Chapter 1 The Problem and Its Scope Research 1
Chapter 1 The Problem and Its Scope Research 1
A Research Paper
Presented to the College of Education
of Foundation University
By
Niña Amato
January 2020
STUDENTS’ READING COMPREHENSION SKILLS AND ORAL READING PERFORMANCE
2
Chapter 1
Introduction
Reading is the fountainhead of all pedagogical skills; it is one of the copious fundamental
skills somebody should learn; it is a diverse practice. Thus, teaching it in separation from other
disciplines is impossible. Additionally, reading is not solely the skill to be familiar with written
or printed words but expressing a consolidated understanding of what you have read; also, it
pertains to providing meaning to what you read (Snow, 2002). Further, it is a major pillar upon
which the teaching/learning process is built. The reading ability plays a central role in the
teaching/learning success at all educational stages. Ozdemir (2009) stressed that reading is
important in getting knowledge as all the lessons and learning activities are mostly based on the
In addition, Ono (2004) highlight that reading can help English language learners become
better readers, and make improvements in other aspects of their English skills. Based on the
study of Scott (2010) and Luckner & Handley (2008) reading is the cornerstone of instruction for
all learners regardless of their level and ability to do such, because this serves as a strong
Further, reading with comprehension influences the learner’s education and his entire life
instrument on hand. Likewise, a learner who cannot read comprehensively finds it difficult for
him or her to be successful in his or her education. Reading comprehension—is one of the
Al- Khateeb (2010) affirmed that reading comprehension is the essence of the whole reading
process, which contains all other methods; to some researchers, it is the final objective of the
reading process because he who does not understand what he read is as if he has not read at all.
As claimed by Alcantara, et.al (1996) many students bear the accuracy in recognizing,
hearing, identifying, and manipulate individual sounds spoken words (phonemic awareness), but
few were able to comprehend—that is the process of simultaneously extracting and constructing
meaning through interaction and involvement with written language. It is also found that students
lack the specific reading strategies to generate inferences that aid in the understanding of various
text presented (Best, Rowie, Ozura, & McNamara, 2005). The National Statistics Office’s 2010
Census of Population and Housing (CPH), the results gained showed that of the 71.5 million
Filipinos who are 10 years and above, 97.5% or 69.8 million were literate or could read and
write. Additionally, on the study of Edutopia (2015), the National Achievement Test (NAT) in
2012 proved that students got a mean percentage score (MPS) of 54.42% in English reading
comprehension, which revealed that Filipino children are generally regarded as average readers.
But, on a recent survey made by the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development
(OECD), among 79 participating countries and economies, the Philippines scored the lowest in
reading comprehension in the 2018 Programme for International Student Assessment (PISA)
which was 340 points, more than 200 points below China (555) and more than 100 points less
Concerning this, the Department of Education (DepEd) supports the Every Child a
Reader Program (ECARP), which aims to make every Filipino child a reader and a writer at his
or her grade level. Thus, DepEd through the Bureau of Learning Delivery-Teaching and
STUDENTS’ READING COMPREHENSION SKILLS AND ORAL READING PERFORMANCE
4
Learning Division (BLD-TLD) shall continue to administer the Revised Philippine Informal
effective School Year 2018-2019. Meanwhile, the Oral Reading Verification (ORV) in
secondary schools is conducted quarterly to measure and describe the learners’ reading
performance in both English and Filipino languages in oral reading and comprehension. These
types of assessments aim to determine the learner’s independent, instructional, and frustration
levels. The data consolidated shall also serve as one of the bases in planning, designing, or
redesigning the reading instruction of the teachers and the school’s reading programs or activities
The researchers took interest to fill the gap and to delve deeper into finding the
correlation between the students’ reading comprehension skills and their oral reading verification
performance in English based on the above details. It is, therefore, the desire of the researchers to
provide sufficient data regarding the matter to pave the way for further strengthening of the
reading scheme in schools and to give beneficial results to the academic institutions in the
country.
