Ethics Midterms With Finals Reviewer Module 1 6
Ethics Midterms With Finals Reviewer Module 1 6
It is about the moral decision process (HOW we arrive at the • Dilemmas are experiences where an agent is
moral decision). confused about the right decision to make
Ethics is not solely about theoretical knowledge but the because there are several competing values that
application of that knowledge…how to transform such are seemingly equally important and urgent.
knowledge into action in our everyday life.
4. Examine the assumptions or premises of arguments. Module 2: Understanding the Moral Agent
5. Be cautious in drawing conclusions from evidence. This module explores an agent to be a moral agent, what
culture is all about, how facets of personal behavior
6. Consider alternative interpretations of evidence. attribute to culture, how Filipino culture establishes Filipino
ethical identity, and how different cultures help shape the
7. Do not oversimplify.
universal ethical standard.
8. Do not overgeneralize.
What is a Moral Agent?
9. Apply critical thinking to all areas of life.
MORAL AGENCY - says that a particular agent can
Module 1: Lesson 2: Moral Dilemma appropriately, be held responsible for her actions and their
consequences. To better understand moral agency we will
What is Moral Dilemma? discuss here how to be a moral agent addressing the two
• Cambridge Dictionary: “a situation in which a questions:
choice has to be made between possibilities that
1. What makes Us us?
will all have results you do not want”
• Oxford Dictionary: “a situation in which a difficult 2. What makes any agent moral agent?
choice has to be made between two or more
alternatives, especially ones that are equally The advantage of dealing these things, it allows one to focus
undesirable.” on mechanisms rather that dwelling on mysteries. By
changing the context slightly, it forces one to re-consider
• At this core, a dilemma is a situation in which a one's comfortable familiarity with concepts like "I/me",
difficult choice has to be made between two or "we/us", and "moral agency".
According to Kant... an action cannot be morally good Make rational calculations of the consequences of
unless the agent in a fact reasoned in certain fairly complex our actions.
ways (allen et al, 2000, p. 253).
Hence, in this lesson, students will be articulated on how
We take a moral agent to be any agent to which it is culture shapes moral behaviour; understanding of right and
appropriate to attribute moral agency: that is, to be morally wrong in the Filipino context considering that there is
accountable for one's actions and their consequences. a universal values. Knowing the notion of culture from the
moral is we believe, necessarily a conceptual agent - three (3) perspective: personal, subconscious, and
example, an agent that possesses and employs concepts. universal. Then identifying the specific cultural
(the converse need not be true: a conceptual agent is not characteristics of Filipinos and Asians.
necessarily a moral agent: example, moral agents are a
subclass of conceptual agents.). According to Edward Tylor, Culture refers to that complex
whole which includes knowledge, beliefs, art, law, morals,
It is not enough, on our account, to be a moral agent that custom, and any other capabilities and habits acquired by
one does morally good things - contra what Colin Allen et al. man as a member of society.
ascribe to John Stuart Mill. No one, we believe - even the
die -hard utilitarian - would hold an agent morally Lesson 2.1. Filipino Culture and Ethics
responsible whose thoughts were not systematically and
productively structured in the manner of conceptual Filipino views on Ethics
thought. Regardless of whether Robbie the Robot is a moral The Filipino character
agent, my Aibo dog is not. Among other consequences, this Asian Westerner
means that it is not enough for the agent merely to
memorize a list of percepts. ETHICS AND CULTURE
Understanding the Moral Agent
M2: LESSON 2 - ETHICS AND CULTURE- FEATURES AND
CHARACTERISTICS OF CULTURE
Culture, Defined…
Ethics - simply means lead to study of human conducts, It refers to that complex whole which includes
study or Solomon says: a set of theories of value, virtue, or knowledge, belief, art, law, morals, custom, and
right (valuable) action. and for Johnson: it is a set of any other capabilities and habits acquired by man
theories that provide general rules or principles to be used as a member of society - Edward Tylor
in making those rules. It refers to an appreciation of good literature,
music, art, and food.
