Multifunction Shoe Cabinet For Small Living Space: Wang Ming Ler & Ahmad Anwar Safwan Sidek
Multifunction Shoe Cabinet For Small Living Space: Wang Ming Ler & Ahmad Anwar Safwan Sidek
1 (2023) 895–906
© Universiti Tun Hussein Onn Malaysia Publisher’s Office
RMTB
Homepage: http://publisher.uthm.edu.my/periodicals/index.php/rmtb
e-ISSN : 2773-5044
*Corresponding Author
DOI: https://doi.org/10.30880/rmtb.2023.04.01.063
Received 31 March 2023; Accepted 30 April 2023; Available online 01 June 2023
Abstract:
Due to urbanization and population growth, the demand for low-cost housing has
increased, resulting in limited living spaces for residents. To combat this issue,
multifunctional furniture has become a popular solution. Shoe cabinets are a
necessary household item that can benefit from multifunctional elements. The
objectives of this study were to identify the design criteria for multifunctional shoe
cabinets, design and develop a prototype suitable for small living spaces. A
questionnaire was distributed to 60 respondents living in Johor Bahru, Johor, via
Google Forms. The survey revealed that the preferred design criteria for
multifunctional shoe cabinets were wood as the main material, extra shoe storage,
seating, a mirror, a minimalist style, wood color, tilt-out drawers, and short-height
shoe cabinets. The design process involved ideation, idea development, design
survey, final design, technical drawings, mock-up creation, bill of materials
generation, and fabrication of the prototype. Each phase contributed to improving the
design of the multifunctional shoe cabinet to meet the design criteria. A full-size
prototype was successfully manufactured based on the final design sketched at the
end of the research. In conclusion, the multifunctional shoe cabinet can provide
storage and additional functions while solving the problem of space efficiency. The
findings of this research can serve as a reference for future research and improve the
design of shoe cabinets.
Keywords: Multifunction furniture, Shoe cabinet, Small living space, Space saving,
Apartment
1. Introduction
The general apartment’s size has gradually decrease compared to 2 decades ago approximately from
70m2 to only 30m2 (Kilman, 2016). Therefore, while living space in apartments is slowly getting
smaller, the demand of space saving furniture also shows an increasing trend in order to accommodate
the limited space for efficiency. In urban area of Malaysia such as Kuala Lumpur, low-cost housing
apartments has always been an important residential concept (Karim, 2013). The low-cost housing
apartments are one of the Government’s initiatives that aim to help lower income group in the society
in the urban areas. However, lower cost residential also leads to other issues, such as lower quantity and
quality. The researcher stated that the low-cost housing apartments lacking quality for its residents in
the aspect of infrastructural needs and others benefits (Karim, 2013). In addition, most of the B-40
income group people that lives in apartments with small living space, making them difficult to furnish
their home with all the necessary furniture because of the limited space (Yahya, 2020).
Multifunctional furniture is known as the type of furniture that provides more than one or multiple
purposes and supports multiple activities at the same time. Other terms for multifunctional furniture are
such as space-saving furniture, multipurpose furniture, and transformable furniture (Husein, 2021). The
main purpose of multifunctional furniture is to better increase space efficiency of a limited interior
space. This type of furniture that serves multiple functions is most effective especially in places with
small space such as apartments and flats. The concept of furniture containing multiple functions shows
its most advantages especially on necessary furniture piece that is crucial in a house. According to
Husein (2021), modern furniture designs should take into account of conserving time, space, and human
effort, especially for the domestic furniture. The concept of multifunction has to be adapting to more
furniture in the market to increase furniture space efficiency, and is very beneficial to living place with
limited space.
Shoe cabinet as known by many is one of the shoe storage furniture serves as a storage unit for
shoes. Shoe storage furniture is undoubtedly a necessary furniture piece for a household or anywhere
else that requires shoes to be taken off. After research, the innovations of multifunction shoe rack were
relatively less as compared to other furniture pieces such as table and cabinet. Therefore, shoe cabinet
have been selected as the furniture to adapt with the multifunction concept in this research. Shoe cabinet
serves its purpose as storage units to accommodate the increasing number of shoes a person owns in
this modernization, not to mention the total pairs of shoes own in a family. Therefore, organizing shoes
and maintaining tidiness of the floor become effortless. The shoe storage furniture in today’s market
comes in varieties of designs, shapes, dimensions, and materials. For instance, some of the common
types of shoe storage furniture are such as shoe rack, shoe cabinet, wall mounted or built-in shoe rack
and over-door shoe rack. When it comes to storing shoe, the number of shoes can be stored not only
depends on the sizes and design but also the mechanism of the drawers. For example, tilt-out or pull-
down drawers provide even more space for storage than normal shoe rack.
