JURISPRUDENCE 1 SUMMARY RESEARCHED AND COMPILED BY MOSES YAZAAMA AND NALUBEGA ROSE

JURISPRUDENCE 1 SUMMARY 2. Historical Jurisprudence. Developed in 19th-

century Germany as a response to positivist
views, historical jurisprudence argues that laws
Definition and Scope
emerge naturally from cultural practices and
Jurisprudence is the theoretical study of law, examining society’s evolution. They further believe that
its principles, nature, and functions within society. law evolves from customs, societal values, and
cultural practices, adapting to societal needs
Originating from the Latin jurisprudentia (“knowledge
of law”), jurisprudence investigates the theory and over time.
philosophy behind legal systems. This field evolved
Key Proponents
from ancient Roman and Greek thought, deeply
influencing modern Western legal systems. H.L.A. Hart
Friedrich Savigny argued that effective legal systems
describes jurisprudence as the science and philosophy of
reflect the customs and values of the people and
law, viewing law as a systematic set of rules enforced by
Montesquieu who emphasized how geography, culture,
authoritative commands. Key figures like Sir John
and historical context shape laws among others.
Salmond and John Austin provided influential views on
the definitions of jurisprudence as the science /
3. Ethical Jurisprudence. With roots in the
philosophy of law.
Enlightenment, this school focuses on aligning
law with moral principles of justice and fairness.
SCHOOLS OF JURISPRUDENCE
They suggest that law’s purpose is to promote
justice, equity, and societal well-being.
1. Analytical (Positivist) Jurisprudence.
Emerging from the Enlightenment period1 in the
Key Proponents
18th and 19th centuries, analytical jurisprudence
sought to understand law systematically,
Immanuel Kant emphasized that law should respect
independent of moral or historical
human dignity and protect moral rights and Jeremy
considerations. Its core belief is that it clarifies
Bentham advocated for utilitarianism, the "greatest
legal concepts without regard to morality or
happiness" principle, as a basis for legal judgments.
history, focusing on law as an organized
structure of rules and commands.
4. Sociological Jurisprudence

Key Proponents Gained popularity in the early 20th century, particularly

in the United States, emphasizing the social impact of
Jeremy Bentham advocated for advocated for utility in
laws on society. Views law as a tool for social
legal structures and opposed vague, morally infused
development, adjusting to societal needs and promoting
legal reasoning, John Austin who developed "command
welfare.
theory," defining law as the commands of the sovereign
backed by threats, H LA Harts a well know schoolar in
the 20th century and Hans Kelsen also a notorious
schoolar known for his insights into what is law.

1
The Enlightenment was an intellectual and philosophical
movement in Europe during the 17th and 18th centuries that
emphasized reason, individualism, and progress.
Page 1 of 22
 JURISPRUDENCE 1 SUMMARY RESEARCHED AND COMPILED BY MOSES YAZAAMA AND NALUBEGA ROSE

Key Proponents of fairness, morality, and justice, making it the basis

for societal governance and human rights.
Roscoe Pound introduced “social engineering,” viewing
law as a means to balance societal interests and solve Key proponents
social conflicts.
Aristotle, who viewed justice as inherent in nature,
5. Realist Jurisprudence
Cicero, who described natural law as universal and
superior to human law and St. Thomas Aquinas,
Emerged in the 1920s and 1930s in the United States as
a reaction against formalist views, stressing the real-life who linked natural law to divine law and human
application of law. It focuses on how laws operate in real reason. Later thinkers like John Locke emphasized
world settings, emphasizing practical outcomes over natural rights like life and property, while Rousseau
theoretical rules. highlighted the alignment of societal laws with
individual freedom. Modern theorist Lon Fuller
Key Proponents stressed the "inner morality of law".

Oliver Wendell Holmes Jr. advocated for “law in EPISTEMOLOGY (SCHOOLS OF KNOWLEDGE)
action,” observing the behavior of judges and the actual
effects of law on society and Karl Llewellyn stressed Epistemology is the branch of philosophy concerned
that law should be evaluated based on its impact on with the nature and scope of knowledge. It explores
society and how it is interpreted by courts among others. questions like "What is knowledge?", "How do we know
what we know?", and "What justifies our beliefs?"
Our Uganda’s judicial system applies a realist approach, Philosophers have debated these questions for centuries,
particularly in constitutional interpretation, where giving rise to various schools of thought, each with its
practical societal impacts are considered. own unique perspective on knowledge and its
acquisition.
6. Natural School of Law
1. Materialism
The Natural School of Law asserts that law is
derived from universal principles rooted in nature, Originating from ancient Greek philosophy, materialism
reason, or divine will. It emphasizes that valid laws re-emerged in modern thought through the works of Karl
must conform to moral and ethical standards and Marx and Friedrich Engels.
that certain rights, such as life, liberty, and justice,
Matter is the fundamental substance, with all
are inherent and inalienable. This school views phenomena, including thought and consciousness,
natural law as eternal, unchanging, and applicable resulting from material interactions.
to all people, transcending human-made laws.
Key Proponents
The central belief is that natural law serves as a
standard for evaluating the legitimacy of positive Karl Marx: Suggested that society is shaped by
laws. If human laws conflict with natural law, they economic and material conditions.
are considered invalid. Natural law is discovered
through human reason and is grounded in principles Friedrich Engels: Co-developed dialectical materialism,
emphasizing economic forces in historical development.

Page 2 of 22
 JURISPRUDENCE 1 SUMMARY RESEARCHED AND COMPILED BY MOSES YAZAAMA AND NALUBEGA ROSE

Materialist theories influence Uganda’s approach to Emerged as a major philosophical approach during the
economic policy, focusing on social equality and class. 17th century, emphasizing experience as the foundation
of knowledge. They believe that knowledge comes from
2. Idealism sensory experience, with ideas formed from observation.

With roots in ancient philosophy, idealism was Key Proponents:

formalized in the 18th and 19th centuries by Kant,
Berkeley, and Hegel. John Locke proposed that the mind is a “blank slate”
and all knowledge comes from experience and David
Reality is fundamentally mental or spiritual, shaped by Hume also argued those ideas are copies of sensory
ideas rather than physical matter. impressions.

Key Proponents Empiricist approaches are essential in Uganda’s

evidence-based judicial processes, especially in criminal
George Berkeley argued that reality is based on law.
perception, with nothing existing outside the mind and
Immanuel Kant who proposed that reality is shaped by 5. Pragmatism
our mental structures and interpretations. Also Hegel
suggested that reality is an unfolding of ideas moving Originated in the United States in the late 19th century,
toward self-awareness. pragmatism evaluates ideas based on practical outcomes.
They believe that truth is determined by an idea’s
Idealist views resonate in Uganda’s emphasis on cultural usefulness and effectiveness in practice.
and spiritual values, particularly in laws related to
customary practices. Key Proponents

3. Rationalism William James stressed that truth is what “works” and

has beneficial results and John Dewey focused on the
Developed during the Enlightenment, rationalism practical value of ideas, particularly in education.
emphasizes reason as the primary source of knowledge.
They believe that certain truths are known independently 6. Existentialism
of sensory experience, accessible through reason and
deduction. Developed in the 19th and 20th centuries, existentialism
stresses individual freedom and the creation of meaning.
Key Proponents They believe that each individual creates their essence
through choices, with no preordained purpose or
René Descartes asserted “I think, therefore I am,” inherent meaning.
suggesting that knowledge of self is innate and Leibniz
who believed knowledge is inherent, with the universe Key Proponents
operating on rational principles.
Jean-Paul Sartre asserted “existence precedes essence,”
Rationalist thought is reflected in Uganda’s legal meaning individuals define their own purpose and Søren
interpretations that emphasize logical reasoning, Kierkegaard: Emphasized personal faith and the “leap”
particularly in constitutional law. into existential meaning.

4. Empiricism

Page 3 of 22
 JURISPRUDENCE 1 SUMMARY RESEARCHED AND COMPILED BY MOSES YAZAAMA AND NALUBEGA ROSE

Existentialism aligns with Uganda’s emphasis on 5. Documentation: Laws are written and
individual rights and freedoms in the Constitution2. published, whereas ethics are unwritten.