Ethics is important because it help us not only in For a biologist, it is likely to be a colony of bacteria
distinguishing between right and wrong but also in knowing or other microorganisms growing in a nutrient
why and on what grounds our judgment of human actions is medium in a laboratory Petri dish.
justified. For anthropologists and other behavioral scientists,
culture is the full range of learned human behavior
Why do we have Moral Theories? MacDonnell: Moral patterns.
Theories " seek to introduce a degree of rationality and
rigor into our moral deliberations." CORE LAYERS OF CULTURE
For Moral Decision-making considerations:
Primary - general
First, the body of cultural traditions that distinguish your Joe’s Pedicab Juan’s Tricycol
specific society
Filipinos’ View on Ethics:
When people speak of Italian, Samoan, or Japanese culture, Propriety (Hiya) versus Troubled (Pagkabagabag)
they are referring to the shared language, traditions, and Personal versus Duty/Obligations\
beliefs that set each of these peoples apart from others. Family solidarity versus universal principle and
general good
The second layer of culture that may be part of your Pakikipag kapwa tao versus Pakikisama
identity is the subculture.
The Filipino Character
This occurs in a complex, diverse societies in which people
have come from many different parts of the world, they
often retain much of their original cultural traditions
Culture survives if it can accommodate to changing Therefore: There are no such things as universal moral
conditions. Culture is viewed as a macro system, binds a standards or objective truths in Ethics.
particular society together, and includes its manners,
morals, tools, and techniques. Relativism in and of itself is self-defeating. Logically, there
must be some standard by which to compare
Culture is a group phenomenon, evolve from the interaction two different moral statements to determine which is the
of person with others, and a person's belief or behavior “more correct” one.
becomes part of the culture when it is externalized and
objectified. Moral relativists are also accused of inconsistently claiming
that there are no universal moral norms while appealing to
According to Erikson, cultures change through the action of a principle of tolerance as a universal norm.
persons whose ideas and behavior "fit" the culture. Change
can also occur as a result of a "paradigm shift" in Note:
fundamental understandings by those in the culture.
Cultural differences are real. But should not be exaggerated.
Culture is viewed as a ways of doing, being, and explaining, There is always a “value” behind cultural practices. Practices
as they exist in each particular system. As a culture may vary and in conflict to one another BUT the value
becomes more complex and differentiated, so too child behind the practices remain constant, thus, universally
rearing, and other social provisions appear. These new acceptable.
systems arise to realize more effectively the complex values
of a culture. Certain values are in conflict with certain other
values, leading to tension and strain within the culture. Module 3: Introduction and Objectives
Culture are marked by the style in which they conduct social This module refers to "The Act" that focuses on the
relationships. Caring is a dimension of culture as much as meaning, substantial elements, and classification of human
tools and language. Caring involves both an emotional acts and explains the chief acts of will and reason. Also, this
disposition and caring labor. it is a practice in which both will explain that moral courage is one of the most desirable
thought and action ate integrated around central aims or character traits in an individual.
goals.
Lastly, this module gives you the concept of Reason and
Hence, regardless of sex, individuals and groups who occupy Impartiality as requirements for ethics, evaluate real-life
subordinates status display a responsive orientation to cases against 7-step mode, a model that uses reason and
others characterized by difference, attentiveness, impartiality. Furthermore, you will be able to articulate
awareness of needs, understanding of perspectives, moods, knowing and actually doing a good moral decision, judge
intentions, and responsiveness. your own moral behavior in terms of planning and making
important moral experiences
Module 3 Lesson 1- HUMAN ACTS VS ACTS OF MAN
1. Knowledge - it is
employed in doing human
act. This is to say that when
the doer is conscious of his
or her actions, his or her
senses are active, and he or
she is aware of the reason
and the consequences of his There are circumstances where human acts may be
or her actions. modified and be deemed as acts of man. These are the
factors that diminish one's responsibility and impair the
2. Freedom - when the doer element of voluntariness of human act.
acts through his or her own initiative and choice without
being forced by another person or situation, then the act is 1. Ignorance- pertains to lack, want, or absence of
done on the basis of freedom. knowledge in a person capable of such.
