Neighborhood Development Plan in Addis Ababa
Neighborhood Development Plan in Addis Ababa
KIFLE TADESSE
ID – GSR/6962/10
1
Part one
Introduction
Urban design is about Place making. It’s about much more than the buildings themselves. It’s
about the place and culture and opportunity and vision. It’s our chance to shift the center of
gravity in a city and provide a far reaching vision that can grow and change and mold a
destination’s future.
As urban designers, site selection is a process that is analytical and factual, but at the end of the
day, it has to feel right. I have developed the following criteria that allow for an inclusive and
objective process.
1. Location: - by considering the location criteria, it needs to identify and more known to
identify the existing condition of the site and the proximity towards the access of the
transportation is the first points. Next to this does the site have good transport
connections to other areas and developments?
2. Zoning: - which is valuable points for the selection of the site and in this section I tried to
check the site permits for the development or not. According to the Addis Ababa City
Structural plan, the site is permitted for development and there is no preserved area
which has not allowed for new development.
3. Surrounding development:- as we know that the surrounding development can
influence the rate of development and situational characteristics of the site regarding
with an urban design project. By considering this for this project, it is trying to identify
the rate of the development in the surrounding. Due to this case, unbalanced rate was
existed on the site towards the surrounding development.
4. Existing Condition: - related to time and cost it needs to identify the existing condition of
the site. Due to this case the site is slum and most of the parcel does not have title deed
and administrated by kebele administration through rent.
2
Based on those conditions the site is selecting for an urban design project for academical
purpose, which has taken for course called urban Design studio I.
According to Lynch there are at list five elements, which indicate more the place to remind
easily by Paths, Edges, Districts, Nodes and Landmarks however, in this project site it is better
to observe the legibility of the site to easily understand the site. Graphically, it is shows in figure
below.
3
Part Two
Existing Street
In this section, the existing street network analysis is being present and the existing street
network deal with Street pattern, street surface materials, street hierarchy and space syntax of
the existing condition.
I. Street pattern
Street is the tree dimensional space that can be analyzed in terms of a number of qualities,
combinations and its visual dynamics. In addition to this street are the Streets are primary
structuring elements of cities, and determine movement and circulation. Due to the nature of
topography and settlement patterns, radial and irregular street pattern are common. Grid,
loop or ring road patterns have been developed subsequently to curb the difficulties of the
radial pattern. In addition to this, an important quality of street that is formed by cadastral
pattern is its permeability, which is the extent to which an urban fabric permits people a choice
of routes, through and within it.
4
II. Street Hierarchy
Actually, there is no fixed standard to classify street in different urban area. According to the
Ethiopia ministry of urban development and construction manual for preparation of the Local
Development Plan classifies street hierarchy by its width and function and function.
Express way: It provides for expeditious movement large volumes of through traffic b/n
area and across the city not intending to provide land access
Arterial street It provides for the through traffic movement b/n areas and across the
city and divert access to the abutting property subject to necessary control of entrance
exit and curbs.
Collector Street It provides traffic movement between major arterial and local street
system and direct access to the abutting property.
Local Street It provides direct access to the abutting property.
5
III. Surface Materials
In the site, the street material is coldness of the area. Due to this case, it is
cobblestone, which dominates, on the suitable for warming the area during high
other hand there are street that covers by sunny time.
CARE (Cooperative for Assistance and Relief
Everywhere) project. Which does stone
cover and we call it ‘Bazola’ and there is
only one street that is earthen in material.
From this, it is useful to prevent soil
erosion, warming the area rather than
asphalt because absorption and reflecting
the ultra violet determine the hotness and
6
Existing Block
Land use plan is the spatial interpretation of the land activity. Here the land use is catagorized
based on the standard of the structrure plan of Addis Ababa City which is shown in figure ___.
From the perspective of different planner in this senarion they believe that most of the
functiion and activities of city land use is more caracterized by mixed use. Based on this in final
draft of the structure plan of Addis Ababa City the planninig commission point out the mixity
issue and as the description there are situations where ‘mixity’ could occur without residences.
