Unit 10
Unit 10
TO ALGEBRA
Structure
Page Nos.
10.1 Introduction
Objectives
10.2 Why,Learn Algebra?
10.3 Learning Algebra
. 10.4 Usink Variables
Use In Formulae
Use In Equations
10.5 Summary
10.6 Comments On Exercises
INTRODUCTION
Over the past few weeks some of us did an informal survey among the people in our
neighbourhoods, regarding their attitude to algebra. We found that most school-children
dread mathematics in general, and algebra in particular. Many parents who spoke to us
regard it a credit to confess that they had been poor at algebra while in school. When asked
why they had done badly, most of them said that it was because doing algebra required them
to handle complicated formulae which are difficult to remember. Many of them also
wondered why algebra is taught in school, as they find it of no use.
Why do people have such a negative attitude to algebra? What can we do to improve the
situation? In this unit we try and answer these questions. We look at some ways of teaching
algebra that may make children algebra-friendly, and algebra child-friendly.
Children first meet algebra in the guise of 'generalised arithmetic'. In Sec. 10.2 we have
discussed what this means, as well as why it should be studied. We have particularly
stressed what generalisation means, and which generalisations are valid.
In the next section we focus on the concept of a variable. This concept is necessary for
learning and using the language of algebra, and is very difficult for children to understand.
We have listed some common errors children make because they have not understood the
concept and use of a variable. In this section we also suggest ways of slowly and carefully
leading children towards this concept.
In Sec.lO.4 we look at ways in which children are expected to use variables. They do so
when they apply formulae and while solving equations. While using variables, the usual
child applies certain thumb-rules mechanically, without understanding the algebra involved.
We suggest some teaching strategies that may improve the situation.
Algebra, and mathematics on the whole, is about generalisation. We have discussed aspects
of this in Unit 1, as well a s h this unit. Therefore, you may like to quickly glance through
Unit 1 before going through this unit.
Objectives
After reading this unit, you should be able to
describe the skills children develop while learning algebra;
suggest ways by which a child of Class 6 and above can learn to generalise arithmetical
principles;
identjfy common errors children make while dealing with variables;
I
I suggest strategies for communicating the concept of a variable to children;
describe ways of helping children use variables;
assess the effecti.venessof your teaching methods.
we can observe a patkrn in the product. This pattern helps us form a general rule about the
process of multiplication by 10, namely,
'To obtain the multiple of any number by 10, shift every digit of the number leftwards by
one place and put a zero in the ones place.'
As you had read in Unit 1, the abi7ifg to generalise from specific instances, and to specialise
from general relationships is an essential part of mathematical thinking. This mental ability
is not restricted to mathematics. We need it often in our day-to-day existence, for example,
when we build the concepts of an animal, blue, girl, round, etc.
Similarly, because of our ability to generalise from our daily experiences, we expect the sun
to rise in the East and set in the West every day, we accept that human beings are mortal,
and so on.
At this point, we need to think about the difference in the use of 'in general' in ordinary
language and in mathematics. When we use this term in English, we mean 'most of the
time', not necessarily in every case. For qxample, 'In general, the monsoons arrive in
Kerala by the end of May' is an accepted statement, even though it is not true in certain
years.
But, when we use 'in general' in mathematics, we mean that the statement that it is applied
to is true for all the cases for which the conditions are satisfied. Thus, 'In general, if the
rightmost digit in an integer is 5, then the integer is a multiple of 5' is acceptable
mathematically because it is true for all integers whose rightmost digit is 5. But the A number whos'efactors are only
1 and itself is called a prime
statement 'In general, prime numbers are odd' is not mathematically acceptable even though
number. Thus, 5 is prime, but 9
it is true for all primes except one, that is, the prime number 2. (Can you prove this?) . is not.
Similarly, the generalisation that all odd numbers are primes is not acceptable since, for
example, 9 is odd but it is not a prime number.
El) ~ i sthree
t general rules that you find in your day-to-day existence. Which of these
would be acceptable according to mathematical logic?
