Extracted Pages 168 178
Extracted Pages 168 178
Now let’s see what we have got. Later we’ll show, that the Γi coefficients are just ∂iϕ in the Newtonian
theory. E.g. in our case we have: 00
where we have defined r′ = (x′, y′, 0). This is just the centrifugal force. Also observe, that we could have
read ϕ directly from the metrics itself — just compare it to the Lorentzian metrics (with gravitation) in the
next chapter.
The other two terms (Γ′102, Γ′201and the symmetric ones) don’t behave as a gravitational force, but rather only
act when we are differentiating (e.g. only act on moving bodies). Below we show this is just the −2ω × dr d
t
term (responsible for the Coriolis acceleration).
Let’s write the full equations of geodesics:
d2 x 0
=0
dλ2
d2 x 1 dx2 dx0
+1 dx0 + 1 =0
Γ 2Γ
2
dλ 2 00 20
dλ dλ
dλ
d2 x 2 dx1 dx0
+2 + 2 =0
Γ dx0 2Γ
2
00
dλ2 dλ 10
dλ dλ
d2 x 3
=
dλ2
0
This becomes:
d2x dy
2
+ 2ω
= xω dt
dt2
dy
2
2 dx
= yω
dt d2z — 2ω
2
dt
=0
dt2
we can define r = (x, y, 0) and ω = (0, 0, ω). Then the above equations can be rewritten as:
2
dr 2
= rω dr
2
dt — 2ω ×
dt
So we get two fictituous forces, the centrifugal force and the Coriolis
force. Now imagine a static vector in the xµ system along the x axis, i.e.
3.40. Differential Geometry 1 1
Theoretical Physics Reference, Release 0.5
10
Vµ= =V
0
2 Chapter 3. Mathematics
Theoretical Physics Reference, Release 0.5
then
′ 1 1
′µ ′ ′
∂x ∂x −xω sin ωt + yω cos ωt + cos ωt y ω + cos ωt
V = −xω cos ωt − yω sin ωt − sin ωt = −x′ω − sin ωt′ = V ′
′µ
V =∂xα V α =
∂x
0 0
In the last equality we transformed from xµ to x′µ using the relation between frames.
Differentiating any vector in the xµ coordinates is easy – it’s just a partial derivative (due to the Euclidean
metrics). Let’s differentiate any vector in the x′µ coordinates with respect to time (since t = t′, the time
is the same in both coordinate systems):
µ
∇0V ′µ = ∂0V ′µ + Γ0α V ′α
′0
VV′0 ′1 ∂0V ′1 + Γ∂10VV ′0 + Γ1 V ′2
′0
∂0V ′1 − x∂′ω 0V2V ′0 − ωV ′2
∇0 V ′2 = ∂ V ′2 + Γ20000V ′0 + Γ20102 ′1 = ∂ V ′2 — y ω
′ 2V ′0 + ωV ′1 =
0 0
V ′3 ∂0V ′3 V ∂0V ′3
′0 ′0
V ′1 −x′ω02 00 −ω 0 00 VV ′1
= ∂0 V + (3.40.2.3)
V −y ω
′2 ′ 2
ω 0 0 V ′2
V ′3 0 0 0 V ′3
0
For our particular (static) vector this yields:
1 0
y′ω + cos ωt′ 0
∇0 ′ =
0
−x ω − sin ωt′
0 0
as expected, because it was at rest in the xµ system. Let’s imagine a static vector in the x′µ system along
the x′ axis, i.e.