7
8
Building Height
The existing condition of the building height in the project site which is dominated highly by
G+0 which is one story building. However there are other stories building in the site which is
shown figure 1.10 below.
9
Figure Ground
10
Surface analysis
In the surface analysis part there are the following concepts which is analyzed slope and aspect
of the site
Slope
A site’s suitability for roads, walkways, building and other structures is, in part based on the
existing slope on the site as well as the planning area. Based on this the classification of slope is
shown table 1.2 and the slope of the planning as well as the site is more dominated by gentle
slope which best for settlement condition.
So studing the slope is more necessary to proposing based on the difference of elevation and
the detail information is shown below. Based on the given percentage of slope classification it is
necessary to consider during proposal stage of the existing slope condition. So
11
Aspect
Microclimate Analysis
Microclimate analysis is differ from regional climate study and it focuses on the given study
area or project area which get information in the given urban site. Most of the time
microclimate analysis of the project site focuses on the following points. Those are sun, wind,
temperature, precipitation, temperature and humidity.
A. Sun
According to Brown (2001), the situational analysis of the site concerned about sun is
encompassed sundial, sun path and solar radiation.
Sundial
It is used to stimulate the changing of position of sun and shade over the day time throughout
the year. In addition to this the sundial is used to evaluate the exiting condition of the site,
impacts of buildings alternative, the tendency of sun penetration on building and finally the
effect of shading device. In different places with reference of the latitude and longitude, the
coldest and hottest month is different and the formation of shadow is differing. Generally, if the
sun angle is low, the shadow becomes long and if the sun angle is higher, the shadow becomes
shorter with reference of the object or buildings (Brown & De kay 2001:5).
The Sun Path
When the sun is available on a particular site the time and the year can be determined due to
this case sun path is a path of the sun along the sky. The sun path diagram shows the path of
12
the sun in the sky dome as projected on horizontal surface. As Brown and De kay (2001) wrote
and cited Libbey Ford (1974) description from the sun path diagram for given latitude used to
determine the sun position in terms of altitude and azimuth for any hour of the year.
By plotting objects like buildings on the sun path diagram, we can tell about obstruction period
that means when the object obstruct and shade the reference point of the building. Because
during hot season and period creating different mechanism and considering the situation is one
of the necessary skill of designer of built environment.
13
Addis Ababa solar radiation
B. Wind
During studying of the wind, there are two concepts. Wind rose and wind square
Wind Rose, which tells (focuses) on the wind direction, speed and frequency in a particular
study area by monthly or yearly. Actually, most of the world cities have their own data, which is
collecting and used in the airport by accessing from International Metrology station. In addition
to this, the Figure 3 in Appendix 3 shows the wind rose of Addis Ababa which is accessing from
the site for this academically purpose. The wind rose of Addis Ababa shows how many hours
per year the wind blows from the indicated direction. For example, SW wind is blowing from
South West to North East. (Wind Rose of Addis Ababa is shown in Appendix-A figure 3)
https://www.meteoblue.com/en/weather/forecast/modelclimate/addisababa_ethiopia_34499
Wind square which represent the patterns
of wind direction and speed by time and
month of the year for a particular location
in addition to this; the wind square gives
more times at specific location than the
wind rose.
14
A wet day is one with at least 1 millimeter alone, or a mixture of the two. Based on
of liquid or liquid-equivalent precipitation. this categorization, the most common form
The chance of wet days in Addis Ababa of precipitation throughout the year is rain
varies very significantly throughout the alone, with a peak probability of 87% on
year. The wetter season lasts 3.3 months, August 4.
from June 9 to September 20, with a
greater than 45% chance of a given day
being a wet day. The chance of a wet day
peaks at 87% on August 4. The drier season
lasts 8.7 months, from September 20 to
June 9. The smallest chance of a wet day is Figure 1.16 Addis Ababa Daily Precipitations
3% on November 19.