Let us now consider the skills children learn while studying algebra. As dhildre6 bet more
and more opportunities to generalise, in real-life and in mathematics, they gradually develop
s e v ~ r dabilities. For instance, they learn to look for common properties of tffemembers of a
set. They learn to look for general patterns and relationships, in mathematics as well as in
ofher fields. This develops their ability to deal with abstractions. They learn to think of, not
one individual member, but of the set as a whole. And, using the language of algebra helps
them to be kore logical, clear and precise in their way of thinking and in expressing rules
and relati9nships.
To appreciate a major reason for studying algebra, consider the following problems I riddles.
1. A number and half of it add up to 63. What is the number? (Such problbms were
given to Egyptians to solve as far back as 1700 BC.)
2. A.father is 30 years older than his son. 10 years ago the father's age was 4 times that
. of his son. How old is the father now?
3. 5 teas and 4 vadas cost Rs. 18.50. But 4 teas and 5 vadas cost Rs. 17.50. How much
does a tea cost?
4. When the price of coffee increased by 20%, a man reduced his coffee consumption by
20%. Has his expense increased or decreased, and by what percent?
5. Two numbers add up to 100 and their product is 2499. What are the numbers?
6. A car travels uphill at a speed of 40kmJhr and immediately returns downhill at 60
km/hr. What is the average speed of the car?
Let us assume the number to be 100. According to the information in the problem, 100 and
half of 100 should add up to 63. But it doesn't. So 100 doesn't work.
Let's try other numbers. In the following table we have done so, and given the sum in each
case.
None of these numbers are giving us the result. We would need to go through, don't know
how many numbers, before we finally get the right number, if at all.
Instead, why don't we just take a general number, call it x, and move frorn there? We know
that the sum of x and half of x is 63, that is, x + 112 x = 63,
that is, (312) x = 63,
that is, x = 63 x 213 multiplying both sides by
= 42.
How easily we got the number merely by using a general number x, instead of a series of
particular ones! This is an instance of the use of algebra for solving seemingly complicated
problems easily.
Yet another reason for studying algebra is FUN! Many games and puzzles in mathematics
have their solution in algebra. For instance, consider this think-of-a-number game:
Think of any 2-digit number. Interchange the digits. Add the new number to the original
one. Divide your answer by the sum of the digits of your original number. Now your
answer will be 11! (We have discussed the way such games work in Sec.lO.4.)
E3) List any other reasons you can think of for learning to generalisearithmetic.
By now, you would agree that children need to study algebra. You would also agree that they
should learn it through a process that they enjoy and which keeps them interested.
Unfortunately, the way most of us teach them algebra, leaves the children disinterested and
with several difficulties. Let us consider these difficulties and some ways of overcoming them.
Sometimes, of course, children may make false generalisations, like 'multiplication makes
bigger'. This is because they may have noticed it for positive numbers (2 x 3 is greater than
2, etc.). But you can ask them if it is always true. You could get them to test it for various
cases. Ask them what happens when one of the numbers is zero, for instance. When they
realise that their generalisation is not true in this case, they should learn to alter it -maybe
to 'multiplying any two non-zero numbers results in a bigger number'. Then you could ask
1
them to try it for fractions, say -. And so on.
2
In this way you could help children to learn to be careful while generalising, as well as to
alterldiscard generalisations that are not valid.
,-
E4) Give an example of a wrong mathematical generalisation made by'children. How
would you help them realise that it is false?
Algebra develops from a search for pattern, relationships and generalisation. The concept that
helps us to study general relationships is that of a variable. This is some letter (say, a,b,x,y,...)
that represents one or more numbers. This means,that in some cases the letter may represent
just one number (as in E2), and sometimes it may represent several numbers (e.g., if x+l is less
than 9, then x can be any number less than 8). So it can take varying values, and hence it is
called a variable.
Developing an understanding of 'variable' is crucial for developing an understanding of
algebra. This is where children face a major block. The statement 'Let x be a number' is
extremely difficult for a child to understand. Actually, this is not the first time a child is
faced with a letter that represents a number. Many textbooks for Class 4 and 5 take a sudden
jump from particular cases like 2 + 3 = 3 + 2 , 4 + 5 = 5 + 4, etc., to the general statement
'a+b = b+a for any two numbers a and b'. The child reacts very negatively to this, ignoring it
or building a mental block against such use of letters. Therefore, when children are
introduced to a variable, it isn't surprising that they rarely understand the concept.
