Literature Review: Impact of Business Intelligence (BI) on the Quality of

Decision Making

Name:

Student Registration Number:

School/Faculty:

Professors’ name:

Date of Submission:
 Abstract
This literature review discusses the trend in quality decision-making influenced by
Business Intelligence within organizations. Businesses in today's world depend so much on data-
driven insights, and as such, BI systems, which combine operational data with analytical tools,
have become so important to better the outputs of decision-making processes. It provides a
review of several research works by categorizing applications of BI in the health sector, financial
sector, customer relationship management, among others. This points towards the structured
nature of BI in processing raw data into information. In turn, this leads to some major benefits
that include increasing the accuracy of decisions, timely output, and elasticity within the
organization. In relation to major challenges linked to the implementation of BI, issues related to
the integration of data, users resisting new systems, and needs for continuous training come to
light. Literature also underlines critical gaps in research that range from developing a robust
model of evaluation of business intelligence to the ethical implications of its practice. Finally,
this review has underlined the fact that while BI significantly enhances the quality of decision-
making, knowing the grey line is important as to how far it pays off. The findings indicate a need
for ongoing research to optimize BI solutions and align them with organizational objectives,
fostering a culture of proactive decision-making in an era characterized by vast and complex data
landscapes.
Key words: Business Intelligence (BI), Decision Making, Data-Driven Insights,
Implementation Challenges, Ethical Considerations
 Table of Contents
Abstract............................................................................................................................................2

1.0 Introduction................................................................................................................................4

2.0 Theoretical underpinning in BI and the decision-making processes.........................................4

3.0 Impact of BI on Decision-Making Quality................................................................................5

4.0 Significance of BI to Decision Making.....................................................................................6

5.0 Key Components of BI..............................................................................................................6

6.0 Applications of BI and Their Impact on Decision Quality........................................................7

6.1 Sectors Using BI....................................................................................................................7

6.1.1 Health Care Sector:.........................................................................................................7

6.1.2 Retail Sector:...................................................................................................................8

6.1.3 Financial Sector:..............................................................................................................8

6.1.4 Business Applications and Efficiency:............................................................................8

6.1.5 Manufacturing Sector:.....................................................................................................8

6.1.6 Education Sector:............................................................................................................9

6.1.7 Cross-Sectoral Insights:...................................................................................................9

6.1.8 Telecommunication:........................................................................................................9

6.2 Enhancing the Quality of Decisions Made About BI............................................................9

7.0 Challenges with Implementation of BI....................................................................................10

8.0 BI in Future Context................................................................................................................11

9.0 Ethics in BI..............................................................................................................................12

Conclusion.....................................................................................................................................13
1.0 Introduction
The increasing amount of information that businesses have to deal with in the modern business
setting creates a demand for effective information management practices that will support better
decision-making. Business intelligence refers to a set of technologies and practices to change raw
data into meaningful insights for informed and better decision-making. This literature review
synthesizes existing research regarding the impact of BI on the quality of decision-making. It
will have the methodologies, applications, implications of BI across sectors, advantages,
challenges, and future directions for research in BI.

2.0 Theoretical underpinning in BI and the decision-making processes

Decision Support Systems (DSS) Fundamentally, BI systems are part of DSS, which covers
semi-structured and unstructured decision-making processes. The basic model for decision
proposed by Simon has, up to a point, remained the basis of all recent studies; however, recent
research, such as Sharma et al. (2020), has evidenced the way in which BI automates the
intelligence phase-data collection and processing-and facilitates the design and choice phases
through real-time analytics and visualization tools.

Data Warehousing and Data Quality Data warehousing theory underlines the integration,
coherence, and availability of data. New developments in dimensional modeling introduce better
structures of data organization, enabling effective analysis. Precise and timely data, stored in BI
systems, substantially enhances the reliability of decisions, as confirmed by Smith et al. (2021).

BI has evolved from integrating data to advanced analytics frameworks. In the year 2008, BI
focused on the integration of data mining and machine learning. In 2009, information extraction
techniques improved unstructured data analysis. In 2010, BI applications expanded into
performance management and customer analytics. Data collection strategies moved a step ahead
with big data technologies in the year 2011. Techniques of evaluation highlighted KPIs and
benchmarking by 2012. BI models and frameworks in 2013 combined business strategy with
analytics on cloud computing and AI. In fact, this was the beginning of modern BI systems that
help drive organizations to make better decisions based on facts.
Knowledge Management and Organizational Learning as more or less accepted, integrating the
knowledge creation model of Nonaka and Takeuchi has taken a very contemporary turn through
BI tools, some recent papers express that nowadays BI systems create substantial support by the
transformation process from tacit into explicit knowledge in organizational learning to improve
and shape a new cultural impact of organizational habits towards evidence-based management.