Among wet days, we distinguish between
those that experience rain alone, snow
D. Temperature: - it is the amount of hotness or coldness of the area.
When we see the temperature of Addis Ababa the warm season lasts for 4.0 months, from
February 7 to June 6, with an average daily high temperature above 23°C. The hottest day of
the year is May 15, with an average high of 24°C and low of 13°C. The cool season lasts for 2.0
months, from July 7 to September 6, with an average daily high temperature below 20°C. The
coldest day of the year is December 23, with an average low of 9°C and high of 22°C.
E. Clouds
In Addis Ababa, the average percentage of the sky covered by clouds experiences significant
seasonal variation over the course of the year.
The clearer part of the year in Addis Ababa begins around August 30 and lasts for 6.7 months,
ending around March 20. On November 2, the clearest day of the year, the sky is clear, mostly
clear, or partly cloudy 62% of the time, and overcast or mostly cloudy 38% of the time.
15
Figure 1.17 Addis Ababa cloud categories
The cloudier part of the year begins around
March 20 and lasts for 5.3 months, ending
around August 30. On July 25, the cloudiest
day of the year, the sky is overcast or
mostly cloudy 76% of the time, and clear,
mostly clear, or partly cloudy 24% of the
time.
16
Socio economy study of the site
Actually, it is difficult to study the socio economic situation in the project site however the
information taken from CSA information from the sub city documentation hence it is trying to
describe based on the statistics of worda and using simple mathematical analytics. Regarding
this the sex ration of male and female in bole woreda 04 is 85.31 and the total number of male
is 13737 and the female is 16102, totally there are 29839 are the sum. The Population
Distribution in Woreda total population distribution of 29839 and which is 9.67 percentage of
the total Bole sub city. Population density in woreda is 153.84 populations per hectare. From
this, it is expecting that there might be 1292.256 in the project area because the site coverage
is 8.4 hectare.
Major Finding
The major finding based on the analysis are described in the following list
Lack of street connectivity based on standard
There are many dead roads
Lack of impermeability, accessibility
Street surface material, cobble stone is good for soil erosion
Large block affect the cadastral situation of street
High and low mixed land uses are available in the site
Activity in the site is not vibrant, mostly happened around the administration office
Gentle slope which is best for settlement patter and use of land
There is land use incompatibility (open space Vs Dust Deposition)
SWOT
Based on the findings as well as the entire analysis of the site the SWOT is describing in the
following two tables.
17
18
Vision of the project
The vision of the project is to develop the site in the concept of riverside development.
To accomplish the vision of the project, it needs to establish both the goals and objective with
the interlinked situation between the existing problems, concepts, goals and objectives, which
describes as follows.
Goal 1: - providing physical infrastructure to increase the mobility rate of the site
Objective 1: - propose well connected street to avoid dead ends;
Objective 2: - Proposed pedestrian path at the edge of the river
Goal 2: - Providing a sense of resident and attract the other to the river side
Objective 3: - Proposed different function by using green space along the river side
Objective 4: - Proposed functional open space and square on the project site
Goal 3: - Providing good morphological appearance
Objective 5: - Propose compatible land use in the site
Objective 6: - Proposed block based on the recommendation size from different
practice.
Program of the project
Actually, there are two main programs in the urban fabric to develop the given site, which is
known as Upgrading and redevelopment system. Upgrading is towards some modification of
the existing situation by maintenance, site on service program without demolishing the entire
existing situation and without relocating the residence at all, Whereas the second is so difficult
to perform in action simply because it has great impact on social aspect and economically. In
addition to this, it has social, economic and political impacts.
Beyond the project site is better to implement both the upgrading and redevelopment scheme
simultaneously.
i. Upgrading - the first two blocks in the projects site, namely the Plaza hotel block and
the place where Bole Woreda 04 Administration office is located are going to
develop by the upgrading scheme to keep its existence.