This study is anchored on six major theories: a) Schema Theory by Frederic Bartlett
(1932); b) Bottom-Up Theory by Dr. Ray Reutzel and Robert Cooter, Jr. (1996); c) Top-Down
Theory (Reutzel & Cooter, 1996); d) Social Cognitive Theory by Albert Bandura (1986); and e)
Self-efficacy Theory by Albert Bandura (1986). The researchers found that these theories bear a
Bottom-Up Theory
This theory has drawn its origin from the stimulus-response chains known as
behaviorism. When placed in the context of the reading process, the stimuli for reading are the
prints or texts on the pages of the book. When the readers initiated the reading activity starting
off with the simplest letters of the alphabet, they later on start to utter the more complex elements
of language which are words, sentences, and paragraphs until they are able to finish the entire
activity and started to draw meaning and understanding on the text they just read. Further, this
theory implies that reading begins with the simplest letters up to the most complex paragraphs
until the readers were able to accomplish comprehension starting with the most tedious ways
until they attain mastery. Today, the main method associated with the bottom-up approach to
reading is known as phonics, which requires the learner to match letters with sounds in a defined
sequence.
Top-Down Theory
This theory emphasizes the importance of meaningful learning which occurs when new
information is presented in a relevant context and is related to what the learner already knows so
that it can be easily integrated into one’s existing cognitive structure. This theory have seen
reading as a complex information processing skill which the reader acts as the active, decision-
making individual who paves the way to facilitating comprehension towards effective reading
based on what he or she already knows. As this complex process begin, the reader starts
confirming, reflecting or refining, and predicting meanings based on his or her experiential
background.
STUDENTS’ READING COMPREHENSION SKILLS AND ORAL READING PERFORMANCE
6
Schema Theory
The idea of schema theory, one of the cognitivist learning theories, was primarily
introduced in 1932 by the work of British psychologist Sir Frederic Bartlett (some suggest it was
first introduced in 1926 by Jean Piaget) and was further developed mostly in the 1970s by
American educational psychologist Richard Anderson. The term "schema" was first used in
According to this theory, reading comprehension has a two-way relationship between the
reader's background knowledge and the text itself because that background may help the reader
relate to things for the reason of knowing something related to it beforehand. Further, the
fundamental principle of schema theory implies that written text does not bear meaning by itself,
but it only serves as a guide for the readers as to how they would give their interpretation of the
text exercising their prior learning (An, 2013). Schema theory links to reading comprehension
because it helps second language learning since obtaining a second language involves a lot of
reading.
Additionally, when the reader fails to spur adequate schema when reading a text, it may
result in poor comprehension. Linguists have an influx of several methods in overcoming the
issue, which includes providing the students with texts to read in their first language, which later
on, they will learn reading in their second language to assess the positive or negative result that it
brought to the reader. Lately, the Mother Tongue- Based Multilingual Education had introduced
2013.
STUDENTS’ READING COMPREHENSION SKILLS AND ORAL READING PERFORMANCE
7
Social Cognitive Theory (SCT) commenced as the Social Learning Theory (SLT) in the
1960s by Albert Bandura. Later, it was developed into SCT in 1986 and postulates that learning
transpires in a social context with a progressive and correlative interaction between the person,
its environment, and behavior. This theory talks about how people’s behavior is shaped by his or
her society emphasizing the external and internal reinforcement. Moreover, this claims that a
person’s behavior is also influenced by his or her past experiences. These factors can be
Thus, this theory has a direct bearing in this study in a sense that teachers and parents
play a vital and active role in helping the students learn how to read and comprehend since the
very first day of school. The former may be the sources of knowledge that the students lean unto
when they began their first reading activity. If the latter learned from the teachings of their
parents and teachers, then probably an effective and promising behavior or outcome towards
reading and comprehension can be expected depending on the students’ pace or behavior in
learning.