Fig.1: Evolution in business intelligence

Source Zhang et al. (2021)

3.0 Impact of BI on Decision-Making Quality

3.1 Enhanced Accuracy and Efficiency: The theory of Resource-Based View of RBV provides
a basis that indicates the circumstances under which firms will enjoy competitive advantages
when the resource of the BI system is competitively valuable, rare, inimitable, and non-
substitutable. Using the RBV framework, it has been documented in literature that BI decreases
human errors and enhances the accuracy of decisions with real-time insight through the work of
Zhang et al. (2021).

3.2. More Advanced Predictive Capabilities: Predictive analytics are at the core of BI, and
such forecasting models as ARIMA and machine learning approaches also go hand in glove with
BI. Such studies as Johnson et al. (2020) prove that BI enhances proactive decision-making
through analysis of historical data to identify trends.
3.3 Decision Support: The various strategic decision-making theories also cite the importance
of information, with the modes of strategy formation by Mintzberg leading the charge in this
regard. To this effect, BI solutions, as cited by Ahmed et al. (2023), involve complete dashboards
and reports for both deliberate and emergent approaches of strategies to be matched with
organizational objectives.

The theoretical perspectives reviewed from the past decade indicate that BI enhances decision-
making quality significantly through better accuracy, efficiency, and strategic fit. However,
challenges regarding data quality, integration, and user adoption need to be overcome if BI is to
be fully effective. Further research should be directed at how emerging technologies such as
artificial intelligence and machine learning can be integrated into BI to extend its capabilities.

4.0 Significance of BI to Decision Making

Business Intelligence plays a very vital role in the field of organizational decision-making.
Ranjan (2006) has pointed out that the main role of BI is to facilitate "converting large doses of
information into usable knowledge, thus enabling metrics-based management towards meeting
strategic business goals." BI enhances the understanding of data, and this phenomenon results in
better performance and competitiveness of an organization, as mentioned by Negash (2004).

The integration of operational data with the analytical tools ensures timely and relevant decision
inputs. Effective BI thus allows organizations to move from reactive to proactive decision-
making, hence responding effectively to dynamic market conditions. A proper understanding of
the role of BI illustrates its effect on the quality of decisions; hence, the critical need for
businesses to leverage these tools in pursuit of operational excellence.

5.0 Key Components of BI

The core components of BI include data warehousing, analytics, and reporting tools. These are
actually complementary parts in an overall analytic ecosystem, wherein all work to enable sound
decisions based on better insights to be made, as suggested by Ranjan, 2005; 2006. More
specifically, data warehousing makes it possible to systematically gather and store data in one
single source for analyses. Additionally, tools such as OLAP further increase the ability to
examine multi-dimensional queries about complex data, further increasing the decision
capabilities, as identified by Ranjan, 2005.
6.0 Applications of BI and Their Impact on Decision Quality
6.1 Sectors Using BI
Business intelligence has now turned into a backbone for modern organization decision-making.
The various tools and methodologies that turn raw data into action enable the organization to
make better decisions with the help of a BI system. Indeed, in organizations, BI is applied in
numerous sectors to present better decisions by using data-driven insights. BI systems improve
patient care in the health sector through enhancement in the quality of clinical decision-making
by analysis of data. For example, physicians can utilize BI tools to study treatment patterns by
analyzing patient data and hence make decisions that can lead to the best patient outcome. This
paper reviews the impacts of BI on decision quality in several industries: healthcare, retail,
finance, manufacturing, and education.

Fig 2: Applications of BI and Their Impact on Decision Quality

Source: Kiron & Shockley (2020)

6.1.1 Health Care Sector:

BI technologies are common in the health care sector, especially for improving clinical and
operational decisions. For example, various studies have indicated that BI enhances the ability to
better forecast patient outcomes, optimize resource utilization, and reduce costs on the part of
healthcare providers (Wang et al., 2019). For instance, predictive analytics using BI assists in the
identification of high-risk patients and management of chronic diseases. BI tools also
accommodate smoothing of administrative processes and improvement in high-quality service
delivery in health care (Kiron & Shockley, 2020).

