M-Sand in Tamil Nadu
M-Sand in Tamil Nadu
https://doi.org/10.1007/s11356-022-19633-w
TREND EDITORIAL
Received: 26 July 2021 / Accepted: 5 March 2022 / Published online: 24 March 2022
© The Author(s), under exclusive licence to Springer-Verlag GmbH Germany, part of Springer Nature 2022
13
Vol.:(0123456789)
30794 Environmental Science and Pollution Research (2022) 29:30793–30801
13
Environmental Science and Pollution Research (2022) 29:30793–30801 30795
ecosystems (Collins et al. 2015). The various direct and indi- involved in the guidelines are the identification of areas
rect impacts of river sand mining are depicted in Fig. 6. of deposition, where mining is allowed by forbidding the
The abiotic impacts of sand mining are studied by the QSR areas of erosion and proximity to infrastructural structures
approach (Lois Koehnken et al. 2020). This study includes the and installations. Similarly, satellite images are utilized
changes in the channel morphology, alterations in the move- for identifying areas of sand deposit and quantity. Corre-
ment and compositions of sediments, impacts on water qual- spondingly, the annual rate of replenishment and allowing
ity, and the alterations related to the flow regime as depicted time for replenishment after mining in the area is carried
in Fig. 7. A detailed summary of the impacts associated with out. Measures for the protection of ecology and the envi-
sand mining is structured by the QSR approach and is pre- ronment are established for identifying the possible ways
sented in Fig. 8. of scientific and systematic mining. A benchmark (BM)
concerning for the mean sea level (MSL) is fixed for an
essential in-mining channel reach (MCR) and no mining
Guidelines for sustainable sand mining operation at the lower benchmark level (Sustainable Sand
Mining Guidelines 2016, 2018). Also, permanent gaug-
The broad principle for any sustainable sand mining ing facilities are made compulsory for mining the sites
guidelines preserves the natural resources by utilizing through excessive operations. The most established unit of
it for the present and future generations. The initial step administration is carried out by the district for an effective
involved in managing the river resource depends on the planning and monitoring. It is suggested that every district
preparation of the district survey report. These processes prepares this document by taking an account of the river
13
30796 Environmental Science and Pollution Research (2022) 29:30793–30801
stretch in that district as an ecological unit. Besides, the sustainable development policy for the protection of ecology
production of aggregate in a particular area is a function and the environment. Sustainable development is designed
of the availability of natural resources, the economy of on the three pillars, which include economic, social, and
the area, and the size of the population. Also, the various environmental. Sustainable development in any part of the
developmental and infrastructural projects are undertaken country will not achieve it, if the environment protects the
in that particular area and protection of bank erosion. The people below the poverty line. Similarly, the sustainable
Malaysian Sand Mining Guidelines DID 2009 have given development cannot be achieved through an inappropri-
setbacks for sand mining from river systems, which is ate economic growth. These guidelines support promoting
depicted in Fig. 9. environmental protection, elementary concept, physiologi-
cal, limiting negative hydrological and social impacts lead-
ing to sustainable economic development. At the district
The sustainable sand mining management level, these factors are accounted for in the most efficient
plan manner. The sustainable mining management plan needs
to be dynamic. A survey has been carried out by the Dis-
The available natural resources are utilized in an efficient trict Environment Impact Assessment Authority (DEIAA)
and environmentally friendly manner in a scientific and sys- with the assistance of other departments in the district at
tematic way. It focuses with an objective focusing on the regular intervals. This sand mining process is permitted by
Fig. 7 Summary of impacts associated with sand mining identified by the QSR approach (Lois Koehnken Max et al. 2020)
13
Environmental Science and Pollution Research (2022) 29:30793–30801 30797
Fig. 8 Details of the papers are included in the review by the QSR approach (Lois Koehnken Max et al. 2020)
depending on the measured annual replenishment volume. replenishment study is well understood, the assessments are
So, an absolute elevation is maintained below without any not undertaken presently at the state level. The guidelines
extraction, and this extraction on the river bed methods is prescribed in “Enforcement & Monitoring Guidelines for
limited to bar skimming. This mining is initiated from the sand mining (MoEFCC 2020)” emphasize the methodology
downstream portion of the bar, and it is only allowed dur- adopted for the replenishment study. Correspondingly, an
ing dry seasons. So, this plan should include a long-term adequate amount of sand replenishes, and then, excavation
monitoring program along with a record of the annual status. is limited in that area. The district survey report (2019) for
sand in Vellar River Perambalur District, Tamil Nadu, rec-
ommends 261 million metric tonne (MMT) mineable sand
Demand–supply assessment at an annual replenishment rate of 7.25 MMT. This annual
replenishment volume of sand for various rivers across
A gap assessment is performed by the State for analyzing Tamil Nadu is studied from the district survey report of that
the demand–supply situation and, accordingly, the rules/ particular district. The Public Works Department (PWD) of
regulations and policies are framed by the State. Annual Tamil Nadu has estimated the demand for the sand as 53.71
replenishment study is carried out across Tamil Nadu in all million tonne per annum (MTPA). In the year 2016–2017,
districts as per the district survey report (DSR), which is the total supply of sand is 18.36 metric tonne (MT) with
prescribed in the Sustainable Sand Mining Guidelines by 15.12 MT from river sand and 3.24 MT from M-sand (Sand
the Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change Mining Framework Government of India 2018). The defi-
(MoEFCC 2018). Since the need for undertaking the annual cit in the State is estimated at 35.56 MT, and to meet this
13
30798 Environmental Science and Pollution Research (2022) 29:30793–30801
deficit, the Public Works Department (PWD) has issued the broadly utilized across the globe and specialists from all over
circular by instructing its officials to use manufactured sand the world. It has become mandatory for utilizing the M-sand
in government projects as an alternative to river sand. On owing to its consistent gradation and zero contamination.
