1 PB
1 PB
org
ISSN 2224-3208 (Paper) ISSN 2225-093X (Online)
Vol.7, No.20, 2017
Abstract
A field experiment was carried out to study the growth and yield response of carrot to different green manures
and plant spacing at the College of Agriculture Education, University of Education, Winneba-Mampong Campus
in 2015 and 2016. Four different soil amendments (10 t/ha Mucuna pruriens, Chromolaena odorata, Gliricidia
sepium, 300Kg/ha NPK (15, 15, 15) and control) along with three spacing regimes (25 x 10cm, 25 x 15cm and
25 x 20cm) were employed in the investigation in Randomized Complete Block Design. The result revealed that
the application of 10 t/ha Mucuna pruriens, Chromolaena odorata, Gliricidia sepium and 300Kg/ha NPK (15, 15,
15) improved the vegetative growth of carrot and translocated the assimilates into the final gross and marketable
yield of the root compared to the control. Among the spacing regimes, 25 x 20cm produced the best vegetative
growth. Application of 300kg/ha NPK was found suitable for maximum gross and marketable yields (28.73 t/ha
and 27.23 t/ha, respectively) in 2015. In 2016, Mucuna pruriens, Chromolaena odorata, and Gliricidia sepium
treatments produced gross and marketable yields similar to 300kg/ha NPK. With the spacing regime, 25 x 10cm
produced maximum gross and marketable yield in both years. The combined treatment effect of 300kg /ha NPK
and 10 t /ha of Mucuna pruriens at 25 x 10cm spacing resulted in the best performance in terms of gross and
marketable yields. From the production as well as economic points of view a combination 10t/ha Mucuna
pruriens at 25 x 10cm spacing may be suggested for maximizing carrot production in the study area.
Keywords: Mucuna pruriens, Chromolaena odorata, Gliricidia sepium, green manure, plant spacing, vegetative
growth, gross and marketable yields.
Introduction
Carrot (Daucus carota L.) is a very important root vegetable mostly used in the diet of many Ghanaians. It is
highly valued as food mostly because it is a rich source of Vitamin A (Zeb and Mahmood, 2004). Furthermore,
carrot has abundant nutrients and minerals (Handelman, 2001). It is used in salads, stews and soups with other
vegetables. Besides being food, different parts of the crop can be utilized for different medicinal purposes. It is
useful in curing kidney diseases (Anjum and Amjad, 2002).
Carrot production can be a lucrative enterprise especially for most small scale, resource poor farmers in
Ghana, since it is a short duration crop and higher yields can be obtained per unit area (Ahmad et al., 2005). In
Ghana, it is one of the highly treasured exotic vegetables with great demand in urban centres and a potential
export crop (MoFA, 2002). However, yields per unit area still fall below the estimated 8-12 t/ ha for the tropics
and the world average of 21 t/ha (Kahangi, 2004).
One of the reasons advanced for such low yields is low soil fertility (Muendo and Tschirley, 2004). In order
to obtain high yield, good soil fertility is required to facilitate the production and translocation of carbohydrates
from leaves to roots. Essential nutrients (nitrogen, phosphorous and potassium) are key limiting factors relating
to growth, development and yield of crops (Glass, 2003; Parry et al., 2005). In most cases, carrot farmers use
inorganic fertilizers as the main source of nutrients supply to obtain higher growth and yield (Stewart et al., 2005;
Dauda et al., 2008). The use of inorganic fertilizers has, however, been associated with health and environmental
problems (Arisha and Bardisi, 1999). Moreover, the increasing costs of inorganic fertilizers have rendered them
unaffordable to most resource-poor small scale growers.
Organic manures have over the years been used as substitute to mineral fertilizers. They have proven to
supply the required nutrients (nitrogen, phosphorus, potassium), improve soil structure, increase microbial
population and maintain the quality of produce (Suresh et al., 2004; Sanwal et al., 2007; Adeleye et al., 2010).
In Ghana, the use of farmyard manure and compost are common among small holder farmers as main sources for
soil fertility improvement with associated transportation and storage problems. The more readily available green
manures therefore constitute a valuable potential source of N (Meelu et al., 1994), which benefits have not been
extensively exploited. Mucuna pruriens, Chromolaena odorata and Gliricidia sepium are among a number of
plant species readily available in the forest-savanna transition zones of Ghana (Gyamfi et al., 2001), but their
green manure has not been widely exploited in carrot production.