Self-efficacy Theory
This theory by Bandura (1986), tackles about the impact that self-efficacy—the
confidence, the ability to design and perform a course of action, to fulfil a task, or to solve and
Moreover, self-efficacy is a personal belief in one’s qualifications. And student’s with high self-
efficacy show the exact self-evaluation in terms of their academic achievement which includes
STUDENTS’ READING COMPREHENSION SKILLS AND ORAL READING PERFORMANCE
8
reading and comprehension. Therefore, their own beliefs about their ability to read and
determining chances for success in whichever activity a person might participate into. To suffice
that claim, psychologists rate self-efficacy higher than talent in the factors that influences a
person’s chances of success. In relation to this, students must pay critical attention to self-
efficacy when they set goals such as fluency in reading and comprehension, so that this factor
should fall in line with their aims to settle with a positive outcome.
uplifting someone to a better level. In fact, the study of Dornyei (2007) postulates that people
who have low self-efficacy interprets difficult tasks in life as threats rather than viewing it as
challenges. Thus, people with that kind of mind set settles more in their personal obstacles and
deficiencies rather than on how to overcome and perform these tasks successfully. And as a
In the academic context, the study of Klomegah (2007) claims that among the factors
affecting academic successes self-efficacy ranks the strongest. It also plays a significant role
towards students’ participation inside the classroom; when the need arises, students with higher
self-efficacy have been reported to manifest high help-seeking behavior compared to students
with low self-efficacy. Thus, students with high self-efficacy tend to have more chances of
This section cites the existing literature and studies which bears significant relevance to
this study.
complex skill that requires mastery among students because the entire learning process would
not be successful without the embodiment of reading in it. Reading can be a very complex and
dynamic process (Gildrie, 2005). It is complicated because of the knowledge base it utilizes, and
the mental activities it employs. According to Nunan (2003), reading is a smooth process of
readers linking information from texts and their background knowledge to construct meaning.
Mikulecky (2011) says that reading is a complex conscious and unconscious mental process in
which the reader uses a variety of strategies to reconstruct the meaning that the author is assumed
to have proposed, based on data from the text and the reader's prior knowledge. Thus, a
meaningful experience is possible between the reader and the book itself since the activity
involves a two-way process. Additionally, the reading process continually involves guessing,
predicting, checking, and asking oneself questions related to the text the readers have read.
Hudson (2007) as cited in the study of Abbott (2012) emphasized the taxonomy of reading skills
that each student must improve; these skills include recognizing the script of language,
insinuating the meanings and use of words that are unknown to the readers, understanding
explicit information from the text, and the understanding of the connection among parts of a text
through grammatical cohesion devices that include the skills and knowledge to understand how
phonemes and speech sounds are connected to print. Lastly, reading comprises two related
processes: word recognition and comprehension. Word recognition, refers to the process of
perceiving how written symbols correspond to one’s spoken language; comprehension is the
STUDENTS’ READING COMPREHENSION SKILLS AND ORAL READING PERFORMANCE
10
process of making sense of words, sentences, and related text. Readers are more likely to make
use of their background knowledge, vocabulary, grammatical knowledge, and experience with
text combined with other approaches to help them understand the written text better.
Reading Comprehension. Pretorious (2000) contends that decoding skill does not
significantly lead to obtaining an overall comprehension of what the text expresses. Several
readers can decode texts but are incapable of finding meaning in the printed word. Thus, based
on comprehension, one can begin to differentiate between a good reader and a poor reader. A
reader who has excellent decoding skills but has poor comprehension skills is still rated as a poor
reader because he or she is unable to find meaning in what he or she has read.
developmental models or representations of meanings from the texts' ideas during the reading
process, which others think are the best strategies to attain understanding. Reading
intuitive and strategic cognitive processes that enables the reader to create a mental
representation of the text for better understanding (Van den Broek & Espin, 2012). The reader is
obliged to attach meaning to what he is reading; he will do this mainly as a function of his
experience, context, knowledge, and language proficiency (Texas Educational Agency, 2002).
