Signal Integrity Analysis of Gigabit Interconnects: Olie Kreidler Tektronix, Inc
Signal Integrity Analysis of Gigabit Interconnects: Olie Kreidler Tektronix, Inc
of Gigabit Interconnects
Olie Kreidler
Tektronix, Inc.
1 Tektronix Confidential
Signal Integrity (SI): Digital Becomes
Analog
“At high frequencies … crosstalk and signal reflections can be
perceived as logic triggers, and can be responsible for
erroneous signal patterns”
– EE Times, April 17, 1998, Special Section on Interconnects
2 Tektronix Confidential
Industry Trends and Issues
On-going trends and issues
– Trends: faster rise times, clock frequencies, increasing interconnect
complexity
– Requirement: increasing need for signal integrity analysis and SPICE /
IBIS interconnect modeling
New trends and requirements
– Trends:
S-parameters and eye diagrams are becoming part of compliance testing for
passive PHY
All standards currently are differential and serial
– Requirements
Eye diagram and S-parameter compliance testing must be performed in
differential mode
Frequency dependent losses need to be modeled
3 Tektronix Confidential
Outline
Interconnect Measurement Accuracy Issues
TDR/T and VNA Measurement Basics
App Note: “TDR and VNA Measurement Primer”
– Impedance Measurements and IConnect® True Impedance Profile
– Time Domain S-parameter Measurements
– Eye Diagram Measurements
– TDR Probing and Fixturing
4 Tektronix Confidential
High-Speed Serial Data Link Analysis
EQUALIZER
- - - - - - - -
path
The risetime of the channel is relatively slow compared to the very fast 1’st channel. i.e. modern channel’s risetime is
quite longer than the UI, thus the eye blures and ‘ISI’-s itself.
Equalize it!
Tx + + + Rx +
+ + path + + path + Rcv Rcv
EQUALIZER
EQ.
- - - - - - - -- -
path
Equalization is the answer for the digital receiver. The eye opens at the input of the receiver, the receiver can decode
the signal.
Equalize
it!
Tx + + + Rx +
+ + path + + path + Rcv Rcv
EQUALIZER
EQ.
- - - - - - - -- -
path
8 Tektronix Confidential
TDR Overview - Typical System
Reflection
Incident
Sampler
Reflections
Probe
50 50
t = 0 Impedance
reference
Test device
Step Generator
TDR Waveform Characteristics
TDR systems observe the superposition of incident
and reflected signals at source
Time separation t1-t0 assures ability to discern
difference
Vreflected
Vincident
t0 t1 Time
TDR Rho Units Definition
Vreflected
and 0 at Z Z 0
Vincident
Amplitude
+1
0
Vreflected
Characteristic (Z = Z0)
Vincident
-1
t0 t1 Time
KCL Applied at Discontinuity
Transmission lines support propagation with specific
characteristic impedance Z
Reflected and forward propagating signals will be such that i
= 0 is satisfied at discontinuity
Can easily solve for Z knowing , Z0, and KCL for lumped
circuits
Forward
Incident
Z
0
Step (Z = Z0)
Source
Discontinui
Reflected ty
Solution for Z Units
1
Z Z 0
Where
1
– Z0 is the known reference impedance
– the sampling oscilloscopedirectly measures
– Z is the calculated test device impedance
Note textbooks usually show reversed expression
Z Z0
Z Z0
TDR Waveforms - Simple Cases
Amplitude
+1 Open (Z =)
reflected =+1
0 (Z = 50)
-1 Short (Z = 0)
t0 t1 Time
TDS Measurement Basics
TDR Block Diagram
V V r e fle c te d
R in c id e n t
Panel
s o u rc e
C a b le : Z 0 , td D U T: Z DU T
O p e n c ir c u it
V Z > Z
V •Z lo a d / (Z lo a d + Z 0) lo a d 0
M a tc h e d lo a d
½ V ½ V
