Unit 2
Unit 2
Structure
2.1 Introduction
Objectives
2.2 Procedure for Maintenance in Confined Space
2.3 Inherent Safety
2.4 Inherent Safety Indices
2.4.1 Different Events and Their Occurrence
2.4.2 Segregation of Incompatible Substance
2.5 Importance of Documents on Safe Work Practices
2.6 Let Us Sum Up
2.7 Key Words
2.8 Answer to SAQs
2.9 References and Future Studies
2.1 INTRODUCTION
Safe working practices are generally included in any industries which are set
of written instructions and methods that outline how to conduct a particular
task or job which involves minimum risk and threat to the employees, labours,
equipment, materials, nearby environment, as well as the opted processes.
Almost all the industries now-a-days are advised to opt and exercise safe
work practices in order to encounter the associated hazards or for redressing
different circumstances that might occur during functioning of the jobs and
this might furnish other liabilities for the industry. Industry’s approach
towards handing these hazards is represented by nature of handling them.
Since owners of the industries are the responsible persons who need to assure
that their staff and employees have a deep knowledge of performing their
allotted tasks in a safe way. This inculcates that they are aware of the possible
hazards which might occur or existing nearby their work station and job place,
and are also familiar with the method of how to control these mishappening.
All these instructions are provided in details in written form to the employee
that is called as safe working procedures. These safety procedures are nothing
but a set of guidelines to assist workers in performing their day-to-day tasks
step by step from beginning to end in a proper and efficient way with the
complete safety.
This unit will cover all the aspects of Safe working practices as well as safe
work procedures, which is provided to the workers for guiding them to work
in their work space with complete safety and hoe to deal with hazards when
they are in situation of risks or threat. Various types of practices that are
found to be useful while implementing safe work procedures are inculcated in
48
this chapter. You will also be introduced to the responsible personals that Safe Working
Practices
need to monitor the smooth running of and implication of safe working
practices at work places. This unit also lets you have knowledge about the
required procedure for conducting maintenance in confined space and
importance of documents on safe work practices. This unit will inform what
precautions and guidelines we should keep in mind while laying out the
machines or laying out the plant and what are the benefits of following those
principles.
Objectives
After studying this unit you should be able to:
define the Safe working practices/ procedures;
recognize proficient ways to outline the safe working procedures on
paper;
discuss the utilization of safety measures in case of fire, explosion and
toxic gas cloud;
describe the importance of safety manual, safety log for ensuring safety
in a plant
Individual risk
49
Introduction to Societal risk
Industrial Safety
Looking into another angle of risk called as societal risk is an estimation and
assessment of risk to a large group of people. By this number of people
affected by the entire incident can be calculated by using this method.
Societal risk builds relationship between the frequency and the total number
of people those suffer from hazard. By using FN curve the societal risks can
be expressed as relationship amongst cumulative frequency and number of
fatalities taking place. This type of study results into a convenient single
measure of group which is at risk.
Sometime one accident leads to another accident and so on, such kinds of
effects need to be checked in advanced and conveyed to the workers for their
safety purpose. For this some principles must be designed whenever new
machine is laid out in the buildings, and if those principles are followed on
regular basis and religiously then the accident count is reduced and accident
prevention can be done to a great extent. In this main role is played by the
management people and they are aware of the costs involved in an accident,
as there are direct cost involved, indirect costs involved whenever there is
injury to any person, and as are the victims of the accidents. A person who is
victim and suffered some accident knows what cost they have been through
for their treatment, in case of severe injury they might lose some body part
which is undesirable from both industry point of view as well as workers
point of view also. The company has to bear other costs also for
troubleshooting the machine in case of break down machine or sometime
they may have to purchase a new machine in order to replace the obsolete
machine. Similarly company has to bear the cost of hospitalization of the
injured worker, and then there are other factors also like number of workers
involved in transferring the injured worker to the hospital, transportation
costs is affected, the man hour is lost, the productivity is reduced and there
are other indirect costs also that company may have to pay compensation
50 amount to the injured workers’ family or insurance company may come into
the picture at that time. So all in all, there are huge costs involved in case of Safe Working
Practices
occurrence of accidents in the workplace. So these problems need to resolve
by some means. So the question arises how these accidents can be minimized,
and how an individual worker can be made to realize importance of following
safety instructions. This can be done by getting the individual worker at the
point of operation to realize his personal responsibilities and duties. Also
these accidents can be reduced by organizing proper plant layout. But
maximum number of accidents usually takes place due to negligence of the
workers while performing their tasks or due to failure of the equipment.
