Acta 2010 3 16
Acta 2010 3 16
Abstract:
Quantity surveyors are construction economists who fulfill varied and comprehensive duties to
support cost-effective construction and property development projects. The core competencies of
quantity surveyors include determining project budgets, measuring project quantities, preparing
contract documentation (such as Bills of Quantities and cost control documents), administering
contracts, and preparing final accounts. Despite being recognised as a professional discipline distinct
from architecture and civil engineering since 1836, quantity surveyors are not immune to the threats
and changes in their operating environment. Some parties in the construction industry have been
critical about the quality of works and services provided by quantity surveyors. Some even question
the importance of appointing quantity surveyors as project consultants. Because of these challenges,
the profession needs to regroup and take stock of the whole situation so that they will not become
extinct in the future. All parties who have vested interest in the development of the profession, be it
the students, educators, registered as well as unregistered quantity surveyors must find an answer to
arguably, the declining roles of quantity surveyors and the lack of recognition they receive in
construction projects. However, recognising the importance of professional competence, this paper
has looked into issues relating to quantity surveyors’ competency. As results, this paper was revealed
that, quantity surveying educators and practices alike, are still deeply entrenched in the ‘traditional’
core competencies rather than the newer and more novel services and skills.
Keywords:
Competency, training, continuous professional development, occupational skills, quantity surveying
many and varied (Cheetham and Chivers, 1996). Periodic financial reporting
In order to arrive at a suggested model of Technical auditing.
competencies and skills for quantity surveyors, it Assessing replacement value for insurance.
is important to elaborate and discuss the job Project management related services.
scopes and varying roles of quantity surveyors, Giving expert evidence in arbitrations,
be it in professional firms, contracting adjudications and legal disputes.
organisations, and construction client bodies. Preparing/defending against construction
This paper will firstly, describe the profession of contract claims.
quantity surveyors, then followed by discussion From being a trade-based vocation, quantity
on quantity surveyors’ job competencies, surveying had developed into a full-fledged
deliberation on the research findings and lastly, profession widely accepted in the construction
description on the suggested model of industry. The quantity surveyors, in its present
competencies for quantity surveyors. day construction industry, uses his ability to
analyse cost components of a construction
QUANTITY SURVEYING PROFESSION project in a scientific way and apply the results
of his analysis to a variety of financial and
The origins of quantity surveyors can be traced economic problems confronting the developer
back to the ancient Egyptian civilisation who and the designer. Badu and Amoah (2004) held
used dedicated personnel to carry out estimates that these changing roles had been redefined by
and costing for their magnificent structures and the educational system received by the quantity
buildings. It developed into an occupation surveyors.
during the 17th century restoration of London
after the Great Fire. In 1836 the profession DIFFERENT ROLES OF QUANTITY SURVEYORS
entered its new age when the new Houses of
Parliament of Great Britain, designed by Sir There are several options in the quantity
Charles Barry, became the first major public surveying field. A qualified quantity surveyor can
contract to be fully measured and tendered usually gain employment in quantity surveying
using detailed bills of quantities for financial firms, construction companies, or property
accountability (RICS 2005). A quantity surveyor developers. Some large public or private
is a professional in the construction industry organisations that deal with a significant amount
who has the ability to analyse both cost of building or construction procurement as part
components and practical physical construction of their activities normally employ quantity
works of a project in a successful way so as to be surveyors among other construction
able to apply the results of his analysis in solving professionals to become their project managers.
problems peculiar to each project (Badu and Quantity surveyors working in consultant firms
Amoah, 2004). In general, the principal services are retained by the construction clients to ensure
that could be offered by any quantity surveying that what is eventually built is what the clients
firm are (John Austen Associates 2004): want or could afford (National Commercial
Preliminary cost advice and feasibility Services UK, 2004). The responsibilities of the
estimates. client’s quantity surveyor include the
Cost planning. preparation of Bills of Quantities and the giving
Advising on contractual methods. of advice on what a project would cost. He also
Advising on selection of other consultants. does cost planning during the design stage of a
Advising on contractor selection. project, examine tenders, price quantities and
Preparing tender documents. report his findings. He also negotiates rates with
Obtaining or negotiating tenders. contractors on negotiated contracts, valuing
Reporting on tenders received or package work in. The distinctive skill of a quantity
deal/design and build offers. surveyor lies in his ability to analyse a project
Evaluating construction work. using the above knowledge and apply it to the
Preparing and agreeing accounts for/with following areas like progress payment and
contractors. making recommendations as to payments to be
Preparing expenditure statements for tax made to the contractor including advising on
accounting purposes. the financial aspects of variations (Badu and
25.00
75.00
95.00
0
0
/ Measurement
developed by the AIQS, RICS, and PAQS had
been used to formulate the theoretical
25.00
75.00
95.00
Analysis
framework for this study. The competency
0
standards models developed by these three
organisations model were perceived to be the Interpersonal
11.11
58.33
41.67
95.00
0
0
skills
most comprehensive ever developed to date.
