Design and Analysis of New Auto-Tensioning Device For Overhead Catenary System of Railway
Design and Analysis of New Auto-Tensioning Device For Overhead Catenary System of Railway
(2024) 24:659–673
https://doi.org/10.1007/s11668-024-01871-4
Submitted: 22 August 2023 / Accepted: 14 January 2024 / Published online: 14 February 2024
ASM International 2024
Abstract In this paper, a new compact spring-based unregulated, i.e., fixed termination of wires is adopted. In
Auto-Tensioning Device (ATD) is designed using TRIZ such case the contact wire will hog or sag depending upon
methodology complying the Indian railway standards the ambient temperature. This in turn will deteriorate the
having reduced weight and maintains the constant tension. current collection performance of OHE and pantograph.
Analytical calculations are done and verified with FE With increasing of sag, insulation distances toward the
analysis by conducting Multibody Dynamic (MBD) anal- surrounding parts such as ground, decrease.
ysis along with structural analysis to optimize the stress The pantograph of a train causes mechanical oscillations
generation in individual components. The spring ATD in the contact wire, and the wave must travel faster than the
reduces significant weight and maintains constant tension train to avoid producing standing waves that would cause
in the contact and catenary cables, thereby preventing wire breakage. Tensioning the line with the help of a ten-
failures due to sag and tension variation. sion device makes waves travel faster. It is, therefore, a
reliable compensation of temperature-linked changes to the
Keywords Electrical overhead Catenary system length of the contact cable, and catenary cables are
Conductor sagging Tensioning devices required for smooth collection of current by the panto-
Multibody dynamics Structural analysis Failure analysis graph. Moreover, the slight reduction in tension is further
swaying of the system due to wind. The cable may come
close to other cables of different phases or to grounded
Introduction parts. The contraction of contact and/or catenary wires due
to ambient thermal reduction can cause high stresses in
The 25-kV AC overhead equipment (OHE) consists of hard cables which cause abnormal lifting of the contact wire
drawn copper contact wire suspended from cadmium with respect to the rail level, or they may break; this could
copper catenary wire by means of solid hard drawn copper not be compatible with a correct collection of the current
dropper wires, modular cantilever having insulator, stay by the pantograph [2].
tube, bracket tube, register arm, steady arm to hold the To improve current collection performance, it is essen-
conductors in position as shown in Fig. 1 [1, 2]. The ten- tial to keep the tension in OHE conductor’s constant,
sion in OHE conductors and thereby the sag depends upon irrespective of expansion of OHE conductors at higher
the temperature of the conductors when the OHE is temperatures and contraction at lower temperatures using
Auto-Tensioning Devices (ATD) at termination of OHE
conductors. Auto-Tensioning Device (ATD) is one of the
V. Patil critical components of the overhead contact lines of the
Veermata Jijabai Technological Institute (VJTI), Mumbai, railways. It serves both as a termination and providing a
Maharashtra, India mechanism for the automatic tension of the contact lines.
I. Jain (&) S. Zanje The dead weight three-pulley system of conductor
Raychem Innovation Centre, Halol, Gujarat, India
e-mail: ishantmiet@gmail.com
123
660 J Fail. Anal. and Preven. (2024) 24:659–673
123
J Fail. Anal. and Preven. (2024) 24:659–673 661
123
662 J Fail. Anal. and Preven. (2024) 24:659–673
123
J Fail. Anal. and Preven. (2024) 24:659–673 663
• Cam angle ðaÞ ¼ 270 to keep the size of device as to wind-unwind on respective pulley and cable/tension
small as possible. wire in which constant tension to be maintained is going to
• k = 237000 N/m; as k decreases, length of spring wind-unwind on cam. As the tension in cable increases/
increases and vertical displacement (difference between decreases due to contraction/expansion of cable, system
maximum and minimum radius) of tension wire will be gets unbalanced, and spring will store/release the elastic
less, thus size of device increases; whereas spring energy to balance the system by compression/relaxation of
length will decrease, and vertical displacement of spring which causes the shaft (along with pullies and cams)
tension wire will be more as k increases. to rotate. The increase or decrease in spring force is getting
balanced by increase or decrease in cam radius keeping the
One can select the above-assumed parameters based on
tension T as constant. The whole assembly is going to be
few iterations. Putting all these values in above equation
fixed on pole/support with the help of fixings [14]. The
we get,
shaft (Diameter = 50 mm) is designed as per the ASME
R0 ¼ 0:10223 m and at a ¼ 270 ; Rmax ¼ 0:249 m: code [15], spring (F max ¼ 98:5kN; deflection ¼ 0:418mÞ is
designed based on shear stress and deflection criteria in
Basically, the assumed parameters must be adjusted helical metallic spring [16–18], round rope6/36 having
such that the R0 will be greater than the shaft radius on tensile strength 1960 MPa is selected for wire ropes
which cam is going to attach and vertical displacement [19, 20], bearings (Nu2210) are selected with static loading
should also be less. In this case, the vertical displacement capacity of 39 kN [21–23].
of tension wire (h)= Rmax R0 =0.1472 m which is less
and preferable.
