PIP INEG Insulation Design Guide
PIP INEG Insulation Design Guide
December 2017
Insulation
PIP INEG1000
Insulation Design Guide
--````,``,`,,,``````,,``,,``,,`-`-`,,`,,`,`,,`---
In an effort to minimize the cost of process industry facilities, this Practice has
been prepared from the technical requirements in the existing standards of major industrial
users, contractors, or standards organizations. By harmonizing these technical requirements
into a single set of Practices, administrative, application, and engineering costs to both the
purchaser and the manufacturer should be reduced. While this Practice is expected to
incorporate the majority of requirements of most users, individual applications may
involve requirements that will be appended to and take precedence over this Practice.
Determinations concerning fitness for purpose and particular matters or application of the
Practice to particular project or engineering situations should not be made solely on
information contained in these materials. The use of trade names from time to time should
not be viewed as an expression of preference but rather recognized as normal usage in the
trade. Other brands having the same specifications are equally correct and may be
substituted for those named. All Practices or guidelines are intended to be consistent with
applicable laws and regulations including OSHA requirements. To the extent these
Practices or guidelines should conflict with OSHA or other applicable laws or regulations,
such laws or regulations must be followed. Consult an appropriate professional before
applying or acting on any material contained in or suggested by the Practice.
© Process Industry Practices (PIP), Construction Industry Institute, The University of Texas
at Austin, 3925 West Braker Lane (R4500), Austin, Texas 78759. PIP member companies
and subscribers may copy this Practice for their internal use. Changes or modifications of any
kind are not permitted within any PIP Practice without the express written authorization of
PIP. Authorized Users may attach addenda or overlays to clearly indicate modifications or
exceptions to specific sections of PIP Practices. Authorized Users may provide their clients,
suppliers and contractors with copies of the Practice solely for Authorized Users’ purposes.
These purposes include but are not limited to the procurement process (e.g., as attachments to
requests for quotation/ purchase orders or requests for proposals/contracts) and preparation
and issue of design engineering deliverables for use on a specific project by Authorized
User’s client. PIP’s copyright notices must be clearly indicated and unequivocally
--````,``,`,,,``````,,``,,``,,`-`-`,,`,,`,`,,`---
incorporated in documents where an Authorized User desires to provide any third party with
copies of the Practice.
PRINTING HISTORY
December 1997 Issued October 2005 Complete Revision October 2010 Reaffirmation with Editorial Revision
April 1999 Complete Revision July 2007 Editorial Revision December 2017 Complete Revision
Insulation
PIP INEG1000
Insulation Design Guide
Table of Contents
1. Scope ...........................................2 9. Type Codes................................16
9.1
General ............................................ 16
2. References ..................................2 9.2
Hot Insulation Types ........................ 16
2.1 Process Industry Practices .................2 9.3
Cold Insulation Types....................... 17
2.2 Industry Codes and Standards ...........2 9.4
Insulation Types for Traced and
2.3 Other References ...............................3 Energy Transfer Jacketed Systems . 18
9.5 AC – Acoustic Control Insulation ..... 19
3. Insulation Materials ....................3 9.6 FP – Fire-Protection Insulation ........ 19
3.1 Categories ..........................................3
3.2 Closed-Cell Insulations.......................3 Table 1: Insulation Materials Selection Table
3.3 Fibrous Insulations .............................4 (US Customary Units) ................... 22
3.4 Granular Insulations ...........................4 Table 1M: Insulation Materials Selection Table
3.5 Jacket Materials and Accessories ......5 (SI Units) ....................................... 28
3.6 Vapor Barriers ....................................6
4. Insulation System Design ..........7 Data Forms
4.1 General...............................................7 INEG1000-D001 – Documentation
4.2 Basic Design Criteria ..........................7 Requirements Sheet
4.3 Other Design Criteria........................11 The following data forms shall be part of this Practice
only if indicated on the purchaser’s completed
5. Corrosion under Insulation ......12 Documentation Requirements Sheet.
6. Insulation Material Selection ...13 INEG1000-D002 – Hot Service Insulation
6.1 General.............................................13 Design Parameters
6.2 ASTM Considerations ......................13 INEG1000-D003 – Cold Service Insulation
6.3 Insulation Materials Properties .........14 Design Parameters
7. Extent of Insulation...................14
8. Insulation Thickness ................15
8.1 General.............................................15
8.2 3E Plus .............................................15
1. Scope
This Practice provides guidance for the design of insulation systems. This Practice describes the types of
insulation systems that are indicated by the type code on the Piping and Instrumentation Diagrams
(P&IDs), data sheets, and other design documents. This Practice provides guidance on insulation design
criteria, insulation materials, extent of insulation, determination of insulation thickness, and insulation
material properties.
