Fire Reviewer
Fire Reviewer
One of the most difficult problems to solve is to determine the cause of Both cause and reason must be established to satisfactorily complete a fire
the fire, since the flames generally consume any evidence of what occurred. This investigation. The "cause" explains the existence of fire, or the WHAT of
is the reason that the cause of most fires cannot be determined without a long investigation; while the "reason" establishes the WHY of the fire and
and careful investigation. investigation. Both are required to correctly classify the fire, and also to provide
guidance in establishing corrective action to preclude a recurrence of the
Firefighters often make snap judgments at the scene as to the cause of a incident.
fire, without an adequate evidence or sufficient investigation on which to base
their decision. Apparently, there is hesitation on the part of the firefighters to The importance of the establishment of a fire cause is the knowledge of the
admit that they do not really know the real cause of the fire, since few fires physical aspects of fire.
(approximately 4% of those reported) are listed as "cause known." Instead, the
fire is attributed to various causes without apparent regard to actual evidence or
to lack of it. Four General Classes of Fire Causes:
Some of the favorite causes listed by firefighters, when they are not 1. Natural Fire - fire caused naturally without human intervention or aid; such as
certain of the actual cause, are faulty wiring, children playing with matches, lightning, spontaneous ignition, mechanical malfunction of equipment.
spontaneous combustion, sparks from stove, burning rubbish, and careless
disposal of smoking materials. 2. Accidental Fire - fire causes where human action is involved directly or
indirectly. i.e.
The very general and indefinite nature of these causes indicates that, in
most cases, they are based on assumptions, rather than on evidence. a) Careless disposal of smoking materials;
b). workers using welding-cutting equipment
In this relation, the material or book will assist you in performing or
conducting investigation to determine the causes and origin of a fire. 3. Arson - fire cause as a result of the willful and criminal action of some persons,
i.e., incendiary fire.
4. Unknown Fire - fires which are not classified as to cause. Evidence kit provides equipment for use in the investigation and for the
preservation of any evidence found at the scene after that evidence has been
Three General Classifications of Fire: photograph in its original location.
1. Innocent fire - e.g. natural and accidental causes • Special clothing such as: coverall, gloves, boots used to protect uniform;
2. Incendiary fire - e.g. arson cases • Flashlight and electric lantern;
3. Unknown fire-e.g. fire of unknown causes. • Measuring tape and small ruler for making measurements;
• Labels (gummed and stringed) used to identify items;
Person/s Responsible to examine and inspect the Fire Scene • New or sterile glass jars with rubber airtight seals used for the collection
(American Settings) of samples;
• Envelopes, boxes, plastic bags, metal cans used for the collection
• Fire Marshall (assorted sizes) used for collection of samples.
• Fire Chief
• Assistant Chief for Technical Service
• Fire Inspector responsible for the specific building Basic Steps in a Fire Scene Examination:
• Senior Fire Officer at the fire scene
• Photographer • Search systematically - make a plan, have in mind what you will look for,
• Utilities Personnel (particularly electrician) the way you will look, and what you will do with each item found and
collected. Be thorough, complete, and orderly
The first four individuals provide technical experience for the investigation. The
Senior Fire Officer from the fire incident is present to explain what was observed • Observe - Use your eyes, ears, nose, and camera if possible to note the
during the fire and to report on the mechanics or what transpire during the conditions. Observe the fire and the spectators.
extinguishment of the fire.
Photographer provides complete coverage, beginning with pictures during the • Take photograph the camera records more details than the naked eye.
firefighting operation; including exterior, interior, special features, circumstances Establish visual reference through numerous photographs. Photograph
each area several times during the various phases of investigation.
and the activities of the investigators at work.
Infrared photography may prove extremely valuable since it is sensitive to
differences in heat.
Utilities personnel provide technical assistance, particularly as to the condition of
electrical circuits and appliances.
• Work by the Process of Elimination establish a checklist and check off
each item. Settle one item before attempting another if possible. Avoid
Fire Investigation and Evidence Kit: backtracking
• Check and Verify - Do not assume or take for granted. Don't jump to
conclusions. Steps on How to Determine the Point of Origin:
1. Examine the entire interior of the building and determine which room
• Take Note - write down all the details or areas has received the most severe fire damage. Generally, this will
be the area where the fire burned extensively or the longest and will
very likely be where it originated.
• Draw diagrams - amplify notes with diagrams depicting locations of
incidents described. 2. Determine the level or origin within the room by examining and
comparing the bottom side of the tables, shelves, and chairs.