Z < Z
S h o r t c ir c u it lo a d 0
0 0
15 Tektronix Confidential
TDR Measurements Basics
Inductance and Capacitance Analysis
S h u n t C d is c o n tin u ity
½ V Z Z
0 0
0
S e r ie s L d is c o n tin u i ty
½ V
Z 0 Z 0
L - C d is c o n tin u ity
½ V
Z 0 Z 0
C - L -C d is c o n tin u ity
½ V
Z 0 Z 0
16 Tektronix Confidential
Measurement Tools: Z-line
Z-line-Based Measurements
t t
1 2 1 2 1
L Z ( t )dt C dt
2 t1 2 t1 Z ( t )
t1
t2
t1
t2
17 Tektronix Confidential
TDR Measurements Basics
TDR Rise Time and Resolution
Accepted rule of thumb for resolving two discontinuities
t s e p a ra te T o r e s o lv e a 1 a n d a 2 a s
s e p a r a te d is c o n tin u itie s :
a1 a2 t s e p a r a te > t T D R _ r is e tim e / 2
80E04 TDR rise time: 30-40ps at the end of the cable, probe, fixture
– Base 1/2trise resolution: 15-20ps
– 0.1”-0.12” in FR4
80E10 TDR rise time: 12-16ps at the end of the cable, probe, fixture
– Base 1/2trise resolution: 6-8ps
– 0.04”-0.048” in FR4
18 Tektronix Confidential
TDR Measurements Basics
TDR Rise Time and Resolution
More real case: resolving a single discontinuity
t s in g le
a 1 is n o t r e s o lv e d if
a1 t s in g le < < t T D R _ r is e tim e
19 Tektronix Confidential
TDR Measurements Basics
TDR Rise Time and Resolution
If 30-40 ps (or 12 ps) fast TDR How in the world a 80 ps
rise time does not resolve it …. signal rise time
will????????????
20 Tektronix Confidential
TDR Measurements Basics
Differential TDR
Differential serial link analysis
Virtual ground plane
Even and odd mode measurements
R s o u rc e
C a b le : Z 0 , td
TDR Oscilloscope Front Panel
V
V ir tu a l g r o u n d D U T: Z DU T
V
V V in c id e n t
r e fle c te d
C a b le : Z 0 , td
R s o u rc e
21 Tektronix Confidential
TDR Measurements Basics
Good Measurement Practices
Perform calibration routines regularly
Minimum warm-up time 20 minutes
Maintain constant temperature in the lab and check the
instrument t°
Zoom in on the DUT – but include all the DUT signature
transitions (more to follow)
Use torque wrenches when mating SMA or other RF connectors
22 Tektronix Confidential
Time and Frequency Domains
VNA Block Diagram
R source
Cable: Z 0
, td
V V
Port 1
VNA Front Panel
incident1 transmitted2
Port 2
V Calib ration
procedures: DUT
- SOLT V reflected1
- TRL
- LRRM
23 Tektronix Confidential
Time and Frequency Domains
Equations for TDR vs. VNA
Vreflected Z load Z 0 1
TDR Z DUT Z0
Vincident Z load Z 0 1
25 Tektronix Confidential
Time and Frequency Domains
Time or Frequency Domain?
SI measurements do not require high dynamic range
V H IG H
-4 0 d B e q u a ls
1 % in tim e
d o m a in
V LOW
1 % (-4 0 d B ) X ta lk
26 Tektronix Confidential
Impedance Accuracy
TDR Basic Equations
V =
Vreflected Z load Z 0 2 td m e a s u re d
V in c id e n t + V r e fle c te d
Vincident Z load Z 0
V in c id e n t
Z Z0
Vreflected Vincident DUT 0
Z DUT Z 0
27 Tektronix Confidential
Impedance Accuracy
TDR Multiple Reflection Effects
Issue: impedance accuracy suffers due to signal re-reflection
inside the DUT
Z0 Z1 Z2 Z3 Z4
Vtransmitted1
Vreflected1 Vreflected2
t0
V reflected 1 1V incident 1
V reflected 2 t 12 2V incident 1 1V incident 2
V reflected 3 ( t 12 t 22 32 t 12 22 1 )V incident 1 t 12 2V incident 2 1V incident 3
Vreflected 1 k1 0 0 0 Vincident 1
V V
reflected 2 k 2 k1 0 0 0 incident 2
Vreflected 3 k3 k2 k1 0 Vincident 3
0