2. References
Applicable parts of the following Practices, industry codes and standards, and references shall be
considered an integral part of this Practice. The edition in effect on the date of contract award shall be
used, except as otherwise noted. Short titles will be used herein where appropriate.
• NACE RP0198-2004 – The Control of Corrosion Under Thermal Insulation and Fireproofing
– A Systems Approach, NACE International
3. Insulation Materials
3.1 Categories
Insulation materials fall into the following three major generic categories based on the structure
of the insulation material and each has properties that give it unique performance characteristics:
a. Closed cell
b. Fibrous
c. Granular
--````,``,`,,,``````,,``,,``,,`-`-`,,`,,`,`,,`---
c. Needled E glass
d. Ceramic fiber
e. Flexible Aerogel
3.3.2 The fundamental difference between the fibrous insulations is the raw material from which
they are made. Mineral fiber is made from volcanic rock; fiberglass and E glass are made
from inorganic glass fibers; and ceramic fibers are made from inorganic ceramics.
3.3.3 Fibrous insulation is not resistant to moisture permeation and can absorb water or
chemicals if exposed to liquid or vapor. There is no permeation minimum included in the
ASTM standards for any of the fibrous materials. For this reason, fibrous insulation is not
used alone for low-temperature applications in which condensation can occur. If used at an
elevated temperature, the organic binder that helps to hold the insulation together is burned
away causing a reduction in strength and an increase in the ability to absorb moisture.
3.3.4 The fibrous insulations, depending on form, are somewhat flexible and have little
compressive strength. As a result, piping should not be supported through fibrous
insulation, and higher strength materials should be considered in damage-prone areas.
3.3.5 The fibrous insulations do not burn but do absorb flammable chemicals that can burn. In
cases in which leaking flammables are likely, the fibrous materials should not be used.
3.3.6 Flexible aerogel material may be composed of amorphous silica or be fibrous in nature,
and may exhibit different performance properties than what is listed above for fibrous
materials.
3.4.3 Calcium silicate is highly absorbent and should not be used if direct exposure to moisture
or leaking chemicals is likely. At temperatures below 500°F (260ºC), perlite resists
moisture absorption and may be used if corrosion under insulation is a concern; however,
perlite is not typically used in low-temperature applications. At temperatures above
500°F (260ºC), the organic binder that imparts the moisture resistance is no longer
effective, and moisture absorption is possible.
--````,``,`,,,``````,,``,,``,,`-`-`,,`,,`,`,,`---
2. Complicated shapes can be handled by fabricating the jacket in place using
mastic and reinforcing fabric. This approach is often used in combination
with metal jacket in which the metal is used for the straight sections, and the
mastic is used for the complicated shapes. Metal fittings should be used for
tees and elbows for PIP installations.
3.5.4 Accessories
3.5.4.1 Non-metallic accessories (i.e. cements, mastics, adhesives, tapes, etc.) are
selected based on insulation material and system configuration.
3.5.4.2 Metallic accessories (i.e. springs, bands, seals, screws, etc.) shall be stainless steel.
4.1 General
4.1.1 An insulation system consists of the insulation material, protective covering if needed,
and accessories used to secure the insulation in place.
4.1.2 The insulation materials chosen depend upon the reasons that insulation is being used.
Many different criteria are important in the selection of an insulation system. Not all the
criteria mentioned in this Practice apply in all cases. The criteria that apply to a project
should be determined, and priorities should be assigned to those criteria. In some cases,
it may be that only heat conservation or personnel protection are important. In most
projects, many criteria apply with some being much more important than others. Because
each project is unique, the criteria should be assessed for each project, and selections
should be made that are appropriate to their unique circumstances. Design criteria that
should be considered in the selection of insulation materials are described in Section 4.2
of this Practice.
defined as the sum of the cost of the insulation system materials plus the cost of
the energy lost minus any tax savings.