Areas to Conduct Fire Investigation:
3. Examine the ceiling and look for the following patterns:
1. Exterior - Determine where the fire vested first by comparing burn char,
smoke, and heat patterns around windows, doors, and roof. a) fire penetration and
b) heaviest fire exposure
Look for the following:
4. Examine the light bulbs within the room. The side of the bulbs which is
• exterior points of origin; initially exposed to heat begin to swell or bulge and lose shape at about
• unusual burn patterns of flammable liquid; 900 degrees F when exposed to heat for 10 minutes or more actually
point to the area of fire origin.
• Tools and flammable liquid containers;
• Footprints and scuff marks at suspected points of entry.
5. Examine walls within the room and look for fire patterns or fire cones.
Fires generally burn upward and outward, leaving corresponding fire
2. Interior - Conduct a cursory examination or general survey of the entire
patterns on wall as a result of heat transfer through convection and
structure of interior for the extent of fire damage. Establish the class of fire
radiation. The steepness or relative pitch of the angle seen on the fire
duration (brief or long) and the approximate burn time by checking the following:
cone is indicative of the type of burning, e.g. Smoldering or Flaming
Types of Furnishing
3. Debris • Upholstered furniture;
• Television sets and table radios;
Examine the fire debris and the floor in the following manner: • Drapes and curtains;
• Kitchen range
• Conduct a detailed search of the debris, examining it layer by layer until
Fire Report (American Setting)
the floor is reached;
• Completely clean the floor on all debris and char dust. The floor and floor
covering should be clean enough to observe and photograph the Fire reports of all fires, regardless of sizes, should be completed. This report
significant burn and char patterns and should be dry. should be initiated and completed without delay. The contents of the fire report
• Carefully reconstruct and replace furnishings and other articles in their may contain the following information:
original positions by using burn patterns and corresponding protected
areas. During fire progress, legs and bases of furniture and other items 1. time of incident;
on the floor will protect the floor, leaving unburned marks which will aid 2. location of incident;
in repositioning. 3. size and nature of fire;
• Examine the floor coverings and floor for significant patterns. 4. fire involvement;
5. fire department plant response;
4. Furnishings 6. injuries and fatalities;
7. time fire extinguished;
Examine fire damaged furnishing such as: upholstered furniture couches, chairs, 8. most probable cause;
beds, etc. 9. follow-up and corrective action required.
1. He should possess knowledge of investigative techniques; 3. Any object which may be material to the circumstances of the fire;
2. He should have an insight of human behavior;
3. He should have a firsthand knowledge of the chemistry of fire and its behavior; 4. Type of tracks, footprints and the location of explosion debris are
4. He should be resourceful. photographed in close details, as well as from a distance.
5. The bur patterns at doorways should be photograph to show the spread of the
The exterior photographs generally shows the nature and material of construction fire between rooms The burn patterns on the walls in hallways normally show
and the locations of the doors, windows, chimneys, flues, electricity fuse box or the room from which the fire originated and the direction of spread of the fire;
gas meter. The openings where the fire vented are usually clearly shown in the 6. Appliances suspected of causing the fire should be photographed from a
exterior photographs. Exterior burn patterns are generally easier to interpret than distance and in close up in the location where they were found. The remains
the equivalent interior burn pattern as they generally provide good color and should be taken outside to allow closer inspection and be photographed in
texture contrast, and are less affected by smoke. sunlight or later at the laboratory.
Panoramic views are valuable in reports as they provide in great detail an overall Points of Entry and Security of Building: Fire brigade personnel will usually give
view of the scene. It can be produced by joining together a sequence of an account of the security of a building as they found it. In many cases their
photographs or by using a wide angle lens or a disposable camera equipped with accounts will need to be verified at each point of entry by an inspection of the
a wide angled lens. burn patterns and soot deposits to surface around the point of entry, and an
examination for tool marks.
Photographing the Interior:
Where to Photograph and what to Photograph
Photographs of the interior of a building are generally more difficult for the
viewer to interpret than the exterior photographs as the interior surfaces are 1. The doors should be first photograph in the position in which
usually burnt and covered with a layer of soot. A good quality flash unit is they were found. If the door was found closed then both sides of the
essential as the photographs need top provide as much detail as possible to allow door should be photograph.
the investigators to familiarize themselves with the nature of the damage and
possibly the identity and purpose of the room before the fire. 2. The burn patterns and soot deposits around the door and the
door frame should be photograph as they normally ascertain the position
Where to photograph and what to Photograph of the door at the time of the fire;
1. All rooms and areas inside the building affected by the fire, the photographs 3. Any parts of the door or lock which may have been dislodged as a
should be sequentially presented in a report from the areas of least damage to result of some type of forced entry should be photograph at the location
the areas of greatest damage, or to the area of fire origin, if this is not the area where they were found and later reconstructed at their original position
of greatest damage.