6. Binding Nature: Laws are binding on all; ethics

DIFFERENCES AND SIMILARITITES BETWEEN
have no such obligation.
LAW AND OTHER ASPECTS
Scholarly Divergence
Law and Ethics
 Simmonds argues that law and ethics often
Law is defined by Black’s Law Dictionary3 as a body of
overlap yet diverge on certain contentious issues
conduct prescribed by controlling authority with binding
(e.g., death penalty).
legal force.
 Okafor critiques legal positivism for focusing
Ethics: Defined by Black’s Law Dictionary 4 as moral
solely on statutory laws, excluding ethics from
principles that govern individual actions. Aristotle
enforcement considerations.
described ethics as the study of character and values
essential for a good life. Law and Morality
Key Scholars Morality is defined under the black’s Law Dictionary
defines it as conformity with accepted societal conduct.
 Steve McCartney and Rick Parent describe
Morality governs both actions and intentions, influenced
ethics as a branch of philosophy concerning
by social norms.
decision-making.
Key Scholars
 Joseph Raz examines how ethical reasoning,
while influential, may not directly affect legal  H.L.A. Hart argues for a separation between
practices. law and morality, with any moral value in law
being incidental.
Differences
 Natural Law Theorists such as Immanuel Kant,
1. Enforcement: Laws are enforced by
claim that law and morality should be inherently
government bodies; ethics rely on personal
connected, aligning with justice.
adherence and lack official sanctions (e.g.,
Ugandan lawyers’ dress code being ethical but Differences
not legally binding).
1. Enforcement. Law is enforced by the state;
2. Punishment: Violating laws leads to penalties morality is enforced by social or religious
(e.g., murder penalties in Uganda’s Penal Code principles (e.g., the Ten Commandments).
Act); ethical violations do not incur formal
penalties. 2. Consequences. Legal violations result in
punishment (e.g., imprisonment for theft), while
3. Authority: Laws are enacted by legislatures, immoral acts may face social disapproval but
while ethics evolve from societal values. lack legal repercussions.
4. Purpose: Laws maintain social order, while 3. Scope. Laws cover specific societal issues,
ethics guide individual actions. while morality is broader and often culturally

2 4
Chapter IV of the constitution supra
3
2nd Edition
Page 4 of 22
 JURISPRUDENCE 1 SUMMARY RESEARCHED AND COMPILED BY MOSES YAZAAMA AND NALUBEGA ROSE

specific (e.g., moral restrictions in the Bagishu 4. Adaptability. Laws adjust to crises, while
culture). customs are resistant to sudden changes.

4. Binding Nature. Laws apply to all citizens; Scholarly Divergence

morality is more subjective and community-
 Allen argues that customs develop naturally
bound.
from societal needs, contrasting with Austin’s
5. Legal vs. Moral Duty. Law imposes specific view of custom as informal yet binding. Allen
duties like tax payment, while morality involves suggests custom is inherent, while Austin sees it
respect and social duties. as optional unless legally recognized.

Scholarly Divergence Similarities Among Law, Ethics, Morality, and

Custom
 Hart sees morality as optional in law, a
perspective opposed by natural law theorists, 1. Societal Order: All serve to maintain order and
who see law as a reflection of moral ideals. The prevent societal harm.
differing views reflect a broader debate about
2. Guidance for Behavior: Each provides
the influence of morality on law, exemplified by
principles to guide individuals within society,
legal systems under dictatorships like Idi Amin’s
though the scope and enforcement vary.
Uganda, where laws lacked moral
underpinnings. 3. Role in Governance: Ethics, morality, and
customs can influence legal reforms and
Law and Custom
interpretations, as seen in Uganda.
Custom is defined in The Magistrates Courts 5Act as
1. Similarities Between Law and Custom
rules of conduct governing legal relations formed
through long-standing traditions, not legislatively  Both laws and customs have consequences if
enacted. violated. Laws have legal consequences, like jail
time, while customs carry social consequences,
Key Scholars
such as being ostracized. Custom, according to
Salmond describes custom as principles rooted in sociologist Emile Durkheim, plays a crucial role
societal conscience and public utility and Austin sees in maintaining social order, especially in early
custom as rules observed spontaneously by the governed societies where law was less formalized.
without formal legal backing.
 While laws are formal and binding through state
Differences power, customs can be so ingrained in society
that they are treated as binding, even without
1. Origin. Law is deliberately enacted; custom
formal legal status. Legal scholars like H.L.A.
grows organically.
Hart have argued that customs can become
2. Authority. Laws are created by legislative “secondary rules” within a legal system,
bodies; customs gain acceptance through especially when they evolve to the point where
societal practice (e.g., Buganda clans' customs). they are recognized and enforced by courts. This
is in contrast to natural law theorists, such as
3. Durability. Laws remain until repealed, while Thomas Aquinas, who emphasize divine law
customs may fade naturally. over social customs.

5
Cap 19
Page 5 of 22
 JURISPRUDENCE 1 SUMMARY RESEARCHED AND COMPILED BY MOSES YAZAAMA AND NALUBEGA ROSE

 Customary law was historically foundational law should be based on secular authority rather than
before the rise of formal legal systems. divine command.
Customary practices often form the basis of laws
Scholarly Divergence
in societies, evolving into codified legal rules. In
the Roman legal tradition, for example, customs While Aquinas and Aristotle argued for a harmonious
were central before codifications like the Corpus relationship between law and religion, contemporary
Juris Civilis formalized laws. However, some legal positivists like Hart and Bentham reject this,
modern legal scholars, like John Austin, maintaining that legal validity stems from human-made
emphasized the role of sovereignty and formal laws and social institutions, not divine decree.
legislation over customary norms in modern
legal systems. For a custom to be recognized as In theocratic states like Saudi Arabia, religious law (e.g.,
a source of law, it must meet specific criteria— Sharia) is embedded within the legal system.
ancient, reasonable, continuous, and consistent Conversely, in secular states like Uganda, law is defined
with public policy, a view espoused by jurists by the Constitution, which ensures that any laws
like Sir William Blackstone. inconsistent with it are void. In Uganda, religious views
often shape public morality, as seen in the Anti-
Law and Religion Homosexuality Act, showing the tension between legal
authority and religious beliefs.
Black’s Law Dictionary6 defines religion as a system of
faith and worship involving belief in a supreme being, Scholarly Divergence
often with moral codes. Merriam-Webster’s definition
frames religion as a set of beliefs and practices Scholars like Rashid Khalidi have argued that religious
institutionalized within a community. This suggests a law in theocratic states offers a more integrated approach
distinction between personal belief and organized to governance, while others like Michael Walzer
religious practice, which is also a point of divergence contend that secularism in Western legal systems fosters
among legal scholars. greater religious freedom and pluralism.