4.2.2.3 Energy loss is reduced for a given insulation material by increasing the
insulation thickness. Increasing the thickness raises the cost of the insulation but
lowers the cost of lost energy. At the economic thickness, the cost of adding
additional insulation thickness is greater than the value of the additional energy
saved.
4.2.2.4 The calculations made to determine the economic thickness require the input of
project-specific data on process conditions, ambient conditions, and economic
data that is specific to the project. To determine an accurate economic thickness,
this data should be obtained for each project. The software contains default
values for process, ambient, and economic variables. However, the default
values are subject to variation and can cause inaccurate economic thickness
calculations.
4.2.3 Personnel Protection Insulation
4.2.3.1 Personnel protection (PP) insulation is used to prevent contact between
personnel and hot operating surfaces. The maximum allowable insulation system
surface temperature is 140°F (60°C) for metallic surfaces. Higher allowable
surface temperatures may be appropriate for non-metallic surfaces, as indicated
in ASTM C1055 Appendix for materials with lower thermal inertia.
4.2.3.2 ASTM C1055 establishes a process for the determination of acceptable surface
operating conditions for heated systems. ASTM C1055 also defines human burn
hazards and presents methods for use in the design and evaluation of heated
systems to prevent serious injury from contact with exposed surfaces. The
method establishes a safe surface contact temperature based on an acceptable
contact time and level of injury. A graph is included in ASTM C1055 that
establishes the temperature-time relationship for burns of specific severity. For
the purposes of this Practice, the acceptable level of injury is reversible
epidermal injury as defined in ASTM C1055, and the PIP adopted acceptable
contact time is 2 seconds. Using the ASTM C1055 graph and the injury and time
parameters leads to the PIP maximum allowable surface temperature of 140°F
(60°C). This temperature is used to calculate the personnel protection thickness.
The personnel protection thickness is chosen so that the outside surface
temperature of the insulation system is no more than 140°F (60°C) for metallic
surfaces under the worst-case operating conditions of highest operating
temperature combined with the highest expected ambient temperature.
4.2.3.3 Two very important variables in the calculation of outside surface temperature
are the emissivity of the jacket material and the wind speed. As the wind speed
increases, the surface temperature falls significantly because of convective
cooling. The wind speed for indoor applications is low, resulting in higher
personnel protection thicknesses than for the same system in an outdoor location.
Choosing a jacket material with high emissivity also reduces the surface
temperature and is a method that can be used to lower the personnel protection
thickness for indoor applications or for high temperature outdoor installations.
As the process temperature drops, increasing the emissivity becomes less
effective at lowering the surface temperature.
cell insulation does not resist moisture penetration and is prone to moisture
absorption if the vapor barrier seal is broken. This insulation should not be used
if the operating temperature is below the highest expected ambient dew point. In
dual-temperature applications, fibrous material can be used as an inner layer to
compensate for thermal expansion, but it should be covered by a closed-cell
outer layer and vapor barrier system to prevent condensation or ice formation on
the inner surface.
4.2.7 Condensation Prevention Insulation
Condensation prevention (CP) insulation is used only to prevent condensation from
occurring on the surface of piping and equipment that is operating at or below the ambient
dew point. The design of condensation prevention systems is the same as cold service
insulation. Thickness is designed only to raise the surface temperature above the project
design ambient dew point. Condensation prevention is typically important for
housekeeping, safety and corrosion control. Closed-cell insulation materials should be used
in condensation control applications. 3E Plus can be used to determine the required
thickness.
4.2.8 Acoustic Control Insulation
4.2.8.1 The primary consideration for use of acoustic control insulation (AC) should be
control of noise.
4.2.8.2 Typically, acoustic control insulation should have a dedicated design for each
application. Refer to ISO 15665 for additional information on acoustic control
insulation.
4.2.8.3 Special consideration of insulation materials and jacketing is typically required.
4.2.8.4 Acoustic control insulation can be combined with other types of insulation.
4.2.9 Fire-Protection Insulation
4.2.9.1 The primary consideration for use of fire-protection insulation (FP) should be
control of the rate of heat gain in a fire.
4.2.9.2 Design of fire-protection insulation should be based on maximum allowable heat
gain, fire case characteristics, allowable time duration, and process characteristics.
