Global Governance
Global Governance
• In 1311 Dante Alighieri wrote a political tract under • Immanuel Kant (1724-1804) said that the problem
the title of De Monarchia, which was translated into of international order, was ‘the most difficult and the
English and published in 1949 as On World last to be solved by the human race.’ Men formed
Government. states to constrain their passions, but each state
sought to preserve its absolute freedom, even at the
• Dante wrote: “it is evident that mankind, too, is most cost of ‘a lawless state of savagery.’ But the
free and easy to carry on its work when it enjoys the ‘devastations, upheaval and even complete inner
quiet and tranquility of peace. To achieve this state of exhaustion of their powers’ arising from interstate
universal well-being a single world government is clashes would in time oblige men to contemplate an
necessary.” alternative. Humanity faced either the peace of ‘the
vast graveyard of the human race’ or peace by • Disarmament
reasoned design.”
• preventing war through collective security
• Kant’s proposal for this “peace by reasoned design”
was a voluntary federation of nations within a • settling disputes between countries through
framework of respect for agreed rules of conduct, and negotiation diplomacy, and
where citizens would no longer wish to face the • improving global welfare.
rigors and consequences of armed conflicts. Kant’s
“league of peace” would evolve into a peaceful world • The League Covenant contained many innovations:
order and “a perfect civil union of mankind Article 8 established provisions for disarmament.
• US President Woodrow Wilson DREAMED to • Wilson believed that nations would not so easily go
create a permanent international organization made to war if they could consult and discuss their
up of the leading powers of the day and with the grievances and openly explore ways to resolve
specific aim of preventing war. them in peaceful ways.
• In a speech delivered to the US Senate on January 22, • The “cooling off” periods embedded in the Covenant
1917 President Wilson said: “There must be, not a were intended to avoid a repetition of the events of
balance of power, but a community of power; not 1914, when Europe mindlessly stumbled upon the
organized rivalries, but an organized, common bloodiest war ever undertaken.
peace.”
The League failed due to:
• Kissinger (2014) notes that Wilson’s concept of
• lack of unanimity
“community of power” would in time reemerge as the
principle of “collective security.” • Lack of US participation
• “The League of Nations…would be founded on a • Germany, Japan and Italy eventually left
moral principle, the universal opposition to military
aggression as such, whatever its source, its target, or
its proclaimed justification.”
CALL FOR A NEW WORLD ORDER
• There is a streak of idealism that runs through
The UN Charter endorsed in 1945 by 51 nations sought to lay
Wilson’s many interventions in support of the
a framework for a new world order: “To save succeeding
League.
generations from the scourge of war,…and to reaffirm faith in
• In a speech in 1919 he noted: “My clients are the fundamental human rights…in the equal rights of men and
children; my clients are the next generation. They do women…to establish conditions under which justice and
not know what promises and bonds I undertook when respect for…international law can be maintained, and to
I ordered the armies of the United States to the soil of promote social progress and better standards of life…and to
France, but I know, and I intend to redeem my employ international machinery for the promotion of the
pledges to the children; they shall not be sent upon a economic and social advancement of all peoples: WE THE
similar errand.” PEOPLES have resolved to establish an international
organization to be known as the United Nations.”
• The League of Nations was a international • officially came into existence on October 24, 1945
organization founded after the Paris Peace with 51 original Member States.
Conference, 1919.
• currently 193 Members of the United Nations.
• It began with four permanent members – Great
• They meet in the General Assembly, which is the
Britain, France, Italy, and Japan – and four non-
closest thing to a world parliament.
permanent members that were elected by the
Assembly for a three-year term. • Each country, large or small, rich or poor, has a single
vote, however, none of the decisions taken by the
• The first non-permanent members were Belgium,
Assembly are BUT the Assembly’s decisions become
Brazil, Greece, and Spain. The composition of the
resolutions that carry the weight of the world
Council was changed several times.
governmental opinion.
The League's goals included:
UN SYMBOL: 3. All members should settle their international disputes by
World held by Olive Leaves peaceful means so that “international peace, security and
justice are not endangered”.
