Shear Buckling of Ship Plates With Different Holes
Shear Buckling of Ship Plates With Different Holes
REGULAR ARTICLE
Abstract. Based on the first-order shear deformation theory, numerical methods and mechanical experiments,
the shear buckling characteristics of hull plates with different holes are investigated. Through eigenvalue
buckling analysis, the critical buckling stress of square plate with hole under uniform shear load on four edges
was calculated. The relationship between the critical shear stress and the hole type, hole size and plate thickness
was obtained by parameterization. The reduction coefficient (ki) was defined to characterize the effect of the hole
on the plate, and the reduction effect of circular hole, square hole and fillet square hole was simplified by graph
and fitting polynomial. The results show that the critical buckling shear stress obtained from numerical
simulation is in good agreement with the experimental value. For different types of holes, the critical buckling
shear stress of the square plate has the same trend with the plate thickness. Both plate thickness and hole size
have great influence on the shear stability of the perforated square plate. When the hole size is constant, the
critical shear stress increases with the increase of plate thickness. The smaller the hole size is, the greater the
influence of plate thickness. The critical shear stress decreases with the increase of hole size, and there is a similar
linear relationship. The smaller the plate thickness, the more obvious the linear relationship. In addition, based
on the reduction coefficient curve or fitting polynomial proposed in this paper, the influence rules of the three
different holes on the shear stability of hull plates can be obtained quickly and effectively, thus providing a useful
reference for the design optimization and mechanical property evaluation of ship structures with holes.
Keywords: shear buckling / stability / reduction factor / hole / hull structure
This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0),
which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
2 Z. Zhu et al.: Mechanics & Industry 23, 4 (2022)
the stability of the plate with a hole was proposed. Abaqus 2 Theoretical method
software was used to calculate the ultimate strength of hull
plate under axial pressure in the literature [10]. The literature 2.1 Basic equation
[11] analyzed the elastic buckling and post-buckling 2.1.1 Displacement field
behaviors of unstiffened plates under complex stress states,
and compared them with empirical formulas and ABS In Mindlin’s first-order shear deformed plate theory, it is
specifications. Peridynamics was applied to the analysis of assumed that the normal strain of the plate along the
axial compression stability of metal plates in the literature thickness direction is zero, and that the normal line
[12]. Galerkin method was used to solve the elastic-plastic perpendicular to the middle plane is still a straight line
buckling problem of rectangular plates under shear stress in after deformation, but it does not remain a normal line. In
literature [13]. The buckling problem of anisotropic this case, the displacement of plate element can be
rectangular plates under shear stress was analyzed by expressed as
differential quadrature method in literature [14]. The
differential equation of lateral displacement function of w ¼ wðx; yÞ
rectangular thin plate under shear buckling was established u ¼ ux z ð1Þ
in literature [15], and the analytical solution of the critical v ¼ uy z
buckling load of rectangular thin plate was obtained. Paik
[16] studied the ultimate strength of perforated steel plate where w, u and v are displacements in x, y and z directions;
under edge shear load, and obtained an empirical formula to Z is the distance from any point of the plate to the neutral
predict the maximum tensile strength of perforated plate. plane along the thickness direction. ux, uy are the rotation
Pham [17] used the finite strip method to study the shear angles of the middle plane of the plate around the y and x
buckling of the plate with a hole, and proposed an axes. It is assumed that there is no internal displacement in
approximate formula for the shear buckling coefficient of a the midplane, for the shear-deformed plate, there is
square plate with a central circular hole and a square hole.
∂w
Local rectangular thin-wall plates subjected to shear ux ¼ g xz
force are widely used in engineering structures such as ships ∂x ð2Þ
∂w
and buildings. The buckling instability of local plates has uy ¼ g yz
become one of the main forms of structural failure. Previous ∂y
studies on the stability of perforated plates were mostly
focused on a single perforated type, and the loading where g xz and g yz are angular strains caused by transverse
conditions were mainly tensile, compression and bending. shear deformation.