Refer to API RP 521, API Publication 2218, and API RP 2001 for additional
information on fire protective insulation.
4.2.9.3 Fire-protection insulation can be combined with other types of insulation.
--````,``,`,,,``````,,``,,``,,`-`-`,,`
--````,``,`,,,``````,,``,,``,,`-`-`,,`,,`,`,,`---
facilitate both identification and removal of surface contamination. Embossed surface
finishes on metal jacket materials can be used to make minor surface damage less visible
to casual observation; however, it is more difficult to clean embossed jackets. Smooth
finishes are more reflective, and damage is more easily visible.
4.3.4 Leak Detection
4.3.4.1 Leak detection is a regulatory requirement for some chemical processes. If
insulating piping and equipment that contains chemicals that fall within the leak
detection classification, it is necessary to design the insulation to permit detection
of leaks at flanges, valves, and other locations that can be prone to leakage.
4.3.4.2 Leak detection provision can be provided in hot systems by not insulating leak-prone
items or by using removable reusable insulation as specified in PIP INSR1000. This
approach is not an option for low-temperature systems because there would be no
vapor seal and condensation or ice formation can occur. Low-temperature systems
require special consideration and should be handled on a case-by-case basis.
4.3.5 Absorption Resistance
The absorption resistance of the insulation material is an important attribute if insulating
piping and equipment that contain flammable or explosive chemicals. If leaks occur and the
insulation absorbs the chemical, it is possible to build up enough of the flammable or
explosive chemical to achieve auto-ignition. It may be necessary to use an appropriate
closed-cell insulation that is compatible with the chemical and does not absorb leaks. It is
desirable to provide drainage to enable the leaking chemical to escape from the insulation
in a controlled fashion.
4.3.6 Emissivity
4.3.6.1 Emissivity is a measure of a body’s ability to radiate energy. A body that radiates
a large amount of energy has an emissivity close to 1, while a material that is a
poor radiator has a low emissivity. All materials have a characteristic emissivity.
New aluminum jacket has an emissivity of about 0.04, while PVC jacket has an
emissivity of about 0.9. The emissivity value can change as the surface
characteristics of the insulation change with time.
4.3.6.2 The surface temperature of an insulation system is a function of the emissivity of
the jacket material. On a hot insulation system, with all other factors held
constant, the outer surface temperature of the insulation jacket is reduced by
using a higher emissivity jacket. If personnel protection is an important criteria,
it may be possible to reduce insulation thickness by using a high emissivity
jacket. On a cold insulation system, the jacket temperature can be raised by using
a higher emissivity jacket. If condensation control is an important criteria, the
surface temperature can be raised by using a higher emissivity jacket.
NACE SP 0198-2010 describes control measures for mitigating corrosion under thermal
insulation. Common coatings for mitigating corrosion under thermal insulation are epoxy
phenolic and coal tar epoxies. PIP CTSE1000 provides more information on coatings.
6.1 General
6.1.1 The appropriate insulation material for a given project is selected on the basis of design
criteria that are appropriate for that specific project. Some important design criteria are
as follows:
a. Operating temperature
b. Strength, rigidity, and the ability to resist mechanical abuse and vibration
c. Absorption resistance
d. Water vapor permeation resistance
e. Fire resistance
6.1.2 Not all insulation materials perform equally well with respect to these design criteria.
Each insulation type has strengths and weaknesses and the strengths of the material
selected for a specific job should be matched to the most important design criteria for
that job. For example, a low permeation material should be chosen for a low-temperature
application in which permeation resistance is needed to prevent condensation on the
surface of the insulated item. A rigid high compressive strength material should be
chosen in situations in which mechanical abuse is likely.
requirement for water absorption. Instead, mineral fiber is evaluated for water vapor
“sorption” using ASTM C1104. ASTM C1104 does not expose the mineral fiber to direct
immersion. Instead, it is exposed to water vapor, a less demanding requirement that does
not indicate how mineral fiber performs if immersed in water. In other cases, the
properties of the insulation change with exposure to elevated temperature. Both perlite
and mineral fiber become much more absorbent if exposed to temperatures that are
sufficiently high to burn away the binder that is applied when the insulation is made.
6.2.3 There is no ASTM test for water wicking except for aircraft-type glass fiber blanket as
published in ASTM C800. Some manufacturers test material using the ASTM C800
procedure however, the appropriateness of this procedure for all materials has not been
demonstrated. The relevance of the procedure to real world applications is also not clear.
