STIRs Trading
STIRs Trading
Tutorial
Malcolm Baker – founder
Interest Rate
Fundamentals
Long Term Interest Rates refer to the Interest Rates of
derivatives with a Residual maturity of 7 years or more. In the
Over-The-Counter (OTC) Bond Markets Bonds trade out to 50
years.
These are not the Interest Rates at which the bonds were issued rather
the interest rates implied by the prices at which these (Government
and Corporate) Bonds are being traded in the financial markets.
Interest Rate Risk, is the risk that interest Risk will rise, thereby decreasing the
value of a bond. The Price of a bond is inversely related to movements in interest
rates. In general, the relationship between price and yield is Convex. In other
words, the sensitivity of the bond price to changes in interest rates varies on the
level of interest rates.
Below you have a chart illustrating the price-yield relationship for two bonds with
the same 5% coupon rate, but different maturities (3years versus 30 years).
Note that the bond with the 3 year maturity is more linear, while the bond with
the 30-year maturity is more convex. Generally, bonds with longer maturities
(beyond 7 years) are more convex, while short-term bonds exhibit little
convexity.
The Price Yield Relationship for Bonds
The Below Chart illustrates the price-yield relationship for two bonds with the
same 10-year maturity, but different coupons (10% versus 5%). The bond with
the larger coupon is more convex than the bond with the smaller coupon.
Generally, bonds with higher coupons have greater convexity.
The price-yield relationship is curvilinear because the coupons paid to the bond
holder over the life of the bond are reinvested, earning interest on interest.
Intuitively, the magnitude of the compounded interest depends positively on the
size of the coupons and the period of time for which the coupons are reinvested.
The Price Yield Relationship for Bonds – continued
The previous two slides show how convexity is larger at both very low yields and
very high yields. As such, convexity varies depending on the magnitude of the
change in interest rates.
By implication, highly convex bonds are more valuable in volatile interest rate
environments. In this scenario of higher volatility the market charges a higher
premium for convexity in the form of a higher price and lower yield.
The Price Yield Relationship for Bonds – Duration.
Duration is a summary measure of maturity, coupon and yield effects that is used to approximate
interest rate risk. A bond with larger coupon and yield has lower duration, while a bond with a longer
maturity has higher duration. Bonds with lower duration are less sensitive to change in yield, while
bonds with higher duration are more sensitive to changes in yield.
Duration approximates interest rate sensitivity. Hence, increase duration if interest rates are expected
to fall, and reduce duration when interest rates are expected to rise. Longer duration bonds have
lower coupons and longer maturities.
Convexity is highly valued during periods of highly volatile interest rates. Hence, shift to bonds with
higher convexity if interest rate volatility is expected to rise, and shift to bonds with lower convexity
when interest rate volatility is expected to fall. Highly convex bonds tend to have maturities beyond
10 years.
When uncertain about the direction of interest rate movements (or you agree with market
expectations), maintain a neutral duration position relative to the targeted benchmark.
Yield Curve Risk: The Yield – Maturity relationship.
The yield Curve – also known as the term structure of interest rates – illustrates the
relationship between the yield and maturity of bonds with the same credit quality. There
are four classic yield curve shapes:
I) Rising (normal): Yields rise continuously, with some reduction in the rate of increase
at longer maturities.
II) Falling (Inverted): Yields decline over the entire maturity range.
III) Flat: Yields are unaffected by maturity.
IV) Humped: yields initially rise, but then peak and decline.
Yield Curve Risk: The Yield – Maturity relationship.
The shape of the yield curve has important implications for the performance of a bond portfolio.
Yield curve risk is the risk that an unanticipated shift in the yield curve will reduce the value of the
bond portfolio. Exposure to yield curve risk depends on the spacing of the maturity of bonds within a
portfolio. Before considering different types of yield curve shifts and their effect on the performance
of a bond portfolio, it is useful to see how the shape of the yield curve can affect performance of a
single bond.
Curve Risk implications for Traders.
Yield Curve strategies involve taking positions in bonds of varying maturities in order to capitalize on
expected changes in the shape of the yield curve.
I) If the yield curve is expected to flatten, longer duration strategies should outperform shorter
duration strategies.
II) If the yield curve is expected to steepen, shorter duration strategies should outperform longer
duration strategies.
III) Longer duration bonds take advantage of a positively sloped yield curve.
Other sources of Risks for Bonds.
Credit risk - Relevant for all bonds. US Treasuries (UST) and German Bunds (Bunds) used to be 100 %
exempt from credit risk, but since 2008 global Financial Crisis and the 2010 European Crisis market
practitioners view these bonds to display a slight credit Risk. Still UST and Bunds are the Benchmark
Bond that analysts look at for gauge the health of the global Economy. In the Event Of Credit Risks,
the Market Buys UST and Bunds as Safe haven.
Event Risk – For corporate Bonds the likely causes of such risk are Natural disasters, industrial
Accidents, Takeovers or corporate restructurings. For Sovereign government debt these are extreme
flight to quality episodes, such as war, dramatic economic shocks or changes in government policy.
Inflation Risk – Except for Inflation linked bonds or floating rate bonds. This is the risk that
unanticipated inflation will erode the value of the bond cash flows.
Liquidity Risk – The Primary measure of liquidity risk is the size of the bid-ask spread. Illiquid bonds
have wide bid ask spreads. Generally, Bunds and UST will not exhibit liquidity concerns.
Interest Rate Futures
A Futures contract represents an obligation to buy (or sell) an asset at a specific price on
a specific date in the future. The seller of a bond futures contract has the obligation to
deliver to the buyer of the futures contract at the settlement date the underlying bond
with a prespecified period remaining to maturity and face value. In selecting the issue to
be delivered, the seller of the futures contract will select from all the deliverable issues
the one that is the cheapest to deliver. As such, the buyer of the bond futures contract
can never be sure exactly which bond will be delivered.
The theoretical price of a bond future is equal to the cash price of the underlying bond
plus the cost of carry. In reality the actual price is lower than the theoretical price
because of the delivery options afforded to the seller of the futures contract. The price
of the futures contract moves with the price of the underlying asset.
Uses of Bond Futures.
