Material Selection For Refinery Application
Material Selection For Refinery Application
petrochemicals
1
Learning objectives
By the end of this course, you should be able to:
1
Describe fundamentals of metal and alloys,
Engineering materials and their properties
2
Describe the need for material selection
Recognize the principles of selecting metals or alloys
for specific applications 3
2
Introduction to material selection
3
Introduction
The selection of materials has a significant impact on the operability, economics, and reliability of refining
2
units and petrochemical plants
• Design 4
5
• Materials of construction
• Specification 6
• Environmental conditions 10
4
General guidelines for materials selection
• Select materials based on their functional suitability to the service environment 2
• Thorough assessment of the service environment and a review of options for corrosion control must 4
be made
• The use of fully corrosion-resistant materials is not always the best choice 5
• Focus should be on improved corrosion resistance through heat treatment / fabrication method 6
• Alloys chosen should be free of susceptibility to corrosion and should meet strength and fabrication 7
requirements.
• If, after fabrication, heat treatment is not possible, materials and fabrication methods must have
8
optimum corrosion resistance in their as-fabricated form.
5
General guidelines for materials selection
Materials with short life expectancies should not be combined with those of long life in non-reparable
assemblies. 1
For equipment for which heat transfer is important, materials prone to scaling or fouling should not be
used. 2
For service environments in which erosion is anticipated, the wall thickness of the equipment /
component should be increased or more resistant material should be selected. 3
Non-metallic materials should exhibit low moisture absorption, resistance to microorganisms, stability
through temperature range, resistance to flame and arc, freedom from out- gassing, resistance to
weathering, and compatibility with other materials. 4
Fragile or brittle materials whose design does not provide any special protection should not be employed
under corrosion-prone conditions.
5
The most economic material during production stage may not be the most economic one during the in-
use stage . Thus, life cycle cost approaches integrating the companies’ strategies allow more conscious 6
6
and informed decisions during product design stages.
Corrosion and damage control philosophy
2
Materials
upgradation
7 Refractory Design
Linings Changes 3
1
Corrosion
Control
Protective Process
6 Coatings Changes 4
Corrosion
Inhibitors
5
7
Principal Materials for Refineries and Petrochemicals
1
Material for refinery application are expected to exhibit following properti
2
Chemical Properties 8 Fabricability 13
Mechanical Properties
8
Classification of materials
1
Materials
1 1
3
Metals Non Metals
Plastics Ceramics
5
2 2
Ferrous Non Ferrous
Plain
Alloy
Carbon 6 6
6
Stainless 6 Tool
10
Effects of alloying element
Specific effects of the addition of such elements are outlined below. 2
11
Principal materials for refineries and petrochemicals
Steels and other alloys for refinery applications fall within the following categories. 1
Stainless steels
Nickel Steels
12
Principal materials for refineries and petrochemicals
1 5
Carbon Steels
• Most common type of material used
• Standard carbon steel used to 80% of components and almost all structural applications. 2
• In refineries, Distillation towers, separators, heat exchangers, storage tanks, most piping, and all structures are generally
fabricated carbon steel
• Limited corrosion resistance, mainly storage applications
• Recommended temperatures below 425° C
Stainless Steels
14
Stainless Steel corrosion behaviour
Stainless Steels Corrosion response of various stainless steels are as follows: 1
Austenitic stainless steels 3 Excellent corrosion resistance and low temperature performance. Good
high temperature performance
Martensitic stainless steels 4 Good for high temperature sulfidic corrosion than low alloy steels
Precipitation hardening Steels 6 Very high strength Steels. Types are 1’7-4PH, 17-7 PH, and 15-5 PH
15
Typical application of Stainless steels in Refinery/Petrochemica
type 405 (S40500), are not subject to hydrogen stress cracking and are
Ferritic stainless steels 2
therefore used for vessel linings
Used in heat exchangers / piping where carbon and low alloy steel grades are not suitable.