For the buckling instability of local rectangular plate under
shear stress, analytical method and finite element method 2.1.2 Physical equation
are mainly used. The calculation of the analytical method is 2 3 2 3
cumbersome, and the finite element simulation can avoid sx ex
the tedious calculation program of the buckling analysis, 6 sy 7 6 ey 7
6 7 6 7
but the calculation accuracy is limited to the design s¼6
6 s xy
7 ¼ D e ¼ D6 g xy 7
7 6 7
accuracy of the model and boundary conditions [18,19]. 4 s yz 5 4 g yz 5
In the actual design process, compared with analytical s xz g xz
derivation and finite element simulation, empirical formu- 2 3
las or graphs are more practical and more efficient. E Ev
6 1 v2 1 v2 _ 0 0 0 72 3
Therefore, this paper focuses on the buckling character- 6 Ev E 7 ex
6 76
istics of ship’s plates with different holes under in-plane 6 0 0 0 7 6 ey 77
shear loading by means of the first-order shear deformation 6 1 v2 1 v2 76
¼6 E 76 g xy 7
7 ð3Þ
6 0 0 7
theory, mechanical experiments and numerical simulation. 6 0
2ð 1 þ v Þ
0 74 g yz 5
In the numerical simulation, eigenvalue analysis method 6 7
was used to study the buckling behavior of the perforated
4 0 0 0 G 0 5 g xz
plates. In order to verify the effectiveness of the numerical 0 0 0 0 G
method, the picture frame fixture was used to conduct the
shear test on the perforated plates. In addition, the where s x, s y and s xy are the in-plane normal stress and
response rules of the hole type, hole size and plate thickness shear stress, respectively; s yz and s xz are transverse shear
to the buckling characteristics of hull plates are obtained. stress; D is the stiffness matrix; ex, ey and g xy are the in-
The reduction factor of perforated plates is defined and plane linear strain and angular strain, respectively; E is the
analyzed. The empirical graph and the fitting polynomial elastic modulus; G is the shear elasticity modulus; n is
are established to characterize the reduction effect of the Poisson’s ratio.
hole of the plate, which can quickly obtain the buckling The displacement function of the first-order shear
critical shear stress of the square plate with a round hole, deformation theory is easy to meet the rigid body
square hole and fillet square hole. These will provide a displacement conditions, constant strain conditions and
useful reference for the shear stability analysis and design continuity requirements, and it is easy to approximate
optimization of the ship structure with holes. curved edges and curved surfaces with small geometric
Z. Zhu et al.: Mechanics & Industry 23, 4 (2022) 3
Parameter Plate Plate Radius of Square hole Fillet radius Elastic Poisson’s
length b thickness circular hole r length 2a of square hole R modulus E ratio n
T
Value 310 mm 1.0 mm 70 mm 125 mm 16.5 mm 210 GPa 0.3
Fig. 12. The linear relation curves of square plates with circular
Fig. 10. The influence of the hole’s area on critical stress holes.
(t = 2.5 mm, b = 300 mm).
Fig. 13. The linear relation curves of square plates with square
is small, the hole type has little effect on tcr, regardless of holes.
the circular hole or the square hole, the tcr increases linearly
with the increase of (t/b)2 . However, when the size of the
hole is large, the linear relationship between tcr and (t/b)2 is critical buckling shear stress tcr and shear yield stress t y
still keep, but the influence of the circular holes on t cr is can be obtained directly by reading these figures, which is
greater than that of square holes. When r/b = a/b = 0.03, simple and quick, and has a certain universality.
the tcr of the plate with circular hole is 18% larger than that
with square hole; when r/b = a/b = 0.4 and (103t/b)2 = 225, 5.2 Hole reduction coefficient
the tcr of the plate with circular hole is 31% larger than that
with square hole. For a rectangular plate simply supported on four edges and
In order to further verify the consistency and validity of with limited torsion, when the four edges are subjected to
numerical results, two groups of linear relation curves of uniform shear forces, the critical buckling shear stress can
square perforated plate are obtained by dimensionless be obtained by the following equation [21]:
geometric variables in Figures 12 and 13. As shown in the
two figures, when the hole size is constant, no matter the Ep2 t2
tcr ¼ k0 ð5Þ
hole size is circular or square, the critical buckling shear 12ð1 v2 Þb2
stress of the plate has a linear relationship with the
geometric parameter (t/b)2, which is consistent with where k0 is the shear buckling coefficient and is a function of
the empirical formula [21]. It can be seen that the results the length-width ratio of the rectangular plate. When the
in the figures are valid and corresponding to different length and width of the plate are equal, k0=15; t is the plate
(t/b)2, and the proportional relationship between the thickness; b is the width of the plate.
