HURS107-Week 6 Lecture
HURS107-Week 6 Lecture
Lesson 1 Complete!
You completed the first lesson of this lecture. Please scroll down to complete the Check
Your Knowledge activity, in which you answer four True/False questions. You will
have unlimited attempts to do this activity, so do not worry if you do not get it correct
the first time. This is a non-graded activity.
Article Takeaways
In the 1980s, the biggest component of executive compensation was cash. Now, the
biggest component is stock options. The main goal in granting stock options is to tie
pay to performance. By increasing the number of shares executives control, option
grants have strengthened the link between pay and performance. There are some critics
that argue stock options do not work and they reward executives even if performance is
subpar.
Perquisites
Perquisites are ‘indirect pay or noncash privileges” (Designing Executive
Compensation…, n.d.). They include benefits such as company cars, free lunch, legal
services, security detail and travel perks.
Perquisites serve the following four purposes:
Lesson 2 Complete!
You completed the second lesson of this lecture. Please scroll down to complete the
Check Your Knowledge activity, in which you answer four True/False questions. You
will have unlimited attempts to do this activity, so do not worry if you do not get it
correct the first time. This is a non-graded activity.
True or False: Executive pay policies and rewards must reflect the mission, vision and
values of the organization
True or False: Long-term incentive plans have performance measurement period of
two years or more.
(3 years or more)
True or False: Stock options can be used alone or in combination with nonqualified
stock options.
True or False: One component of an executive compensation plan is bonuses.
True or False: Another name for perquisites is performance pay.
(perks)
Public
Most executives want to preserve a positive public image. Most executive
compensation packages do not warrant public outcry. In fact, only about 10 percent of
companies who have executive rewards strategies find themselves in the spotlight
(Graham, Roth & Dugan, 2018). Public outcry has caused some companies to reevaluate
their executive compensation strategies.
One of the ramifications of public dissatisfaction with executive pay is strikes. Strikes
are used to bring more attention to pay equity issues and can paint the organization in a
bad light. This is especially troubling when organizations have layoffs and/or have low
profits but executives still receive their total compensation.
Unions
Historically, unions had little influence over the design of executive pay. “Today,
employee unions are becoming increasingly active in trying to influence executive
reward program design” (Graham, Roth & Dugan, 2018, p. 25). Unions highlight the
exorbitant CEO packages to bring light to income inequality. However, unions have
also been criticized for being hypocrites in this fight. Please read the article titled, “Big
Labor Slams CEO Pay, While Ignoring Fat Salaries for Union Bosses” written by
Investor’s Business Daily’s Editorial Board. After reading the article, answer the
following question:
Do you believe it is hypocritical for unions to criticize CEO salaries when some
union bosses have higher salaries? Explain your answer.
Please click the link below to read the article:
Big Labor Slams CEO Pay, While Ignoring Fat Salaries for Union Bosses
Article Takeaways
The article suggests that the AFL-CIO releases misleading data regarding executive
compensation each year, while failing to acknowledge that union bosses have bigger
salaries than CEOs. The average wage for all CEOs in 2016 was $194,350. Labor union
presidents made an average of $252,370, plus another $31,000 in benefits. The highest
paid union president made $526,292, plus $250,000 in benefits.
Government
The U.S. government regulates executive compensation through the following agencies:
Department of Labor (DOL) & ERISA – the DOL Employee Benefit Security
Administration determined that pension funds had a “fiduciary obligation to
vote all proxies in the best interest of their beneficiaries” (Department of
Labor…, n.d., para. 1). A fiduciary is a person or organization that acts on behalf
of another person or persons to manage money (para. 1).
Department of the Treasury – the Treasury Department ensures that taxes and
the ability to defer taxation of executive compensation is done correctly
(Department of Labor…, n.d., para. 1).
Internal Revenue Service (IRS) – the IRS enforces tax codes passed by Congress
which provide rules for executive compensation (Department of Labor…, n.d.,
para. 1).
Securities and Exchange Commission - The Securities and Exchange Commission
is the primary regulator of financial markets in the United States. “The SEC’s
mission is to protect investors, maintain fair, orderly, and efficient markets, and
to facilitate capital formation” (Department of Labor…, n.d., para. 1).