Most of the apartments' users especially in big cities, having to deal with problem of small living
spaces (Tahir & Qaradaghi, 2020). Small living space in apartments has limited user’s to be smart and
creative with furniture selection with the limited interior. Besides that, most of the people who lived in
a small space in an apartment or flats located in cities encounter problems of having not enough spaces
in their homes for necessary furniture such as storage furniture. While the overall size of apartments
kept shrinking, the size of furniture however still remains the same and takes the same amount of space
in a room (Husein, 2021). When living in a small space packed with several different kinds of furniture,
it causes user to feel uncomfortable staying in the room and possibly causes stress, which counters the
meaning of home and shelter of being the place to feel safe and to relax. Thus, multifunctional or
multipurpose furniture is a smart approach and solution for small room problems. Multifunction
furniture does not only serve more than one purpose, but also gives the advantage of saving room space.
The concept of multifunctional furniture has been established and implemented in many types of
furniture for many years. However, the significance of these inventive has not been fully taken into
account until now (Canepa, 2017).
On the other hand, many existing shoes rack own by most of the people lack of possible added
function for better used of the design. For instance, most of the shoe racks in the market are not designed
with seating and only basic rack stacking storage, which cause the problem of lacking space to store
896
Wang & Sidek, Research in Management of Technology and Business Vol. 4 No. 1 (2023) p. 895-906
shoes (Muhammad et al., 2020). Therefore, the effectiveness of shoe rack has to be improved by adding
possible functions to its design while increase the storage space at the same time.
The scope of study was limited to the design of multifunction shoe cabinet for small living space.
The research will be conducted by using survey questionnaire method through an online namely
“Google Form” and social media platform such as “WhatsApp”. Target respondent of this study are the
apartment residents that reside in Johor Bharu of Johor, Malaysia. The total numbers of target
respondents that will be contributing to this research are 60 respondents.
This research will introduce a new innovative design of shoe cabinet to the furniture industry, which
focused on multifunction and space efficiency. The proposed multifunction shoe cabinet are estimate
to provide the maximum storage comes with added function while remain its main purpose as a space-
saving furniture. Therefore, the multifunction shoe cabinet aims to help residents that lives in
apartments or flats that encounter the problems of shoe storage and space efficiency. Furthermore, all
the analysis and information provided in this research can be used as reference for relating research in
the future and for improvement.
2. Literature Review
Furniture can be defined as the objects for comfortable living or working that are place in a house,
office, and other places such as chairs, tables, beds, and many more (Cambridge Dictionary, n.d.). A
furniture piece is made for helping in human activities in their daily lives. Furniture can be considered
as a crucial component in an interior or exterior space that can be designed according to its surrounding
and use (Husein, 2021). According to Chen (2016), furniture that are put inside of buildings often has
its relation in attributes similarly to the architecture. A furniture piece has to fulfil its function for
supporting human activities and bring convenient in their daily life. Furthermore, the 4 purpose of
furniture is to make humans live easier and provide comfortable living (Astonkar & Kherde, 2015).
For many years, furniture pieces were created and designed to support or served their only function.
For example, tables for writing, chairs for seating, beds and sofas for resting, cabinets and wardrobes
for storing and so on (Husein, 2021). Multifunction furniture started to show up as times moved on
when urbanization rate was growing. Multifunctional furniture is known as the type of furniture that
provides more than one or multiple purposes and supports multiple activities at the same time. Other
terms for multifunctional furniture are such as space-saving furniture, multipurpose furniture, and
transformable furniture (Husein, 2021). According to Xie (2016), multifunctional furniture can be
regarded as a revolution in furniture design. The reason behind that is because multifunctional furniture
does not only shine as a solution for limited spaces, but also serve their aesthetic appearance to its
surrounding area.
Shoe storage is a flexible furniture item that used for storage for many types of foot wears and other
small accessories (Imam, 2017). Shoe storage can be manufactured with different kind of materials such
as wood, metal, stainless steel, plastic and others depends on preferences of users. There exist varieties
of shoe storage available in the current market that built different in designs, functions, dimensions, and
materials according to where the shoe storage will be located at. According to Kaori (2019), shoe
storage furniture for living space has variety of options that suit from large houses to tiny apartments.