Z. Zhu et al.: Mechanics & Industry 23, 4 (2022) 7
Ep2 t2
tcr ¼ k0 ki ði ¼ 1; 2; 3Þ ð6Þ
12ð1 v2 Þb2
y3 ¼ 2:5209x3 þ 1:8084x2 3:1911x þ 1:0304 ð10Þ y3 ¼ 2:6274x3 þ 6:3332x2 4:3358x þ 1:0364 ð14Þ
8 Z. Zhu et al.: Mechanics & Industry 23, 4 (2022)
6 Conclusions
In this paper, the shear buckling characteristics of ship
perforated plates with circular hole, square hole and fillet
square hole are studied by numerical simulation. The
validity of the numerical simulation results of critical
buckling shear stress is verified by theoretical analysis
and mechanical experiment. By changing geometrical
Fig. 18. The fitting reduction coefficient k1 of the square plate
parameters such as hole size, plate thickness and hole
with square hole. type, a series of mechanical response relationships
between critical shear stress and hole type, hole size
and plate thickness were obtained. It is found that the
critical buckling shear stress of the square plate has the
same trend with the plate thickness, for different types of
holes. Both plate thickness and hole size have great
influence on the shear stability of the perforated square
plate. When the hole size is constant, the critical shear
stress increases with the increase of plate thickness. The
smaller the hole size is, the greater the influence of plate
thickness. The critical shear stress decreases with the
increase of hole size, and there is a similar linear
relationship. The smaller the plate thickness, the more
obvious the linear relationship. Under a certain plate
thickness, the degree of influence of hole size on tcr is that
circular hole > fillet square hole > square hole; When the
size of the hole is small, the hole’s type has little effect on
Fig. 19. The errors of the reduction coefficient k2 of the square tcr. However, when the size of the hole is large, the
plate with square hole. influence of the circular hole on tcr is greater than that of
square hole. Corresponding to the same area of the hole,
The fitting condition of reduction factor k2 is similar to the influence of the hole’s type on the tcr is similar, and
that of k1. Figure 18 shows the closeness between y and k1 the influence of the circular hole is slightly larger, followed
for different hole sizes. And Figure 19 shows the errors of by the fillet square hole and the square hole. Therefore,
the reduction coefficient with the power exponent of the under the same working condition, circular hole is more
fitting polynomial at different hole sizes. The order of the suitable for shear condition. In addition, the reduction
fitting accuracy of k2 is also y6>y5>y4>y3. coefficient (ki) was defined to characterize the effect of the
In the practical application of ships, square plates hole on the plate. Based on the reduction coefficient curve
with square hole often require chamfering to reduce stress and fitting polynomial proposed in this paper, the
concentration. However, the relationship between critical influence rules of these three type holes on the shear
buckling shear stress and geometric parameters after stability of hull plates can be obtained quickly and
chamfering is more complex. And it is difficult to obtain a effectively, which provides a useful reference for designers
uniform change rule with the change of hole size and fillet to analyze the shear stability and structural optimization
radius. There are also few previous related studies. In this of open hole plate.
Z. Zhu et al.: Mechanics & Industry 23, 4 (2022) 9
Fig. 20. The relationship between the reduction coefficient and the geometric parameters of the square plate with fillet square hole
(t = 0.1 mm).
