IPR Short Notes
IPR Short Notes
Concept of Intellectual
Property (IP)
The term 'property' is of widest importance. The Supreme Court defined property
to mean "the highest right a man can have to anything being that right which one
has to lands or tenements, goods or chattels which does not depend on another's
courtesy. It includes ownership of estates and interests in corporeal things, and
also rights, such as trademarks, copyrights, patents and even rights 'in personam"
capable of transfer or transmission, such as debts, and signifies a beneficial right to
or athing considered as having a money value, especially with reference to transfer
or succession, and of their capacity of being acquired".
Property may be corporeal and incorporeal. Corporeal property is always visible
and tangible. It relates to material things. Whereas, incorporeal property is
intangible and having no physicalexistence. Intellectual property rights deals with
intangible property.
Intellectual property is a legal concept which refers tocreations of the mind for
which exclusive rights are recognised. Under IP Law, owners are granted certain
Cclusive rights to a variety of intangible asets, such as musical, literary and Cin th
artistic works, discoveries, inventions and words, phrases, symbols and design
ghts, trade dress and in some jurisdiction trade secrets. Concepta
P cannot be defined or identified by its own physical parameters. Generally, Theories C
trademarks, copyrights, patents and trade secrets are referred to as intellectual " Internatior
to Intellect
property.
copyright. However, certificate of registration of
erevcopr
iladtienngce¢
History of IP and the entries nade therein serve as prima fucie
with reference to
AVenetian Lawof 1474 made the first systematic attempt a court of law dispute ie
to protect an invention in the fornm of patent. In the same ownership of copyright. Application for tn
entury, Johannes Gutenberg contributed to the o igin of filed inCopyright office. copyright Can be
the first 'Copyright System' in the world. Computer software or programme can also be
Although, the British Statute of Anne (1710) and the "literary work'. As per Copyright Act, 1957, of registered
India,'
a
Statute of Monopolies (1624) are nowseen as the origins of work' includes computer programmes, tableiteranad
the copyright and patent law respectively. Modern usage of compilations, including computer database,
the terms dates back to l867 with the founding of the 'Source Code' has also to be supplied along
North German Federation whose Constitution granted application for registration of copyright for with the
Iegislative power over protection of the IP to the federation, products. softwite
after the merger of Paris Convention (1883) and the Berne The 2012 amendments make Indian
Convention (1886) as adopted IP in their common title. compliant with the Internet Treaties like the Copyright La
WIPO
Objectives of IP Intellectual Property Organisation) Copyright (Wots
Trn
(WCT) and WIPO Performances and
" To protect the rights of the product, its innovators, (WPPT).
Phonograms Treat:
inventors, research sponsors and the public.
To eliminate the infringement, improper exploitation Industrial Property
and abuse of the project's intellectual assets belonging to Industrial property means a property that is used ig
the product or the other persons. manufacturing, processing or warehousing. It is a kind
Tooptimise the environment and incentives for research intellectual property. It relates to creations of the human
and for the creation of new knowledge. mind. Such creations are inventions and industrial desiom
" To promote linkages with industry and stimulate Industrial property includes trademarks,patents, industral
research through developing and utilising novel designs, geographical indications, trade secrets, etc.
technologies and creative works for commercialisation These are as follows
and plough back resources to the interested parties.
1. Trademark
" To promote creativity and innovation. Atrademark is typically a name, word, phrase, logo, symba.
" To ensure fair and equitable distribution of all benefits
accruing from all innovations and inventions. design, image, or a combination of these elements. There s
also a range of non-conventional trademarks comprising
Types of Intellectual Property marks which do not fall into these standard categories, sud
as those based on colour, smell, or sound (like jingles. A
Intellectual property is usually divided into two branches trademark cannot be offensive.
Copyright According to Section 2(1) (zb) of the Trademarks Act, 1%
Copyright is a bundle of rights given by the law to the of India, a trademark should be capable ot Du
creators of literacy, dramatic, musical and artistic works and represented graphically and should also be capable 0
the producers of cinematography and sound recordings. distinguishing the goods or services of one person tu
The rights provided under Copyright law include the rights those of others. tothe
of reproduction of the work, communication of the work to The function of trademark is to give an indication
manufactur
the public, adaptation of the work and translation of the tothe
purchaser or a possible purchaser as indicationofbi
work. Ideas or concepts do not have copyright protection. quality of the goods or services, to give an senvio
goods or thei
Copyrights of works of the countries mentioned in the eye or the trade source from which the Pas on
International Copyright Order are protected in India, as if come, or the trade hands through which they
such works are Indian works. way to the market. brvugt
of tradenark
MarksAt
The term of copyright in a work shallnot exceed that limit In India, the first legislation in respect
Merchandise
which is enjoyed by it in its country of origin. Acquisition of on the statute book was the Indian Trademarks whit
copyright is automatic and it does not require any formality. 1889. This act was followed by the adopted
Copyright comes into existence as soon as a work is created Accordingly, the Trademarks Act, 1999 was
and no formality is required to be completed for acquiring came into force on 15th September, 2005.