Vreflected n k k n 1 kn 2 k1 Vincident n
n
29 Tektronix Confidential
Impedance Accuracy
Board Trace IConnect® Z-line
Multiple reflections in
TDR waveform
30 Tektronix Confidential
Impedance Accuracy
Board Trace IConnect® Z-line
Accurate impedance
profile in IConnect®
31 Tektronix Confidential
Impedance Accuracy
Package Trace IConnect® Z-line
Impedance profile
in IConnect®:
Exact failure location,
improved resolution
32 Tektronix Confidential
Impedance Accuracy
IConnect® Software Z-line Algorithm
TDR measurements suffer from multiple reflections
– No limited to TDR, also in TD in VNA
IConnect removes multiple reflections
– Ensures accurate impedance measurements in multi-impedance DUT
– Direct and accurate readout of Z, td, L, C
– Different and more accurate than Z readout in the scope
Attention!:
– Data noise may interfere with accuracy
Use scope averaging
Use software noise filtering
– Line loss is extracted separately
33 Tektronix Confidential
Frequency Dependent S-parameters
Why S-parameters
Compliance testing
– Insertion loss (around 6-10 dB)
– Return loss (around 20-30 dB)
– Frequency domain crosstalk
Link performance evaluation and simulation
– Simulate S-parameters directly
34 Tektronix Confidential
Frequency Dependent S-parameters
Equations for TDR vs. VNA
Vreflected Z load Z 0 1
TDR Z DUT Z0
Vincident Z load Z 0 1
35 Tektronix Confidential
Frequency Dependent S-parameters
Single-ended TDR
T D R s tim u lu s o n c h a n n e l 1 , T D R s tim u lu s o n c h a n n e l 2 ,
re s p o n s e o n c h a n n e l 1 re s p o n s e o n c h a n n e l 1
T D R s tim u lu s o n c h a n n e l 1 , T D R s tim u lu s o n c h a n n e l 2 ,
re s p o n s e o n c h a n n e l 2 re s p o n s e o n c h a n n e l 2
36 Tektronix Confidential
Frequency Dependent S-parameters
Correct Data Acquisition
DUT waveform
to settle to
steady DC level
37 Tektronix Confidential
Frequency Dependent S-parameters
Return Loss = TDR
Measure TDR, compute S11 (return loss) in IConnect
What is
wrong with
this RL
picture?
38 Tektronix Confidential
Frequency Dependent S-parameters
Insertion Loss = TDT
Measure TDT, compute S21 (insertion loss) in IConnect
Test case
for loss
extraction
39 Tektronix Confidential
Frequency Dependent S-parameters
Differential and Mixed S-parameters
C o m m o n m o d e T D R s tim u lu s ,
D iffe r e n tia l T D R s tim u lu s , d iffe r e n tia l r e s p o n s e
d iffe r e n tia l r e s p o n s e (u s e fu l in tim e d o m a in fo r E M I
(m o s t im p o r ta n t) tr o u b le s h o o tin g )
Several InfiniBand
traces of different
length.
Differential return
loss.
41 Tektronix Confidential
Demo of TDR and S parameter
measurements
42 Tektronix Confidential
Additional Material
43 Tektronix Confidential
44 Tektronix Confidential
Frequency Dependent S-parameters
Power Plane Resonance
Observe plane
impedance
profile (Z-line)
Resonances
between planes
45 Tektronix Confidential
Frequency Dependent S-parameters
Electrical Compliance Testing
Need fixture to interface to interconnects for compliance testing
DUT Connection
Traces
Reference thru
Traces
Infiniband
Connector
46 Tektronix Confidential
Frequency Dependent S-parameters
VNA Fixture De-embedding
For VNA requires additional standard to de-embed properly
Insertion loss: fixture insertion loss must be subtracted from
DUT insertion loss
Return loss: no way to de-embed without additional standards!