Plant spacing is one of the important factors for the increased production of carrot. Carrot yield is also
adversely affected by planting density (Splittoesser, 1990). McCollum et al. (1986) reported that there is positive
correlation between the number of plants and yield of carrot. But many workers have reported that different plant
16
Journal of Biology, Agriculture and Healthcare www.iiste.org
ISSN 2224-3208 (Paper) ISSN 2225-093X (Online)
Vol.7, No.20, 2017
densities have different effect for marketable yield of carrot (Nogueira et al., 1982; Dragland, 1986). Significant
interaction between plant spacing and soil amendments have been recorded for many crops (Salter et al., 1979)
with scarce information on carrots. Information on optimum spacing for carrot production is varied. For instance,
Tindall (1983) recommended inter-row spacing of 30-40cm and intra rows of 8-10cm. Rice et al. (1987) stated
that seeds are sown with rows 30-40cm apart and seedling thinned to 10-14cm apart within row. Hodder and
Stoughton (1990) suggested between rows of 15cm and within rows of 10cm. Observation on farmers’ fields in
Ghana reveals varied inter and intra-row spacing resulting in small and uneven root sizes which are rejected by
most market women. The study was undertaken to determine the influence of spacing and green manure on the
growth and yield of carrot in the forest-savanna transition zone of Ghana.
17
Journal of Biology, Agriculture and Healthcare www.iiste.org
ISSN 2224-3208 (Paper) ISSN 2225-093X (Online)
Vol.7, No.20, 2017
means obtained were separated by Least Significant Difference (LSD) method at 5% significance level.
18
Journal of Biology, Agriculture and Healthcare www.iiste.org
ISSN 2224-3208 (Paper) ISSN 2225-093X (Online)
Vol.7, No.20, 2017
more leaves and nodes per plant of okra. The significantly higher plant height recorded for the closer spacing
treatment shows that there was competition for light and space among the treatments. This collaborates with the
findings of Agyekum (1999) who reported closer spacing increases competition among the plants for nutrients,
air, and light, which results in taller and weaker plants. The wider spacing plots significantly recorded greatest
fresh and dry weight values which might be due to less competition among plants on those plots.
Table 2: Number of Leaves, Plant Height, Fresh and Dry Shoot Weight as Influenced by Plant
19
Journal of Biology, Agriculture and Healthcare www.iiste.org
ISSN 2224-3208 (Paper) ISSN 2225-093X (Online)
Vol.7, No.20, 2017
amendments and spacing reported that the wider spacing of 30cm x 5cm promoted vegetative growth and
increased root length of carrot but planting at closer spacing of 20cm x 5cm resulted in higher total and
marketable yields and also increased income and profit. Carrot yield is also adversely affected by low planting
density (Splittoesser, 1990). The root length of the green manure amended plots was significantly higher than the
control in both years. The green manure treatments probably improved the physical soil properties and increased
the levels of soil nutrients which improved plant growth and increased the root length. Asiedu et al. (2007) also
reported increased root length of carrot with the application of poultry manure and cowdung compared to the
control. The structural superiority of the green manure amended soils enhanced the textural quality of the root by
maintaining uniform soil moisture and nutrient levels. This enabled the carrots roots to expand to deeper layers
without any inhibition resulting in longer roots compared to the control. This work supports that of Warman and
Havard (1996) and Stone (1998) who stated that it is possible to obtain carrots root length of more than 18 cm on
green manure treated fields. The root length of NPK amended plots was higher than the control plots.
Mallareddy (2007) reported that a recommended dose of NPK fertilizer alone can perform better in terms of root
length. The report of Mallareddy (2007) is supported by the present study of NPK contribution to the carrot root
length.
Generally, it could be observed that the mean root diameter of green manure and NPK amended plots was
higher than the control. The increase in diameter of carrot roots could be due to the phosphorus content in the
green manure and NPK confirming the work of Cole (1984) that applied P in adequate quantity increased the
medium yield of carrot crown diameter between 2.5-5.0cm.
