A Classification of Seven Tone Scales
A Classification of Seven Tone Scales
Abstract: In this work we provide an original approach to the classification of seven tone
scales from the view point of composition and improvization. There are a total of 66
seven tone (heptatonic) scale formulas for equitempered systems out of which we
eliminate 34 of them in view of the principles of tonal harmony and classify the
remaining 32 scales into seven groups which are associated with the seven modes of the
educator and the composer. We also provide a number of musical examples that
1. Introduction
and analyze any concept or problem under consideration. With regard to musical scales
the history of such attempts yield back to the era of ancient Greeks. In literature a
systematic investigation of “synthetic scales”, i.e., scales formed by raising and lowering
the pitches of the tones of the natural diatonic major scale, is generally attributed to the
book of the great composer Busoni [1], which later has been improved and cathegorized
in a paper by Mason [2]. In [2] a total of 1254 seven tone “Busoni scales” have been
enlisted under the tonal limitation that the accidential of each tone is restricted to ( , , ,
1
Professor, Faculty of Education, Department of Fine Arts, Trakya University, Edirne, TURKEY
2
Professor, Faculty of Arts and Sciences, Department of Mathematics, Uludağ University, Bursa, TURKEY
1
#,x). Such a high number in Busoni scales arises when an enharmonic mapping onto the
twelve tones of the equitempered system is avoided (i.e., when F is not assumed equal to
E and so forth). However, Busoni scales have been critisized in literature as early as
1929, around 18 years after they appeared, by Barbour [3]. In his related works [3,4]
Barbour discusses the synthesis of seven tone scales in equal temparament within the
range of tonal harmony and critisizes that the enumeration of Busoni scales are not
supported by any theoretical background that interconnects them. In that context Busoni
addresses a total of 66 seven tone cyclic scale formulas, which is also the starting point of
Based on the principle of cyclic permutation the mentioned 66 seven tone scale formulas
2
It is observed that in case of equal temparament the 1254 modes of Busoni in [2] reduce
into 66*7=462 modes. Certainly, this is still a huge number to benefit effectively for
restrictions are imposed in accord with the principles of tonal harmony depending on the
purpose of a composer.
In his 1949 paper [4] Barbour handles this subject and critisizes Delezenne [5], Gandillot
[6], Hatherly [7] and Helmholtz [8] for avoiding 31 of 66 scales due to insistance in these
references that any scale that “works” should involve at least two perfect fifths. In that
context Barbour draws attention to the melodic varieties offered by the rest of those
One should also mention to the book by Slonimsky [9, pp.137-154] first published in
1947 where a total of 54 out of 224 modes, though unsystematically, are enlisted as
constructed over the note C (i.e., a “C scale”) also accompanied by 4 note chord voicings.
At this point we wish to introduce our own perspective on this set of 66 seven tone scales.
We consider a subset of these scales for which all mode formulas can be constructed as a
C scale under the natural and unique restriction that accidentals on each tone is always
for which all seven modes permit a C scale limited to the mentioned accidential
restrictions. From this perspective we are left with only 32 out of the 66 scales. They
comprise all 23 scales of Classes I and II and 9 out of 15 scales of Class III. The 6 scale
3
formulas of Class III that are eliminated are enlisted in Table 2. It is an easy task for any
reader to verify that at least one mode of every cyclic scale formula in Table 2 does not
permit a C scale.
Our perspective in a classification of any scale that “works” is that its structure should be
connected to any of the well known seven modes of the natural diatonic major scale
depicted in Table 3.
1 (221)+2+(221) Ionian
2 (212)+2+(212) Dorian
3 (122)+2+(122) Phrygian
4 (222)+1+(221) Lydian
5 (221)+2+(212) Mixolydian
4
6 (212)+2+(122) Aeolian
7 (122)+1+(222) Locrian
Table 3. The natural diatonic major scale as the generator of all synthetic scales
In Figure 1 we illustrate the mathematical distribution of the 31 synthetic scales under the
seven groups represented by the modes of the generator diatonic major scale.
