M.B.A.

-I
206SC-OSCM-02 : SUPPLY CHAIN MANAGEMENT
(2019 Pattern) (Semester-II)

1|Page
 M.B.A.-I
206SC-OSCM-02 : SUPPLY CHAIN MANAGEMENT
(2019 Pattern) (Semester-II)

Q1) Answer any 5 out of 8. (2 marks each)

a) Define the term Core competency.

Core competency refers to a specific set of unique strengths, capabilities, or advantages that
distinguish a business or organization from its competitors and enable it to create and deliver
value to its customers. These competencies typically lie at the heart of a company's strategic
direction and are central to its ability to achieve sustainable competitive advantage in the
marketplace. Core competencies can include a combination of technical skills, specialized
knowledge, innovative processes, and distinct resources that are difficult for competitors to
replicate or imitate. Identifying and leveraging core competencies is essential for
organizations to focus their efforts, allocate resources effectively, and differentiate
themselves in their industry.
b) What are the five critical flows in supply chain which can
result in value addition for the ultimate customers.

The five critical flows in the supply chain that can result in value addition for ultimate
customers are:

1. Material Flow: This involves the physical movement and transformation of raw
materials into finished products. Efficient material flow ensures timely delivery of
products to customers while minimizing costs and waste.

2. Information Flow: Information flow encompasses the transmission of data and

communication throughout the supply chain. This includes order processing,
inventory tracking, demand forecasting, and other relevant information exchange.
Timely and accurate information flow helps in improving coordination, reducing lead
times, and enhancing customer service.

3. Financial Flow: Financial flow involves the transfer of payments, transactions, and
financial resources between supply chain partners. It includes processes such as
invoicing, payment terms negotiation, and financing arrangements. Efficient financial
flow helps in optimizing cash flow, reducing transaction costs, and improving overall
financial performance.

4. Product Flow: Product flow refers to the movement of goods from manufacturers to
end customers through various distribution channels. This includes transportation,
warehousing, and logistics activities. Streamlining product flow ensures on-time
delivery, reduces inventory holding costs, and enhances customer satisfaction.
2|Page
 5. Value-Adding Flow: Value-adding flow involves the processes and activities that
directly contribute to enhancing the value of products or services for customers. This
includes product customization, quality assurance, after-sales service, and other value-
added services. By focusing on value-adding flow, organizations can differentiate
their offerings, increase customer loyalty, and drive competitive advantage in the
marketplace.

c) Define logistics.

Logistics is the process of planning, implementing, and controlling the efficient, cost-
effective flow and storage of goods, services, and related information from point of origin to
point of consumption. It involves the management of resources, such as transportation,
inventory, warehousing, packaging, and distribution, to ensure that products are delivered to
the right place, at the right time, and in the right condition. Logistics plays a critical role in
supply chain management, as it aims to optimize the movement of goods and services while
minimizing costs and maximizing customer satisfaction. Effective logistics management
requires coordination and collaboration among various stakeholders, including suppliers,
manufacturers, distributors, retailers, and customers, to ensure smooth and seamless
operations throughout the supply chain.

d) Describe the concept of pull based SC.

A pull-based supply chain (SC) is a model where the production and distribution of
goods and services are driven by actual customer demand rather than forecasts or
speculative production. In this model, production is initiated in response to customer
orders, which triggers the movement of materials and resources upstream through
the supply chain.

Here's how the pull-based supply chain concept works:

1. Customer Demand: The process starts with customer demand. Instead of

relying on forecasts or pushing products into the market, the supply chain
responds to actual orders placed by customers.

2. Order Processing: When a customer places an order, it initiates a series of

actions within the supply chain. This includes processing the order, confirming
availability of inventory or resources, and scheduling production or
procurement.

3. Production and Procurement: In a pull-based supply chain, production or

procurement activities are triggered by customer orders. This means that
goods are produced or materials are procured only when there is a confirmed
demand, reducing the risk of overproduction and excess inventory.

3|Page
 4. Inventory Management: Inventory levels are kept at minimum levels
required to fulfill customer orders promptly. This minimizes the need for
holding excess inventory, reducing carrying costs and the risk of obsolescence.

5. Distribution: Once products are produced or materials are procured, they are
distributed directly to customers or to distribution centers based on the
specific order requirements.

6. Information Flow: Information flow is crucial in a pull-based supply chain to

ensure timely communication and coordination between all stakeholders. This
includes real-time visibility into inventory levels, production schedules, and
order status.

Benefits of a pull-based supply chain include reduced inventory carrying costs,

improved responsiveness to changing customer demand, reduced lead times, and
increased overall efficiency. However, implementing a pull-based supply chain
requires effective demand forecasting, agile production processes, robust inventory
management systems, and strong collaboration among supply chain partners.

e) What is Agile Sc?

Agile supply chain (SC) refers to a flexible and responsive approach to managing the
flow of goods, services, and information throughout the supply chain in order to
quickly adapt to changing market conditions, customer demands, and other external
factors. It draws inspiration from agile principles commonly applied in software
development and project management.

Key characteristics of an agile supply chain include:

1. Flexibility: Agile supply chains are designed to be flexible and adaptable,

capable of quickly responding to changes in customer demand, market trends,
and disruptions in the supply chain.

2. Collaboration: Collaboration among supply chain partners is essential in an

agile supply chain. This includes sharing information, resources, and best
practices to improve responsiveness and decision-making.

3. Customer Focus: Agile supply chains prioritize customer satisfaction and aim
to deliver value by meeting customer needs and expectations in a timely
manner.

4|Page
 4. Continuous Improvement: Agile supply chains embrace a culture of
continuous improvement, seeking to optimize processes, reduce waste, and
enhance efficiency and effectiveness over time.

5. Risk Management: Agile supply chains proactively identify and mitigate risks,
including supply chain disruptions, market volatility, and other uncertainties,
to ensure business continuity and resilience.

6. Technology Integration: Technology plays a crucial role in enabling agility in

the supply chain. This includes the use of advanced analytics, real-time data
visibility, automation, and digital platforms to enhance decision-making and
streamline operations.

Agile supply chain practices include:

• Just-in-Time (JIT) Manufacturing: JIT manufacturing involves producing

goods only in response to customer demand, minimizing inventory holding
costs and reducing lead times.
• Lean Principles: Lean principles focus on eliminating waste and optimizing
processes to improve efficiency and responsiveness in the supply chain.
• Cross-Functional Teams: Agile supply chains often employ cross-functional
teams that collaborate across different departments and functions to
streamline processes and improve communication.
• Adaptive Planning: Agile supply chains use adaptive planning approaches
that allow for quick adjustments to production schedules, inventory levels, and
distribution strategies based on changing conditions.

f) Define customer success.

Customer success refers to the ongoing process of ensuring that customers achieve
their desired outcomes and derive maximum value from the products or services
they have purchased. It involves understanding customers' goals, addressing their
needs, and proactively helping them overcome challenges throughout their journey
with a company.

Key aspects of customer success include:

1. Understanding Customer Needs: Customer success starts with

understanding the goals, expectations, and pain points of customers. By
gaining insights into their specific needs and desired outcomes, companies
can tailor their products, services, and support to meet those requirements
effectively.

5|Page
 2. Onboarding and Adoption: Effective onboarding processes are crucial for
helping customers get started with a product or service and maximizing its
value. This includes providing guidance, training, and resources to ensure
smooth adoption and usage.

3. Proactive Support: Customer success teams actively engage with customers

to provide assistance, address issues, and offer solutions before problems
arise. This proactive approach helps build trust, foster loyalty, and mitigate
potential churn.

4. Value Delivery: Customer success is about delivering tangible value to

customers and helping them achieve their desired outcomes. This may involve
identifying opportunities for optimization, offering additional features or
services, and showcasing the return on investment (ROI) of the product or
service.

5. Relationship Building: Building strong relationships with customers is

essential for long-term success. Customer success teams serve as trusted
advisors, building rapport, and maintaining open lines of communication to
understand evolving needs and preferences.