If individual worker knows that due to his negligence some particular type of
accident or mishappening may take place then if he is cautious and if he is
performing his duty and job religiously by following the safety instruction
during working hours then there are no chance that would lead to an accident
to occur in a workplace.
Although there are still many chances in which equipment may fail and some
accident may take place, which is beyond workers control. But the important
part is to educate and train the workforces, that they willingly take the
personal responsibility in preventing the accidents. The management person
also plays a crucial role in designing the whole system in such a way that
accident incidents are not likely to occur in workplace. So the designs of the
system, plant, or building have to be such that there are least chances of
accident cases. In order to fulfill these requirements there are few guidelines,
precautions, principles, rules and regulations need to be followed while
laying down the building or a plant.
The layout of the plant and the machines as well as the tools should be
designed by keeping the accident prevention criterion in mind so that the
chances of the accidents can be prevented. The general principles of the plant
layout that should be kept in mind while designing the plant layout are as
follows;
In cases where chances of rising temperatures are very high and it may
lead to some kind of accident, so attention must be given to those types
of conditions that such conditions do not prevail. Temperature and
pressures need to be controlled and monitored on regular basis so that
accidents do not take place due to these conditions. 53
Introduction to Simpler systems/processes to reduce potential loss of containment or
Industrial Safety
possibility of errors causing a hazardous event
Fail-safe design means that even if some system failure intervenes in the
work place then there must be some sort of sensors or valves to check the
possibility of failure in that part during the functioning and attack the
problem before it tends to happen by stopping the equipment or machine
in order to prevent the accident.
Risk indices does not point out specific danger but it draws attention towards
those areas which are prone to risk and it provides the required in depth
analysis auxiliary-safety measures for those arena. So these risk indices are
found to be helpful in finding out or in identifying the areas where chances of
occurrence of risk is higher. It is but obvious that areas prone to higher risk
are at much greater risk of accidents. These risk indices helps in recognizing
54
areas that are most prone to incidents of accidents and assists in eliminating Safe Working
Practices
them from the plant. Risk indices are based on qualitative and quantitative
method. These methods are quite clear and cane be utilized quickly.
Quantitative means these risk indices will hold different numerical value for
different areas within the plant and this ultimately gives a lead to track out
that which area is having more chances of accidents and where are the least
chances of happening incidents. On the other hand quantitative technique
covers the range of hazardous materials process conditions and inventories.
So by making use of quantitative method of risk indices one can attain a
range by which person can point out that this thing is going to be hazardous.
This mainly covers the range hazards of materials process conditions and
inventory. There is another index which is called as OW-MOND index that
pin point particular type of hazards and also evaluates different indices
covering fire and other types of related explosions, in addition to overall
rating. This overall rating helps and gives conformity to the level of danger or
the level of risk associated with a particular area within the plant. So by
means of method that makes use of equations or graphs to locate the related
hazards. Comparatively graphs are easier to analyze and visualize. A
quantitative technique assesses the risks linked with the different stages of the
process and at different sites of the plant. Eventually these risk assessing
techniques are helpful in providing better understanding of the accident
prevention steps. As soon as these indices provide an idea of the area that is
more susceptible to accidents, preventive steps can be undertaken by the
management team to prevent that accident to happen. Accidental prevention
policies and procedures should be implemented for those areas that are more
prone to incidents of accidents. Risk indices are very important part of
industrial safety where chances of accidents are more. These risk indices
causes chances of occurrence of objectivity into the system in order to
counter the subjectivity. Ultimately to avoid occurrence of any accidents
these indices would aid in providing adequate management schemes for
undertaking preventive measures. These is one effect known as Domino
effect which could be better understood by considering an example of cycles
parked in a row. In case if we push one cycle then it will lead to fall of
second cycle, then circle and then ultimately all the cycles would fall with the
slightest push. This effect is termed as domino effect.