3. Voluntariness - the act is done willfully when the doer 2. Passion or Concupiscence - defined as a compelling desire
consents to the act, accepting it as his or his own, and for something. It can also refer to a person's sexual desire
assume the accountability for its consequences. or lust.
Courage as Virtue
Both Plato and Aristotle wrote about courage as a virtue. Plato's Laches is a dialogue about nature of courage (literally translated,
"manliness"). Aristotle defined virtue as a purposive disposition, lying in a mean and being determined by the right reason.
Phenomenology of Feelings
“A sensitive heart is a rich source of ideas”
– Nikolai Karamzin
OBJECTIVES:
At the end the lesson, the students should be able to:
Scheler contends that the being and appearance of the As such, the values of culture are always spiritual
characteristics of objects are founded on feeling as a irrespective of the objects that may bear this value, and
response to value rather than on the presentation of an values of the holy still remain the highest values regardless
object as Husserl had argued of their bearers.
Love is the movement which "brings about the continuous 1. Values of the holy vs. disvalues of the unholy
emergence of ever-higher value in the object; on the part of 2. Values of the spirit (truth, beauty) vs. disvalues of
the lover .... true love opens our spiritual eyes to ever-higher their opposites
values in the object loved.” 3. Values of life and the noble vs. disvalues of the
vulgar
Hatred, on the other hand, is the closing off of oneself or 4. Values of pleasure vs. disvalues of pain
closing ones eyes to the world of values. 5. Values of utility vs. disvalues of the useless
Love and hate are not only reactions to felt- values…rather, Ranking of Values in Accordance to
"Love and hate are acts in which the value-realm becomes Va l u e s ’ E x i s t e n c e a n d N o n - E x i s t e n c e
accessible to the feelings of a being. is either extended
or narrowed.” 1. The existence of a positive value is itself a
positive value.
Love (hate) is not a psychical feeling; it has intentional 2. The existence of a negative value (disvalue) is
function (part of man’s willing and thinking); it is a value- itself a negative value.
cognition. 3. The non-existence of a positive value is itself a
negative value.
Material Value Ethics (Scheler) versus Formal Ethics (Kant) 4. The non-existence of a negative value is itself a
positive value
Values are given a priori, and are "feelable"
phenomena. Ranking of Values With Respect to Good and Evil
Values are not formal realities (they are not
objective realities); they do not exist somewhere 1. Good is the value that is attached to the realization
apart from the world and their bearers, and they of a positive value in the sphere of willing.
only exist with a value-bearer, as a value-being.
2. Evil is the value that is attached to the realization
of a negative value in the sphere of willing.
Summing up….
Values have true primacy as real inherent qualities
discovered in things, people, situations and the
like.
Values and immanent emotive experience are co-
extensive and intentional. The American psychologist Lawrence Kohlberg grouped
The correlates of feelings and emotions are values together children while they were still small and did a
study on the moral development of these people in a span
As a value being and bearer of values every
of about twenty years. He was interested in the
person is as unique
justification or reasoning behind the right behavior of the
Values are emotively intuited (it comes before
group and was able to mark out six stages of development.
reason).
Values are realized though personal apprehensions
(i.e. "attractions" and "repulsions") of positive (and
negative) qualities discoverable through our own
pre-thought, pre- willed acts of preference.
Stage Two
Instrumental-Purposive Orientation is the institution, the society, or the church. One
What is right is one's own immediate interest, and letting sees a given social issue from the perspective of a
others act also in their own interest. What is right is what is fixed system of laws and beliefs.
fair. You do your thing, I do my thing; we have fair equal
exchange. Post-Conventional - Universal Focused
• The reason is to satisfy one's need and admit the Stage 5: Common Good
needs of others in their own self-interest. While ▸ Standards of Society
other is after his/her own interest, I too have my ▸ Social Contract
own interest. If I do what is wrong, I might not Stage 6: Universal Principles
obtain my own interest. ▸ Decision of Conscience
▸ Logical Moral Principles
Conventional - Group- focused
Post-conventional level is concerned of the effort to define
Stage 3: Peer and Group Acceptance the moral values and principles that have validity and
Orientation application apart from the authority of groups or persons
▸Approval- Group Norms and the ability to see beyond laws and norms of society. It is
▸Loyalty- Belonging here that one examines, adopts, and applies the different
Stage 4: Legalistic Orientation(LAW) ethical frameworks or principles.