6. Measurement and Feedback: Customer success initiatives should be

measurable, with key performance indicators (KPIs) such as customer
satisfaction scores, retention rates, and renewal rates used to assess
effectiveness. Collecting feedback from customers is also critical for identifying
areas of improvement and refining strategies.

g) Define VMI.

VMI stands for Vendor Managed Inventory. It is a supply chain management practice
where a supplier takes responsibility for managing the inventory levels of their
products at a customer's location. In a VMI arrangement, the supplier monitors the
customer's inventory levels and replenishes stock as needed, typically based on
predetermined agreements and demand forecasts.

Key features of Vendor Managed Inventory (VMI) include:

1. Inventory Ownership: In VMI, the supplier retains ownership of the inventory

until it is consumed by the customer. This shifts the burden of inventory
management, including carrying costs and stockouts, from the customer to
the supplier.

6|Page
 2. Collaborative Planning: VMI requires close collaboration between the
supplier and the customer. Both parties share information about inventory
levels, sales forecasts, and demand patterns to optimize inventory levels and
ensure timely replenishment.

3. Automatic Replenishment: VMI systems are often automated, with the

supplier using electronic data interchange (EDI) or other technologies to
monitor inventory levels and trigger replenishment orders automatically when
predefined thresholds are reached.

4. Risk Sharing: VMI arrangements often include mechanisms for sharing risks
and rewards between the supplier and the customer. This may involve
agreements on pricing, inventory levels, and performance metrics to
incentivize collaboration and alignment of goals.

Benefits of Vendor Managed Inventory (VMI) for both suppliers and customers
include:

• Reduced Inventory Costs: VMI helps minimize inventory holding costs,

including storage, obsolescence, and carrying costs, by optimizing inventory
levels and reducing excess stock.
• Improved Service Levels: By ensuring that products are available when
needed, VMI can improve service levels, reduce stockouts, and enhance
customer satisfaction.
• Enhanced Efficiency: VMI streamlines inventory management processes,
reduces administrative overhead, and improves supply chain visibility, leading
to greater efficiency and productivity.
• Better Demand Forecasting: VMI facilitates better demand forecasting and
inventory planning by providing real-time data and insights into customer
demand patterns and consumption trends.
• Stronger Relationships: VMI fosters closer collaboration and trust between
suppliers and customers, leading to stronger relationships, improved
communication, and mutual business benefits.

h) Define JIT production.

Just-in-Time (JIT) production is a manufacturing strategy aimed at producing goods or

delivering services exactly when they are needed, neither too early nor too late, to minimize
inventory holding costs and waste. The JIT philosophy originated in Japan and became
popularized by Toyota in the 1970s.

7|Page
Key principles of JIT production include:

1. Demand-Pull System: JIT production operates on a demand-pull system, where

production is triggered by actual customer orders rather than forecasts or speculative
production schedules. This ensures that goods are produced only in response to
customer demand, reducing the risk of overproduction and excess inventory.

2. Continuous Flow: JIT production emphasizes the continuous flow of materials and
resources through the production process, with minimal waiting times or delays
between production stages. This helps eliminate bottlenecks, reduce lead times, and
improve overall efficiency.

3. Takt Time: Takt time refers to the rate at which products need to be produced to
meet customer demand. In JIT production, production activities are synchronized to
match the takt time, ensuring that goods are produced at the right pace to meet
customer requirements.

4. Pull Systems: JIT production employs pull systems, such as Kanban, to control the
flow of materials and resources through the production process. Pull systems rely on
visual signals or triggers from downstream processes to initiate production or
replenish inventory upstream.

5. Zero Defects: JIT production emphasizes quality at every stage of the production
process, with a focus on preventing defects rather than detecting and correcting them
later. This helps minimize rework, scrap, and waste, leading to higher quality products
and lower costs.

6. Supplier Partnerships: JIT production requires close collaboration with suppliers to

ensure timely delivery of materials and components in small, frequent batches.
Suppliers are often located nearby to facilitate quick response times and minimize
transportation costs.

Benefits of JIT production include:

• Reduced Inventory Costs: JIT production helps minimize inventory holding costs by
reducing the need for excess inventory and storage space.
• Improved Efficiency: By eliminating waste, streamlining processes, and reducing lead
times, JIT production improves overall efficiency and productivity.
• Enhanced Quality: JIT production emphasizes quality at every stage, leading to fewer
defects, higher-quality products, and greater customer satisfaction.
• Flexibility and Responsiveness: JIT production enables companies to quickly respond
to changes in customer demand, market trends, and production requirements.
• Continuous Improvement: JIT production fosters a culture of continuous
improvement, with ongoing efforts to optimize processes, reduce waste, and enhance
performance over time.

8|Page
Overall, JIT production is a lean manufacturing approach that focuses on delivering the right
quantity of products at the right time, in the right place, and with the right quality, while
minimizing waste and maximizing efficiency.

Q2) Answer any 2 out of 3. (5 marks each)

a) Describe JIT purchasing and JIT transportation used by auto

assembly plant.
Certainly! Let's break down JIT purchasing and JIT transportation as applied in an auto
assembly plant:

1. JIT Purchasing: JIT purchasing involves acquiring raw materials, components, and
parts from suppliers in precise quantities and at the exact time they are needed for
production. In the context of an auto assembly plant, JIT purchasing ensures that the
necessary components and materials arrive at the production line just in time to be
assembled into vehicles. Here's how JIT purchasing works in an auto assembly plant:

• Supplier Collaboration: The auto manufacturer maintains close relationships

with its suppliers, often located nearby to facilitate quick deliveries. Suppliers
are considered partners in the production process, and their performance is
closely monitored to ensure reliability and quality.

• Small, Frequent Deliveries: Suppliers deliver components and parts to the

assembly plant in small, frequent batches rather than large, infrequent
shipments. This minimizes the need for inventory storage at the assembly
plant and reduces the risk of overstocking or stockouts.

• Kanban System: JIT purchasing often utilizes a Kanban system, where visual
signals or cards are used to trigger replenishment orders based on actual
consumption or production needs. When components are used on the
production line, empty bins or Kanban cards signal the need for
replenishment, prompting suppliers to deliver additional parts.

• Quality Assurance: Suppliers are expected to maintain high standards of

quality and consistency to ensure that the components they provide meet the
required specifications. Any deviations or defects are addressed promptly to
prevent disruptions to the production process.

2. JIT Transportation: JIT transportation involves the efficient and timely movement
of materials and components from suppliers to the assembly plant, as well as the
distribution of finished vehicles to dealerships or customers. In the context of an auto
assembly plant, JIT transportation plays a crucial role in ensuring that components
arrive on time and that vehicles are delivered promptly to meet customer demand.
Here's how JIT transportation is implemented:

9|Page
 • Optimized Routes: Transportation routes are optimized to minimize transit
times and reduce costs. Suppliers and logistics providers work together to plan
efficient delivery schedules and routes, taking into account factors such as
traffic patterns, weather conditions, and vehicle capacity.

• Lean Logistics: JIT transportation adopts lean principles to eliminate waste

and streamline operations. This includes reducing unnecessary handling and
storage, optimizing loading and unloading processes, and using just-in-time
delivery schedules to minimize idle time and inventory holding costs.

• Real-Time Tracking: Advanced tracking and monitoring systems are used to

provide real-time visibility into the status and location of shipments. This
allows logistics managers to track the progress of deliveries, anticipate
potential delays, and proactively address any issues that may arise.

• Collaboration with Carriers: Auto manufacturers collaborate closely with

transportation carriers, such as trucking companies and logistics providers, to
ensure reliable and efficient transportation services. Contracts may be
negotiated to secure capacity and ensure priority access to transportation
resources when needed.

In summary, JIT purchasing and JIT transportation are integral components of the supply
chain strategy employed by auto assembly plants to minimize inventory, reduce costs, and
improve efficiency. By synchronizing the delivery of components with production schedules
and optimizing transportation logistics, auto manufacturers can effectively meet customer
demand while minimizing waste and maximizing value.

b) Explain how the linear SC transformed into collaborative

network.