In an IRS two parties agree to exchange periodic interest payments. The most common
arrangement is the “plain vanilla” swap, where one party agrees to pay the other party
fixed interest payments (at a spread over Treasuries or another benchmark government
yield) in return for floating payments based on a reference rate (usually 6-month London
Interbank offered Rate – LIBOR) the Fixed rate payer (i.e. the payer of fixed) is long the
swap and benefits if interest rates rise. Conversely, the floating rate payer (i.e. the
receiver of fixed) is short the swap and benefits if interest rates fall.
The swap spread is the interest rate differential between the swap rate and the
government benchmark yield of the same maturity.
European Central Bank (ECB) – The Primary objective of the ECB’s Monetary Policy is to
maintain price stability. The ECB aims at inflation rates of below, but close to, 2% over
the medium term.
UK Monetary Policy Committee (MPC) – The Primary objective of the MPC is to enable
the UK inflation target to be met.
Swiss National Bank (SNB) – Its sole responsibility is to define Price Stability and use the
tools at its fingers to ensure this target is met.
Federal Reserve (US Fed) – Its obligations are to Maximize Employment, Stabilize Prices
and Moderate Long Term interest Rates.
Bank of Japan (BOJ) – Decides and implements monetary policy with the aim of
maintaining price stability.
Key Drivers of STIRs (LL)
Core Inflation (Excluding Fodd and Energy) Personal income and consumption There are many Pieces of Economic Data
available to Traders every month/Quarter.
Crude Oil and other Commodity Prices consumer confidence
The most important ones are opposite.
Labour (employment) costs Retail sales, homes sales, auto sales
LL Traders need to follow all Tier 1 UK data
Average Hourley earnings Industrial production, factory orders
through each month. These Data releases
Currency strength/weakness Capital spending by business (capex) usually come out at 0930 UK time with the
exception of BOE-MPC Meetings and Minute
Business outlook
releases. LL traders need to follow US Tier 1
Corporate earnings Data also.
Non-Farm Payrolls
Trade Balance
Productivity growth
Key Economic Data.
Labour (employment) costs Retail sales, homes sales, auto sales For STIRs traders, think Inflation, inflation, inflation…
Average Hourley earnings Industrial production, factory orders Within each bucket of either Direct or Indirect Inflation Economic
releases traders will bucket these into which are most important.
Currency strength/weakness Capital spending by business (capex)
In Reality Tier 1 Data will be the CPI, Employment, GDP,
Consumer Confidence, Retail sales, PPI, Average Hourly Earnings.
Business outlook
But Markets are extremely sensitive to All Economic Data so the
Corporate earnings Tier 1 Bucket gets filled with many more releases from time to
time.
Business inventories
The Tier 1 Data bucket Economic releases can often be that
significant their releases can completely change the direction of a
Durable goods orders
market for a significant period of time.
Construction activity, housing starts What is missing from the Opposite Economic Releases are the
Actual Central bank meetings and decision on Interest Rates and
Unemployment rate also Points in time when Central governors make Key note
speeches. Traders need to watch for these.
Initial and continuing jobless claims
Central Bank Interest rate decisions, minutes and speeches are
always well known in advance to not knock markets unawares
Non-Farm Payrolls
with surprises.
Trade Balance
Productivity growth
The Taylor Rule
The Taylor Rule is a formula developed by Stanford economist John Taylor. It was
designed to provide “recommendations” for how a Central Bank like the Federal Reserve
should set short term interest Rates as economic conditions change to achieve both its
short run goal for stabilising the economy and its long run goal of Inflation.
There are two charts opposite, one of the Short Sterling Mar2017 (in
price) and one of the UK PMI Manufacturing Survey (a strong indicator of
the health of the Economy). The UK PMI would be your Indicator and the
LL Mar2017 the traded asset. We do not trade Outrights at OSTC, in this
example it is to show you the impact of Economic release on one of the LL
futures. Knowing in which business cycle you are in will enable you to
know how this impacts the spreads we trade.
Although not a linear relationship, you can see clearly a strong Inverse
relationship/correlation between the UK PMI Manufacturing Survey and
the markets prediction on future 3 month LIBOR Rates.
Although, UK PMI is just one Piece of Economic Data out of 10 that are
really important to the UK BOE-MPC in setting future Interest Rates, it
demonstrates how sensitive LL futures are to these Pieces of data. The
theory is that weaker Manufacturing that we can witness from the falling
UK PMI from 58 to 50 from 2013 to 2016, demonstrates a weakness in the
UK economy. As each Release in this 3 years is known by the markets the
LL futures start to trade higher (i.e. Market predicting the at BOE-MPC will
start lowering Interest Rates to stimulate the flagging economy)
Tier 1 Data.
1 Hour Prior to the US Jobs data. Non Farm Payrolls and Unemployment
Data. The US economy is the Largest by far and as such if there is a
dramatic slowdown or increased growth this will impact all global
Markets
Opposite you have 2 charts of the Upcoming US Employment Data for the
Major Global Markets to analyse.
The top Chart is Non Farm Payrolls Data. A higher number for this release
is highly positive for the US Economy, conversely a lower number is
adversely negative.
This brings us back to the conundrum for Central Banks, they have to
balance Inflation. So signs of Economic Indicators that can ultimately
drive up Inflation will concern the Central banks into potentially
withdrawing stimulus and potentially Raising Interest Rates.
Although one Economic release ultimately will not drive the Central bank
into rushing to change policy, the Financial Markets will begin to make
changes to the probability of future changes in interest Rates.
1 Hour Prior to the US Jobs data. Non Farm Payrolls and Unemployment Data. The US economy is the Largest by far and as such if there is a dramatic slowdown or
increased growth this will impact all global Markets.
Market Players will look at the expected 180,000 prediction of the US NFP and make the following predictions on how this will impact the LL Futures.
A NFP release of > 300,000 LL Sep17 sell down to 99.68 from Baseline 99.72
A NFP release between 249,000 and 299,000 LL Sep17 sell down to 99.71 from Baseline 99.72
A NFP release between 191,000 and 249,000 LL Sep17 sell down to 99.70 from Baseline 99.72
A NFP release between 170,000 and 190,000 LL Sep17 no price change from Baseline 99.72
A NFP release between 169,000 and 129,000 LL Sep17 Buy up to 99.73/99.74 from Baseline 99.72
A NFP release of < 100,000 LL Sep17 buy up to 99.75 from Baseline 99.72
Tier 1 Data.
What happens prior to the release of a Tier 1 Piece of economic Data? Defining the Baseline.
What happens prior to the release of a Tier 1 Piece of economic Data? Defining the Baseline.
