Development Team: Library Use and User Studies
Development Team: Library Use and User Studies
Principal Investigator
&
Dr. Jagdish Arora, Director
Module : 22Subject
Models of Information
Coordinator LiteracyINFLIBNET
Part- 2 Centre, Gandhinagar
Development Team
Paper Coordinator
Principal Investigator
Dr. Jagdish Arora, Director
&
INFLIBNET Centre, Gandhinagar
Subject Coordinator
Content Writer
Module Id LIS/LIUS-M/22
Note: The models have been given in accordance to their chronological manifestation.
3.1 “Society of College, National and University Libraries”; linked to the Seven Pillars of
Information Literacy model.
3.2 ACRL’s “Information Literacy Competency Standards for Higher Education”
3.3 “Council of Australian University Librarians”/the Australian and New Zealand Institute
for Information Literacy”
3.4 AASL's Standards for the 21st Century Learners3
3.5 “Objectives for Information Literacy Instruction: A Model Statement for `
Academic Librarians”
3.6 AASL and AECT Information Literacy Standards for Student Learning.
Source: http://www.leeds.ac.uk/bigblue/finalreportful.htm
Step 1- Recognizing an Information Need: The first stage of this model is the recognition of
information need is, this step suggests that at first stage students should be trained to identify
their information needs.
Step 2- Addressing the Information Need: In this stage covers the addressing the information need,
means students should properly address their needs, it also formulation of proper key words and search
strategy and even select and evaluate information sources.
Step 3 – Retrieve Information: This stage covers retrieval of information as per decided keywords
and formulated search strategy which should be able to answer his query, question and satisfy
information requirement. This stage also involves selection and retrieval of right information.
Step 4 – Evaluate Information Critically: This stage involves the evaluation of the information and
this should be done critically, because information should be evaluated with its relevance,
purpose, currency, authority and the quality. If students find that the retrieved information is not
relevant then user has to revise his strategy.
Step 5 – Adapt Information: This stage is belongs to adaptation of information which includes
generation and creation of new knowledge for self and for others.
Step 6 – Organizes Information: This stage is extension of the previous stage, because the
information that has been generated and created should be organized in ethical manner, which
includes correct records of sources, by using style manuals.
Step 7 – Communicates Information : The success of this method and even process of information
search is depend on communication of information in right manner, so the users of this
information can be used and understood properly.
Step 8 – Reviews the Process: This is the last stage of this model, which includes examination or
review of information, at this stage user has to able the answers the questions which was decided
or emerged before him, if found that the information not useful, then user has to repeat the all
stages to get right information, this process will inherit lifelong learning in user(s).
Olin and Uris Libraries, Cornell University, Ithaca NY6 has developed an information literacy tool for students.
This model was developed for students, which helps in finding information for research, this process also
inherits ethical use of information, and it is effective when the users is having familiarity with the library system.
4
This “Information Literacy Scope and Sequence” is a kind of research model and based on Bloom's taxonomy, it
offers a comprehensive framework for teaching and learning of information literacy skills.
This is five steps information literacy models, which are given as under:-
Question: This question stage is primary stage of this model, in this stage student has to make certain
important things, such as recognize need of information, select topic, formulate questions, select suitable
presentation form, and to decide the quantity of information.
Find: This stage belongs to the finding of information. In this stage student has to learn how is
information will be found, verity of information (media), indentifies available sources (primary and
secondary information sources) and electronic resources etc, decide criteria to select sources, then after
decide search strategy, locate information on appropriate material from all possible resources.
Gather: This step is about how to gather information? In this stage students has to learn how to gather
information, this task has to be completed attentively, purposefully, gather information through verity of
sources, and also use ethical practices like citing sources.
Create: In this stage students learn how to organize or create a final result; means organize all sources
though proper listing, Create Product, and apply legal and ethical practices.
Assess: This stage involves the practices of assessment of result and the process. This assessment can be
done by its contents, format, completeness, effectiveness, strength, and weaknesses.
Category 1: Information searching is seen as looking for a needle in a haystack: It was observed that in
normal course of search students are tend to use one or two search engines, which are their favourite,
they are more familiar with, they trust most, and have been recommended by the peers. But this
restricts their search because other search engines may have better options and features.
Category 2: Information searching is seen as finding a way through a maze: This category shows about
awareness of the process or planning of the searching information on web, since the information search
has become more important so that student has to use advance search features, search quality
information, and have to have completely aware with variety of search tools and options. This has to be
learned by the students to search relevant and quality information.
Category 3: Information searching is seen as using the tools as a filter: This category shows about
awareness information environment, it also includes a clear understanding of every aspect of the online
environment. In this stage students have to show their ability to generate results, for that they have to
use advance search options as instruments.
