D06e. Cal. M-109 Stop Log - 30SEP24
D06e. Cal. M-109 Stop Log - 30SEP24
30-Sep-24
1. DESIGN CONDITION 3
3. DESIGN LOAD 6
6. SUMMARY 21
1) Downstream Water
2) Upstream Water
3) Bending Stress, σb
1,200 1,600
(Per Net Sectional Area) 1) ℓ/b ≤ 9/K : 1,200 1) ℓ/b ≤ 8/K : 1,600
Aw : Sectional Area of Web Plate (cm^2) If Aw/Ac < 2, K=2 If Aw/Ac < 2, K=2
4) Shearing Stress, τ
700 900
(Per Gross Sectional Area)
5) Remarks
Bronze (BC) 8 8 10
Brass Alloy
230 450 450 230 450
(HB210 above)
3. DESIGN LOAD
Flap Gate is arranged two (upper/lower) layers. Lower one will be calculated as follows:
3.1 Normal Design Hydrostatic Load
1) Hydrostatic Load P1 (Downstream & Upstream Water - Design Load)
[Table 3.1]
1 Ws tf/m^3 1.030 Ws -
2 Wr tf/m^3 - Wr 1.030
3 h m 1.350 h2 1.300
4 h1 m 0.000 h3 0.000
EL 5.35
0.00
EL 5.35
h3 0.00
1.350
h1
=
1.350
1.350
Downstream Upstream
h
h2
H
[Fig 3.1]
where,
P1 : Hydrostatic Pressure Load (tf)
2) Special Load Case P2 (Upstream Water = Sill Level; Downstream = Design Level)
EL 5.350
S 1.300
Upstream T Down
P
EL 4.050
where,
3) Exceptional Load Case P3 (Upstream Water = Design Level; Downstream = Sill Level)
where,
[FIG 4.1]
[Fig 4.1.1]
P1 = 0.000 (tf/㎡) ①
0.40
P2 = 0.412 (tf/㎡) ②
0.35
P3 = 0.773 (tf/㎡) ③
0.30
1.35
P4 = 1.082 (tf/㎡) ④
0.20
P5 = 1.288 (tf/㎡) ⑤
0.10
P6 = 1.423 (tf/㎡) ⑥
[Fig 4.2.1]
[Table 4.2.1]
Hydraulic Pr (tf/m^2) Beam Span (m) Remarks
p1 = 0.00 -
p2 = 0.41 L1 = 0.40
p3 = 0.77 L2 = 0.35
p4 = 1.08 L3 = 0.30
p5 = 1.29 L4 = 0.20
p6 = 1.42 L5 = 0.10
Sum = 4.98 Sum = 1.35
a B a
w(tf/m)
A B
L
[Fig 4.2.4]
where,
Zct : Section Modulus (c: compression, t: tension) (cm^2)
σct : Bending Stress (c: compression, t: tension) (cm^2)
[Table 4.2.7.1]
Beam Size Corrosion Allowance (1mm)
Member Remarks
Width b (cm) Height, h (cm) Width b (cm) Height, h (cm)
Up Flange b1 9.00 h1 1.30 8.80 1.20 Skin Plate
Web b2 0.90 h2 27.40 0.70 27.40
Low Flange b3 9.00 h3 1.30 8.80 1.20
Member A (cm^2) y (cm) Ay (cm^3) Ay^2 (cm^4) Io (cm^4)
Up Flange A1 10.56 y1 14.30 151.01 2,159 1.3
Web A2 19.18 y2 0.00 0 - 1,200.0
Low Flange A3 10.56 y3 -14.30 -151.01 2,159 1.3
∑ 40.30 0.00 0 4,319 1,202.5
9
(b1) (h1)
1.3
FLOW
y y
27.4
(h2)
30
1.3
Moment of Inertia
Iy = ∑ Io + ∑ Ay^2 - ∑A*e^2 = 5,521.38 (cm) [Eq 4.2.7.1]
where,
Iy : Moment of Inertia (y-y) (cm^4)
Io : Moment of Inertia for geographic center Axis (cm^4)
A : Sectional Area (cm^2)
e : Eccentric from geographic center (cm)
Eccentrics
e = ∑A*y / ∑A = 0.00 (cm) [Eq 4.2.7.2]
Neutral Axis
e1 : 14.90 - 0.00 = 14.90 (cm)
e2 : 14.90 + 0.00 = 14.90 (cm)
Sectional Modulus
Zc = Iy / e1 = 370.56 (cm) [Eq 4.2.7.3]
Zt = Iy / e2 = 370.56 (cm) [Eq 4.2.7.4]
12
(b1) (h1)
1.5
FLOW
y y
(h2)
32
35
1.5
12
Moment of Inertia
Iy = ∑ Io + ∑ Ay^2 - ∑A*e^2 = 12,869.67 (cm) [Eq 4.2.7.1]
where,
Iy : Moment of Inertia (y-y) (cm^4)
Io : Moment of Inertia for geographic center Axis (cm^4)
A : Sectional Area (cm^2)
e : Eccentric from geographic center (cm)
Eccentrics
e = ∑A*y / ∑A = 0.00 (cm) [Eq 4.2.7.2]
Neutral Axis
e1 : 17.40 - - = 17.40 (cm)
e2 : 17.40 + - = 17.40 (cm)
Sectional Modulus
where,
VERTICAL BEAM
0.000 p1
0.40
L1
P1
0.412 p2
0.35
L2
P2
0.773 p3
0.30
L3 P3