▸Law and Order
▸ Duty to Society Stage 5
Social Contract Orientation
Conventional Level is concerned with fulfilling role This stage includes what is right, individual rights, and
expectations, maintaining and supporting the social order, standards which have been critically examined and agreed
and identifying persons or groups involved in this order. upon. One says, “these rights have been examined, and
since they are right, they are the ones to be followed.”
Stage 3 Here, one is concerned that obligations be based on
Interpersonal Agreement Orientation calculations of overall utilty, what is really good for all. To a
What is deemed right is what pleases or helps others, what certain extent, there is universality in this good but still
is approved by others, what reinforces mutual relationships within basic human society, basic human agreements.
such as trust, loyalty, respect, and gratitude.
The reason for helping others, for pleasing others, The social perspective here views the rights of
for doing what is conventional or what is each as best protected when stability governs
mutually good for everyone is the need to be seen relations, when one recognizes that moral and
by the self and others as a loyal, caring legal perspectives sometimes differ and thus one
person(important here is my image to others), the may question the legal because it may not be
desire to maintain rules and authority that moral.
support your typical good behaviour and living up
to what significant others expect. Stage 6
• In relation to the social perspective, one takes the Universal Ethical Principles
group expectations that take primacy over Kohlberg was not able to observe this stage in his group ,
individaul interest. thus he projected it. What is right is following self chosen
ethical principles based on judgements that are
Stage 4 universalizable and consistent.
Social Structure Orientation What is right are the universal principles of justice, and the
What is right is doing one's duty, showing respects for laws, reason given are the validity of universal and moral
authority and society and contributing to the maintenance principles and the sense of personal commitment to these
of society and institutions. One's reason for doing one's duty principles.
and the like is that, action which breaks the social or moral
agreements impair the system which is a value. It would be The social perspective taken is the moral point of
hazardous to digress from conformity and from social view from which even the social arrangements
norms. are derived; from this universalizable moral point
One reason for this is that conscience is of view, moral judgments are made.
imperative to the moral law, to the ethical Thought of as an ideal, aspirational stage
system. Another reason is the maintenance of the
system for its own sake. The social perspective
takes the perspective of a generalized other and M4: While Task Lesson 1 Frameworks and Principles
not just the personal other. The generalized other
Lesson 1: Moral Framework and Principles action. Ethical obligations are the same for all rational
creatures.
What Exactly Is Moral Framework?
An ethical framework is a set of codes that an individual The Rights Approach, the second important approach to
uses to guide his or her behavior. Ethics are what people ethics has its roots in the philosophy of the 18th-century
use to distinguish right from wrong in the way they interact thinker Immanuel Kant and others like him, who focused on
with the world. So based on your moral judgment what you the individual's right to choose for herself or himself. what
think is the best solution for a particular problem is moral makes human beings different from mere things is that
framework. people have dignity based on their ability to choose freely
What they will do with their lives, and they have a
Why is it necessary? fundamental moral right to have these choices respected.
Moral values help in improving behavior, instilling respect
and enhancing relationships with others. Knowing what is The Fairness or Justice Approach (the best ethical action)
right or wrong is an important element in life that shapes protects the ethical rights of those who are affected by the
the character on an individual. Good moral values allow a action. It emphasizes the belief that all humans have a right
person to make the right decisions and improve their to dignity. Act in such a way that you treat humanity,
interactions with other people. whether in your own person or in the person of another,
always at the same time as an end and never simply as a
Lesson 2. Ethical Theories means to an end.
