Commercial Law
Commercial Law
FACULTY OF LAW
ASSIGNMENT FILE
ON
COMMERCIAL LAW
SUBMITTED TO – SUBMITTED BY –
1|Page
Acknowledgement
2|Page
INDIAN PARTNERSHIP ACT 1932
Introduction
Partnership results from a contract and is governed by the Partnership Act 1932. The
partnership is also governed by the general provision of the Indian Contract Act on
such matters where the Partnership Act is silent. It is expressly mentioned that the
provision of India Contract Act which is not repealed will be applicable on Partnership
until and unless such provision is in contrary to any provision of Partnership Act, 1932.
The rules of contract regarding the capacity to contract, offer, acceptance etc will
also be applicable to the partnership. But the rules regarding the status of minor will
be governed by the Partnership Act, 1932 since Section 30 of the Act talks about the
position of the minor.
Nature of Business
It is a business organization where two or more persons agreed to join together to
carry out the business for the purpose of earning the profits. It is an extension of a
sole proprietorship. It is better than sole proprietorship because in sole proprietorship
the business is carried out by the individual with limited capital and limited skill. Due
to the limited resources of a single individual carrying a sole proprietorship, a larger
business requiring more resources and investment than available to the sole
proprietor cannot be thought of such business. On the other hand in partnership, a
number of partners join together with their capital to form an agreement and carry
out a business jointly.
Meaning
“Partnership is the relation between persons who have agreed to share the profits of
a business carried on by all or any one of them acting for all”.
3|Page
The agreement must be to carry out the business jointly or by any of them
acting on the behalf of all i.e., there must be mutual agency.
Examples:
A and B buy 100 tons of oil which they agree to sell for their joint account. This forms
a partnership and A and B are considered as partners.
A and B buy 100 tons of oil and agreed to share it among them. It does not form a
partnership as they had no intention to carry out business.
Number of members
Any two or more persons may form a partnership. There is no limit imposed on the
minimum and the maximum number of partners under the Partnership Act,1932.
According to Companies Act 2013, the maximum number of 100 must not exceed in
case of partnership and minimum is 2 partners.
If in any case, it exceeds the maximum limit then it will amount to the illegal
association under Section 464 of Companies Act,2013. According to Section 11 of
Companies Act the maximum number of partner in case of:
Agreement
The partnership is an agreement in which two or more person has decided to carry out
business and share the profit and losses equally. To create a legal relationship it is
necessary to form a partnership agreement.
The partnership agreement becomes the foundation or the basis on which it is based.
It can be either written or oral. The written agreement is known as a partnership
deed. Partnership deed mainly consists of the following details:
4|Page
Rules to be followed in case of admission, retirement and death of a partner
Mode of settlement on disputes among partner.
Any other affecting the rights of the partners.
The business is to be carried by all of them or by any one of them on behalf of all. It
gives two assumptions
Each partner is entitled to carry out the business. The mutual agency exists between
the partners. Each partner is a principal as well as an agent for the other partners.he
is bound by the acts of other partners as well as can bind others by his own act.
Sharing of profit
The agreement is to share profit and losses among the partners. The sharing of profit
and losses can be according to the ratio of the capital contributed or equally.
It helps to distribute the burden among the partners in the case when the partnership
suffers losses.
Liability of partnership
All the partners are jointly liable for paying the debts of the firm. The liability is
unlimited which means that the partner’s private assets can be disposed of for the
purpose of paying the debts of the firm.
Test of partnership
Section 6
Section 6 of the Indian Partnership Act provides the mode of determining the
existence of a partnership. The following are the provisions in Section 6:
5|Page
1. While determining whether an association of persons is a firm or if a person
is a partner to a firm, the real relation shown by relevant facts between the
parties must be examined.
2. Sharing profits from a property held by persons jointly does not
automatically qualify such persons as partners.
3. A person can hold a receipt of the share in profits or receipt of payment
that is contingent upon the profits, but that does not make him a partner.
The following are such persons:
It is clear from Section 6 that the sharing of profits is not the ultimate test for
determining whether a partnership exists. The existence of a partnership depends on
the actual intention of the parties and the contract drawn up by them. In some cases,
an alleged partner might have a share in the profits of the business, but that does not
by default make him a partner.