The transformation from a linear supply chain (SC) model to a collaborative network
reflects a fundamental shift in how businesses approach supply chain management
and collaboration with their partners. Here's how this transformation typically occurs:

1. Linear Supply Chain Model: In a linear supply chain model, each player in
the supply chain operates independently with limited communication and
collaboration. The flow of materials, information, and resources tends to be
one-directional, moving sequentially from suppliers to manufacturers, then to
distributors, and finally to customers. This traditional model often results in
inefficiencies, such as excess inventory, long lead times, and suboptimal
utilization of resources.

2. Emergence of Collaboration: The recognition of the limitations of the linear

supply chain model prompts businesses to explore alternative approaches
that emphasize collaboration and partnership. As companies strive to become
10 | P a g e
 more agile, responsive, and customer-centric, they realize the importance of
working closely with suppliers, manufacturers, distributors, and other
stakeholders to optimize the entire supply chain ecosystem.

3. Integration and Information Sharing: Collaboration in the supply chain

involves integrating systems, processes, and data across different
organizations to enable seamless coordination and communication. This
integration allows for real-time visibility into inventory levels, production
schedules, demand forecasts, and other relevant information, facilitating
better decision-making and responsiveness.

4. Shared Goals and Objectives: Collaborative networks are characterized by

shared goals and objectives among supply chain partners. Rather than
pursuing individual interests, businesses align their strategies and incentives
to achieve mutual benefits, such as improved efficiency, reduced costs, and
enhanced customer satisfaction. This alignment fosters trust, transparency,
and long-term relationships among partners.

5. Cross-Functional Teams and Innovation: Collaboration extends beyond

traditional boundaries, with cross-functional teams and collaborative
initiatives driving innovation and continuous improvement throughout the
supply chain. Companies leverage the collective expertise, resources, and
capabilities of their partners to address challenges, seize opportunities, and
drive value creation.

6. Technology and Digitalization: Technology plays a crucial role in enabling

collaboration within supply chain networks. Digital platforms, cloud-based
systems, Internet of Things (IoT) devices, and advanced analytics provide the
infrastructure and tools needed to facilitate seamless communication, data
sharing, and collaboration among supply chain partners.

7. Dynamic and Adaptive Networks: Collaborative networks are dynamic and

adaptive, capable of responding quickly to changes in market conditions,
customer preferences, and supply chain disruptions. By leveraging the
collective intelligence and agility of their partners, businesses can adapt and
innovate in real-time to stay competitive in a rapidly evolving environment.

c) Explain value added services provided by telecom operator.

Telecom operators provide a range of value-added services (VAS) alongside their core
telecommunication services to enhance customer experience, differentiate their offerings, and
generate additional revenue streams. These value-added services leverage the telecom

11 | P a g e
infrastructure and technology platforms to deliver various functionalities and features beyond
basic voice and data communication. Here are some examples of value-added services
provided by telecom operators:

1. Entertainment Services:

• Streaming Services: Telecom operators may offer streaming services for

music, movies, TV shows, and other multimedia content over their networks.
This includes subscription-based platforms or pay-per-view options.
• Gaming Services: Some telecom operators provide gaming services, allowing
customers to access and play video games via their mobile devices or home
internet connections.

2. Content Services:

• Content Aggregation: Telecom operators often curate and distribute digital

content such as news, sports updates, lifestyle articles, and educational
materials to subscribers through their platforms.
• Content Partnerships: Operators may partner with content providers,
publishers, and creators to offer exclusive or premium content to their
subscribers.

3. Communication Services:

• Messaging Applications: In addition to traditional SMS, telecom operators

may offer messaging applications with advanced features such as multimedia
messaging, group chats, and voice or video calling.
• VoIP Services: Voice over Internet Protocol (VoIP) services allow customers
to make voice calls over the internet, often at lower rates compared to
traditional phone calls.

4. Productivity and Utility Services:

• Cloud Storage: Telecom operators may provide cloud storage solutions,

allowing customers to store and access their files, photos, and documents
remotely.
• Mobile Payments: Many telecom operators offer mobile payment services,
enabling customers to make payments, transfer funds, and manage their
finances using their mobile devices.
• Location-Based Services: Telecom operators leverage location-based
services to offer features such as mapping, navigation, location tracking, and
geo-targeted advertising.

5. Security and Safety Services:

12 | P a g e
 • Mobile Security: Telecom operators may offer mobile security solutions,
including antivirus software, malware detection, and device tracking to protect
customers' devices and data.
• Emergency Services: Operators may provide emergency communication
services such as emergency alerts, SOS features, and location sharing during
critical situations.

6. IoT (Internet of Things) Services:

• Connected Devices: Telecom operators enable connectivity for IoT devices

such as smart home devices, wearables, and industrial sensors, allowing
customers to remotely monitor and control their devices.
• IoT Platforms: Operators may offer IoT platforms and solutions for
businesses to deploy and manage IoT applications and devices efficiently.

These value-added services not only enhance the customer experience but also contribute to
revenue diversification and customer retention for telecom operators in an increasingly
competitive market.

Q3) Answer any one question. (10 Marks)

a) Contrast anticipatory based business model and response
based business model.

Sure, let's contrast the anticipatory-based business model and the response-based business
model:

1. Anticipatory-Based Business Model:

• Forecasting and Planning: In an anticipatory-based business model,

companies rely on forecasts, historical data, market trends, and predictive
analytics to anticipate future demand and plan their operations accordingly.
They proactively invest in resources, inventory, and capacity to meet expected
demand.

• Risk Mitigation: Anticipatory models aim to mitigate risks associated with

uncertainty by making informed predictions and decisions based on available
data. Companies may build buffer inventory, secure supply chain partnerships,
and implement contingency plans to address potential disruptions.

• Efficiency and Optimization: Anticipatory models prioritize efficiency and

optimization by aligning resources, processes, and investments with forecasted
demand. This may involve batch production, economies of scale, and fixed
capacity utilization to minimize costs and maximize profitability.

13 | P a g e
 • Examples: Traditional manufacturing industries, such as automotive and
consumer electronics, often operate on anticipatory-based models, where
production schedules are planned in advance based on sales forecasts and
demand projections.

2. Response-Based Business Model:

• Agility and Flexibility: In a response-based business model, companies

emphasize agility and flexibility to quickly adapt to changing market
conditions, customer preferences, and demand fluctuations. They prioritize
responsiveness over long-term planning and invest in dynamic capabilities to
respond effectively to unforeseen events.

• Real-Time Data and Feedback: Response-based models rely on real-time

data, feedback loops, and sensing mechanisms to detect changes in demand
patterns and market dynamics. Companies leverage this information to make
rapid adjustments to their operations, supply chain, and product offerings.

• Collaboration and Partnerships: Response-based models emphasize

collaboration and partnerships with suppliers, distributors, and other
stakeholders to enhance agility and resilience. Companies may adopt lean
principles, JIT (Just-in-Time) inventory management, and agile manufacturing
practices to reduce lead times and increase responsiveness.

• Examples: E-commerce platforms, on-demand services, and fast-fashion

retailers often operate on response-based models, where inventory
management, production, and distribution are dynamically adjusted based on
real-time demand signals and customer feedback.

In summary, while anticipatory-based models prioritize long-term planning, risk mitigation,

and efficiency, response-based models focus on agility, flexibility, and responsiveness to
adapt quickly to changing market conditions and customer needs. The choice between these
models depends on factors such as industry dynamics, market volatility, and the level of
uncertainty businesses face in their operating environment.

OR
b) Explain the necessity of outsourcing and elaborate the
advantages of outsourcing.
Outsourcing is the practice of contracting out business processes, functions, or
services to external vendors or third-party providers. It has become increasingly
common in today's globalized economy due to several factors that make it necessary
for businesses to consider outsourcing. Here are some reasons why outsourcing is
necessary, along with its advantages:

14 | P a g e
 1. Access to Specialized Expertise: Outsourcing allows businesses to access
specialized skills and expertise that may not be available in-house. By
outsourcing specific tasks or functions to external specialists or service
providers, companies can leverage the knowledge and capabilities of experts
in the field, leading to higher quality results and improved performance.

