1 1 of

13

SARA IMRAN
F2023105143
Database systems (Y3)
Assignment#01

Submitted to:
SIR HAMID RAZA MALIK.

1
2 2 of
13

Abstract
File Management Systems (FMS) are foundational components of early data storage and
retrieval technologies. Before the widespread adoption of Database Management Systems
(DBMS), organizations relied on file-based systems to manage and manipulate data. An
FMS enables basic operations such as data storage, retrieval, updating, and deletion by
interacting directly with files on storage media. This paper explores the structure,
functionality, and ongoing relevance of File Management Systems in database
environments. It discusses the core role of FMS in supporting essential data operations
and highlights its key limitations, including data redundancy, lack of integrity constraints,
limited querying capabilities, and security concerns.

Despite these shortcomings, File Management Systems remain valuable in specific

applications, particularly in scenarios that prioritize simplicity, speed, and low-cost
implementation. A practical case study of a small retail inventory management system
demonstrates how FMS can effectively support business operations using simple tools
like CSV files and lightweight programming logic. This example underscores the utility
of FMS for small-scale applications, especially when database complexity and overhead
are not justified.

The paper concludes by reflecting on the relevance of File Management Systems in

modern computing. While DBMS solutions offer robust features for complex data
environments, FMS continues to serve niche needs where straightforward data
management is sufficient. Understanding FMS provides valuable insight into the
evolution of data systems and equips practitioners with the knowledge to make informed
decisions about data architecture, especially in resource-constrained or legacy contexts.

File Management Systems

Introduction

File Management Systems (FMS) are essential components of computing environments,

particularly within the realm of database systems. A File Management System is
responsible for managing data files in a structured and efficient manner. It provides
services such as data storage, retrieval, and update mechanisms, while also ensuring data
security and integrity. FMS operates at the lowest level of a database system, interacting
closely with the operating system to facilitate effective file handling. Despite the
emergence of more advanced database models, File Management Systems remain
relevant, particularly in small-scale or legacy systems.

2
3 3 of
13
Components of a File Management System

1. File System Interface

The file system interface allows users and applications to interact with the file system. It
includes commands for creating, deleting, and modifying files, as well as organizing
them into directories and subdirectories. The interface ensures a user-friendly experience
when dealing with complex file systems.

2. File Management Tools

These tools aid in searching, indexing, and managing files. Some tools also provide file
version control, enabling users to track file changes over time. File management tools are
critical for businesses dealing with large amounts of data and require quick retrieval and
high accuracy.

3. File Organization and Metadata

File organization is about how files are structured within the system. It involves
organizing files into directories or folders to streamline access. Metadata plays a crucial
role by storing information about each file, such as its size, creation date, modification
history, and access permissions, ensuring that files are easily identifiable and accessible.

Role of File Management Systems in Database Systems

In the early days of computing, before the advent of modern database management
systems (DBMS), organizations relied on file-based systems to manage their data. These
systems used file formats such as text files, CSV, or proprietary binary formats to store
data. File Management Systems played a pivotal role by enabling users and programs to
access and manipulate data directly from these files.

An FMS provides various functionalities that support database operations. These include:

1. Data Storage and Retrieval

 The FMS is responsible for managing the physical storage of the data. In a
DBMS, when data is stored in tables or indexes, the FMS determines how and
where to store these data elements on disk.
 Efficient retrieval: The FMS ensures that data is stored in such a way that it can
be quickly retrieved when requested, optimizing performance and minimizing
access time.

3
4 4 of
13
2. File Organization and Structure

 The FMS supports file organization methods such as sequential, indexed, and
hashed files. The structure of these files is critical in how quickly data can be
retrieved, updated, or deleted.
 For example, an indexed file may use an index to speed up data retrieval, whereas
a sequential file organizes records in a linear order, suitable for batch processing
tasks.

3. Data Integrity and Consistency

 File integrity: The FMS ensures the integrity of the files by preventing data
corruption due to disk failures or system crashes. It provides mechanisms to
maintain the consistency of the data stored in files, which is critical for
transactional systems within DBMS.
 Atomic operations: The FMS works with the DBMS to ensure that data
modifications (inserts, updates, deletes) are performed atomically, meaning either
the entire transaction is committed, or none of the changes are applied (rollback
in case of failures).

4. Backup and Recovery

 The FMS plays a vital role in data backup and recovery mechanisms within
DBMS. It provides tools to periodically back up data files and restore them in the
event of a system crash or hardware failure.
 Transaction logs: The FMS may work alongside transaction logs that track
changes made to the database, ensuring that if a failure occurs, the system can be
rolled back to a consistent state.