11
W′µ =0
0
µ 1
′ ′ ′ ′ ′
1
∂x −x ω sin ωt − y ω cos ωt + cos ωt −yω + cos ωt
W = x′ω cos ωt′ − y′ω sin ωt′ + sin ωt′ = xω + sin ωt
µ ′α
W =
∂x ′α
0 0
then
0′ 2
′µ 1 −x ω
∇ 0W = ∇0 1 = ′ 2
0 −y ω + ω
0 0
1
0 0 0 0 0 0
−yω + cos ωt −ω sin ωt 0 0 −ω 0 cos ωt
∇ 0 W µ = ∂0 xω + sin ωt = ω cos ωt
= 0 ω 0 0 sin ωt = ω × W
0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Similarly
0
−y ω − ω
′ 3 2
′µ
∇0∇0W ==
—x′ω3
0
20
∇0∇0W == −ω
µ cos ωt
−ω2 sin ωt
0
How can one prove the relation:
dA d
′
A (3.40.2.4)
=ω×A +
dt dt
that is used for example to derive the Coriolis acceleration etc.? We need to write it components to under-
stand what it really means:
0 0 0 0 ′1A′0 ′0
A′0 0 0 −ω 0 A A
A′1 A′1
∇0 ′2 = + ∂0
A 0 ω 0 0 A′2 A′2
A′3 0 0 0 A ′3
A′3
0
Comparing to the covariant derivative above, it’s clear that they are equal (provided that x′ = 0 and y′ =
0, i.e. we are at the center of rotation).
Let’s show the derivation by Goldstein. The change in a time dt of a general vector G as seen by an observer
in the body system of axes will differ from the corresponding change as seen by an observer in the space
system:
Now consider a vector fixed in the rigid body. Then (dG)body = 0 and
(dG)rot = (dG)space = dΩ × G
For an arbitrary vector, the change relative to the space axes is the sum of the two effects:
(dG)space = (dG)body + dΩ × G
Gi = ajiG j
′
Let’s make the space and body instantaneously coincident at time t, then aji = δji and daji = —ϵijkdΩk =
ϵikjdΩk, so we get the same equation as earlier:
dGi = dG i + ϵikjdΩkG j
′ ′
+ω×
body G
Let’s start with some notations: By u = (u1, u2, u3)T we denote the displacement vector in 3D Cartesian
coordinates, and by ϵ the tensor of small deformations,
1 ∂ui ∂uj
ϵ = + , 1 ≤ i, j ≤ 3.
ij
2 ∂xj ∂xi
where
3 ∂u 3
divu = Σ = Σ ϵ
k
= Tr(ϵ).
kk
k=1 ∂xk k=1
The symbols λ and µ are the Lam'e constants and δij is the Kronecker symbol (δij = 1 if i = j and δij = 0
otherwise). The equilibrium equations have the form
3
Σ ∂σ
∂xijj + fi = 0, 1 ≤ i ≤ 3, (3.40.2.6)
j=1
where (f1, f2, f3)T is the vector of internal forces (such as gravity).
The boundary conditions for linear elasticity are given by
ui = uˆ i on Γ1
3
Σ
σijnj = gi on Γ2,
j=1
Weak formulation
6 Chapter 3. Mathematics
Theoretical Physics Reference, Release 0.5
Thus
g ∫
3 ∂v i ∫ f i v i, 1 ≤ i ≤ 3. (3.40.2.8)
∫ σij — i vi =
Σ
Ω j=1 ∂xj Γ2 Ω
First let us show how the partial derivatives of a scalar function g are transformed from Cartesian coordinates
x1, x2, x3 to cylindrical coordinates r, ϕ, z. Note that
x1(r, ϕ) = r cos ϕ, x2(r, ϕ) = r sin ϕ, x3(z) = z.
Since
Using (3.40.2) and the fact that ur does not depend on ϕ, this yields
∂u1 ∂ur 1
= cos2 2
∂x1 ∂r ϕ + u r sin ϕ,
∂ur r 1
∂u1 = cos ϕ sin ϕ — cos ϕ sin ϕ,
u
∂x2 ∂r r r
∂u1 = ∂u r
cos ϕ.