Ethical theories are often broadly divided into three types: Divine Command Approach sees what is right as the same
1. Consequentialist Theories as what God commands, and ethical standards are the
(The Utilitarian, Egoistic Approach) creation of God’s will. Following God’s will is seen as the
2. Non-consequentialist Theories very definition what is ethical. Because God is seen as
(The Common Good, Duty, Based, Right, omnipotent and possessed of free will, God could change
Justice, Fairness and Justice, Divine Command what is now considered ethical, and God is not bound by
Approach) any standard of right or wrong short of logical
3. Agent-cantered Theories (The Virtue, Feminist contradiction.
Approach
Agent-centered Theories
Consequentialist Theories or the Utilitarian
Approach analyze an issue using the utilitarian approach, The Virtue Approach assumes that there are certain ideals
we first identify the various courses of action available to toward which we should strive, which provide for the full
us. Second, we ask who will be affected by each action and development of our humanity. These ideals are discovered
what benefits or harms will be derived from each. And through thoughtful reflection on what kind of people we
third, we choose the action that will produce the greatest have the potential to become.
benefits and the least harm. The ethical action is the one
that provides the greatest good for the greatest number. Feminist Approach, in recent decades has been
supplemented and sometimes significantly revised by
The Egoistic Approach is one variation of the utilitarian thinkers in the feminist tradition, who often emphasize the
approach is known as ethical egoism, or the ethics of self- importance of the experiences of women and other
interest. In this approach, an individual often uses utilitarian marginalized groups to ethical deliberation.
calculation to produce the greatest amount of good for him
or herself. M4: Lesson 2 Chart of Main Contrasts between the three
Frameworks
Properties of Justice
The three essential properties of justice:
i. Justice always refers to another person. Strictly
speaking, there are no obligations of justice toward
oneself.
ii. The object of justice is not a free gift, but
something that is strictly due. Compensatory Justice
iii. Justice does not demand an approximate • refers to the extent to which people are fairly
compensation, but only what is exactly due, compensated for their injuries by those who have
neither more nor less.
injured them; just compensation is proportional to contribution the individual makes to a society, a
the loss inflicted on a person. task, a group, or an exchange.”
• concerns the fairness when restoring to a person How the value of the contribution is to be measured?
what the person lost when he or she was wronged 1. By work effort: the harder you work, the greater
by someone else. the benefits accrued to you.
2. Productivity: the greater the quantity the person
Conditions for obligation to Compensate injured party contributed, the greater the gains of the person.
1. The action inflicted was wrong and negligent.
2. The action was the real cause of the injury Justice based on Needs and Abilities: (Socialism)
3. The act was voluntarily inflicted. • “Work burden should be distributed according to
people’s abilities, and (but) benefits should be
Procedural or Retributive Justice distributed according to people’s needs.”
• Issues of procedural justice concern the fairness of • Acts 2:45,11:29, “From each according to his
how information is gathered or how a decision is ability, to each according to his need.”
made (fairness in the imposition of punishment Bases of Socialist Principle:
and penalties); also known as Retributive Justice. 1. People realize their human potential by exercising
• The punishment should be consistent and their abilities in productive work.
proportionate to the wrong act. If the purpose of a 2. Benefits of work should be used to promote
punishment is to deter others from committing the human happiness and well being, by distributing
same wrong or to prevent the wrongdoer from them to meet basic needs.
repeating the same wrong, then punishment
should not be greater than what is consistently Justice as Freedom: (Libertarianism)
necessary to achieve these aims. • “From each according to what he chooses to do, to
Distributive Justice each according to what he makes for himself and
• Refers to the extent to which society's institutions what others choose to do for him and choose to
ensure that benefits and burdens are distributed give him of what they’ve been given previously and
among society's members in ways that are fair and have not yet expanded or transferred.”
just. • “From each as they choose, to each as they are
• When the institutions of a society distribute chosen.”
benefits or burdens in unjust ways, there is a Critique:
strong presumption that those institutions should 1. Freedom from coercion at the expense of other
be changed. rights and values.
