ASEAN Logistics Network Map - JETRO
ASEAN Logistics Network Map - JETRO
3
Outline of “ASEAN Logistics Network Map”
~Study Stage~
4
Objectives and the Structure of “ASEAN Logistics Network Map”
Objectives:
1. To provide useful information on logistics-related hard and soft aspects
2. To clarify the present situation of logistics network
□ To identify bottlenecks
□ To propose measures for improvements
□ To carry business sectors’ needs to policy makers
Structure:
Route survey for 7 priority routes
□ Transportation mode: land, sea, air
□ Door-to-door cost and time are analysed by
each phase of transportation.
AND
Logistics database (CD-ROM)
□ Hard infrastructure & soft infrastructure
□ User-friendly (works on web browser)
The result of study in 2006 (English version) is available on our website. (http://books.jetro.go.jp/en/)
5
Route survey: Surveyed Routes
Selected by Business Sectors’ interests in Japan and ASEAN
Transportation Time
Fig. The relation of Steel
between processWire from China to Vietnam by Air
and leadtime(8+1304_Route3_Air)
30 35
30
25
Leadtime of process(H)
Accumulared time(H)
25
20
20
Leadtime of process
15
Accumulated time
15
10
10
Commodity: Steel wire
5
5
0 0
ea n
ha n
Pa ion
ea r
er
er h er s
s
Lo g
sp g
Sh e
Un ge
Tr e
g
ns ling
g
e
er
er
in
in
in
io
tio
in
lin
nc
nc
sf
sf
a
ad
ag
ad
ain orta
at
ipp
th
th
nd
nd
Dr
ra
ra
ec
om ran
an
t
Vietnam
in
ck
lo
O
O
ha
China
am
p
T
cl
cl
In
er
Ex
s
a
in
(HCMC)
om
tr
a
(Guangzhou)
t
nt
er
st
st
n
Co
Co
rd
Cu
Cu
bo
s
os
Cr
Process
In this sample, the import custom clearance in Vietnam takes most of the time,
and it diminishes the merit of air transport.
7
Route Survey: Data Sample 2
TransportationFig.
Cost of Automotive
The relation Parts
between process from Philippine to Thailand by Sea
and costs(78_Route7_Sea)
800 3000
700
2500
Accumulated costs(US$)
600
Cost of process(US$)
2000
500
Cost of process
400 1500
Accumulated costs
300
http://free-icon.org/data/dl_18/m_01.gif 1000
200
Commodity: Automotive Parts
500
100
0 0
ea n
ha n
Pa ion
ea r
er hers
er
s
Lo g
Sh e
sp g
Un ge
g
Tr e
g
ns ling
g
e
er
in
er
in
in
io
tio
in
lin
nc
nc
sf
sf
a
ad
ag
ad
at
ain orta
ipp
th
th
nd
nd
Dr
ra
ra
ec
om ran
an
t
in
ck
Thailand
lo
O
O
ha
Philippines
am
p
T
cl
cl
In
er
Ex
s
in
om
tr
ta
nt
er
st
st
n
Co
Co
rd
Cu
Cu
bo
s
os
Cr
Process
In this sample, the domestic transportation cost in Philippines holds the
largest share, while customs clearance also costs much in both countries.
8
Database: Collected Information
9
Database: Screen Layout
Select Country
10
Database: Sample Maps 1 (Each Country)
11
Database: Sample Maps 2 (ASEAN Wide)
12
Our Study in 2007/08
To focus on 3 routes
Thailand – Malaysia – Singapore – Indonesia
Thailand – Lao PDR – Vietnam – South China
ASEAN – India
To consider not only cost and time but also quality
(i.e. damage, delay, reliability)
To conduct trial transportation
Policy Recommendations
Suggestion of improvement guidelines for further actions
towards productive consequence
We need your cooperation to collect and update data !!!
13
Some Results and Implications
from the Study in 2007/08
~A Case of Road Transport
on East West Economic Corridor (EWEC)~
14
Possibility of Road Transport on EWEC (Bangkok~Hanoi)
Road 8
Cost * 4
Sea
Air(69,910USD) >Road
(5,500USD) >Sea(2,910USD) Fast
(40ft container or 30 tons of cargo) Cost Comparison
High
0 20 40 60 80 100
In terms of time, road transport enjoys
an advantage over sea, favorably Sea 100
*It is rare to carry 30 tons of cargo by air. Please consider this as for reference.