In urban places, the rapid growing population has push for faster rate of urbanization and causing
more pressure on housing. Hence, to counter this issue, Malaysia government has started to increase
more projects on building small sized apartments. Hence, the issue of small living space mostly occurs
in apartments of urban cities (Karim, 2013). Generally, furniture is the most important element inside a
house or and interior space to provides functions that support human activities in their daily lives and
most of the furniture are irreplaceable with other objects. Lack of space in apartments required smart
897
Wang & Sidek, Research in Management of Technology and Business Vol. 4 No. 1 (2023) p. 895-906
solutions such as multipurpose furniture, space saving furniture, or transformable furniture. The reason
of that requirement is because limited space is impossible to furnish with all the necessary furniture
pieces as furniture will occupy a lot of interior space. A room that is packed with furniture make the
limited room feels even smaller and space for activity will decrease gradually (Husein, 2021).
According to Gentili (2017), apartments’ residents do not have the space to fully accommodate their
furniture.
Different type of shoe storage is unique in dimensions according to user preferences. Standard
height of a short shoe cabinet should be around 40 to 45 cm, 30 - 33 cm depth, and 78 to 80 cm length.
However, the standard dimension can be varying depend on the type of shoe cabinet. Spacing or shelf
height between the storage of shoe cabinet also has different dimensions according to preference, but
the standards dimension of the storage space to store shoes is 30 cm.
3. Research Methodology
3.1 Questionnaire
Questionnaire was the method used to collect information and later to investigate the design criteria
of the multifunction shoe cabinet that is preferred by the users currently. “Google Form” was utilized
to construct a series of questions. The questions constructed were divided into two main sections.
Section A is to collect the respondents’ demographic and personal information, while Section B
contains questions on the design criteria of the multifunction shoe cabinet preferred by the respondents.
The questions contain in the survey questionnaire is close-ended questions, which respondents are
provided with choices or options for each question. The survey questionnaire is later spread to
respondents through social media such as “WhatsApp”. The target respondents for the survey
questionnaire are 60 respondents that reside in apartments in Johor Bahru of Johor, Malaysia. The
results of the questionnaire helped the researcher to understand better the users’ needs and precise
desired features. Hence, it determined the design of the multifunction shoe cabinet.
3.2 Visual Research
Visual research is the act of brainstorming the design draft of a product by researching the current
available product in the market along with other design elements and features that are related. Visual
research helps to provide a direction where, what and how the outcome of a product’s design will be.
For instance, pictures from articles and journals as well as furniture catalogues are very useful to be
reviewed before the sketching process started as it is one of the sources of inspiration for designing.
Visual research is important before beginning any sketching process because it will determine the first
drafting of the multifunction shoe cabinet design. For example, the result of the questionnaire
determines the design criteria to be implemented into the design of the shoe cabinet and visual research
will be done based on those obtained design criteria.
3.3 Thumbnail and Ideation Sketches
Thumbnail sketches are the early drawing phase of brainstorming all the possible design of a
product. Generally, designs are sketched not detailed, small and each design is differed with the others.
The main reason of drawing thumbnail is simply to visualize the plain design with the base concept of
the design along with others design elements. In this research, thumbnail sketches of the shoe cabinet
were sketched on a piece of A3 paper containing 15 different designs. Ideation sketch is the process
followed after thumbnail sketches to present the base design concepts. Few designs are chosen from the
thumbnail sketches to further evaluate by drawing in more details. During this process, the obtained
design criteria from the survey questionnaire are implemented into the design.
898
Wang & Sidek, Research in Management of Technology and Business Vol. 4 No. 1 (2023) p. 895-906
899
Wang & Sidek, Research in Management of Technology and Business Vol. 4 No. 1 (2023) p. 895-906
prototyping in this study is plywood and finish neatly with laminate. The manufacturing process of the
prototype was recorded and will be explained in the further part in this research.
900
Wang & Sidek, Research in Management of Technology and Business Vol. 4 No. 1 (2023) p. 895-906
Figure 2: Thumbnail
In the ideation phase, the sketches were drawn in 3 dimensional views and sketched with more
detail. Detail of design criteria were implemented and sketched into the design. Figure 3 below displays
the 3 ideation sketches.
901
Wang & Sidek, Research in Management of Technology and Business Vol. 4 No. 1 (2023) p. 895-906
Figure 3: Ideation
902
Wang & Sidek, Research in Management of Technology and Business Vol. 4 No. 1 (2023) p. 895-906
The final process of determining the overall design idea of the multifunction shoe cabinet was the
final design sketch. Design 2 was chosen by the respondents through the design survey and undergone
further modified in terms of detailing, modifying, and dimensioning. The carved in handle of the cabinet
doors were modified to using cabinet door handles because according to expert manufacturer’s opinion,
carving the 18 mm plywood might damage the plywood’s durability. Cabinet door handles can provide
better experience for users when opening the cabinet doors rather than just carved because with handles
can be hold when pulling. Besides, a cushion seat was added for the middle section which provides
comfortable seating. Apart from that, LED light stripe was considered into the design particularly at the
small open space under both side of the shoe cabinet to further enhance the shoe cabinet’s appearance.