average, there is a demand for 25,000 loads of M-sand daily Consistently, Karnataka gathers around 9 million tonnes per
across Tamil Nadu. In this regard, the government has per- year of sand, out of which a major share is sourced from
mitted 358 M-sand manufacturing units to push the State riverbed mining. The Center for Study of Science, Technol-
for M-sand to meet the demand–supply gap. This transition ogy, and Policy (CSTEP) has led an examination to assess
enables the sustainable use of sand to manufacture it in the the present interest for sand in Karnataka. It is reported that
future. it has produced 26 million tonnes per year in 2014 and this is
The scarcity of river sand forces the builders to look for expected to increase to 56–81 million tonnes for each year by
an alternative material and many have started using manu- 2030. This appeal has prompted a look through an elective
factured sand as a substitute for construction activity. The material, for example, M-sand with a specific end goal to
necessity for the use of manufactured sand increases with take care of the demand. Furthermore, the State Government
the river sand supply dropping by over 80%. In India, Tamil of Karnataka has made it obligatory for the Public Works
Nadu occupies the second longest sandy beach area covering Department (PWD) to utilize M-sand for the development of
about 1.076 km (670 miles). To mention in particular, the structures, bridges, and different works in September 2013.
Palar, Vaigai, and Cauvery River basins have been subjected Consistently, 47 and 59 billion tonnes of development
to illegal sand mining continuously. In Tamil Nadu, each material are mined all-inclusive (Steinberger et al. 2010),
measuring 200 cubic feet of sand is mined approximately out of which, the speediest and the biggest extraction share
every day between 5500 and 6000 truckloads (SibiArasu (68 to 85%) is for fine aggregate (sand) and (32 to 50%) is for
2017). Continuous extraction of river sand has a huge impact coarse aggregate (Krausmann et al. 2009). In a roundabout
on the river beds, which has resulted in a decrease in the way, the worldwide utilization of aggregates is evaluated
amount of sediment supply and lowering of the water table. through the generation of cement for concrete, as concrete is
The Kerala government is reportedly the first State to start made of cement, sand, gravel, and water. In 2012, 3.7 billion
using M-sand extensively for construction. It has started tonnes of cement is generated by 150 nations (US Geologi-
popularizing the M-sand in 2004 after facing an acute short- cal Survey. 2013a). Also, the construction industry requires
age of natural sand. On the other hand, the accessibility of around six to seven times more huge amounts of sand and
manufactured sand is troublesome except in Kerala and in a gravel for every tonne of cement and the world utilization
few sections of Southern and Western India. It has a demand of aggregates surpasses 40 billion tonnes per year (US Geo-
of 50,000 tonnes of M-sand per day, but the manufacturers logical Survey. 2013b). One approach to reduce the usage of
do only 25,000 tonnes. So, it has mooted the idea of desilting sand is to enhance the utilization of existing structures and
reservoirs to quarry sand without causing ecological dam- foundations. Reused construction materials and quarry dust
age to rivers. Also, there is a broad consensus on the need to are the substitute for river sand.