The earlier position was that the share of profits is the criteria for determining
partnership, as held in the case of Waugh v. Carver (1973). The House of Lords
overruled this decision in the case of Cox v. Hickman (1860). In this case, Lord
Crownworth held that the real test of partnership is mutual agency among the
members of the particular association. However, the factor of share of profits cannot
be eliminated. Share of profits is certainly an important piece of evidence that helps
to determine the existence of a partnership, but not the ultimate test.
Kinds of partnership
Partnership at will
when no fixed period is prescribed for the expiration of partnership then it is a
partnership at will. According to Section 7 two conditions need to be fulfilled:
6|Page
No agreement about the determination of the fixed period of partnership
No clause with respect to the determination of partnership.
When the partners fixed the duration of the partnership firm then after the expiration
of the fixed period the partnership comes to an end. When the partners decided to
continue with the partnership even after the expiry of the fixed period then it
becomes a partnership at will.
When the partnership is created for completing any project or undertaking. When
such an undertaking or project have been completed then partnership comes to an
end. The partners have a choice to continue with the firm.
General Partnership
when the partnership is created for the purpose of carrying out the business. There is
no particular task that has to be completed. The task is general in nature.
If any of the partners have made the contract without the consent of all other
partners then the question as to the validity of such contract arises. If all the partners
have accepted or ratified the contract then no question as to the validity of such
contract arise.
With the consent of all the partners, the partnership can become a member of
another firm.
7|Page
Partners
The member of a partnership is called partners.it is not mandatory that all the
partners are the same or all the partners participate in the conduct of the business or
share the profit or losses equally. The partners are classified depending on the nature
of work, the extent of liability, etc. There are basically six types of partner:
All the partners have a right to create their own terms and condition with regard to
the affairs of the business in the partnership deed. The Indian Partnership Act has
prescribed the provision to govern the relation of partners and this provision is
applicable in case when there is no deed. The various rights of the partners are
explained below:
8|Page
Such a deed can be made either expressly or by necessary implication. For example, if
one partner looks into sales daily and other partners do not object to it, his conduct
will be presumed as the right of all the partners in the absence of written agreement.
So it can be concluded that all partners create a right for their own.
9|Page
liabilities, whether it was made in ordinary course of business or in
emergency.
Right to dissolve the partnership: Section 44 provides that a partner has
the right to file a suit to dissolve the partnership. The court may dissolve
firm on any of the grounds given below:
Section 46 provides that after dissolution, a partner has the right to wind up
the business of the firm. On dissolution, every partner or his
representative is entitled, as against all the other partners, to have the
firm’s property applied in payment of debts and liabilities of the firm, and
then have the surplus distributed among the partners or their
representatives.
Right to not get expelled: Section 33 provides that all partners have right
to not get expelled except on certain grounds and they must be given
reasonable warning and opportunity of explanation before the expulsion.
Right to prevent introduction of new person: Section 31 provides that
every partner has the right to prevent the introduction of a new partner
without his consent to the firm, unless the agreement has expressly
provided that such introduction is permitted.
Right to retire: Section 32 of the Act provides that a person has right to
retire with the consent of other partners, unless the requirement of consent
is waived by the agreement. The partners can retire by simply providing a
notice to other partners in partnerships at will.
Section 18 to 22 of the Act talks about the relation of partners third parties
Section 18 prescribes that the partners are an agent of the firm for the purpose of
conducting the affairs of the business. The partners act as the principal and agent as
well. when he performs the act in his own interest he is the principal and when he
10 | P a g e
does in the interest of another partner then he is an agent. He is not an agent for the
dealings or the transactions between the partners themselves.
Section 19 states that any act which is performed by the partners in the usual course
of its business binds the firm itself. The authority to bind the firm is implied authority
Section 20 states that partners can make a contract to restrict or expand the implied
authority of a partner.
Section 21 states that if any act is done by any partners in case of an emergency
which a prudent man would do, then such acts need to bind the firm.
Section 22 specifies that if any act is done by any partner then it must be done in the
name of the firm or in such manner which binds the firm.
Duties of partners
11 | P a g e
Duty to act diligently: As per Section 12(b), a firm’s partner must act
diligently in the business.