Spacing and amendments had significant influence on weight of root per plant. In this study, the widest
spaced plants produced greater weight of roots per plant but in terms of per hectare, the closest spaced plants had
more roots and therefore greater weight. Similar results were obtained by Agyekum (1999) that wider spacing
gave greater weight per plant of okro than closer spacing but yield per unit area increased with closer spacing.
Green manure and fertilizer amendments significantly influenced the weight of roots per plant and per
hectare. Nitrogen applied together with adequate amount of phosphorus and potassium has beneficial effect on
productivity of crops. Generally, N fertilization rates maximized carrot root yield. In a study conducted by
Hochmuth et al. (1999) on nitrogen fertilization in a sandy soil, it was observed that yield increased with N
fertilization. Similarly, the application of nitrogen and potassium to carrot resulted in root yield significantly
increased over control (Ali et al., 2006)
Spacing, amendments and their interaction had significant effect on both gross and marketable yield. The S
1
plants produced greater gross and marketable roots per hectare than the S and S plants. The yield per hectare for
2 3
the inorganic fertilizer and soil amended plots was better than the control in both years during the period of the
study. The increase in yield of NPK and the amended plots than the control might be due to the adequate supply
of phosphorus which is involved in carrot establishment and yield. The NPK and the amendments supplied
enough nutrients to the carrot plant which ensured good growth and yield more than the control. This supports
Cole (1984) that adequate supply of phosphorus is involved in carrot establishment and good yield. The yield
could also be attributed to the nitrogen content supplied in the soil which stimulated root growth and
development as stated by Brady (1990). Similarly, Walker and Bernal (2004) stated that microbes in green
manure release growth regulators essential for plant growth and photosynthetic activity. This might be the reason
why carrots on green manure plots grew better and produced higher yields which could be attributed to high
nutrient sustainability of the manure and improved biological properties of the soil.
20
Journal of Biology, Agriculture and Healthcare www.iiste.org
ISSN 2224-3208 (Paper) ISSN 2225-093X (Online)
Vol.7, No.20, 2017
Table 3 Root Length, Diameter and Weight as Influenced by Green Manure and Plant Spacing
Parameters Root Length (cm) Root Diameter(cm) Root Weight (g)
2015 2016 2015 2016 2015 2016
Treatments
Spacing
S1 25 x 10cm 18.23 16.52 3.32 2.30 49.56 47.48
S2 25 x 15cm 18.55 17.42 3.56 2.49 51.22 49.14
S325 x 20cm 19.91 19.29 3.77 3.01 51.94 49.86
LSD(P<0.05) 1.186 0.880 0.180 0.199 NS NS
CV (%) 9.82 7.74 8.10 12.03 7.91 8.22
Amendments
T1 Mucuna pruriens 21.25 17.78 3.71 2.82 54.46 52.38
T2 Chromolaena odorata 19.57 18.04 3.72 2.72 52.34 50.26
T3 Gliricidia sepium 20.80 17.73 3.33 2.70 46.86 44.78
T4 NPK (15, 15, 15) 20.05 18.79 4.67 2.51 58.50 56.42
T5 Control 12.81 16.37 2.34 2.24 42.37 40.29
LSD (P<0.05) 1.531 1.130 0.240 0.257 3.302 3.302
CV (%) 9.82 7.74 8.10 12.03 7.91 8.22
Table 4: Gross and marketable yield as influenced by green manure and plant spacing
Parameters Gross Yield (t/ha) Marketable Yield (t/ha)
Spacing
S1 25 x 10cm 21.44 18.55 19.03 16.14
S2 25 x 15cm 20.42 16.29 18.11 12.74
S325 x 20cm 19.58 13.59 17.41 10.74
LSD(P<0.05) 0.361 1.866 0.349 1.798
CV (%) 2.84 18.13 3.01 21.31
Amendments
T1 Mucuna pruriens 23.55 17.52 21.18 15.06
T2 Chromolaena odorata 22.15 18.68 19.43 14.72
T3 Gliricidia sepium 21.22 19.71 18.76 16.47
T4 NPK (15, 15, 15) 28.73 17.33 27.23 14.66
T5 Control 6.75 7.48 4.32 5.12
LSD (P<0.05) 0.466 2.409 0.450 2.321
CV (%) 2.84 18.13 3.01 21.31
Conclusion
The study showed that the application of the green manure and 300kg/ha NPK (15:15:15) improved vegetative
growth, increased root length and yield of carrot relative to the control. Planting at 25 x 20cm improved the
vegetative growth and root length of the crop. The closer spacing (25 x 10cm), however, gave more yield. From
the economic point of view, carrot growers in Mampong- Ashanti can increase their yield with the application of
10t/ha Mucuna pruriens green manure and planting at 25 x 10cm spacing.
