Part Specification & Manufacturing Feasibility

S.K Engineers
Drg. Discription DS-501015 Revision No. X2 Revision Date. 05.02.22

Supplier Location
Supplier for this
Part (Tick) Under Production New Regular Alternate
part (Tick)

Sr. No. Drawing Parameters Confirm Not Confirm Can'nt Confirm Not Applicable Justification / Proposal DSPL COMMENTS
1 All critical dims are understood & possible Yes
2 Material specs understood & available Yes
3 All dimensions are understood & possible. Yes
Dimensions Specifications Criticality

1 Dia 75.7-0.3 Yes

This dimension is not correct if you add ID with the
2 Dia 72.30 thickness. Also this dimension is meaningless and OK
Cant Confirm should be removed
3 Dia 69.3+0.3 Yes
4 Dimensions 10.0 Min Yes
5 Ht 30.00 Yes
6 Ht 13.00 Yes
7 Dia 91.00 Yes
8 Radius R2.0~2.5 Yes
9 Angle 90°±1° Yes
10 Material E34 Yes
11 Thk 2.5±0.15 Yes
Must be protect against Anti rust oil
12
oxidation
Yes
free from sharp corners &
13 Apperance Burrs Yes
14 Component Should Meet REACH & RoHS Yes
Remarks :

Name/Sign - Approved by Harish Sharma

(Development Head)
Fit / Function Critical

Safety / Critical
 Part Specification & Manufacturing Feasibility
S.K Engineers
Drg. Discription DS-501014 Revision No. X1 Revision Date. 28.01.22

Supplier Location
Supplier for this
Part (Tick) Under Production New Regular Alternate
part (Tick)

Sr. No. Drawing Parameters Confirm Not Confirm Can'nt Confirm Not Applicable Justification / Proposal DSPL COMMENTS
1 All critical dims are understood & possible Yes
2 Material specs understood & available Yes
3 All dimensions are understood & possible. Yes
Dimensions Specifications Criticality

1 Conc 0.30 Yes

2 Dia 17.0+0.1/+0.3
Yes

3 Radius R0.3 Max Tooled up dimension, cannot be measured. Does not MEASURED ON PROFILE
serve any purpose, sugges that it should be removed PROJECTOR CRITICAL
Can't Confirm from drawing DIMENSION
4 Dimensions 15.6~15.8 Yes

5 Angle 110° Radius at start and end of angle so difficult to cleanly

measure. This will be a tooled up dimension. Suggest
Can't Confirm to make it a reference dimension MEASURED TOOL DIMENSION
6 Perpendicularity 0.25 Yes
7 Ref Ht 20.00 Yes
8 Ht 13.00 Yes
9 Dia 38.00 Yes
10 Dia 79.0+0.3 Yes
11 Dimensions 4.0+0.5 Yes
12 Radius R1.0 Yes Tooled up dimension OK
BSK46 is not readily available in the market. We are
13 Material BSK 46 confirming that we will use E350 material or
Can't Confirm equivalent for this part OK FOR SAMPLES ONLY
14 Thk 3.0±0.2 Yes
Must be protect against Anti rust oil
15
oxidation Yes
Free from Sharp edges &
16 Apperance Burrs Yes
17 Component Should Meet REACH & RoHS Yes
Remarks :

Name/Sign - Approved by Harish Sharma

(Development Head)
Fit / Function Critical

Safety / Critical
 Part Specification & Manufacturing Feasibility
S.K Engineers
Drg. Discription DS-501048 Revision No. X1 Revision Date. 05.02.22

Supplier Location
Supplier for this
Part (Tick) Under Production New Regular Alternate
part (Tick)

Sr. No. Drawing Parameters Confirm Not Confirm Can'nt Confirm Not Applicable Justification / Proposal DSPL COMMENTS
1 All critical dims are understood & possible Yes
2 Material specs understood & available Yes
3 All dimensions are understood & possible. Yes
Dimensions Specifications Criticality

1 Radius R24 Yes Tooled Up Dimension, will come as per actual

2 Conc 0.20
Yes
3 Tapping M20X1.5 -6H Yes
4 Angle 60° Yes
5 Dim 12.00 Yes
6 Dim 16.76 Yes
Very High Thickness will make it difficult to control the 0.1 IS INLINE WITH THE
6A Flatness 0.10 flatness in 0.1 mm. Suggest to change the dimension SPEC IS 1079
Cant Confirm to 0.2 mm flatness
6B Thk 6.0±0.25 Yes
HR5 not readily available in such high thickness. Very
7 Material HR5 IS1079 high tensile needed. Request that material be
updated to E34 or E350 or equivalent for meeting the
Cant Confirm high tensile requirement OK FOR SAMPLE
8 Surface Finish Magnese Phosphate & Oiled Yes
9 Apperance Remove all sharp Corners Yes
10 Component Should Meet REACH & RoHS Yes
Remarks :

Name/Sign - Approved by Harish Sharma

(Development Head)
Fit / Function Critical

Safety / Critical
 Part Specification & Manufacturing Feasibility
S.K Engineers
Drg. Discription DS-501018 Revision No. X1 Revision Date. 15.08.21

Supplier Location
Supplier for this
Part (Tick) Under Production New Regular Alternate
part (Tick)

