MSM Dec2023
MSM Dec2023
Cover image is
courtesy of
Satellogic.
Publishing Operations Features
& Issue Contributors
Gilat Satellite Networks: Year In Review—Shaping The Future Of Global Security......4
Author: Doreet Oren
Silvano Payne
Publisher + Executive Author
Government Satellite Report: NRO, industry, unite for space-based.............................8
Simon Payne intelligence architecture
Chief Technical Officer Author: David Pesgraves
Hartley G. Lesser
Editorial Director + Author Transforming Military Comms Through LEO Connectivity............................... 10
Author: Rick Lober
Pattie Lesser
Executive Editor + Author
Satellite Manufacturers Stuck In Orbit.............................................................. 12
Donald McGee Author: Tom Hennessey
Production Manager
Sean Payne
Business Development Mgr. Liability In The Orbits: The Challenge Of Assigning Responsibility................ 16
Author: Salouda Moutaoufik
Dan Makinster
Technical Advisor
COMMAND CENTER: Ed Slater, OneWeb Technologies.................................. 18
Curt Blake
Senior Columnist
Quadsat: Year In Review...................................................................................... 22
Author: Joakim Espeland
Chris Forrester
Senior Columnist
COMMAND CENTER: Matt Tirman, Satellogic.................................................. 24
Karl Fuchs
Senior COLUMNIST
Space Safety: Challenges and Developments................................................... 26
Rick Lober Author: Joe Chan
Senior Columnist
Salouda Moutaoufik Comtech (formerly Comtech Xicom Technology, Inc.).................... Cover (1) + 7
MilsatMagazine is published 11 times per year by SatNews Publishers, 800 Siesta Way, Sonoma, California - 94576 - USA — Phone: (707) 939-9306 / Fax: (707) 939-9235 © 2023 SatNews Publishers
We reserve the right to edit all submitted materials to meet publication content guidelines, as well as for grammar and spelling errors, or to move articles to an alternative issue to accommodate publication space requirements, or remove
content due to space restrictions or unacceptable content. Submission of articles does not constitute acceptance of said material by SatNews Publishers. Edited materials may, or may not, be returned to authors and/or companies for
review, prior to publication. The views expressed in SatNews Publishers’ various publications do not necessarily reflect the views opinions of SatNews Publishers. All rights reserved. All included imagery is courtesy of, and copyright to,
the respective companies and/or named individuals. SatNews reserves the right to alter publication dates and print issue designations, based on industry event date changes and circumstances that are beyond the control of SatNews
Publishers or the company’s staff.
Gilat’s SATCOM solutions have been designed specifically to meet the needs
of today’s net-centric battlefield, including flexible, secure platforms for
huge amounts of data and high-bandwidth applications to connect soldiers,
platforms, and terminals across land, sea, and air; continuous and resilient
connectivity to ensure that information is available when, where and how it is
needed; with all necessary technology, equipment, applications, products, and
solutions under one roof.
The Elastix-Architecture is a cloud-based distributed architecture, enabling Gilat also received initial orders for the SkyEdge IV Aquarius modems from
the ability to split between transmission functions located in the gateway and two leading defense system integrators in the U.S. These are the first steps in
data processing SW-based functions which can be flexibly deployed on cloud establishing a significant channel for Gilat’s next-generation modems based on
servers located anywhere in the network. U.S. government demand.
Gilat developed two unique VSATs specifically to address the special needs of
military and government organizations: Acquisition Of DataPath
SkyEdge IV Aquarius is an ultra-high-performance family of VSATs Earlier this year, Gilat signed an agreement to acquire DataPath Inc., a leading
providing security forces with ruggedized terminals that can be deployed U.S. Defense Satellite integrator.
on vehicles or carried in a backpack, ensuring seamless connectivity for
both on-the-move and on-the-pause missions. It further delivers reliable
beyond-line-of-sight (BLoS) connectivity between command and tactical
levels, allowing a seamless flow of information. Our resilient networks
provide true interoperability, drastically reducing the time between decision,
implementation, and evaluation. In addition, Gilat’s low SWaP systems allow
military and border patrol teams to exploit the full potential of long-endurance
missions with airborne, maritime, and land-based communications.
Global satellite operators Intelsat and SES have already selected Gilat’s These attributes have enabled DataPath to secure and maintain their continual
SkyEdge IV to support new satellites. SES will use the SkyEdge IV platform presence in the provision and sustainment of MILSATCOM systems, such as
to simultaneously operate with its SES-17 satellite and its upcoming second- portable ground stations and related services.
generation NGSO constellation, O3b mPOWER. Intelsat will use the SkyEdge
IV platform to provide expanded capacity from the Intelsat IS-40e satellite.
Solid-State Power Amplifier Wartime and tactical missions often take forces into unfamiliar territory crawling
with unpredictable and unknown threats. Access to real-time intelligence on
Gilat’s U.S.-based subsidiary, Wavestream, launched Endurance, a new line the ground — where and when troops need it — can make all the difference
of high-power, “always-on” Solid-State Power Amplifier (SSPA) products. It is between a successful and an aborted mission.
positioned to lead the industry in linear power with its gateway-ready, fully redundant
design that ensures the maximum available power for multiple carrier inputs. Gilat continues to dedicate strategic resources to providing defense
organizations with the technology, expertise, local presence, and support they
The 500W Ka-Wideband Block Upconverter (BUC) covers military Ka- and need to meet their current and future military needs.