With the lack of adequate comprehension, reading is a pointless exercise in word calling. It is not
an overstatement to argue that how well a student mastered reading, affects their lives since
reading serves as the foundation of everything from the very least ones up to the most complex
elements of language. Based on the study made by Morrow (2003), reading is not only a skill to
be mastered but also plays a vital tool for further learning. In agreement, Izizinga (2000), states
that children with adequate reading comprehension skills can learn other subjects with
STUDENTS’ READING COMPREHENSION SKILLS AND ORAL READING PERFORMANCE
11
efficiency. Furthermore, learners use the ideas that they gained from texts to meet particular
needs in particular situations; comprehension gives the ability to utilize the information achieved
through reading into different situations, which can be quite beneficial notably in the field of
academics ((Frankel, Pearson, & Nair, 2011). In other words, comprehension gives learners the
ability to apply the information they have accomplished by reading to diverse situations.
according to different reading resources. In the book entitled “Effective Study and Thinking
Skills” of Belen et.al. (2003), the four levels of comprehension are literal, interpretative, applied,
The literal level yields knowledge of what the writer stated in his text. The students
decode the words, learn what each word means in a given context, and understand that there are
associations among words that express what the author has penned. In this level, the students
should recognize the essential information and follow simple instructions; they should form ideas
or meanings stated in the selection. These ideas are elicited by questions beginning with what,
The interpretive level or reading between the lines applies to what the author has said to
derive, infer, and imply meaning from a statement or text. Students look into relationships
among statements within the material they have read; learners should discern the implications of
the events by inference and conform ideas or meanings indirectly or implicitly stated in the
selection. In this level, how and why questions call for students' reasoning, implications,
The critical or evaluative level refers to reading beyond the lines. The students give
their reaction, judgment, and evaluation of what is written by the author; this involves how they
can recognize the literal meaning of words from opinions or purposes expressed upon reading.
Further, it calls for the reader's judgment on the wisdom, validity, or appropriateness of one's
The application or creative level is the most exceptional level of comprehension, for it
needs the use and utilization of efficient intellectual exercise. This level develops the readers'
ability to profit from the vicarious experiences attained by reading. Also, it allows the reader to
create new concepts and ways of expressing the pieces of knowledge they got from the text on
their own. Thus, teachers can evaluate the achievement and effectivity of the reading process.
Elementary School” by Tizon (2012) found out that more than the majority of the Grade VI
pupils were average in their overall level of reading comprehension ability. Specifically, more of
the pupils had an average literal ability; however, their higher level of comprehension was very
low as reflected in their lowest creative ability; also, the pupils had lower interpretive and
evaluative skills. Thus, the highest level of comprehension needs enhancement. It is then
recommended that teachers must use effective methodologies, strategies, and activities that will
develop their pupils' reading ability most especially their higher comprehension skills.
Lasaten and Racca (2016) also conducted an action research which strived to identify the
English Language Proficiency and Academic Performance of Philippine Science High School
Students. The study reveals that the students’ academic performance in Science and Mathematics
falls under a very good level while at a good level in English. Likewise, the study concludes that
STUDENTS’ READING COMPREHENSION SKILLS AND ORAL READING PERFORMANCE
13
there is a significant correlation between the students' English language proficiency and their
academic performance in each of the subjects. The higher the English language proficiency
levels of the students are the higher their academic performance levels in Science, Mathematics,
and English. Hence, the study further stresses that students’ English language proficiency could
since, the medium of instruction used in the teaching of these subjects is English and therefore,
Romero (2014) disclosed in his study entitled, "Improving the Reading Comprehension
Skills of Grade 7 Students of Sta. Josefa National High School through Enhancing Reading
Comprehension Skills (EReCoS) Activities" that the reading comprehension skills of the
participants had improved from the frustration level to zero frustration. The three identified least
mastered competencies include identifying the main idea, vocabulary development and making
inferences after employing the EReCoS. These are reading materials, which are consist of
diverse activities namely, simple identification, guided identification, word box, context clues,
reading between the lines, and valid or invalid that helped address the identified least mastered
Bayugan City Division" that there exists a notable difference in the students’ exposure to reading
materials; it serves as a factor to the students’ reading proficiency level. Further, the study found
a significant distinction in the status of the implementation of the reading program on the reading
proficiency level of the students. Meanwhile, the study of Aton (2014) entitled "Improving the
through Reading Intervention Program" also showed that the implementation of an intervention
STUDENTS’ READING COMPREHENSION SKILLS AND ORAL READING PERFORMANCE
14
program would give a good result and reasonable progress on the student’s reading level.