Sr. No. Drawing Parameters Confirm Not Confirm Can'nt Confirm Not Applicable Justification / Proposal DSPL COMMENTS
1 All critical dims are understood & possible Yes

2 Material specs understood & available HR1 not readily available locally. IS 10748 Grade 2 IF, USE IS 10748
readily available and should be provided in the MATERIAL THEN
Cant Confirm drawing GRADE 4 REQUIRED
3 All dimensions are understood & possible. Yes
Dimensions Specifications Criticality

1 Dia 104.00 Yes

2 Conc 0.30

Yes
3 Dia 88.1+0.3 Yes
4 Dimensions 2.50 Yes
5 Flatness 0.20 Yes
Material specs understood HR1 not readily available locally. IS 10748 Grade 2
6 HR1 IS1079 readily available and should be provided in the
& available
Cannot Confirm drawing
7 Thk 2.5±0.2 Yes
8 Surface finish FeZn Ni 8CS Yes
9 Component Should Meet REACH & RoHS Yes
Remarks :

Name/Sign - Approved by Harish Sharma

(Development Head)
Fit / Function Critical

Safety / Critical
 Part Specification & Manufacturing Feasibility
S.K Engineers
Drg. Discription DS-501012 Revision No. X2 Revision Date. 05.02.2022

Supplier Location
Supplier for this
Part (Tick) Under Production New Regular Alternate
part (Tick)

Sr. No. Drawing Parameters Confirm Not Confirm Can'nt Confirm Not Applicable Justification / Proposal DSPL COMMENTS
1 All critical dims are understood & possible Yes
2 Material specs understood & available Yes
3 All dimensions are understood & possible. Yes
Dimensions Specifications Criticality

1 Dia 65.65±0.05 Yes

2 Ref Dia 59.00

Yes
This dimension is not clear as it coincides with ID.
3 Dia 57.0 Min This dimension is not serving any purpose and should NO DEVIATION.MEASURED
Can't Confirm be removed TOOL DIMENSION
4 Dia 36.0 Gauge Yes
5 Dim 4.5 Min Flat Yes
6 Dim 1.75±0.2 Yes

7 Dim 7.6±0.2 Yes

8 Ht 17.50 Yes
Tooled up Dimension, hard to measure. Will come as NO DEVIATION.MEASURED
9 Parallelism 0.3 Max
Can't Confirm per the actuals TOOL DIMENSION
Tooled up Dimension, hard to measure. Will come as
10 Radius R0.75±0.25
Can't Confirm per the actuals
11 Radius R9.25±0.25 Yes
Tooled up dimension will come as per actuals,
12 Conc 0.3
Cant Confirm Cannot be measured
Tooled up dimension will come as per actuals, NO DEVIATION.MEASURED
13 Angle 23° Cannot be measured, Unecessary Dimension and TOOL DIMENSION
Cant Confirm should be removed
14 Angle 20°±2° Yes Tooled up dimension, will come as per actuals
Need additional tolerance as this dimension is not
easy to check and varies when checked from person
15 Dia 54.9±0.1 to person due to even minutest of movement in hand
or vernier. We need +/- 0.2 min tolerance in this
Can't Confirm dimension OK
16 Dia 57.5 Min Yes
Tooled up Dimension, hard to measure. Will come as
17 Radius R0.8 Yes
per the actuals NO DEVIATION.MEASURED
During forming thinning happens can maintain min TOOL DIMENSION
18 Dim 2.9 Min
Can't Confirm 2.7 mm but 2.9 mm we cannot confirm
19 Angle 23°±1°30 Yes

20 Radius R0.8
Tooled up Dimension, hard to measure. Will come as TOOLED DIMENSION MAINTAIN
Can't Confirm per the actuals WITH IN 0.8

21 Dia 17.1±0.1
Yes

Cannot be measured; can only be checked visually;

22 Radius R0.2 Yes
This dimension should be removed from the drawing

23 Conc 0.3 Max Tooled up dimension will come as per actuals,

Cant Confirm Cannot be measured, imaginary dia
NO DEVIATION.MEASURED
24 Angle 3X120° Yes Tooled up Dimension, hard to measure. Will come as TOOL DIMENSION
per the actuals
Tooled up Dimension, hard to measure. Will come as
25 Dia 22.0±0.4
Cant Confirm per the actuals

26 Radius R0.8 Max Tooled up Dimension, hard to measure. Will come as

Can't Confirm per the actuals

27 Dim 4.75 Min Flat Yes

28 Radius R1.79 Yes Tooled up Dimension, hard to measure. Will come as SHOULD NOT BE MORE THAN R
per the actuals 1.5

29 Ref Dim 12.00 Yes

30 Dim 5.5 Min Flat Yes

CR3 sometime not available. CR2 is always

31 Material CR3 avaialble.Request to update the mateiral to CR2. It is OK.
Can't Confirm almost same as CR3

32 Thk 3.0±0.2 Yes

AS PER REVISED DRAWING
THK 3.5 REQUIRED
This surface may be
33 irregular as drawn but - Yes
must be free from burrs
Flat area must be same
34 - Yes
height all around

Must be protect against

35 - Yes
oxidation for min. 3month

36 Component Should Meet REACH & RoHS Yes

Remarks :

Name/Sign - Approved by Harish Sharma

(Development Head)
Fit / Function Critical

Safety / Critical