Scholarly Divergence: Differences Between Law and Religion

Scholars like John Locke argued for the separation of 1. Religious laws typically do not specify
religion and government, believing that religion should penalties for violations, or if they do,
not interfere with the functioning of the state, while legal penalties are often reserved for the
theorists like Karl Schmitt, in contrast, maintained that afterlife. In contrast, secular laws
religion plays an integral role in shaping legal authority provide clear penalties for breaches,
and legitimacy. This has been even affirmed in the case such as imprisonment or fines. Legal
of the Most High Rev V Maazi and other7. scholars like Max Weber have noted
that modern law is characterized by its
Separation vs. Integration of Law and Religion formal sanctions and enforcement by a
central authority, unlike religious law,
There is debate on whether law and religion should be
which may rely on internal moral
distinct or intertwined. Some, like Thomas Aquinas,
compulsion and spiritual sanctions.
believed that laws should align with divine law to avoid
societal chaos. On the other hand, legal positivists like Scholarly Divergence
Jeremy Bentham argued for the clear separation of law
from religious and moral principles, emphasizing that While Weber emphasized the rational-legal nature of
state-enforced law, others like Émile Durkheim argued

6
2nd Edition 7
2003
Page 6 of 22
 JURISPRUDENCE 1 SUMMARY RESEARCHED AND COMPILED BY MOSES YAZAAMA AND NALUBEGA ROSE

that religion provides a system of moral guidance that is 3. Both systems seek to direct how people should
equally influential, even without formal legal sanctions. live their lives, with law focused on societal
order and religion on moral or spiritual purity.
2. Law is often seen as arising from the
collective will of society or the state,
whereas religious law is viewed as
LEGAL EDUCATION IN UGANDA
deriving authority from divine or
supernatural sources. Legal education equips individuals with the principles,
practices, and theories of law. not merely instruction
Scholarly Divergence
received at school or college,but the whole course of
Natural law theorists like Aquinas argued that human training, moral, intellectual, and physical. Education
law should align with divine law, while legal positivists maybe particularly directed to either the mental, moral,
like H.L.A. Hart contend that law is a human construct, or physical powers and faculties,”
separate from religious principles.
Its primary goals are;
3. One can practice religion without
1. Preparing legal professionals (advocates, judges,
requiring others to follow the same
etc.).
beliefs, whereas laws apply to everyone
within a given jurisdiction. 2. Empowering others to apply legal knowledge in
fields like business, governance, and research.
Scholarly Divergence: This concept reflects a division
between pluralistic legal systems, which recognize Historical Context of Legal Education in Uganda
diverse belief systems (e.g., liberal democracies), and
 1952. The colonial government initiated the
more monolithic systems, where religious belief may
directly shape the law (e.g., Islamic states). "African Pupils-Crown Law Chambers,"
opening legal training to African natives.
4. Laws are enforced by state institutions,
 1968. Makerere University School of Law
such as the judiciary and police, while
religious laws are often seen as being became Uganda’s first law school as Makerere
enforced by God. College with the department of law.

 1970. The Law Development Centre (LDC) was

Scholarly Divergence: Scholars like John Rawls
advocated for a division of religious and state authority established under the Law Development Centre
to preserve individual freedoms, whereas legal scholars Act to conduct professional legal training,
like Carl Schmitt argued for the inclusion of religious research, and law reform.
values in legal governance to ensure moral and ethical  There are up to 13 universities teaching law and
consistency. Makerere is the only university offering LLD
Similarities Between Law and Religion (Doctorate Of Laws)

1. Both law and religion are perceived as fixed Stages of Legal Education
systems. Law, like religious doctrines, often
emphasizes stability and consistency in guiding
human behavior.
2. Both systems involve clear commands that
followers are expected to obey. In law, these
commands come from the state, while in
religion, they come from a divine source.
Page 7 of 22
 JURISPRUDENCE 1 SUMMARY RESEARCHED AND COMPILED BY MOSES YAZAAMA AND NALUBEGA ROSE

The World Bank-funded Legal Education Report 1. Application to the National Council for
(1995), cited in Pius Nuwagaba v. Law Development Higher Education (NCHE)
Centre8, outlined three stages;
The university seeking accreditation must submit an
1. Academic Stage which is undertaken at application to the NCHE, Uganda's regulatory authority
universities and focused on foundational legal for higher education. The application must include;
knowledge.
o Institutional profile (ownership, mission,
2. Professional Stage which is institutional governance, physical location, etc.)
training (e.g., at the LDC) and supervised
o Proposed academic programs (e.g.,
practice.
Bachelor of Laws (LLB))
3. Continuing Legal Education which is ongoing
o Curriculum structure and content
learning for practicing lawyers to remain
professionally competent. o Staff qualifications and recruitment
plans
Holding of the court emphasized the need for all stages
as discussed above to uphold high ethical and o Facilities, including libraries, lecture
professional standards. halls, and moot courts.
Regulation of Legal Education 2. Fulfillment of Basic Requirements
Legal education is regulated by two key bodies; The NCHE evaluates whether the institution fulfills the
following key requirements;
1. National Council for Higher Education
(NCHE) The institution must be registered as a university.
Mandated under the Universities and Other Tertiary Adequate governing structures, such as a university
Institutions Act9 to accredit universities and law council and faculty boards.
programs.
Sufficient facilities such as classrooms, libraries, IT
2. Law Council systems, and moot courts for law students.
Oversees professional legal training and ensures ethical Lecturers and professors with credentials in law.
standards under the Advocates Act10
Compliance with NCHE guidelines for law education
Asiimwe Alex Byaruhanga v. LDC & Anor 11 where programs, including core courses (e.g., constitutional
undergraduate law programs are regulated by the NCHE, law, criminal law, etc.). 0745500500
while professional education is overseen by the Law
Council it was that the NCHE must consult the Law 3. Site Inspection
Council in accrediting universities to ensure alignment NCHE conducts a physical inspection of the university
with professional standards. premises to verify the information submitted. The
Steps to becoming a fully accredited law institution in inspection focuses on infrastructure adequacy, safety
Uganda standards, and the suitability of facilities for legal
education.

8
(Civil Application No. 18 of 2005)
9 11
cap 262 (Misc. Cause No. 267 of 2017)
10
295
Page 8 of 22
 JURISPRUDENCE 1 SUMMARY RESEARCHED AND COMPILED BY MOSES YAZAAMA AND NALUBEGA ROSE

4. Approval of Academic Programs by NCHE stressed the need to instill a sense of professional
responsibility in law students.
The law program must undergo evaluation to ensure it
meets academic and professional standards. The NCHE b. Accreditation Issues
assesses the proposed curriculum, including coursework,
Some universities teach law without proper
credit hours, practical training (e.g., internships), and co-
accreditation. In Asiimwe Alex Byaruhanga & Ors v.
curricular activities (e.g., moot court competitions).
Law Council & Ors12 where only universities
5. Consultation with the Uganda Law Council (ULC) accredited by the NCHE and approved by the Law
Council can offer law degrees. It was found that Gulu
The Uganda Law Council, which oversees the legal
and Cavendish Universities were found to have valid
profession, plays a crucial role in accrediting law
accreditations. A dispute between Cavendish University
programs. The council ensures that the university’s law
Uganda (CUU) and the Rwanda Higher Education
graduates are eligible for admission to the Law
Council (HEC) prevented graduates from finding
Development Centre (LDC) for the Postgraduate
jobs. The HEC denied an application for equivalence,
Diploma in Legal Practice (a requirement to practice law
saying that CUU did not meet accreditation requirements
in Uganda). ULC approval confirms that the law
in Uganda.
program aligns with the professional standards for legal
practice. c. Regulatory Overlap

6. Provisional Accreditation Confusion exists between the mandates of the NCHE

and the Law Council regarding undergraduate law
If the university meets the NCHE and ULC standards, it
programs and the solution is collaboration and joint
is granted provisional accreditation. This allows the
inspections by both bodies to ensure quality standards.
institution to begin offering the law program while being
subject to periodic monitoring and evaluation. d. Resource Limitations

7. Full Accreditation Inadequate reference materials, outdated libraries, and

lack of qualified teaching staff undermine legal
After a successful track record of offering the program
education. In Justice Kalinda v. Attorney General13
(usually over a set probationary period), the university
where the court held that access to adequate resources is
can apply for full accreditation. NCHE and ULC review
essential for maintaining educational standards.
the institution's performance, student outcomes, and
adherence to standards. Quality of Legal Education In Uganda

8. Periodic Monitoring and Renewal a. Overcrowding and Competition

Even after full accreditation, the university must undergo High student admissions strain facilities and reduce the
periodic reviews by NCHE and ULC to maintain its quality of training. Institutions compete to attract
status. Any deviation from the set standards may result students, sometimes compromising standards.
in suspension or withdrawal of accreditation.
b. Practical Deficiencies
Challenges in Legal Education In Uganda.
Curricula focus heavily on theory, neglecting practical
a. Lack of Ethical and Professional Standards skills like advocacy, drafting, and courtroom procedures.