5. File Access and Security

 The FMS is responsible for managing file access control. It ensures that only
authorized users or processes can read, write, or modify certain files. This is
especially important for DBMS security, where sensitive data needs to be
protected.
 Access permissions: The FMS enforces read/write permissions on data files,
limiting unauthorized access or modification, which is vital for maintaining the
confidentiality of the data.

4
5 5 of
13
6. Concurrency Control

 When multiple users or applications are accessing the DBMS concurrently, the
FMS plays a role in managing file-level concurrency control. It ensures that data
modifications are handled in such a way that one transaction does not interfere
with another, preventing issues like data inconsistency.
 The FMS coordinates with the DBMS’s locking mechanisms to ensure that only
one process can modify a file at a time while allowing concurrent read
operations.

7. File Compression and Space Management

 Compression: To optimize storage and reduce disk usage, the FMS may use
techniques like file compression, where data files are compressed to save
space without sacrificing retrieval speed.
 Space management: The FMS ensures that disk space is allocated efficiently by
maintaining a free space manager that tracks available storage. This is
important for managing large databases and ensuring that there is enough space
for future data growth.
Although FMS lacks the sophisticated features of DBMSs, such as complex
querying or transaction management, it is still widely used where simplicity and
performance are prioritized.

8. Indexing and Search Optimization

 Index files: The FMS works in tandem with the DBMS to manage
indexes on database tables. Indexes improve the speed of data
retrieval by providing a faster way to locate records in a large
dataset.
 The FMS also manages search optimization by maintaining
index files that allow the DBMS to quickly locate records
without having to scan entire tables.

G. Data Migration and File Conversion

 When a DBMS needs to migrate data from one system to

another (e.g., from a local server to the cloud), the FMS
supports data migration and the conversion of file formats to
ensure compatibility across different systems.
 This is particularly important when upgrading or changing
database systems or platforms, where files need to be transferred
5
6 6 of
13
without loss of data integrity.

6
 7 7 of
13
10. Storage Management

 The FMS is responsible for managing the storage medium

where data resides, which can be disk-based, cloud
storage, or even networked storage systems. It ensures
that the DBMS can efficiently manage the physical storage,
allocate and deallocate storage space as needed.
 Disk space management: The FMS ensures that large
volumes of data (often exceeding hundreds of gigabytes or
more) are managed effectively, allocating disk space without
causing fragmentation or inefficiencies.

11. Support for File-based and Hybrid Systems

 In hybrid database systems, where both file-based and

database management techniques are used, the FMS facilitates
seamless integration of database management with file-based
storage. This allows the DBMS to store non-relational data (e.g.,
documents, images) in files while maintaining structured
relational data in tables.
 Mixed data types: For instance, in a DBMS that manages
both relational data and unstructured data like images or
videos, the FMS supports file storage for these large objects
(LOBs - Large Objects) while DBMS handles structured data in
relational formats.

Critical Issues in File Management Systems

Despite their advantages, File Management Systems come with several limitations and
challenges:

1. Data Redundancy and Inconsistency: Since data is stored in multiple files

without central control, redundant data often leads to inconsistencies.
2. Lack of Data Integrity: Ensuring data validity across multiple files is difficult
without built-in integrity constraints.
3. Limited Querying Capabilities: Unlike relational databases, FMS does not
support complex querying languages like SQL.
4. Security Issues: File systems generally provide basic security features which
may not be sufficient for sensitive data.
7
8 8 of
13
5. Difficult Backup and Recovery: Manual processes or custom scripts are often
required to back up and restore data, increasing the risk of errors.
6. Poor Scalability: As the volume of data grows, managing files
becomes increasingly difficult and inefficient.

8
 9 9 of
13
These limitations have led many organizations to adopt more advanced DBMS solutions.
However, understanding these issues is crucial for effectively working with or
transitioning from FMS-based systems.

Application of File Management Systems: A Case Study

One notable application of File Management Systems is in the development of simple

inventory management systems for small businesses. These systems often do not require
the full complexity of relational databases and instead opt for file-based data storage.

Case Study: Small Retail Inventory System

A small retail store implemented an inventory management system using a File

Management System to manage product stock levels, sales, and restocking schedules.
The system used CSV files to store different datasets:

 products.csv for product details

 sales.csv for recording transactions
 stock_levels.csv for tracking inventory

The application, developed in Python, used the csv module to interact with these files. It
allowed the store manager to:

 Add new products

 Update stock levels after each sale
 Generate sales reports

This simple file-based system met the business requirements without incurring the overhead
of a full-scale DBMS. While not suitable for larger businesses, it exemplifies how FMS
can still be effectively used in niche applications.