Consequently, right from the time they begin studying algebra, upto the time that they can
manage to get rid of it, they gather misconceptions which lead to situations like the
following:
i) The child doesn't understand that the letter represents a number. So she ignores it.
For example, she says that 3x + 4 is 7.
ii) The child thinks that a letter represents some objects. For example, when 11-year-old
Rashmi was asked what p is in 7p, she said it was anything, like apples, or pencils, or
books.
iii) The child thinks that the letter represents only those objects whose names start with
that letter. For exwple, Amar insisted that the a in 3a could stand for apples, or
alligators, not for bananas "because. then it would have been 3b."
This notion of the child may be because of the short notation she has been using for
the units earlier (e.g., 3m for 3 metres).
iv) The child thinks that a letter stands for &particularnumber. For example, when Saba
was asked what x would be if x + 6 is less than 10, she said x = 1. When asked if there
were any other possibilities, she said there weren't.
V) Most children are confused by the representations like 2a, a3, etc. They don't
differentiatebetween, say a3 and 3a. Some write 5a2 when asked to add 3a and 2a.
vi) Many children don't know how to apply the laws governing the operations on letters.
Some write 3x + x + 5x = 8x, ignoring the numerical coefficient 1 of x. Some write
- a - an.
arn-n-m
There are many other errors that you must have come across. You can note them down
while doing the following exercise.
E5) list at least 3 other kinds of errors related to the concept and use of a variable that
children make.
How can we help rid children of such misconceptions? While planning any strategy for this,
we must remember to proceed slowly. We must remember that the concept of a variable is
not acquired in a huny and that the learner will go through several stages before arriving at.
the concept.
Before mapping out your strategy, you may Iike to read about what MS.
Acharya does in this
context.
Example 1: Ms. Acharya has been teaching mathematics to the children of Class 6 of a
municipal school for some years. Over this period, she has been carefully evaluating how
well she has been able to teach the children the concept of a variable. Each time, she uses
the feedback she gathers to modify her teaching strategy. At present she considen the
following one "successful".
Ms. Acharya believes that arriving at and understanding this stage is very difficult for
children. They struggle with this for quite a while. She encourages them to discuss their
ideas about what they think is happening. There are occasional arguments. But, with
patience and with repeated trials with different numbers, they accept this representation.
Then she asks them, "Now, if C%hotu (one of the kids there) eats 2 out of these mangoes,
how many will I have?". She, and the children, discuss this and conclude that their
answers of 53,43, etc., can also be written as
(the number of mangoes) + 5 - 2,
which is, (the number of mangoes) + 3.
She points out to them the tediousness of writing ,the long expression 'the number of Generalising
Arithmetic to Algebra
mangoes' each time, and asks them if there is a way out. She tells them that since she
doesn't know exactly how many there are, she can't replace the phrase by a specific number.
Could she possibly use a smaller sign for it? What if she calls the number n, and just writes
n instead of the whole phrase, where n can be any number? They usually agree to this. So
she writes n+3 on the blackboard, and simultaneously says that she has n+3 mangoes left
now.
"Now, suppose I add another box of mangoes of the same size. How many will I have?"
she asks. Involving children in thinking about this, she gradually gets them to write
n + n + 3
At this stage she prepares a table:
b
INo. of mangoes in a box 1 10 . 20 30 ..... n
No. of mangoes in 2 boxes 20 40 60 ...... n + n
No. of mangoes I have 23 43 63 ...... n + n + 3
Here She may ask, "Can we say definitely that the number of mangoes in the box is lo? or
20? or 30?" Through examples she guides them towards seeing that it may be anything -
15,25,47, ..., and that for any of these values they can find out 2n + 3, the number of
mangoes she finally has. Then she points out to them that the letter n that they are using for
showing the number of mangoes is a variable, because it can be any number.
She continues in this way, trying to get the children to think about the meaning and use of a
variable. To reinforce their understanding, she also does some examples like the following
ones with them.
i) The relation between a child's age and her mother's age: For instance, she tells them
that the mother's age is 6 years more than 5 times the child's age. Then she asks them
to discuss among themselves and tell her how they would show this relationship. (If
the child's age is taken as the variable x, then the mother's age, is (5 x x + 6).)
ii) The natural number immediately following a natural number: She asks them how they
would use symbols to show that the natural number immediately following any natural
number is got by adding 1 to it. (If n is the number, the next one is n + 1.)
iii) The number of sticks required to make triangles: She asks the children how many
sticks are used for making 1 triangle? 2 triangles that don't touch each other? and so
t on. She writes their answeis down in a table as below.