Acknowledgement
The authors would like to thank Mr. Oteng Okae Kissiedu for his immense contribution in bringing this work to
fruition
Reference
Adeleye EO, Ayeni LS, Ojeni SO (2010). Effect of poultry manure on soil physico-chemical properties, leaf
nutrient content and yield of yam (Dioscorea rotundata) on alfisol in South Western Nigeria. J. Am. Sci.,
6(10): 871-878.
Afari, D. (1999). Preliminary Evaluation of Fertilizer Application on GardenEgg (Solanum integrifolium L) and
Cowpea (Vigna unguiculata L) Intercropped system. MSc dissertation, Department of Horticulture, KNUST,
21
Journal of Biology, Agriculture and Healthcare www.iiste.org
ISSN 2224-3208 (Paper) ISSN 2225-093X (Online)
Vol.7, No.20, 2017
Kumasi.
Agyekum, E. (1999). Effects of different spacings and fertilizer levels on the growth, yield and quality of okra
variety ‘Asontem White’ A BSc dissertation. Department of Horticulture, KNUST, Kumasi.
Ahmad Z, Ali N, Ahmad M, Ulhag S, Ahmad S (2005). Yield and economics of carrot production in organic
farming. Sarhad J. Agric., 21(3): 357-364.
Anjum MA, Amjad M (2002). Influence of mother root size and plant spacing on carrot seed production. J.
Resour. Sci., 13(2): 105-112.
Ali, M.K. Tawab, K. A. Ala m, M.N. and Barkotulla, M.A.B.( 2006). Effect of Nitrogen levels on yield and
yield combusting characters of three varieties of carrot. Damman community college. King Fahd
University of petroleum and minerals.
Amjad, M. Naz, S. and Ali, S. (2005). Growth and seed yield of carrot as influenced by different regimes of
nitrogen and potassium. Journal of Research (Science), pp. 73-78 ISSN 1021- 1012 73 J. res. Sci., 2005,
16(2), 73-78 Bahauddin Zakariya University, Multan, Pakistan.
Anjum MA, Amjad M (2002). Influence of mother root size and plant spacing on carrot seed production. J.
Resour. Sci., 13(2): 105-112.
Arisha H M, Bardisi A (1999). Effect of mineral fertilizers and organic fertilizers on growth, yield and quality of
potato under sandy soil conditions. J. Agric. Resourses., 26: 391-405.
Asiedu, E. K., Hemeng, O. B., Dawuda, M. M., Agbeko, Y. and Amponsah, E. K. (2007). Effect of poultry and
sheep manure on growth and yield of carrot. Ghana Journal of Horticulture 6: 65 – 69.
Atta Poku, P., Agyarko K., Dapaah H. K. and Dawuda, M. M (2014). Influence of Mucuna pruriens Green
Manure, NPK and Chicken Manure Amendments on Soil Physico – Chemical Properties and Growth and
Yield of Carrot (Daucus carota L.). Journal of Agriculture and Sustainability, Vol. 5 (1): 26-44
Brady, N.C. (1990). Soil organic matter and organic soils. The nature and properties of soils. Macmillan
Publishing Co. New York, p. 279-313.
Birbal, K., Nehra, B. K. and Malik, Y.S. (1995). Effect of spacing and nitrogen fertilizer on fruit yield of okra,
cv. Varsh Upland, Haryana Agricultural University Journal of Research (1995) 25 47-51
Cole, A.J. (1984). Nitrogen, Phosphorus, Potassium, Calcium and Copper as Plant Nutrients for Carrots Grown
on Wood Fen Peat, Irish Journal of Agricultural Research © 1984 TEAGASC-Agriculture and Food
Development Authority
Dauda SN, Ajayi FA, Ndor E (2008). Growth and yield of water melon (Citrullus lonatus) as affected by poultry
manure application. J. Agric. Soc. Sci., 4: 121-124.