1 Hour Prior to the US Jobs data. Non Farm Payrolls and Unemployment Data. The US economy is the Largest by far and as such if there is a dramatic slowdown or
increased growth this will impact all global Markets.
Market Players will look at the expected 180,000 prediction of the US NFP and make the following predictions on how this will impact the LL Futures.
Actual Release LL Sep 17 Price
A NFP release of > 300,000 LL Sep17 sell down to 99.68 from Baseline 99.725 avg
A NFP release between 249,000 and 299,000 LL Sep17 sell down to 99.71 from Baseline 99.725 avg
A NFP release between 191,000 and 249,000 LL Sep17 sell down to 99.70 from Baseline 99.725 avg
A NFP release between 170,000 and 190,000 LL Sep17 no price change from Baseline 99.725 avg
A NFP release between 169,000 and 129,000 LL Sep17 Buy up to 99.73/99.74 from Baseline 99.725 avg 151,000 99.735 avg
A NFP release of < 100,000 LL Sep17 buy up to 99.75 from Baseline 99.725 avg
Tier 1 Data.
Budget Blowouts are Bond Bearish – Fiscally loose governments, like seen in Southern
Europe in the early 2010’s can cause horrific Bond stress and cause huge falls in bond
prices as confidence wanes and thus huge rises in the Government Bond prices.
Political Crisis - Will undoubtedly cause a bond crisis in the domestic Country. Recent
Crisis in Europe in 2010 caused much contagion to other developed Economies.
A trader's Strategy template
I) Fundamentals:
A) Growth (direction, pace)
B) Inflation (pace, variability)
C) Demographics (trend)
II) Politics:
A) Monetary policy changes
B) Fiscal policy changes
C) Geopolitical considerations
II) Behaviour:
A) Risk Appetite (volatile)
B) Sentiment
C) Momentum
Every trader should understand where the Economy is right now and look to
understand most or all of the trends and factors above.
Fundamentals
How do the Swap, Bond, STIR, FRA, OTC, Futures Markets interact?
What is a Bond Future?
An underlying (government) bond, that matches the deliverable criteria, must either be delivered on a given date (Eurex) or during a given time
window (CME).
Expiry dates are quarterly in March, June, September and December, but may be on the 10th of the month (Eurex) or during the month (CME).
The prices are quoted with reference to a ‘standard’ bond contract with a defined yield to maturity of 6% (CME and Eurex) or 4% (ICE).
The Tick value of a bond future is the smallest price increment possible multiplied by the face value. For Eurex Bond Futures (which are quoted
in Decimals and quoted with a 0.01% increments), this makes life straight forward, being the tick Value EUR 10, apart from Shatz (2year
contracts) which can move in 0.005% increments and hence have a EUR 5 tick value. For CME, it varies with the futures contract, from $7.8125 to
$31.25.
The Actual invoice price of the deliverable bond is calculated using a Conversion Factor.
Conversion factors can be complex, suffice to say that because bond futures are not based on a single underlying bond issue, but rather a basket
of eligible (“deliverable”) bonds, there is always a bond that makes more economic sense than others to deliver. Therefore, the market assumes
that any contract seller will always deliver this “cheapest to deliver” bond in the event of delivery.
Think of it this way, if you are trading Coffee and you had to deliver Coffee to the Buyer at the Warehouse, and you had a choice between various
different grades and cost of Coffee, you would always deliver the cheapest grade of Coffee within the acceptable grades per the contract
specifications . Bond Deliveries are much the same.
http://www.eurexchange.com/exchange-en/market-data/clearing-data/deliverable-bonds-and-conversion-factors/Deliverable-Bonds-and-
Conversion-Factors/173146
Size wise, Bond futures are simply huge trading a notional daily volume of $12 trillion per day.
What is an interest rate swap?
An interest rate swap is an agreement between two parties to exchange one stream of interest payments for another, over a set
period of time. Swaps are derivative contracts and trade over-the-counter.
The most commonly traded and most liquid interest rate swaps are known as “vanilla” swaps, which exchange fixed-rate payments for
floating-rate payments based on LIBOR (London Inter-Bank Offered Rate), which is the interest rate high-credit quality banks charge
one another for short-term financing. LIBOR is the benchmark for floating short-term interest rates and is set daily. Although there are
other types of interest rate swaps, such as those that trade one floating rate for another, vanilla swaps comprise the vast majority of
the market.
The “swap rate” is the fixed interest rate that the receiver demands in
exchange for the uncertainty of having to pay the short-term LIBOR
(floating) rate over time. At any given time, the market’s forecast of
what LIBOR will be in the future is reflected in the forward LIBOR
curve.
At the time of the swap agreement, the total value of the swap’s fixed
rate flows will be equal to the value of expected floating rate
payments implied by the forward LIBOR curve. As forward
expectations for LIBOR change, so will the fixed rate that investors
demand to enter into new swaps. Swaps are typically quoted in this
fixed rate, or alternatively in the “swap spread,” which is the difference
between the swap rate and the equivalent local government bond
yield for the same maturity.
What is the Swap Curve?
Trading strategy; to take a view on the difference in rates between an Interest Rate Swap and a Government Bond.
Any interest rate swap will make or lose money as rates go up or down. But what if an investor does not have an
opinion on whether rates will go up or down? Perhaps, they think that the credit-worthiness of the financial
industry will change relative to sovereign debt? Maybe our investor thinks that markets are poised for a Flight to
Quality, or that other investors want to avoid Libor-based instruments and the lack of liquidity in associated swaps.
In this case, they can transact a Spread over.
Consider an investor who believes that 10 year Interest Rate Swaps will move differently to 10 year Government Bond yields. They
would be well served to enter into a Spread over trade. If they think 10 year Interest Rate Swap rates will go up by more (or go up
faster) than the yield on a 10 year Government Bond, then they should pay the fixed rate on a 10 year swap and buy the 10 year
Government Bond. If they think 10 year Interest Rate Swap rates will go down more (or go up slower) than 10 year Government Bond
yields, then they should receive on a 10 year swap and sell the 10 year Government Bond.