Many law graduates lack a strong foundation in Recommendations to this can be through;
professional ethics. The World Bank Report (1995)

12 13
(Misc. Cause No. 269 of 2017) (HCT-00-CV-CS-0148-2018)
Page 9 of 22
 JURISPRUDENCE 1 SUMMARY RESEARCHED AND COMPILED BY MOSES YAZAAMA AND NALUBEGA ROSE

Introduce moot court competitions and internships. FUNDAMENTAL LEGAL CONCEPTIONS AS

Establish partnerships with international universities for APPLIED IN REASONING
knowledge exchange.
Legal Reasoning Legal reasoning is the process by
c. Fraud and Forgery which judges and legal professionals interpret and apply
legal principles to factual circumstances in order to
Some students and professionals forge academic
resolve disputes15. It serves as the foundation of judicial
documents, jeopardizing the credibility of legal
decision-making and legal interpretation. For legal
education. In Justice Kalinda v. Attorney General14 it
systems to function effectively, legal reasoning must
was held that academic integrity must be upheld to
remain consistent, logical, and clear. Legal reasoning is
protect the legal profession’s credibility.
influenced by frameworks that help in categorizing
Curriculum and Assessment relationships between individuals, the state, and other
entities within the law.
 Examinations should focus on analytical
reasoning rather than rote learning. One influential thinker in this field was Wesley
Newcomb Hohfeld, a legal scholar whose analytical
 Law students should also study related framework on legal relations has greatly shaped legal
disciplines (e.g., economics, sociology) to theory and reasoning, especially in common law
understand the broader societal implications of jurisdictions like Uganda.
law.
Wesley Newcomb Hohfeld and His Contributions to
8. Infrastructure and Affordability Legal Theory
a. Financial Barriers Hohfeld sought to bring clarity to legal reasoning by
High tuition fees limit access to legal education for introducing a systematic classification of legal rights and
many students. duties, which were often used interchangeably and
imprecisely by judges and scholars. His work
Solution: Flexible tuition policies and scholarships to highlighted the importance of distinguishing between
make education more accessible. different legal concepts to promote clear judicial
b. Outdated Infrastructure reasoning.

 Many institutions lack modern facilities, such as Hohfeld’s framework remains relevant in various legal
digital libraries and updated learning resources. contexts, including contract disputes, property law, and
constitutional law. It simplifies the complex web of legal
9. Practical Training and Continuous Learning relations into eight fundamental conceptions, organized
into pairs of correlatives and opposites.
 Institutions must emphasize practical skills to
prepare students for real-world legal challenges. Hohfeld's Analytical Framework
 Continuous legal education is vital for both Hohfeld's analytical framework is composed of eight
faculty and professionals to stay updated on fundamental legal conceptions, divided into four pairs of
evolving legal trends. In Pius Niwagaba v. correlatives (rights-duties, privileges-no-rights, powers-
LDC (2005) it was held that practical training is liabilities, immunities-disabilities) and their opposites.
a core requirement for professional legal Each pair represents specific legal relationships between
education and must be enforced at all levels.

14 15
(HCT-00-CV-CS-0148-2018) 2nd Edition
Page 10 of 22
 JURISPRUDENCE 1 SUMMARY RESEARCHED AND COMPILED BY MOSES YAZAAMA AND NALUBEGA ROSE

individuals or entities, providing a structured method for An immunity is a legal protection that prevents another
interpreting and applying legal principles. party from altering one’s legal relations, while a
disability means that the other party is incapable of
1. Rights and Duties
altering those relations. In constitutional law, public
A right is a legal entitlement that one party has, while a officials may have immunity from prosecution for
duty is the corresponding obligation imposed on another actions taken in their official capacity. This immunity
party. Rights and duties are correlative, meaning one creates a corresponding disability on others, preventing
cannot exist without the other. For instance, in contract them from prosecuting the official for those actions.
law, a party has a right to expect performance, and the
Clarification of Confusing Terminology
other party has a duty to fulfill it.
One of Hohfeld’s key contributions was clarifying the
Under the Contracts Act16 (Section 9), once a valid
distinction between "rights" and other legal terms such
contract is formed, one party's right to demand
as "privileges," "powers," and "immunities." In everyday
performance corresponds with the other party’s duty to
legal discourse, these terms were often used
perform. In Nsimbe Holdings Ltd v Attorney General,
interchangeably, leading to confusion. Hohfeld's
the failure of the government to fulfill its contractual
framework helps legal professionals use precise
duty violated Nsimbe's right to payment, emphasizing
terminology, ensuring consistent and logical reasoning.
the interdependence of rights and duties.
For example, distinguishing between a right to cross
2. Privileges and No-Rights land (imposing a duty on others) versus a privilege to
use one's own land (without imposing any duties on
A privilege is a legal freedom to act without imposing a others) is crucial in property law. The Land Act 18 in
duty on anyone else e.g diplomats, presidents, judicial Uganda embodies these distinctions by outlining the
officers under Art 12817, while a no-right means that rights and privileges of landowners.
another party has no claim to interfere with that
privilege. Privileges and no-rights are also correlative. In The Importance of Hohfeld’s Framework in
Kivumbi v Attorney General, the Constitutional Court Ugandan Law
struck down a law requiring police approval for public
Hohfeld’s framework is especially important in Ugandan
gatherings, reinforcing citizens' privilege to assemble
law, which operates under the common law system. It
without interference.
helps in understanding and resolving issues in contract
3. Powers and Liabilities law, property law, and constitutional law by providing
clear distinctions between various legal relations. For
A power is the legal ability of one party to alter the legal instance, the Ugandan Constitution protects individual
relations of another, while a liability is the rights, such as property rights, but these rights impose
corresponding susceptibility to having one's legal corresponding duties on the state not to interfere
relations changed. Example in the context of contract arbitrarily. Hohfeld's systematic breakdown of legal
law, a party may have the power to terminate a contract, relations ensures that legal professionals in Uganda can
thereby altering the legal relationship with the other analyze disputes with greater precision, whether they
party. This alteration imposes a liability on the other involve contractual rights, privileges in land use, or
party to accept the legal change. immunities from legal action.
4. Immunities and Disabilities Hohfeld's Framework and Legal Reasoning in
Ugandan Jurisprudence

16 18
Cap 284 Cap 236
17
1995 Constitution as amended.
Page 11 of 22
 JURISPRUDENCE 1 SUMMARY RESEARCHED AND COMPILED BY MOSES YAZAAMA AND NALUBEGA ROSE

Hohfeld's framework provides a structured way of government’s duty to fulfill its obligations. This case
analyzing legal concepts such as rights, duties, illustrates the correlation between rights and duties in
privileges, powers, liabilities, immunities, and contract law.
disabilities. This analytical approach is highly applicable
• Tort Law. The framework is also significant in tort law.
in Ugandan law, from constitutional law to contract, tort,
In Muwonge v Attorney General, the court held the
and property law. Immunities and Disabilities
government liable for a police officer’s actions,
In Hohfeld’s framework, immunities refer to the reinforcing the duty not to harm others. Hohfeld's idea of
protection from legal changes by others, while correlating duties and rights underpins the reasoning in
disabilities denote the incapacity to alter someone else's tort cases involving negligence and compensation.
legal position.
• Property Law. Hohfeld's framework helps in
Example of Immunities in Uganda: understanding ownership rights, easements, and land use
under Ugandan property law. The Land Act guarantees
Presidential Immunity: Article 9819 grants the sitting
landowners the right to exclusive possession, correlating
President immunity from legal proceedings while in
with others' duty to respect that right. The concept of
office. This was significant in Besigye v Museveni &
immunities is reflected in laws protecting culturally
Electoral Commission, where the courts held that the
significant lands or public-use lands from alteration.
President could not be prosecuted during his tenure.
• Constitutional Law. Hohfeld’s distinctions between
Diplomatic Immunity. The Vienna Convention, to which
powers, immunities, and disabilities are crucial in
Uganda is a party, exempts diplomats from local
balancing governmental authority and individual rights.
prosecution, demonstrating immunity in international
For instance, Attorney General v Susan Kigula and
relations.
417 Others dealt with the death penalty, weighing the
Example of Disabilities in Uganda government’s power to impose it against individuals'
right to be free from inhuman punishment.
Minors. Under Section 10 of the Contracts Act20, minors
are under a legal disability when entering into contracts, Other Scholarly Views on Legal Reasoning
as contracts with minors are voidable except for
• Hans Kelsen viewed legal concepts as tools for
necessities. This protects minors from exploitation.
regulating behavior through legal norms. He defined
Mental Incapacity21: The Mental Treatment Act legal sanctions, obligations, rights, and liabilities in
provides legal disability for individuals with mental precise terms, offering a systematic analysis of how laws
illnesses, preventing them from managing their property motivate or prevent certain actions.
or entering binding contracts, as seen in Kasule v
Application in our jurisprudence
Uganda Development Bank, where a contract was
voidable due to the appellant’s mental incapacity. Kelsen's focus on legal obligations and liability relates to
how Uganda’s laws enforce contractual and tortious
Application of Hohfeld's Framework in Various
duties. For example, in tort law, when a breach of duty
Areas of Ugandan Law
occurs, as in Muwonge v Attorney General, the
• Contract Law. Hohfeld's distinction between rights and concept of liability becomes crucial in determining
duties is evident in the Contracts Act. For example, in compensation.
Nsimbe Holdings Ltd v Attorney General, the
• John Austin and the Positivist Jurists focus on legal
plaintiff’s right to payment was matched by the
rights as interests protected by law, distinguishing them