– Fixture return loss ends up being lumped with the DUT return loss
– Can be a problem even with quality fixtures
47 Tektronix Confidential
Frequency Dependent S-parameters
VNA Real Fixture Limitation Example
Spec:
-10 dB
at 1.25 GHz
48 Tektronix Confidential
Frequency Dependent S-parameters
TD-VNA Fixture De-embedding
Simplicity of calibration allows simple fixture de-embedding
Spec:
-10 dB
at 1.25 GHz
Fixture de-embedded
with TDNA, the
assembly is passing
49 Tektronix Confidential
Frequency Dependent S-parameters
Correlation with Network Analyzer
50 Tektronix Confidential
Frequency Dependent S-parameters
Correlation with Network Analyzer
0
FREQ, Ghz
2.0
0.5
1.0
1.5
2.5
3.0
3.5
4.0
4.5
5.0
5.5
6.0
6.5
7.0
7.5
8.0
8.5
9.0
9.5
-5
-15 IConnect®
S11.wfm(dBMag). No
TDR calibration
-20
-25
51 Tektronix Confidential
Frequency Dependent S-parameters
Correlation with Network Analyzer
-2
-4
IL (dB)
VNA
-6
TDA
-8
-10
-12
000.0E+ 1.0E+9 2.0E+9 3.0E+9 4.0E+9 5.0E+9 6.0E+9 7.0E+9 8.0E+9 9.0E+9 10.0E+9
0
Frequency (Hz)
52 Tektronix Confidential
Frequency Dependent S-parameters
Correlation with Network Analyzer: 65 GHz
The TD-VNA bandwidth is
0
-5
65 GHz
0
-10
VNA
-40
4022
-50
-60
0 10 20 30 40 50 60
frequency (GHz)
53 Tektronix Confidential
Frequency Dependent S-parameters
Calibrated Results: SOLT
54 Tektronix Confidential
Frequency Dependent S-parameters
Noise Floor and Dynamic Range
55 Tektronix Confidential
Frequency Dependent S-parameters
TD-VNA Incident Effective Power
The TD-VNA 0
bandwidth
directly related -20 4022 10 ps
4022 10ps
magnatude (dB)
TDT signals -60
-80
-100
-120
-140
0 20 40 60 80 100
frequency (GHz)
56 Tektronix Confidential
Frequency Dependent S-parameters
TD-VNA Dynamic Range (with PSPL Module)
57 Tektronix Confidential
Frequency Dependent S-parameters
IConnect Produces S-parameters
Differential, mixed mode and single ended
Insertion, return loss and frequency domain crosstalk
Performance with base DSA8200: 50-60 dB dynamic range (vs.
100 dB for VNA), 12 GHz bandwidth
Performance with 80E10 up to 50GHz bandwidth
Cost ½ of a comparable VNA solution
Intuitive, easy to use and more than adequate dynamic range
for digital designers
58 Tektronix Confidential
TDT and IConnect Eye Diagram
Efficient S-parameters Testing in IConnect
Easy, quick, efficient S-parameter measurements and electrical
compliance testing
– Insertion, return loss, frequency dependent crosstalk
– Excellent correlation with traditional VNA techniques
– Cost-effective and quick
Minimal calibration required
– Only reference at the end of the fixture
– Easy fixture de-embedding
59 Tektronix Confidential
TDT and IConnect Eye Diagram
Why Eye Diagram in IConnect?
Eye Diagram for Interconnects
– Specification mask testing
– Not just communication standards, also for new serial link standards
IConnect benefit: no pattern generator required for
interconnect eye diagram analysis
– De-embed deterministic / interconnect jitter
– No active component jitter
60 Tektronix Confidential
TDT and IConnect Eye Diagram
Eye Diagram Degradation in Interconnects
Interconnect losses
Pattern-dependent, crosstalk induced jitter
Method to improve the eye
– Equalization, pre-emphasis and de-emphasis
– Other signal conditioning techniques
Only deterministic jitter exists in interconnects, no random
component!
61 Tektronix Confidential
TDT and IConnect Eye Diagram
Eye Diagram Options
62 Tektronix Confidential
TDT and IConnect Eye Diagram
New Eye Mask and Jitter Measurements
63 Tektronix Confidential
TDT and IConnect Eye Diagram
Why is TDT Based Eye Better?
Easy to de-embed fixture
– The same improvement as for S-parameter
measurements!