commercial Ka- frequency bands and features hot-swappable components for
a truly “always-on” satellite communication solution. Endurance is unique in its www.gilat.com
ability to replace existing SATCOM solutions currently serviced by Traveling
Wave Tube Amplifiers (TWTAs). Author Doreet Oren has been with Gilat since 2012 and is responsible
for defining product positioning, solution messaging, go-to-market
strategies, market research, and analyst relations. Ms. Oren has
over 20 years of industry experience, and has held management
positions in R&D, Product Management, Product Marketing and
Solution Marketing for international high-tech companies. In this
capacity Ms. Oren contributes to product and solution definitions
and is responsible for delivering the company’s vision to the media
and analyst community. Oren publishes thought leadership articles
in renowned international journals and speaks at numerous
industry conferences worldwide. Oren received a BSc in
Computer Science from George Washington University and Doreet Oren
graduated from the Modern Marketing Program at the Recanati Graduate
School of Business Administration, Tel Aviv University.
Author:
Author:
The adversarial threats posed to the United States on-orbit are greater now than
they have ever been in the nation’s history. Simply put, the jobs of military and With adversaries growing and fielding their arsenal of anti-satellite capabilities,
Intelligence Community leaders are getting far more difficult to accomplish. and developing space-enabled lethal weapons systems, Gen. Povak admits that
they are, “…gaining on our technology advantage at a rapid pace.”
That was the sentiment expressed by the Deputy Director of the National
Reconnaissance Office (NRO), Major General Christopher Povak, at a recent However, Gen. Povak assured the forum audience that the National
Schriever Spacepower Forum. Reconnaissance Office (NRO) remains the world leader in developing and
operating space intelligence capabilities and that the agency is prepared to stay
In his comments during the event, Gen. Povak explained that the decades-long abreast of the threat and will also ensure U.S. dominance in the space domain.
era of the U.S. being the undisputed leader in space technology, “…is no longer
the case.” NRO + Space Defense
Global superpowers such as Russia and China are closing the technology gap According to Gen. Povak, the NRO is responsible for the research and
between themselves as well as the current capability set the U.S. employs. development, acquisition, launch, integration, and operation of the nation’s vast
While near-peer adversaries continue to heavily invest funds and manpower to constellation of space-based intelligence, surveillance, and reconnaissance
the development of capable military space systems, they are also demonstrating (ISR) capabilities.
aggressive actions in space that could pose real threats to U.S. systems.
“As a defense agency and an element of the Intelligence Community, the NRO
“Today, several nations…are actively developing ground and space-based collects intelligence and information to support national level and Department
weapons specifically designed to interfere with or destroy our systems in of Defense missions,” Maj. Povak explained. “Overall, NRO’s mission is to work
space,” said Gen. Povak. “These counter-space capabilities include missiles with our partners to gain and maintain the nation’s intelligence advantage during
and weapons systems designed to deliver direct energy, electronic warfare, peacetime and throughout periods of crisis and conflict around the world.”
and cyber attack defense – all of which threaten our ability to freely access and
operate in space.” As part of its response to the rapid growth of adversarial capability and
presence in the space domain, Gen. Povak said that the NRO is advancing U.S.
According to the general, a critical component of these situational awareness “Now, we have an array of a community of industry partners that are working
and intelligence chains are the commercial partners in the satellite and hard to get some of these commercially-available products into our architecture,”
space industries. Gen. Povak explained. “I think the benefits of commercial is not them on their
own; it’s how they’re integrated with our infrastructure.”
Bringing The NRO + Industry Together
Gen. Povak noted that space will always continue to be a battleground of
Gen. Povak views commercial satellite data as an especially critical source for constant competition for information advantage, but that the NRO will ensure
situational awareness and intelligence, due to its unclassified and shareable that the U.S. will maintain its dominance in the domain.
nature. He considers the partnership between industry and the NRO as a
valuable tool to continue to rely upon, and highlighted the benefits derived from “Today, the NRO’s space-based ISR capabilities are without a doubt the best in
a modern, hybrid intelligence architecture — pointing to the role commercial the world,” he said. “However, in an era of growing competition, our imperative
satellite imagery played in intelligence gathering throughout the early moments is to develop the technologies, tools, capabilities, and space-minded expertise to
of the Russia-Ukraine conflict. stay that way.”
“Fortunately, the NRO is already building the largest and most capable, diverse Select this link to view the video to hear more about how the NRO is uniting
and resilient overhead constellation in our history,” said Gen. Povak. “Within with industry partners to create its hybrid intelligence architecture and also learn
the next decade, NRO expects to quadruple the number of satellites we about the capabilities of SES Space & Defense.
currently have on-orbit, with different sizes and different orbits for commercial
and national.” This article was first published on GovSat and is republished with permission of
GovSat and SES Space & Defense.
He explained these satellites will deliver more than 10 times as many signals and
images than are being collected today.
Industry has been hard at work in assisting the NRO in the agency’s mission
of maintaining space-based ISR dominance. According to Gen. Povak, the David Pesgraves
Author:
For military forces in the field, establishing a long-distance These new, Low Earth Orbit (LEO) constellations can deliver connectivity with
communications link has never been simple. It has typically lower latency than a traditional GEO satellite. The antenna does not have to be
involved a technician with a portable terminal setting up a small pointed in any specific direction. As long as the antenna has a clear view to the
satellite dish, and then pointing the dish at exactly the right spot in sky, it will connect to the LEO constellation.
the sky to connect to a geosynchronous satellite (GEO). Only after
obtaining a good signal could the team communicate with anyone One of the new LEO constellations is operated by OneWeb. Hughes was
outside the range of their portable radios. an early investor in OneWeb and, now, as a OneWeb distributor and partner
of choice, can deploy LEO connectivity as part of a military network or
However, that is about to change — dramatically. enterprise solution.