Conclusion

File Management Systems represent a fundamental aspect of data management in

computing. Though largely replaced by advanced database systems in large-scale
applications, FMS continues to be relevant in specific contexts where simplicity, control,
and low overhead are priorities. Understanding the strengths and weaknesses of File
Management Systems is essential for database professionals, particularly when dealing
with legacy systems or developing lightweight data solutions.

By examining real-world applications such as small retail inventory systems, we can appreciate
the continued utility of File Management Systems. As technology evolves,

9
1 10 of
0 13
FMS will likely retain its place in specific domains, serving as a reliable and
straightforward method for managing data.

References

1. Silberschatz, A., Korth, H. F., & Sudarshan, S. (2020). Database System Concepts
(7th ed.). McGraw-Hill Education.
URL: https://www.db-book.com

This is a widely used textbook that explains fundamental concepts of database systems,
including file organization and file-based systems.

2. Date, C. J. (2003). An Introduction to Database Systems (8th ed.). Addison-

Wesley.
URL: https://archive.org/details/introductiontoda00date_0

Offers in-depth discussion on database models and contrasts between file-based systems
and DBMS.

3. TutorialsPoint. (n.d.). File-Based System.

URL: https://www.tutorialspoint.com/dbms/dbms_file_based_system.htm

Provides a beginner-friendly overview of file-based systems, their architecture, and

drawbacks.

4. GeeksforGeeks. (n.d.). File System vs DBMS.

URL: https://www.geeksforgeeks.org/difference-between-file-system-and-dbms/

Highlights the key differences between traditional file systems and modern DBMS.

5. W3Schools. (n.d.). Working with CSV files in Python.

URL: https://www.w3schools.com/python/python_csv.asp

Helpful for the practical case study part involving inventory systems using file-based
storage.

1
0
1 11 of
1 13

Article 1: File-based Data Management System

Source: TutorialsPoint
URL: https://www.tutorialspoint.com/dbms/dbms_file_based_system.htm

File-based Data Management System

A File-based Data Management System is a system for managing data through files
stored on a computer system. These systems are considered as the predecessors of
modern database systems. They are mainly used to manage simple data structures,
especially for home users and small businesses.

Features of File-based Systems:

1. Data Redundancy:
a. Multiple copies of the same data may exist in different files.
b. Redundant data leads to inconsistencies when data is updated in one file
and not in others.
2. Data Isolation:
a. Data is stored in various files, making it difficult to access and integrate.
3. Data Integrity Issues:
a. Ensuring accuracy and consistency becomes a challenge in a file-
based system.
4. Security Constraints:
a. There is no robust security mechanism for access control.
5. Concurrency Access Problems:
a. File systems usually don’t support simultaneous data access by
multiple users.

Advantages of File-based Systems:

 Simplicity: Easy to design and understand for small systems.

 Low Cost: No expensive software/hardware required.
 Control: Full control over file organization and storage.

1
1
 12 12 of
13
 Good for Small Applications: Works well for single-user or small-
scale applications.

Disadvantages of File-based Systems:

 Data Redundancy and Inconsistency

 Lack of Security
 Poor Data Integrity
 Limited Data Sharing
 Difficult Maintenance and Upgrades

Conclusion:

File-based systems work best for simple applications but have critical limitations in
handling large-scale, multi-user data management requirements. As a result, they have
mostly been replaced by more sophisticated database systems in modern applications.

Article 2: Difference Between File System and DBMS

Source: GeeksforGeeks
URL: https://www.geeksforgeeks.org/difference-between-file-system-and-dbms/

Difference Between File System and DBMS

File System:

A file system is software that manages and organizes files on a storage device. It provides basic
functionalities such as storing, retrieving, naming, and organizing data files.
Commonly used file systems include NTFS, FAT32, and ext4.

12
13 13 of
13
DBMS:

A Database Management System (DBMS) is a software system that facilitates the

creation, manipulation, and management of data in a structured format. It provides
various functionalities like multi-user access, data integrity, query processing, and secure
access.

Key Differences:

Feature File System DBMS

Data High Low
Redundancy
Data Difficult to Easy due to integrity
Consistency maintain constraints
Data Integrity Difficult to Enforced through schemas and
enforce rules
Data Security Low High (user-level access control)
Concurrency Limited or none Supports multiple users and
Control transactions
Query Basic file Advanced SQL support
Capability access
Backup and Manual Automated and robust tools
Recovery available
Data Hard to model Easy with relational models
Relationships

13