• Olive Branches represent Peace
4. All members are to refrain from the threat or use of force
• Main Goal of the UN: Maintain world peace and against any state.
security.
5. All members are to assist the UN in any actions taken and
• UN Headquarters are in New York City are not to assist any state against which the UN is acting.
• PARLIAMENT OF NATIONS
PRINCIPLES OF THE UN • the forum for all member states
1. The Organization is based on the “sovereign equality” of • holds an annual session in September but meets
all members. throughout the year for emergency debates.
2. All members are expected to fulfill “in good faith” all UN
obligations.
• meeting place where world leaders or their Currently the ten non-permanent members elected for two-
representatives, from nations large and small, present year terms by the General Assembly (with end of term year)
their positions on various issues. are: Belgium (2020), Dominican Republic (2020), Estonia
(2021), Germany (2020), Indonesia (2020), Niger (2021),
• Meet to consider world problems and 2/3 majority is Saint Vincent and the Grenadines (2021), South Africa (2020),
needed to decide International peace and security Tunisia (2021) and Vietnam (2021).
issues, admitting new members, and budget.
The General Assembly divides its responsibilities among • Each member has one vote. 5 permanent nations have
six standing committees: veto power.
• 1. Disarmament and International Security • Procedural matters require a 3/5 majority (No veto)
Committee Substantive matters are 3/5 plus the consent of the P-
5
• 2. Economic and Financial Committee
• “All members of the UN agree to accept and carry
• 3. Social, Humanitarian and Cultural Committee out the decisions of the SC” They can apply
• 4. Special Political and Decolonization Committee sanctions, take military actions against an aggressor,
and many others
• 5. Administrative and Budgetary Committee.
• The SC functions continuously in NY
• 6. Legal Committee
ECONOMIC AND SOCIAL COUNCIL (ECOSOC)
• the fifteen judges (no duplicate countries) are elected ➢ It just means that the system is in one of the calm
by the Security Council and the General Assembly. phases of the business cycle.
STABILITY
➢ Firmness in position, permanence, and resistance to Sustainability Problems in Environmental Issues and
change especially in a disruptive way Resources
BASIC CONCEPTS #11: Make cities inclusive, safe, resilient and sustainable
1. The issue of sustainability will expand to all fields of #12: Ensure sustainable consumption and production
economic life and merge with stability. patterns
2. Moving towards a new economic model #13: Take urgent action to combat climate change and its
impacts*
3. Pluralism of institutional arrangements
#14: Conserve and sustainably use the oceans, seas and
4. Corrected goal and measure of development marine resources
SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT GOALS #15: Sustainably manage forests, combat desertification,
halt and reverse land degradation,
➤ A set of 17 goals for the world’s future, through 2030
halt biodiversity loss
➤ Backed up by a set of 169 detailed Targets
#16: Promote just, peaceful
➤ Negotiated over a two-year period at the United
Nations and inclusive
#4: Ensure inclusive and quality education for all and • Invented by Thomas Newcomen in 1712,
promote lifelong learning with significant improvements by James
Watt in the 1760s.
#5: Achieve gender equality and empower women and girls
• Revolutionized transportation and
#6: Ensure access to water and sanitation for all manufacturing by providing a reliable source
of power.
#7: Ensure access to affordable, reliable, sustainable and • Enabled the development of factories,
modern energy for all railways, and steam-powered ships.
#8: Promote inclusive and sustainable economic growth, • Increased efficiency and productivity in
employment and decent work for all industries such as textiles, mining, and
agriculture
#9: Build resilient infrastructure, promote sustainable
industrialization and foster innovation
2nd Industrial Revolution
#10: Reduce inequality within and among countries
• Facilitated the storage and retrieval of vast
The Second Industrial Revolution began in amounts of information, leading to the
the 19th century through the discovery of development of databases and information
electricity and assembly line production. Henry systems
Ford (1863-1947) took the idea of mass production
from a slaughterhouse in Chicago: The pigs hung
from conveyor belts and each butcher performed 4th Industrial Revolution
only a part of the task of butchering the animal.