Advances in ground antenna technology have led to satellite antennas that are With more than 600 satellites in orbit, OneWeb can deliver a signal virtually
small and flat, rather than dish shaped. At the same time, a new generation of anywhere, with enough throughput to allow military and other users to send and
satellites operating close to Earth can send signals capable of being picked up receive not only data and audio, but also full-motion video transmissions using a
with a flat antenna configuration, technically called an electronically steerable flat, portable antenna.
antenna (ESA).
Hughes engineers are finalizing the designs for aero versions of the single-panel As government and defense agencies explore the power and potential of LEO
ESA that can be used on small aircraft, both manned and unmanned. These services, ESAs will be key in enabling this game-changing connectivity for
should be available in the second half of 2024. These antennas will be similar warfighters across the globe.
in size and power to the planned, single-panel ESAs soon to be
available for mobile ground units, but will be designed to fit www.hughes.com/resources/hughes-defense-capabilities
the curved body of an aircraft with little negative
impact on aerodynamics.
Naval Maritime
SATCOM
EM
SOLU
TIONS
MilsatMagazine
EMS Cobra Ad.indd 2 Page 11 December
15/12/2022 2023
7:58:53 AM
Satellite Manufacturers
Stuck In Orbit
With underinvestment in digitization technology
Author: Tom Hennessey, Chief Marketing Officer, iBase-t
Author:
Author:
Today the global military satellite market is a $14.44 billion Getting A Tighter Grip On Supply Chains
industry, according to Precedence Reasearch. While it might seem
that the sector is at the forefront of technological innovation, the A lack of digital maturity has become a serious roadblock to productivity in
reality is somewhat different. manufacturing in the satellite sector.
According to iBase-t’s A&D Digital Manufacturing Productivity Although Industry 4.0 advancements have proven critical to sustaining
Snapshot research, 97% of A&D manufacturers, including satellite operations during the pandemic, most manufacturers grapple with a lack of
manufacturers in the U.S. and the UK, say the industry has suffered from an system and process maturity and this is preventing them from leveraging
underinvestment in digitization and that now is the time to improve supply chain operational data for business intelligence and smarter decision-making. Being
efficiencies and create a productivity advantage. able to convert critical data into actionable improvements is pivotal to true
digital transformation.
Considering the complexity and risks involved, it is alarming that a majority of
manufacturers continue to use paper-based processes (88%) and spreadsheets While this lack of digital maturity impacts many areas of satellite
(57%). The fact that major satellite projects are potentially being run manufacturing, one area in particular that requires close attention is the supply
spreadsheets, or pen and paper, creates a huge cause for concern. chain. In this industry, it’s absolutely mission-critical that organizations are
able to manage a highly regulated manufacturing environment, and complex
At best, this approach can cause inefficiencies and lead to mistakes. At worst, it production processes.
could lead to project failure and space leaders losing their jobs. Notably, almost
half (48%) of respondents say a lack of investment in new technologies and
processes has resulted in them losing business — alarm bells should be ringing
across the industry.
To optimize performance, satellite manufacturers must also carefully track how Taking Action With Your Digital Investment
each supplier is contributing to their enterprise. Are suppliers causing problems,
or are they enabling success? The incorrect tools cause inefficiencies and that can result in costly mistakes
aas well as leaders losing their jobs.
It’s important to view supplier management as an ongoing process, rather
than a one-time project. It requires continuous optimization to maintain top It’s been more than ten years since spreadsheet errors contributed to JP
performance, and centralized communication with suppliers is essential. Morgan Chase losing $6 billion in the London Whale incident. This lack of digital
maturity could cause equally damaging outcomes in the manufacturing industry.
However, today there is an overreliance on email and paper-based
communications, which is not only inefficient but can also lead to significant As satellite manufacturing accelerates, there has never been a more important
quality issues. time to relinquish paper-based systems and spreadsheets and leverage the
power of digital technologies to gain a productivity advantage.
Digital Tools Unlock Intelligence
From improving efficiency, productivity and performance to attracting the next
Satellite manufacturers must act now and invest in digital, or else they run the generation of talent, the benefits are clear for those who want to get ahead of
risk of falling behind the competition. the competition.
A Manufacturing Execution System (MES) can make all the difference. By www.ibaset.com
placing an MES front and center of digital operations, manufacturers can
address the data concern, unlocking real-time visibility and intelligence, while
enjoying improved control. Author Tom Hennessey is the Chief Marketing Officer at iBase-t.
Organizations that have already adopted MES have had a head-start, not just in
embracing innovation, but also in channeling it toward achieving bespoke goals
and aims, ensuring more sustainable decision-making moving forward.
Tom Hennesey
avltech.com
HARSH WEATHER?
Communicate through extremes
Author:
Author:
This past year, Hugh White, the company’s Senior Director of Space Domain
Awareness, spoke at the Military Space Situational Awareness Conference
in London. Addressing Kratos’ advances in commercially available RF SDA
capabilities that are delivering real-world mission impact, he focused on the
capabilities of RF SDA in the Rendezvous and Proximity Operations (RPO)
space arena. Kosmos-2504 lifts off from
Plesetsk on March 31, 2015.
Image credit: russianspaceweb.com
RPOs are an example of a dual-use technology. On one end there are mission
extension vehicles, such as the MEV-1, that is docked with Intelsat 901 to
service and reposition it.
