Political Risk Report 2024 FullReport
Political Risk Report 2024 FullReport
report 2024
March 2024
2 Political risk report 2024
Contents
01 Executive summary
3 04 The divergent risks of a
macroeconomic shift
8
Executive summary
Businesses face a world made more volatile and riskier by
systemic macroeconomic and geopolitical changes. Governments
are increasingly pursuing state-led economic policies, intensifying
the frequency and severity of trade disruption and distortion. At the
same time, international governance norms are losing legitimacy,
contributing to a surge in unpredictable and longer-lasting conflicts.
In this context, operational planning is an unusually volatile process.
Strengthening the ability to identify, prepare for, • Governments will continue implementing
and mitigate difficult to predict challenges is therefore protectionist climate change mitigation and
paramount for leaders. In the coming year and beyond, as investment policies. As domestic politics compete
these trends reshape structures of international politics, with international priorities, contract stability and
trade, and finance, they will also be influenced by specific project investment returns will be at risk of disruption.
risks in 2024: In turn, these policies may also create opportunities
ranging from national food security projects to water
• Around the world, more than 60 elections will take access sustainability improvements.
place, primarily oriented around inward-looking
By understanding how time-sensitive risks and
economic policymaking and outward-looking
long-term political trends affect business decisions,
security concerns. The outcomes are likely to affect
companies can more effectively position themselves
international relationships and drive policy uncertainty,
in uncertain geopolitical and economic conditions to
disrupting markets as a result. Media coverage can
take advantage of opportunities which, as the 2024
create a variety of distracting narratives, challenging
Global Risks Report notes, are still available. In such an
the ability of executives to see past the noise.
atmosphere, intelligent allocation of risk and use of
• The global macroeconomic transition underway may risk transfer solutions will help corporates and lenders
discourage businesses from pursuing otherwise continue to secure capital, access liquidity, and manage
available investment opportunities. To navigate through ambiguity, thereby enabling ongoing trade and
disrupted supply chains and an unstable geopolitical demand capture.
environment, companies will increasingly rely on data
and risk analysis to understand and manage risks.
2
4 Political risk report 2023
Shifting
01| Global announced trade interventions by year (2010 – 2023)
300
macroeconomic
and geopolitical
structures
100
0
The era of globalization and commerce-oriented 2010 2014 2018 2022
Over the past five years, many governments have issued significant financial support
and imposed trade barriers to protect economically and politically important domestic
industries. They have also encouraged investment in climate-friendly sectors,
sometimes disregarding existing international economic rules. This shift coincides
with an increasingly inward-looking electorate; an IPSOS global poll found that positive
perceptions of “globalization” had dropped 10% in all countries surveyed.
Growing geopolitical instability These realities will continuously stress the ability of most economic models — designed for and built off
The ongoing process of geoeconomic fragmentation is closely linked to geopolitical data from an era of relative economic and political stability — to forecast future outcomes. Further, as some
changes, which have accelerated in recent years. The unipolar international security actors take advantage of the heightened level of insecurity and unpredictability, assets and investments in
system, dominated by the US for more than 20 years, is strained, increasing complexity many foreign markets may be more exposed to political violence, terrorism, expropriation, or disruption.
and unpredictability for businesses in coming years.
3
6 Political risk report 2023
2024
2024: The
02| 2024 elections span the globe
biggest election
year in history
As organizations make decisions for the
future, they need to consider how long-
term uncertainty caused by geoeconomic
competition and geopolitical insecurity may
also be influenced by current events.
More than 60 countries, representing at least 40% of the global population
and GDP, will hold elections in 2024. As pre- and post-election noise
increasingly permeates media and business conversations, the focus areas Source: Marsh
for organizations seeking to understand the implications should include:
ELECTORAL VIOLENCE
The risk of electoral violence and the impact of AND ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE
artificial intelligence.
The link between elections and civil unrest is well understood; given the number of elections in 2024,
there is a correspondingly elevated risk for electoral violence. Compounding this risk is a new and
poorly understood factor: the potential for artificial intelligence to amplify political misinformation and
The value of tracking voter turnout in unfree races. disinformation.