desilt dams, as it has yielded not only sand but also clay for An investigation is led by the Indian Institute of Science
the brick and tile industry. According to reports, M-sand is (IISc), Government of Karnataka, on the appropriateness of
13
Environmental Science and Pollution Research (2022) 29:30793–30801 30799
M-sand as a fine aggregate. This examination details that the requires 200 million tonnes of aggregates every year for their
physical qualities of M-sand are like river sand, yet it is con- construction purposes. This demand for sand in the State of
trasted with it. This M-sand substituted concrete has a higher India stood for 24 million tonnes a year, against the supply
compressive strength of 6–9% and higher flexure strength of of 14 million tonnes (Nagesh Prabhu. 2015). The location of
12–15%. Also, the specialized examination has demonstrated licensed sand pits in remote areas has led to high transpor-
that manufactured sand is utilized as another option to river tation costs. This low-value by-product obtained from rock
sand. As of late, the Karnataka State Cabinet has chosen to crushers is effectively and efficiently used in the production
give 5% sponsorship on enthusiasm to set up the manufactured of high-value products in the construction industry.
sand units in areas that need normal sand assets, as announced
in The Hindu. Keeping in mind the end goal to make a request,
the State Government of Karnataka has additionally energized
the utilization of produced sand in all government ventures. Advantages of using manufactured sand
Today, the Bangalore Airport and the Bangalore Metro are in concrete
the portion of the real tasks that have used this manufactured
sand. Owing to the shortage of naturally available river sand, The particles are cubical with definite and consistent particle
M-sand has emerged as a sustainable alternative for the con- size distribution, and the fine content is generally higher than
struction industry. Manufactured sand is used as an alterna- natural sand. This surface texture of the particles is rough and
tive construction material thereby reducing the demand and has higher crushing strength. This particle size distribution
dependence on naturally occurring sand. is thick, and the surfaces are less weathered than the normal
According to reports, M-sand is broadly utilized across sand. M-sand created from hard rock has the lower difference
the globe and specialists from all over the world. The in mineralogy. There are no organic impurities in M-sand,
demand is mandatory for the utilization of M-sand, owing and the presence of silt is less than 3% by weight, and this
to its consistent gradation and zero contamination. The tran- M-sand has a consistent gradation. It is produced by con-
sition to manufactured sand enables the future sustainable forming to zone II grading as per IS 383 (1970). This has per-
use of sand. fect grading and is angular in shape, which in turn increases
the compressive strength by 10–15%. It has also consistently
graded with greater precession by constantly removing the
Manufactured sand, a solution, and a viable micro fines, and hence, it has a higher “fineness module
alternative to river sand index” than the natural sand. M-sand is more cost-effective
than the river sand, since it is produced in areas very close to
The growing demand for the fine aggregate in the construc- the construction site thereby reducing the cost of transpor-
tion industry has driven our attention to the use of manu- tation. This manufactured sand is used in compliance with
factured sand. Besides, the global scarcity of natural sand the new European Standards, as per EN 13, 139 (2006). The
and the remote location of sandpits has led to the use of Cement Concrete and Aggregates Australia (CCAA) has car-
manufactured sand. There are various factors that have ried out extensive research and has developed the guidelines
driven us towards the production of M-sand such as global to support the replacement of natural sand with manufactured
scarcity for river sand, growing demand for fine aggregate, sand. This M-sand produced from hard rock has consistent
the remote location of sandpits, and the presence of impu- particle size distribution, and it is more cost-effective than
rities like silt and clay in natural sand. This depletion of river sand. Besides, it is produced in areas very close to the
natural sand is due to continuous sand mining of the river construction site thereby reducing the cost of transportation.
sand globally, which has led to the use of manufactured sand Table 1 shows the number of impurities present in river
as an alternative. The International Center for Aggregates sand. This river sand contains 5 to 20% of clay and silt, 2 to
Research (ICAR) has given the promising results on the use 4% of marine products, and 6 to 10% of oversized materials,
of manufactured micro fines up to 17% in concrete. Hence, whereas manufactured sand is free from these impurities.
sand dredging is heavily taxed, and it is banned almost now Table 1 Comparison of impurities in river sand and M-sand (Aswath
in Tamil Nadu. Now, the river sand is available on the river 2015)
beds, which contains about 5 to 20% silt and clay impurities
SI. no Impurities present River sand Manu-
(Fate 2014). The presence of even minor quantities of silt factured
and clay impurities affects the strength, and it damages the sand
screed and concrete (Sreenivasa.G. 2012). Hence, the river
1 Clay and silt 5 to 20% Nil
sand is processed well before use to bring the impurities to
2 Marine products 2 to 4% Nil
the acceptable limit. About 65 to 80% of the concrete mix
3 Oversized materials 6 to 10% Nil
is composed of sand and aggregates. In the UK alone, it
13
30800 Environmental Science and Pollution Research (2022) 29:30793–30801
Manufactured sand is utilized in many nations such as Nor- Acknowledgements This work was supported by Dr. M.G.R. Educa-
way, South Africa, India, and Australia. In the USA, limestone tional and Research Institute.