Duty to perform without remuneration: As per Section 13(a), every partner
must perform and attend to the firm’s business without expecting
remuneration. There is a presumption that all partners are to work for the
common advantage of the firm.
Duty to share losses: As per Section 13(b) of the Act, partners must share
losses in the proportions as provided by the partnership agreement. If the
agreement does not provide it, it must be shared in the proportion that they
share the profits.
Duty to indemnify for wilful neglect: As per Section 13(f), a partner shall
indemnify his firm for any of the losses caused to it due to his wilful neglect
during the course of the business. Wilful neglect refers to an act that is
deliberate and intentional.
Duty to not assign his rights: No partner can assign his rights in a
partnership firm to a third person in order to make him a partner.
Duty to act within authority: Every person has to act within the authority
that he has conferred upon him as per the partnership agreement.
Duty to account private profits: Section 16(a) provides that no partner can
use the partnership firm’s property for private use, or use any profits
derived from the partnership business for his own advantage. If the property
of profits of a firm is ever used for personal advantage, it must be
accounted for.
Duty not to compete: Section 16(b) states that no partner of a firm can
carry on another business simultaneously, except with the consent of other
partners. On the failure of obtaining the consent, he must account for all
the profits he made as a result of that and must compensate for the losses
sustained by the firm if any.
Duty to properly use the firm’s property: Sections 14 and 15 of the Act
provide that the property of the firm must be used solely for the purpose of
the firm’s business and not for private purposes. The term ‘property of the
firm’ covers all properties and rights and interests in a property originally
acquired by the firm for the purpose of running the business. The goodwill
of the business is also a property of the firm.
The existing relationship between the partners come to an end when there is a
change in the constitution of the firms. Such changes in the constitution of the firm
may occur due to the following reasons (Section 17)
12 | P a g e
Expiration of term of the firm.
Carrying out the additional business other than agreed upon.
Changes in the composition of members due to admission, retirement or the
death of a partner.
The duties and rights of partners remain the same until there is any change in
agreement but such right and duties may vary or modified by creating a fresh
agreement.
Status of a minor
Section 30 states the legal provision related to the minor according to Section 18 of
the Indian Contract act 1872, no person below the age of 18 years can enter into the
contract which implies that no minor can enter into a contract. But Section 30 states
that the minor cannot be a partner in a partnership firm but he can be admitted to
benefit from the partnership firm. The minor will be liable to get only the benefits
from the partnership but is not liable for any losses or liability. The minor can be
admitted to the partnership only with the consent of all the partners.
Liabilities of a minor
A minor has Limited liability. If minor is declared as insolvent his share will
be kept in the possession of official liquidator.
If after attaining the age of 18 years he decided to become the partner then
he has to give public notice within 6 months of attaining the majority. If
notice not given then minor will become liable for all the acts of others until
the notice is given
When a minor partner becomes the major he will be liable for the acts of all
partners to the third parties.
If he decided to become a full-time partner then he will be considered as a
normal partner and will take part in the conduct of the business.
13 | P a g e
Liabilities
Liability of partners for the acts of the firm (Section 25): All the partners
is jointly and severally liable for the acts of the firms. He is liable only for
those acts which are done at the time he is a partner.
Liability of a firm for the wrongful act of partner (Section 26): When any
wrongful act or omission is done by any of its partners in the ordinary course
of its business or with the consent of others partners then the firm is liable
to the same extent as a partner.
Liability of a firm for the misapplications by partner (Section 27): when
any partner acting as an agent receives the money from the third party and
misapplies it or the firm receives the money and money are misappropriated
by any of its partners then the firm is liable to pay for the loss suffered.
Section 59 states that when the Registrar is satisfied that the conditions of Section
58 are complied with then he shall record an entry of the statement in a register
called the Register of Firms, and shall file the statement.
14 | P a g e
Non-registration of partnership firm
No suit can be initiated in civil court by the firm or other co-partners against
the third party
In case of breach of contract by the third party; the suit cannot be brought
in any civil suit. The suit must be filed by the one whose name is registered
as a partner in a register of the firm.
No partners can claim a relief of set-off.
Any action which is brought out by the third party against the firm having a
value of Rs 100 cannot be set off by the firm or any of its partners.