The threat that misinformation poses to democratic structures is already being aggravated by the ability of
actors — including non-state groups, adversarial states, politicians, and individuals — to leverage AI tools
How the US presidential election could influence to create convincing, yet fake, video and audio. Such tools can also enhance the speed and spread of false
corporate and sovereign decision-making. narratives across social and traditional media. The US government has already accused the governments of
China, Russia, and Iran of attempting to weaponize AI for those purposes.
7 Political risk report 2024
The misuse of AI can exacerbate the connection between political violence consequences. On a positive note, the limited range of potential outcomes will
and its impact, leading to heightened risks for businesses, particularly where facilitate efforts to use scenario-planning strategies to prepare for the results.
political tensions are high. As the election nears, levels of governmental policy paralysis are expected
to worsen, with neither Democratic nor Republican parties eager to give the
VOTER TURNOUT opposition a legislative victory on which to campaign.
risks of a
100%
macroeconomic
75%
50%
shift 25%
economic downturn.
Note: Since 2007, the US Federal Reserve Board has issued quarterly guidance to clarify the FOMC members’
Even in a soft-landing scenario, however, businesses should expect economic divergence sense of how uncertain their economic forecasts were relative to historical context. A 100% score means
between sectors and economies and consider the implications in the context of growing that every member of the committee views that quarter’s economic projections as more uncertain than
government intervention and increased levels of geopolitical insecurity. the historical norm. Conversely, a 0% score means that all members of the committee assess economic
uncertainty levels to be “normal.”
Members of the US Federal Open Market Committee (FOMC) assess the level
of US economic uncertainty to be falling, suggesting growing alignment with
markets on the likelihood of a soft landing for the US economy. However,
perceived uncertainty remains elevated relative to historical norms. The views
of the FOMC are a reminder that while progress on inflation and other core
economic metrics has been significant and better than expected, at least in the
US, the economic environment remains finely balanced.
9 Political risk report 2024
SOVEREIGNS
While advanced economies are generally forecast to register weak growth
in 2024, many emerging markets, led by India and much of Southeast Asia,
are expected to post resilient growth rates and continue to provide ample
opportunities for businesses. China, as the world’s largest developing economy,
may be an exception to this rule, with softer growth and structural domestic
imbalances that are expected to take much of the government’s attention.
04| Political risk ratings for countries facing high debt/GDP ratios and risk of unrest
Country
Currency Contractual
Strikes, riots, & civil Country economic inconvertibility & agreement Legal & regulatory
commotion Terrorism War & civil war risk transfer risk Sovereign credit risk Expropriation repudiation risk
Argentina 7.4 2.9 2.0 7.4 7.8 8.3 4.7 5.5 5.5
Bangladesh 7.6 5.4 3.8 5.1 6.0 5.7 4.0 5.9 6.9
Egypt 4.5 5.9 4.7 5.9 6.2 6.6 4.6 4.9 5.9
Ethiopia 6.5 6.8 6.4 6.4 7.4 8.9 5.7 7.0 5.9
Kenya 6.4 6.9 3.5 5.3 5.9 6.7 4.5 5.4 5.7
Emerging markets are not alone in facing record-high debt burdens this year. Developed countries,
120 including the US, Italy, and Japan, have seen their debts balloon since the COVID-19 pandemic, with US debt
making up more than one-third of the world’s total. Meanwhile, Japan has the second-highest debt/GDP
100 ratio globally (above 250%). Italy’s debt fundamentals have noticeably weakened; as of late 2023, its 10-year
bond yield reached levels rarely seen since the Eurozone crisis.
80 Unlike some of their emerging market peers, however, these advanced economies benefit from important
debt safeguards that can limit the risks faced by investors. US debt is expected to remain the world’s
safe-haven asset; yields on Japan’s debt are uniquely low and, therefore, unusually sustainable; and Italy’s
60
sovereign risk remains manageable thanks to the euro and the watchful eye of the European Central
Bank. Nevertheless, high debts may discourage further subsidy implementation and support the ongoing
40 implementation of trade barriers.