and granite record for 86% of the rock; it is used to produce
Author contribution Both the authors equally contributed to the prepa-
manufactured sand, while the rest are from basalt, dolomite, ration of the manuscript.
sandstone, and quartzite (Ahn and Fowler 2001). The molten
igneous rocks have produced about 10 to 30% of quarry fines. Data availability The data and material are available within the
Limestone contains dolomite, and chalk quarries commonly manuscript.
deliver around 20 to 25% of fines, though sandstone quarries
create up to 35% of fines, as given by Manning 2004). Declarations
The aggregates obtained from the Vertical Shaft Impact
(VSI) crushers are more cubical than the other crushers. Ethics approval This is a new work and is submitted to the Environ-
mental Science and Pollution Research. The manuscript is prepared as
This shape of the particles obtained from other jaw crush- per ethical standards.
ers is flaky. So, the crushed aggregate from the VSI crusher Consent to participate Yes
acquires improved particle shape, and it reduces surface Consent for publication Yes
roughness than the other crushers.
Competing interests The authors declare no competing interests.
From the experimental work, it is noticed that legiti-
mately prepared M-sand enhances the strength and dura-
bility characteristics of concrete through better bonding
than the river sand (Vijaya and Senthil Selvan 2015). By References
the year 2050, the global population would reach 9 billion,
and accordingly, the construction activities are expected to Ahn N, Fowler DW (2001) An experimental study on the guidelines
grow with a long-term trend of sand scarcity, which needs for using higher contents of aggregate microfines in Portland
to respond by the construction material industry. By taking cement concrete. International Center for Aggregates Research.
Research Report ICAR 102–1F: The University of Texas at Austin
action now, many research work is related to the strength and Texas A&M University, p 1–435
and corrosion behavior of concrete containing manufactured Aswath MU (2015) “Manufactured sand“. The Master builder, p
sand to address this growing global challenge (Vijaya and 120–126
Senthil Selvan 2018), and it has laid foundations for more Bendixen M, Best J, Hackney C, Iversen LL (2019) Time is running
out for sand. Nat Cell Biol 571:29–31
sustainable use of sand in the future. Brunauer S, Copland LE (1964) The chemistry of concrete. Sci Am
210(4):80–92
CCAA T 60. Guide to the specification and use of manufactured sand
Conclusion in concrete. Cement concrete aggregate Australia. p 1–15
Collins A, Coughlin D, Miller J, Kirk S (2015) The production of quick
scoping reviews and rapid evidence assessments.A how to guide:
• The large-scale mining of river sand below the existing Dept. for Environment Food and Rural Affairs, NERC. Joint water
streambed level has adverse impacts on the existing envi- evidence group
ronment. David Manning (2004) Exploitation and use of quarry fines, miro-final
report. Report No.087/MIST2/DACM/01, MIST project reference:
• It is therefore concluded that the mining of sand should MA/2/4/003: p 1–60
be subjected to a strict regulatory regime and should DID (2009) River sand mining management guidelines. Department
be carried out based on the approved framework of the of Irrigation and Drainage, Ministry of Natural Resources and
mining plan. Also, it should provide rehabilitation and Environment
EN IS 13139 (2006) Guidelines on the use of aggregates for mortar.
reclamation of the mined-out zones in the future. National standard Authority of Ireland
• So far, the inherent deficiencies of natural river sand are Enforcement & monitoring guidelines for sand mining. Ministry of
extensively used for the modification of concrete prop- Environment, Forest and Climate change (MoEFCC 2018 and
erties by incorporating manufactured sand as a partial 2020)
Freedman J, Carline R, Stauffer JR (2013) Gravel dredging alters diver-
replacement for river sand. sity and structure of riverine fish assemblages. Freshwater Bio
• It can also be concluded that the M-sand can be utilized 58:261–274
as an efficient fine aggregate in concrete in order to meet ICAR - International Centre for Aggregate Research 102–1F: an
the global scarcity of river sand in the future. experimental study on the guidelines for using higher contents of
aggregate microfines in Portland cement concrete: The University
• The use of M-sand eliminates the global scarcity of river of Texas at Austin and Texas A&M University p 1–435
sand, and it prevents associated environmental problems Ilangovan R, Mahendran N, Nagamani K (2008) Strength and dura-
such as indiscriminate sand mining and soil erosion, bility properties of concrete containing quarry rock dust as fine
thereby enhancing and contributing to environmental aggregate. ARPN J Eng Appl Sci 3(5):20–26
sustainability.