Numerical Analysis
Design and Working of Spring ATD Numerical analysis is performed to understand the real-
time scenario, i.e., variation of tension in outer cable with
Based on the schematic mechanism as shown in Figs. 7, 8 respect to its displacement which happens due to temper-
and 9 represents the refined design of ATD, which has four ature variation. Analysis has been done by the commercial
pulleys (two on either side of spring casing) and two cams FEA software package—COMSOL MultiphysicsTM which
(one on either side) to have balanced structure, fixed sup- compute the results based on finite element method (FEM).
port, shaft and bearing housing, spring and casing to FEM solves discretized equations which are obtained by
protect spring. Spring will be protected from environmental discretizing the mathematical model to analyze the results.
factors such as dirt, dust, moisture by the casing. The cams 3D CAD model of ATD shown in Figs. 8 and 9 is made in
and pulleys are mounted on the same shaft, and shaft is commercial software package—Autodesk InventorTM and
rotating inside the bearing housing. Four steel ropes (two imported in COMSOL. Except steel shaft and spring most
on either side) are attached to the top plate which are going
123
664 J Fail. Anal. and Preven. (2024) 24:659–673
Table 2 Material properties was given to capture detail features of models (filets, cur-
vature, holes, etc.).
Properties
Multibody Dynamic (MBD) analysis is done to know
Material E (GPa) l q (kg/m3) Yield strength (MPa) the tension in contact/catenary cable along with the force
versus displacement of spring. Stiffness (spring constant)
Aluminum 70 0.33 2700 240
value is given between the top and bottom plate in place of
52Cr4MoV 190 0.29 7800 1200
spring to reduce complexity and computational time. The
spring constant resembles the effect of spring in the system.
of the components are made from aluminum to reduce Analysis of helical spring is done separately to verify the
weight. Material properties are listed in Table 2 (Fig. 10). spring force and deflection. The boundary conditions for
Geometry is simplified from computation point of view MBD of ATD are given in following way:
to reduce complexity and computational time as shown in 1. The lower most point on the cam in y-direction is
Fig. 11 and discretized using COMSOL meshing feature. measured and taken as a reference for computation of
Figure 12 shows the detailed meshed view of ATD. Swept radius of cam at instant.
mesh is used for components having large aspect ratio in 2. As known, the cable is going to be displaced by
dimension to reduce computation time, and fine meshing 0.83 m; therefore, the prescribed displacement of
123
J Fail. Anal. and Preven. (2024) 24:659–673 665
123
666 J Fail. Anal. and Preven. (2024) 24:659–673
123
J Fail. Anal. and Preven. (2024) 24:659–673 667
123
668 J Fail. Anal. and Preven. (2024) 24:659–673
123
J Fail. Anal. and Preven. (2024) 24:659–673 669
123
670 J Fail. Anal. and Preven. (2024) 24:659–673
123
J Fail. Anal. and Preven. (2024) 24:659–673 671
Conclusion
The only maintenance that is typically required for a
spring ATD is to visually inspect it periodically to make The new spring-based ATD is a promising solution
sure that it is in good condition and that there are no signs designed as per RDSO specification no TI/SPC/OHE/
of wear or damage. If any damage is found, the spring ATD SPRINGATD/1001, for preventing failures in Overhead
should be repaired or replaced immediately. Catenary Systems. It is a lightweight and cost-effective
The prototype of the new design of ATD was developed device that can help to reduce the risk of contact wire
in-house and tested completely as per the RDSO specifi- breakage, catenary cable breakage and derailment. By
cation no TI/SPC/OHE/SPRINGATD/1001. The preventing failures, the ATD can help to improve the
performance test plot is shown in Fig. 34 where it is reliability and safety of electric train service.