19 21
1995 Constitution as amended. Also, Section 11 Of the Contracts Acts is well elaborate on
20
Cap 286 the same.
Page 12 of 22
 JURISPRUDENCE 1 SUMMARY RESEARCHED AND COMPILED BY MOSES YAZAAMA AND NALUBEGA ROSE

from moral or natural rights. This concept applies According to the Oxford Advanced Learner’s
broadly in Ugandan law, where rights are enforced by Dictionary23, Ubuntu represents a philosophy of
the legal system rather than by moral or religious sympathy, compassion, and benevolence, extending not
standards. only to humans but also to animals and the environment.
In the African Journal of Social Work24, Ubuntu is
• Jeremy Bentham critiqued the command theory of
defined as a "collection of values and practices" guiding
law and classified legal mandates into commands,
people of African origin to live in harmony with one
prohibitions, non-commands, and permissions. His
another.
views on liberty the right to act freely where the law
does not forbid—are reflected in Ugandan legal Evolution of Ubuntu Bulamu
protections of individual freedoms, particularly in public
The origins of Ubuntu are rooted in African traditional
and property law. For example, Bentham’s ideas of
philosophy, where it was deeply embedded in
corroborated powers are evident in cases like Uganda v
governance, justice, and social interactions. Its principles
Fabiano, where self-defense was justified by the right to
emphasized shared responsibility, moral obligation, and
inflict harm under certain
collective decision-making. Historically, Ubuntu guided
In conclusion, Hohfeld’s framework, along with the community-based dispute resolution and governance,
insights of Kelsen, Austin, and Bentham, provides a prioritizing restoration and reconciliation over punitive
foundation for understanding legal reasoning in Ugandan justice.
jurisprudence. The concepts of rights, duties,
Ubuntu evolved as a unifying ethos across various
immunities, liabilities, and powers are not merely
African societies, including;
theoretical but actively shape how Ugandan courts
interpret and apply the law across various legal domains.  South Africa. Ubuntu gained global recognition
By recognizing the interplay of these legal constructs, during post-apartheid reconciliation efforts,
Ugandan jurisprudence ensures a structured, fair, and prominently in the Truth and Reconciliation
consistent legal system that protects both governmental Commission led by Archbishop Desmond Tutu.
functions and individual rights. S v Makwanyane and Another25 decided by
the South African Constitutional Court,
CONCEPT OF UBUNTU BULAMU
abolished the death penalty for violating the
Ubuntu, derived from the Nguni Bantu term, translates constitutional rights to life, dignity, and equality.
to "humanity" or "being human." It embodies The court invoked the principle of Ubuntu,
compassion, interconnectedness, and collective well- emphasizing reconciliation, humanity, and the
being. The phrase "Ubuntu Bulamu" emphasizes interconnectedness of people, as opposed to
relational humanity, often expressed as “I am because retributive justice. Justice Mokgoro highlighted
we are, and we are because I am.” This highlights the that Ubuntu, rooted in African jurisprudence,
mutual dependence and shared humanity of individuals values compassion and restorative justice,
within a community. Mpanga F K22 once said we shall making the death penalty incompatible with
never develop until we develop a central nervouse these principles. The case remains a cornerstone
system that feels each other’s pain. Thus, reinforcing the in promoting human dignity in African legal
concept of Ubuntu. systems.

22 25
Politics of common sense (CCT3/94) [1995] ZACC 3; 1995 (3) SA 391 (CC); 1995 (6)
23
(10th Edition) BCLR 665 (CC).
24
(2020)
Page 13 of 22
 JURISPRUDENCE 1 SUMMARY RESEARCHED AND COMPILED BY MOSES YAZAAMA AND NALUBEGA ROSE

 Zimbabwe. Ubuntu influenced land ownership  Justice and Fairness: Resolving conflicts
customs and dispute resolution. through reconciliation rather than punishment.

 Uganda and Malawi. Ubuntu shaped customary  Shared Responsibility: Encouraging collective
practices like marriage, inheritance, and action for societal progress.
community solidarity.
Ubuntu challenges the individualism prevalent in
In the 20th century, Ubuntu transitioned from an Western philosophies, advocating instead for a
unwritten moral code to a recognized legal and communal approach to life and law.
philosophical principle, integrated into constitutional and
Application of Ubuntu in our Ugandan
judicial frameworks.
Jurisprudence
Maxims of Ubuntu Bulamu
Ubuntu Bulamu's values resonate deeply with Ugandan
Ubuntu principles are founded on three core maxims, as legal principles, particularly in customary law and
highlighted by Stanlake J.W26.: constitutional provisions well elucidated below;

1. Affirmation of Humanity: Recognizing and A. Recognition in Customary Law

respecting the humanity of others.
Uganda recognizes customary law under Section 15 of
2. Interconnectedness: Building relationships and the Judicature Act 2013. Customary law must align with
fostering mutual respect. justice, morality, and constitutional principles, reflecting
Ubuntu’s values of fairness and human dignity. For
3. Moral Obligation: Prioritizing collective
example the Customary Marriages Registration Act28
welfare over individual gain.
respects customary marriage practices, emphasizing
Justice Albie Sachs in S v. Makwanyane27 identified community consent and shared responsibility.
Ubuntu as the foundation of social solidarity and
B. Prohibition of Torture and Degrading Treatment
reconciliation, emphasizing that "a person is a person
through others." Ubuntu's emphasis on human dignity aligns with Article
2429, which prohibits torture, cruel, and inhumane
Archbishop Desmond Tutu, a key proponent of
treatment. The case of Salvatory Abuki v. Attorney
Ubuntu, described it as a philosophy emphasizing
General showcased this principle when the court
"shared humanity and interdependence," where acts of
deemed banishment for witchcraft unconstitutional, as it
kindness and respect affirm one’s humanity. He
violated human dignity.
Championed Ubuntu as a tool for reconciliation and
social cohesion. C. Right to Fair Hearing

Core Principles of Ubuntu Bulamu Ubuntu supports the constitutional guarantee of fair
hearing under Article 28, which ensures that individuals
 Human Dignity: Every individual deserves
are given the opportunity to defend themselves before
respect and fair treatment.
judgment. This principle was reinforced in cases
 Solidarity and Compassion: Promoting advocating for due process and humane treatment.
communal well-being and harmony.
D. Guidance in Judicial Decisions

26 27
Stanlake J.W. (2012). Ubuntuism: A Zimbabwean Supra
28
Indigenous Political Philosophy. Midlands State University Cap 146
29
Press, Zimbabwe. 1995 Constitution of Uganda
Page 14 of 22
 JURISPRUDENCE 1 SUMMARY RESEARCHED AND COMPILED BY MOSES YAZAAMA AND NALUBEGA ROSE