Henry Ford carried over these principles into We are currently implementing the Fourth
automobile production and drastically altered it in Industrial Revolution. This is characterised by the
the process. While before one station assembled application of information and communication
an entire automobile, now the vehicles were technologies to industry and is also known as
produced in partial steps on the conveyor belt - "Industry 4.0". It builds on the developments of the
significantly faster and at lower cost. Third Industrial Revolution. Production systems that
already have computer technology are expanded
by a network connection and have a digital twin on
• Major advancements in the late 19th and the Internet so to speak. These allow
early 20th centuries, notably with the work communication with other facilities and the output
of inventors like Thomas Edison and of information about themselves. This is the next
Nikola Tesla. step in production automation. The networking of all
• Electricity replaced steam power in many systems leads to "cyber-physical production
industrial processes, leading to cleaner and systems" and therefore smart factories, in which
more efficient operations. production systems, components and people
• Enabled the widespread adoption of electric communicate via a network and production is
lighting, which transformed urban nearly autonomous.
environments.
• Facilitated the development of electric
motors, leading to innovations in • Originated in the mid-20th century as
transportation and manufacturing. researchers explored the possibility of
creating machines capable of intelligent
behavior.
3rd Industrial Revolution • Experienced rapid advancements in recent
decades, fueled by developments in
The Third Industrial Revolution began in the algorithms, computing power, and data
’70s in the 20th century through partial availability.
automation using memory-programmable • Applications range from autonomous
controls and computers. Since the introduction of vehicles and natural language processing to
these technologies, we are now able to automate image recognition and medical diagnosis.
an entire production process - without human • Promises to revolutionize various industries
assistance. Known examples of this are robots that by enhancing efficiency, decision-making,
perform programmed sequences without human and innovation.
intervention.
Globalization:
• Emerged in the mid-20th century with the
invention of the electronic computer, • Refers to the increasing
notably the ENIAC (1946) and UNIVAC interconnectedness and
(1951). interdependence of economies, cultures,
• ENIAC stands for "Electronic Numerical and societies worldwide.
Integrator and Computer," while UNIVAC • Facilitated by advances in transportation,
stands for "Universal Automatic Computer." communication, and technology, allowing
• Dramatically increased the speed and for the easier flow of goods, services,
accuracy of calculations, revolutionizing capital, information, and people across
data processing and analysis. borders.
• Enabled automation of tasks in various • Leads to both opportunities and challenges,
industries, from manufacturing to finance. including economic growth, cultural
exchange, and technological innovation, as Sure, here's a questionnaire based on the provided text for
well as concerns about inequality, cultural your review:
homogenization, and environmental
degradation.
1. **Global Governance and Its Definition:**
Hyper-Consumption: a. What is the purpose of global governance according to the
provided text?
• Describes a pattern of excessive and b. According to Young (1994), how does he define global
unsustainable consumption, driven by governance?
factors such as advertising, consumer
culture, and planned obsolescence.
• Often associated with affluent societies and 2. **Globalization and Governance:**
fueled by desires for status, convenience,
and novelty. a. How are globalization and global governance
• Leads to environmental consequences such interconnected?
as resource depletion, pollution, and waste b. Describe the relationship between states, globalization,
generation, as well as social issues like and the need for supranational entities according to the text.
debt, inequality, and stress.
Metaphors of Globalization:
5. **Structure and Functions of the United Nations:**
Solid a. Describe the structure and functions of the General
• Yung hadlang Assembly and the Security Council of the United Nations.
2. **Globalization and Governance:** b. The SDGs aim for universality, integration, and
transformation, meaning they apply to all nations, are
a. Globalization and global governance are intimately interconnected, and require fundamental changes in how we
connected, as globalization leads to challenges that surpass the live on Earth.
capacities of individual governments, necessitating
coordination at a global level.
b. The text suggests that as globalization occurs, states lose 7. **Concepts of Stability and Sustainability:**
control over their destinies, prompting the delegation of
a. Stability refers to firmness, permanence, and resistance to
political authority to supranational entities to address global
disruptive change, while sustainability considers the long-term
issues effectively.
capacity of a system to exist without compromising future
generations' needs.