Category 4: Information searching is seen as panning for gold: This category emphasizes on quality of
information, the only aspect remain after going through the above categories, i.e. external databases,
internet databases, and term analysis. These should be included for achieving perfection in the learning
process.
It is further suggested that while educating information searching skills students should be encouraged to
distinguish their information searching process and experience how he can distinguishes difference search
options and experiences, and they should be encourage in such type of search process.
15
Sylvia L Edwards has further cleared about four areas which should be considered in this variation model,
are:-
This model of information literacy i.e. “Six Frames for Information Literacy Education” 16 is based on certain
assumption/presumptions. The presumption is about the idea that teaching, learning and Information literacy are
being seen differently by participants.
The presumptions are:
Following six frames 17 have been devised through the experimenting above given presumptions:-
CONTENT FRAME
View of Information Information exists apart from the user, can be transmitted
Curriculum Focus What should learners know about the subject, about IL?
COMPETENCY FRAME
View of learning and Teachers analyze tasks into knowledge skills; learners become competent
teaching by following predetermined pathways
View of learning and Teachers facilitate collaborative leaning; learners develop conceptual
teaching structure and ways of thinking and reasoning
View of Content Content is chosen for mastering important concepts and fostering
reflective practice
View of Assessment Complex, contextual problem and proposed. Self or pees assessment is
encouraged
View of learning and Teaching focuses on helping learners to find motivation. Learning is
teaching about finding personal relevance and learning
View of Content Problems, cases, scenarios selected to reveal relevance and meaning
View of learning and Teachers role in challenges the status quo. Learning is about adopting
teaching perspective that will encourage social change.
View of Assessment
RELATIONAL GRAME
Curriculum Focus Bringing about awareness of the critical ways of seeing of experience
View of learning and Teachers being about particular ways of seeing specific phenomena;
teaching learning is coming to see the world differently
View of Content Examples selected to help students discover new ways of seeing. Critical
phenomena for learning must be identified
Each frame conveys a particular analysis of IL, information, curriculum focus, learning and teaching, content,
and assessment.
A series of “lenses” 19 is developed for different users so the model can be applied in specific situation. The
model is depicted in three dimensional circular “building”, the circular nature of the model that express to
become information literate is not a linear process; and all pillars are repeatedly closely linked.
The top view and front view of the SCONUL Model can be represented as under:-
Source:http://www.sconul.ac.uk/sites/default/files/documents/coremodel.pdf
Each pillar is further described with set of skills/competencies and a set of attitudes/understandings. It is
expected that as a person travel through pillar to pillar in circular motion understands/grasp attributes of each
pillar and this process converts him into information literate person.
10
“Society of College, National and University Libraries”; linked to the Seven Pillars of Information
Literacy model.
ACRL’s “Information Literacy Competency Standards for Higher Education”
“Council of Australian University Librarians”/The Australian and New Zealand Institute for Information
Literacy”
AASL's Standards for the 21st Century Learners
“Objectives for Information Literacy Instruction: A Model Statement for Academic Librarians”
AASL and AECT Information Literacy Standards for Student Learning
The brief details of the above given information literacy standards are given as under:-
3.1 The “Society of College, National and University Libraries” i.e. SCONUL is the same as we discussed
in the above given explanation in Seven Pillars of Information Literacy Model.
Understand the economic, legal, and social issues surrounding the use of information, and
access and use information ethically and legally.” 23
3.3 “Council of Australian University Librarians”/The Australian and New Zealand Institute for Information
Literacy”
The Australian and New Zealand information literacy (ANZIL) framework 24 is derived, from the Association of
College and Research Libraries’ (ACRL) Information literacy competency standards for higher education.
The Australian and New Zealand Information Literacy Framework developed in 2004 by the Australian and
New Zealand Institute of Information Literacy. The Information Literacy Framework is developed to reflect new
understandings of information literacy. The ANZIL framework 24 is based on four overarching principles,
according to these principles information literate people:-
Engage in independent learning through constructing new meaning, understanding and knowledge
Derive satisfaction and personal fulfilment from using information wisely
Individually and collectively search for and use information for decision making and problem solving in
order to address personal, professional and societal issues
Demonstrate social responsibility through a commitment to lifelong learning and community
participation
“recognizes the need for information finds needed information effectively and efficiently
critically evaluates information and the information seeking process
manages information collected or generated
applies prior and new information to construct new concepts or create new understandings
uses information with understanding and acknowledges cultural, ethical, economic, legal, and social
issues surrounding the use of information” 25
The American Association of School Librarians (AASL), was established in 1951, it is a important division of
the American Library Association (ALA). The main function of the AASL is to support excellence, facilitate
change, and develop leaders in the school library field; in support of mission the AASL has developed Standards
for the 21st-Century Learner 26 in 2007 to promote information literacy in school libraries.