19
ii. Redevelopment scheme: - out of the two blocks, there will be redevelopment
scheme. In this system the new street proposal will be prepare based on the finding
of the existing situation as well as the slope condition of the site. In addition to this
the new block will be generate base on propose street condition because the
arrangement of block is depend on the street network.
Concept of the projects
There are two basic concept plans, which describe in the following way with that of their
advantages and disadvantages.
Alternative one
Advantage
Allocate mixed use
Create green in the riverside
Good street network
Disadvantage
Lack of pedestrian path along the riverside
There is no green and open space network
Not connected to the nearby site
Alternative Two
Advantage
Mixed land use with based on the AASP
Green and pedestrian path along the riverside
Appropriate block length and width
Primary activities propose (school)
Allocating of open space and green
Interconnected to the nearby site
Proposed also the building height based on the guideline
river side from different practice (case study)
Disadvantage
There might be problem with irregular block
20
Part Three
Proposal
21
Proposed land uses
Based on the alternative concept two, the proposed land use map is shown in figure…… that
shows the detail allocation of different function of land use in the area. Actually, there is
guideline to show the ration of land use classification in small neighborhood design, which
prepares by the ministry of urban development.
In the land use above the bold green is the buffer zone of Kebena River, which is directly taken
from AASP by 15m distance from the center of the river. In this area, it is not permitting to do
any development.
22
Open space
23
Function of the green and open space
Urban agriculture
Small park
Recreational activities
24
Land Block and Plot Design
During arrangement of block, there is no more vibrant which is called small block and
fixed guideline in the urban fabric. mostly 80-120 block size is more significant
According to Carmona (2010) for small for visual and physical permeability
block, it is necessary to remember (environment responsive, 1985).
pedestrian permeability, walkability and
Based on this condition and local context
social use of space and for large blocks
small block size in the proposal is 80-130
based on the optimum distribution of built
and the others are considered as large block
form and open space. In addition to this it is
size, which is shown in the figure below.
pointed out that rather than a single
repeated block size, a range of block size
(including small and large block) is
encourage and facilitate greater diversity of
building types and land use and this block
size can be determined by the local context
(M. Carmona et al, 2010, 98).
In the proposal, building mass most of the buildings are common building which provide for
condominium house and at two-block level, it is planned to allocate for real estate
development function. In addition to create mixed purpose, it is necessary to create
segregation system for all income groups as well as the existing residence in the form of
cooperative housing project by creating legal framework.
On the other hand based on the development scheme of the project there is upgrading are in
their parcel and some minor problems like by making standard street size to adjust parcel size.
25
In this case, the existing residence may develop based on the appropriate typology in
cooperative way or individual or by create business-oriented system with the high-income
groups. For this matter, the following guideline is used for percolation process.
Land Preparation and City Development Manual (June 2009) suggest three types of parcel
standard. From the three the first is with ration of 1:2. For instance if the frontage is 10meter in
length the width become 20 meter in length. This is more recommended and for this project.
On the other hand, there is 1:3, which is not recommended but if there is no alternative, it is
better to use it for efficiency of land. In this ratio if the frontage is 8 meter in length the width
become 250 meter, which is not common during design and planning period.
26
Building Height
Based on the practice of other countries and lesson from the case study and guideline, the
building height line step down towards the riverside. Due to this case the building height along
river front low rising building of maximum G+4 and along access street Maximum of G+9 or 35
meter. Here it is trying to encompass the standard of Addis Ababa Structure plan. More over
the building height is show below in figure. The maximum building height for building height is
35m and Floor Area Ratio (FAR): the minimum floor area ratio (FAR) building height is 0.5,
which is 0.5 times the size of the plot. The building height cannot exceed the maximum height
of the zone is 35m. The FAR for buildings facing a local street (street width less than 15m)
however is restricted to FAR 3. It is just use the city rule and regulation based on AASP manual
from planning commission.
Set back
Setback of buildings is proposed by this urban design project to ensure a pleasant urban life and
street to building relation.