2. Cost Savings: One of the primary reasons for outsourcing is cost savings.
Outsourcing certain functions or processes to countries with lower labor costs
can significantly reduce operational expenses, including wages, benefits,
infrastructure, and overhead costs. This can help businesses remain
competitive and allocate resources more efficiently.

3. Focus on Core Competencies: Outsourcing non-core activities allows

businesses to focus their time, resources, and energy on core competencies
and strategic initiatives that are essential for their success. By delegating
routine or ancillary tasks to external providers, companies can streamline
operations and concentrate on value-added activities that drive growth and
innovation.

4. Scalability and Flexibility: Outsourcing provides businesses with greater

scalability and flexibility to adapt to fluctuating demand, market conditions,
and business cycles. External vendors can quickly ramp up or down resources
as needed, allowing companies to respond more effectively to changes in
customer preferences, seasonality, or expansion opportunities.

5. Risk Mitigation: Outsourcing can help mitigate various risks associated with
business operations, such as market volatility, regulatory compliance,
technological obsolescence, and talent shortages. By diversifying suppliers
and tapping into external resources, companies can spread risk and enhance
resilience against unforeseen events or disruptions.

6. Global Market Expansion: Outsourcing can facilitate global market

expansion by providing access to international markets, networks, and
distribution channels. By partnering with offshore suppliers or service
providers, companies can expand their geographic reach, enter new markets,
and capitalize on opportunities for growth and expansion.

7. Improved Focus on Customer Experience: Outsourcing certain functions,

such as customer support or back-office operations, to specialized providers
can lead to improved customer experience and satisfaction. External vendors
with expertise in customer service or process optimization can enhance service
quality, responsiveness, and efficiency, ultimately driving greater customer
loyalty and retention.

15 | P a g e
Q4) Answer 4 (a) or 4 (b) (10 marks)
a) How can vendor managed inventory be applied successfully?
Successfully implementing vendor-managed inventory (VMI) requires careful
planning, collaboration, and execution between the vendor and the customer. Here
are some key steps to apply VMI successfully:

1. Establish Clear Objectives: Define the goals and objectives of implementing

VMI, such as reducing inventory carrying costs, minimizing stockouts,
improving order fulfillment rates, or enhancing overall supply chain efficiency.

2. Select the Right Vendor: Choose vendors who are willing and capable of
participating in a VMI arrangement. Look for suppliers with a track record of
reliability, quality, and collaboration, as well as those who can provide real-
time data visibility and support VMI processes effectively.

3. Define Inventory Policies and Parameters: Establish clear inventory policies,

such as safety stock levels, reorder points, lead times, and order quantities, in
collaboration with the vendor. Ensure that both parties agree on the
parameters and metrics used to measure inventory performance and success.

4. Implement Technology and Data Sharing: Set up systems and technologies

to facilitate seamless data sharing and communication between the vendor
and the customer. Implement electronic data interchange (EDI), cloud-based
platforms, or other digital tools to exchange real-time inventory data,
forecasts, and order information.

5. Develop Collaborative Forecasting: Collaborate with the vendor to develop

accurate demand forecasts based on historical data, market trends, and
customer insights. Share demand forecasts, sales projections, and inventory
plans to enable the vendor to optimize production and replenishment
schedules accordingly.

6. Establish Performance Metrics: Define key performance indicators (KPIs) to

evaluate the effectiveness of the VMI arrangement. Monitor metrics such as
inventory turns, fill rates, on-time delivery, stockout rates, and overall
inventory accuracy to assess performance and identify areas for improvement.

7. Promote Transparency and Trust: Foster open communication,

transparency, and trust between the vendor and the customer. Share relevant

16 | P a g e
 information, feedback, and insights to facilitate collaboration, problem-
solving, and continuous improvement initiatives.

8. Provide Training and Support: Train employees and stakeholders involved in

VMI processes on the objectives, procedures, and best practices of VMI.
Ensure that both the vendor and the customer have the necessary skills,
resources, and support to effectively manage inventory and address any
challenges that may arise.

9. Monitor and Adjust: Continuously monitor inventory levels, demand

patterns, and supply chain performance to identify trends, patterns, and areas
for optimization. Regularly review the VMI arrangement, gather feedback from
stakeholders, and make adjustments as needed to optimize inventory
management and achieve desired outcomes.

By following these steps and fostering a collaborative partnership between the

vendor and the customer, businesses can successfully implement VMI to improve
inventory visibility, optimize supply chain efficiency, and drive mutual benefits for all
parties involved.

OR
b) Critically analyze operational challenges to make shift from
linear SC to collaborative network in reality.
Transitioning from a linear supply chain (SC) model to a collaborative network poses several
operational challenges that need to be critically analyzed and addressed. While collaborative
networks offer numerous benefits, such as increased agility, flexibility, and responsiveness,
there are several hurdles that organizations may encounter during the transition process. Here
are some key operational challenges:

1. Cultural and Organizational Resistance:

• Resistance to change: Employees and stakeholders may resist adopting

collaborative practices due to fear of job loss, changes in roles and
responsibilities, or uncertainty about the new operating model.
• Siloed mentality: Breaking down organizational silos and fostering a culture of
collaboration across departments and functions can be challenging, especially
in large or hierarchical organizations.

2. Information Sharing and Integration:

• Data silos: Integrating data from different sources and systems across the
supply chain can be complex, especially when organizations have disparate IT
infrastructures or legacy systems.

17 | P a g e
 • Information security: Sharing sensitive data and intellectual property with
external partners raises concerns about data privacy, security breaches, and
compliance with regulations such as GDPR or HIPAA.

3. Trust and Relationship Building:

• Trust issues: Establishing trust and building strong relationships with supply
chain partners takes time and effort. Companies may face skepticism or
reluctance from partners, especially if they have experienced past disputes or
conflicts.
• Conflicting interests: Balancing the interests and priorities of different
stakeholders within the collaborative network, such as suppliers, distributors,
and customers, can be challenging when there are competing goals or agendas.

4. Coordination and Communication:

• Coordination complexity: Managing a collaborative network requires effective

coordination and communication among multiple stakeholders with diverse
backgrounds, cultures, and objectives.
• Communication barriers: Language barriers, time zone differences, and
cultural nuances can hinder effective communication and collaboration,
leading to misunderstandings or delays in decision-making.

5. Risk Management and Accountability:

• Risk allocation: Collaborative networks involve sharing risks and

responsibilities among partners, but determining how risks are allocated and
managed can be complex, especially in case of disruptions or failures.
• Accountability: Ensuring accountability and responsibility for performance
and outcomes within the collaborative network can be challenging,
particularly when there is ambiguity or lack of clarity about roles and
obligations.

6. Technology and Infrastructure:

• Technology integration: Integrating and aligning IT systems, platforms, and

processes across the collaborative network requires investment in technology
infrastructure, interoperability standards, and digital transformation initiatives.
• Scalability and compatibility: Ensuring that technology solutions are scalable,
adaptable, and compatible with the diverse needs and requirements of different
partners within the collaborative network can be a significant challenge.

7. Legal and Regulatory Considerations:

• Contractual agreements: Negotiating and drafting contractual agreements,

service level agreements (SLAs), and other legal documents to govern the

18 | P a g e
 relationships and interactions within the collaborative network requires careful
consideration of legal and regulatory requirements.
• Compliance and governance: Ensuring compliance with laws, regulations, and
industry standards, such as antitrust regulations, trade policies, and
environmental regulations, can be complex when operating within a
collaborative network involving multiple jurisdictions and stakeholders.

Addressing these operational challenges requires a strategic and holistic approach that
encompasses organizational alignment, stakeholder engagement, process optimization,
technology enablement, and risk management. Companies must invest in building trust,
fostering collaboration, and developing robust governance structures to successfully
transition from a linear supply chain model to a collaborative network in reality.

