Urban Contraction
Urban Contraction
Q: the period between 4 t h century and 8 t h century CE was marked by agrarian expansion and
urban contraction. Examine the statement.
R. S. Sharma (1987) has argued that the peak of early historical urbanism in the sub continent
occurred between c. 200 BCE and 300 C E . This was followed by two phases of urban decay—
the first in the later half of the 3rd or in the 4th century C E , and the second after the 6th
century C E . According to Sharma, archaeological evidence from all over the subcontinent
reflects the phenomenon of urban decline. He also points to a decrease in references to artisans
and merchants in inscriptions. Sharma admits the literary evidence for urban decay is not
strong, but cites the gloomy prophecy made in Varahamihira's Brihatsamhita that various towns
will either be destroyed or will fall on evil days, the Valmiki Ramayana's description of
Ayodhya after Rama's exile, and the picture of the city's desolation in Kalidasa's Raghuvamsha.
He explains the urban decay as the result of a decline in long-distance trade and asserts that it
lasted for at least seven centuries. A mild urban renewal occurred in some parts of the
subcontinent in the 11th century, and by the 14th century, urbanism became a recognizable
process.
With specific reference to the Vakataka kingdom, Shrimali (1987: 30) argues for a decline
in trade, traders, and the urban economy, and asserts that the inscriptions convey a picture of a
non-monetary, small-scale village economy, an expansion of rural settle ments, a contraction of
urbanism, and an early onset of feudalism. There are scarcely any references to urban centres
(this is actually not surprising, given that they are grants of rural land). Only about 16
settlements can be tentatively identified as having some sort of urbanness—on the basis of
suffixes such as 'pura', 'puraka', and 'nagara'.
The hypothesis that there was a subcontinental urban decay during c. 300-600 CE, can be
questioned on several grounds. 1 Texts of the time abound in lengthy, poetic de scriptions of
cities and citydwellers that need not be taken literally, but certainly reflect an idea and
awareness of flourishing urban centres. The Brihatsamhita mentions the opulent paraphernalia of
kings and courts and mansions of kings, officials, and other wealthy people. The
Mrichchhakatika gives a vivid description of the heroine Vasantasena's mag nificent house in
Ujjayini, its lofty portal and gold doors studded with diamonds, and its lavishly decorated
rooms. The Amarakosha offers lists of words for various kinds of ornaments and elaborate
articles of clothing. The descriptions of the wealthy, educated, refined, and sophisticated man-
about-town—referred to in the Kamasutra as the naga- raka—are similarly connected with an
urban milieu. And the very production of a so phisticated range of literature of various genres,
as well as the architectural and sculptural products of this period, point to an urban milieu and
urban sources of patronage.
The vivid descriptions of cities and city life in the Tamil epics clearly indicate
that urbanism was an on-going process in the far south. The Silappadikaram
describes the busy and bustling markets of Puhar and Madurai, with sellers of
flowers, garlands, aromatic powder, betel nut, shell bangles, wines, cloth, and
garments. There were also shopkeepers, gem workers, and various kinds of
skilled workers.
1 The problems in accepting this theory for the subsequent centuries will be discussed in
Chapter 10.
595 A HISTORY OF ANCIENT AND EARLY MEDIEVAL INDIA
AGRARIAN EXPANSION
The expansion of the agrarian economy was the result of various factors such
as the extension of the margin of agriculture through land reclamation, the
spread of irrigation techniques, and an expansion in the range of crops. The
increase in the area under cultivation can be inferred from the fact that donees
of land grants were sometimes given rights over forested area, references to
forests in the vicinity of gifted land, and the mention of the transfer of
wasteland to the donee. There is some direct evidence as well. A 6th century
inscription of the Kadambas (who ruled over the Goa area) gave the Brah-
mana donee the right to engage labourers in order to clear a piece of forested
area and bring it under cultivation. It also mentions the reclamation of a tract
of coastal land, and its conversion to rice fields by damming up seawater.
The use of the araghatta (Persian wheel) spread to South India in the
early medieval period. Inscriptions mention sluices which distributed
the water of rivers and tanks. Nandi (2 00 0: 91 -9 4) has described the
596 A HISTORY OF ANCIENT AND EARLY MEDIEVAL INDIA