2. The peripheral areas where the fire had not originated; On Windows
3. The area of fire origin should be photograph before excavation will commence
and again photograph should be taken during excavation, if the process has 1. The position at the time of the fire should also be determined and the
yielded points of interest; evidence used for such an evaluation should be photograph;
4. At areas where an accelerant is suspected, the areas of localized damage to the
floor as well as the overhead damage should be photograph; 2. The position of the window frames in the case of a sliding aluminum
window;
3. The position of the falling glass could both indicate the position of the the color and size of flames are indications of what type of material is burning.
window at the time of the fire; The color of smoke often indicates whether an accelerant, such as gas, was
used to speed the burning process.
4. The smoke and heat patterns above a window can also indicate the
position of the window at the time of the fire should also be 6. Give particular attention to the most burned charred areas. The structure
photographed; should be photographed from all sides or angles to show the damaged areas.
Other things to look for are incendiary devices and combustible materials, such
5. The window locks should also be recovered and photograph as matchbox/es, paper, liquids (such as gas and paint thinner), and fuses.
Although they may have burned completely, there could be a visible trail,
defective wiring and electrical or gas appliances that may have been the cause
Importance of Photography in Arson Investigation: of the fire.
Every effort should be made to photograph the scene of a fire, whether or not
arson is suspected, before it is disturbed by other operations. Pictures may be
used to prove the intent to commit arson
4. Show the progressive stages of burning and fire fighting from various angles. If
possible keep a record of the time each picture was taken.
5. Help investigators determine the type of material/s burning. This is where the
use of color film is recommended. The steam, color, and quantity of smoke and
Photographing the Exterior
7. In such event that death results from a fire incident (fatal fires),
the concerned FAI shall immediately sought the assistance of the
PNP-SOCO, or any other legal recognized group for lifting and
6. The FAI must inform all concerned persons, occupants and autopsy of the cadaver/body found at the fire scene/crime scene.
managements of the burned premises that the fire scene is
Module 11 ANOTHER SIGNIFICANT PROVISION OF THE LAW
LEGAL ASPECTS OF FIRE INVESTIGATION
1. The increase in administrative fines from P12,000 to P50,000 for violation
Arson and other crimes involving destruction of the Provisions of the Fire Code;
ARSON- It is the intentional or malicious destruction of property by fire. 2. For failure to correct the deficiency or abate the fire hazard a fine from
P20,000 to P100,000 with the punishment of imprisonment of one to six
The Legal Aspects of Arson/Fire Investigation: years, in addition to the payment of damaged to victims if violation leads
It is the concern of the fire investigator to prove malicious intent of the offender. to the loss of life and damaged to property;
Intent must be proved, otherwise no crime exists. The law presumes that a fire is 3. Imposes accountability on public officials or employees, through:
accidental, hence criminal designs must be shown. Reprimand, Suspension, or Removal, as well as Criminal Penalties for
Fire caused by accident or criminal design must be shown. Fire caused by Negligence, Malfeasance, Misfeasance in performing their sworn duties
accident or negligence does not constitute arson. to the country;
4. Public officials who violate the law will be punished by a jail term of six (6)
Basics of Criminal Liability in Arson:
months to six (6) years, and a fine of not more than P100,000 or both.
1. Kind and character of the building burned; 5. Requires Private Fire Volunteers and Fire Practitioners should undergo a
2. Location of the building; Mandatory Training and Competency Evaluation to be conducted by the
3. Extent of value of the damage; BFP under the direct operational control of the BFP Fire Ground
4. Whether inhabited or not. Commander.
PD No. 1613 - Amending the Laws on Arson.