No jitter from the pattern generator
64 Tektronix Confidential
TDT and IConnect Eye Diagram
Predicted and Measured Eye Diagrams
IConnect IConnect
K28.5 PRBS 210-1
65 Tektronix Confidential
TDT and IConnect Eye Diagram
Predicted and Measured Eye Diagrams
66 Tektronix Confidential
TDT and IConnect Eye Diagram
Predicted and Measured Eye Diagrams
1.5Gb/s
(Gen 1)
Simulated Measured
3.0Gb/s
(Gen 2)
Simulated Measured
Simulated Measured
67 Tektronix Confidential
TDT and IConnect Eye Diagram
Efficient Eye Diagram Testing in IConnect
Easy, quick, efficient eye diagram measurements and
compliance testing
– Excellent correlation with traditional pattern generator techniques
– Cost-effective and quick
Minimal calibration required
– Only reference at the end of the fixture
– Easy fixture de-embedding
68 Tektronix Confidential
Outline
Interconnect Measurement Accuracy Issues
TDR/T Probing and Fixturing
App Note: “TDR Measurement Primer”
App Note: “TDR Techniques for Characterization and Modeling of
Electronic Packaging”
Quick Guide:“Interconnect Probing Quick Guide”
Interconnect SPICE / IBIS Modeling and Model Validation
69 Tektronix Confidential
Probing and Fixturing
TDR Measurement Setup
TDR oscilloscope
70 Tektronix Confidential
Probing and Fixturing
Probing and Fixturing Issues
Probing is the weakest link!
Start with a probe
– 50 Ohm for TDR measurements
– must be rugged and inexpensive
– ensure stable repeatable contact
– large pitch* means small bandwidth
– variable pitch means poor repeatability
– ensure sufficient compliance
71 Tektronix Confidential
Probing and Fixturing
Package and Connector Probing
Use a high-quality probe (and positioner)
Need an interface adapter or fixture to probe
Fixturing requirements
– Reproduce the real application environment
– Ensure easy fixture de-embedding (reference short and open structures
may be needed)
H ig h -
Speed P C B p r o v id e s g r o u n d
P C B p r o v id e s C o n n e c to r c o n n e c tio n s
S ig n a l- S ig n a l-
g ro u n d P C B tra c e to
R e fe re n c e G ro u n d G ro u n d
c o n n e c tio n s c o n n e c to r le a d
s h o rt a n d o p e n P ro b e P ro b e
F ix tu r e F ix tu r e
g ro u n d g ro u n d
p la n e p la n e
V ia s to
package P ackage V ia t o g r o u n d f o r r e f e r e n c e m e a s u r e m e n t s
le a d s
72 Tektronix Confidential
Probing and Fixturing
Board Probing
Ensure good contact to a via
– Difficult for a microwave probe
– Use TDA’s QuickTDR™ probe
– Probes also available from TDR
manufacturers
Ensure ground contacts near your
signals
Variable pitch: a sad necessity
– Available from from TDR manufacturers and probe manufacturers
(Cascade Microtech, ICM)
– Measurements suffer from poor repeatability and decrease the
instrument usable bandwidth
73 Tektronix Confidential
Probing and Fixturing
Probing vs. Fixturing
74 Tektronix Confidential
Outline
Interconnect Measurement Accuracy Issues
– Impedance, S-parameters and eye diagram measurements and compliance
testing
Interconnect SPICE / IBIS Modeling and Model Validation
– Z-line, lossy line, and automatic behavioral modeling
75 Tektronix Confidential
Outline
Interconnect Measurement Accuracy Issues
Interconnect SPICE / IBIS Modeling and Model Validation
Measurement Based Interconnect Analysis
– Behavioral Modeling: MeasureXtractor™
– Topological Modeling:
TDT and Lossy Line Modeling
Impedance Profile (Z-line) Transmission Line Modeling
L and C JEDEC computation
– Examples:
Power Plane Analysis
Backplanes and cable assemblies
76 Tektronix Confidential
Measurement-Based Link Design
How to Analyze System Signal Integrity?