• Issues of distributive justice concern the fairness of 2. It will generate unjust treatment for the
the distribution of something among several disadvantaged.
people or groups.
Theories on Justice Justice as Fairness:
1. Justice as Equality • The distribution of benefits and burdens in a
2. Justice based on Contribution society is just, if and only if:
3. Justice based on Needs and Abilities 1. Each person has an equal right to the most
4. Justice as Freedom extensive basic liberties compatible with similar
5. Justice as Fairness liberties;
2. Social and economic inequalities are arranged so
Justice as Equality: (Egalitarianism) that they are both:
• All burdens and benefits should be distributed a) to the greatest benefits of the least advantaged
according to the formula: people and
• “Every person should be given exactly equal shares b) attached to offices and positions open to all under
of a society’s or a group’s benefits and burdens.” conditions of FAIR and EQUALITY of opportunities.
• Critique 1: Humans are not equal in terms of
abilities, values, needs, desires, physical
characteristics. M6 - Lesson 1: Globalization and its Ethical Challenges
• Critique 2: Egalitarians ignore some characteristics Lesson 1: Globalization and its Ethical Challenges
that should be taken into accounting in the
distribution of goods: need, ability, effort. What is Globalization?
Globalization is a process of interaction and integration
Justice based on Contribution: (Capitalism) among the people, companies, and governments of
• For Capitalist Justice: “Benefits should be different nations, a process driven by international trade
distributed according to the value of the and investment and aided by information technology.
Likewise, for centuries, people and corporations have Resistance to globalization has therefore taken shape both at
invested in enterprises in other countries. In fact, many of a popular and at a governmental level as people and
the features of the current wave of globalization are governments try to manage the flow of capital, labor, goods,
similar to those prevailing before the outbreak of the First and ideas that constitute the current wave of globalization.
World War in 1914.
M6 - Lesson 1.1 - Various Aspects of Globalization Various
But policy and technological developments of the past Aspects of Globalization
few decades have spurred increases in cross-border
trade, investment, and migration so large that many Globalization has various aspects which affect the world in
observers believe the world has entered a qualitatively several different ways. These aspects include:
new phase in its economic development.
Industrial globalization – development of
Since 1950, for example, the volume of world trade has worldwide production markets and broader
increased by 20 times, and from just 1997 to 1999 flows access to a range of foreign products for
of foreign investment nearly doubled, from $468 billion consumers and companies involving
to particularly movement of material and goods
$827 billion. Distinguishing this current wave of between and within national boundaries.
globalization from earlier ones, author Thomas Friedman Financial globalization – development of
has said that today globalization is “farther, faster, worldwide financial markets and better access
cheaper, and deeper.” to external financing for borrowers.
Economic globalization – establishment of a
This current wave of globalization has been driven by global common market, based on the freedom
policies that have opened economies domestically and of exchange of goods and capital.
internationally. In the years since the Second World War, Political globalization - creation of
and especially during the past two decades, many international organizations to regulate the
governments have adopted free-market economic relationships among governments and to guarantee the
systems, vastly increasing their own productive potential rights arising from social and economic globalization.
and creating myriad new opportunities for international Informational globalization – increase in
trade and investment. information flows between geographically
Governments also have negotiated dramatic reductions in remote locations. (This can also be seen as a
barriers to commerce and have established international technological change related to the advent of
agreements to promote trade in goods, services, and fibre optic communications, satellites, and
investment. increased availability of telephone and
Internet.)
Taking advantage of new opportunities in foreign markets, Cultural globalization - sharing of ideas,
corporations have built foreign factories and established attitudes and values across national borders.
production and marketing arrangements with foreign This sharing generally leads to an
partners. A defining feature of globalization, therefore, is an interconnectedness and interaction between
international industrial and financial business structure. peoples of diverse cultures and ways of life.
Mass media and communication technologies
Technology has been the other principal driver of are the primary instruments for cultural
globalization. Advances in information technology, in globalization.
particular, have dramatically transformed economic life.