On the other end, there are ASAT weapons with kinetic kill capability. For
missions across the RPO spectrum, accurate and commercially available
RF SDA data is key for providing transparency to allied governments and
commercial spacecraft operators.
Unexpected Neighbor in Space Warfighters are using commercial RF SDA to learn in real-time what
MILSATCOM communication links are being targeted and degraded. Just
In July of 2022, Kratos SDA analysts saw Luch execute a sudden as commercial overhead imagery is being used to inform decisions on the
63,000-kilometer relocation drift. The satellite positioned itself next to Intelsat battlefield, commercial RF SDA geolocations are used to understand where
37E, and on October 31st, 2022, came within 4 kilometers of the Intelsat adversary jammers are located and what mitigation options are available.
spacecraft. Precise data like this is crucial for operators, such as Intelsat, so Commercial RF SDA is being used to understand changes in Space EW
they can respond appropriately and fly their satellites safely when confronted techniques and tactics and inform responsible parties on how best to
with a non-cooperative intruder entering into their orbital slot. mitigate them.
In space, tracking enemy spacecraft helps anticipate their actions and safeguard
our nation’s and our allies’ space assets. In communication, analyzing satellite
bandwidth reveals adversary movements and communication methods,
while space electronic warfare support enhances awareness of targeted
and degraded communication. On Earth, commercial RF SDA helps locate
intentional jammers to address electromagnetic interference.
SDA has become vital to mission success given the increase in commercial
space activity and the escalating number of international actors influencing the
dynamic theater.
Kratos owns and operates the world’s most precise commercial ground network
Kratos Common Operating Picture (RF COP) revealing orbital slots relocation by Luch 2 satellite. of RF sensors. Strategically positioned apertures around the globe enable
precise and persistent RF sensing, providing insight for missions in defense,
Incidentally, this satellite repositioned itself almost six months before the
intelligence and commercial operations.
Russian escalation near the Ukraine. The positioning of space assets is a key
step in preparing for conflict. Warfighters know this and use the precise tracking
The global deployment of more than 170 sensors are capable of pinpointing
of satellites, combined with an understanding of satellite missions, as valuable
satellite locations within 100 meters. The global network covers L-, S-, C-, X-
data warning of adversary intent.
and Ku-bands. Kratos’ state-of-the-art OpenSpace® Platform manages and
controls the status of the global network.
Situational Awareness Is Not Just About Where
Learn more about Kratos and the RF SDA commercial products and services
SDA recognizes that the significance lies not only in the location of a satellite but
available by going to www.kratosdefense.com/sda.
also in its ongoing activities. Monitoring RF links can help in assessing intention.
Since Space Electronic Warfare (EW) is one of the reversible effects that are
especially important in a limited scale conflict such as Ukraine, Hugh said it is no
surprise that we’ve seen a massive uptick in jamming in this theater.
Author:
Since Yuri Alekseyevich Gagarin’s historic space travel in 1961, In order to address military aggression effectively, there is a need for further
it has become evident that space serves as a pivotal frontier for clarification; to define what actions may be considered contrary to peaceful
human exploration and scientific progress as well as a potential purposes, particularly when the boundaries are blurred, as is the case with
catalyst for heightened geopolitical tensions and confrontations. direct-ascent ASAT tests.
With the development of space-based weaponry and anti-satellite technology For instance, should anti-satellite tests against one’s own assets be regarded
(ASAT), the militarization of space can no longer be disregarded. While space as hostile if the resulting debris poses a threat to other satellites? Would such
has been a realm of confrontation, whether technological or military, the actions be categorized as acts of violence?
absence of clear, international regulations and liability frameworks has the
potential to escalate conflicts. As for now, the United Nations General Assembly has called for the prohibition
of ASAT test. However, this is far from being a legal condemnation.
The absence of comprehensive measures to control potential military
aggressions in space raises several pressing questions. For instance, in the Consequently, it becomes evident that international law does not adequately
event that one country attacks a foreign asset, how can responsibility be address the mitigation of space debris resulting from military activities in space.
assigned? Which international court would rule over such a case? How can the Furthermore, in addition to the legal ambiguity surrounding the use of force in
international community interpret the UN Charter in a way that allows for its space, another question can be posed in regard to the existence of a liability
enforcement in the context of space? system if force does indeed occur.
According to Article 2.4 of the United Nations Charter: “All Members shall With the increasing number of actors and assets in space, these concerns
refrain in their international relations from the threat or use of force against the become more pronounced. The United Nations Convention on International
territorial integrity or political independence of any state, or in any other manner Liability for Damage Caused by Space Objects, adopted in 1972, primarily
inconsistent with the Purposes of the United Nations.” focuses on damages caused to airspace or Earth’s surface by launches,
neglecting on-orbit incidents. This omission leaves urgent issues such as
This article embodies a fundamental principle of international law: the prohibition satellite collisions and debris creation unaddressed. Expanding liability
of the use or threat of force in international relations. Nevertheless, this provision coverage to encompass all potential incidents could prevent unauthorized use
is counterbalanced by Article 51, which recognizes the legitimate right of self- of force in space.
defense in response to an armed attack.