C o n n e c to r
Tx B o a rd C o n n e c to r
( s im p lif ie d
C a b le m o d e l)
A s s e m b ly
C o n n e c to r
D a u g h te rc a rd
C o n n e c to r
B a c k p la n e Rx
77 Tektronix Confidential
Measurement-Based Link Design
Interconnect Measurement Based Design
C o n n e c to r
B o a rd C o n n e c to r
( s im p lif ie d
C a b le m o d e l)
A s s e m b ly
C o n n e c to r
D a u g h te rc a rd
Linearize the link input and C o n n e c to r
78 Tektronix Confidential
Measurement-Based Link Design
Measurement Based Design Details
Impedance measurement => reflections
TDR/T or S-parameters => losses, jitter, eye diagram
degradation
– System losses is a result of losses in components
– Eye diagram is a result of losses and crosstalk in components
79 Tektronix Confidential
IConnect Modeling Methodology
Goals and Model Validity
Goal: accurately predict interconnect performance via
simulations
– Need an accurate SPICE /IBIS models
Model required range of validity is defined by the fast corner
rise time of the driver
– Equivalent bandwidth estimated as:
fbw=0.35 / trise or harmonics of clock
It may be desired to extend the required range of model
validity beyond trise and fbw
– Have a confidence guard band
80 Tektronix Confidential
IConnect Modeling Methodology
Modeling Technique: Behavioral
Behavioral Modeling: MeasureXtractor™
– A universal, fully automatic, exact
modeling technique
– Can use time or frequency domain data
– Matches exactly both time and frequency response
– Perfect for…
Connector, package or socket modeling
Model for a characterization fixture for a connector, a package or a cable
Model for a daughtercard board
When behavioral model is acceptable
– Can create large model for a large interconnect such as a backplane or
cable assembly
81 Tektronix Confidential
IConnect Modeling Methodology
Modeling Technique: Topological
Lossy line and coupled lossy line modeling
– When need to predict losses and crosstalk
Large lossy backplanes and motherboards
Cables and cable assemblies
82 Tektronix Confidential
IConnect Modeling Methodology
Modeling Technique: Topological
JEDEC technique for L and C computation
– Industry standard technique for electrically short interconnects
– Electrically short: trise >> tprop delay
– Packages, connectors, sockets
tprop delay
trise
83 Tektronix Confidential
IConnect Modeling Methodology
Behavioral or Topological?
Behavioral Topological
Measurement Requires two-port or four- Just TDR (reflection) is
Requirements port measurements sufficient
Topology Automatic, no user User-controlled (easy and
selection intervention intuitive from TDR
measurements)
Extraction Automatic, no user User-driven; more labor
intervention intensive than behavioral
Type of “Black-box,” no internal Intuitive, easy “what-if”
models changes allowed scenario analysis
Limitation for Large model for long Efficient model extraction
long interconnects (backplanes, processes exist for large
interconnects cable assemblies) interconnects
84 Tektronix Confidential
IConnect Modeling Methodology
Methodology: Gbit Ethernet Example
86 Tektronix Confidential
Outline
Interconnect Measurement Accuracy Issues
Interconnect SPICE / IBIS Modeling and Model Validation
Behavioral Modeling: MeasureXtractor™
– Topological Modeling:
TDT and Lossy Line Modeling
Impedance Profile (Z-line) Transmission Line Modeling
L and C JEDEC computation
– Examples:
Power Plane Analysis
Backplanes and cable assemblies
87 Tektronix Confidential
Behavioral Modeling
MeasureXtractor™ Modeling
A fully automatic algorithm for conversion of VNA S-parameter
or TDR/T data into SPICE or IBIS model
– Passivity of the model guaranteed
– Compact and efficient
– Fully automated
– Not an optimization
– Behavioral models
88 Tektronix Confidential
Behavioral Modeling
Lack of Passivity Produces Oscillations
Slide
courtesy: Instability is a very
bad thing!
TERASPEED
CONSULTING
GROUP
89 Tektronix Confidential
Behavioral Modeling
Sources of Passivity Issues
Insufficient attention to measurements or calibration
– Interconnects do not amplify signals!
– Even if individual measurements are passive, combined system
measurements can have amplification properties
Simulator extrapolation and interpolation based on model, not
original measurement
Finite measurement acquisition window (in the limit, the data is
infinite!)