Likewise, in the study made by Marcon (2014) entitled "Reading Proficiency of First-year
students of Philsaga High School Foundation, Inc.: Basis for Developing Reading Intervention
Program," she highlighted that reading teachers or language teachers should consider the type of
materials used in the reading sessions or reading subjects. Thus, they recommended the teachers
to continue the assessment of the pupil’s reading abilities in all grade levels to determine the
performance of the pupils and the enhancement of the reading skills of the pupils are vital to
their success.
The literature and studies mentioned above supports on the importance of determining the
students’ reading comprehension skills and oral reading verification performance to give
recommendations that would fit to whatever results this study may gain.
STUDENTS’ READING COMPREHENSION SKILLS AND ORAL READING PERFORMANCE
15
Below is a schematic model of the study. The framework shows the relationship between
students’ reading comprehension skills and their oral reading verification performance.
Dependent Variable
Independent;
Age Instructional;
Frustration; and
Sex
Non-Reader
Parent’s Educational
Attainment
Figure 1. Relationship between Students’ Reading Comprehension Skills and their Oral Reading
Verification Performance
The study sought to find out the relationship between students’ reading comprehension skills and
their oral reading verification (ORV) performance in English. Specifically, the researchers aimed
1. What is the students’ ORV performance in English during the S.Y. 2019-2020?
STUDENTS’ READING COMPREHENSION SKILLS AND ORAL READING PERFORMANCE
16
2. What is their level of reading comprehension skills during the S.Y. 2019-2020?
3. To what extent does students’ reading comprehension skills affect their oral reading
4. Is there a direct correlation of the students’ reading comprehension skills towards their
5. Is there a significant relationship between reading comprehension skills and oral reading
5.1 age;
Students. This will provide grappling readers with a chance to overcome reading
challenges, for they will be the recipient of any reading intervention program after they were
determined to be settling in the frustration level. The students will also concentrate on any of the
reading skills recognized as weak among them. Thus, they (students) may able to perform well in
English teachers. Determining the students' proficiency level and oral reading
verification performance will aid the teachers in utilizing the designed intervention program for
the learners. Through this, the teachers will achieve their goals in heightening the frustration
School administrators. The results of this study could provide important concepts that
could be useful in addressing issues on students’ reading comprehension skills and oral reading
Material developers. The findings and outcomes of this study may suggest the
development of relevant reading materials as an aid in conducting the reading instruction to help
Future researchers. The study can be a beneficial source for further studies on the
reading comprehension skills and oral reading verification performance of the students. Other
researchers who wish to undertake a similar study for development may find this as a suitable
Scope of the study. This research is focused on the identification of the student’s age,
sex, parent’s educational attainment, and their reading comprehension skills and how these
variables correlate to their oral reading verification performance during the S.Y. 2019-2020
The respondents of this study were from the Grade 7 Simplicity of Foundation Preparatory
Limitation of the study. This study is only limited to the interpretation of data gathered
and treated from the ORV results of the respondents and the identification of their reading
comprehension skills.
STUDENTS’ READING COMPREHENSION SKILLS AND ORAL READING PERFORMANCE
18
Research Methodology
Research Design. This research study made use of the descriptive-correlational method
since it is focused in determining the student’s selected profile, their reading comprehension
one of the private schools located in the city of Dumaguete. The said institution is located at Dr.
Research Respondents. The respondents of this research study were the thirty (30)
students of Grade 7 Simplicity in Foundation Preparatory Academy. Twelve (12) of which were
Research Instruments. The researchers made use of the oral reading verification tool—
particularly a reading passage composed of 7 comprehension questions that the students must
answer after reading the story and a table for marking and scoring the oral miscues committed by
the reader. The mechanics in administering the ORV test will be followed in order to come up
with an accurate baseline data. The materials are designed to measure the oral reading
non-reader.
Data-Gathering Procedure. After the design hearing, the researchers integrated all the
necessary corrections and suggestions made by the panel members. Subsequently, a letter request
to conduct the study was sent to the school principal of Foundation Preparatory Academy. Upon
approval, the request was then presented to the adviser of the section and the respondents to
STUDENTS’ READING COMPREHENSION SKILLS AND ORAL READING PERFORMANCE
19
formally start the conduct of the ORV where the researchers primarily took part aided by the
respondents’ adviser. The results were handed to an expert statistician for the treatment of data.