Republic Act 9514
The "Revised Fire Code of the Philippines of 2008" An Act Establishing А Section 1. Arson - Any person who burns or sets fire to the property of another
Comprehensive Fire Code of the shall be punished by Prision Mayor (Reyes, 1999). The same penalty shall be
Philippines, Repealing Presidential Decree No. 1185 and for other purposes was imposed when a person sets fire to his own property under circumstances which
signed and approved by President Gloria M. Arroyo on December 19, 2008. The cause or expose danger the life or property of another.
new Fire Code aims to promote economic development through the Prevention
Section 2. Destructive Arson - The penalty of Reclusion Temporal in its maximum
and Suppression of all kinds of destructive fires and to boost the fire service as a
period to Reclusion Perpetua shall be imposed by burning the following:
profession. The law is a consolidation of Senate Bill No. 2553
AUTHORITY/POWER OF BFP CHIEF 1. Any ammunition factory and other establishment where explosives,
1. Issue closure orders for building structures declared as fire hazards, inflammable or combustible materials are stored;
notwithstanding any permits, clearances or certificates earlier issued by 2. Any archive, museum, whether public or private, or any edifice devoted
local authorities; to culture, education or social services;
2. Order the removal of hazardous materials or hazardous operations of 3. Any church or place of worship or other building where people usually
business establishments whose physical layout is prone to industry assemble;
related fire incidents; 4. Any train, airplane or any aircraft, vessel or watercraft, or conveyance for
3. Order the work stoppage of structures still being constructed for absence transportation of persons or property:
or violation of any approved construction plan.
5. Any building where evidence is kept for use in any legislative, judicial, Section 6. Prima Facie Evidence of Arson - Any of the following circumstances
administrative or other official proceedings; shall constitute primafacie evidence of arson:
6. Any hospital, hotel, dormitory, lodging house, house tenement, shopping
1. If the fire started simultaneously in more than one part of the building or
center, public or private market, theatre or movie house or any similar
establishment;
place or building;
2. If substantial amount of flammable substances or materials are stored
7. Any building whether used as a dwelling or not, situated in a populated or
within the building not necessarily in the business of the offender or for
congested area.
household use;
Section 3. Other Cases or Forms of Arson - The penalty of Reclusion Temporal to 3. If gasoline, kerosene, petroleum or other flammable substances or
Reclusion Perpetua shall be imposed if the property burned is any of the materials soaked therewith or containers thereof, or any mechanical,
following: electrical, chemical, or electronic contrivance designed to start a fire,
ashes or traces of any of the foregoing are found in the ruins or premises
1. Any building used as offices of the government or any of its agencies;
of the burned building or property;
2. Any inhabited house or dwelling;
4. If the building or property is insured for substantially more than its actual
3. Any industrial establishment, shipyard, oil well or depot, mine shaft, value at the time of the issuance of the policy;
platform or tunnel;
5. If during the lifetime of the corresponding fire insurance policy, more
a. Any plantation, farm, pasture land, growing crop, grain field, orchard, than two fires have occurred in the same or other premises owned or
bamboo groove or forest; under the control of the offender and/or insured;'
b. Any rice mill, sugar mill, cane mill or mill central; and 6. If shortly before the fire, a substantial portion of the effects insured and
c. Any railway or bus station, airport, wharf, warehouse. stored in a building or property had been withdrawn from the premises
except in the ordinary course of business;
Section 4. Special Aggravating Circumstances in Arson - The penalty in any case 7. If a demand for money or other valuable consideration was made where
of arson shall be imposed in its maximum period: the fire in exchange for the desistance of the offender or for the safety of
the person or property of the victim.
1. If committed with intent to gain;
Section 7. Conspiracy to commit Arson. - Conspiracy to commit arson shall be
2. If committed for the benefit of another;
punished by Prision Mayor in its minimum period.
3. If the offender is motivated by spite or hatred towards the owner or
occupant of the property burned; Section 8. Confiscation of Object of Arson. - The building which is the object of
4. If committed by a syndicate. The offense is committed by a syndicate if it arson including the land on which it is situated shall be confiscated and escheated
is planned or carried out by a group of three (3) or more persons. to the State, unless the owner thereof can prove that he has no participation in
nor knowledge of such arson despite the exercise of due diligence on his part.
1. Qualification of Technician When entering the building, the investigator should observe the following:
2. Safeguarding of the samples during analysis 1. Look for mark on doors and windows not burned for possible indication of
3. Result of the examination (to be made in non-technical language) forcible entry.
C. Interpretations of the Findings 2. Notice whether the intruder has discarded tools used for forcible entry.
3. Notice unusual arrangement of the building content.
D. Interview and Interrogation:
4. Stocks or substitution of stocks, new expensive stocks have been
1. Time and Place of questioning removed, substituted by second hand or old stocks.
2. Interviews of firemen, neighbors, person who discovered the fire, Guidelines in the Investigation of Arson:
insurance agent, insured person and other person who has direct
connection regarding the burned property I. Arrival and Observation
3. Interrogation
Arrival
a) proof of the existence of the fire
Methods
Among the most likely method to be used by investigators are the
recording of the facts noted at the fire scene, sketches and
photographs as well as statements taken from the witnesses. And