Acknowledgements. This work was financed by the National [8] C.D. Moen, B.W. Schafer, Elastic buckling of thin plates
Natural Science Foundation of China (Grant No. 51909103), with holes in compression or bending, Thin-Walled Struct.
the Natural Science Foundation of Fujian Province (Grant 47, 1597–1607 (2009)
No. 2021J01841) and the Project of Fujian Provincial [9] P. Zuxing, Semi-analytical methods for stress and stability
Department of Education of China (Grant No. JAT200290). analyses of perforated plates. Ph.D. Thesis, Huazhong
University of Science and Technology, 2014
[10] F. Liang, H. Jingke, S. Hongda et al., Influence factors and
References sensitivity analysis of numerical calculation of hull panel
ultimate strength, Ship Sci. Technol. 39, 48–55 (2017)
[1] J.K. Paik, Ultimate strength of perforated steel plates under [11] X. Jinsong, Q. Enrong, Ultimate Strength Analysis of
combined biaxial compression and edge shear loads, Steel unstiffened plates under Complex Stress, in: Proceedings of
Constr. 46, 207–213 (2008) the 20th Anniversary Academic Conference in Commemo-
[2] C. Yanting, Y. Changli, G. Hongbin, Research development ration of Ship Mechanics, 2017
of buckling and ultimate strength of hull plate and stiffened [12] S. Luyan, Stability analysis method study of metallic plates
panel, Chin. J. Ship Res. 1, 54–62 (2017) based on peridynamics. Master’s Thesis, Shanghai Jiao Tong
[3] L. Xiaowen, Z. Zhaoyi, L. Yan et al., Research on buckling University, 2014
and post buckling behavior of composite stiffened panel for [13] S. Renu, L. Roshan, Buckling and vibration of non-
ships, Shipbuild. China 61, 186–194 (2020) homogeneous orthotropic rectangular plates with variable
[4] W. Zhao, Z. Xie, X. Wang et al., Buckling behavior of thickness using DQM, Adv. Intell. Syst. Comput. 23, 295–
stiffened composite panels with variable thickness skin under 304 (2014)
compression, Mech. Adv. Mater. Struct. 1–9 (2019) [14] E. Jaberzadeh, M. Azhari, Elastic and inelastic local
[5] M.C. Xu, C.G. Soares, Numerical assessment of experiments buckling of rectangular plates subjected to shear force using
on the ultimate strength of stiffened panels, Eng. Struct. 45 the Galerkin method, Appl. Math. Modell. 33, 1874–1885
(2012) (2009)
[6] W. Jianzhong, H. Ying, C. Yanling et al., Shear buckling [15] Y. Duansheng, H. Yan, L. Guangli, Shear buckling analysis
analysis for simply supported plate panel with larger of anisotropic rectangular plates, Chin. J. Appl. Mech. 29,
opening, Shipbuild. Technol. 1, 27–30 (2012) 221–224 (2012)
[7] G. Eccher, K. Rasmussen, R. Zandonini, Elastic buckling [16] J.K. Paik, Ultimate strength of perforated steel plates under
analysis of perforated thin-walled structures by the iso- edge shear loading, Thin-Walled Struct. 45, 301–306 (2007)
parametric spline finite strip method. Thin-Walled Struct. [17] C.H. Pham, Shear buckling of plates and thin-walled channel
46, 165–191 (2008) sections with holes, J. Constr. Steel Res. 128, 800–811 (2017)
10 Z. Zhu et al.: Mechanics & Industry 23, 4 (2022)
[18] C. Yan, T. Fenglian, X. Zhigang, In-plane stress analysis of [20] N.Z. Chen, C.G. Soares, Buckling analysis of stiffened
thin sheet with irregular shape, Mach. Des. Manufact. 8, composite panels, in: III European Conference on Computa-
218–220 (2012) tional Mechanics, Springer, Netherlands, 2006
[19] F. Wei-gang, Y. Feng, W. Hong et al., The buckling [21] L. Xiangdong, Ship structure and strength (Harbin Engi-
numerical analysis of rectangular plates under shear force, neering University Press, 2010)
Mach. Des. Manufact. 8, 20–22+26 (2015)
Cite this article as: Z. Zhu, X. Li, Q. Chen, Y. Cai, Shear buckling of ship plates with different holes, Mechanics & Industry 23, 4
(2022)