Dawuda1 M. M., Boateng P.Y, Hemeng O.B and G. Nyarko (2011) growth and yield response of carrot to
different rates of soil amendments and spacing. Journal of Science and Technology, Vol. 31, No. 2 (2011),
pp 11-20 11
Dragland, S. (1986). Plant density and row spacing in Carrots. Forskning og Forsoki Landbruket, statens
Forskingsstasjon kise, Norway. 37:3,139- 145
Fordham, R. and Biggs, A.G. (1985). Principles of Vegetable Crop Production William Collins and Sons Co
Ltd London p 175.
Frempong, M. E., Ofosu-Anim, J. and Blay, E.T. (2006). Nutrient supply strategies on growth and yield and
yield components of okro (Abelmoschus esculentus L. moench). Ghana Journal of Horticulture Volume 5.
Glass ADM (2003). Nitrogen use efficiency of crop plants: physiological constraints upon nitrogen absorption.
Crit. Rev. Plant Sci., 22: 453-470.
Gyamfi, E., Loos, H. and Anthofer, J. (2001). Farmers’ perceptions of adoption of soil fertility technologies.
Paper presented at the International Conference of the Soil Science Society of Ghana (26th February to 2nd
March 2001) held at Tamale, Ghana.
Handelrman GJ (2001). The evolving role of carotenoids in human biochemistry. Nutrition, pp. 818-22.
Hochmuth, G. J. Brecht, J. K. Bassett, M. J. (1999). Nitrogen fertilization to maximize carrot yield and
quality on a sandy soil. American Society for Horticultural Science, Alexandria,VA, ETATS-UNIS (1966)
(Revue) HortScience ISSN 0018-5345 CODEN HJHSAR 1999, vol. 34, no4, pp. 641-645 (40 ref.)
Hodder and Stoughton (1990). Gardening without chemicals. Consumers association. Marylebone Road, London.
NW14D. 47 Bedford square London. WC1B3DP pp 12-30.
HU, Y. & Barker, A.V., (2004). Evaluation of composts and the combinations with other materials on tomato
growth. Commun. Soil Sci. Plant Anal. 35 (19 & 20), 2789 – 2807.
Kahangi, E. (2004). Daucus carota L. In: Grubben, G.J.H. and Denton, O.A.(eds.) Plant Kalyanasundaram, N.
and Sambandam, L. (1979) Performance of three bringal varieties to various levels of nitrogen. Journal of
Science in India Vol 25(2): 54-58.
Kalyanasundaram, N. and Sambandam, L. (1979) Performance of three bringal varieties to various levels of
nitrogen. Journal of Science in India Vol 25(2): 54-58.
Korem, S. O., Ahmed, F. A. and Farag. I. A. (1991). Effect of irrigation, planting density and nitrogen rate on
22
Journal of Biology, Agriculture and Healthcare www.iiste.org
ISSN 2224-3208 (Paper) ISSN 2225-093X (Online)
Vol.7, No.20, 2017
bulb yield and quality in CV Shandwell I, onion grown from setts. Journal of Agric. Science Vol 21 (1) p
309-318.
Koriem, S. O. and Farag, I. A. (1990). Effect of nitrogen fertilizer, spacing and size of setts on growth, yield
and quality of onion: Growth characteristics. ASSIUT Journal of Agric Science 21(1): 257– 264.
Mallareddy, A.K. (2007). Effect of Different Organic Manures and Inorganic Fertilizers on Growth, Yield and
Quality of Carrot (Daucus carota L.) Karnataka Journal of Agricultural Sciences: 20(3), (686-688).
Rajendranagar, Hyderabad-500 030, India.
McCollum, T.G., S.J. Locascio and J.M. White (1986). Plant density and row arrangement effects on carrot yield.
J. Amer.Soc.Hort. Sci 111(5):648-651.
Meelu, O.P., Yadoinder-Singh and Bijah-Singh (1994). Green manuring for soil productivity improvement.
World Soil Resources Reports, 76, FAO, Rome.