12
This standard has indentified main four components of this model, and each component has to reply meet key
question, this model can be presented in tabular form as under:-
Key abilities needed for Ongoing beliefs and Common behaviours Reflections on one’s
Information Literacy
Does the student have Is the student s the student aware that Can the student
disposed to higher- recognize personal
the right proficiencies to the foundational traits
level thinking and strengths and
explore a topic or for
actively engaged in weaknesses over time
Key Question
subject further?
critical thinking to 21st-century learning and become a
gain and share requires self- stronger, more
knowledge? accountability that independent learner?
extends beyond skills
and dispositions?
13
3.5 “Objectives for Information Literacy Instruction: A Model Statement for Academic Librarians”
The ACRL has developed In Model Statement of Objectives for Academic Bibliographic Instruction 28 in 1987,
and it was felt by the Instruction Section of ACRL that the these instructions are not able to meet the
complexities of new situations i.e. ICT, then a Task Force was created in 1997 to review earlier model. The Task
Force began its work at ALA Annual in 1998. The Task Force has created “Information Literacy Competency
Standards for Higher Education” in 2000.
The model has following four Competency Standards and performance indicators:-
“Competency Standard One: The information literate student determines the extent of the information
needed.
Competency Standard Two: The information literate student accesses needed information effectively
and efficiently.
Competency Standard Three: The information literate student evaluates information and its sources
critically and incorporates selected information into his or her knowledge base and value system.
Competency Standard Four: The information literate student, individually or as a member of a group,
uses information effectively to accomplish a specific purpose.
Competency Standard Five: The information literate student understands many of the economic, legal
and social issues surrounding the use of information and accesses and uses information ethically and
legally.” 29
3.6 AASL and AECT Information Literacy Standards for Student Learning
AASL and AECT (American Association of School Librarians and Association for Educational
Communications and Technology) has jointly developed information literacy model 30 in 1998 and 2007 for the
students of K-12 Standards. This model has given a comprehensive view of IL.
These nine national standards and twenty-nine indicators provide the framework for the standards:-
INDEPENDENT LEARNING: The student who is an independent learner is information literate and:
4. Pursues information related to personal interests
14
SOCIAL RESPONSIBILITY: The student who contributes positively to the learning community and to
society is information literate and:
7. Recognizes the importance of in formation to a democratic society
8. Practices ethical behaviour in regard to information and information technology respects the
principles of intellectual freedom respects intellectual property rights uses information
technology responsibly
9. Participates effectively in groups to pursue and generate information.” 31
4. Conclusion
It has been explained through the details given above that the information literacy modules and the
information literacy standards developed by the individuals /associations /organizations are useful to
develop the information literacy skills in the individuals. It is a kind of drive which is required to be
maintained / initiated by the educational institutions to teach information literacy skills in day to day
routine and must be included in their curriculum, and libraries should be made a principal agency to
carry this initiatives. Information literacy is an innovative standard for lifelong learning in the library
and information environment. The steps have been illustrated in the modules and standard transform
information into knowledge and also empower individuals in a state of information literate persons,
simultaneously develop intelligence in regards to use information.
References
1. "Big Blue : Jisc." Big Blue : Joint Information Systems Committee. 29 June 2014.
<http://www.jisc.ac.uk/whatwedo/programmes/programme_jos/project_big_blue>.
2. "Big Blue : Joint Information Systems Committee " Big Blue : Jisc. 29 June 2014.
<http://www.jisc.ac.uk/whatwedo/programmes/programme_jos/project_big_blue.aspx>.
3. Basili, Carla. Information literacy in Europe: a first insight into the state of the art of information
literacy in the European Union. Roma: Consiglio nazionale delle ricerche, Istituto di studi socio-
economici sull'innovazione e le politiche della ricerca, 2003.
4. "The Big Blue : Information Skills for Students." Final Report. 30 June 2014.
<http://www.jisc.ac.uk/media/documents/programmes/jos/bigbluefinalreport.pdf>.
5. "The Big Blue." The Big Blue. 30 June 2014. <http://www.leeds.ac.uk/bigblue/onlineiscourses.html>.
6. "The 7 Steps of the Research Process - Bloomfield College Information Literacy Website." The 7 Steps
of the Research Process - Bloomfield College Information Literacy Website. N.p., n.d. Web. 30 June
2014. <https://sites.google.com/site/bcinfolit/Home/the-7-steps-of-the-research-process>.
15
16
17