Q5) Answer 5 (a) or 5 (b) (10 marks.)

a) “Reverse logistics Booms as Americans return 17% of all retail
purchases” thomas index report. By reading this report Mr.
Saurav, a recent management graduate from pune wish to set up
a start up focused on managing reverse logistics of retail products.
he appoints you as a consultant for reverse logistics help him to
know R’s of reverse logistics.

Certainly! Mr. Saurav's interest in setting up a startup focused on managing reverse

logistics of retail products aligns with a growing need in the market. To help him
understand the key aspects of reverse logistics, let's discuss the "R's" of reverse
logistics:

1. Returns Management: Returns management involves handling product

returns from customers efficiently and effectively. This includes processes such
as return authorization, product inspection, refurbishment or repair,
restocking, and disposal. Effective returns management aims to minimize the
impact of returns on operations, maximize recovery value, and maintain
customer satisfaction.

2. Remanufacturing: Remanufacturing involves refurbishing or restoring

returned products to a like-new condition for resale or reuse. This process
typically involves disassembly, cleaning, repair or replacement of parts,
reassembly, and testing. Remanufacturing helps extend the lifecycle of
products, reduce waste, and capture additional value from returned goods.

19 | P a g e
 3. Recycling: Recycling involves the recovery and reuse of materials and
components from returned products that cannot be refurbished or resold. This
includes processes such as dismantling, sorting, shredding, and processing
materials for reuse in manufacturing or other applications. Recycling helps
reduce environmental impact, conserve resources, and minimize landfill waste.

4. Reuse: Reuse involves repurposing returned products or components for

alternative uses or markets. This may include selling refurbished products at
discounted prices, repackaging returned items for resale, or redistributing
surplus inventory to secondary markets. Reuse helps maximize value recovery
and minimize disposal costs.

5. Resale: Resale involves reselling returned products through secondary

channels, such as liquidation marketplaces, outlet stores, or online platforms.
This allows companies to recoup some of the value of returned goods and
minimize losses. Resale strategies may include discounting, bundling, or
remarketing returned items to attract buyers.

6. Redistribution: Redistribution involves reallocating returned products or

inventory to other locations, markets, or channels where there is demand. This
may involve transferring inventory between stores, warehouses, or distribution
centers to optimize inventory levels and fulfill customer orders more
efficiently. Redistribution helps prevent excess inventory buildup and improve
supply chain agility.

7. Remarketing: Remarketing involves promoting and selling returned products

through targeted marketing efforts to attract new customers or re-engage
existing ones. This may include offering special promotions, discounts, or
incentives to encourage sales of returned items. Remarketing helps drive sales
and maximize recovery value from returned goods.

By focusing on these key aspects of reverse logistics, Mr. Saurav can develop a
comprehensive strategy and business model for his startup that addresses the
growing demand for efficient and sustainable management of retail product returns.

OR
b) Mr. Ramesh has visited the automotive assembly plant, he has
seen visual signals are used to control the material what is the
system of controlling the material? How this system gives high
level of sophistication for OEM?

20 | P a g e
The system of controlling materials using visual signals in an automotive assembly
plant is typically known as the Kanban system. Kanban is a lean manufacturing
technique that originated from the Toyota Production System (TPS) and is widely
used in various industries, including automotive manufacturing.

Here's how the Kanban system works:

1. Visual Signals: The Kanban system relies on visual signals, such as cards, bins,
or markings, to control the flow of materials and trigger production or
replenishment activities. Each visual signal represents a specific quantity of
materials or parts needed at a particular workstation or production area.

2. Pull-based System: The Kanban system operates on a pull-based principle,

where production is triggered by actual demand from downstream processes
or customers. When inventory levels at a workstation or production line drop
below a predetermined threshold, the corresponding Kanban signal is
generated to authorize the replenishment of materials from upstream
suppliers or inventory storage locations.

3. Just-in-Time (JIT) Production: By using visual signals to signal production

needs in real-time, the Kanban system enables just-in-time (JIT) production,
where materials are delivered and used only when needed, minimizing
inventory holding costs and reducing waste.

4. Limiting Work in Progress (WIP): Kanban helps limit work in progress (WIP)
by establishing maximum inventory levels or "kanban card limits" for each
production area or workstation. This prevents overproduction, reduces lead
times, and improves overall efficiency by focusing on completing tasks in a
timely manner.

Now, let's discuss how the Kanban system gives a high level of sophistication for
original equipment manufacturers (OEMs) in automotive assembly plants:

1. Efficient Inventory Management: The Kanban system allows OEMs to

efficiently manage inventory levels by aligning production with actual
demand. This reduces the need for excess inventory, minimizes stockouts, and
optimizes inventory turnover rates.

2. Improved Production Flexibility: Kanban enables OEMs to quickly adjust

production schedules and respond to changes in customer demand or
production requirements. This flexibility helps OEMs adapt to fluctuating
market conditions, minimize lead times, and meet customer delivery deadlines
more effectively.

21 | P a g e
 3. Enhanced Supply Chain Visibility: The Kanban system provides real-time
visibility into inventory levels, production status, and material flow throughout
the supply chain. This visibility enables OEMs to identify bottlenecks, optimize
production processes, and make data-driven decisions to improve efficiency
and performance.

4. Continuous Improvement: Kanban fosters a culture of continuous

improvement within automotive assembly plants by encouraging employees
to identify waste, streamline processes, and implement lean manufacturing
principles. This continuous improvement mindset helps OEMs drive
operational excellence and achieve higher levels of productivity and quality.

Overall, the Kanban system offers OEMs in automotive assembly plants a

sophisticated and effective tool for managing materials, optimizing production
processes, and driving continuous improvement in their operations. By leveraging
visual signals and pull-based principles, OEMs can achieve higher levels of efficiency,
flexibility, and responsiveness in their manufacturing operations.

First Year M.B.A.

206-SC-OSCM-02 : SUPPLY CHAIN MANAGEMENT
(2019 Pattern) (Semester-II)
Q1) Answer any 5 out of 8. [2 marks each]

a) Define 5R’s of Reverse Logistics.

The 5R's of reverse logistics are:

1. Returns: The process of handling product returns from customers, including

receiving, inspecting, and managing returned goods.

2. Remanufacturing: Refurbishing or restoring returned products to a like-new

condition for resale or reuse, often involving disassembly, repair, and
reassembly.

3. Reuse: Repurposing returned products or components for alternative uses or

markets, such as selling refurbished items or redistributing surplus inventory.

4. Recycling: Recovering and reusing materials and components from returned

products that cannot be refurbished or resold, through processes such as
sorting, shredding, and processing for reuse in manufacturing.

22 | P a g e
 5. Resale: Reselling returned products through secondary channels, such as
liquidation marketplaces or outlet stores, to recoup some of the value and
minimize losses from returns.

b) Explain the flows involved in supply chain.

The flows involved in supply chain are:

1. Material Flow: The movement of raw materials, components, and finished

goods through the supply chain, from suppliers to manufacturers, distributors,
retailers, and ultimately to customers.

2. Information Flow: The exchange of information and data related to orders,

inventory levels, production schedules, and other supply chain activities
among various stakeholders, enabling coordination and decision-making.

3. Financial Flow: The transfer of payments, invoices, and financial transactions

between suppliers, manufacturers, distributors, and other partners in the
supply chain, facilitating the exchange of goods and services.

c) Define push based supply chain.

A push-based supply chain is a traditional supply chain model where production and
distribution decisions are based on forecasts, production plans, and predetermined
schedules, rather than actual customer demand. In a push-based supply chain, products are
pushed through the supply chain based on anticipated demand, leading to the risk of
overproduction, excess inventory, and stockouts.

d) Enumerate types of KANBAN.

Types of KANBAN include:

1. Production Kanban: Used to signal the start of production for a specific item
or batch of items based on demand from downstream processes or
customers.

2. Withdrawal Kanban: Used to authorize the movement or withdrawal of

materials from inventory or storage locations to support production at
downstream processes or workstations.

23 | P a g e
e) Explain the term ‘CRM’.