3. **Historical Calls for World Order:** b. Stability and sustainability are intertwined concepts that
require balancing economic growth with environmental
preservation and social equity.
b. How does the Security Council differ from the General
Assembly in terms of authority and decision-making?
8. **Challenges and Solutions:**
a. Global governance and sustainable development are a. Define stability and sustainability in the context of
crucial for addressing pressing global challenges and economic and environmental challenges.
promoting peace, prosperity, and equity worldwide. b. Discuss the importance of balancing stability and
b. Studying this text provides insights into historical and sustainability for long-term global well-being.
contemporary efforts to create a more just and sustainable
world through international cooperation and collective action.
7. **Challenges and Solutions for Sustainable
Development:**
Certainly! Here's another questionnaire based on the provided a. Identify key challenges hindering sustainable development
text: according to the text.
b. Why is global governance considered necessary in a world 8. **Role of the United Nations in Addressing Global
of interdependent actors? Issues:**
b. What were the main motivations behind these historical 9. **Reflections on Global Governance and Sustainable
calls for world order? Development:**
b. Why did the League of Nations fail, and how did the
United Nations seek to address its shortcomings? Feel free to review these questions, and let me know if there
are any adjustments or additional areas you'd like to explore!
Sure, here are the answers to the questionnaire:
a. Outline the main organs of the United Nations and their 1. **Understanding Global Governance:**
respective functions.
a. Global governance, as defined in the text, refers to the a. The Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) are a set of
establishment and operation of social institutions that define 17 goals adopted by the United Nations in 2015 to address
social practices, assign roles, and guide interactions among global challenges such as poverty, inequality, and climate
interdependent actors to resolve conflicts, facilitate change, aiming to achieve sustainable development by 2030.
cooperation, and alleviate collective action problems.
b. Examples of specific SDGs include ending poverty (Goal
b. Global governance is considered necessary in a world of 1), ensuring clean water and sanitation (Goal 6), promoting
interdependent actors because it helps coordinate collective gender equality (Goal 5), and combating climate change (Goal
action and address global challenges that exceed the 13).
capabilities of individual governments.
b. The Security Council has primary responsibility for 9. **Reflections on Global Governance and Sustainable
maintaining international peace and security, with authority to Development:**
enforce decisions through measures such as sanctions or
military action, whereas the General Assembly serves as a a. Global governance and sustainable development are
forum for member states to discuss and decide on international essential for addressing global challenges and promoting
issues, with decisions made by a simple majority vote. peace, prosperity, and equity worldwide.
3. Provide examples of global public goods mentioned in the 14. Define globalization and hyper-consumption based on the
text. text.
4. Describe historical calls for a new world order as outlined in 15. Explain the concept of hyper-debt according to the
the text, including references to specific individuals and their provided information.
proposals.
**Section 5: Reflection**
**Section 2: The United Nations**
8. What are the main purposes and principles of the United 19. Reflect on the role of the United Nations in addressing
Nations according to the provided information? global challenges such as sustainable development and
peacekeeping.
1. **What is the definition of global governance?** 7. **How many original member states were there in the
United Nations?**
- Global governance brings together diverse actors to
coordinate collective action at the level of the planet. It - There were 51 original member states in the United
involves the establishment and operation of social institutions Nations.
capable of resolving conflicts, facilitating cooperation, and
alleviating collective action problems in a world of
interdependent actors. 8. **What is the main goal of the United Nations?**
- Globalization and global governance are intimately 9. **Who is the current President of the General Assembly?**
connected. As globalization occurs, states lose control over
their destinies, problems become larger than the capacities of - The current President of the General Assembly is Volkan
individual governments, and states must delegate and possibly Bozkir.
abdicate political authority to supranational entities with
powers that more nearly coincide with the scope of the issues
and actors to be managed. 10. **How many permanent members are there in the United
Nations Security Council?**