Then she asks them to give 10 different pairs of numbers that can be written in the box
and circle in 2 x 0 + 0= 17.
Ms. Acharya does several examples and exercises of this kind, off and on, through the
year, with them. In this way she feels that the children learn what a variable is.
E7) Create 3 more examples like the questions given above where relationships are
expressed ili terms of a variable.
Once children have become comfortable with the idea of a variable, they can be led towards
dealing with it wherever they need to. Let's see some ways of doing so.
Children don't need to be in Class 5 or 6 before they are exposed to formulae. Even '
children of Class 3 can learn to create and use formulae. For this we could'begin with
examples related to squares. We could ask children to draw squares of varying lengths
along the lines given on arithmetic paper (see Fig. 1). Then we could ask them to find the
corresponding perimeters. We could ask them to form a chart, like the one below.
I I I I I I I
Length of a square 1 unit 2 units 5 units ...... lo-units
. Pig. 1: A square of length 4 units
on arithmetic paper. Perimeter of the square 4 units 8 units 20 units ...... 40 units
The children should be asked to look at the results and try and come out with a rule relating
the length and the perimeter. We could guide them through discussions to obtain a rute. If a
child comes out with a wrong rule, we would need to discuss it in detail, including why it is
wrong. Again, thrpugh discussions we could lead them to the rule:
The perimeter of a square of length L is 4L.
We could, similarly, ask them to build a table and find the formula for the area of a square in
terms of the number of squares of the arithmetic paper.
Once children are comfortable with formulae involving one variable, we.could introduce
them to those for finding the perimeter and area of rectangles. In this case the formulae
involve two variables, an idea which children find difficult to understand. To help them, we' ,
could have discussions about why the length of a side of a rectangle is a variable. Once they
accept this, they could denote the length by L, say. Then we could ask, "Now, is the
breadth also a variable? Can I take itio be L? Why not? What happens if I do?" Let them
conclude that if the length and breadth are represented by the same letter, they would be
equal and the rectangle would be a square - not a general rectangle.
We could let them draw different rectangles on arithmetic paper to help them conclude that
the breadth is also a variable, but a different one -the value it takes does not depend on the
value of L. This is an important step, and chldren should be given enough time and
examples to realise this.
When the children get used to the idta of two independent variables in the formula, we
could ask then, to draw a chart as below. And then, as in the case of a square, we could help
them arrive at the formulae for the perimeter and area.
Generalising
, Length ' Breadth Perimeter Area Arithmetic to Algebra
2 3 10 6
4 5 18 20
L b 2x(L+b) Lxb
E8) Do you agree with the method suigested above? If not, what changes would you
make in it?
Formulae are not only related to geometry. We can also generalise relationships between
numbers and write them as formulae. For instance, you can ask the children to give any two
numbers, say 2 and 3. Then you can ask them to see the relationship between 2 + 3 and
3 + 2. You can do this with several pairs of numbers. Then you could lead them towards
algebraically showing that the sum of any two numbers remains unchanged if their order is
changed, that is, you can lead them to
a + b = b + a (the commutative rule for addition)
You could then ask them to re-check whether the formula is true by taking various values of
a and b. For instance, is it true when a = 1 1 and b = 13? when a = 7 and b = 37? and so on. Fig. 2: Is adding water to milk a
commuta~veaction? 7 ,"
To facilitate children's understanding of substituting numbers for variables in algebraic
expressions, you could use the 'cannon'. For instance, to explain to them that, not only is x
a variable, but so is 3x + 2, you could use the '3x + 2 cannon' (see Fig.3). Depending on the
value of x you feed into the cannon, the shell will be fired to a distance of 3x + 2. So, if you '
-0 2 8 1-4
Pig, 3: Pinding parlicvlar vaiues of an algebraic expression
The important point that must be reinforced with examples here is that if a rule is true for
several values, it may still not be true for all values. Even if the rule is false for a single
case, it is not an acceptable rule.