Reading Comprehension Skills. These are the skills of the students’ in reading that the
Oral Reading Verification Performance Level. These refer to the reading ability of the
slow reader, good comprehension. Or students read fluently with little or no comprehension; fast
Non-Reader Level. Students in this level cannot read; students are syllabic
readers.
Oral Reading Verification Performance. These are the performances of students in the
Oral Reading Verification Tool. This is the tool used by the researchers in determining
References
Abbot, M. (2012) What makes reading difficult for ESL students? Strategies for struggling
reader. Retrieved from
www.org.uk/Resource/NALDIC/Professional.20Developmental/DocumentINCAbbot.pdf
Al Khateeb, O. (2010). The impact of using KWL strategy on grade ten female students'
reading comprehension of religious concepts in Ma'an city. Retrieved from World
Wide Web http://www.eurojournals.com/ejss_12_3_14.pdf
Alcantara, R.D. et. al. (1996). Reading strategies for the teaching of communication arts:
Listening, speaking, reading, and writing. Quezon City: Katha Publishing Co. Inc.
Aton, M.C.C. (2014). Improving the reading proficiency of grade 7 students of Philsaga High
School Foundation Incorporated through reading intervention program. (Unpublished
master’s thesis). PNU-Mindanao.
Belen, V. et.al. (2003). Effective study and thinking skills. Trinitas Publishing Inc.
Dornyei, Z. (2007). Research methods in Applied Linguistics. Oxford: Ooxford University Press.
Edutopia (2015). The reading profile of children in the Philippines. Retrieved from
https://www.edutopia.org
Frankel, K.F., Pearson, D.P., & Nair, M. (2011). Reading comprehension and reading
disability. In A. McGill-Franzen & R. L. Allington (Eds.) Handbook of reading disability
STUDENTS’ READING COMPREHENSION SKILLS AND ORAL READING PERFORMANCE
21
Hudson, T. (2007). Teaching second language reading. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Izizinga, R. (2000). The teaching of reading in Uganda. In K. Parry (Ed.) Language and
literacy in Uganda: Towards a sustainable reading culture. Kampala: Fountain
Publishers.
Lasaten, R.C.., & Racca, R.M.A. (2016). English language proficiency and academic
performance of Philippine Science High School students. Retrieved from
http://www.ijlll.org/index.php?m=content&c=index&a=show&catid=42&id=357
Luckner, J.L. & Handley, C. M. (2008). A summary of the reading comprehension research
undertaken with students who are deaf or hard of hearing. American Annals of the Deaf 1,
6–36.
Mikulecky, Beatrrice S. 2011. A short course in teaching reading: Practical technique for
building reading power. United State America: Pearson Longman.
Nelson B., & Ketelhult, D. (2008). Exploring embedded guidance and self-efficacy in
STUDENTS’ READING COMPREHENSION SKILLS AND ORAL READING PERFORMANCE
22
Ono, L., Day, L. & Harsch, C. (2004). Tips for reading extensively. English Teaching Forum.
pp. 12-16.
Ozdemir, A. (2010). The effect of reading comprehension abilities primary school students over
their problem solving achievement. Retrieved from
http://findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_hb6516/is_2_46/ai_n32 067948/
Pretorius, E.l. (2000). lnferem:e generalion in the reading of expository texts by university
students. Pretoria: Dnisa
Romero, V. (2014). Improving the reading comprehension skills of Grade 7 Students of Sta.
Josefa National High School through EReCoS (Enhancing Reading Comprehension
Skills) activities. (Unpublished master’s thesis). PNU – Mindanao.
Scott, C. (2010). Word study instruction: Enhancing reading comprehension, The literacy and
numeracy secretariat. Illinois, Learning Point Associates.
Tizon, M. (2012). Reading comprehension ability of grade 6 pupils of Kinangay Sur Elementary
School. La Salle University –Ozamiz
Van den Broek, P., & Espin, C. A. (2012). Connecting cognitive theory andassessment:
Measuring individual differences in reading comprehen-sion. School Psychology
Review,41, 315–325.