5
The details of the idea behind this grouping is as follows: Since the Ionian is a major
scale (with a major third), all root scale formulas with a major third are located under this
group. Similarly, since the Aeolian is a minor scale (with a minor third), all root scale
formulas with a minor third are located thereunder. It is seen that a total of 23 scale
families out of 32 are grouped under the natural major and minor scales. As for the
groups under Dorian, Phrygian, Mixolydian and Locrian scales a similar idea is employed
where stronger tonal relations can be observed since in most cases the whole lower
tetrachord structure keeps unchanged. In this representation it is seen that none of the
synthetic scales is related to the Lydian mode. It stems from the fact that the lower
tetrachord of Lydian mode ranges on a 6 semitone interval, while the rest of the mode
range on a 5 semitone interval. We shall emphasize on this issue in more detail in Section
And in the determination of the root scale formulas out of seven modes indicated by each
one of the 31 cyclic formula, we have picked those for which the simultaneous
appearance of tones with flat and sharp accidentials is at minimum in view of tonal
harmony. These principles for melodic connections are illustrated in the following 6
6
Scale Scale
Treble Clef Representation
Name Formula
Ionian
(221)+2+(221)
(Generator Mode 1)
Ionian 6 (221)+2+(131)
Ionian (132)+2+(211)
2,#4,#5,#6
Ionian (221)+1+(123)
5, 6, 7
Ionian (221)+1+(213)
5, 6, 7
Ionian (131)+3+(211)
2,#5,#6
Ionian (132)+1+(131)
2,#4, 6
Ionian (131)+1+(231)
2, 5, 6
Ionian (131)+1+(132)
2, 5, 6, 7
Ionian
(313)+1+(121)
#2,x4,#5
Ionian (312)+1+(131)
#2,#4, 6
Table 4. The scales generated by Ionian Mode
7
Scale Scale
Treble Clef Representation
Name Formula
Dorian
(Generator (212)+2+(212)
Mode 2)
Scale Scale
Treble Clef Representation
Name Formula
Phrygian
(Generator (122)+2+(122)
Mode 3)
Phrygian (122)+2+(221)
#6,#7
Phrygian #7 (122)+2+(131)
Phrygian
(123)+1+(311)
#4,x6,#7
Table 6. The scales generated by Phrygian Mode
Scale Scale
Treble Clef Representation
Name Formula
Mixolydian
(221)+2+(212)
(Generator Mode 5)
Aeolian 5, 6 (212)+1+(132)
Aeolian 7 (212)+2+(113)
Aeolian 4 (211)+3+(122)
Aeolian (211)+2+(231)
4, 5,#7
Aeolian (211)+1+(223)
4, 5, 6, 7
Aeolian (211)+2+(312)
4, 5,#6
Aeolian (211)+2+(123)
4, 5, 6, 7
Aeolian (212)+1+(213)
5, 7
Aeolian (212)+1+(123)
5, 6, 7
Aeolian #7 (212)+2+(131)
9
Scale Scale
Treble Clef Representation
Name Formula
Locrian
(122)+1+(222)
(Generator Mode 7)
Locrian #7 (122)+1+(231)
Ionian 6 (221)+2+(131)
Ionian 5, 6, 7 (221)+1+(123)
Ionian 5, 6, 7 (221)+1+(213)
Phrygian #7 (122)+2+(131)
Aeolian 5, 6 (212)+1+(132)
10
Aeolian 7 (212)+2+(113)
Aeolian 4 (211)+3+(122)
Aeolian (211)+1+(223)
4, 5, 6, 7
Aeolian 4, 5,#6 (211)+2+(312)
Aeolian (211)+2+(123)
4, 5, 6, 7
Aeolian 5, 7 (212)+1+(213)
Aeolian 5, 6, 7 (212)+1+(123)
Aeolian #7 (212)+2+(131)
Locrian #7 (122)+1+(231)
Ionian 2, 5, 6 (131)+1+(231)
Ionian 2, 5, 6, 7 (131)+1+(132)
For a deeper insight on the melodic connections between the 32 cyclic formulas we also
introduce symbolic representations for the tetrachords constituting the scales through the
notation XTY , where the letter T stands for the initial of tetrachord; X denotes the total
differentiating between the tetrachords having the same X value. With all these in mind
12
Set of Tetrachord Tetrachord
Semitones Formula Symbol
{1,1,1} 1-1-1 3T
1-1-2 4T1
{1,1,2} 1-2-1 4T2
2-1-1 4T3
{2,2,3} 2-2-3 7T1
2-3-2 7T2
3-2-2 7T3
{1,3,3} 1-3-3 7T4
3-1-3 7T5
3-3-1 7T6
Table 14. A list of altered tetrachord formulas and symbols
In Table 14 a notational convenience is introduced for the first tetrachord by removing the
Now the mathematical structure of all 32*7=224 modes we consider can be tabulated by
Corresponding Opposite
Order Scale Structure
Scale Structure