An aggrieved person cannot sue against firms or other partners
Generally, no action can be brought against the firm or the partners but there is
an exception to it. In a case when the firm is dissolved it can bring a suit for the
realization of his share in the firm’s property.
15 | P a g e
Modes of introduction
Section 32 of Act talks about the retirement of partners. When the partner withdraws
from the partnership by dissolving it then it is dissolution but not a retirement.
16 | P a g e
Liabilities of retired partner
A retired partner continues to be liable for the acts of firms and other partners till he
or any other partners give public notice about his retirement. When the third party
does not know that he was a partner and deals with the firm; then in such case a
retired partner is not liable. if it is a partnership at will then there is no requirement
to give public notice about his retirement.
The outgoing partner may enter into an agreement to not carry similar business or
activities within a specified period of time.
A partner can be expelled only when below three conditions are satisfied:
Generally, the partnership comes to end on the death of a partner but if there is a
contract between partners to continue with the partnership on the death of a partner
then surviving partner continues with the business after clearing the deceased partner
estate from any liability for the future acts of the firms.
17 | P a g e
Liability of outgoing partner (Section 36)
The outgoing partner may enter into an agreement not to carry similar business or
activities within a specified period of time. After the specified period, the outgoing
partner is allowed to carry on a similar business or advertise it.
When the any of the partners ceases to be a partner or dies and remaining partner
continues with the business without settling the accounts then the outgoing partner is
liable to get a share from the profit earned by the firm since the date he ceases to be
a partner.
The share may be attributable to the use of a share of his property or 6% interest per
annum on the amount of share in his property.
The surviving partner has the option to purchase the share of the deceased partner
and if they purchase it then the deceased partner has no right to get the profit
derived from such property.
Dissolution of a firm
Section 39 to 44 deals with the Dissolution of a firm.
Sometimes circumstances arise when the firm gets dissolved. Sometimes a firm is
dissolved voluntary or by the order from the court. There are various modes
prescribed under Section 39 to 44 for the dissolution of a partnership firm. Even when
the partnership is dissolved then it gives certain rights and liabilities to the partners.
18 | P a g e
Dissolution of a firm ( Section 39 to Section 44)
Liabilities of partners after the dissolution of the partnership firm (Section 45)
The partners are liable for the acts of the firm to the third party until public notice is
given. A partner who is declared as insolvent, or who is retired, the estate of a person
who dies, or who was not known as a partner at the time of dealing with the third
party will not be liable for the act.
When the firm is dissolved every partner has a right to apply for the firm’s property in
the payment of debts and liabilities. If there is any surplus it needs to be distributed
among the partners.
The partners have mutual obligations and rights until the affairs of the firm is wound
up.
When the partnership has dissolved the accounts of the partners needs to be settled
under the usual course of business. Various modes can be used for the settlement of
accounts.
The asset of the firm and the capital contributed by the partners to meet up the
deficiency in the capital is applied in the following order:
19 | P a g e
The property of the individual partners is applied firstly for the payment of separate
debts.
Personal Profit Earned After Dissolution of Firm (Section 50 and Section 53)
When the firm is dissolved by the death of the partner and business is carried out by
the existing partners or his legal heirs then they have to account for the personal
benefit earned before winding up the partnership.
Section 53 states that if there is no contract the partner can restrain other partners
from carrying similar activities, or using the firm’s name or firm’s property for their
own benefit until the winding up process is complete.
When the firm is dissolved before the expiry of a fixed period, then a partner paying a
premium can receive a return of a reasonable part of the premium. Such rules are not
applicable in a case when the partnership is dissolved by:
The goodwill is treated as an asset. The goodwill is included in the assets while
settling the account after the dissolution of the firm. The goodwill may be sold
separately or with other assets. Once the firm is dissolved and goodwill is sold then
any partners can carry on a similar business or advertise a business competing with
the buyers of the goodwill. The partners are prohibited from doing the following acts:
20 | P a g e
To solicit the customers of the firm dealing before dissolution.
Conclusion
Partnership is a very common type of business which is prevailing in the country. It
has many advantages for the company. This Act is a complete Act as it covers all the
aspect related to the partnership.
21 | P a g e
22 | P a g e