If in doubt about the appropriate use of a specific insulation material contact the owner’s
representative for guidance.
7. Extent of Insulation
7.1 Extent of insulation refers to what can and cannot be insulated during a project. PIP datasheets
INSH1000-D003 and INSC1000-D003 m be used to specify the extent of insulation for a project.
The extent of insulation varies depending on the design criteria. For example, in the case of heat
conservation, flanges, valves, or other potentially high maintenance items can be left uninsulated
to facilitate leak detection and repairs. In the case of cold conservation, piping items cannot be
left uninsulated because condensation and ice formation can occur. As a general rule, all low-
temperature surfaces should be insulated. Both heat conservation and process stability
applications should be insulated as much as possible to ensure these criteria are met.
7.2 If insulating only for mitigating personnel protection, the extent of insulation is quite different
than for heat or cold conservation. Personnel protection insulation is only applied to those
surfaces with which personnel can make contact under normal operating conditions. If the
normal operating temperature is greater than 140°F (60°C), personnel protection insulation is
required on all surfaces to 2.13m (7-feet) above grade or platforms, and 0.91m (3-feet)
horizontally from the periphery of platforms, walkways, or ladders. In some circumstances,
guards or barriers can be substituted for insulation to provide personnel protection if insulation
would impair the function of the equipment. A guard is positioned near the pipe or equipment to
prevent personnel contact at a specific location. Guards can be fabricated from a variety of
materials including sheet or expanded metal. Barriers or signs are used to prevent access to areas
where hot equipment is present. An example of a barrier is a chain that bars access to a ladder
that leads to a platform where hot equipment is operating. Hot items that typically cannot be
insulated are refractory-lined vessels, condensers, or equipment that can be subject to corrosion
under insulation.
--````,``,`,,,``````,,``,,``,,`-`-`,,`,,`,`,,`---
8. Insulation Thickness
8.1 General
8.1.1 Insulation thickness depends on the design criteria applied to the project. Insulation that
is intended to conserve heat is typically installed with a different thickness than
insulation designed to protect personnel. There are many variables that influence
insulation thickness including:
a. Operating temperature
b. Average ambient weather conditions
c. Insulation material
d. Jacket material
e. Substrate material of construction
f. Basic Design Criteria (paragraph 4.2)
8.1.2 Because each project is unique, the insulation thickness should be calculated specifically
for each project. Generic thickness tables are not provided in this Practice because any
thickness calculated by 3E Plus is completely dependent upon project specific variables.
Instead, information is provided in this Practice on when to use 3E Plus.
8.1.3 Project-specific data sheets, PIP INEG1000-D002 and PIP INEG1000-D003, formatted
to record the variables required for 3E Plus calculations, are furnished in the appendix of
this Practice. Additional data sheets are furnished to record project specific thicknesses
calculated by 3E Plus using project specific parameters.
8.1.4 Blank thickness data sheets are provided to record the calculated thicknesses for both hot
and cold services. The datasheets are included in PIP INSC1000 and PIP INSH1000.
8.2 3E Plus
8.2.1 3E Plus can be downloaded free of charge from the NAIMA website at
https://insulationinstitute.org/tools-resources/free-3e-plus/. The system of mathematical
heat flux equations used in the 3E Plus analysis is based on the equations published in
ASTM C680 and is applicable to most systems typically insulated with bulk-type
insulations. 3E Plus can be used to calculate thickness for different design criteria. It can
calculate thickness for personnel protection based on easily obtained process data.
8.2.2 3E Plus can also calculate an economic thickness that is optimized based on a series of
economic variables that should be provided by the designer. To obtain an accurate
economic thickness, these variables should be determined for each project. Using the
defaults supplied in the program does not produce an accurate result. The 3E Plus user’s
guide provides a detailed description of the basis for the economic analysis that goes
beyond the scope of this discussion. Among the data required by 3E Plus is climate
information that requires both ambient temperature and wind speed. Both affect heat
transfer. Climate data for many locations in the U.S. is available at www.noaa.gov, the
website of the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA). The actual
climatic data used depends upon the design criteria of the project and the location of the
item to be insulated.