The “risk-free” term structure of interest rates is a key input to the pricing of derivatives. It is used for defining the expected growth rates of
asset prices in a risk-neutral world and for determining the discount rate for expected payoffs in this world. Before 2007, derivatives dealers
used LIBOR, the short-term borrowing rate of AA-rated financial institutions, as a proxy for the risk-free rate. The most widely traded
derivative is a swap where LIBOR is exchanged for a fixed rate. One of the attractions of using LIBOR as the risk-free rate was that the
valuation of this product was straightforward because the reference interest rate was the same as the discount rate.
The use of LIBOR to value derivatives was called into question by the credit crisis that started in mid-2007. Banks became increasingly
reluctant to lend to each other because of credit concerns. As a result, LIBOR quotes started to rise. The TED spread, which is the spread
between three-month U.S. dollar LIBOR and the three-month U.S. Treasury rate, is less than 50 basis points in normal market conditions.
Between October 2007 and May 2009, it was rarely lower than 100 basis points and peaked at over 450 basis points in October 2008.
Most derivatives dealers now use interest rates based on overnight indexed swap (OIS) rates rather than LIBOR when valuing collateralized
derivatives.
Overnight indexed swaps are interest rate swaps in which a fixed rate of interest is exchanged for a floating rate that is the geometric mean of
a daily overnight rate. The calculation of the payment on the floating side is designed to replicate the aggregate interest that would be earned
from rolling over a sequence daily loans at the overnight rate. In U.S. dollars, the overnight rate used is the effective federal funds rate. In
Euros, it is the Euro Overnight Index Average (EONIA) and, in sterling, it is the Sterling Overnight Index Average (SONIA). OIS swaps tend to
have relatively short lives (often three months or less). There are two sources of credit risk in an OIS. The first is the credit risk in overnight
federal funds borrowing which we have argued is very small. The second is the credit risk arising from a possible default by one of the swap
counterparties.
The three-month LIBOR-OIS spread is the spread between three-month LIBOR and the three-month OIS swap rate. This spread reflects the
difference between the credit risk in a three-month loan to a bank that is considered to be of acceptable credit quality and the credit risk in
continually-refreshed one-day loans to banks that are considered to be of acceptable credit quality. In normal market conditions it is about 10
basis points. However, it rose to a record 364 basis points in October 2008. By a year later, it had returned to more normal levels, but it rose
to about 30 basis points in June 2010 and to 50 basis points at the end of 2011 as a result of European sovereign debt concerns. These
statistics emphasize that LIBOR is a poor proxy for the risk-free rate in stressed market conditions.
Bundles.
ICE Futures Europe packs and bundles are recognized trading strategies that enable you to easily
execute a combination of contract months in Short-Term Interest Rate (STIR) Euribor, Sterling,
Eurodollar and Euroswiss futures contracts. This allows users to gain exposure to longer term interest
rates, without the legging risk and cost of trading the individual months.
Leg Pricing
Packs and Bundles prices will be quoted using the annualised price convention, also known as Average
Difference Change (ADC) Pricing. The tick increment to be used in the pack and bundle markets for
Three Month Sterling Futures will be:
The Exchange will use a price factor of 100 to convert the displayed screen price of a pack or bundle
into basis point tick increments. Packs and Bundles leg prices will be assigned in whole basis points
and allocated starting from the back months of the strategy and moving forwards. For example: a user
submits a price of 2.75, which is then converted to 0.0275 ticks by dividing the price by the price
factor (2.75/100). This tick price can then be assigned to each individual leg price.
What does a Listed Interest Swap look Like?
There are USD and Euro denominated Swap Futures with very similar contract specs, below I
have focused on the GBP denominated version. They are designed to give the holder (buyer or
seller of the swap) exactly the same economic cash flow as to holding a notionally equivalent
Interest Rate swap in the OTC Market.
£100,000 notional principal whose value is based upon the difference between a stream of
semi-annual fixed interest payments and a stream of quarterly or semi-annual floating interest
payments based on 3 or 6 month GBP LIBOR, over a term to maturity.
Quarterly IMM Dates (3rd Wednesday of each March, June, September, December) (e.g. 2YR
Tenor may read “Mar 18, 2015” or “Mar 15”) Up to 8 consecutive future Effective Dates
tradable at one time
The last day on which the Contract can be traded is the Holiday Calendar business day
preceding the Maturity Date. On the Last Trading Day trading will cease at 6:00 PM London
Time.
Net Present Value (“NPV”) per Contract will be used for trade execution. NPV is expressed in
per contract terms for the Buyer (Pay Fixed). Each Future negotiated in NPV terms has an
implicit Futures-Style Price of:
The B and C components are calculated once daily and applied by IFEU, and are not subject to
negotiation by the counterparties.
All the Interest Rate Markets discussed prior are linked intrinsically to one another.
Bootstrapping, interpolation and extrapolation are used commonly in the Interest Rate markets to plot yield curves. We don’t need to dive
into the math of these approaches, we just need to know this is how the Financial Engineers plot yield curves on a day to day basis.
Between each of the derivatives listed there is a Strong traded ‘basis’ product which ties all our Interest Rate curves together.
As the only key difference between an Interest Rate Swap and a Government bond with equal start dates and Maturity dates will be the
Credit Difference, it is no surprise the price difference will be very small and to the most part, the prices of the two instruments, will remain
tightly linked to one another. This strong ‘bond’ between these two instruments holds for all the tenors up and down the yield curve, 2yr,
3yr, 5yr, 10yr and 30yr.
Given Interest Rate Swaps are a string of Forward LIBOR Rates one would expect, and be right, that a 2 year EUR Interest Rate swap (a
string of 4 consecutive 6m EURIBOR rates) will resemble closely a string of 8 Euribor Futures (2 year bundle). There is a basis, which is
pretty constant, between 3Month and 6Month Euribor or Libor Rates, this is called the 3s*6s Basis.
IMM Dated Forward Rate Agreements or FRAs are the Over-the-Counter STIR essentially. The ONLY differences are the FRA is quoted in
Yield Terms and the STIR is quoted in terms of price (100-Yield) and that a FRA is quoted with another counterparty/Bank and a STIR is
traded in the Clearing House of an Exchange.
Bond Markets
Swap Spread Basis
OIS/Eonia/
Interest Rate
Sonia/Fed Swap Markets
Funds
FRAs STIRs
All the Interest Rate Markets discussed prior are linked intrinsically to one another, yet the curve shapes remain very similar.