1 3T + 2 + 7TY or (3T , 7TY ) 7TY + 2 + 3T or (7TY ,3T )
2 3T + 3 + 6TY or (3T , 6TY ) 6TY + 3 + 3T or (6TY ,3T )
3 3T + 4 + 5TY or (3T ,5TY ) 5TY + 4 + 3T or (5TY ,3T )
4 4TX + 1 + 7TY or (4TX , 7TY ) 7TY + 1 + 4TX or (7TY , 4TX )
5 4TX + 2 + 6TY or (4TX , 6TY ) 6TY + 2 + 4TX or (6TY , 4TX )
6 4TX + 3 + 5TY or (4TX ,5TY ) 5TY + 3 + 4TX or (5TY , 4TX )
7 4TX + 4 + 4TY or (4TX , 4TY ) 4TY + 4 + 4TX or (4TY , 4TX )
8 5TX + 1 + 6TY or (5TX , 6TY ) 6TY + 1 + 5TX or (6TY ,5TX )
5TX + 2 + 5TY or (5TX ,5TY ) 5TY + 2 + 5TX or (5TY ,5TX )
9
Table 15. A list of all possible scale structures for 224 modes
13
It should be realized that the coefficients in each structure sum up to 12. Therefore one
can express the sum formula in a shorter way as in paranthesis avoiding the connector
The distribution of tetrachords into the 32 scales of Classes I, II, III are enlisted in Table
16.
Class Tetrachords
III 3T 4T1 4T2 4T3 5T4 5T5 5T6 6T1 7T4 7T5 7T6
; , , ; , , ; ; ,
Table 16. The distribution of tetrachords into scales of Classes I, II, III
This new notation provides an opportunity to observe the mathematical symmetries and
One may also note that 4 among the 224 modes have a self-inverse structure as given in
Table 18.
Mode Mode
Scale and Mode
Formula Symbol
Phrygian #6,#7 Scale
(122)+2+(221) (5T1 ,5T3 )
Mode 1
Aeolian #6,#7 Scale
(221) +2+(122) (5T3 ,5T1 )
Mode 5 (Melodic Major)
Diatonic Major Scale
(212) +2+(212) (5T2 ,5T2 )
Mode 2 (Dorian)
Aeolian #4,#7 Scale
(131)+2+(131) (5T5 , 5T5 )
Mode 5 (Double Harmonic Major)
Table 18. Self inverse modes
In the classification of the cyclic scale formulas constituting the mathematical family tree
it is already mentioned that the structure of the lower tetrachords are taken into
consideration. Now under the new notation further remarks on classification can be made
over the lower tetrachords. Out of the 32 root scales 26 of them are seen to possess
15
natural lower tetrachords, while the remaining 6 possess altered ones. Their properties are
summarized in Tables 19 and 20.
Lower Tetrachord
Scale Common Properties
Structure
Dorian #6,#7
Aeolian 5, 6
Aeolian 7
Aeolian 5, 7 5T2
Aeolian 5, 6, 7
The lower tetrachords coincide exactly
Aeolian #7
with those of natural major or minor scales
Aeolian #6,#7
Ionian
Ionian 6
5T3
Ionian 5, 6, 7
Ionian 5, 6, 7
Phrygian #6,#7
Phrygian #7 5T1
Locrian #7
Locrian #6,#7
The lower tetrachords differ from
Ionian 2,#5,#6
those of natural major or minor scales
Ionian 2, 5, 6 5T5
only by an accidential on the second note/tone
Ionian 2, 5, 6, 7
Mixolydian #2, 5
5T6
Locrian x2,#3
6T4 The lower tetrachords differ from
Aeolian #4,#7 that of natural minor scale
only by an accidential on the fourth note/tone
Phrygian #4,x6,#7 6T2
Ionian 2,#4,#5,#6
6T3 The lower tetrachords differ from
Ionian 2,#4, 6 those of natural major or minor scales
only by accidentials on the second and fourth
Ionian #2,#4, 6 notes/tones
6T6
Mixolydian #2,#4
16
Lower Tetrachord
Scale Common Properties
Structure
Aeolian 4
Aeolian
4, 5,#7
Aeolian The lower tetrachords differ from
4, 5, 6, 7 4T3 that of natural minor scale
Aeolian only by an accidential on the fourth note/tone
4, 5,#6
Aeolian
4, 5, 6, 7
Ionian The lower tetrachords differ from that of natural
7T5 major scale only by accidentials on the second and
#2,x4,#5
fourth notes/tones
Table 20. Root scales possessing altered lower tetrachords
Regarding the scale nomenclature, we shall confine ourselves to the ancient Greek
modes in Table 3 and leave the ethnic, cultural or regional names for much of the 224
Of critical importance are the standard harmonic and melodic major/minor scales
Scales over
Standard Nomenclature
Greek Modes
Ionian 6 The (Ionic) Harmonic Major
Ionian 2, 6 The (Ionic) Double Harmonic Major
Ionian 6, 7 The (Ionic) Melodic Major
Aeolian #7 The (Aeolic) Harmonic Minor
Aeolian #4,#7 The (Aeolic) Double Harmonic Minor
