:earf!_ing, qre .discussed in the succeeding paragraphs_.
2
Assessment of Learning 2
school routines are organized based on subject areas; and (2) assessment of affective 'targets
is fraught with difficulties. (M.cMillan, 2007)
Cognitive subject matter targets are agreed on as desirable for all students. This places
affect in a position of importance but still ·secondary to cognitive learning. It also makes
difficult to determine which affective targets are appropriate for all students. It is simply not
easy'to define attitudes, values, and interests.
The second possible reason is that many pqtential sources �f error in measuring
affective traits often result in low reliability. Motivation is of primary con<:_eri:i. Students
need to take such assessments seriously to provide accurate results, but still many may
restrain from giving honest answer if the responses are not treated with anonymity and
confidentiality. It would be easier to fake responses to self-report instrume_nts if the results
are to be used for grading or some other purpose. Students may want to please the teachers
with positive responses. Other possible source of,error is that soine affective traits are easily
influenced by momentary or temporary moods. This is true for younger students who may
report more negative affect after a bad day or session. Teachers' bias may also contribute
significantly on what may be recorded or perceived.
Though a lot of demotivating instances were mentioned in the_previous paragraphs,
these discouraging instances slwuld not hinder the as,ses·sment of the students' affect.
Positive affective traits and skills are essential for:
• Effective learning
•· Being an involved and productive member of our society
• Preparing for oc<;upational and vocational satisfaction and productivity (exainple:
work habits, willingness to learn, interpersonal skills)
• Maximizing the motivation to learn at present and in the future
• Preventing students from dropping out of school.
Various ways by which teachers can sign�l to students that clearly defined positive
affect is important than just simply systematically assessing it. It begins with identifY,ing
appropriate affect targets.. In the next paragraph. this,.action will be explained more.
3
Assessment of Learning 2
Shown in the table below are the different affective traits and its corresponding
description:
TRAIT DESCRIPTION
Attitudes Predisposition to respond favorably or unfavorably to
- specified situations, concepts, objects, institutions, or
persons· .
-
Values Importance, worth, or usefulness of modes or
conduct and end states of existence
4
Assessment' of Learning 2
In the_ succeeding parts of thi� chapter, some of these affective traits will be discussed in
· ' line with setting of affective targets or outcomes. These traits have been studied and found
out to be contributory factors in student learning.
5
Assessment of Learning 2 -
is likely that for many swdents, theSe components win�/ con,;adict:e another. Fo; example,
Juana may not like English very much but thinks that English is important. The question
is, what would her attitude be, in general sense, toward English? That would depend op
what components of the attitude is being measured. If it is only affective component then
the attitude would be negative; but if it is the cognitive component, it would translate to a
positive attitude..
This trifocal conceptualization has significant implications for identifying attitude_
targets. Do.es the assessment need to focus on feelings, thoughts, or behavior? If the
learning .target for example is "students will have a positive attitude to�ard school" then
the assessment needs to include all the three-components since the general nature of target
would need to be consistent with the assessment. -But, if the target is "students will like
. -
coming to school," then it would suffice that the assessment focus only on the affective
component.
�reedom Students should believe that democratic countries must provide the
,.
maximum level of freedom to their citizens.
,. ..
C
(Popham, 2005)
6
As-s.eg_sment of Learning 2
McMillan (2007) and Popham (2005) suggested other non-controversial values (aside
from those mentioned above) like kindness,. generosity, perseverance, loyalty, respect,
courage, compassion, and tolerance. Both of them believed that there should be a limit to the
number of affective traits ta_rgeted and assessed. It is better to do an excellent job assessing
a few important_traits than to try to assess many traits casually.
reward· or punishment. · Likewise, it has been shown that students who are motivated by a
need to understand and master the task (mastery orientation) show more positive behavior
and thinking as compared to those who are doing something for the result or outcome
(perfe>rmance operation). Students who are for mastery orientation are·more engaged, have
in general, inclination to generate solutions to difficulties, and generate more positive credits
to success and faUure (success attributed to ability and moderate effort; failure to lack of
effort).
or counselor. . --,
8
Assess m en t of L e_a rn in g 2 ·
Sharing
Cooperative Listening Students will demonstrate
Skills Volunteering ideas and suggestions that they are able to
Supporting and accepting others' negotiate with others and
ideas compromise
Taking turns
Criticizing constructively
9
Assessment of Learning 2
Collaborative skills needed to work in· small groups may include four components
namely: (1) basic inte�action; (2) getting along; (3) coaching;' and (4) fulfilling particular
roles (Borkh & 'I_'ombari, 2004; 1-Ioy& Greg, 1994).