6.1.2 Retail Sector:

The retail organizations use BI to draw some valuable insights about customer behavior, price
optimization, and efficient supply chain management. Research has pointed out that BI-powered
analytics enhances the segmentation of customers and personalized marketing of products at
retail stores. Due to the fact that most of the retailers implement BI tools in their business, they
identify various trends, thus predicting the demand for certain products with very high accuracy
and increasing their revenue through improved customer satisfaction.

6.1.3 Financial Sector:

In finance, the applications of BI are crucial in risk management. Companies, with the use of BI
analytics, can study the trends of the past, detect anomalies, and project future performances to
decide on strategic investment decisions. BI may help organizations conduct deep analyses of
customer data to develop strategies accordingly, hence playing an important part in customer
relationship management.

6.1.4 Business Applications and Efficiency:

Aruldoss et al. (2015) have identified seven broad categories of applications of BI, each
representing the unique contribution of the decision-making processes. Further, their research
classified applications in financial services, healthcare, retail, among others. It was clear that the
functionalities of the BI solutions are driven by the needs of each particular domain.

6.1.5 Manufacturing Sector:

The manufacturing firms apply BI in order to bring effectiveness in the areas of production
processes and reduction and waste and supply chain too. According to studies, BI enhances
operational efficiency by providing insights into machine performance, inventory levels, and
production schedules, Kamble et al., 2020. Advanced BI applications, such as predictive
maintenance, minimize down time and increase productivity.
6.1.6 Education Sector:
In the education sector, BI systems are used to enhance decision-making at the institutional level,
improve student outcomes, and efficiently use resources. Various studies have indicated that BI
tools help administrators to identify students who are at risk and develop appropriate
interventions to ensure academic success (Daniel, 2015). In addition, BI enables curriculum
planning and resource distribution based on enrollment trends and performance measures.

6.1.7 Cross-Sectoral Insights:

Across sectors, BI's impact on decision-making quality is variously contingent upon its
capability for timely, correct, and relevant insights. However, data quality, user training, and
integration of the system remain formidable barriers to realizing the full potential of BI. Those
organizations that invest in surmounting these obstacles often achieve superior outcomes; these
include increased strategic alignment and competitive advantage.

6.1.8 Telecommunication:
In the telecommunication industry, the use of BI to enhance the segmentation and customization
of service provided to customers is a very good example. According to Tanko & Musiliudeen
(2012), the usage pattern of every customer is analyzed by the BI tools to create specific
marketing campaigns in order to ensure revenue generation because of increased customer
engagement. Such usages depict how BI provides better decision quality by availing proper
insights to meet each business requirement.

Application of BI in the various fields has indicated the transformation in the quality of
decisions. Organizations use data-driven intelligence to develop methods that will balance
customer satisfaction, processes, and strategic objectives. Future research should investigate the
integration of emergent technologies, such as artificial intelligence and machine learning, for an
advanced decision-making capability into BI systems.

6.2 Enhancing the Quality of Decisions Made About BI

Improvement of decision-making quality has been one of the most important benefits of BI
systems that are cited consistently. For example, one study investigating the impact of BI showed
that organizations using BI systems saw significant improvement in the accuracy and timeliness
of decisions and decision outcomes, such as increased profitability and customer satisfaction.
Moreover, BI systems can allow a higher level of automation in decision-making. The managers
are empowered with dashboards and visualization tools that show key performance indicators in
real time so that they can act swiftly to emerging business trends. Such agility is highly
important in today's fast-moving business world where delay in processing information can
result in loss of opportunities.

7.0 Challenges with Implementation of BI

While the benefits of BI are large, a variety of factors prevent a proper implementation of BI
systems. Ranjan cited data integration, where organizations contain disparate data sources that
complicate the integration to be able to perform meaningful analytics. Even within existing data
management systems, there is still the headache of data coming in different formats on different
platforms. Recent research, such as that by Chen et al. (2020), proves that big data inflates the
integration problem, hence requiring advanced tools and strategies necessary for the
harmonization of a wide variety of data sources.

Another major critical issue for implementation in BI studies is data quality. Poor data quality
comprises inaccuracies, inconsistencies, and incomplete values, each of which impairs the
efficacy of the BI systems. Kumar et al. opine that organizations need to invest in cleansing and
data governance frameworks for valid analytical outcomes.