123
672 J Fail. Anal. and Preven. (2024) 24:659–673
Fig. 34. Load vs displacement curve for the prototype developed in-house
Acknowledgment This research and development work was sup- 7. T. Uchida, T. Shimbori,Gas Spring Apparatus, Patent US
ported by Raychem Innovation Centre(RIC) of Raychem RPG Ltd.. A 6378848B1, 08 July 1999
sincere thanks to Dr. Samsual Ekram, head of the Raychem Innova- 8. L. Zhangping, Z. Xiaobing, L. Development, Y. Qizhi, G. Yong,
tion Centre, Halol and Dr. Sudhakar Reddy for their support, H. Guoquan, Constant tension Vortex Spring Compensating
encouragement, continued interest and sharing their valuable time Device, Patent CN101973217B, 02 Nov 2010
through their busy schedule. We would like to express our sincere 9. R. Capacchione, F. Maggi, L. Femminis, Device for Compen-
gratitude to Mr. Akash Sharma, deputy director of OHE (Moradabad sating Variations in the Length of Tensioned Cables, with
Junction), for suggesting working on this project. Substantially Constant Tension, Patent EP2066523B1, 28 Sept
2006
10. O. Nannini; Inventor, Pfisterer S.R.L, Device for Compensating
Funding The authors declare that they have received no funding from Variations in the Length of Tensioned Cables, with Substantially
anyone for this research work. Constant traction, Patent WO1998021794A1, 08 Nov 1996
11. B. Furrer, B. Casali, Tension Adjustment Device for Catenaries of
Electrical Railways, Patent EP2789498B1, 10 Apr 2013
12. B. Furrer, U. Wili, B. Casali, P. Principe, Tension Adjustment
Conflict of interest The authors declare that they have no known Device for Catenaries of Electrical Railways, Patent
competing financial interests or personal relationships that could have EP2631107B1, 27 Feb 2012
appeared to influence the work reported in this paper. 13. R. Tie, L. Wu, R. Tie, G. Tie, C. Wu, Constant Strain Spring
Compensation Device, Patent US8602178B2, 23 Jan 2007
14. I. Jain, S. Zanje, V. Patil, A Device for Maintaining Constant
References Tension in an Overhead Power Line for Electric Railways, India
Patent 2019210225808, 7 June 2019
1. B. Aynabeba, Customized Guideline for Designing Overhead 15. V. B. Bhandari, Design of Machine Elements 3rd edition
Contact System for Ethiopian Railway: Case Study of Indode 16. P.P. Thakare, V.L. Kadlag, Design and analysis of helical com-
Station (August 2014) pression spring for special purpose application. IJARIIE. 3(4),
2. F. Kiessling, R. Puschmann, A. Schmieder, E. Schnider: Contact 849–858 (2017)
Lines for Electric Railways: Planning, Design, Implementation 17. A. Agarwal, V. Jain, Design and analysis of helical spring in two
and Maintenance (Siemens, 2009) wheeler suspension system using finite element method. Int. R. J.
3. CAMTech, Gwalior, Duties of Senior Section Engineer SSE Eng. Technol. (IRJET). 4(9), 2395–10072 (2017)
(OHE) (Phase II- Module No. STC- TrD-2) 18. N.P. Chironis, Spring Design and Applications. (McGraw-Hill,
4. Specification for Spring Auto Tensioning Device specification no. New York, 1961)
TI/SPC/OHE/SPRATD/0110(12/2011) 19. G. A. Costello Theory of Wire Rope Second Edition (Department
5. Tension Compensator, Patent CN202703321U, 30 Jan 2013 of Theoretical and Applied Mechanics University of Illinois at
6. T. Kimura, Inventor; NHK Spring Co Ltd, Overhead Wire Ten- Urbana, USA) ISBN 978-1-4612-7361-5
sion Balancer and Waterproof Cover for Overhead Wire Tension 20. Usha Martin Ltd Wire Rope Hand Book (2011)
Balancer, Patent US8702072B2, 10 June 2008 21. A. Palmgren, Ball and Roller Bearing Engineering (SKF Indus-
tries, 1959)
123
J Fail. Anal. and Preven. (2024) 24:659–673 673
22. H. Peck, Ball and Parallel Roller Bearings—Design Applications Springer Nature or its licensor (e.g. a society or other partner) holds
(Pitman, 1971) exclusive rights to this article under a publishing agreement with the
23. PSG College of Technology Design Data-Design data book of author(s) or other rightsholder(s); author self-archiving of the
Engineers (Coimbatore, India) ISBN-978-81-917355-0-4 accepted manuscript version of this article is solely governed by the
terms of such publishing agreement and applicable law.
Publisher’s Note Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to
jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
123