A general target regarding "improved social relationships" or "improved collaboration
skills" does not provide specifics to focus instruction and assessment.
0
CHARACTERISTIC DESCRIPTION
Affiliation T 1e extent to which stud ent like and accept each other
Involvement The extent to which students are interested
in and engaged in learning
Task Orientation The extent to which classroom activities are focused o·n the
completion of academic task�
Cohesiveness The extent to which students share norms and expectations
Competition The emphasis on competition between students
Favoritism Whether each studen.t enjoys the same privileges
Influence The extent to which each student influences classroom
. decisions l
10
Assessment of Learning 2
11
Assessment of Learning 2
I Or ganizing Stude nts successively inter nalize Student inte g rates the
values, they. encounter situations less ons lear ned in Math
in w hich mor e than one value is with Science.
relevant. This requires the necessity of
or ganizing their values into a system
such that cer tain values exer cise
greater control.
Char a c t er i z i ng b y Inter nalization has taken place in Student applies the lessons
a V a I u e o r va·1 u e an individual's value hierar chy to lear ned in Mathematics in
Complex the exte nt that he or she can be �faily activities such buying,
characterized as holding a particular cooking, ana others.
value or set of values. \
12
Assessment of Learning 2
-
A. Given the following classroom situations, think of a solution that will help you as
teacher to understand better your students and how affective targets will help yo
, improve the, situation if not tota�y solve the.problem. Discuss your answers with your
classmates.
1. Carlos is ap intelligent kid but never makes it to the top ten of his class because o
his attitude towards some of his teachers.
2. Angel is a tohsistent honor student �ince grade scho_ol and active too in extra
curricular activities. Then, ail of a sudden, in high school she became an average
performing student. It resulted when she found out tha.t there was favoritism. Grades
were adjusted in order for some of her classmates not to be disqualified in being part
of the top section (due to technicalities of grade requirement).
B. Given t�e classroom situation, analyze and identify what characteristics of classroom
environment is/are present in the situation. Propose what action(s) must be done to
improve the situation. Discuss your answers and give your comments and suggestions to
what you and your classmates will share during discussion. Use the template provided.
13
Assessment of Learning 2
A. Apply the concepts discussed about affective domain of the taxonomy of educational
objectives• in the given situation by crafting affective objectives correctly. The
objectives must be measureable. Group discussion follows after this activity to share
and solicit additional comments and suggesti0ns from your classmates. Use the
template provided for your answer.
Situation:
The school,_ being sectarian, wants to ensure that their graduates will embody
the character traits that are expected of their g'raduates. As such, th� pr[!sident
gave an instruction that religion must be integrated in all the subjects and not just
during religion class.
As a teacher, what and how will you support this direction of the school
president so that it will be realized, focusing on the affective domain of the
students?
Levels I Measurable Affective Objective
14
Assessment of Learning 2
B. Using this graphic organizer, write your own ideas about the importance of affective
targets in learning.
Affective Targets
15
Assessment of Learning 2
C. In SectiOJ?. A, list all the facts you know about Affective Targets. In Section B, list your
feelings and associations. In Section C, write a summary statement about affective
targets.
C
Summary Statement
..
16
Assessment of Learning 2
--· --
Group Members:·--------------- Date: _______
A. On ·the template provided, write affective-objectives for each level orthe Taxonomy
of Educational Objectives:. Affective Domain.
2. Responding
--
3. Valu·ing
4. Organizing
5. Characterizing
17
Assessment of Learning 2
8. Brainstorm, analyze, and come up with your group's affective objectives, depicting the
progress in each stage of the Taxonomy of Educational Objectives: Use the template
. provided for your answers.
-
1. Receiving/Attending
2. Responding
3. Valuing
4. 9rganizing
5. Characterizing
18
- ·Assessment.of Learning 2
C. Craft two Affective Learning Outcomes for each of the affective traits. Use the
template provided below..
ALO #2
Values ALO #1
ALO #2
Motivation ALO #1
ALO #2
--
19
Assessment of Learning 2
D.. Craft two Affective Learning Outcomes for each of the affective traits. Use the
template provided below.
ALO #2
ALO #2
ALO #2
20
Assessment of.Learning 2 ·
❖ .The term affect refers to emotions and feelings, yet affective targets include
cognitive and behavioral traits.
21