∂x3 ∂z
Analogously, for u2 we calculate
∂u2 ∂ur 1
= cos ϕ sin ϕ — u cos ϕ sin ϕ,
∂x1 ∂r r r
∂u =
2 ∂u r 2 1 2
∂x2 sin
∂r ϕ + u r cos ϕ,
∂u r
∂u2 = r
sin ϕ.
∂x3 ∂z
For u3, using that it does not depend on ϕ, we have
∂u3 ∂uz
= cos ϕ,
∂x1 ∂r
∂u3 ∂uz
= sin ϕ,
∂x2 ∂r
∂u3 ∂uz
∂x3 = ∂z .
For further reference, transform also divu into cylindrical coordinates
∂u1 ∂u2 ∂u3
divu = + + =
∂x1 ∂x2 ∂x3
∂ur 2 1 2 ∂ur 2 1 2 ∂uz
= cos ϕ+ sin ϕ+ =
∂r ϕ + ur ∂r ϕ + ur ∂z
sin r cos r
∂ur 1 ∂uz
= + ur +
∂r r ∂z
Axisymmetric formulation
Assuming that the domain Ω is axisymmetric, we can begin to transform the integrals in (3.40.2) to cylindrical
coordinates. Recall that the Jacobian of the transformation is J(r, ϕ, z) = r. The first equation in
(3.40.2) has the form:
∫
∂ur 1 ∂uz ∂ur 1 ∂vr cos2 1
r λ( + u r + ∂z ) + 2µ( ∂r cos 2 ϕ + u r 2 ϕ) ( ∂r ϕ + v r 2 ϕ) +
Ω ∂r r sin r sin r
∂ur 1 r ∂v 1r
r2µ ∂r cos ϕ sin ϕ — r u cos ϕ sin ϕ ∂r r cos ϕ sin ϕ —
r v cos ϕ sin ϕ +
∫ ∫
∂ur ∂uz ∂vr
rµ cos ϕ + cos ϕ cos ϕ — rgr vrcos2ϕ = rf r v rcos2 ϕ,
∂z ∂r ∂z Γ2 Ω
The second equation in (3.40.2) has the form:
∫
∂ur 1 ∂vr 1
r2µ cos ϕ sin ϕ — u cosr
ϕ sin ϕ cos ϕ sin ϕ — vr cos ϕ sin ϕ +
Ω ∂r r ∂r r
8 Chapter 3. Mathematics
Theoretical Physics Reference, Release 0.5
∫ ∫
∂ur ∂uz ∂vr
rµ sin ϕ + sin ϕ ( sin ϕ) — 2
rgr vr sin ϕ = rf r v r sin2 ϕ,
∂z ∂r ∂z Γ2 Ω
This gives us
∫ ∫ ∫
∂ur ∂vz ∂uz ∂vz ∂uz ∂vz 1∂ur ∂uz ∂vz
rµ + +2 + rλ + ur + — g v r= f v r.
Γ2 z z Ω z z
Ω
∂z ∂r ∂r ∂r ∂z ∂z ∂r r ∂z ∂z
Since the integrands do not depend on ϕ, we can simplify this to integral over Ω0, where Ω0 is the
intersection of the domain Ω1 with the x+x3 half-plane. Dividing both equations by 2π we get
∫ ∫
∂ur 1 ∂u
∂z z )( ∂vr 1 ∂ur ∂vr 1 r r ∂ur ∂vr ∂uz ∂vr
rλ( + u r + + v r) +
rµ 2 ∂r ∂r + 2 u v + ∂z ∂z + ∂r ∂z
Ω0
∂r r ∂r r ∫ Ω0 r
— ∫
g v
Γ2 r r r = fr vrr
Ω0
∫ ∫ ∫
∂ur ∂vz ∂uz ∂vz ∂uz ∂vz ∂ur 1 ∂uz ∂vz
rµ + +2 + rλ + ur + — g v r= f v r.