90 Tektronix Confidential
Behavioral Modeling
Example: Correlation of Measurement and Model
91 Tektronix Confidential
Behavioral Modeling
Example: Model Listing
…
.subckt DUT port1 gnd_ r14 port1 15 -1898.27 c33 34 gnd_ 7.10021e-016
r1 port1 2 -24977.9 r15 port1 16 -971048 r90 35 gnd_ 3622.1
r2 port1 3 23982.9 r16 port1 17 2103.52 c34 35 gnd_ -7.10021e-016
r3 port1 4 -12111 r17 port1 18 15884.8 r91 36 37 176812
r4 port1 5 3124.2
r5 port1 6 -2348.66
r18 port1 19 326913
r19 port1 20 6566.94
… r92 36 gnd_ 57641.7
c35 36 gnd_ 7.15572e-016
r6 port1 7 14099.3 r20 port1 21 1508.55 r93 37 gnd_ 3932.13
r7 port1 8 -4392.43
r8 port1 9 1444.76
r21 port1 22 -885.906
r22 port1 23 4789.5
… c36 37 gnd_ -7.15572e-016
r94 38 gnd_ -2488.86
r9 port1 10 1.1046e+007 r23 port1 24 2788.21 c37 38 gnd_ -3.07009e-015
…
r10 port1 11 -301858 r24 port1 25 -14075.7 r95 39 gnd_ 5982.67
r11 port1 12 3622.64 r25 port1 26 -18495.7 c38 39 gnd_ -2.49077e-014
r12 port1 13 -1221.14 r26 port1 27 -1786.85 .ends
r13 port1 14 6965.14 r27 port1 28 -27328.6
… …
92 Tektronix Confidential
Behavioral Modeling
MeasureXtractor™ Summary
Converts S-parameters or TDR/T data into an exact-match
model
Passivity is guaranteed
If you can measure it, and want model it with little effort, use
MeasureXtractor™!
93 Tektronix Confidential
Outline
Interconnect Measurement Accuracy Issues
Interconnect SPICE / IBIS Modeling and Model Validation
Topological Modeling:
TDT and Lossy Line Modeling
App Note: “Practical Characterization of Lossy Transmission Lines Using TDR”
Impedance Profile (Z-line) Transmission Line Modeling
L and C JEDEC computation
– Examples:
Power Plane Analysis
Backplanes and cable assemblies
94 Tektronix Confidential
TDT and IConnect Lossy Lines
TDT and Lossy Line Modeling Is For:
Long lossy transmission lines in backplanes and motherboards
Long lossy cables
95 Tektronix Confidential
TDT and IConnect Lossy Lines
Loss Example: Time and Frequency Domain
96 Tektronix Confidential
TDT and IConnect Lossy Lines
Skin Effect vs. Dielectric Loss
97 Tektronix Confidential
TDT and IConnect Lossy Lines
Different Loss Modeling Approaches
Lumped (behavioral)
– Defined for all frequencies
– Slow for long lines
Distributed
– Based on parameters (Rskin, Gdielectric)
Defined for all frequencies
Not as general
– Based on RLGC data
General for quasi-TEM
Not defined for all frequencies
98 Tektronix Confidential
TDT and IConnect Lossy Lines
Causality in TEM Models
From basic physics, the real and imaginary parts of the
dielectric constant are tightly related to ensure causality.
The same is true of the permeability constant,
In TEM modeling, this means that R and L are related, and G
and C are related
Models based on RLGC data (or S-parameters) should address
this issue !!!
99 Tektronix Confidential
TDT and IConnect Lossy Lines
Our Model Extraction Approach
Assume standard simulator equations:
Z Rdc Rac f jL
Y Gdc Gac f jC
Two extraction methods:
– Open circuit reflection (TDR, one port)
– Matched circuit transmission (TDR, TDT, two-port)
Extract loss parameters: Rdc, Rac, Gdc, Gac, L, C
Write resulting model in various formats
– Lumped
– Distributed with parameters
– Distributed with RLGC data
T D R s o u rc e 1
B o a r d li n e s
T D R s o u rc e 2
Assumptions:
– The lines are symmetrical
– TDR steps are symmetrical
– TDR steps arrive at the lines at the same time at the beginning of both
lines
Lself Lm Lself Lm
Z odd Z even
C tot C m C tot C m
Zeven>Zself>Zodd
teven>tself>todd
Note:
- Odd mode = differential measurement (two TDR sources of opposite polarity)
- Even mode = common mode measurement (two TDR sources of the same polarity)
Z01
Z02
td
t t
1 2 1 2 1
L Z ( t )dt C dt
2 t1 2 t1 Z ( t )
t1
t2
t1
t2
Simulate,
compare
Extract and verify
Process model
Measure data
and acquire
Long interconnect
– Split lines in multiple segments
Z odd , to d d
-Z odd / 2 , to d d
Z e v e n/ 2 , te v en
tprop delay
trise
R V in c id e n t
Panel
s o u rc e L
C a b le : Z 0 , td
TDR Oscilloscope Front
V V r e f le c t e d
V t
W V in d u c e d
TDR
P ackage
T D R in to t h e u n d e r te s t L L
W
s
p a c k a g e le a d m u tu a l
ad
s h o rt
le
S h o r t le a d
e V
ag
e n d s to b a c k g r o u n d n o is e
ck
M e a s u r e r e f le c t io n
g ro u n d
Pa
M e a s u re n e a r-e n d
Z
c r o s s t a lk in a d ja c e n t Lself 0 (WTDR W short )dt
le a d 2 V 0
TDR waveform:
Z
– TDR into package lead. Lmutual 0 (Winduced Wbackground )dt
Short all the leads to ground on the 2 V 0
inside of the package.