CRM stands for Customer Relationship Management. It refers to the practices, strategies, and
technologies used by businesses to manage and analyze interactions with current and
potential customers throughout the customer lifecycle. The goal of CRM is to improve
customer retention, enhance customer satisfaction, and drive sales growth by understanding
and responding to customer needs and preferences effectively.

f) Define Linear SC.

A linear supply chain (SC) is a traditional supply chain model characterized by sequential and
unidirectional flows of materials, information, and resources from suppliers to manufacturers,
then to distributors, retailers, and finally to customers. In a linear SC, each entity in the supply
chain operates independently with limited coordination or collaboration, leading to
inefficiencies and suboptimal performance.

g) Define VMI.
VMI stands for Vendor Managed Inventory. It is a supply chain management practice where a
supplier takes responsibility for managing the inventory levels of their products at a
customer's location. In a VMI arrangement, the supplier monitors the customer's inventory
levels and replenishes stock as needed, typically based on predetermined agreements and
demand forecasts.

h) Define Logistics.
Logistics refers to the process of planning, implementing, and controlling the efficient and
effective flow and storage of goods, services, and information from point of origin to point
of consumption to meet customer requirements. Logistics encompasses activities such as
transportation, warehousing, inventory management, order fulfillment, and distribution,
aimed at optimizing the movement and delivery of products to customers while minimizing
costs and maximizing service levels.

Q2) Answer any 2 out of 3. [5 marks each]

a) Explain how the linear SC transformed into collaborative
network.

The transformation from a linear supply chain (SC) model to a collaborative network
reflects a fundamental shift in how businesses approach supply chain management
and collaboration with their partners. Here's how this transformation typically occurs:

1. Recognition of Limitations: Companies begin to recognize the limitations of

the linear supply chain model, such as limited flexibility, responsiveness, and
resilience to market fluctuations and disruptions. They realize that traditional

24 | P a g e
 linear SCs may not be sufficient to meet the evolving demands of today's
dynamic and interconnected business environment.

2. Emergence of Collaboration: The growing complexity and interdependence

of global supply chains drive businesses to explore alternative approaches that
emphasize collaboration, integration, and partnership with their suppliers,
customers, and other stakeholders. Collaboration becomes increasingly
important for achieving supply chain agility, efficiency, and innovation.

3. Integration and Information Sharing: Companies start to integrate systems,

processes, and data across different organizations to enable seamless
coordination and communication within the supply chain network. This
integration allows for real-time visibility into inventory levels, production
schedules, demand forecasts, and other relevant information, facilitating
better decision-making and responsiveness.

4. Shared Goals and Objectives: Collaborative networks are characterized by

shared goals and objectives among supply chain partners. Instead of pursuing
individual interests, businesses align their strategies and incentives to achieve
mutual benefits, such as improved efficiency, reduced costs, and enhanced
customer satisfaction. This alignment fosters trust, transparency, and long-
term relationships among partners.

5. Cross-Functional Teams and Innovation: Collaboration extends beyond

traditional boundaries, with cross-functional teams and collaborative
initiatives driving innovation and continuous improvement throughout the
supply chain. Companies leverage the collective expertise, resources, and
capabilities of their partners to address challenges, seize opportunities, and
drive value creation.

6. Technology and Digitalization: Technology plays a crucial role in enabling

collaboration within supply chain networks. Digital platforms, cloud-based
systems, Internet of Things (IoT) devices, and advanced analytics provide the
infrastructure and tools needed to facilitate seamless communication, data
sharing, and collaboration among supply chain partners.

7. Dynamic and Adaptive Networks: Collaborative networks are dynamic and

adaptive, capable of responding quickly to changes in market conditions,
customer preferences, and supply chain disruptions. By leveraging the
collective intelligence and agility of their partners, businesses can adapt and
innovate in real-time to stay competitive in a rapidly evolving environment.

25 | P a g e
b) Explain how JIT purchasing can result in creating the lean
SC?
Just-in-Time (JIT) purchasing is a key component of lean supply chain management, aimed at
optimizing inventory levels, reducing waste, and improving overall efficiency. Here's how
JIT purchasing can result in creating a lean supply chain (SC):

1. Minimization of Inventory: JIT purchasing focuses on acquiring materials,

components, and parts from suppliers in precise quantities and at the exact time they
are needed for production. By minimizing inventory levels and holding only what is
necessary to meet immediate production requirements, JIT purchasing reduces the
carrying costs associated with excess inventory, such as storage, handling, and
obsolescence.

2. Reduction of Lead Times: JIT purchasing emphasizes shorter lead times and faster
response times from suppliers. By synchronizing the delivery of materials with
production schedules and demand forecasts, JIT purchasing helps minimize delays
and disruptions in the supply chain, allowing for smoother production flow and
improved responsiveness to customer demand.

3. Improvement of Supplier Relationships: JIT purchasing fosters closer relationships

and collaboration with suppliers. By working closely with suppliers to establish
reliable delivery schedules, quality standards, and performance metrics, companies
can build trust, transparency, and long-term partnerships that contribute to a more
efficient and responsive supply chain.

4. Elimination of Waste: JIT purchasing helps identify and eliminate waste throughout
the supply chain, including excess inventory, overproduction, waiting times, and
unnecessary transportation. By aligning production with actual demand and reducing
variability in the supply chain, JIT purchasing minimizes non-value-added activities
and focuses resources on value-creating activities that contribute to leaner operations.

5. Flexibility and Adaptability: JIT purchasing enhances the flexibility and

adaptability of the supply chain to changes in customer demand, market conditions,
and business requirements. By enabling quick adjustments to production schedules,
order quantities, and inventory levels, JIT purchasing allows companies to respond
more effectively to fluctuations in demand and minimize the risk of excess inventory
or stockouts.

6. Continuous Improvement: JIT purchasing promotes a culture of continuous

improvement within the supply chain, where employees are encouraged to identify
opportunities for optimization, streamline processes, and implement best practices. By
continuously refining and optimizing purchasing processes, companies can achieve
higher levels of efficiency, productivity, and cost-effectiveness over time.

Overall, JIT purchasing plays a critical role in creating a lean supply chain by reducing
inventory, improving supplier relationships, eliminating waste, enhancing flexibility, and
fostering a culture of continuous improvement. By embracing JIT principles and practices,

26 | P a g e
companies can achieve greater efficiency, responsiveness, and competitiveness in today's
dynamic and demanding business environment.

c) Compare and contrast Pull based SC and Push based SC.

Pull-based and push-based supply chain (SC) models represent two different
approaches to managing production and distribution processes based on demand
signals. Let's compare and contrast these two models:

1. Pull-Based Supply Chain:

• Definition: In a pull-based SC, production and distribution activities

are driven by actual customer demand. Products are produced or
replenished in response to customer orders, forecasts, or consumption
signals, pulling inventory through the supply chain.

• Characteristics:

• Reactive: Production and replenishment activities are triggered

by customer orders or consumption signals, allowing for real-
time adjustments based on actual demand.
• Flexibility: Pull-based SCs are more flexible and responsive to
changes in customer preferences, market conditions, and
demand fluctuations.
• Reduced Inventory: Inventory levels are typically lower in pull-
based SCs compared to push-based SCs, as products are only
produced or replenished as needed.

• Examples:

• Just-in-Time (JIT) manufacturing: Production is initiated based

on actual customer demand, minimizing inventory holding costs
and reducing the risk of overproduction.
• Make-to-order (MTO) production: Products are manufactured
only after receiving customer orders, allowing for customization
and reducing the need for finished goods inventory.

2. Push-Based Supply Chain:

• Definition: In a push-based SC, production and distribution activities

are driven by forecasts, production schedules, or predetermined

27 | P a g e
 inventory levels. Products are pushed through the supply chain based
on anticipated demand.

• Characteristics:

• Proactive: Production and replenishment activities are initiated

based on forecasts or predetermined schedules, regardless of
actual customer demand.
• Efficiency: Push-based SCs are often more efficient for high-
volume, standardized products with predictable demand
patterns.
• Higher Inventory: Inventory levels tend to be higher in push-
based SCs compared to pull-based SCs, as products are
produced or stocked in anticipation of future demand.

