Next Generation Is
Next Generation Is
Next-Generation
Information Systems Theories
Special Issue Editors
Andrew Burton-Jones, University of Queensland (abj@business.uq.edu.au)
Brian Butler, University of Maryland (bsbutler@umd.edu)
Susan Scott, London School of Economics (S.V.Scott@lse.ac.uk)
Sean Xin Xu, Tsinghua University (xuxin@sem.tsinghua.edu.cn)
Now is a particularly opportune time for the Information Systems field to take stock of its theoretical progress and develop next-
generation IS theories. We are witnessing fundamental changes in the field’s core phenomena as well as major changes in our
data, methods, and categories of knowledge. This Special Issue offers an opportunity to energize the best theoretical minds in
the field to see if we can lay the foundations for a new generation of research.
This will be the second MIS Quarterly’s Special Issue devoted to theory papers.1 As a result, this Special Issue represents an
opportunity for MISQ to publish not only the best theoretical work, but also the best of the theory paper genre. While not wishing
to limit the structure of papers submitted to the Special Issue, we suggest three examples that might work for many authors:
1. Pure theory papers: Papers that provide a detailed review of theory in a focal domain but where the new theoretical contri-
bution departs from the prior literature and the focus is on the new theory being generated.
2. Review-oriented theory papers: Papers that provide a very detailed review of theory in a focal domain and where the new
theoretical contribution stems from the authors’ synthesis of that review (e.g., through its critique or reformulation).
3. Empirically enhanced theory papers: Papers that focus on the generation of new theory but where data plays an important
developmental, illustrative, or justificatory role.
1
In March 1999, MIS Quarterly issued a Call for Submissions for a Special Issue on Redefining the Organizational Roles of Information Technology in the
Information Age. The issue was motivated by transformations occurring throughout the 1990s. The papers for that Special Issue appeared in the September 2002
issue (Volume 26, Number 3).
If a given submission is in the grey area between a theory paper and another style of paper, the Editors of the Special Issue will
make a final decision on the paper’s appropriateness for the issue.
The Special Issue takes a broad and inclusive view of theory and encourages all and any type of theoretical contribution related
to IS. While being open to substantial variety, the common element underlying all successful papers in the Special Issue will be
that they offer incisive and important theoretical contributions that change the way we think in the IS field.
Summing up, attractive papers for the Special Issue will be those that
• Motivate: Strong papers will identify areas in which there is inadequate theorization and motivate the need for new theory
with evidence and arguments for why the limitations of current theories, or the lack of theory altogether, has real, substantive
consequences.
• Create: Papers will either develop a significant theoretical advance to existing theory (whether through revising or chal-
lenging it) or create entirely new theory.
• Mobilize: Effective papers will be written so as to excite a significant portion of the MISQ audience to take on the challenges
and pursue the possibilities arising from their ideas.
Submission of an extended abstract is not necessary to in order to submit to the Special Issue, but it is highly encouraged. Authors
will submit the extended abstracts through the MIS Quarterly ScholarOne submission system, which will be open from November
1, 2018, to November 15, 2018. High-level feedback will be provided on each abstract by January 15, 2019. (MISQ’s ScholarOne
submission site is located at https://mc.manuscriptcentral.com/misq)
Full papers are due April 1, 2019, via the MIS Quarterly ScholarOne submission system. All papers will be submitted in the
Special Issue category. The system will be open for submissions to the Special Issue from March 1, 2019, to April 1, 2019.
Key Dates:
• Submission of extended abstracts: November 15, 2018
• Feedback on extended abstracts to authors: January 15, 2019
• First round submission: April 1, 2019
• First round decisions to authors: July 1, 2019 [i.e., 3 month review cycle]
• Theory development workshop: August 1, 2019
• Second round submission: December 1, 2019 [i.e., 5 months for revisions]
• Second round decision to authors: March 1, 2020 [i.e., 3 month review cycle]
• Third and final round submissions: July 1, 2020 [i.e., 4 months for revisions]
• Third and final round decisions to authors: September 1, 2020 [i.e., 2 month review cycle by the editors only, not reviewers]
To view the full Call for Papers, go to the MIS Quarterly’s home page at https://misq.org