2Patent
A
patent is an exclusive right granted for an invention, leatures, such as the shape of an article, or two dimnensional
features, such as patterns, lines or colour"
whihlsaproduct or process that provides, in general, a
newway off doing something, or offers a new technical Industrial designs refer to the creative activity which resules
problem. This right is in the ornamental or formal appearance of a product and
xNution too a conferred by Patent
otice. It is arightfor an inventor to exploit his invention "design right' refers to a novel or original design that is
subjecttothe provisions of Patents Act, 1970 for alimited accorded to the proprietor of a validiy registered design.
periodoftime. Industrial designs are arn element of intellectual property.
Theobjectof.Patent law is to encourage scierntific research, In principle, the owner of a registered industrial design or of
new technology and industrial progress. The price of the a design patent has the right to prevent thrid parties from
grantofmonopolyis the disclosure of the invention at the making, slling or importing articles bearing or embodying a
which after the expiry of the fixed period (i.e.
office, design which is a copy, or substantially a copy of the
L Patent t
protected design, when such acts are undertaken for
years)ofthe monopoly, passes into the ppublic domain.
4 20 commercial purposes. Such rights are perpetual.
Theefundamental principle of patent law is that a patent is Under the TRIPS Agreement, minimum standards of
granted onlyfor. an invention which must have novelty and
protection of industrial designs have been provided. As a
utility. It is. essential for the validity of apatent that it must developing country, India has already amended its national
e the inventor's own disCOvery as opposed to mere
legislation to provide for these minimalstandards.
verification of what was already known before the date of The existing legislation on industrial designs in India is
dthe patent. Apatentable invention, apart from being anew contained in the New Designs Act, 2000 and this Act serves
. manufacture, must also be useful.
its purpose well in the rapid changes in technology and
Protection of Inventions Act was adopted in 1883. These international developments.
acts were consolidated in 1888 as the Inventions and India has also achieved a mature status in the 'field' of
Design Act. The 'Patents Bill' was introduced in the Lok industrial designs and in view of globalisation of the
Sabha on 21st September, 1965, which however lapsed. In economy, the presernt legislation is aligned with the changed
1967,again an amended bill was introduced, which was technical and commercial scenario and made to confom to
referred to as Joint Parliamentary Committee and on the international trends in design administration.
Einal recomnmendation of the committee, the Patents Act,
1970 was passed. The Act came into force on 20th April, 4.Geographical Indications
1972. A Geographical Indication (GI) is a sign used on products
Some important facts related to patent are that have a specific geographical origin and possessess
E Evergreening of Patent is not Allowed In order to be qualities or a reputation that are due to that origin. In order
patentable, an improvement on something known to function as a GI, a sign must identify a product as
before or a combination of different matters already originating in a given place.
known, should be something more than a mere In addition, the qualities, characteristics or reputation of the
Workshop improvement, and must independently satisfy product should be essentially due to the place of origin.
the test of invention or an inventive step. Since, the qualities depend on the geographical place of
must produce a new result, or a new article or a better production, there is a clear link between the product and its
u cheaper article than before. The new subject matter original place of production.
must involve 'invention' over what-is-old. A geographical indication right enables those who have the
" k
Allows Licensing This strikes balance right to use the indication toprevent its use by a third party
between twoCompulsory
objectives, i.e. rewarding patentees for whose product does not conform to the applicable standards.
innovation and to make sure that patented products, For example, in the jurisdictions in which the Darjeeling
inparticularly pharmaceutical ones, are available to public geographical indication is protected, producers of Darjeeling
afforddevel
able opripincges.
and underdeveloped countries at tea can exclude the use of the termn Darjeeling' for tea not
grown in their tea gardens or not produced according to the
standards set out in thecode of practice for the geographical
.Indust
per riWIPO,
al Desi"ingn a legal sense, an industrial design
indication.
Depending on the legal system, the protection of trade Everyone has property right in the labour of his own body,The
labour of his body and the work of his hands are properly his
secrets forms part of the general concept of protection The appropriation of an unowned object (ideas or theories)
against unfair competition or is based on specific provisions arises out of application of human labour to that object.
or case law on the protection of confidential information. Mixing one's own labour with unowned thing confers upon a
The subject matter of trade secrets is usually defined in property right in the whole thing. However, after appopriation,
broad terms and includes sales methods, distribution there must remain objects of similar quality in sufficient quanty
methods, consumer profiles, advertising strategies, lists of for others i.e. 'Enough and as good left for other'.
suppliers and clients, and manufacturing processes.