E9) How would you help children arrive at the formula that relates,millimetres to
centimetres?
fill the blanks in 3 + -= 7 and 3 + - # 5. Alongside these activities, you could talk about # denotes 'not equal to'
some choices that make the statement true, and some that make it false.
~umbers-II
You could then progress to activities whlch lnvolve creatlng equations with variables. For
instance, you could play 'think-of-a-number' games with the child - ask her to think of a
number, subtract 3 from it, multiply the result by 2 and add 8 to this. Now the child should
tell you what her result is. From this you can tell her the number she had originally thought
of. For example, if the result is 12, the child's number is 5.
The child may be wond rstruck by the 'magic' you've performed. Now, you can tell her
1
how you did it', by taki g her through-the following chart.
1. Think of a number
2. Subtract 3
4. Add 8
You can tell her that this is an example of an equation with a variable in it. Here you may
need to emphasise that an equation is any expression that involves the 'equal to' sign. For
instance, 3x + 5 = 7, or 3 + 2 = 3. or 2(x - 3) + 8 = 12. We must remember n d to refer to
one side of the equation as 'the problem', and the other side as 'the result'. Doing so creates
confusion in the child's mind regarding the use of =.
Another point that we must stress is that for any value of x, the expressions on both sides
of '=' must have the same value. You could ask the child to put different values of x in the
equation you have, and check if it is satisfied by them. For instance, she can Uy x = 1. x = 3,
x = 5, x = 2, and so on. As she can see, the equation holds for x = 5. For another value of x,
say x = 3, she would get 8 = 12, which she knows is not true.
You could now move towards helping the child solve the equation. The first step at this Generalising
Arithmetic to Algebra
stage is that she must realise that whatever operation is applied to one side of the equation
must also be applied to the other side. You could help her see this by using equations that
involve only numbcrs. For instance, adding 3(say) to only one side of 3 + 2 = 5 will make
the equation false.
At this stage you could shift to solving of equations. You could start by taking an equation
like x + 3 = 8. She should consider how to get from x + 3 to x. You could give her some
I
hints -what happens if you subtract 1 from either side? What happens if you subtract 3?
etc.
E10) Try out a 'think-of-a-number' game with a 10-year-old (or older) child. Ensure
that the equation you get involves a variable and at least two operations. How would
you help the child solve it?
With this we come to the end of this unit on ways of helping children develop a sense of
algebra. Let us take a brief look at what we have done in it.
10.5 SUMMARY
In this unit we have covered the following points.
1) Children's exposure to algebra is in the form of generalisation of number patterns and
arithmetical relationships.
2) Ways in which children can develop their ability to make mathematically acceptable
generalisations.
3) Learning algebra helps the child to develop the ability to recognise patterns, to find
common properties in a set of objects, to generalise these properties and relationships
further, and to express all this in a concise and clear manner.
4) The concept that helps to express this generalisation is that of a variable.
5) Ways of communicating the meaning of a variable to children.
6) Ways of helping children learn to develop and use formulae.
7) Ways of helping children learn to create and solve equations.
-
10.6 COMMENTS ON EXERCISES
El) 'Night follows day', for example.
E2) To do it algebraically, we can frame equations and solve them - an easy and quick
solution. If the son is x years old, then the father is (x+30) years old. Therefore, 10
years ago, their ages were (x-10) and [x+20), respectively. We know that
x+20 = 4(x-10)
that is, 3x = 60
that is, x = 20.
Therefore,Jhe father is now 50 years old.
E3) For example, it helps build the ability for logical step-by-step thinking. It helps the
child get a feel for the nature of mathematics
EM) Give an example from your own experience. (For instance, have you come across
their belief that the larger the perimeter of a figure, the larger its area?) Did you give
the child counter-examples to prove that her generalisation was wrong?
E5) i) 2 x ( 3 ~ + 6 ) = 2 x x 3 y + 6
ii) 4xy, when x = 7 and y = 5, is 475.
iii) (x + 812 = x2 + 64.
There are many others that you would find while interacting with children.
E6) Some strong points, according to us,
student-friendly, and it would lead
emphasises concept-building and understanding, which is the exact opposite of '
rote-learning.
E9) One of the common errors regarding this formula is to write the rule as 10 m = c
instead of 10 c = m, where m and c 'denote the number of millimetres and centirnetres,
respectively.