The research aims is to put forward a model of Communi-
50.00
50.00
90.00
competencies for professional quantity
0
cation
surveyors in Malaysia. Literature search
conducted in the earlier stage of the research Documen-
50.00
50.00
90.00
0
0
tation
revealed that a Malaysian model of competency
standards for the quantity surveyors had not Construction
50.00
50.00
90.00
been developed before. A sample of 50 quantity
0
technology
surveying firms registered with The Board of
Quantity Surveyors, Malaysia was randomly
58.33
41.67
88.33
Management
0
selected for this study. Postal questionnaires
were sent to these firms in January 2005. By the
Appraisal /
66.67
33.33
86.67
20th of February 2005, 12 firms had returned
0
0
Evaluation
completed questionnaires to the researcher. A
small number of filled questionnaires received Construction
66.67
33.33
86.67
after the cut off date (20th February) was not Law and
0
0
regulation
analysed due to time limitation of the research.
Hence, the effective research respondents are 12 Self-
11.11
66.67
25.00
85.00
(N=12), a response rate of 24%.
0
development
25.00
85.00
Leadership
0
75.00
16.67
Synthesis 83.33
0
16.67
81.67
8.33
0
technology
quantity surveyor. The list, adapted from the literacy
Australian Institute of Quantity Surveyors’ * 1- Not important, 2- Less imp., 3- Neutral,
competency model contained 13 characteristics, 4- Important, 5- Very imp.
abilities, and knowledge. The results are shown The respondents stated that, the most important
in Table 2, as follows. characteristics, abilities and knowledge for
Overall, all the respondents were agreeable to quantity surveyors to possess are
the list of basic characteristics, abilities and quantification/measurement, analysis, and
knowledge of a competent quantity surveyor interpersonal skills. Communication,
proposed to them. This is because, the lowest documentation, and construction technology
importance index reading is 81.67 (for are also regarded as highly important for
‘computer and information technology quantity surveyors to achieve an accepted level
literacy’). Hence, it could be deduced from the of competency. Other less important
result that, the respondents are generally characteristics, abilities and knowledge to
accepting the importance of all the items in the acquire are management, appraisal/evaluation,
list provided to them. construction law and regulation, self-
development, leadership, synthesis, and
computer and information technology literacy.
Three pertinent points came out from this result. degrees in quantity surveying programmes. The
Firstly, the respondents widely accepted that criteria and standards are prepared as part of the
interpersonal skills are one of the three most Ministry of Higher Education Malaysia’s ambition
important abilities to acquire for any would-be to assure the quality of higher education in the
competent quantity surveyors. This finding field of built environment. Other field of studies
shows that apart from quantity surveying related within the built environment disciplines are
knowledge, it is important for quantity surveyors which have formulated their own respective
to acquire the ‘soft’ skill such as interpersonal criteria and standards are architecture, interior
skills to help them carry out their work in a architecture, landscape architecture, land
competent manner. Secondly, it is interesting to surveying, building surveying, urban and
note that documentation did not come up top in regional planning, valuation and real estate
the ranking of characteristics, abilities and management, and construction. The Board of
knowledge importance. According to popular Quantity Surveyors Malaysia agreed that, the
belief, the knowledge of documentation should general education goals for quantity surveying
be one of the most important aspects of quantity educators in Malaysia are to educate, train, and
surveying work. Apparently, the respondents produce graduate quantity surveyors who are
disagreed with such a belief and did not place competent, creative and versatile, guided by
documentation in a higher position of high moral and ethical values for God and
importance. Similarly, construction law and Mankind. After completing the quantity
regulation – popularly perceived as one of the surveying education programme, the graduates
most important scope of quantity surveyors did should possess knowledge, understanding, skills
not make it to the most important or even and competencies in:
highly important list of characteristics, abilities 1. Meta-competencies – versatile and adaptable,
and knowledge for quantity surveyors. Thirdly, pro-active and positive thinking, able to
computer and information technology literacy communicate effectively, high self-esteem,
was not ranked high enough by the respondents highly creative and innovative with problem
as important in the pursuit of quantity surveying solving ability, able to work in team, high
competency. This is despite the nature of ethical and moral value lifelong learning
quantity surveyors work that relies heavily in outlook.
cost estimates and quantitative-based activities. 2. Construction economics, cost and financial
With the help of computers and advanced management – including project cost
designer software, surely it would make their estimating and cost plans, preparing project
work much faster, accurate and error-free. budget and cash flows, administration of
project cost and finance, carrying out
COMPETENCY STANDARDS FOR QUANTITY feasibility and viability studies including
SURVEYORS collecting, preparing, analysing, and
interpreting project cost and financial data
The study was based on the AIQS’ model of and related information.
competency standards for quantity surveyors. In 3. Management of construction project
all, there are 13 competency standards to be procurement and contract – inclusive of
tested by the study (as shown in the preceding identifying, collecting, processing and
page). Early findings indicate that ‘contract interpreting data and information for the
documentation’, budgetary process’ and evaluation and selection of appropriate
‘tendering process’ are consistently ranked procurement system and contractual
higher than the other standards by the arrangement, preparing tender and contract
respondents. This warrants further scrutiny documents, administration of tendering
during the next round of data collection. At the processes and managing the implementation
time of writing, the Board of Quantity Surveyors of construction contract.
Malaysia and the Ministry of Higher Education 4. Measurement, quantification and
Malaysia had just released their final draft of documentation – inclusive of measuring and
‘Criteria and Standards for Educational quantifying construction works for project
Programmes in the Field of Quantity Surveying’ costing, cost planning and control,
to be used by all public universities offering preparation of bills of quantities, work