1.082 p4
0.20
L4
P4
1.288 p5
0.10
L5
P5
1.423 p6
Ph * L^2
Q = (tf)
4
Q1 = 0.003 (tf)
Q2 = 0.018 (tf)
Q3 = 0.020 (tf)
Q4 = 0.011 (tf)
Q5 = 0.003 (tf)
Q Max = 0.020 (tf)
P * L^3
M = For L < a [Eq 4.4.4.1]
12
P*a
M = x (3L^2 - a^2) For L > a [Eq 4.4.4.2]
24
[Table 4.4.5]
Beam Size Corrosion Allowance (0mm)
Member Remarks
Width b (cm) Height, h (cm) Width b (cm) Height, h (cm)
Up Flange b1 9.00 h1 0.90 8.80 0.80 Skin Plate
Web b2 0.90 h2 33.20 0.70 33.20
Low Flange b3 9.00 h3 0.90 8.80 0.80
Member A (cm^2) y (cm) Ay (cm^3) Ay^2 (cm^4) Io (cm^4)
Up Flange A1 7.04 y1 17.00 119.68 2,035 0.4
Web A2 23.24 y2 0.00 0 - 2,135
Low Flange A3 7.04 y3 -17.00 -119.68 2,035 0.4
∑ 37.32 0.00 0 4,069 2,135.4
9
(b1) (h1)
0.9
FLOW
y y
33.2
(h2)
35
0.9
Moment of Inertia
Iy = ∑ Io + ∑ Ay^2 - ∑A*e^2 = 6,204.55 (cm) [Eq 4.2.7.1]
where,
Iy : Moment of Inertia (y-y) (cm^4)
Io : Moment of Inertia for geographic center Axis (cm^4)
A : Sectional Area (cm^2)
e : Eccentric from geographic center (cm)
Eccentrics
e = ∑A*y / ∑A = 0.00 (cm) [Eq 4.2.7.2]
Neutral Axis
e1 : 17.40 - 0.00 = 17.40 (cm)
e2 : 17.40 + 0.00 = 17.40 (cm)
Sectional Modulus
Zc = Iy / e1 = 356.6 (cm) [Eq 4.2.7.3]
Zt = Iy / e2 = 356.6 (cm) [Eq 4.2.7.4]
where,
(1) Bending Stress of Skin Plate will be calculated as per TIMOSHENKO'S FORMULA.
1 P
σ = x k x a^2 x [Eq 4.4.1]
100 (t - ε)^2
σ4 ▽ where,
σ : STRESS (Kgf/cm^2)
k : COEFFICIENT
P
σ3 0.3 σ1 a : MINOR WIDTH OF PANEL (cm)
b : MAJOR WIDTH OF PANEL (cm)
a
VERTICAL BEAM
0.000 p1 Ph, Mean Hydrostatic Press.
0.021 (Kgf/cm^2)
22.0
40.0
L1
1
0.412 p2
0.059
23.0
35.0
L2
2
0.773 p3
0.093
18.0
30.0
L3
3
1.082 p4
0.119
20.0
8.0
L4
4
1.288 p5
0.136
10.0
5.0
L5
5
1.423 p5
[T 4.4.3]
N P a b σa t ε+t
b/a k
O Kgf/cm² (cm) (cm) Kgf/cm² (cm) (cm)
1 0.020 22.00 71.0 3.22 50.0 1,200 0.06 0.16
2 0.059 23.00 71.0 3.08 50.0 1,200 0.11 0.21
3 0.092 18.00 71.0 3.94 50.0 1,200 0.11 0.21
4 0.118 8.00 71.0 8.87 50.0 1,200 0.05 0.05
5 0.135 5.00 71.0 14.2 50.0 1,200 0.03 0.03
t max 2.10
∴ SKIN PLATE THK, t = 5.0 mm > 2.1 mm OK
b > 20 + 0.1 PR
where, b: Distance from Side to Roller Center, cm
PR
PR: Maximum Load of Roller (tf)
b
PR y
(b1, b3)
100
6 88 (h2) 6
(h1) 100 (h3)
[Fig 5.1.2]
Moment of Inertia
Iy = ∑ Io + ∑ Ay^2 - ∑A*e^2 = 45.8 + 265 - 0.0 = 310.9 (cm^4)
where, [Eq 4.1.7]
Iy : Moment of Inertia (y-y) (cm^4)
Io : Moment of Inertia for geographic center Axis (cm^4)
A : Sectional Area (cm^2)
e : Eccentric from geographic center (cm)
Eccentrics
e = ∑A*y / ∑A = - (cm) [Eq 4.1.8]
Neutral Axis
e1 : 5.00 - 0.00 = 5.00 (cm)
e2 : 5.00 + 0.00 = 5.00 (cm)
Sectional Modulus
Zc = Iy / e1 = 311 / 5.00 = 62 (cm^3) [Eq 4.1.9]
Zt = Iy / e2 = 311 / 5.00 = 62 (cm^3) [Eq 4.1.10]
where,
σa : Allowable Stress (Kgf/cm^2)
Aw / Ac = 7.04 / 6 = 1.17
K = [3 + (Aw / 2Ac)]^(1/2) = (3 + 7.04 / 2x6.00)^(1/2) = 2.00
ℓ = 40.0 cm, ℓ / b ≤ 9 / K is (40.0/10.0 = 4.0 ≤ 9/2.00 = 4.5).
σa = 1,200 (Kgf/cm^2)
[Fig 5.1.3]
6. SUMMARY
6.1 Stop Log Gates are arranged with Upper and Lower layer gates.
As the water levels for upper gate is lower than that of the lower one, the member sizes
for upper gate are identical to the lower gate, except No 4 horizontal beam.