MOFA, (2002). Production Guide. Aubergine Production and Postharvest Handling Practices. MOFA, Accra,
Ghana pp6.
Muendo, Tschirley (2004). Improving Kenya’s domestic horticultural production and marketing system: current
competitiveness, forces of changes, and challenges for the futute. Working paper No.08A Tegemeo Institute
of Agricultural policy and development. Evergeton university, Kenya.
Muck, H. J. (1980). Effect of row spacing on processing carrot root yields. American Society of Horticultural
Science Journal 15 (2): 144 – 145.
Naik, L. B., Prabhakar, M. and Doijode, S. D. (1996). Effect of nitrogen on growth, yield and quality of bringal
(Solanum melongena). Annals of Agric. Research 17 (4): 419-421.
Nandekar, D. N. and Sawarkar, S. D. (1990). Effect of plant nutrients (NPK) on different varieties of bringal
(Solanum melongena L). Orissa Journal of Horticulture (1990) 18 (1-2) 1-5 Hort. Abst. Vol 62.11
Nogueira, I.C.C., F.C. Nogueira and M.Z de Negreiros (1982). Effect of plant spacing on yield of carrot (Daucus
carota L) cv Kuroda Nocional. Proc. Trop. Reg., Amer.Soc. Hort Sci.25:125-127.
Norman, J. C. (1992). Tropical Vegetables Crops. Arthur, H. Stockwell Ltd. Elms Court Ilfracombe, Devon,
UK, pp 232.
Ogundare, S. K., Babatunde, I. J. and Aduloju M. O (2014). Effect of Soil Applied Chromolaena Odorata Fresh
Biomass and Urea Fertilizer On Plant Available Nitrogen, Growth And Yield Of Maize(Zea MaysL.) In
Ejiba, Kogi State, Nigeria. Proceedings of the International Soil Tillage Research Organisation (ISTRO)
Nigeria Symposium, November 3 - 6, Akure, Nigeria: 272 – 279
Parry MAJ, Flexas J, Medrono H (2005). Prospects for crop production under drought. Research priorities and
future directions. Annual Appl. Biol., 147: 211-226.
Rice, R. P. Rice, L. W. and Tindall, H.O (1987). Fruits and vegetable in the tropics. Macmillan publishers Ltd pp
249-251.
Salter, P.J., L.E. Curral and J.R. Fellows (1979). The effect of plant density, spatial arrangement and time of
harvesting on yield and root size in carrot. J. Agric. Sci. 93 (2): 431-440
Sanwal SK, Lakiminarayana K, Yadav RK, Yadav N, Musumi B (2007). Effect of quality of turmeric. Indian J.
Hortic., 64(4): 444-449.
Splittstoesser, W. E. (1990). Vegetable Growing Handbook. Organic and Traditional Methods, 3rd edition.
Chapman and Hall, UK. pp 215.
Stewart MW, Dibb, Johnston EA, Syth JT (2005). The contribution of commercial fertilizer nutrients to food
production. Agron. J., 97: 1-6.
Stone, D.A., (1998). The effects of “starter” fertilizer injection on the growth and yield of drilled vegetable crops
in relation to soil nutrient status. J. Hort. Sci. & Biotech. 73(4), 441 – 451.
Suresh KD, Sneh G, Krishna KK, Mad CM (2004). Microbial biomass carbon and Microbial activities of soils
receiving chemical fertilizers and organic amendments. Arich. Agron. Soil Sci., 50: 7-641.
Tindall, H.D. (1983). Vegetable in the tropics. Macmillan education limited. Hounds mills Basingstoke,
Hampshire RG21x pp406-408.
Walker, D.J. & Bernal, M.P., (2004). Plant mineral nutrition and growth in a saline Mediterranean soil amended
with organic wastes. Commun. Soil Sci. Plant Anal. 35(17 & 18), 2495 – 2514.
Warman, P.R. & Havard, K.A, (1996). Yield, vitamin and mineral content of organically and conventionally
grown carrots and cabbage. Agric. Ecosystem & Environ. 61, 155– 162.
Zeb A, Mahmood S (2004). Carotenoid contents from various sources and their potential health applications.
Pakistan J. Nutr., 3(3): 199-204
23