2000 2005 2010 2015 2020
Export-dependent emerging markets could Vietnam, for example, is expected to have a year of relatively soft growth but is equally likely
face passing headwinds to stand out over the mid- and long-term. In addition to the relative reliability of the country’s
single-party rule and an improved regulatory environment, the government has demonstrated
The second set of emerging markets likely to underperform in 2024 are those with the an apparent skill at navigating the competing interests of major powers; it was the only country
largest trading relationships with major advanced economies (such as the US, the EU, visited by both US and Chinese presidents in 2023.
and the UK), given that many of the latter are expected to see underwhelming growth,
which may drag down import volumes. Short-term economic underperformance, Businesses looking for the countries best placed to benefit from supply chain distortions
however, should not dissuade investors from focusing on the long-term opportunities brought on by macroeconomic competition should consider focusing less on emerging
that these emerging markets provide and the likely benefits they can derive markets’ geographic proximity to major advanced economies. Instead, they should evaluate
from smart positioning within the context of macroeconomic competition. whether governments possess the structures and relationships necessary to steer through a
shifting landscape of competing international incentives.
Country
Currency Contractual
Strikes, riots, & Country inconvertibility & Sovereign agreement Legal &
civil commotion Terrorism War & civil war economic risk transfer risk credit risk Expropriation repudiation regulatory risk
South Korea 4.9 1.3 3.0 2.9 1.7 1.6 1.7 3.0 2.9
Malaysia 3.3 2.8 2.2 3.0 2.8 3.0 2.4 4.0 3.7
Mexico 6.1 3.6 2.6 3.7 3.6 3.7 4.4 6.8 5.4
Philippines 4.9 5.6 5.1 3.8 3.5 3.5 4.2 4.9 5.2
Thailand 5.2 4.9 4.1 3.4 3.0 3.4 2.3 4.6 4.9
Vietnam 4.6 2.2 2.7 3.4 4.7 4.6 3.8 4.8 5.5
Very low level Low level High level Very high level
(more than -20%) (-20% to -5%) (-5% to +20%) (+20% and more)
2024 expected level compared to 2019
the energy transition: The World Bank estimates that water shortages are
on track to cost some regions of the world 6% of GDP
by 2050, contributing to conflict and exacerbating
In advanced economies, policies designed to disincentivize emissions-heavy industries or develop domestic • Panama capped the number of ships allowed to
green economies may increasingly come into force, occasionally to the detriment of lower-income countries and transit the Panama Canal, as low water volumes
businesses that trade between them. For some emerging economies, however, policies such as the EU’s Carbon required the government to choose between letting
Border Adjustment Mechanism may create valuable investment opportunities in green manufacturing. more ships through the vital waterway and ensuring
water availability for other critical uses.
15 Political risk report 2024
140
number of people living in acute food insecurity distorting well-established supply chains and
increased by more than 60% between 2019 and destabilizing economically significant sectors
2022 and now represents more than 4% of the across several emerging market countries.
120 world’s population. These findings could worsen
once the current El Niño cycle’s full impact on Advanced economies are aware of the
global food availability is felt. And while nearly damaging implications these policies could
80% of people most exposed to crop failures live have for emerging economies but, to date,
100 in either Sub-Sahara Africa or South/Southeast are not doing enough to take action to
Asia, the effects of more frequently disrupted significantly offset their impact. For instance,
harvests will ripple worldwide — for instance, to help countries cope with the effects of anti-
80 through the potential spreading of conflict and deforestation rules, the EU announced a Team
2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 larger migration flows. Europe Initiative in December 2023, funded with
an initial sum of €70 million, a small fraction
In 2024’s busy election year, many governments of the likely cost of the policy on impacted
will likely maintain existing food and fertilizer nations. Absent greater support from advanced
Meat indexed Dairy indexed Cereals indexed Sugar indexed
export controls to prevent electorally damaging economies, the economic impact may be
price spikes, with populations in other parts of wide-ranging: Out-of-compliance markets may
the world negatively impacted as a result. divert exports to non-EU countries, free trade
negotiations are likely to be further delayed,
Source: Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations: FAO.FAOSTAT. License: CC BY-NC-SA 3.0 IGO. Climate change mitigation and financing for high-deforestation risk
Accessed: January, 31 2024.