Dodd-Frank Act
In 2010, President Obama signed into law the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and
Consumer Protection Act of 2010 (Dodd-Frank). The act mostly covers regulatory
reform for the financial sector. However, it contains several executive compensation
reforms that apply to most U.S. public companies. Some of the provisions include:
shareholder voting on executive compensation (“say-on-pay”) and golden
parachutes;
new independence requirements and considerations for compensation
committees and their advisers;
shareholder access to proxy materials to nominate directors;
executive compensation disclosures of pay-versus-performance and internal pay
equity;
a requirement that companies adopt a policy providing for the recovery of
executive compensation in the event of a financial statement restatement (a
“clawback policy”);
disclosure of company policies on hedging of company securities by directors or
employees;
elimination of discretionary voting by brokers on executive compensation and
other matters;
elimination of the requirement for auditor attestation regarding internal controls
for non-accelerated filers; and
revisions to SEC beneficial ownership and Section 16 short-swing profit
reporting.
(Kinel, 2010, para. 2).
Lesson 3 Complete!
You completed the third lesson of this lecture. Please scroll down to complete the
Check Your Knowledge activity, in which you answer four True/False questions. You
will have unlimited attempts to do this activity, so do not worry if you do not get it
correct the first time. This is a non-graded activity.
Check your Knowledge #3
True or False: External factors that influence executive compensation include the public,
government and unions.
True or False: The IRS- ensures that taxes and the ability to defer taxation of executive
compensation is done correctly
(Treasury Department ensures that taxes and the ability to defer taxation of executive
compensation is done correctly
True or False: The Dodd-Frank Act contains several executive compensation reforms
that apply to most U.S. public companies.
True or False: Historically, unions had little influence over the design of executive pay.
In your opinion, is it ethical for CEOs to be the chair of the board of directors?
Explain.
Please click the link below to read the article:
Corporate Boards and self-dealing lead to outrageous CEO pay
Compensation Consultants
Compensation consultants are independent advisors who are often retained by the
Compensation Committee to provide advice on executive compensation. Nearly 90% of
large companies use compensation consultants and 90% of retention agreements are
made directly with the Compensation Committee or Board. In addition to traditional
compensation consultants, advisors to the Compensation Committee may include tax
and accounting experts in particularly complex situations (Novick, 2019).
Lesson 4 Complete!
You completed the fourth lesson of this lecture. Please scroll down to complete the
Check Your Knowledge activity, in which you answer four True/False questions. You
will have unlimited attempts to do this activity, so do not worry if you do not get it
correct the first time. This is a non-graded activity.
In order to identify potential conflicts of interest surrounding executive pay that impact
company culture, companies should do the following:
Do not provide multi-period compensation packages.
Carefully monitor CEO and financial analyst relationships.
Establish an independent compensation committee composed of board members
without CEO participation.
Limit to only the CEO and certain top executives the grant of options and
deferred stock, and with these, make every effort to establish true estimates of
costs to the company and their impact on the CEO and firm value.
(FTI Journal, n.d., para. 3).
Why does the author believe the limiting the deductibility of executive
compensation in excel of $1 million is a failed solution?
Do you agree with the author’s findings?
Article Takeaways
The author, John Coble, believes executives are being paid excessive amounts for no
valid reason. He also believes the current tax code does little to eliminate excessive pay
packages. He believes a better tax solution would be to tax the excess of the average
worker’s pay for the company at 100%. This would do a lot to reduce income inequality
and bring average worker’s compensation closer to the actual value that the worker
brings to the company.
Lesson 5 Complete!
You completed the fifth lesson of this lecture. Please scroll down to complete the Check
Your Knowledge activity, in which you answer four True/False questions. You will
have unlimited attempts to do this activity, so do not worry if you do not get it correct
the first time. This is a non-graded activity.
Conclusion
Executive compensation will continue to be in the spotlight and face controversy. The
focus on pay equity is the driving force behind eliminating many of the exorbitant
compensation packages CEOs receive. Legislation such as Dodd-Frank has assisted in
this effort with Say-on-Pay’ votes that allow shareholders to express their views on
executive compensation. However, these votes do not determine how much executives
will be paid. Boards of directors, their Compensation Committees, and compensation
consultants design, structure, and approve compensation plans. Ultimately the decision
on executive compensation falls on the Board.
References:
Baker, D., Bivens, J., & Schieder, J. (2019). Reigning in CEO Compensation and
Curbing the Rise of Inequality. Retrieved from
https://www.epi.org/publication/reining-in-ceo-compensation-and-curbing-
the-rise-of-inequality/
Centers on Executive Compensation Website. (n.d.). Department of Labor & ERISA.