Austenitic stainless steels 3 Stabilised grades SS321/SS347 are used in hydro processing heater and reactor system.
SS316/317 as heater tubes due to resistance against Naphthenic acid corrosion.
Heat exchanger tubes where Cu alloy and SS tubes not permitted due to
Duplex stainless steels 5 ammonia / chloride presence in process streams. REAC tubes and header boxes.
Precipitation hardening Steels 6 It is used for valve seats, pump shafts, pump wear rings, and impellers.
Quick Fact : Stainless steel suffers sigma phase embrittlement when exposed to
temperatures in the range of 538 00C to 95400C).
16
Stainless Steel family
Shown below is the evolution of stainless steel grades starting from basic 304 grade
1 Super Ferritic Stainless Steel
Ni-Cr-Fe
Duplex Stainless Steel
alloys
Alloy
Alloy Properties
• Copper and its alloys combine excellent corrosion resistance with good thermal conductivity,
3 ease of machinability and good strength, especially when alloyed
Copper Alloys • Copper and aluminum alloys are usually restricted to applications below 260°C because of 3
strength limitations
• Used for low temperature, but very corrosive sulfidic and chloridic environments
• Coolers and condensers having high salt content or using seawater
Titanium Alloys 4 • If hydrogen is present, temperatures should not exceed 80 0 C to prevent embrittlement by 4
hydride formation
18
Typical application of stainless steels in refinery/petrochemica
• Nickel is an important alloy constituent of many corrosion resistant materials, including, the
austenitic stainless steels
Ni Steel/Alloys • The stress corrosion cracking resistance of austenitic stainless steels rapidly increases as the nickel
content is increased above 20 percent
• For example, Inconel 600 (700% Ni Cr Fe alloy) shows excellent stress corrosion cracking resistance
and is used for this reason in many refinery applications
Copper Alloys • Monel 400 (a Ni-Cu alloy) is used extensively as a lining in the top of crude oil distillation towers to
resist hydrochloric acid
• High nickel alloys, including Inconel 625 and Incoloy 825, are used to prevent polythionic acid
corrosion of flare stack tips and in hydroprocessing effluent piping
Titanium Alloys • Alloys C-276 have excellent resistance to all concentrations of sulphuric acid up to at least 930 C.
• Limitations : nickel alloys can be attacked and embrittled by sulfur bearing gases at elevated
temperatures 19
Typical application of stainless steels in refinery/petrochemica
• Copper and its alloys combine excellent corrosion resistance with good thermal conductivity, ease of
machinability and good strength, especially when alloyed.
• Copper is a relatively noble metal and is usually not corroded unless oxygen or other oxidizing
agents are present.
Ni Steel/Alloys
• Copper alloys are especially resistant to aqueous corrosion, in both fresh and saltwater, and are
commonly used for heat exchanger tubes.
• One of the more common copper alloys used in refineries is admiralty brass, a copper alloy
containing 28% zinc and 1 % tin, with trace amounts of antimony, arsenic, or phosphorous added for
Copper Alloys
improved resistance to corrosion.
• Admiralty tubes have been used extensively in water cooled condensers and coolers.
• Aluminum bronze, 90-10 cupro-nickel, and 70-30 cupro-nickel are other copper alloys often used in
Titanium Alloys refinery applications.
• Limitations : It experiences significant loss of strength above 260 0C and also have poor resistance to
sulfidic corrosion above this temperature.
20
Typical application of stainless steels in refinery/petrochemica
• Titanium and its alloys Titanium is a highly reactive metal which depends on a protective oxide film
for corrosion protection
Ni Steel/Alloys • Tubes made from pure titanium (Grade 2) are used extensively in overhead coolers and condensers
on a number of units to prevent corrosion by chlorides, sulfides, and aqueous sulfur dioxide.
• Titanium tubes are very useful at locations where seawater or brackish water is used for cooling.
They are also good in sour water stripper overhead service.
