How to Write a Case Comment Law Review: Expert Guide

Writing a case comment law review can be an intimidating task for law students and young
lawyers. However, with the right approach and a deep understanding of the subject matter, it can
also be a rewarding and impactful exercise. In this blog post, we will explore the key steps and
strategies to help you master the art of writing a compelling case comment law review.

Understanding the Purpose of a Case Comment Law Review

Before delving into the technical aspects of writing a case comment law review, it is important to
understand the purpose of this exercise. A case comment is a critical analysis of a specific legal
case, focusing on its implications, significance, and potential impact on the legal landscape.
Opportunity legal scholars practitioners engage nuances particular case offer insights
perspectives.

Key Steps in Writing a Case Comment Law Review

Step Description

1. Case Choose recent relevant legal case interest implications legal community.
Selection

2. Case Provide a concise summary of the facts, issues, and legal arguments involved
Summary in the case.

3. Legal Conduct a thorough legal analysis of the case, exploring its implications and
Analysis potential impact on relevant areas of law.

4. Personal Offer your own perspectives and insights on the case, supported by sound
Reflections legal reasoning and research.

Tips for Writing a Compelling Case Comment Law Review

 Focus clarity precision writing, avoiding jargon overly complex language.

 Engage relevant legal literature precedents support analysis arguments.

 Seek feedback peers, mentors, legal scholars refine case comment publication.
  Be mindful word limits formatting requirements set law review publication targeting.

 Should provide your own original analysis of the case, such as: The case was decided
incorrectly. The court is correct, but for the wrong reasons. The court missed the point.
The whole area of law is a mess, and you have a better approach. The court is correct.
Some creative, dynamic idea of your own.

Choose Your Approach

After reading, decide what your case comment will argue. See the following examples:-

1. “The case was decided incorrectly because…” • Most common approach • Demonstrate
why the court’s analysis is wrong • Must be careful not to mimic the dissent
2. “The court is correct, but for the wrong reasons.” • Demonstrate that the court applied the
wrong reasoning and explain why this was the wrong approach • Must be careful to
distinguish your reasoning from the court’s reasoning
3. “The court missed the point.” • Analyze a different issue in the case that you think the
court missed • Make sure to incorporate the principal case and the other materials in the
packet
4. “The court is correct.” • Demonstrate that the court was 100% correct • Address the
relevant counterarguments • Make sure not to simply repeat the court’s opinion • This can
be tricky. It’s often easier to criticize than to agree
5. “The whole area of law is a mess, and [suggest an alternative approach].” • Very
ambitious approach • Use the principal case to suggest your own approach to the area of
law • Make sure your approach is logical, yields consistent results, and has public policy
support

Case Study: Landmark Case Comment Law Reviews

One notable example compelling case comment law review Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg`s
analysis landmark case United States v. Virginia Virginia Law Review. In her commentary,
Justice Ginsburg offered a thought-provoking assessment of the case`s impact on gender equality
and the legal framework for government-funded institutions.

Writing a case comment law review is a valuable opportunity to engage with the legal
community, contribute to legal scholarship, and hone your analytical and writing skills. By
following the key steps and tips outlined in this blog post, you can craft a compelling and
impactful case comment that resonates with your readers and peers in the legal profession.

Frequently Asked Legal Questions: How to Write a Case Comment Law Review

Question Answer

1. What is a case comment in a A case comment in a law review is a critical analysis of a

law review? particular legal case, discussing the significance and
implications of the court`s decision.

2. How do I choose a case to When selecting a case for a comment, consider recent and
write a comment on? impactful decisions, controversial issues, or cases that raise
novel legal questions.

3. What included introduction The introduction should provide background information on

case comment? the case, a brief summary of the court`s decision, and a
statement of the issues to be discussed.

4. How analyze legal reasoning When analyzing the legal reasoning, delve into the court`s
case? interpretation of the law, application of precedent, and
reasoning behind the decision.

5. Is it important to consider Yes, discussing dissenting opinions adds depth to your analysis
dissenting opinions in a case and demonstrates a comprehensive understanding of the case.
comment?

6. How can I effectively Organize your analysis by addressing the key legal issues,
structure the body of my case presenting arguments from both sides, and providing your own
comment? critical evaluation of the court`s decision.

7. Should I include references Absolutely! Citing relevant statutes, case law, and scholarly
to legal sources in my case articles strengthens the credibility of your analysis.
comment?

8. What tone should I maintain Adopt a professional and objective tone, avoiding biased
in a case comment? language and focusing on the legal principles at hand.

9. How do I conclude a case Conclude by summarizing the key points of your analysis and
comment effectively? offering insights into the broader implications of the court`s
decision.

10. What are some tips for Ensure clarity, precision, and coherence in your writing, and
improving the writing style of consider seeking feedback from peers or legal professionals to
a case comment? refine your commentary.