As access to space has become more affordable, the actions of private
While the UN Charter does not explicitly mention space, these principles can companies engaged in (potential) hostile activities can become a fundamental
be extrapolated. Considering the absence of geographical limitations, these issue. The majority of space law has been crafted by and for a handful of
principles can be extended to space. spacefaring nations. With the proliferation of commercial activities on-orbit, from
satellite servicing to future space tourism missions, the ability of existing legal
However, it is essential to acknowledge that international law does include precedents to adequately address current challenges is questionable.
specific provisions pertaining to space under the Outer Space Treaty (OST) that
states that the moon and other celestial bodies must be used exclusively for In October of 2023, the Federal Communications Commission sanctioned,
peaceful purposes. for the first time, a company that failed to respect its de-orbit plan. While the
legal issue creates a noteworthy precedent for space sustainability and safety,
Article 4 of the OST stipulates: “States Parties to the Treaty undertake not the issues of jurisdiction and liability are even more complex when it comes to
to place in orbit around the earth any objects carrying nuclear weapons or hostile and aggressive behavior.
any other kinds of weapons of mass destruction, install such weapons on
celestial bodies, or station such weapons in outer space in any other manner. Is the legal framework under which private actors operate solely based on
The moon and other celestial bodies shall be used by all States Parties to the the laws of their home country, or should it adhere to international norms and
Treaty exclusively for peaceful purposes. The establishment of military bases, regulations, in relation to a sovereign nation?
installations, and fortifications, the testing of any type of weapons, and the
conduct of military maneuvers on celestial bodies shall be forbidden...”
This ambiguity creates a liability gap where assigning responsibility and blame to become more pronounced as non-consensual space activities become
becomes intricate. Of course, this is not a new issue as similar challenges arose more prevalent.
during the Iraq war with private contractors.
With the goal of avoiding escalation in violence, space situational awareness
Nevertheless, irrespective of the commercialization of space, the fundamental companies, such as Share My Space, have a role to play. Sharing valuable
issue remains that the current soft law framework does not provide incentives information with operators and governments can enhance confidence in
for states to act peacefully. States can generate hazardous debris or de-orbit neighboring space activities and reduce risks of misunderstanding.
their assets through uncontrolled reentries without fearing any major legal
consequences or worse engage in unpeaceful operations. Share My Space advocates for responsible space conduct that is compliant
with international norms of behavior and work activity to promote guidelines for
As the future unfolds, states will need to safeguard their national interests peaceful operations.
while still maintaining liability in case of misconduct. This imperative is likely
www.sharemyspace.space
Saloua Moutaoufik
Ed Slater is the
Senior Vice
President,
Sales and
Marketing
at OneWeb
Technologies,
a leading
provider of
secure and
commercial Ed Slater
satellite
communications connectivity
for applications and wireless
technologies globally. In this role,
he is responsible for leading the
development and implementation
of the sales distribution and
marketing strategy.
Mr. Slater has more than 25
years of experience in satellite
communications, both as an
operator and in commercial
delivery, previously holding senior
positions in the USAF and the
commercial sector. Most recently,
Mr. Slater was Senior Director
of Sales at OneWeb Technologies, after previously serving as the Good day, Mr. Slater. Thanks for taking the time to offer us your
company’s Director, insights. Would you please tell us how you initially became
Partner Development. interested, and involved, in the satellite communications
Mr. Slater brings a wealth of prior experience in satellite (SATCOM) industry?
communications, government business development, partnerships
and operations to OneWeb Technologies. Prior to OneWeb Ed Slater
Technologies, he was Director, Government Aviation at OneWeb When I was in the U.S. Air Force (USAF), I learned firsthand that ensuring our
and held multiple government business leadership positions at warfighter’s safety and security ultimately boils down to providing them with
Satcom Direct Communications, the largest provider of Inmarsat critical access to the data and information they require when it matters most.
L-band services to the Department of Defense (DoD). It became clear that communications were an essential component to any
He has experience leading teams responsible for customer operational strategy.
support, activations, contract management and sales, servicing all I became interested in satellite communications solutions as an opportunity
branches of DoD as well as the State Department, FBI and other to help provide our military and government access to the essential
Federal Agencies. connectivity, confidence and visibility that they require for successful global
Mr. Slater retired from the USAF in 2014 as a SMSgt. as missions. For obvious reasons, terrestrial cellular networks were not an option
Superintendent, Air Force One Communications. During his military in austere, contested, degraded and operationally-limited environments –
career, he served in the 99th Airlift Squadron, traveling the globe and satellite communications (SATCOM) provided the infrastructure when
in support of the U.S. Vice President, cabinet members, DoD terrestrial was unavailable.
leadership and federal agencies. He also served in the Presidential Today, commercial SATCOM solutions not only enable this vital lifeline on the
Airlift Group (PAG), where he led airborne communication for U.S. battlefield, but also help meet the demand for increased bandwidth as military
Presidents Bush and Obama. While at the PAG, he ran multiple technology becomes more sophisticated and requires more of it.
programs to modify communications and enhance the technology
and capabilities of Air Force One. During his 14 years at Andrews How did your career in the U.S. Air Force (and thank you for
AFB, he was qualified on 747B, C-32A/B, C-20B/H, C-37A aircraft as your service] prepare you for entry into the world of SATCOM
both an instructor and evaluator. and MILSATCOM?
Mr. Slater holds a Bachelor of Science degree in Information
Technology Management from American Military University. Ed Slater
In the early 2000s, my military career required that I travel the globe to serve
in the 99th Airlift Squadron supporting the Vice President of the United States,
cabinet members, Department of Defense (DoD) leadership and federal
Author:
The satellite industry has ushered in a new era where space and environment safe. It is not surprising that it is an area where we are seeing a
ground segments are becoming significantly more complex as lot of innovation, from better tracking to interference monitoring, and of course,
the industry pivots to meet consumer demand for high-speed improving testing.
connectivity and high availability.