Although Ubuntu is not explicitly codified in Uganda’s often focusing on maintaining social harmony
Constitution, its values are reflected in national within the community.
objectives, particularly Objective III, which promotes
3. Conflicting Parties. The individuals or groups
unity, peace, and cultural protection. These align with
who are involved in the dispute and seek a
Ubuntu’s ethos of communal harmony and social justice.
resolution.
E. Influence on Reconciliation and Restorative
Reasons for the Rise of Popular Justice
Justice
Several factors have contributed to the need for popular
Ubuntu’s reconciliation-focused approach has influenced
justice in Uganda:
mediation and restorative justice mechanisms in Uganda.
Traditional justice systems, like the Acholi Mato Oput, 1. Delays in the Formal Justice System. Backlogs
emphasize healing and community restoration, echoing of cases due to a shortage of judges, lengthy
Ubuntu’s principles. procedures and frequent adjournments and
complex legal processes, particularly in civil
Thus Ubuntu Bulamu, it is rooted in African philosophy,
cases.
serves as a guiding principle for human dignity,
solidarity, and justice. In Uganda, its principles permeate 2. Limitations of Formal Courts. Formal courts
constitutional and customary laws, shaping governance may lack the expertise to handle certain matters,
and dispute resolution. Ubuntu’s integration into modern such as customary practices and involving local
jurisprudence underscores its relevance in promoting experts can enhance the understanding and
fairness, reconciliation, and societal progress. By resolution of such cases.
blending tradition with formal legal structures, Ubuntu
offers a unique approach to justice that fosters unity and 3. Preference for Reconciliation. Popular justice
shared humanity. often prioritizes reconciliation over retribution,
aiming to restore relationships and prevent
CONCEPT OF POPULAR JUSTICE further conflict. This approach contrasts with the
punitive nature of traditional legal systems.
Popular justice, also known as lay justice, is a legal
theory that emphasizes the involvement of ordinary 4. Accessibility and Cost. In some areas, formal
citizens in the administration of justice. It aims to courts may be geographically distant or
promote reconciliation and rehabilitation rather than inaccessible. Popular justice mechanisms often
solely focusing on retribution for the victim. This offer a more convenient and affordable option
approach aligns with democratic principles, empowering for dispute resolution.
the people to play a role in the justice system.

Ideal Model of Popular Justice Features of Popular Justice

The ideal model of popular justice involves three key  Involvement of Ordinary Citizens. Popular
actors; justice emphasizes the active participation of the
1. The State. The state, through formal courts, common people in the administration of justice,
aims to resolve interpersonal conflicts using especially in areas with limited legal resources.
established legal procedures.
 Promotion of Reconciliation. This approach
2. Informal Institutions. These institutions, such aligns with Article 126(2)(d) of the Constitution
as community leaders or elders, prioritize of the Republic of Uganda, which encourages
reconciliation between the parties involved, courts to promote reconciliation between parties.

Page 15 of 22
 JURISPRUDENCE 1 SUMMARY RESEARCHED AND COMPILED BY MOSES YAZAAMA AND NALUBEGA ROSE

 Flexible Procedures. Popular justice often OJECTIVE. Objective II, fundamental human rights
employs informal and flexible procedures, such under Chapter 4 of the Constitution and promotion of
as alternative dispute resolution, plea bargaining, the democratic principle under Objective II.
and local council courts.
Protection of Rights. The Bill of Rights in principle -
 Trial by Assessors. In some cases, citizens may settlement of Ubuntu. Botswana has a feature of
be involved as assessors in formal court reconciliation. Utilization of people in the justice
proceedings, providing input and local process, the High Court can sit in its local laws as
knowledge to the decision-making process. adjudicator in every civil law. Rule 4(1) of the
Judicature Act 32. Courts sit in local laws as adjudicators.
Historical Development of Popular Justice
Further Section 26 of the People's Justice Act 2013, has
Popular justice has its roots in the socialist movements been incorporated to empower officials and arbitrators to
of the 20th century, particularly those inspired by the decide some cases especially those of a civil nature and
ideas of Lenin30 and Mao Zedong31. These ideologies their case because an arbitrator is entrusted as a judge
emphasized the role of the people in creating a just hypothetically high court. In EADB v. Zawa33, the court
society and resolving conflicts through collective action. held that the role of an arbitrator is ensuring that there is
During the Cold War, socialist countries such as the the solution of any dispute; under Article 21, all persons
Soviet Union, China, and Cuba implemented various are equal before the law. Upholding the notion of
forms of popular justice. In Uganda, the concept gained equality; serve to narrow the disputes and curtail the
prominence during the 1980s, after the National remaining litigation. Twinomujuni, that it was
Resistance Movement (NRM) came to power in 1986. discriminatory in nature to which Court ruled dismissing
The NRM, influenced by socialist and revolutionary it. Junior Twinomujuni complained with our modern
ideologies, established Resistance Councils to empower concept of Equality and non-discrimination.
local communities and promote grassroots democracy.
Alternative Dispute Resolution. Parties to a dispute
These councils were tasked with resolving local
negotiate their own settlement with the help of an
disputes, administering justice, and implementing
intermediary who is neutral, impartial, and trained in the
development projects. While the RC system has
techniques of Alternative Dispute Resolution. It
undergone reforms and is now known as the Local
concentrates more on reconciliation between parties than
Government system, the principles of popular justice,
punishment and it gives parties a chance to choose an
including community participation, informal procedures,
arbitrator.
emphasis on reconciliation, and accessibility, continue to
shape the Ugandan legal landscape. Alternative dispute resolution mechanisms include:

Article 126(2)(d) of the Constitution of the Republic of 1. Arbitration: This is a mechanism provided for
Uganda has played a significant role in shaping the legal under Section 2734 where two parties agree upon
framework for popular justice in the country. It a neutral intermediary or third party usually
mandates that courts should promote reconciliation, trained in the field of concern to solve their
which aligns with the principles of popular justice. disputes without recourse to court. As a
requirement, the third party must be agreeable to
Applicability of the principles to Ugandan
both parties to ensure acceptability of the results
Jurisprudence.
from the arbitration to both parties. There are
two forms of arbitration that is to say court

30 33
1919 formation of the Soviet Comrade Courts. [1997-2000] 1 CLR 247
31 34
1949 adoption in China Judicature Act
32
2013
Page 16 of 22
 JURISPRUDENCE 1 SUMMARY RESEARCHED AND COMPILED BY MOSES YAZAAMA AND NALUBEGA ROSE