1. Fire
Incident of fire and its spreading can take place owing to following factors;
Convention
Radiation
Conduction
Gas
FIRE SAFETY Passive for Protection
Suppression AUDIT
System
There are other criteria also which should be kept in mind while adopting the
type of safety (active or passive) measures, like substances’ toxicity and
fumes produced during the fire. Similarly the size of the inventory also plays
important role while adopting the type of preventive measures. Suppose fire
outbursts into the plant and if it is not controlled within three to four hours
then active fire protection systems are called for emergency services e.g.
sprinklers. But if that fire is shut down within half to one hour then passive
fire protection services could be thought of adopting in that time. Other than
this there are other criteria also that should be kept in mind like frequency of
hazardous operation, distance between different hazardous installations, and
58
available resources to fire brigade. All these parameters need to be kept in Safe Working
Practices
mind while calling for active or passive fire protection services.
2. Explosion
Some guidelines and principles must be followed to safeguard the plants or
buildings against the incidents of explosion. The plant and related system
should be safe whenever any explosion takes place. Pressure waves or
missiles usually lead to explosion propagation. It is imperative to make a note
of it that explosion going to occur, what are the possible causes and
consequently what are the basic principles or guidelines that must be kept in
mind while designing a building or a plant to safeguard it against explosion.
As we have seen in case of fire in previous part that fire may spread from one
starting point to another point via different modes of conduction, convention
and radiation then similarly measures must be taken in case of explosion
casualties also. A lot of factors promote the incident of explosion, like
presence of combustible source, confinement of dust, dispersion of dust,
oxidants, ignition sources etc. as shown in Figure 2.2. Preventive measures in
case of explosion might include blast walls that prevent transfer of explosion
from one site of the plant to the other part of the plant. In order to prevent
severe damages caused due to explosion adequate safety procedures must be
undertaken like some valves or sensors or some accident control devices that
will not allow the explosion to occur or in case of explosion it will prevent
the progress of explosion to the other parts of the building.
EXPLOSION
60
Also when part in a plant is suspected with some toxic substances or Safe Working
Practices
flammable substances, then it will lead to creation of atmosphere full of those
flammable gases. This will lead to an accident or huge explosion if
preventive measures are not carried out on time. For preventing these
incidents of explosion, open air ventilation should be provided in a plant for
easy evacuation of vapors, flames, gases and dusts. In addition to these
measures, care should be taken to avoid actions of ignition at these suspected
areas. For the sake of example if a person visits any petrol pump, authorities
advises all visiting customers not to smoke or light a match stick there, it is
because such ignition sources might lead to the incident of fire explosion.
Figure 2.3 is enclosing all the necessary preventive steps that are required and
must be adopted for avoiding possible hazards that might be confronted while
working at work sites.
Identify Hazards/Threats
Mitigate Hazards
Keep trying
Evaluate Hazards
Evaluate those
Conduct Mock Drills Resources
Workstation Inspection
Incident Tracking
SAFETY
MANAGEMNET
Employee Qualification
Action Item Tracking
63
Introduction to These safety instructions in written format are an essential part of the system
Industrial Safety
for ensuring safe working conditions during actual operation. Management
team takes the responsibility of conducting and ensuring safe working
environment for the employers. For achieving this motto, management team
provides multiple safety trainings, orientation programs and induction
trainings to the newly appointed workers as well as to the newly shifted
workers.
Safe work practices can be categorized into following three basic practices
that must be undertaken to minimize the incidents of accidents and inhibit
injuries:
Task Hazard Analysis: this generally compiles the processes that are
responsible for analyzing and finding all the possible hazards associated
with the current task, the details of the control actions that must be
adopted in case of mishappening and circulating the safety practice
instruction manual amongst the workers that need to be followed to
reduce the possibility of accidents and injury.