Retrieved from http://execcomp.org/Issues/Issue/department-of-labor-and-
erisa.
Centers on Executive Compensation Website. (n.d.). Department of the Treasury.
Retrieved from http://execcomp.org/Issues/Issue/department-of-labor-and-
erisa.
Centers on Executive Compensation Website. (n.d.). Internal Revenue Service.
Retrieved from http://execcomp.org/Issues/Issue/department-of-labor-and-
erisa.
Centers on Executive Compensation Website. (n.d.). Securities and Exchange
Commission. Retrieved from http://execcomp.org/Issues/Issue/department-of-
labor-and-erisa.
Chand, S. (n.d.). 7 Important Theories That Can Explain Executive Compensation.
Retrieved from http://www.yourarticlelibrary.com/business-management/7-
important-theories-that-can-explain-executive-compensation/2595.
Coble, J. (2019, June 18). How to Solve the Disparity Between Executive Compensation
and the Average Employee’s Wages. Retrieved from
https://medium.com/swlh/how-to-solve-the-disparity-between-executive-
compensation-and-the-average-employees-wages-9972e2d6679a.
FTI Journal Website. (April 2010) Executive Compensation: A New Solution to an Old
Problem. Retrieved from http://www.ftijournal.com/article/Executive-
Compensation-A-New-Solution-to-an-Old-Problem.
Graham, M., Roth, T., & Dugan, D. (2018). Effective Executive Compensation.
New York, NY: AMACOM.
Hall, B. (2000, March-April). What Your Need to Know About Stock Options.
Retrieved from https://hbr.org/2000/03/what-you-need-to-know-about-stock-
options.
Investor’s Business Daily Website. (2017, May 15). Big Labor Slams CEO Pay, While
Ignoring Fat Salaries For Union Bosses. Retrieved from
https://www.investors.com/politics/editorials/big-labor-slams-ceo-pay-while-
ignoring-fat-salaries-for-union-bosses/.
Kinel, D. (October 2010). The Impact of the Dodd-Frank Act on Executive
Compensation and Corporate Governance. Retrieved from
http://www.marcumllp.com/insights-news/the-impact-of-the-dodd-frank-act-
on-executive-compensation-and-corporate-governance
McCrimmon, M. (n.d.). What is an executive? Retrieved from
https://www.lead2xl.com/what-is-an-executive.
Novick, B. (2019, July 31). Executive Compensation: The Role of Public Company
Shareholders. Retrieved from
https://corpgov.law.harvard.edu/2019/07/31/executive-compensation-the-
role-of-public-company-shareholders/.
PayScale Website. (2009, August 29). How to Design an Executive Compensation
Policy. Retrieved from
https://www.payscale.com/compensation-today/2009/08/how-to-design-an-
executive-compensation-policy.
Quader, A. (2015). Difference Between Executive and Manager. Retrieved from
https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/difference-between-executive-manager-
ahmed-abdul-qader/.
Reh, J. (2018, October 29). Senior Management-Level Jobs. Retrieved from
https://www.thebalancecareers.com/senior-management-level-jobs-2275744.
Shampine, R. (2016, November 11). How Executive Compensation Plans Work.
Retrieved from https://youtu.be/IHX-_8yvbL0.
SHRM Website. (n.d.). Designing Executive Compensation Plans. Retrieved from
https://www.shrm.org/resourcesandtools/tools-and-samples/toolkits/pages/
executivecompensationplans.aspx.
SpencerStuart Website. (n.d.) Retrieved from
https://www.spencerstuart.com/research-and-insight/ssbi-2018.
Swinford, D. (October 2017). Supporting Culture Through Compensation, Recognition,
and Reward Systems. Retrieved from
https://www.pearlmeyer.com/knowledge-share/article/supporting-culture-
through-compensation-recognition-and-reward-systems-page.
Talent Lyft. (n.d.). Retrieved from https://www.talentlyft.com/en/resources/what-is-
executive-compensation.
Thomson, L. (2009, January 18). What is Corporate Governance? Retrieved from
https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/money-you/what-is-corporate-
governance/articleshow/3995278.cms?from=mdr.
Tomlinson, C. (2019, June 17). Corporate Boards and self-dealing lead to outrageous
CEO pay. Retrieved from
https://www.houstonchronicle.com/business/columnists/tomlinson/article/
Corporate-boards-and-self-dealing-leads-to-13969309.php.