Ω0 Γ2 z z Ω0 z z
∂z ∂r ∂r ∂r ∂z ∂z ∂r r ∂z ∂z
so:
This is the weak formulation valid in any coordinates. Using the cylindrical coordinates (see above) we get:
x = (ρ, ϕ, z)
3
d x = dρ dϕ dz
ij 1 01 0
g = 0 2 0
0 ρ0 1
√ q
|g| = | det gij| = ρ
k 1 √ 1
k k
∇ ku = √ ∂k( |g|u ) = ∂k(ρu ) =
|g|1 ρ ρ
= u + ∂ uρ + ∂ uϕ + ∂ uz
ρ ϕ z
ρ
(∇juz + ∇zuj)∇jvz = (gjk∇kuz + gzk∇kuj)∇jvz = (∂ρuz + ∂zuρ)∂ρvz + (∂zuz + ∂zuz)∂zvz =
= (∂ρuz + ∂zuρ)∂ρvz + 2∂zuz∂zvz
gρj ∇ vρ = gρρ∇ vρ 1
j ρ = ∂ρvρ + Γρkρ = ∂ ρv ρ + vϕ
vk ρ
+ v )=
gϕj∇ vϕ = gϕϕ∇ 1 1 ϕ 1
ρ ρ
ϕv
ϕ
j = v ϕ + Γ ϕ v k) =
(∂
ϕ
ρj2vz = gzz∇zvz = ∂zvρz2 (∂ v
kϕ
∫ gzj∇ +∫ ϕΓz vk = ∂zvz
1
λgij uρ + ∂ uρ + ∂ uϕ + ∂ uz + µ(∇jui + ∇iuj) ∇ viρ dρ dϕ dz = fkz i i
v ρ dρ dϕ dz
ρ ϕ z j
ρ
for i = 1, 2, 3 we get:
∫ ρ ϕ z ∫
1ρ ρ ρ 1 ϕ
λ u + ∂ u + ∂ u + ∂ uz
ρ ϕ
ρ + µ (2∂ uρ∂ vρ + (∂ uρ + ∂ uz)∂ vρ) ρ dρ dϕ dz = f ρ v ρ ρ dρ dϕ
∂ρv dz+ ρv ρ ρ z ρ z
∫ ∫
1 ρ 1 ϕ 1 ρ
λ u + ∂ρ uρ + ∂ϕ uϕ + ∂z uz ∂ϕv + ρv ρ + µ (2∂ρ u ∂ρ v + (∂ zu + ∂ ρu )∂ zv ) ρ dρ dϕ dz = f ϕ v ϕ ρ dρ dϕ
ρ ρ ρ z ρ
ρ ρ2
dz
∫ ∫
1 ρ
λ u + ∂ ρuρ + ∂ ϕuϕ + ∂ zuz ∂ zvzρ + µ ((∂ ρuz + ∂ zuρ)∂ ρvz + 2∂ uz
z ∂ v
z
z ) ρ dρ dϕ dz = f z v z ρ dρ dϕ
ρ
dz
3.41 Operators
3.41.1 Introduction
The domain of the operator A is D(A), a subspace of the Hilbert space H . Linear operator is:
⟨u|Av⟩ = ⟨Au|v⟩
for all |u⟩ , |v⟩ ∈ D(A) dense in H . If D(A) is dense in H , then the adjoint operator A† is defined by
⟨u|A†v⟩ = ⟨Au|v⟩
for all |u⟩ ∈ D(A). The domain D(A†) is given by all |v⟩ for which the above relation holds. It can be
shown that D(A) ⊂ D(A†).
Operator A is self-adjoint if A = A†. Symmetric operator is self-adjoint only if D(A) = D(A†). (Bounded
symmetric operator is always self-adjoint.) Hermitean operator is a bounded symmetric operator.
Hermitian implies self-adjoint implies symmetric, but all converse implications are false. Below, we need the
operator to be self-adjoint (we assume unbounded by default).