Drone technology is another area where we are seeing a huge amount of
At the same time, space has become the new frontier for security and defence. innovation due to the enormous volume of drones being used in modern
The geopolitical situation is changing and countries around the globe are warfare. This is leading to higher production volumes, as well as better reliability
stepping up defensive and preventative actions in response to the evolving and optimized costs.
threats to military satellite systems. All of this is activity driving the need for
improved testing programs. While a lot of this innovation is being driven by necessity, it will be crucial
to ensuring the defence industry can continue to use space in a secure and
The Threat In Space Has Become Real reliable way.
The current geopolitical situation has brought a growing awareness of the While testing ground equipment doesn’t stop the aggressive actions, it does
threats in space. ensure governments and defence entities can ensure their systems are
performing optimally at all times.
While space has been a potential target for many years, we are starting to
see real actions and tests that could have a catastrophic impact on the entire While the industry is mostly on board with testing pre-operation, testing
space environment. throughout the life-cycle and in real situations has historically been far
more challenging.
From ASATs to jamming and cyber-attacks, the defence industry is
constantly working to protect its military satellite systems from threats, and It is arguably more important in a defense situation than any other operation
attacks from adversaries. when you consider the challenging situations under which these systems
operate and the ongoing threats that might cause degradation.
Of course, the industry hasn’t been sitting on its laurels and there are already a
huge amount of counter measures developed, and being developed to keep the
Author:
Matt Tirman serves as the President of Satellogic The U.S. government seems to be streamlining its processes
and brings more than 20 years of experience for working with commercial providers -are we likely to see
in technology and aerospace from across the governments relying on commercial operators more?
U.S. government and international markets. As
President, he leads the operational execution of Matt Tirman
Satellogic’s strategy and business plan. Prior to There is growing concern that the U.S. would lose its lead in spaceflight which
this appointment, Mr. Tirman held the position of opened the door for more contracts with commercial operations. What we
Chief Commercial Officer, where he began laying saw this month was the U.S. Senate Subcommittee on Space and Science
the groundwork for Satellogic’s early entry into addressing the red tape with the regulatory framework called “Part 450.”
the U.S. market. The United States Space Force (USSF) has been building a broader strategy
Before joining Satellogic in 2021, Matt for procurement of commercial services over the past year to ultimately have a
served as Head of Government at Descartes “commercial space reserve” and the organization is working on a commercial
Matt Tirman Labs, a leading provider of geospatial and strategy, or blueprint, as to how this will integrate commercial satellite services
multi-sensor analytics, where he revenue growth and customer into routine military activities.
delivery across defense and intelligence clients. His previous roles Commercial systems continue to prove as a critical partner to national
include Chief Commercial Officer at PlanetRisk, where he was capabilities. The expansion in various Earth Observation (EO) related
responsible for delivering enterprise geospatial risk analytics and contracts, such as the upsizing of the National Reconnaissance
customized big data solutions to Global 1000 customers; Chief Organization (NRO) and National Geospatial-Intelligence Agency (NGA)
Executive Officer and founder of Access Global, a consulting firm contracts, and establishment of the USSF, are but a few examples of
providing executive management, sales, and business development opportunities shaped by commercial providers.
solutions in foreign markets across EMEA and Asia; Vice President
and Managing Director at Strategic Social, a technology and services Commercial satellite operators seem to be advancing rapidly —
firm operating frontier markets across the Middle East and North what applications are coming out of the commercial sector that are
Africa that he helped grow to more than $40M in annual revenue of most interest to government clients?
before it was sold to Constellis in 2014.
Additionally, Matt has served as an analyst for the US Matt Tirman
Department of Defense on cooperative Research and In 2022, a record number of commercial satellites were deployed — 2,325 —
Development and as a speechwriter for senior military leadership and the private sector is historically a stronger engine for innovation as well as
in Washington D.C. and Baghdad, Iraq. He holds a master’s for lower costs and increased capabilities.
degree in Defense and Security from Lancaster University When looking at reliability, flexibility and redundancy, one example
and a BS in Political Science from East Carolina University. would be the U.S. Army — a large user of satellite data — has a goal of
decentralizing data sharing. Remote sensing is a priority for U.S. government
use during national security emergencies. Also, exceptional, high-resolution,
Company update EO capture capability with the best geospatial data quality, all at the lowest
Satellogic recently announced its redomicile to the U.S. with a new focus on cost, must be attained.
expanding business within the U.S. market and Matt Tirman was appointed
the President and is overseeing the firm’s U.S. strategy.
Matt Tirman
As we look to 2024 and beyond, our continued growth will be in Asset
Monitoring, Constellation-as-a-Service, and our Space Systems —
which we anticipate will contribute considerably.
Matt Tirman
The U.S. intelligence community and DoD are increasingly reliant
on commercial satellites for imagery and other critical data. Since
Russia’s invasion of the Ukraine, commercial space companies have
provided critical intelligence and communications services to Ukraine
and that nation’s allies, and Russia’s military has threatened to target
commercial systems.
The U.S. is working to ‘better enable protection of commercial remote
sensing space assets’ The NRO, the NGA and U.S. Space Command
(USSPACECOM) recently signed an agreement to improve threat
intelligence sharing with commercial satellite operators.
satellogic.com
However, as space becomes busier, the risk of damage to satellites from an in-
There can be no denying that the global space industry has
orbit collision with other space objects increases.
experienced a significant growth rate in recent years.