It will have, besides general user resistance; this is towards the deployment and use of these BI
systems because such employees "may perceive themselves as intrusive," as Aruldoss et al.
(2015) confirm, or less in need within an organization they have grown culturally dependent on
traditional applications of decision-supporting tools internally. This actually explains a form of
cultural resistance through which the attainment of identified organizational benefits of its
deployment is put up by the organization of strategy effect towards effective change. Davis and
Singh (2021) also reiterate that user resistance mostly emanates from a lack of training and a lack
of appreciation of the expected benefits from the BI. For this reason, organizations have to
educate users in order to integrate a data-driven decision-making culture.

Another challenge is that of security and privacy. BI systems use the sensitive organization's data
and customer data, making the latter become a target of cyberattacks. Zhang et al. (2022) argues
that with this understanding, implementation cybersecurity measures should be implemented
comprehensively, especially in this era of compliance with data protection policies such as
GDPR.

Finally, there are complexities in the integration of BI systems with operationally existing IT
infrastructures. Ahmed et al. report that many of the existing legacy systems usually lack
compatibility with modern BI toolkits and often result in certain inefficiencies, slowing the
processes of deployment. Effective integration will definitely require coordination from the IT
team with the BI solution vendors themselves.

8.0 BI in Future Context.

Even though the current era has marked vast improvements in various aspects of BI research
studies, some lacuna remains unexamined. Some of these require the formulation and
development of strong models pertaining to the performance evaluation of an effective BI
implementation, according to Aruldos et al. (2015) and Negash (2004); this will eventually
involve metrics suitable for matching BI activities to the intended organizational key result areas
or indicators. In the future, research should be directed toward the establishment of standardized
frameworks that can be used to determine the ROI in BI systems, integrating quantitative and
qualitative measures to give a holistic value of the systems.

In addition, future BI research will be driven by integrations of emerging technologies such as

AI, ML, and NLP. These can enhance predictive analytics capabilities for better forecasting and
scenario analysis. AI-powered automated recommendations may reduce decision-making time
and enhance operational efficiency. The integration of AI into BI will lead, in turn, to a possible
autonomous decision-making system in which decision choices dynamically change to
accommodate evolving conditions in the marketplace, as postulated by Chen et al.

Future research into the future direction of BI must include data ethics and governance at a
nascent stage, while ethical discussions pertaining to questions related to such variables as
personal information and other protected data properties grow in popular discourses-just as one
should expect as envisioned by Johnson et al. 2022: fairness in information and insights gleaned
via computation, responsibility within data-to-application flows; that is to say, there is every
hope that over the next year, researchers continue examining how design mechanisms offer a
process or set procedure enabling BI analytics and systems using BI to use business intelligence
information, algorithms provide logic, models serve to offer clear rationale for conclusions in a
verifiable, reliable fashion.

Lastly, democratization in BI is another developing trend that needs future research. More
friendly user interfaces and self-service BI tools allow non-technical users to have contact with
data analytics. Research here should move toward how these tools can be leveraged to provide
empowerment for all levels within the organization and lead to a data-driven culture. Davis and
Singh (2021) propose that future studies should focus on the influence of self-service BI upon
organizational decision-making and employee performance.

Addressing these areas could further help organizations unlock the full potential of data-driven
decision-making with additional future BI research, enabling them to sail through the intricacies
of a world filled with data.

9.0 Ethics in BI
With increased organizational reliance on data-driven insights, ethical considerations about the
usage, privacy, and security of data also come into play. Huge volumes of data are processed
through the BI systems, which contain highly sensitive information concerning persons and
organizations. This creates several ethical issues. Poor management of data will lead to
violations of privacy, misuse of information, loss of reputation, and hence calls for strong ethical
guidelines to be defined and considered while undertaking BI practices.

One of the important ethical issues involves data privacy. Organizations must comply with
regulations such as the General Data Protection Regulation and the California Consumer Privacy
Act, which require organizations to be transparent in data collection and use. BI systems should
be designed to anonymize personal data when necessary, making sure that no individual
identities are disclosed. Furthermore, transparency regarding how data is utilized builds trust
among stakeholders, as highlighted by Johnson et al. (2022).

Another critical issue is data security. BI systems are generally databases of critical business and
consumer data; hence, cyber criminals see them as honey pots. Zhang et al. say, "Security
protocols should be advanced, including encryption of data and multi-step authorization of
personnel, to protect against unauthorized access and data breaches." Additionally, resources for
cybersecurity need to be distributed equitably in order not to leave smaller organizations
disproportionately vulnerable.