Aeolian #6,#7 The (Aeolic) Melodic Minor
Table 21. Standard Harmonic and Melodic Major/Minor Scales
17
It should be recalled that the natural modes in describing harmonic/melodic major and
minor scales in Table 16 are the Ionian and Aeolian respectively. Therefore these scales
are actually “Ionic” and “Aeolic” as stated only in parantheses since we avoid these
adjectives in practice. However we can extend these definitions covering the scales
constructed over the remaining Greek modes using the phrases “Doric”, “Phrygic”,
In that regard the scales Aeolian #7; #6,#7; Phrygian #7;#6#7; Locrian #7;#6,#7; and
Dorian #6,#7 can be located instantly in Figure 1. One should expect similar formulas
between the scales constructed over the Greek modes as in Table 17. To name a few
Mixolydian #7 = Ionian
6. Musical Samples Displaying Melodic Progressions Along the Family Tree and
Concluding Remarks
progressions along the 5 branches of the family tree. It is observed that the mathematical
order of the scales on any branch of the family tree should by no means be expected to
To demonstrate how the melodic family tree works we provide below 5 musical samples
where the numbers in parantheses for each phrase stand for the order of the scales in the
“melodic” family tree. Accordingly, in Example 1, (1) is the Ionian mode, (2) is Ionian
19
Example 1. A musical sample for melodic progressions over the Ionian mode
20
21
Example 2. A musical sample for melodic progressions over the Aeolian mode
22
Example 3. A musical sample for melodic progressions over the Mixolydian mode
Example 4. A musical sample for melodic progressions over the Locrian mode
23
Example 5. A musical sample for melodic progressions over the Phrygian mode
It is also interesting for us to observe in the examples that a number of alterations in the
upper tetrachords along the branches belonging to Ionian, Phrygian and Aeolian modes,
and similarly in the lower tetrachords along the branches belonging to Mixolydian and
Locrian modes reveal many melodic properties specific to eastern music, which should be
Through these 5 examples one can get some idea on the incorporation of synthetic scales
When one considers the 12 notes (colors) of the chromatic scale as the tonic for any of
the 224 modes we have considered, there appears as many as 224*12=2688 scales that
can be incorporated in any composition under the general assumption that the harmonic
Throughout the analysis we have also observed two points which provide a good display
of the parallelity relations between natural major and minor scales. The first one is in
24
Figure 1 where a total of 23 root scale formulas out of 32 are grouped under the natural
major and minor scales. And the second is in the last two relations in Section 5 where 2 of
the 12 minor root scale formulas in the family tree bring about major scales in Mode 5.
the seven tone scale theory with a supplement of 5 musical examples serve as background
25
REFERENCES
[1] F. Busoni, “Entwurf Einer Neuen Aesthetik der Tonkunst (1907); English
translation by Th. Baker (G. Schirmer, Inc., New York 1911).
[2] R.M. Mason, “Enumeration of Synthetic Musical Scales by Matrix Algebra and a
Catalogue of Busoni Scales”, Journal of Music Theory 14 (1970) 92 - 126
[3] J.M. Barbour, “Synthetic Musical Scales”, Am. Math. Monthly 36, No.3, 155-160
(March 1929)
[4] J.M. Barbour, “Musical Scales and Their Classification”, The Journal of the
Acoustical Society of America, 21 No.6 (Nov.1949) pp.586-589.
[5] C.E.J. Delezenne, “Note Sur le Nombre des Modes Musicaux”, Recueil des
travaux de la société des sciences, de l’agriculture et des arts, de Lille 8, 57-71
(1826/27)
[7] S.G. Hatherly, “A Treatise on Byzantine Music” (A. Gardiner, Paisley and
London) (1892).
[9] N. Slonimsky, “Thesaurus of Scales and Melodic Patterns”, New York (1947).
26