Space safety is critical for the space industry because without it, the successful
According to a report by the Space Foundation, in 2021, the industry grew at its
and sustainable operation of spacecraft, satellites, and other space-related
fastest rate since 2014, with an impressive, year-over-year growth rate of 9%.
activities cannot be maintained. Improving and maintaining space safety is
however, not without its challenges.
This growth has been driven by a number of factors, including advancements in
technology, increased demand for space-based services, and the emergence of
The Problem With Debris
new players.
It stands to reason that as the number of objects on-orbit increases, so does the
The industry is no longer dominated by traditional government space agencies
amount of debris created by defunct satellites, rocket stages, and other objects.
and large aerospace companies.
Although there are systems in place for tracking debris over 10 cm, our ability
Instead, a new generation of private companies and startups are entering the
to detect and track smaller pieces of debris is limited. This is where the problem
market, offering new services and products.
rests, as even smaller objects, less than the size of an orange, have the potential
to still cause significant damage to satellites and spacecraft.
These companies are leveraging advances in technology and new business
To put this into perspective, consider the damage a moped traveling at 50 kph
models to offer services such as satellite internet and remote sensing.
would do in a collision — that would certainly would be significant.
As the industry continues to expand, it’s bringing new and exciting opportunities
Compare this with an object traveling in space that is only as big as a paperclip,
for companies and individuals, as well as playing an increasingly important role
such as a tiny fleck of paint from a spacecraft and weighing just one gram.
in our economy and society.
That moped and the fleck of paint would both
impact with the same kinetic energy and could
cause an identical level of damage upon impact.
Another important development is the use of artificial intelligence and machine The time has come for technology to catch with to the crucial need of reliable
learning (AI / ML) algorithms. These technologies help to analyze vast amounts SSA to ensure safety in space.
of data from space surveillance and tracking systems, so that patterns can be
identified and potential collisions predicted. www.space-data.org/sda/
In addition, the use of advanced communications systems, such as satellites Author Joe Chan is the director of Flight Dynamics at Intelsat.
and laser communications, have made it possible to transmit data and He oversees the FDS operation and engineering of more than 70
information from space to ground stations in real-time. geostationary satellites that Intelsat currently operates. He has
These systems allow for far more accurate and timely SSA, enabling faster been with Intelsat for 24 years. Prior to joining Intelsat he worked
response to potential collisions or other hazards. at Goddard Space Flight center on the TOPEX/POSEIDON
and Mars Observer projects.
The use of advanced sensors and imaging systems have also played a big use
of high-resolution cameras and other sensors have significantly improved the
Joe Chan
Author:
The world increasingly depends on data — from the GPS signals “Many of the components of our data transport
that navigate location for first responders to shipping, agriculture, system have worked very well, for a very long
and hosts of other industries, to timing signals that help secure time,” said Colonel Peter C. Mastro, senior
financial transactions, to the missile warning and intelligence materiel leader, Tactical Command, Control and
information that aids warfighters in the field. Communication Delta at SSC. “But now, we’re on
the brink of a data transport revolution and SSC is
While the United States has long enjoyed a competitive advantage through its working hard to create a stronger, faster and more
space-based satellite systems, several factors have created the need for a multi- resilient system that can meet the threat now — and
faceted push within the U.S. Space Force (USSF) to modernize data transport, adapt to the demands of the future.”
with Space Systems Command (SSC) as the key driver.
Mastro’s work focuses on getting commands to
Previously, U.S. satellite communication missions were spread out among satellites and the connection between satellite
the military branches. With the creation of the USSF, those missions are now ground systems and the satellites on-orbit, as well Col. Peter Mastro
consolidated under one branch to ensure unity of effort. as the movement of data across terrestrial lines that
connect USSF missions together.
Factors driving modernization efforts include rapid improvements in technology
that have expanded capabilities; the explosive growth in the number of on-orbit Satellites and the ground systems that support them provide a wealth of critical
satellites, particularly in Low Earth Orbit (LEO); new partnerships with allies and data: position, navigation and timing (PNT); intelligence, surveillance and
the commercial space industry; and the need for more resilient systems that can reconnaissance (ISR); missile warning and missile defense; communications,
withstand threats from adversaries. weather; and research and development (R&D).
The backbone of the system is the Satellite Control Network (SCN), which was
first established in 1959. The SCN is a worldwide system of 19 antenna stations
in seven separate geographical locations that track Department of Defense
(DoD) and other government agencies’ satellite locations, collect data on the However, Mastro added that figure is an overall average capacity metric: there
satellites’ status and send control commands to various sub-systems. SCN is may be some specific geographic areas and times during which, “the network
also an important part of launch support and provides emergency support for may be maxed out, and there may be space vehicles that want a particular
lost or out-of-control satellites. contact, and they are turned away from the SCN because there isn’t capacity to
help them.”
“You can think about it like the Space Force is operating a drone — this drone
(satellite) just happens to be on-orbit,” Mastro said. “You have to be able to send Priority is set by the U.S. Space Command, and if, for example, a
it commands to do things, to turn on payloads like the communication radios. communications satellite needs a slot at the same time one of the missile
Or, if it happens to have a camera on board or, for our missile warning satellites, warning satellites requires access, then the communication satellite may need to
an imager, point it in the right direction. And then you have to be able to monitor wait for a later time slot, Mastro noted.
the satellite, that all the subsystems are working as we expect them to be. “That
temperature readings are all staying in the bounds as they go around the earth From 2021 to 2022, there were more than 15,000 “conflict deletes” where
and get exposed to the sun and then go into the shadow.” SCN operators were unable to accommodate specific requests, according to
the GAO.