policies of advanced activities will be more challenging to obtain.
economies
With the European Union taking a strong lead on
enforcing climate policies, it is possible that its
6
16 Political risk report 2024
Conclusion
Navigating political and security risks has long been one of the
most complex and ill-defined tasks that organizations must
manage. Recently, this obligation has become more challenging
as the growing trend of self-interested government economic
intervention is layered with an increasing frequency of hard-to-
predict disruptive security events.
Organizations should identify this year’s most • A delicate macroeconomic period will be further
salient risks and discuss the implications for their stressed by high debt levels among companies
businesses, to: and governments, expected weak growth in
advanced economies, and a heightened risk of
• Encourage decision-makers to consider unpredictable conflict events and credit risk.
where certain risks in one geography
• The renormalization of government-led
or sector may increase the likelihood of
industrial and trade policy will overlap
knock-on disruption in another, and how
with the climate change agenda, creating
an understanding of that disruption can
a fluid web of regulatory complexity
guide the use of risk mitigation solutions.
and political risk for businesses.
• Focus on data and look past the noise. Narrative-
In a time of such uncertainty, where the range
filled politics and the potential of AI to spread
of possible scenarios and structural outcomes
disinformation means it can be easy for rapidly
seems to grow ever broader, those businesses
shifting consensus to cloud a long-term view.
that understand, accept, manage, and transfer the
The economic and political structural shifts risks inherent in the changing macroeconomic and
currently underway will both shape and be shaped geopolitical environment will be well-positioned to
by events specific to 2024: pursue growth opportunities that emerge during
this period of transition.
• Election politics in a year likely to see a record
number of voters will focus on internal
economic and international security concerns.
AI may be used to amplify misinformation
and disinformation, potentially creating policy
uncertainty and political violence risks.
17 Political risk report 2024
Contacts
For more information on the Political Risk & Structured Credit (PRSC) market please contact your regional
PRSC leader.
+44 7385 976 367 +65 9625 3996 +44 7852 765 494 +1 929 319 8508
robert.perry@marsh.com serene.soo@marsh.com ed.nicholson@marsh.com mark.mcleod@marsh.com
+971 58 257 1044 +27 71 600 8987 +61 499 033 487 +44 7789 923 390
sud.chanthralingam@marsh.com lynn.harrod@marsh.com kyle.williams@marsh.com kate.muir-jones@marsh.com
About Marsh
Marsh is the world’s leading insurance broker and risk advisor. With more than 45,000 colleagues advising
clients in over 130 countries, Marsh serves commercial and individual clients with data-driven risk
solutions and advisory services. Marsh is a business of Marsh McLennan (NYSE: MMC), the world’s leading
professional services firm in the areas of risk, strategy and people. With annual revenue $23 billion, Marsh
McLennan helps clients navigate an increasingly dynamic and complex environment through four market-
leading businesses: Marsh, Guy Carpenter, Mercer and Oliver Wyman. For more information, visit marsh.
com, and follow us on LinkedIn and X.
This marketing communication is compiled for the benefit of clients and prospective clients of Marsh & McLennan (“MMC”).
If insurance and/or risk management advice is provided, it will be provided by one or more of MMC’s regulated companies.
Please follow this link marsh.com/uk/disclaimer.html for further regulatory details. Marsh Ltd is authorised and regulated
by the Financial Conduct Authority for General Insurance Distribution and Credit Broking (Firm Reference No. 307511). Copyright
2024 Marsh Ltd All rights reserved. 24-180103