Safe Work Procedures: this category generally addresses and
introduces the step-by-step and systematic procedures to the employers
for making them aware of hazardous tasks that they are working for
completing the task. The risks possessed with high hazard tasks are
eliminated from day to day working sites by providing step-by-step
procedures to the workers, so that they can follow those instructions
while conducting their desired job and can complete their work with
hundred percent safeties.
Codes of Practice: this usually involves reviewing of those tasks that are
identified as high or medium risk level tasks and development of safe
work procedures and providing these manuals to the workers working
with those tasks. Some risk level determination matrix is developed
under this category and some guidelines associated with the identified
risks are provided for proper safety precautions. These codes of practice
gives practical solutions and guidance to the personals those are
responsible for conducting some risk related work or business and makes
them to understand their desired duties in case of accident. These
practices can be applied to any type of workplaces whether it is remote,
mobile or outdoors. These codes of practices gives information regarding
first aid kits, related procedures, facilities and providing training for first
aid providers.
The recording of safe procedures in documents form provides details
regarding following;
Details regarding policies, rule, regulations, guidelines and necessary
procedures.
64
Maintaining consistency and uniformity in the safety concerns of Safe Working
Practices
workplace.
Checking for the up to date version available for the safety instruction
manual.
Evidence of past happenings or accidents, and information related to
them for avoiding reoccurrence of such incidents again in future.
Proper record handling and their management.
Record retention time and their proper disposal in case of newly
developed safety record manual. Obsolete documents and manuals must
be discarded properly.
It should also provide emergency escape routes.
First aid treatments techniques must also be incorporated.
Hazard/ Incident reports could also be enclosed.
Training and induction programs checklist should be included.
Performance management related plans.
Emergency plan should also be provided in the safety booklet for ensuring
easy escape routes to the employers. The role of first aider in case of
emergency must be assigned in accordance to their acquired qualification and
competence. The employers should be informed about the first aider so they
are aware of what to do and who to communicate in case of sickness or injury
while working in a plant. The information provided must be in easy
understandable language, must be accessible and it must consider the literacy
level of labours working there.
Different modes can be used for explaining the instructions like verbal
methods or visual methods. A verbal method takes into account the methods
of explanations and demonstrations whereas a visual method addresses
instructions via posters and videos.
First air instruction and information must include few points like first air
equipment location and dedicated facilities, name of affected person and
65
Introduction to location of that person, the required step-by-step procedure to be followed in
Industrial Safety
case of first aid requirement.
36 Percent (%)
33 Percent (%)
Figure 2.6: Main Barriers Confronted by Health and Safety Practices at Worksite
There are few obstructions that are confronted in attaining safety and health
practices in a workstation. Figure 2.6 enlists various types of factors along
with percentages that are leading to increase in number of accidents at plants.
A variety of factors contribute to organizational safety performance. The
culture of organization is also affected by company values and beliefs.
Organizational culture aids in recognizing and handling hazards via effective
safety methods which indirectly helps in identifying and eradicating injuries
and illness which might affect the organizations safety and health if not
solved prior to actual happening. The overall safety and accident prevention
is monitored by senior management’s leaders and desired actions are taken up
under their supervisions.
SAQ 1
a) State True or False T/F
68
OSHA Occupational Safety and Health Administration – A government Safe Working
Practices
agency in the department of Labor to maintain a safe and health work
environment.
Safety Manager – Provides cost savings and staffing flexibility while
ensuring you’re in compliance with safety regulations.
Safety Strategy – The act of being safe, understand how strategy affects
structure and how the choice of structure affects efficiency and effectiveness.
Active System - A system that uses mechanical means to satisfy load
demand as opposed to passive systems.
Risk -When we refer to risk in relation to occupational safety and health the
most commonly used definition is 'risk is the likelihood that a person may be
harmed or suffers adverse health effects if exposed to a hazard.
Explosion -An explosion is the result, not the cause, of a rapid expansion of
gases. It may occur from physical or mechanical change.