The 2 year EUR Interest Rate Swap’s price discovery/direction is 97.5 % correlated on average to that of the 2year Shatz Future. To further
illustrate this tight ‘bond’ between these derivatives I have created two (intraday) charts below. The left hand chart shows the intraday price
movement of the actual Swap spread between the two derivatives. This shows a stable relationship between the two ‘different’ but highly
connected markets. The right hand chart illustrates the intraday price movements of the actual 2 products that create the 2 year EUR swap
spread, i.e. the 2year German Govt Bond (benchmark 2 year in Europe for 2 years) and the 2 year EUR Interest Rate Swap. It is no surprise that
the two derivatives are 97.5% correlated as you can see their close relationship in the chart, as one product trades higher so does the other
product.
Banks are the major users of Interest Rate Swaps and usually are the Major Market Makers to their clients (Hedge Funds and Asset Managers) Liquidity in both is
very high and these Major players will use both markets to hedge open positions when they need. If a Bank is requested to quote a large trade in the 2 year EUR
IRS from a client and then the client trades with him, he will use all the Tools he has in front of him to hedge the immediate ‘outright risk’ of the Interest Rate
swap. He will / could hedge all the risk in the 2yr Govt bond Future or a combination of both products. The Banks will then ‘warehouse this Basis Risk’ between
the two derivatives, much preferring this basis risk to outright exposure of the IRS.
Long Term Trends can drive Swap Spreads in one direction or another to form a Long Term Trend.
Despite this long term trend in the ‘basis’ between the two derivatives the intraday price action, of the component
legs of the basis, are highly correlated to one another and one we must watch.
Despite large fiscal deficits in the US, UK and Germany, government bond supply implies tighter spreads however the flight to quality from
Eurozone crisis and Central Bank bond buying have pushed swap spreads wider (higher, as illustrated in the 2 year chart of the EUR 2 year
Swap spread above). This widening is exacerbated as the panel of Euribor banks is made up of banks from the whole Eurozone as well as a
handful of non-Eurozone banks.
While the current Longer term drivers of the 2 European Swap spreads have been driven by the initial uncertainty around the partial
repayment of the 3 year LTRO and continued pressure from the European crisis, expectations of European interbank stress are contained by
the ECB’s actions and should keep a lid on further widening in this spread.
These longer term drivers of Swap spreads are very subtle or appear not present in the microstructure of the Euribor and Shatz futures, yet
underneath they are part of a strong current that we should understand at the very least.
Interest Rate Swaps, STIRs and Bond curve shapes.
Despite this long term trend in the ‘basis’ between the two derivatives the intraday price action, of the component
legs of the basis, are highly correlated to one another and one we must watch.
To highlight the symbiosis between the Shatz-Bund (bond spread - blue) and EUR 2yr-10yr (IRS spread - orange), I have overlaid a 60 minute
chart of each above.
Statistically these two spreads are 79% correlated in their price action.
a) Supply and Demand. These markets have different players making different trades at different times for different reasons.
b) Liquidity.
c) Slight difference in Duration. Bund is 9 years Approx. in Maturity and the 10 yr. EUR IRS start value spot and not Dec 2016 when the
Bund start date is.
Price action of 2 year Shatz, 2 year EUR IRS and 2year Euribor Bundle.
Despite this long term trend in the ‘basis’ between the two derivatives the intraday price action, of the component
legs of the basis, are highly correlated to one another and one we must watch.
Price action of 5 year Bobl, 5 year EUR IRS and 5 year Euribor Bundle.
Despite this long term trend in the ‘basis’ between the two derivatives the intraday price action, of the component
legs of the basis, are highly correlated to one another and one we must watch.
Price action of 10 year Bund future and the 10 year EUR IRS.
Despite this long term trend in the ‘basis’ between the two derivatives the intraday price action, of the component
legs of the basis, are highly correlated to one another and one we must watch.
Short Term Interest
Rates
What is a Short-Term Interest Rate Future (STIR)?
STIRs are very liquid instruments. They are one of the most important tools for managing interest rate risk.
The contracts are quoted as “100 minus interest rate” so that the price of the contract mirrors the
properties of a bond – price up, yield down and vice versa.
That’s so that us simple traders don’t get too confused when trading between different instruments!
STIRs at ICE Futures Europe
When ICE bought NYSE Euronext in 2012/2013, they also gained control of the LIFFE derivatives exchange in London. LIFFE is
an acronym for the London International Financial Futures Exchange. The STIR contracts traded on LIFFE are:
• Euribors, known as ‘Bors. These contracts cash settle at 100 minus the 3 month Euribor fixing. (see slide 48)
• Short Sterling. These contracts cash settle at 100 minus the 3 month GBP Libor fixing. (see slide 47)
• EuroSwissy. These contracts cash settle at 100 minus the 3 month CHF Libor fixing. (see slide 49)
And for completeness sake, the other notable STIRs around the globe are:
• Eurodollars, traded at CME. These contracts cash settle at 100 minus the 3 month USD Libor fixing. (see slide 50)
• Euroyen vs TIBOR, traded at SGX and TFX. These contracts cash settle at 100 minus the 3 month JPY Tibor fixing on
a notional of JPY100m.
• Aussie Bills, traded at ASX. These contracts are deliverable! Quoted as 100 minus the 3 month AUD BBSW fixing.
• Kiwi Bills, traded at ASX. These contracts cash settle at 100 minus the 3 month NZD BKBM fixing.
CME Eurodollar volumes are huge
You cannot get away from this fact as soon as you look at the data. Below is the percentage market share of the
STIR market by currency (last 12 months):
• The chart shows USD-equivalent notional volume traded each day in Eurodollars (USD), Euribors (EUR),
Short Sterling (GBP) and Euroswissy (CHF), expressed in percentage of total traded.
• The blue bars, representing USD notional traded dominate.
• As a rule of thumb, CME Eurodollars make up 70-75% of STIR trading on any given trading day.
Euribor volumes are surprisingly small
Ask any trader, and they will confidently assert that Euribors are liquid and Short Sterling is a pig to trade due to a
lack of liquidity. I was therefore surprised when I analysed recent volumes for the European STIR contracts:
a) Volume and Liquidity is important but does not guarantee or confirm whether a Particular
product can be a profitable product to trade.
b) The below Volume breakdown clearly shows a increase in Liquidity/volume in Short Sterling in
the last 4 months relative to the previous 2 months. This is mainly because of Volatility / Uncertainty around the
Brexit ( UK vote on EU referendum ) vote and outcome In June 2016.
c) Volume will pick up in Euribor and Euroswissy Futures if there is Economic news to impact
Interest Rates.
d) Negative Interest Rates / Low Interest Rate Policy by Central Bank is very damaging for Volumes
and Volatility in STIRs.