Accordingly, the following setback are proposed
A setback of 5 meter is proposed for building along the sub collector Street and for
services
Optional and Null setback for parcel based buildings.
27
Part
Landscape
(Myrtaceae)
Rubber Tree
(Moraceae)
Blue Gum
Dragon Tree
In addition to this, there are no hardscape elements in the site like that of street furniture,
28
1. Clearance to streets and sidewalks
Street trees and planters should generally be located within the Green scape /
Furnishing zone. Trees shall be offset by at least 0.35 m from the curb (to center of the
tree). Therefore, no street tree planting is allowed on sidewalks with a total width less
than 2 m, in order to ensure the minimum Pedestrian / Through zone width as well as a
healthy environment for the tree:
29
The minimum distance between tree stem and an intersection shall be 8 m on sidewalks
on the near side of intersections and 1.5 m on sidewalks at the far side of intersections.
2. Planting spacing
Street tree spacing shall be determined by the expected mature size of the tree. A tree
should fit in the available growing space without major pruning since frequent pruning
increases maintenance costs. Generally, trees should be planted with the following
spacing:-
small trees (< 7 m crown diameter at maturity) should be planted 6m on center;
Large trees (> 11 m crown diameter at maturity) should be planted 10m on center.
30
DESIGN ELEMENTS
o Plants
o Inert Materials
o Landforms
o Site Amenities
o Circulation
o Water Feature
Trees Provide Shade and Reduce Glare Trees Used to Define Space
Wind Control
Plants can modify wind speed on the ground for distances up to thirty times their height. Dense
masses of large evergreen trees planted to intercept prevailing winter and summer winds can
influence energy efficiency of facilities and increase the livability of outside spaces.
31
Noise Abatement
Trees, shrubs, groundcovers, and turf buffer noise. That is, plants diffract and break up sound
waves, changing their direction and reducing their intensity when sufficiently massed. To be
truly effective in controlling noise, plants should be used in concert with masonry walls or
similar noise buffering structures.
Glare Control
Trees, shrubs, and other vegetation can effectively reduce glare and reflection when placed
between the light source and the observer.
32
Streets
The use of street trees is an effective way to visually soften, complement, and define the road
system hierarchy. Large trees provide a canopy and give emphasis to the major corridors. Trees
are the main component of a streetscape corridor plan. Two styles of tree planting are
commonly used: formal and informal.
Formally planted street trees generally are equally spaced, equally sized, on both sides, and
follow the alignment of the street. This style is ideal along a street with limited planting space.
On most Air Force installations, formal tree planting should be considered for the main
roadways, primary housing area streets, unique pedestrian or bicycle paths, historical areas, or
entry to a headquarters or command facility.
A formal street tree arrangement conveys a disciplined, organized, and ceremonial image with
strong directional emphasis. The drawback to the formal style occurs when a mature tree dies
or is removed from the symmetrical alignment. Finding a replacement of the appropriate size is
extremely difficult or impossible.
33
Intersections
Site distance triangles should be utilized to enhance safety for pedestrians and vehicle operators.
Generally, what this means is that no planting or other site improvements between 0.6 and 1.2
meter tall that will inhibit vehicle operator views of opposing traffic should occupy the triangular
space 9 meter in each direction from the intersection corner.
34
Soft and hard landscape
Soft Landscape
Soft landscape is areas where plant and soil dominate which is implemented by the green land
scape design approach with composing of plants in different manner. The advantage of designing
a mixed planting is that there are so many plant types from which to choose. A mixed planting
can include small trees, shrubs, evergreens, grasses, perennials, bulbs, climbers, annuals, tropical
and even cacti and succulents.
Hard landscape
Hard landscape are area in which plants don’t dominate and usually compromise paved or hard
surfaced area, walkways, landscape furniture and street lights.
Selected plants for the project area
Based on those elements of the plant the following out puts are done in simple lmanner.
35
36
37