annexed arbitration and consensual arbitrations Acholi tradition of "Mato Oput" is a prominent
as provided for under Section 3 of the example, focusing on reconciliation and amnesty. This
Arbitration and Conciliation Act. The former is tradition involves mediation by traditional chiefs (rwodi)
referred by the court while the latter is as a result to resolve conflicts, including homicides. It emphasizes
of a pre-existing agreement. community participation and acknowledging
wrongdoing within a social context.
2. Mediation: This involves a 3rd party to assist
conflicting parties come to an agreement but Plea Bargaining. Defined as an agreement between the
does not necessarily require a result or solution. prosecution and the accused, where the accused pleads
Unlike arbitration and conciliation, mediation guilty in exchange for a reduced charge or a lenient
simply helps conflicting parties to come up with sentence. Promotes reconciliation and involves the
a solution Section 88(2) 35"provides that land accused in the justice process. Governed by the
disputes under customary tenure are permitted to Judicature (Plea Bargain) Rules 38.
be adjourned as long as court deems it fit that
Public Interest Litigation where legal actions brought
the case may be settled faster if referred to
to protect the rights of the public at large. Allows
mediation. Furthermore, the Judicature
individuals to initiate legal actions on behalf of others,
(commercial court division) mediation rules by
promoting public participation in justice. Based on
virtue of Rule 8 require that all matters that
Article 50(2)39.
come before the commercial court should first
be referred to mediation. Legal Aid provides legal assistance to financially
constrained individuals. Enhances access to justice and
3. Conciliation: This is where parties agree to a
encourages public participation. Implemented through
third party to help them come to a solution to
institutions like Justice Centers and legal aid clinics.
their grievances or conflicts. Conciliation only
Section 3 of the Poor Persons Defense Act Cap40
requires a 3rd party to assist the parties in an
provides that parliament shall provide for remuneration
independent and impartial manner to reach an
of legal representation provided to poor persons. Legal
amicable settlement of their dispute by virtue of
aid extends beyond representation by a lawyer in court
Section 53(1) of the Arbitration and
to include legal advice and assistance in both civil and
Conciliation Act 36.
criminal matters. Examples of institutions that have been
Court Assessors established and endorsed to provide legal aid include the
Muslim Centre for Justice and Law, Uganda Network on
These are court officials who usually 2 but not less than
Law, Ethics and HIV/AIDS, Law and Advocacy for
two are judicial officers on evidence given. These
Women in Uganda, Foundation for Human Rights
assessors are usually called to trials before the High
Initiative, LDC Legal Aid clinic, Uganda Christian
court, it was held that the requirement for the presence of
Lawyer Fraternity, Centre for Law and Peace, etc. Some
assessors at every trial is mandatory and Section 3 of
of the above legal aid firms are state-sponsored while
Trial on Indictments 37.
others are not.
Traditional Justice Mechanisms
Amicus Curiae (Experts). In Mundwa v Central Nile
The Constitution of Uganda recognizes the existence of Transportation Association41, an amicus curiae, also
traditional institutions led by traditional leaders. The referred to as a friend of the court, is not a party to the

35 39
Land Act Cap 236 Constitution of Uganda
36 40
Cap 5. Cap 22
37 41
Cap 25 miscellaneous civil revision of 2017
38
2016
Page 17 of 22
 JURISPRUDENCE 1 SUMMARY RESEARCHED AND COMPILED BY MOSES YAZAAMA AND NALUBEGA ROSE

case but assists a court by offering information that has a To fully grasp the concept of law in Uganda, it is crucial
bearing on the case. An amicus curiae should have the to consider its historical development. Uganda's legal
relevant expertise or experience in a subject matter and system draws influence from various sources, including
should be independent. An amicus curiae can be customary law, English common law, and constitutional
important and relevant when the court is of the opinion provisions. The colonial legacy greatly shaped Uganda's
that the matter before it requires some kind of expertise legal landscape, and efforts have been made to
and his/her participation must be in the wider interest of harmonize traditional practices with laws inherited from
public justice. Thus, this takes us to opinion evidence by the British colonial era.
virtue of Section 43 of the Evidence Act42.
Definitions
In conclusion, the manifesto applicability or popular  Law;
justice in Uganda has been haunted with the question of
how much control the state should have in the informal Austinian Definition. A command issued by a
justice structures. It can be said that community sovereign to a subject, backed by the threat of a sanction.
participation and reconciliation play an important role in Salmond's Definition. The body of principles
the administration of justice in light of the 1 failure of the recognized and applied by the state in the administration
mainstream justice systems. of justice.

Roscoe Pound's Sociological Definition as a body of

CONCEPTS OF STATE, LAW AND
precepts governing human conduct, formulated and
INDIVIDUAL applied by the state as a means of achieving social ends.
Uganda, a landlocked country in East Africa, offers a  State:
compelling context for studying the concept of law and
how it relates to the state and individuals. This essay A political organization of a society, or a community of
explores the legal framework and its practical persons permanently occupying a definite territory,
application in Uganda, highlighting the key elements independent of external control, and possessing an
that govern the relationship between the state and its organized government.
citizens. Examining the role of law as an instrument for
 Individuals:
maintaining order, ensuring justice, and safeguarding
individual rights, this essay aims to enhance our In law, an individual is a natural person, as distinguished
understanding of legal dynamics in Uganda. from a legal entity such as a corporation or partnership.
This means that an individual is a human being who has
John Stuart Mill proposed an attractive principle that the capacity to have rights and obligations under the law.
governs the relationship between the state and the
individual. He argued that: Individuals as Beneficiaries of Law

"The only purpose for which power can be rightly Individuals are the primary beneficiaries of law. Law
exercised over any member of a civilized community, protects their rights and liberties, and it provides them
against his will, is to prevent harm to others. His own with a framework for resolving disputes and promoting
good, either physical or moral, is not a sufficient justice. For example, individuals have the right to a fair
warrant." trial if they are accused of a crime. They also have the
right to sue someone for breach of contract if the other
Historical Context party fails to uphold their obligations.

42
Cap 8
Page 18 of 22
 JURISPRUDENCE 1 SUMMARY RESEARCHED AND COMPILED BY MOSES YAZAAMA AND NALUBEGA ROSE

The Importance of Law fair process for resolving disputes and punishing
criminals.
Law is important for the following reasons:
4. Deter Crime and Protect Public Safety as
 Maintaining Order. Law provides a framework
laws clearly define criminal offenses and
for social order and stability, preventing chaos
prescribe punishments. This deters individuals
and anarchy.
from committing crimes and helps maintain
 Protecting Rights. Law safeguards individual public safety.
rights and liberties, ensuring that everyone is
5. Promotes Economic Prosperity as laws create
treated fairly and justly.
a stable environment for businesses to operate
 Resolving Disputes. Law provides mechanisms and invest. They protect intellectual property
for resolving disputes peacefully, such as rights and promote fair competition.
through courts and alternative dispute resolution.
6. Protects the Environment as laws regulate
 Promoting Justice. Law aims to ensure that pollution and other environmental hazards. They
justice is served and that wrongdoers are held protect endangered species and natural
accountable. resources.

 Facilitating Economic Development. Law 7. Promotes Public Health and Safety as laws
provides a stable legal environment that regulate food safety, product safety, and traffic
encourages investment and economic growth. safety. They require businesses to provide safe
working conditions for employees.
The Role of Law in Society
8. Protects Consumers as laws protect consumers
Law plays a crucial role in shaping society and from fraud and abuse. They regulate the sale of
governing human behavior. It provides a framework for goods and services and prevent deceptive
order, justice, and fairness. This essay explores the marketing practices.
various functions of law and its importance in modern
society. 9. Promotes Social Justice and Equality as laws
prohibit discrimination on the basis of race,
Functions of Law religion, gender, sexual orientation, and other
1. Provides Order and Stability as without laws, factors. They promote equal opportunities for
society would be chaotic and all.
unpredictable.Laws define acceptable and 10. Resolves Disputes Peacefully as laws provide a
unacceptable behavior, ensuring a sense of order framework for resolving disputes through
and predictability. negotiation, mediation, or arbitration. This helps
2. Protects Individual Rights and Freedoms as avoid violence and conflict.
laws safeguard fundamental rights such as the The Concept of Law, State, and Individuals in
right to life, liberty, and property. They also Uganda
protect freedoms of speech, religion, and
assembly. The concept of law, state, and individuals has practical
applicability in various aspects of Ugandan society,
3. Promotes Justice and Fairness as laws ensure including governance, human rights, and access to
equal treatment for all, regardless of race, justice.
religion, gender, or social status. They provide a
1. Governance

Page 19 of 22
 JURISPRUDENCE 1 SUMMARY RESEARCHED AND COMPILED BY MOSES YAZAAMA AND NALUBEGA ROSE

Separation of Powers. The Ugandan Constitution Providing Public Goods and Services. The state
establishes a system of government based on the provides essential services like education, healthcare,
principles of separation of powers, with the executive, and infrastructure.
legislative, and judicial branches.
Promoting Economic Development. The state creates a
43
Rule of Law . The rule of law is a fundamental conducive environment for economic growth and
principle in Uganda, ensuring that everyone is subject to development.
the law, including those in power.
INDIVIDUALS AND THEIR RELATIONSHIP
2. Human Rights WITH THE STATE

Protection of Rights. The Ugandan Constitution44 Individuals are the fundamental units of society. They
guarantees a wide range of human rights, including the have rights and responsibilities, and their relationship
right to life, liberty, and security of person. with the state is governed by law. The state, in turn, has
a duty to protect the rights and interests of its citizens.
Access to Justice45. The legal system in Uganda
provides mechanisms for individuals to seek justice and The Role of Law in Uganda
redress for wrongs.
The Ugandan legal system is a blend of customary law,
Law plays a vital role in shaping society and protecting English common law, and statutory law. It has evolved
individual rights. By understanding the functions of law over time to reflect the country's unique cultural and
and its application in Uganda, we can better appreciate historical context.
its importance in ensuring a just and equitable society.
Key Features of the Ugandan Legal System
The Interplay of Law, State, and Individuals in
 Separation of Powers. The Constitution of
Uganda
Uganda establishes a system of checks and
The Concept of Law `balances, dividing power among the executive,
legislative, and judicial branches.
Law, in its broadest sense, is a system of rules and
regulations that govern human behavior. It provides a  Rule of Law. The principle of the rule of law
framework for social order, justice, and the protection of ensures that everyone, including government
individual rights. officials, is subject to the law.