Toxic- It is a chemical that has a median lethal concentration (LC50) in air of
more than 200 parts per million (ppm) but not more than 2,000 parts per
million by volume of gas or vapor, or more than 2 milligrams per liter but not
more than 20 milligrams per liter of mist, fume or dust, when administered
by continuous inhalation for 1 hour.
70
By splitting of vertical and horizontal sections by employing fire Safe Working
Practices
resisting walls as well as floors the spreading of fire from its originating
source can be prohibited to a great extent. In this case compartmentation
is another term which can be used to avoid spreading of fire. For
example, in case a large hall is there in any plant and in that if any
incident of fire happens at one specific area then it is clear that this fire
will be spread to the entire hall. But this escalation of fire can be
prevented if entire hall is divided by providing different compartments
like four to five compartments in a single hall that too built with fire
resistant walls and fire resistant roof.
i) Explosion: Some guidelines and principles must be followed to
safeguard the plants or buildings against the incidents of explosion.
The plant and related system should be safe whenever any explosion
takes place. Pressure waves or missiles usually lead to explosion
propagation. It is imperative to make a note of it that explosion
going to occur, what are the possible causes and consequently what
are the basic principles or guidelines that must be kept in mind while
designing a building or a plant to safeguard it against explosion.
ii) Release of toxic gases: Other type of hazard linked to the explosion
is discharge of toxic gases in the environment that may lead to
Domino effect by rendering neighboring industries, adjacent sites,
plants and injuring workers working in the vicinity and leading to
accidents. This type of Domino effect can be controlled by
preventing, mitigating hazards associated with the explosion through
the utilization of automatic control systems by adopting inherently
safer guidelines and principles and a convenient control room for
conducting all these required preventive steps. Ultimate requirement
is stop these kinds of damages or hazards that may take place due to
explosion. Explosion usually takes place due to release of gases and
these leaked gases can be detected by using some sort of gas
detector implanted in the areas prone to gas leakages. These gas
detectors alerts the employers working in that area by generating an
alarm and will warn the security checkers to take preventive steps in
case of leakage of toxic gas in the environment.
e) The inherent safety index is another imperative aspect that need be
understood thoroughly. Inherent safety index is the only one by which
whole process routes can be assessed, and consecutively the most
suitable route for further development can be found. There are many
ways by which accidents may take place, so there is huge need to
provide for a particular system or for particular working conditions in
which the accidents do not take place and the operators feels safe while
working on their jobs and perform their duties safely while working in
the plant. There are still chances of accidents to happen, in that case there
71
Introduction to is need to have a enumerated technique which would help in checking
Industrial Safety
and assessing the risk that how much is the risk involved in that
particular type of system or process. It is the most suitable technique to
minimize the risk. This method also compares the inherent safety index
of the plant with the cost of capital and production- it is believed that
inherently safe plants are cost-effective plants. Inherent safety index of
the plant and cost of capital and production are interrelated with each
other, so always there is risk involved with them and ultimate aim is to
minimize the risk.
f) Documentation of safe work instructions plays a vital role in any
industry as these act as the foundation for that particular work place. A
local management personal enrolled, is generally responsible for
developing and implementing safe work practices in an industry. Figure
2.4 depicts all the possible checks that are conducted by safety
management department in a plant. Safe work practicing is nothing but a
set of instructions that are usually recommended for undertaking any
process or activity safely. Those industries who have their safe working
instructions in written format possesses safe working system, also they
conforms overall health and safety of their employers. These safety
instructions in written format are an essential part of the system for
ensuring safe working conditions during actual operation. Management
team takes the responsibility of conducting and ensuring safe working
environment for the employers. For achieving this motto, management
team provides multiple safety trainings, orientation programs and
induction trainings to the newly appointed workers as well as to the
newly shifted workers.
g) Labour Attitudes: Workers are not interested or are obstructive
ii) Staff does not analyze the risks or problems at worksite
iii) Least involvement of workers in health and safety procedures
iv) Organizational resistance to change
v) Lacking Safety Culture
72
5. “Management of Industrial Accident Prevention and Preparedness” A Safe Working
Training Resource Package UNEP, vol. 1, pp. 55-97, June (19 Practices
73