• Examples:

• Make-to-stock (MTS) production: Products are manufactured

and stocked in inventory based on forecasts or production
schedules, allowing for faster order fulfillment but risking excess
inventory.
• Retail replenishment: Stores receive shipments of merchandise
based on predetermined schedules or allocations, rather than
customer demand, to maintain shelf availability.

Comparison:

• Demand Orientation: Pull-based SCs are demand-driven, responding to

actual customer demand, while push-based SCs are forecast-driven,
anticipating future demand.
• Flexibility: Pull-based SCs offer greater flexibility and adaptability to changes
in demand and market conditions, while push-based SCs may struggle to
adjust to fluctuations in demand.
• Inventory Management: Pull-based SCs typically have lower inventory levels
and reduced risk of excess inventory compared to push-based SCs, which may
experience inventory imbalances and obsolescence.
• Customer Responsiveness: Pull-based SCs enable faster response times and
improved customer service by aligning production with actual demand, while
push-based SCs may result in longer lead times and potential stockouts or
backorders.
• Cost Efficiency: Pull-based SCs may offer cost savings in terms of inventory
holding costs, transportation costs, and production efficiency, while push-

28 | P a g e
 based SCs may incur higher costs associated with excess inventory, storage,
and handling.

Q3) Answer 3(a) or 3(b). [10]

a) Explain in brief customer value requirement planning.
Customer Value Requirement Planning (CVRP) is a strategic approach to product
development and supply chain management that focuses on understanding and fulfilling the
value requirements of customers. Here's a brief explanation of CVRP:

1. Understanding Customer Value: CVRP starts by identifying and understanding the

value expectations and preferences of customers. This involves gathering feedback,
conducting market research, and analyzing customer behavior to determine what
features, benefits, and attributes customers value most in a product or service.

2. Defining Value Requirements: Once customer value expectations are understood,

CVRP involves translating these requirements into specific criteria or metrics that can
be used to evaluate and prioritize product features, design elements, and performance
attributes. This may include factors such as quality, reliability, functionality, cost, and
convenience.

3. Aligning with Business Objectives: CVRP aligns customer value requirements with
the strategic objectives and goals of the business. This ensures that product
development efforts are focused on delivering value propositions that are aligned with
the company's mission, vision, and competitive positioning in the marketplace.

4. Cross-Functional Collaboration: CVRP emphasizes cross-functional collaboration

and coordination among different departments and stakeholders involved in product
development, including marketing, design, engineering, operations, and supply chain
management. By involving various perspectives and expertise, CVRP ensures that
customer value requirements are considered holistically throughout the product
lifecycle.

5. Iterative Planning and Improvement: CVRP is an iterative process that involves

continuous planning, monitoring, and improvement based on changing customer
needs, market trends, and competitive dynamics. By regularly reviewing and updating
value requirements, companies can adapt and evolve their products and services to
remain competitive and meet evolving customer expectations.

Overall, Customer Value Requirement Planning is a customer-centric approach to product

development and supply chain management that emphasizes understanding, prioritizing, and
fulfilling the value requirements of customers to drive business success and competitive
advantage.

OR

29 | P a g e
b) Elaborate “the firms acheiving JIT by JIT production, JIT
purchasing and JIT transportation acheives greater operational
performance compared to the competition.
Achieving Just-in-Time (JIT) practices in production, purchasing, and transportation can
significantly enhance a firm's operational performance compared to competitors. Let's
elaborate on how JIT production, JIT purchasing, and JIT transportation contribute to greater
operational performance:

1. JIT Production:

• Reduced Inventory: JIT production focuses on producing goods only as they

are needed, in the quantities required by downstream processes or customer
demand. This minimizes inventory levels throughout the production process,
reducing holding costs and the risk of obsolescence.

• Improved Efficiency: JIT production promotes the continuous flow of

materials and work-in-progress (WIP) through the production process,
minimizing wait times, bottlenecks, and idle resources. This leads to smoother
operations, shorter lead times, and increased throughput.

• Higher Quality: JIT production emphasizes quality at the source and

proactive problem-solving to prevent defects and errors. By focusing on error
prevention and early detection, JIT production reduces rework, scrap, and
warranty costs, resulting in higher-quality products and improved customer
satisfaction.

2. JIT Purchasing:

• Supplier Integration: JIT purchasing involves close collaboration and

integration with suppliers to ensure timely delivery of materials, components,
and parts in the quantities and specifications required for production. This
minimizes lead times, reduces inventory holding costs, and improves supply
chain efficiency.

• Streamlined Procurement: JIT purchasing streamlines the procurement

process by reducing paperwork, transaction costs, and administrative overhead
associated with ordering and managing inventory. By automating ordering
processes and leveraging electronic data interchange (EDI) or supplier portals,
firms can improve purchasing efficiency and accuracy.

• Cost Savings: JIT purchasing helps minimize inventory carrying costs, reduce
order cycle times, and optimize procurement spend through volume discounts,
bulk purchasing, and negotiated pricing agreements with suppliers. This
results in cost savings and improved profitability for the firm.

3. JIT Transportation:

30 | P a g e
 • Optimized Logistics: JIT transportation ensures timely and efficient delivery
of materials and finished goods to support production schedules and customer
demand. By coordinating transportation activities with production and
inventory management, firms can minimize transportation costs, reduce lead
times, and improve service levels.

• Flexible Supply Chain: JIT transportation enables flexibility and

responsiveness in the supply chain to adapt to changing customer
requirements, market conditions, and operational needs. By leveraging
transportation modes, routes, and carriers dynamically, firms can optimize
logistics operations and mitigate risks associated with disruptions or delays.

• Enhanced Visibility: JIT transportation provides real-time visibility into the

status and location of shipments, allowing firms to track and monitor
inventory movements throughout the supply chain. This visibility enables
proactive decision-making, exception management, and performance
monitoring to ensure on-time delivery and customer satisfaction.

In summary, firms that achieve JIT practices in production, purchasing, and transportation
can gain a competitive advantage by reducing costs, improving efficiency, enhancing quality,
and increasing flexibility in their operations. By optimizing resource utilization, minimizing
waste, and aligning supply chain activities with customer demand, these firms can achieve
greater operational performance and deliver superior value to customers compared to
competitors.

Q4) Answer 4(a) or 4(b). [10]

a) How can vendor managed inventory be applied successfully.
Successfully implementing vendor-managed inventory (VMI) requires careful planning,
collaboration, and execution between the vendor and the customer. Here's how VMI can be
applied successfully:

1. Establish Clear Objectives: Define the goals and objectives of implementing VMI,
such as reducing inventory carrying costs, minimizing stockouts, improving order
fulfillment rates, or enhancing overall supply chain efficiency. Ensure alignment
between the vendor and the customer regarding the expected outcomes and benefits of
VMI.

2. Select the Right Vendor: Choose vendors who are willing and capable of
participating in a VMI arrangement. Look for suppliers with a track record of
reliability, quality, and collaboration, as well as those who can provide real-time data
visibility and support VMI processes effectively.

3. Define Inventory Policies and Parameters: Establish clear inventory policies, such
as safety stock levels, reorder points, lead times, and order quantities, in collaboration
with the vendor. Ensure that both parties agree on the parameters and metrics used to
measure inventory performance and success.

31 | P a g e
 4. Implement Technology and Data Sharing: Set up systems and technologies to
facilitate seamless data sharing and communication between the vendor and the
customer. Implement electronic data interchange (EDI), cloud-based platforms, or
other digital tools to exchange real-time inventory data, forecasts, and order
information.

5. Develop Collaborative Forecasting: Collaborate with the vendor to develop

accurate demand forecasts based on historical data, market trends, and customer
insights. Share demand forecasts, sales projections, and inventory plans to enable the
vendor to optimize production and replenishment schedules accordingly.

6. Establish Performance Metrics: Define key performance indicators (KPIs) to

evaluate the effectiveness of the VMI arrangement. Monitor metrics such as inventory
turns, fill rates, on-time delivery, stockout rates, and overall inventory accuracy to
assess performance and identify areas for improvement.