3.41.2 Spectrum
To obtain a spectrum of the operator A, we need to solve the following problem:
A |λ⟩ = λ |λ⟩
Those values of λ for which the solution |λ⟩ ∈ H belong to the discrete part of the spectrum. λ are called
eigenvalues and |λ⟩ eigenvectors. Those values of λ for which |λ⟩ can be normalized to a delta function:
⟨λ|κ⟩ = δ(λ — κ)
belong to the continuous part of the spectrum (note that in this case |λ⟩ ∈/ H ).
Eigenvectors belonging to the continous part of the spectrum obey the completeness relation:
∫
|λ⟩ ⟨λ| dλ = 1
Eigenvectors belonging to the discrete part obey the following completeness relation:
Σ
|λ⟩ ⟨λ| dλ = 1
λ
The sum or integral runs over the whole spectrum (if the spectrum contains both discrete and continous
part, we simply combine sums and integrals).
Spectrum of a self-adjoint operator is real, because
12 Chapter 3. Mathematics
Theoretical Physics Reference, Release 0.5
The sum over λ runs over the whole spectrum (i.e. it becomes an integral over the continuos parts). Also
the coefficients⟨ λ| f are either discrete or continous depending on the part of the spectrum. The series
converges in the⟩ norm, i.e. the following norm goes to zero as we sum over λ:
Σ
¨ (x) —
¨f
λ
⟨x|λ⟩ ⟨λ|f ⟩¨ →
¨
0
3.41.3 Derivative Operator
We have the eigenvalue problem
Au = λu
where
d
A = —i
dx
The operator A is unbounded. A is self-adjoint if:
∫ b ∫ b
u∗(x)Av(x)dx = (Au(x))∗v(x)dx
a a
So
∫ b ∫ b
u∗(x)Av(x)dx = d
a
u∗(x) i dx v(x)dx =
∫ b a —
d ∗
= i u (x) v(x)dx — i[u∗(x)v(x)]b =
dx a
a
∫ b
d
= —i ∗
u(x) v(x)dx — i[u∗(x)v(x)]b =
a dx a
∫ b
= (Au(x))∗v(x)dx —i[u∗(x)v(x)]ab
a
The operator is self-adjoint if and only if [u∗(x)v(x)]ba = 0. Few boundary conditions that satisfy this
condition:
u(a) = 0, u(b) = 0
• Periodic boundary conditions
u(a) = u(b)
• Antiperiodic boundary conditions
u(a) = —u(b)
Solving the eigenproblem:
Au = λu
d
—i u = λu
dx
u(x) = eiλx
Fourier Series
We restrict our space to periodic functions. Applying the periodic boundary condition:
u(a) = eiλa = u(b) = eiλb
so
2πn eiλ(b−a) = 1
λ= for n = 0, ±1, ±2, . . .
b—a
The normalized eigenvectors are:
1 i 2πn x
un(x) = √ e b−a
b—a
These eigenvectors belong to our space and as such all λ = 2πn
b −form
a a discrete spectrum. Other solutions
do not satisfy the periodic boundary condition and so there i s n o continous part in the spectrum.
The eigenvectors must be orthogonal, as we can check:
∫ b
u∗n(x)um(x)dx =
∫ b
a
1 −i 2πn x 1 i 2πm x
= √ e b− √ e b−a dx =
a b—a a b—a
1 ∫ b
= 2π(m− n)
dx =
ei b−a x
∫ b—a a
b 0
1 e dx
h ib for m = n =
= b−a
1a i
2π(m−n)
x
e for m /= n
b−a
i2π(m−n)
a
= (1 1 for m = n
2π(m−n) 2π(m−n)
=
b i i a
i2π(m —n) b−
—e b−a for m /= n
e a
=
for m = n
for
= 1ai 2π(m−n)
−
(—
π ( m −n )
2 (b
i a) b−a
e b−a e 1 m /=
i2π(m−n) 1 for m = n
= = mn
0 for m /= n