*Cost of road transport is estimated under assumption of no return cargo. Low
15
Example of door-to-door cost estimation method (road)
Country Node/Link Functions Basic elements of cost Conditions cost(US$)
Thailand Bangkok Loading (1)Road transport charge Transport charge includes loading charge
Bangkok Road Transport Transport charge including loading 700
~ ・Distance: 700km
Mukdahan ・Unit cost: setting 1US$/km
・Transport charge: 700US$
Mukdahan Export custom (3)Document fee 200US$ 200
Laos Savannakhet Transit custom (3)Document fee 200US$ 200
Transshipment (2)Transshipment fee Setting 100US$(in the case using crane) 100
Savannakhet Road Transport (1)Road transport Transport charge including loading
~ charge ・Distance: 250km
250
Den Savan ・Unit cost: setting 1US$/km
・Transport charge: 250US$
Den Savan Transit custom (3)Document fee 200US$ 200
Vietnam Lao Bao Import custom (3)Document fee 200US$ 200
Lao Bao Road Transport (1)Road transport Transport charge including loading
~ charge ・Distance: 700km
700
Hanoi ・Unit cost: setting 1US$/km
・Transport charge: 700US$
Hanoi Unloading Transport charge includes unloading charge
Total Document processing (3)Document fee 200
Total (1)Road transport 1,650
(2)Transshipment fee 100
(3)Document fee Custom document processing fee 800
Total document processing fee 200
Total 2,750
Cost of each phase of transportation is estimated under conditions above.
Total cost will be doubled (5,500USD) if no return cargo by chartered service.
16
Road Transport on Bangkok~Singapore Route (For Reference)
Sea
Sea(151h)> 100
35
Road
Road(53h) >
19
Air
Air(29h)
Fast
Road(2,730USD)> A ir
4 100
Sea(2,000USD) Road
3
4
*It is rare to carry 30 tons of cargo by air. Please consider this as for reference.
*Cost of road transport is estimated under assumption of no return cargo. Low
17
Some Issues concerning EWEC (Bangkok~Hanoi)
700km
EWEC 250km
Mukdahan (Thailand) /
Savannakhet (Lao PDR)
Loaded
750km (2nd Mekong Bridge)
Bankok
19
JETRO’s Trial Transport on EWEC (Bangkok~Hanoi)
Loaded Unloaded
Unloaded Loaded
Transshipment of
Containers
in Savannakhet
250km
Loaded Loaded
Our Trial
Loaded Loaded
20
JETRO’s Trial Transport on EWEC (Bangkok~Hanoi)
Hanoi
Vietnam
Vinh
Nakomratchasrima
Saraburi
21
JETRO’s Trial Transport on EWEC (Bangkok~Hanoi)
Country Thailand Lao PDR Vietnam
City Bangkok Mukdahan Savannakhet Densavan Lao Bao Hanoi
M o v em en t o f Loaded Loaded
T ru cks an d Transshipment
C o n t a in er s Loaded Loaded
Dept from
Arr at factory
terminal (east
Arrive at Arrive at Arrive at Arrive at (east bound) /
bound) / Dept Arrive at CY Arr at terminal
from factory Customs Customs Customs Customs
(west bound)
(west bound)
30-Oct-07 31-Oct-07 31-Oct-07 31-Oct-07 1-Nov-07 1-Nov-07 2-Nov-07
Date
6:30 8:00 10:45 11:05 10:20 10:45 11:55
Bangkok Accum. Time
0:00 25:30 28:15 28:35 51:50 52:15 77:25
to Hanoi (h)
(east Accum.