13
Environmental Science and Pollution Research (2022) 29:30793–30801 30801
Indian Standard IS: 383 (1970 Reaffirmed: 2002) Code of practice: Sustainable Sand Mining Guidelines (2018) Ministry of Environment.
specification for coarse and fine aggregates from natural sources Forest and Climate change. New Delhi
for concrete. Bureau of Indian Standards. New Delhi Swapnil S Fate (2014) Concrete with smart material (manufactured
Kiss T, Balogh M, Fiala K, Sipos G (2018) Morphology of fluvial levee crushed sand)-a review. IOSR Journal of Mechanical and Civil
series along a river under human influence Maros River Hungary. Engineering: pp. 27–29.
Geomorphology 303:309–321 Tillin HM, Houghton AJ, Saunders J E, Drabble R, Hull SC (2011)
Krausmann F, Gingrich S, Eisenmenger N, Erb K-H, Haberl H, Fischer- Direct and indirect impacts of aggregate dredging, marine aggre-
Kowalski M (2009) Growth in global materials use, GDP and gate levy sustainability fund (MALSF). Science Monograph
population during the 20th century. Ecol Econ 68:2696–2705 Series, p 1–41
Koehnken L, Rintoul MS, Goichot M, Tickner D, Loftus A-C, Acre- Torres A, Brandt J, Lear K, Liu J (2017) A looming tragedy of the sand
man MC (2020) Impacts of riverine sand mining on freshwater commons. Science 357:970–971
ecosystems: a review of the scientific evidence and guidance for United States Geological Survey USGS (2013b) Sand and gravel (con-
future research. River Research and Applications. Wiley, p 362– struction) statistics. In: Kelly TD, Matos GR (eds) Historical sta-
370. https://doi.org/10.1002/r ra.3586:pp362-370 tistics for mineral and material commodities in the United States.
Gavriletea MD (2017) Environmental impacts of sand exploitation U.S. Geological Survey Data Series 140. Reston
analysis of sand market. Rev Sustain MDPI 9(7):1118. https:// United States Geological Survey USGS (2013a) Cement, statistics and
doi.org/10.3390/su9071118 information. U.S. Geological Survey, Reston
Prabhu N (2015) State pushes for m-sand to close demand-supply gap. United Nations Environment Programme (UNEP (2019) Rising
Panel to clear applications of those seeking permission to estab- demand for sand calls for resource governance. UNEP, Geneva
lish M-sand units The Hindu, dated November 23, 2015 Vijaya B, SenthilSelvan S (2015) Experimental investigation on the
Padmalal D, Maya K (2014) Sand mining, environmental impacts and strength and durability properties of concrete using manufactured
selected case studies. Springer, Berlin. Germany sand, International Journal of Applied Engineering Research. Int
Sand Mining Framework Government of India, Ministry of Mines- J Appl Eng Res 10(68):109–114
March 2018 Vijaya B, SenthilSelvan S (2018) Corrosion effects on the flexural
SibiArasu (2017) Pursuing riches, miners plunder Tamil Nadu’s river strength behavior of concrete containing manufactured sand.
sand. Retrieved from http://www.circleofblue.org/2017/world/ ARPN J Eng Appl Sci 13(5):1972–1982
pursuing-riches-miners-plunder-tamil-nadus-riversand/ Vijaya B, SenthilSelvan S (2015) Comparative study on the strength
Sreenivasa G (2012) Use of manufactured sand in concrete and con- and durability properties of concrete with manufactured sand.
struction an alternate to river sand. New Building Materials and Indian J Sci Technol 8(36):1–7
Construction World. p 1–16 World Wildlife Fund (2018) Living planet report risk and resilience in
Stebbins M (2006) Can gravel mining and water supply wells co-exist. new era. WWF International, Gland, Switzerland
University of Maine News Reports, Maine, p 8
Steinberger JK, Krausmann F, Eisenmenger N (2010) Global patterns Publisher's note Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to
of materials use: a socioeconomic and geophysical analysis. Ecol jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Econ 69:1148–1158
Sustainable Sand Mining Guidelines (2016) Ministry of Environment.
Forest and Climate change. New Delhi
13