BREXIT affected volumes
One of the motivations to include ICE STIR volumes now is to monitor events in GBP markets. June saw elevated
volumes in Short Sterling as a result of the referendum:
• Volumes, in USD-notional equivalents, traded per day for Euribors (EUR), Short Sterling (GBP) and Euroswissy (CHF) for June
2016.
• Volumes in Short Sterling (in Red) have overtaken Euribors on 11 trading days in June!
• This might be a fleeting phenomenon, but anyone running risk in these products should be aware of these market
changes.
STIRs and FRAs
FRAs are essentially an OTC version of a STIR future. Less Liquidity (as you can see from the Volume comparison on
slide 49) but far more granularity in Maturity Dates.
An FRA is a contract in which the underlying rate is simply an interest payment, not a bond or time deposit, made in dollars, euribor
or any other currency at a rate that is appropriate for that currency. A forward rate agreement is a forward contact on a short-term
interest rate, usually LIBOR, in which cash flow obligations at maturity are calculated on a notional amount and based on the
difference between a predetermined forward rate and the market rate prevailing on that date. The settlement date of an FRA is the
date on which cash flow obligations are determined.
FRAs are essentially an OTC version of a STIR future. Less Liquidity (as you can see from the Volume comparison)
but far more granularity in Maturity Dates.
• Aggregated weekly notional amounts of STIR futures (Euribors, Short Sterling and Euroswissy) vs FRAs (EUR,
GBP and CHF).
• On average, FRA notional traded makes up around 20% of total short-term interest rate risk.
• This is a much higher percentage than I anticipated. In futures markets there is a lot of risk recycling by
liquidity providers, which inflates volumes for a given change in open interest.
• FRA volumes are far more likely to be down to risk management of large swaps desks – akin to
“compressing” short dated interest rate risk of swaps with FRAs.
Fed Funds Futures
The Fed Funds futures contract price represents the market opinion of the average daily fed funds effective rate as
calculated and reported by the Federal Reserve Bank of New York for a given calendar month. It is designed to
capture the market’s need for an instrument that reflects Federal Reserve monetary policy. Because the Fed Fund
futures contract is based on the daily fed funds effective rate for a given month, it tends to be highly correlated
with other short-term interest rates and is useful for managing the risk associated with changing credit costs for
virtually any short-term cash instrument. Fed Funds futures can be used either speculatively to anticipate changes
in monetary policy or more conservatively to hedge inventory financing risk across many different markets.
a) Notional Face Value of $5,000,000 for one month calculated on a 30-day basis at a rate
equal to the average daily Fed funds effective rate for the delivery month.
b) 100 minus the average daily Fed Funds effective rate for the delivery month.
c) Nearest month: one-quarter of one basis point (0.0025), or $10.4175 per contract. All other
contract months: one-half of one basis point (0.005), or $20.835 per contract.
d) 36 consecutive Monthly contracts listed (3years)
e) Last business day of the delivery month. Trading in expiring contracts closes at 4:00 p.m.,
Chicago time (CT), on the last trading day.
The CME Group FedWatch tool lets you quickly gauge the market’s expectations of potential changes to the fed
funds target rate at upcoming FOMC meetings. Users can view the probabilities of future rate
movements for the next scheduled FOMC meeting, as well as the probabilities of rate movements for deferred
FOMC meetings.
cmegroup.com/fedwatch
tool, visit
CME Group FedWatch Tool
Below you have the CME Group Fed Watch tool. This computes, by upcoming Fed Fund Futures Contracts, the
current expectation (by current Market Price of Fed Funds Futures) of a change in Monetary Policy by the federal
reserve.
On the Right hand side you have the FOMC’s assessment of the future path of Interest Rates given the current
FOMC projections on Growth and Inflation. tool, visit
Short Term Interest Rates refer to the Interest Rates of derivatives with a Residual
maturity of 5 years or less. In the Over-The-Counter (OTC) Short term interest rate
markets you can trade as short as Overnight and 1 week.
These are not the Interest Rates at which the bonds were issued rather the interest rates
implied by the prices at which these (Government and Corporate) Bonds are being
traded in the financial markets.
Euribor 3 Month Interest Rate Futures – Tracks 3 month EUR Euribor Interest Rate
Short Sterling 3 month Interest Rate – Tracks 3 Month GBP Libor Interest Rate
EuroSwiss 3 Month Interest Rate – Tracks 3 month CHF Libor Interest Rate
Eurodollar 3 month Interest Rate – Tracks 3 month USD Libor Interest Rate
Canadian 90 Day Bankers Acceptance – Tracks 90 Day CAD Bankers
Acceptance Interest Rate
ICE 3 month Short Sterling Futures (LL):
Cash Settled future based on ICE benchmark Administration limited London Interbank
Offered Rate (ICE LIBOR) rate for three months deposits.
Notional: £500,000
Quotation: 100 minus Rate of Interest
Minimum Price Movement & tick Value: 0.005 Front month £6.25
0.01 All other Contracts £12.50
Trading Hours: 07:30 AM – 18:00 PM London Time
Last Trading Day: 11:00 on the 3rd Wednesday of Delivery month
Execution algorithm: Time Based Pro-Rata matching algorithm
Settlement: Based on ICE benchmark LIBOR for 3 month Sterling deposits at 11:00 on Last Trading
Day.
Delivery Months: March, June, September, December such that there are 26 delivery months are
available for trading. In addition to this at the Front of curve there are 3 consecutive Monthly
contracts.
Related Products:
Cash Settled future based on EMMI EURIBOR rate for three month deposits.
Related Products:
Euribor Calendar Spreads, Euribor Butterfly, Euribor Condors, Euribor Combos, Euribor Options.
ICE 3 month EuroSwiss Futures (EuroSwiss):
Cash Settled future based on Swiss Franc LIBOR rate for three month deposits.
Related Products:
Euroswiss Calendar Spreads, Euroswiss Butterfly, Euroswiss Condors, Euroswiss Combos, Euroswiss
Options.
CME 3 month EuroDollar Futures (Eurodollar):
Cash Settled future based on Swiss Franc LIBOR rate for three month deposits.