The overall height for the shoe cabinet was 428 mm, overall length is 1272 mm, and the depth is
319 mm. All cabinets adapt the tilt-out or pull-down drawers’ design with 3 layers, which provide users
more space to store more shoes than usual shelving design. The main material of the multifunction shoe
cabinet was plywood. Figure 5 shows the final design sketch and the rendered model using AutoCAD
software of multifunction shoe cabinet for small living space.
903
Wang & Sidek, Research in Management of Technology and Business Vol. 4 No. 1 (2023) p. 895-906
4.6 Mock-up
A mock-up of the multifunction shoe cabinet was done with the scale of 1:6 ratio according to the
exact dimensions from the final design. The materials used for the mock-up are 2mm plywood sheets,
cutter knife, pencil, L shape ruler, super glue, 80 grit and 600 grit sandpapers, modelling clay,
aluminium foil, plastic sheet, foam, and cloth. Figure 6 shows the mock-up result of the multifunction
shoe cabinet.
Figure 6: Mock-up
904
Wang & Sidek, Research in Management of Technology and Business Vol. 4 No. 1 (2023) p. 895-906
Figure 8: BOM
905
Wang & Sidek, Research in Management of Technology and Business Vol. 4 No. 1 (2023) p. 895-906
5. Conclusion
In conclusion, this research will benefit not only apartment residents but also those who live in other
places that have the problems to limited living space. The designed multifunction shoe cabinet in this
study is able to provide multiple function and space saving features as it provides enough storage for
shoes. Apart from that, closed-storage designed enables the users to tidy up their shoes making the space
look cleaner and more organized. At the end, the set objectives of this research have also been
successfully achieved, whereby, design criteria have been identified through survey questionnaire. The
design criteria obtained for the multifunction shoe cabinet were made by wood, designed with extra
shoe storage, seating, and mirror, minimalist style, wood colour, built with tilt-out drawers, and short-
height shoe cabinet. Besides, after gone through multiple designing processes, the multifunction shoe
cabinet has been successfully designed. Final design of the multifunction shoe cabinet was evaluated
starting from visual research, thumbnail sketches, ideation, idea development, and design survey. Based
on the final design, technical drawing was constructed and a scaled mockup model was built to visualise
the design. The constructed technical drawings were used as the main reference for fabricating process
of the prototype. The manufactured prototype achieved every design criteria required, for example each
of the shoe cabinet drawer can store up to 3 or 4 pairs of shoes with the adaption of the tilt-out drawer,
finish with wood sticker and built low in height where seating feature is allow. Thus, all objectives of
this research were accomplished.
References
Canepa, S. (2017). Living in a Flexible Space. IOP Conference Series: Materials Science and Engineering, 245
(5), 052006.
Gentili, E. (2017). Exploring Wellbeing in Small and Unconventional Dwellings: Understanding living in small
and unconventional dwellings through a multi-dimensional perspective of space. Master Thesis: University
of Vaxjo, Sweden.
Husein, H. A. (2020). Multifunctional Furniture as a Smart Solution for Small Spaces for the Case of Zaniary
Towers Apartments in Erbil City, Iraq. Int. Trans. J. Eng. Manag. Appl. Sci. Technol, 12, 1-11.
Karim, A. Z. (2013). Living condition in the low cost apartments in Malaysia: An empirical investigation. Asian
Social Science, 9(17), 20.
Muhammad, S. A., Rizal Halmy, M. I. D., & Zulkarnain, Z. H. (2020). Innovative Shoe Rack with Seating.
Institutional Repository at Politeknik Sultan Salahuddin Abdul Aziz Shah.
Tahir, H. M., & Qaradaghi, A. M. A. (2020). The Influence of Using Minimalist Furniture on the Efficiency of
the Living Space-Residential Apartments in Sulaimani City as Case Study. Diyala Journal of Engineering
Sciences, 13(2), 78-86.
Yahya, A. S. (2020). Rumah sebagai alat untuk keluar dari belenggu kemiskinan. Dicapai pada Mei 16, 2022, dari
https://bebasnews.my/2020/08/26/rumah-sebagai-alat-untuk-keluar-dari-belenggu-kemiskinan/
906