Cri 201 Lie Detection
Cri 201 Lie Detection
Polygraph Examination
- used to test an individual for the purpose of detecting deception or
verifying the truthfulness of his statements.
Types of Polygraph:
1. Analog Polygraph - a polygraph instrument that directly records the
responses of the subject on a piece of the chart.
2. Computerized Polygraph - a polygraph instrument capable of
monitoring, recording, storing, and analyzing respiratory,
electrodermal, and cardiovascular activity.
Main Components:
a. Pneumograph - It records the respiratory activity.
i. Has a 5 inches recording pen and 10 inches of rubber tube.
ii. Thoracic and Abdominal
b. Cardiograph / Cardiosphygmograph - It records cardiovascular
activity.
i. Has a 5 inches of recording pen.
c. Galvanograph - Component responsible for producing the graphic
recording of skin resistance or Electrodermal Activity (EDA). EDA
recently replaced the term Galvanic Skin Response (GSR).
i. Has a 7 inches of recording pen.
d. Kymograph - a motor that drives the polygraph chart under the
recording pen at a uniform rate of 1 division/ 5 seconds (1 division of
the chart is equivalent to ½ inch) This component is used only in
analog polygraphs in which the polygram is produced simultaneously
with the application of stimulus.
Accessory Components:
● Polygraph Chair - A chair designed to absorb concealed muscular
movements of the subject. To serve its purpose, an additional
recording channel must be provided in the polygraph to register the
movements of the subject.
● Plethysmograph - Device that measures changes in blood volume in
a part of the body.
○ Occlusion - the use of inflatable cuff to restrict venous return
while measuring volume changes indirectly via pressure or
resistance.
○ Photoelectric - the use of infrared light emitter-collector diode
pair that measures volume changes indirectly by directing light
into the skin and detecting its reflection back.
● Polygram - A graphic representation containing selected
physiological data generated by an examinee during the data
collection phase of a polygraph examination. Also refers to the
physiologic recording of responses of the examinee in response to
stimuli. Also known as (Polygraph Chart or Test Data)
● Polygraphist - Someone who has successfully completed formal
education and training in conducting polygraph examinations and is
either authorized or formally certified, by the examiner's agency, to
conduct such examinations.
○ Other names: (Polygraph Examiner, Forensic Psycho-
physiologist, and Polygrapher)
● Subject (Examinee) - Person taking a polygraph examination.
● Stimulus - A force or motion reaching the organism and excites the
preceptors.
● Question string - All questions that appear between the
commencement and termination.
● Serial position - the position of a question within a question string.
Also known as Question
● Polygraph Examination - A process that encompasses all activities
that take place between a PDD examiner and an examinee during the
phases of a polygraph examination. Also known as (Polygraph Test,
Lie-Detector Test, Psychophysiological Detection of Deception
(PDD), and Criminalistics).
Test Results:
1. Deception Indicated (DI) - charts revealed the physiological
responses to the relevant question(s) are indicative of deception.
2. No Deception Indicated (NDI) - charts revealed the physiological
responses to the relevant question(s) were not indicative of
deception. No Significant Response (NSR) is an equivalent term to
NDI
3. Inconclusive - when an examinee's polygraph record shows
responses that are insufficient to determine truthfulness or deception.
In the recent year, polygraphists no longer use this test result and if
the subject is inconclusive, their diagnosis is reduced to No Opinion
4. No Opinion (NO) - An evaluation that indicates the examiner cannot
render a conclusive opinion of DI or NDI based on the physiological
data on a given set of charts. Based on earlier references, this result
is the diagnostic opinion of the examiner when the subject has been
uncooperative during the test and the data has been corrupted.
Causes of Errors
1. misinterpretation of the data on the charts
2. lack of training and experience of the polygraph examiner
3. counter-measures from the examinee
4. equipment malfunction
5. failure to properly prepare the examinee for the examination
6. poorly worded test questions
7. improper assessment of the examinee's emotional and physical
condition
8. improper use of testing techniques
9. lack of quality control review
Kinds of Lies:
1. White Lie/ Benign Lie - it is used to avoid the harmful and realistic
implications of the truth. It is basically used to lubricate interpersonal
relationships.