7. Promote Transparency and Trust: Foster open communication, transparency, and

trust between the vendor and the customer. Share relevant information, feedback, and
insights to facilitate collaboration, problem-solving, and continuous improvement
initiatives.

8. Provide Training and Support: Train employees and stakeholders involved in VMI
processes on the objectives, procedures, and best practices of VMI. Ensure that both
the vendor and the customer have the necessary skills, resources, and support to
effectively manage inventory and address any challenges that may arise.

9. Monitor and Adjust: Continuously monitor inventory levels, demand patterns, and
supply chain performance to identify trends, patterns, and areas for optimization.
Regularly review the VMI arrangement, gather feedback from stakeholders, and make
adjustments as needed to optimize inventory management and achieve desired
outcomes.

By following these steps and fostering a collaborative partnership between the vendor and the
customer, businesses can successfully implement VMI to improve inventory visibility,
optimize supply chain efficiency, and drive mutual benefits for all parties involved.

OR
b) Elaborate the necessity of outsourcing.
Outsourcing has become an integral part of modern business strategy due to several
compelling reasons:

1. Focus on Core Competencies: Outsourcing allows companies to focus their

resources, time, and energy on their core competencies – the activities and functions
that differentiate them in the marketplace and provide a competitive advantage. By
outsourcing non-core functions such as IT support, payroll processing, or customer
service, companies can redirect their efforts towards strategic initiatives, innovation,
and business growth.

32 | P a g e
 2. Cost Savings: Outsourcing certain business functions can often lead to cost savings
through economies of scale, specialization, and access to lower-cost labor markets.
Outsourced service providers may operate more efficiently and cost-effectively due to
their expertise, infrastructure, and scale, resulting in reduced overhead costs and
improved profitability for the client company.

3. Access to Specialized Skills and Expertise: Outsourcing enables companies to

access specialized skills, knowledge, and expertise that may not be available
internally. By partnering with external service providers or consultants who possess
domain-specific experience and capabilities, companies can tap into a broader talent
pool and benefit from best practices, innovation, and industry insights.

4. Flexibility and Scalability: Outsourcing offers flexibility and scalability to adapt to

changing business needs, market dynamics, and resource requirements. Companies
can easily scale up or down their operations, adjust capacity, or access additional
resources as needed without incurring significant upfront investments or long-term
commitments.

5. Risk Mitigation: Outsourcing can help mitigate various risks associated with
business operations, such as technological obsolescence, regulatory compliance,
geopolitical instability, or natural disasters. By outsourcing certain functions to
specialized service providers or offshore locations, companies can diversify risk,
improve business continuity, and enhance resilience to disruptions.

6. Improved Focus on Customer Experience: Outsourcing non-core functions allows

companies to allocate more resources and attention to enhancing the customer
experience and delivering value-added services. By offloading routine or
administrative tasks to external partners, companies can free up internal resources to
focus on building stronger customer relationships, innovating products, and delivering
exceptional service.

7. Global Expansion and Market Access: Outsourcing provides opportunities for

global expansion and market access by leveraging the capabilities and networks of
external partners. Companies can tap into new markets, access international talent
pools, and establish a presence in foreign regions more efficiently and cost-effectively
through strategic outsourcing initiatives.

Overall, outsourcing is a strategic business decision that enables companies to streamline

operations, improve efficiency, drive innovation, and remain competitive in today's dynamic
and interconnected business environment. By leveraging external expertise, resources, and
capabilities, companies can unlock value, achieve operational excellence, and focus on
driving sustainable growth and success.

Q5) Answer 5(a) or 5(b). [10]

a) Draw the generalized supply chain model and highlight
supplier network Integrated enterprise & Distributive network.
Creating a generalized supply chain model involves depicting the flow of materials,
information, and value across different stages of the supply chain. Here's a simplified

33 | P a g e
depiction of a supply chain model, highlighting the supplier network, integrated enterprise,
and distributive network:

[Supplier] [Manufacturer] [Distributor] [Retailer]

[Customer]
Network Integrated Network Network
Network
Enterprise

Raw Materials Production/ Distribution/ Retail

End User
Assembly Warehousing Operations

1. Supplier Network:

• The supplier network represents the upstream portion of the supply chain,
consisting of suppliers, vendors, and other partners involved in providing raw
materials, components, and parts.
• Suppliers may be local or global, providing inputs necessary for production or
assembly processes.
• Raw materials flow from suppliers to manufacturers, initiating the supply
chain process.

2. Integrated Enterprise:

• The integrated enterprise refers to the internal operations of the manufacturer,

where production, assembly, and value-added processes take place.
• This stage involves transforming raw materials into finished goods or
intermediate products through manufacturing, assembly, quality control, and
other operations.
• The integrated enterprise may incorporate advanced technologies, lean
principles, and cross-functional collaboration to optimize efficiency and
quality.

3. Distributive Network:

• The distributive network encompasses the downstream portion of the supply

chain, involving distribution centers, warehouses, logistics providers, and
other entities responsible for storing, handling, and transporting finished
goods.
• Distribution centers and warehouses serve as hubs for inventory management,
order fulfillment, and transportation coordination.
• Finished goods flow from manufacturers to distributors, then to retailers,
before reaching the end customer.

34 | P a g e
In this generalized supply chain model, the supplier network, integrated enterprise, and
distributive network represent distinct stages and functions within the supply chain, each
playing a crucial role in delivering products to end customers efficiently and effectively.
Highlighting these components helps visualize the interconnectedness and interdependence of
various supply chain entities in fulfilling customer demand.

OR
b) Draw the line diagram for automotive OEM and highlight
upstream and downstream firms/structures which adds value in
the product to give superior quality products at optimal cost to
the end consumer
Sure, here's a simplified line diagram for an automotive Original Equipment Manufacturer
(OEM), highlighting both upstream and downstream firms/structures that add value to the
product to deliver superior quality products at optimal cost to the end consumer:

[Raw Material Suppliers] -> [Component Suppliers] -> [OEM Manufacturer] -> [Assembly Plants] ->
[Distribution Centers] -> [Retailers] -> [End Consumers]

1. Raw Material Suppliers:

• These are the providers of basic raw materials such as steel, plastics, rubber,
glass, etc., which are used in the manufacturing of automotive components and
parts.
• Raw material suppliers may include mining companies, chemical
manufacturers, and other primary producers.

2. Component Suppliers:

• Component suppliers produce specialized parts and components that are used
in the assembly of vehicles.
• These suppliers manufacture items such as engines, transmissions, chassis,
electrical systems, and interior components.
• Component suppliers may include both Tier 1 suppliers (direct suppliers to the
OEM) and lower-tier suppliers (Tier 2, Tier 3, etc.).

3. OEM Manufacturer:

• The OEM manufacturer is responsible for assembling various components and

parts into finished vehicles.
• The OEM manages the overall design, engineering, production, and quality
control processes to ensure the final product meets customer specifications and
regulatory standards.

4. Assembly Plants:

35 | P a g e
 • Assembly plants are facilities where vehicle components are brought together
and assembled into finished vehicles.
• These plants may include body assembly lines, paint shops, and final assembly
lines where vehicles are completed and tested.

5. Distribution Centers:

• Distribution centers are logistics hubs where finished vehicles are stored,
managed, and prepared for shipment to retailers or dealerships.
• Distribution centers may also handle inventory management, order processing,
and vehicle customization activities.

6. Retailers (Dealerships):

• Retailers or dealerships are the final point of sale where customers purchase
vehicles.
• Dealerships provide sales, financing, and after-sales services such as
maintenance, repairs, and warranty support to end consumers.

7. End Consumers:

• End consumers are the ultimate users of the automotive products, who
purchase and use vehicles for personal or commercial purposes.

In this line diagram, each stage represents a link in the automotive supply chain where value
is added through manufacturing, assembly, distribution, and retailing activities. Collaboration
and coordination among upstream and downstream firms are essential to deliver high-quality
products at optimal cost to meet the needs and expectations of end consumers.

36 | P a g e