--````,``,`,,,``````,,``,,``,,`-`-`,,`,,`,
8.2.3 Insulation used for condensation control should be designed for the expected humidity
conditions. 3E Plus can be used for the design of low-temperature systems. If a low
process temperature is specified, 3E Plus should be supplied with the ambient
temperature and relative humidity. The highest expected relative humidity at the highest
expected ambient temperature can provide the worst-case dew point temperature. The
insulation thickness should be selected so that the surface temperature of the insulation
jacket is greater than the calculated dew point temperature. The surface temperature of
the insulation system can be significantly altered by changing the emissivity of the
jacket. Using a jacket material with an emissivity close to 1 raises the temperature of the
jacket surface and reduces the thickness of insulation required. 3E Plus can be used to
calculate the effect of emissivity on surface temperature. If making condensation control
calculations, it is important to include an accurate wind speed because the required
thickness for condensation control goes up as wind speed drops. An under estimate of
wind speed can result in excessive thickness and an over estimate can result in unwanted
condensation on the jacket surface.
8.2.4 Process stability requirements are also project specific. 3E Plus can calculate heat loss or
heat gain for user-specified operating conditions. The allowable amount of heat loss or
gain depends upon the process and should be determined for the specific project in
consultation with the process designer.
9. Type Codes
9.1 General
9.1.1 Insulation type codes should be used on P&IDs, data sheets, piping isometrics, and other
project documents.
9.1.2 Insulation type codes consist of up to four characters. The first two characters are
defined in this Practice. The second two characters can be used to define additional
requirements such as combination systems or special requirements.
--````,``,`,,,``````,,``,,``,,`-`-`,,`,,`,`,,`---
9.2.4.3 Design of prevention from freezing insulation should be based on local climatic
conditions.
9.2.4.4 Prevention from freezing insulation can be combined with other types of insulation.
9.4 Insulation Types for Traced and Energy Transfer Jacketed Systems
9.4.1 General Considerations
9.4.1.1 The primary consideration for using tracing or heat transfer jacketing and
associated insulation should be control of process temperatures.
9.4.1.2 Design of insulation should be based on the operating temperature, heat transfer
jacketing temperature, or the tracer temperature. The same insulation thickness
as that for heat conservation (HC) or cold service (CC), as appropriate, should be
used unless design optimization dictates a different thickness.
9.4.1.3 Optimization of the tracer or heat transfer jacketing design and insulation
thickness should be required if specified.
9.4.1.4 Oversize insulation should be considered to accommodate tracer(s) or heat
transfer jacketing.
9.4.1.5 Unless otherwise specified by the purchaser, grooving of insulation to
accommodate tracing is not recommended.
9.4.2 ET – Electric Traced
Electric tracing and associated insulation should be designated with the code ET.
9.4.3 ST – Steam Traced
Steam tracing and associated insulation should be designated with the code ST.
9.4.4 SJ – Steam Jacketed
Steam jacketing and associated insulation should be designated with the code SJ.
9.4.5 HT – Hot Fluid Traced
Hot fluid tracing (except steam) and associated insulation should be designated with the
code HT.
9.4.6 HJ – Hot Fluid Jacketed
Hot fluid jacketing and associated insulation should be designated with the code HJ.
--````,``,`,,,``````,,``,,``,,`-`-`,,`,,`,`,,`---
PARAMETERS
INEG1000-D003 YES NO COLD SERVICE INSULATION DESIGN
PARAMETERS
NOTES:
--````,``,`,,,``````,,``,,``,,`-`-`,,`,,`,`,,`---
Annual fuel inflation rate %
Physical plant annual operating hours hr/year
Physical plant depreciation period years
New insulation depreciation period years
First year cost of energy (Natural Gas) $/Mm³ $/Mft³
Heating value J/m³ Btu/ft³
First year cost of energy ( ) ( )
Heating value ( )
Design factor for thermal conductivity
Design factor for piping complexity simple complex
Productivity factor
Insulation installation labor rate $/hr
Pipe Insulation Block Insulation
DN 50 x 50 mm 50 mm
Insulation material cost NPS 2 x 2 in. 2 in.
$/m $/ft $/m²
$/m $/ft $/m²
$/m $/ft $/m²
$/m $/ft $/m²
NOTES:
NOTES:
--````,``,`,,,``````,,``,,``,,`-`-`,,`,,`,`,,`---