Short the leads that are not being
measured to ground on the outside of
the package.
Induced waveform:
Measure near end crosstalk with far end
of the victim shorted
Short waveform:
– TDR into the “short”; connect the probe Background waveform:
signal contact to ground on a conductive Corrects for the noise and scope DC
(metal) pad offset
R V in c id e n t
Panel
s o u rc e
C a b le : Z 0 , td
V ref o p e n t
V VTDR dt
1 2 1 1
C
C dt ref open
V TD R
2 t1 Z ( t ) Z 0V t1
W V in d u c e d
open
P ackage C
T D R in to t h e u n d e r te s t
C m u tu a l
W
ds
p a c k a g e le a d TDR
lea K e e p le a d V
e
b a c k g r o u n d n o is e
ag
ends open
ck
M e a s u r e r e f le c t io n
Pa
1
M e a s u re n e a r-e n d
c r o s s t a lk in a d ja c e n t C self (Wopen WTDR )dt
le a d 2 Z 0 V 0
1
2 Z 0 V 0
C mutual (Winduced Wbackground )dt
TDR waveform:
– TDR into package lead
Short the leads that are not being
measured to ground on the outside of
Induced waveform:
the package – Measure near end crosstalk with far end of
the victim open-ended
Open waveform:
– TDR into the “open”;disconnect the Background waveform:
probe from the DUT or remove the DUT – Corrects for the noise and scope DC offset
from the fixture
ds
e v e n m o d e T D R w it h c o m m o n
l ea
m o d e s t im u lu s
e
ag
ck
Pa
T D R in t o t h e t w o a d ja c e n t
s o c k e t le a d w it h d if f e r e n t ia l a n d
c o m m o n m o d e s t im u lu s
ds
e v e n m o d e T D R w it h c o m m o n
l ea
m o d e s t im u lu s
e
ag
ck
Pa
T D R in t o t h e t w o a d ja c e n t
s o c k e t le a d w it h d if f e r e n t ia l a n d
c o m m o n m o d e s t im u lu s
Lself
1
Z event even Z odd t odd 1 t odd t
C tot even
2 2 Z odd Z even
1 t odd t
1 Cm even
Lm Z event even Z odd t odd 2 Z odd Z even
2
Ctotal = Cself + Cm
P r o b e p la c e m e n t a t p o in t
o f p o w e r a p p lic a t io n 3"
1 3/8" (35mm)
V ia c o n n e c tio n to b o tto m p la n e
P a d c o n n e c tio n to to p p la n e
R e f e r e n c e s h o r t c o n n e c t io n f o r
in d u c ta n c e m e a s u r e m e n t
T o p p la n e
P o in t o f p o w e r d e liv e r y
R L
R C
C
R C L
R C L 1
C 2
1 1
Lself Z even t even Z odd t odd Lmutual Z even t even Z odd t odd
2 2
***** Partition #1
l1 port1 1 1.9n
l2 port3 2 1.9n
k1 l1 l2 200m
W-line
L=198nH, C=69.7pF
Ro=0.18 Ohm
Rs=0.2uOhm
LC T-line CLC Gd=6.7nS (nMho)
L=700pH Z=53 Ohm L=6nH (long => lossy)
C=280fF Td=520ps C=1.5pF
(short => lossless)
Daughter Card
Model (odd mode)
Backplane
Model
(odd mode)