0 744 755 760 1,004 1,005 1,719
Distance (km)
bound) Waiting time: 50mins
Stay overnight in (Mukdahan Customs) Cutom clearance: Stay overnight in Custom clearance: Cutom clearance: 55mins Arr at factory,
Remarks Mukdahan
Customs clearance and X ray
inspection: 1 hour and 15 mins
13mins Savannakhet 20mins
Running at night (Dong Ha to
Thanh Hoa)
devanning
(2nd Mekong Bridge)
22
Estimation of Improvement: Time
96:00
Time Model
84:00
Trial Transport including waiting time for return cargo
72:00 Synchronized with opening time of custom house + shorter transshipment time
48:00
36:00
24:00
12:00
0:00
e
rt
rt
rt
r
ce
en
en
ce
no
en
en
en
ne
nc
po
po
po
an
an
pm
ig
op
op
op
ig
ra
ns
ns
ns
ip
ar
ns
ns
ar
ea
hi
tra
tra
tra
sh
to
to
to
le
le
co
co
ss
cl
ns
c
e
e
c
ad
ad
ad
an
f ic
f ic
f ic
om
at
at
m
ra
o
o
Tr
to
of
of
of
to
g
ng
R
R
R
st
in
us
m
m
cu
cu
di
ad
to
to
to
tc
oa
rt
rt
Lo
us
us
us
si
po
po
nl
an
rc
rc
rc
U
Im
Ex
Tr
fo
fo
fo
g
g
g
tin
tin
tin
ai
ai
ai
W
W
Transport Process
Single stop cross-border system is the most effective for time saving.
23
Estimation of Improvement: Cost (1st STEP)
Cost (USD) per 30 tons by road transport
60,000
40,000
10,000
0
10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
Loading rate (%)
The most effective way to reduce cost is to get return cargos, and the second
is to increase loading rate by LCL (Less-than-Container Load).
24
Estimation of Improvement: Cost (2nd STEP)
Fuel is the main component of land transport cost. Energy saving means
cost saving and greener transport !
A 3 ,0 0 0
c
c Loading Rate 100% with Return Cargo
u 2 ,5 0 0
Improvement level 1
m
Improvement level 2
u
(
2 ,0 0 0
l
U
a
S 1 ,5 0 0
t
$
e
)
d 1 ,0 0 0
c 500
o
s
t 0
t
e
e
e
en
g
g
g
g
rg
rg
rg
in
in
in
in
in
ss
ss
ss
ss
ss
ha
ha
ha
hip
ce
ce
ce
ce
ce
tc
tc
tc
ss
ro
ro
ro
ro
ro
or
or
or
an
tp
tp
tp
tp
tp
sp
sp
sp
tr
en
en
en
en
en
an
an
an
m
um
m
um
tr
tr
tr
cu
cu
cu
ad
ad
ad
do
do
do
do
do
ro
ro
ro
Tr an spo r t P r o c e ss
25
Estimation of Improvement: Quality
In case of careful transport with container transshipment by high-level truck
drivers and staffs for material handling, the shock level is the same as
expressways in Japan.
Shock (G) level Vertical vibration on freight container (not on cargo itself)
For shippers
1st: to secure return cargo by information sharing between
in-gourp and related companies (For Cost Reduction)
2nd: to improve loading ratio (For Cost Reduction)
3rd : to improve management by HRD, e.g. transport planning, proper use
of transport package (For Cost Reduction & Quality)
29
Toward Improvement of Logistics Performance
Quality
Policy Logistics
Recommendations Facilitation
Administrative ASEAN Private
Bodies in Logistics Sectors in
ASEAN Network Map ASEAN
and and
Japan Japan
Strengthen competitiveness of
ASEAN region and Japanese companies
JETRO is also conducting supporting projects
to make a concrete improvement in ASEAN.
Action !
□ HRD in logistics management especially for shippers
□ Facilitate “Green Logistics” to reduce energy consumption / CO2 emission
□ Capacity building in logistics management for related agencies in CLMV countries
31
Roadmap for the Integration of Logistics Services by ASEAN
NO. MEASURES IMPLEMENTING BODY TIMELINE
SPECIFIC ISSUES
I Me mbe r c o u n try sh all e n de avo u r to ac h ie ve su bstan tial libe ralis atio n o f lo gistic s se rvic e in th e
f o llo win g se c to rs:
Maritime c argo h an dlin g se rvic e s, Sto rage & ware h o u sin g se rvic e s, Fre igh t tran spo rt age n c y
se rvic e s, Co u rie r se rvic e s, Pac kagin g se rvic e s,
Executive Board
Body to handle general matters (Coordination among Working Groups (WGs), approval of their activity schedule,
exchange of views and information)
36