Another ethical challenge relates to biased data analysis and decision-making. Most of the time,
BI systems are driven by algorithms that unconsciously tend to perpetuate biases in historical
data. For instance, Ahmed et al. (2023) have noted that biased algorithms may result in
discriminatory outcomes, especially in sectors involving hiring and lending. Such algorithms
need to be audited and validated by an organization on a periodic basis to ensure equity and
inclusion in decision-making. The important concepts that must be critically debated include
ethical implications regarding who owns the collected data when an asset becomes so valuable.
Organizations must obtain overt consent from data providers. Additionally, monetizing practices
need to be matched in a manner compatible with the original intent for collection. According to
Davis and Singh, 2021.

Last but not least, there should be ethics in place, which are relevant for ensuring responsible
usage of BI. The ethics include the training of staff for ethical ways of handling data,
appointment of data ethics officers, and cross-functional committees overseeing the BI activities.
According to Chen et al. (2020), in designing, deploying, and operating a BI system, ethics need
to be ensured for value creation of a sustainable and trusted data ecosystem. The focus of
research should also be on articulating comprehensive ethical frameworks for the BI practices
concerning challenges such as integrating artificial intelligence and machine learning. Ethical
issues, if dealt with in advance, can protect the interests of both organizations and consumers in
using BI systems.

Conclusion
Overall, the literature highlights how Business Intelligence can help in improving the quality of
decisions in organizations. In transforming raw data into actionable insight, BI prepares decision-
makers for the ability to navigate through a complex business environment. The diversity of
applications in various sectors adds to the utility of BI in facilitating informed decision-making.

However, careful management of the challenges associated with the implementation of BI is

required if the fullest benefits are to be derived. Future research should focus on the development
of frameworks for evaluation, integration of emerging technologies, and consideration of ethical
issues related to data use. As the adoption of BI systems continues, ongoing commitment to
improvement and responsible stewardship of data will ensure the long-term success of the
initiatives.

References

Ahmed, S., Khan, R., & Patel, T. (2023). Strategic decision-making with business
intelligence tools: A comprehensive review. Journal of Business Analytics, 8(1), 45-
60.

Aruldoss, M., Lakshmi, T. M., & Venkatesan, V. P. (2015). A survey on recent research in
business intelligence. Journal of Enterprise Information Management, 28(3), 456-475.

Aruldoss, M., Miranda Lakshmi, M., & Venkatesan, V. P. (2015). A survey on recent
research in business intelligence. Journal of Enterprise Information Management,
27(6), 831-866. http://dx.doi.org/10.1108/JEIM-06-2013-0029

Chen, H., Chiang, R. H., & Storey, V. C. (2020). Data-driven decision-making: Challenges
and best practices. MIS Quarterly, 44(2), 589-610.

Davis, R., & Singh, P. (2021). Adoption of business intelligence tools: Overcoming user
resistance. Information Systems Management, 38(4), 290-305.

Domo. (n.d.). How business intelligence is revolutionizing decision making. Retrieved

from https://www.domo.com
Fereydoon, A., & Mohammad, D. (2012). Business intelligence application in healthcare:
Improving patient care quality. International Journal of Healthcare Management,
5(3), 138-145.

Jalileh, M., Nooriafshar, M., & Rohani, S. (2011). Investigation of the impact of business
intelligence on the performance of financial institutions: A case study of the shahr
bank. International Journal of Trade, Economics and Finance, 2(3), 252-257.

Johnson, T., Lee, H., & Kim, S. (2022). Ethical considerations in big data analytics: A focus
on privacy and transparency. Journal of Data Ethics, 14(2), 102-120.

Krishnamoorthy, S. (2012). Business intelligence: The key to effective decision-

making. Journal of Business Management and Economics, 4(5), 100-107.

Kumar, A., Gupta, P., & Sharma, R. (2019). Enhancing data quality in business intelligence
systems: Frameworks and methodologies. Journal of Data and Information Quality,
11(3), 1-15.

Negash, S. (2004). Business intelligence. Communications of the Association for Information

Systems, 13(1), 177-195.

Ranjan, J. (2006). Business intelligence: Concepts, components, techniques and benefits.

Journal of Theoretical and Applied Information Technology.