The State and Its Role  Human Rights. The Constitution guarantees a
wide range of human rights, including the right
The state is a political entity that exercises sovereignty
to life, liberty, and security of person; freedom
over a defined territory. Its primary functions include;
of expression; and freedom of assembly.
Maintaining Law and Order. The state enforces laws
 Access to Justice. The legal system aims to
and regulations to ensure social stability.
provide equal access to justice for all citizens,
Protecting Rights. The state safeguards individual regardless of their social or economic status.
rights and freedoms, such as the right to life, liberty, and
Challenges and Opportunities
property.
While Uganda has made significant progress in
developing its legal system, challenges remain. These

43 45
Article 2 (Supremacy of the Constitution) Article 50 of the 1995 Constitution as amended.
44
Chapter VI
Page 20 of 22
 JURISPRUDENCE 1 SUMMARY RESEARCHED AND COMPILED BY MOSES YAZAAMA AND NALUBEGA ROSE

include corruption, inefficient judicial processes, and societal stability. For example, laws against theft and
limited access to justice for marginalized groups. To assault protect property and individual security.
address these challenges, it is essential to strengthen the
2. Adapting to Societal Needs
rule of law, promote good governance, and invest in the
Law evolves to meet societal demands. Max Weber49
legal infrastructure.
emphasized the need for laws to adapt to economic and
In conclusion, the interplay between law, state, and social transformations. The Children Act, Cap,
individuals is a complex and dynamic relationship. In amended to enhance child protection and welfare50,
Uganda, the legal system plays a crucial role in shaping reflects societal recognition of children’s rights. It
society, protecting rights, and promoting justice. By addresses issues like child labor, education, and abuse.
understanding the principles and mechanisms of the
3. Institutionalization and Internalization
Ugandan legal system, we can better appreciate its role
H.L.A. Hart51 discussed how law facilitates
in fostering a just and equitable society.
institutionalization of behavior patterns necessary for
TRANSFORMATION OF LAW IN societal progress. The Anti-Corruption Act,
DEVELOPING COUNTRIES institutionalizes anti-corruption measures, fostering
accountability and transparency in governance52.
Transformation refers to a shift or movement from one
state to another. John Paul Omony46 defines Law as a Tool of Progressive Social Change in
transformation as "a change or movement from one state Uganda
to another, especially one involving improvement"
1. Rule of Law and Separation of Powers
Social transformation involves significant changes in
A.V. Dicey53 asserted that the rule of law ensures
societal structures and institutions, often facilitated by equality before the law and prevents arbitrariness.
law. Article 254 establishes the rule of law. For example, in
Laws shape societal norms, ensure stability, and address Male Mabirizi v. Attorney General55, the judiciary
socio-economic challenges. This is well elaborated reviewed the removal of presidential term limits,
below; upholding constitutionalism.

Law as a Tool for Social Transformation 2. Human Rights Protection

Chapter Four of the Ugandan Constitution protects
1. Stability and Order in Society fundamental rights, including the prohibition of torture
Law promotes stability by regulating behavior and (Article 24). Lon L. Fuller56 stated that the purpose of
resolving disputes. Roscoe Pound47 argued that law law is to preserve human dignity. The Prohibition of
functions as a tool for social engineering, balancing Female Genital Mutilation Act, criminalizes harmful
competing societal interests. The Penal Code Act48, cultural practices, protecting women and girls.
defines offenses and prescribes punishments, fostering

46 51
(Omony, J. P., Key Issues in Jurisprudence: An In-depth (Hart, H.L.A., The Concept of Law, Oxford University Press,
Discourse on Jurisprudence, LawAfrica Publishing, 2006). 1961)
47 52
(Pound, R., Social Control Through Law, Yale University Also supported by the IGG Act section 7.
53
Press, 1942) (Dicey, A.V., Introduction to the Study of the Law of the
48
Cap 128 Constitution, Macmillan, 1885)
49 54
(Weber, M., Economy and Society: An Outline of 1995 Constitution of Uganda
55
Interpretive Sociology, University of California Press, 1978). Constitutional Appeal No. 2 of 2018
50 56
Section 3 (Fuller, L.L., The Morality of Law, Yale University Press,
1964)
Page 21 of 22
 JURISPRUDENCE 1 SUMMARY RESEARCHED AND COMPILED BY MOSES YAZAAMA AND NALUBEGA ROSE

3. Women’s Rights and Equality Moral Resistance. Societal values may resist
Catherine MacKinnon57 argued that law can dismantle progressive laws. For example, laws prohibiting
systemic gender discrimination. The Succession Act, polygamy face cultural opposition. The Marriage Act62,
affirms women’s inheritance rights. For example, in limits recognition of customary marriages.
Bamwite v. Nangobi, the court upheld a woman’s right
Economic Constraints. Thomas Piketty63 highlighted
to inherit property.
that inequality impedes law enforcement. The
4. Environmental Protection Education Act, addresses economic constraints by
Christopher D. Stone58 proposed that legal systems promoting universal education.
recognize environmental rights. The National
Ignorance and Illiteracy. uninformed citizens struggle
Environment Act, mandates environmental impact
to utilize legal protections effectively.
assessments to protect ecosystems. Section 112 requires
evaluations for any projects impacting the environment. As we conclude, Law is a potent instrument for societal
transformation, fostering equality, protecting rights, and
5. Economic Development and Investment
promoting development. Uganda’s legal framework
Amartya Sen emphasized the importance of inclusive
demonstrates significant progress in addressing societal
policies for development. The Investment Code Act,
challenges, though limitations persist. Continuous
incentivizes investments by offering tax holidays for
reform is essential to ensure laws align with societal
industries in priority sectors, fostering economic growth.
values and aspirations.
6. Public Health Regulations
Michel Foucault argued that laws regulating public
health reflect the state's responsibility to manage life.
The Public Health Act, empowered regulations during *****END*****
the COVID-19 pandemic under the Public Health
(Prevention of COVID-19) Rules59.

7. Social Order and Behavior

Emile Durkheim noted that laws mirror collective
societal values. The Domestic Violence Act,
criminalizes abuse, promoting family stability and social
order.

Limitations of Law as a Tool for Social

Transformation

Conflict of Interest. Karl Marx60 argued that laws

often serve elite interests. The Land Act61, illustrates
conflicts between customary land rights and statutory
laws favoring elites.

57 60
(MacKinnon, C., Toward a Feminist Theory of the State, (Marx, K., Das Kapital: Critique of Political Economy,
Harvard University Press, 1989) Penguin Books, 1976)
58 61
(Stone, C.D., Should Trees Have Standing? Oxford University Cap 236
62
Press, 1972) (Foucault, M., Discipline and Punish: The Birth of Cap 146
63
the Prison, Pantheon Books, 1977) (Piketty, T., Capital in the Twenty-First Century, Harvard
59
2020 University Press, 2014).

Page 22 of 22