2. Black Lie - telling an untruth and attributing it to a false source. A lie
who accompanies pretensions and hypocrisies, intriguing to cause
dishonor or discredit one's good image.
3. Red Lie - a lie common to communist countries, it is used to destroy
common ideologies by means of propaganda.
4. Aggressive lies - are self-serving and may potentially damage
others, and therefore, most people would see them as clearly
immoral.
5. Bold-faced Lie - lie that is told when it is obvious to all concerned
that it is a lie.
6. Perjury - making verifiably false statements on a material matter
under oath or affirmation in a court of law or in any various
statements in writing.
7. Malicious lie - It is a very pure and unjustifiable kind of lie that is
intended purely to mislead or obstruct justice by a guilty accused
person.
8. Altruistic lies - are those lies that are told to benefit someone else,
to reduce suffering, or to help increase self-esteem.
9. Pathological Lies - A lie made by persons who cannot distinguish
right and wrong Furthermore, the lie is not determined solely by
situational factors and appears to be compulsive or fantastic.
10. Emergency Lies / Defensive Lies - used when the truth may
not be told because of the harm that would come of it.
11. Humorous Lies - (Jocose Lie) those aimed at amusing the
listener, and any intent to deceive is transient and teasing.
12. Bluffing - is an act of deception that is not usually seen as
immoral because it takes place in the context of a game where this
kind of deception is consented to in advance by the players. This kind
of deception is accepted as a tactic and even expected.
13. Exaggeration - is when the most fundamental aspect of a
statement is true but the degree of its truthfulness is incorrect.
Maximization of felt emotions reflects a dramatic attempt to influence
another person.
14. Minimization - The result of an individual's attempt to dampen
the external appearance of a more deeply experienced emotion.
15. Neutralization - An effort to mask emotional response by
adapting a "poker face". Psychoanalysts and other professionals may
display relatively little or no response in their efforts to appear
nonjudgmental of the patient's or client's statements.
16. Substitution - it's a common mechanism of hiding one's true
feelings. One of the most common techniques employed for this
purpose is to substitute "pleasure" for a negative emotion. Smiling is
one of the easiest nonverbal communications to produce and may be
used to mask feelings of arrogance, anxiety, or boredom.
17. Promotion Lie - a kind of lie used in advertising or marketing
strategies that is used to influence the consumers to buy products.
Specifically, the 15% errors in lie detection tests come from the
following circumstances
1. Nervousness or extreme emotional tension experienced by a
subject who is telling the truth regarding the offense in question but
who is nevertheless affected by:
a. apprehension induced by the mere fact that suspicion or
accusation has been directed against him.
b. apprehension over the possibility of an inaccurate lie detector
test result.
c. Over-anxiety to cooperate in order to assure accurate test
results.
d. apprehension concerning possible physical hurt from the
instrument.
e. anger resentment over having to take a lie detector test.
f. over-anxiety regarding serious personal problems unrelated to
the offense under investigation.
g. previous extensive interrogation, especially when accompanied
by physical abuse.
h. a guilt complex or fear of detection regarding some other
offense that he had committed
2. Physiological abnormalities such as:
a. excessively high or excessively low blood pressure.
b. diseases of the heart.
c. respiratory disorder
3. Mental abnormalities such as:
a. feeblemindedness as in idiots, imbeciles, and morons.
b. psychosis as in manic depressive, paranoid, schizophrenic,
paretic, etc..
c. psychoneurosis and psychopathy, as among the so-called
"peculiar" or emotionally unstable persons
4. Unresponsiveness in a lying or guilty subject because of:
a. no fear of detection.
b. apparent inability to consciously control response by means of
certain mental sets of attitudes.
c. a condition of 'sub-shock" or "adrenal exhaustion at the time of
the test.
d. rationalization of the crime in advance of the test to such an
extent that lying about the offense arouses little or no emotional
disturbance.
e. extensive interrogation prior to the test
5. Attempt to "beat the machine" by controlled breathing or by
muscular flexing.
6. Unobserved application of muscular pressure which produces
ambiguities and misleading indications in the blood pressure
tracing