Corruption
Information technologies have given all sorts of individual Corruption is a concept that agglomerates practices
economic actors—consumers, investors, businesses— ranging from multi-million dollar payments to high
valuable new tools for identifying and pursuing economic government officials to a few dollars bribe to a low-level
opportunities, including faster and more informed analyses bureaucrat. It is estimated that over $1 trillion are paid in
of economic trends around the world, easy transfers of bribes annually, which squanders public resources and
assets, and collaboration with far-flung partners. deprives millions of food, education and other government
services to which they are entitled. Millennial Generation is also known as Generation Y,
because it comes after Generation X — those people
Bribery in foreign operations was not always considered between the early 1960s and the 1980s. The publication Ad
morally wrong. Some even saw it as a normal operating Age was one of the first to coin the term "Generation Y," in
expense when doing business in emerging economies. an editorial in August 1993. But the term didn't age well,
German corporate law, while severely punishing bribery and "Millennials" has largely overtaken it. But the terms
at home, considered foreign bribes as tax deductible basically mean the same thing.
expenses.
Millennials Characteristics
Attitudes toward bribery changed in the late 1970s after Millennials have been characterized in a number of
the US Congress passed the Foreign Corrupt Practices Act different ways. On the negative side, they've been
which outlawed paying bribes abroad for American described as lazy, narcissistic and prone to jump from job
companies. to job. The 2008 book "Trophy Kids" by Ron Alsop discusses
It is beyond doubt that bribing foreign officials to win a how many young people have been rewarded for minimal
contract is immoral. However, less clarity exists in other accomplishments (such as mere participation) in
situations. For example, is it acceptable to bribe a low- competitive sports, and have unrealistic expectations of
level bureaucrat to speed up a procedure he is supposed working life.
to do anyway? A story in Time magazine said polls show that Millennials
Small payments are tolerated in some countries and even "want flexible work schedules, more 'me time' on the job,
rationalized by the need to supplement the meager and nearly nonstop feedback and career advice from
salaries earned by public officials. It is not always clear, managers." Another Time story in May 2013, titled "The
however, what should count as a “small payment”. In Me Me Me Generation," begins: "They're narcissistic.
April 2012, it was reported that Walmart paid more than They're lazy. They're coddled. They're even a bit delusional.
$24 million to Mexican officials to speed up permits to Those aren't just unfounded negative stereotypes about 80
open new branches. Payments were made to expedite a million Americans born roughly between 1980 and 2000.
process that officials should have executed anyway. Is They're backed up by a decade of sociological research."
$24 million a “small payment” for a company the size of The article also points out that Millennials may be simply
Walmart? adapting quickly to a world undergoing rapid technological
change.
In some cases, cultural differences exist in the They have also been described in positive ways. They are
appropriate relationship between a company and its generally regarded as being more open-minded, and
stakeholders. Following China’s integration in the global
economy, scholars became interested by the ethical more supportive of gay rights and equal rights for
status of guanxi, informal networks of favor exchange minorities.
between companies and public officials.
Other positives adjectives to describe them include
Since it is not a specific payment for a particular service, confident, self-expressive, liberal, upbeat and receptive to
guanxi does not fit into the conventional definition of new ideas and ways of living.
bribery. Advocates of guanxi argue that the definition of
bribery is based on a Western concept of impartiality Though viewed as more liberal, some Millennials are
that is not necessarily shared by all cultures. bucking the trend. A study published March 31, 2017 by
the Council on Contemporary Families found that high
Critics contend that guanxi is similar to Western mafia school seniors increasingly believe that the man should be
practices of “today you scratch my back and tomorrow I the bread-winner in a relationship and a woman should
will scratch yours”. It is unclear whether these exchanges care for the home. "It's been a steady reversal," said study
of favors constitute a form of corruption or whether it is co- author Joanna Pepin, a doctoral candidate in sociology
a legitimate way of doing business in the Chinese market. at the University of Maryland.