The final determination of what information constitutes a Utilitarian Theory
trade secret, will depend on the circumstances of, each Utilitarian is institution socially beneficial. Act
individual case, and unfair practices in respect of secret utilitarianism is a utilitarian theory of ethics which states
information include industrial or commercial espionage,
breach of contract and breach of confidence. that a person's act is morally right, if and only if, it produces
the best possible results in that specific situation.
Theories of Intellectual Act utilitarianism is based on the principle of utility,
which is the basis of all utilitarian theories and is best
Property summed up in Bentham's well-known phrase, 'the greatest
happiness for the greatest number'. It states that we
There are four main justifications offered for Intellectual
Property Rights (IPRs), which includes natural rights have intellectual property systems because it has the effect
theory, utilitarian theory, ethic and reward theory, on the betterment of the society. Its correctness is to be
personality-based or personhood theory. assessed in the economic success of the countries.
This theory is advocated by economists such as Bentham
The NaturalRights Theory and Mill and assume that the objective of any policy should
It is the theory of bulk of right that is vestedonly on human be the attainment of the greatest good for the greatest
being. In another sense, natural law is a doctrine of rights number. However, utilitarian arguments can be cut tor or
which are fundamental element to survive as human being against the claims of intellectual property rights.
onthis universe. Specially, great contribution of natural law The utility gains from increased incentives for innovation
is human rights which exist in this days, in very powerful must be weighed against the losses incurred from
ways. monopolisation and their diminished diffusion. Thus, the
The natural rights theory considers that everyone has a problem arises, as the benefits gained cannot be measured
natural property right on his ideas. Aperson has a right to against the losses suffered.
own the creation of his mind in the same manner he owns Such kind of theories have never been successtul as we
Creation of his labour. When a person is deprived of what he would expect them to be. There is an objection from
has created, there is a violation of IP. economists. When intellectual property is given exclusive
The problem is that natural right theory doesn't cope with rights, according to them, it is a creation of a monopoly
the temporal limitationof intellectual property rights. It is right. Monopoly is contradistinguished with a perfectly
true that temporal limitation is applicable to iintellectual competitive market. If monopoly is unrestricted, it will
property. Intellectual property is most of the time limited in result in market crush.
time as to the protection accorded by law.
Itheneverthelaw gives an exclusive right to the innovator, deserving of protection, since in asense they are a part ot
holder is not enabled to conttol the
Jherear s0 many ways of resolving a problem. Thatproblem.
means that physical person
intellectual propety law which prohibits Hegel, who is the main souce of this theorv, claims hat
innovatoIN from innovating a Intellectual rightspermit and protect the developing of the
solution to the sne personality, which ctends to the maerial things In the
mem.
sane way, the copier is considered as a thicf who offers to
The Ethic and Reward Theory the public, someone else's spirit
Iheerewandtheory advocates rewardingindividuals not only However, such a justification is deficient in the sense that
the personality is neither linked nor affected by the
ÁNtheir own labour, but also for the societal benefit of their
outcome of the reati because it is noA Costitutive by
tort. This theory justifies the cxclusive rights of
ntellectual property with some moral and ethical aspect. itself of the human person. Indeed, when the creation is
done, the work is independent from its creator but
Indeed, the ethic requires a fair and proportional dependent on the public. As a matter of fxt, the work
contribution,for the effort that the creator has made for the obtains substance only because the others decicded to attach
! oal utility. The exclusive rights are an expression of importance to it.
gratitude to an author for doing more than society expects The personality theory is described by Fisher as justifyirng
a feels that they are obliged to do. the property rights "when and only when they wouid
However, since rewards are given to people who did promote human flourishing by protecting or fostering
omething disagreeable and grievous for the benefit of the fundamental human needs or interests". Such needs or
whole society, we could question whether creators and interests include privacy, individual self realisation, identity
inventors truly deserve it. By admitting that they do, it is and benevolence. These needs have been identified by
obvious that they definitively do not deserve it twice. Fisher himself.
Some consider that the inventor is already remunerated In all of the theories, the nature and characteristics of
considering that if the invention is really in advance, the economic efficiency and social justice are greatiy apart when
time between the apparition of his invention and the first the issue is attribution of rights. As the name indicates,
copies will give him enough profit to reward him. In this economic efficiency implies an allocation of rights which
2Se, it is evident that the exclusive right is far more complies with basic economic principles, namely the
excessive. maximisation of welfare.