Notional: $1,000,000
Minimum Price Movement: 0.0025 Very Front contract Tick Value $6.25
Minimum Price Movement: 0.005 Very Front contract Tick Value $12.50
Quotation: 100 minus Rate of Interest
Trading Hours: 17:00 PM – 16:00 PM Chicago Time (23 Hours)
Last Trading Day: 11:00 Two Business days prior to the 3rd Wednesday of Delivery month
Execution algorithm: Pro-Rata matching algorithm
Settlement: Based on the ICE Benchmark Administration Limited LIBOR Rate (ICE LIBOR) for three
month EuroDollar deposits at 11:00 London time on the Last Trading day.
Delivery Months: March, June, September, December such that there are 40 delivery months are
available for trading. In Addition to these there are four monthly contracts at the very front of the
curve.
Related Products:
Eurodollar Calendar Spreads, Eurodollar Butterfly, Eurodollar Condors, Eurodollar Combos, Eurodollar
Options.
What are Three month Short term Contracts (STIRs) ?
The actual current trading price (as in 99.59 for Dec 2019)
almost never will be equal to the actual LIBOR Rate on that
expiry date. It is the current perception of where the LIBOR
would fix.
Starting from the top with the ‘naked’ outright future (long
or short) and moving down to the bottom to the 6 month
Condor, each strategy increases in potential amount of risk
associated with that strategy. We look at that as the actual
and potential volatility associated with that strategy.
Top of Book refers to the Best Bid Ask Price in the Central Limit Order book (CLOB) at any time. The VWAP calculated here takes into account all the Best Bids and
offers in the CLOB and their Size and calculates the average price based on price and volume at any time. You can see this in the snapshot in the column G under AVG.
In the example of LL Jun17-Sep17-Dec17 the VWAP Price is consistent with the CLOB price with a skew of 3 times the amount of orders looking to sell this
combination than buy it at the current price. In the example of LL Jun17-Sep17-Dec17 Prices created from the outrights, it is suggesting that the bid price of -0.01 is
weak and despite having 8491 lots on the bid, potentially could trade out lower.
LL Futures, Calendar Spreads and Butterflies.
What Drives Price Discovery of the LL Futures, Calendar spreads and Butterflies?
a) Domestic Central Bank Policy – Fundamental Analysis of Current Central Bank Policy
b) Political Backdrop
c) Global Central Policy
d) Government Bond Market Prices
e) Quantitative Research and Technical research.
What can we take away from the below .jpg of Short Sterling futures prices on Central bank Policy and market Interpretation of the current and Future
Economic climate?
a) LL Futures are pricing in a Future Easing in UK interest Rates of 11 to 12 bps between SEP2016 and SEP2017, which
signifies UK economic outlook looks more weak than strong.
b) Between DEC2017 and DEC2020 the Market is expecting that the current Economic weakness will subside a little (Hence
DEC2020 is pricing in a Higher Interest Rate than DEC2017) and Economic activity would increase.
c) Despite the BOE/MPC having cut rates in August2016 the market is expecting a further easing before the current
Economic downturn subsides.
Short Sterling (LL) Sep2017, LL Sep2017-Dec2017 & LL Sep2017-Dec2017-Mar2018 Butterfly
Analysing the ranges for the last 6 months you can determine how Volatile each
of the contracts are. We calculate this by comparing the last 6 months trading
range versus the Bid-Ask spread of each Contract:
What can take away from this .jpg on LL Futures and Strategies and the Bid-Ask
Analysis above?
STIR Futures prices are ONLY the Current Market perception of where Future 3 Month ICE LIBOR will be set and NOT the current LIBOR Rate.
The LL futures price action takes into account Day by Day Economic Updates to gauge where future policy will be set. As you can imagine these
are almost always wrong to where the actual rate is set as predicting such accurate points in time’s LIBOR rates is next to impossible.
Central Banks usually move, with the exception of the Bank of Japan (BOJ) and the European Central Bank (ECB), in 25 or 50 Basis Points. The
BOJ and ECB have recently started to move in 10 basis point increments.
LL futures move in 1 Basis Point increments, so very gradual/small compared to the Central Bank Policy moves.
A) LL Futures 31st August 2016. Gloomy Economic Data Pushed Market B) LL Futures 1st September 2016. UK economic activity gripped with concern over Brexit
Sentiment that the BOE-MPC would ease Interest Rates. impact, despite this, UK Manufacturing Data suggested the Economy remains strong, and up to
8 Basis points of Easing is removed from LL futures.
Rule 2.
STIR futures are very sensitive to every piece of Economic data, Central Bank release and Geopolitical news. Such that in the short space of time
between Diagram A (31st August 2016) to Diagram B (1st September 2016) the LL Futures perception of Future ICE 3 month LIBOR rates can
change from very gloomy (probability of further Interest Rate cut by the BOE-MPC) to very positive (probability of further Interest Rate Rise by
the BOE-MPC).
A) LL Futures 31st August 2016. Gloomy Economic Data Pushed Market B) LL Futures 1st September 2016. UK economic activity gripped with concern over Brexit
Sentiment that the BOE-MPC would ease Interest Rates. impact, despite this, UK Manufacturing Data suggested the Economy remains strong, and up to
8 Basis points of Easing is removed from LL futures.
Rule 3.
The 3 month ICE LIBOR rate is NOT the Bank Of England Bank Rate. The ICE LIBOR Rate is the rate at which banks will borrow from one another
in the International Money Markets. As you can imagine the UK Government has a higher credit Rating (Aaa or there about) and Interbank
Credit Rating is somewhere between A to BBB. Much like in the Real world those with Better credit Ratings can borrow money cheaper than
those with adverse Credit ratings. This means that the ICE GBP 3 month LIBOR Rate is higher than the UK Bank Rate, usually around 12 basis
points higher.
B) LL Futures 1st September 2016. UK economic activity gripped with concern over Brexit
A) LL Futures 31st August 2016. Gloomy Economic Data Pushed Market impact, despite this, UK Manufacturing Data suggested the Economy remains strong, and up to
Sentiment that the BOE-MPC would ease Interest Rates. 8 Basis points of Easing is removed from LL futures.
Rule 4.