Mastro continued, “When you collect the data, you also have to contact the
satellite. All of that data needs to get down to the ground and processed, But USSF and SSC have launched multiple efforts to improve the way the Space
typically through the mission-unique antennas we have.” Force can communicate with the increasing number of satellites, including
expanding the number of antennas the USSF can access.
However, the SCN antenna stations communicate with satellites using parabolic
antennas and can only communicate with one satellite at a time — and only Under the Federal Augmentation Services system, USSF gets access to
within a limited window of time when that satellite is in range of the antenna. antennas owned by NOAA, and if those antennas are underused, the USSF is
As the number of active payloads increases, demand for those communication able to use them, Mastro said, adding, “That way, the federal government is
slots is skyrocketing. more efficiently using the resources that we have so we don’t have to go out and
buy more — we just better share what we have across our federal agencies.”
“With the existing SCN antennas, they talk to one satellite at a time,” Mastro
said. “And as we launch more satellites, that starts to put a capacity burden on Another project underway is the Satellite Communication Augmentation
the number of satellites that we can actually talk to.” Resource (SCAR), a phased-array antenna that would be capable of as many
as 10 simultaneous contacts. Unlike a parabolic antenna, a phased array panel
An April 2023 report from the U.S. Government Accountability Office (GAO) has a flat panel that receives and transmits from multiple beams, Mastro said.
estimated that the SCN averaged more than 164,000 contacts with satellites per
year, or about 450 a day. “SCAR is a Space Force-built, Space Force-owned antenna — development
and delivery is being run by the Space Rapid Capabilities Office,” Mastro said.
The GAO also noted that the utilization rate for the SCN has averaged 75% “When they develop and deliver that, it’s going to be absolutely outstanding and
over the last decade — exceeding the 70 percent level cited by USSF as the will drastically increase the number of simultaneous satellite contacts the Space
threshold used by the commercial industry to indicate the need for Force will be able to do.”
more capacity.
SSC has continued to develop partnerships with the commercial space industry
as part of its “exploit what you have, buy what you can, and build what you
must” strategy, and that includes the field of data transport. But Mastro noted
there are some limitations. “We have been working to get access to more of the
commercial network antennas that are out there. But there are a few things that
Space Force satellites require that are difficult to find in the commercial market.”
One critical factor is that almost all USSF satellites communicate on a specific
frequency for uplink and downlink and a specific waveform, SGLS. (additional
information on SGLS is available at this Space Foundation infosite link).
Although USSF is adding more satellites to LEO to make their systems more
resilient, it also has a number of satellites in Medium Earth Orbit (MEO)
and Geosynchronous Orbit (GEO) and many of the available commercial
antennas aren’t sized — either in their physical size or their power — to handle
transmissions to those orbits, Mastro said.
“That waveform has been used by the Air Force, and now the Space Force for
decades, and is not supported by commercial providers — outside of the Space
Force, nobody really uses that standard,” Mastro said. “But nearly all of our
satellites need to communicate in that waveform.”
“As we look to expand out and get access to commercial antennas, we either
have to only use those antennas to communicate to a very small number
of Space Force satellites or you end up having to do things like modifying
The project originally started two years ago with Sev1Tech to develop a “Sometimes with a capability like our antenna network, it is more difficult to
prototype for a modern, resilient, scalable, and secure data transport network. get that high priority in funding decisions in comparison to some of the end
operational capability,” Mastro said. “Over the years, there has been an under-
investment in the SCN.”
Next year, SSC will replace it with AST (AF(SCN) Scheduling Tool) which
will put the system on a modern infrastructure. After that, SSC will roll out
Enterprise Resource Manager (ERM) a Cloud-based system “which will
really automate the way we do scheduling, not just across government-owned
antennas, but also across commercial and other federal network antennas,”
Mastro said. ERM is expected to be launched sometime in 2028.
“We have a lot going on,” Mastro said. “We’re improving multiple pieces of it, all
in parallel.”
This pathfinding effort is already integrating disparate mission systems’s data Contact Space Systems Command at SSC@spaceforce.mil and follow
transport and provides a scalable foundation for future efforts to utilize across on LinkedIn.
Space Force, Air Force and, ultimatly, other branches of military service to
achieve.Joint All-Domain Command and Control (JADC2).
“We are building out this Mesh network of long-haul data transport that has all
the modern cybersecurity capabilities, has Zero Trust capabilities embedded in
it, and it provides resilient pathways,” Mastro said. “Currently, it’s all terrestrial
fiber optic paths, but we will be expanding into MILSATCOM connections as
well as connections through commercial, proliferated LEO. So we will have even
more diversity and resiliency in the way the Space Force moves data.”
Mastro said SSC has collected requirements from mission partners across the
USSF and has been working to roll out capabilities to them. Currently, there are
17 worldwide deployed nodes at different bases around the world.
“So many programs out there have to figure out how to move data and turn to
DISA,” Mastro said. “DISA is an outstanding partner in providing that support,
but now with a program like meshONE-T, if there is any individual program that
should be focused on their mission, they can turn to meshONE-T and meshONE-T
can handle all the details around how to move that data. MeshONE can work with
DISA, meshONE-T can work with the commercial satcom through proliferated
LEO. And we can provide, in partnership with DISA, something that is even more
resilient than the mission unique program would otherwise obtain.”
FEBRUARY 6 – 8, 2024
SMALLSATSHOW.COM