Central Banks meet every month or two to analyse the current economic climate and plan a path of Monetary policy that can ensure the
economy meets their mandate. This mandate is devised to ensure long Term growth for the Country. Central Banks (BOE-MPC) are often
‘bombarded’ with dozens of confusing sets of economic data to analyse to determine the correct path of interest Rates. Often these interest
Rates are set to ensure Inflation remains at the correct level (not to high not to low)
Central Banks are looking at the exact same economic data that banks, Hedge Funds and Prop traders are. With this, the Market knows from
historical Evidence and mathematical probability of how certain sets of Data will impact the LL futures prices and ultimately the 3 month ICE
LIBOR Rate. Therefore, markets are quite efficient in pricing in probability changes in perception of future interest Rates. These changes are
evident in the two diagrams below.
B) LL Futures 1st September 2016. UK economic activity gripped with concern over Brexit
A) LL Futures 31st August 2016. Gloomy Economic Data Pushed Market impact, despite this, UK Manufacturing Data suggested the Economy remains strong, and up to
Sentiment that the BOE-MPC would ease Interest Rates. 8 Basis points of Easing is removed from LL futures.
Classic Curve Shape of STIR Futures (LL)
The magnitude of the economic data news will impact the propensity of changes in LL futures and where the Inflection point is located. During
the 2008 Financial crisis daily price fluctuations were over 50 basis points in LL futures.
A C
B
D
Classic Shape 1: Weak Economic Data, STIR futures (LL) go higher/Lower Interest Rates.
The Chart above depicts the Short Sterling futures moves from the start of day (Blue line) to the End of Day (Orange line), these are in Tick Increments where in the example Mar17
closed at 0.020 up on the day.
What ever causes the STIR markets to move at any point in time the STIR futures (LL) will react in a highly repetitive manner. This pattern of cause and reaction is displayed in all
STIR curves. The only difference between different STIRs will be the ‘PIVOT’ point. Above diagram shows the inflection point marked with arrow C. Usually this inflection point is
located in the future where monetary Policy can have had enough time to impact the current economic climate. Thus will need reversing with the opposite monetary policy.
A – All STIR futures curves will roll down to the current ICE 3 month LIBOR rate. With Central Banks policy changes usually 6 to 9 months in the future the very front contracts will
be least impacted by the bad Economic news and will rise very small.
B – STIR futures will start to predict from the Economic bad data, that there is higher probability of BOE-MPC cutting interest rates than before. This drives the contracts from DEC
2016 to Mar2018 to go higher (lower int rates)
C – The current LL futures inflection point. This is usually the highest Point of the LL futures Daily move where the Economic news is bad.
D – In this typical STIR Futures up move the Markets will start to predict that the LL futures should not be higher than the contracts at Point C because it believes that the economic
Data will improve with the stimulus from the Central Banks, thus increasing probability that the Central banks will reverse the Interest Rate cut with a hike.
This shape of the STIR curve will ensure you understand where each STIR future should be trading in an up move* of LL futures. As most of you will only trade as far as the 12th LL
future the General rule is Economic Data/News Weak Back contracts rise more than the front. Conversely, we see the opposite if the Economic News is good.
* An up move in LL futures is defined as where the LL futures prices are trading higher than yesterday’s settlement (closing price)
Classic Curve Shape of STIR Futures (LL)
Classic Shape 1: Very Strong Economic Data, STIR futures (LL) go lower/Higher Interest Rates.
The Chart above depicts the Short Sterling futures moves from the start of day (Blue line) to the End of Day (Orange line), these
are in Tick Increments where in the all STIR curves.
A) The Inflection point in the STIR futures (LL) curve moves much further down the curve. This inflection point in this instance
reflects where the market is increasing the probability that GBP LIBOR rates, after the Strong Economic Data, will increase
from previous levels out to Dec 2020.
B) The General rule of thumb that the further out the LL future is it will move more (up or down depending on the direction) than
the nearer in contracts up until the inflection point.
C) Thankfully, the inflection point does not jump around much. This is because Central banks will keep communicate and be
transparent on their Economic Planning/monetary policy.
Classic Curve Shapes at end or Beginning of an Economic / Business Cycle
At the beginning or end of an Economic Cycle you will expect to see a change
in Monetary Policy to either; a) Cut Interest Rates to promote Spending and
Lending in the Real Economy or b) Raise Interest Rates to reduce Lending, cool
the Economy and encourage People to Save.
Either way as the UK Bank Rate and the ICE three month Libor rates are highly
correlated to one another in their direction, the LL Futures will begin to move.
Remember the LL futures are prediction of the Future ICE LIBOR at each point
in time.
Note -No-one really knows the exact point that you enter a new Business
cycle until you are months into it as you can go into a new cycle and come out
very quickly.
If the UK economy had been growing too fast and Interest Rates were too Low
for the Growth path (U.K. Bank Rate & ICE GBP LIBOR will Rise) or the UK
economy had been growing too slow and Interest Rates were too High for the
Growth path (U.K. Bank Rate & ICE GBP LIBOR will Fall) Either way UK Interest
Rates will need to be on a new Path. In these scenarios we will expect to see;
a) Scenario Need for Rate Cuts from opposite Rate path course – Bear
Steepening curve shape. 70-80% of the time in this phase the LL futures
will trade higher.
b) Scenario Need for Rate Hikes from opposite or neutral Rate path course
– Bull Flattening curve shape. 70-80% of the time in this phase the LL
futures will trade lower.
Classic Curve Shapes in the middle of an Economic / Business Cycle
The Middle of the Business cycle refers to the state of the Economy when a
direction of growth or weakness is experienced for a prolonged period of
time. This will be confirmed by Economic Data pointing to sustained strength
or weakness. Central Banks will talk about a path of Interest Rate Cuts or
Rises.
In an Interest Rate cutting Cycle where the Economy is not strong enough and
needs stimulus, the curve shape will be 70-80% of the time Bull Steepening.
This is because Interest Cuts in the next few years will improve the economic
climate and at some point in the future will be unwound by removing these
cuts and possibly Raise Interest Rates as Inflation and growth Picks up.
In an Interest Rate Raising (Hiking) Cycle where the Economy is too strong and
needs stimulus removed, the curve shape will be 70-80% of the time Bear
Flattening. This is because Interest Raises in the next few years will lower/cool
the economic climate and at some point in the future will be unwound by
removing these Hikes and possibly cutting Interest Rates as Inflation and
growth slows down.
The Inflection point of each of these curves is usually around the 5th Generic
STIR (LL) to the 12th Generic STIR (LL)
Thank you