• Titanium alloyed with nickel and molybdenum (Grade 12) can be use in under deposit corrosion
Copper Alloys
environment.
• Limitation: Titanium is not suitable for high temperature service and because of its reactivity must
be welded and cut under inert gas conditions to prevent contamination and embrittlement.
Titanium Alloys • From a practical standpoint, use of titanium in refinery service is limited to temperatures below
2600C. If hydrogen is present, temperatures should not exceed 800 F to prevent embrittlement by
hydride formation.
21
1
Non-Metals
Chlorinated Properties of PVC plus the ability to handle temperatures upto 930C.
polyvinyl chloride Uses: cpvc pipe, fittings, and valves suitable for hot corrosive service & hot water distribution
(CPVC) systems.
Lightest thermoplastic , low cost and good chemical temperature resistance up to 60”C. There are
Polyethylene (PE) 2 commercial forms of PE, high density(hdpe) and low density (LDPE).
Fibre reinforced Excellent corrosion resistant properties, composite fibre reinforced plastic (FRP) has displaced
plastic (FRP) other more costly metals. FRP+CPVC finds application in storage of various chemicals like caustic,
HCL, H2SO4 etc.
22
Knowledge check
Knowledge check 1
For concentrated hydrochloric acid storage we require tank made of _______.
Select the correct option and then click submit.
Carbon steel
Nickel alloy
Knowledge check 2
Which of the following curve is used to check suitability for high temperature hydrogen attack
Select the correct option and then click submit.
McConomy curve
None of above
Knowledge check 3
Austenitic
Ferritic
Martensitic
Cementite
Knowledge check 4
Creep failure
Temper embrittlement
Caustic embrittlement
28
Corrosion resistance
Corrosive constituents enter into system through the crude which participate in corrosion of 1
equipment at refining and petrochemical units.
Corrosiveness of
3
Corrosiveness of Hydrocarbons 3 4 Other media
2
Crude Oils Oils
5 Refinery 6
Crude Oil
Ammonia
Sulphur CN
Chloride H2SO4
3
2
30
Classification of corrosion
4
7
31
Corrosion Resistance – Low Temperature Corrosion
Hydrogen Sulfide Corrosion
Preferred Materials -
• carbon steel (hardness <200BHN, Postweld heat treated
• Alloy 400 (<150 OC),
• type 405 or type 304 SS lining (low Chlorides)
• titanium grade 2 for Heat exchanger tubes
H2S corrosion – Shallow pits
Hydrogen Chloride
Preferred Materials -
• Piping - carbon steel.
• Cooler condenser tubes - admiralty brass / Titanium Gr-2,
• column top lining -Monel
Preferred Materials -
• Carbon steel ( 50 to 80 °C, depending on concentration.
• Austenitic SS upto 120 °C, Caustic
• Nickel alloys at higher temperatures Gauging : Failed
tube cross
section
Corrosion Resistance – Low Temperature Corrosion Slide - 16
Preferred Materials -
• Carbon Steel (Velocity: 3-6M/Sec, NH4HS < 8wt%)
• Alloy 825, duplex SS
• Titanium and Alloy C276
ABS Corrosion - HPS sour water
line of HDT
Preferred Materials -
• Carbon Steel (Velocity: 3-6M/Sec, NH4HS < 8wt%)
• Alloy 825, duplex SS
• Titanium and Alloy C276
Preferred Materials –
• 300 Series SS (< 600C)
• Copper alloys (vulnerable to ammonia)
• nickel alloys
Ammonia Cracking
Preferred Materials –
• 300 Series SS and
• nickel base alloys
Preferred Materials -
• Carbon steel ( PWHT as per API RP 945)
• solid or clad stainless steel,
• Alloy 400
Amine Cracking
Preferred Materials –
• chemically stabilized grades types 321 and 347 and
• nickel base Alloys 825 and 625
Material Susceptibility to SCC in different environment
Alloy Environment
Preferred Materials –
• higher chromium alloy (refer Modified McConomy
Curve)
• solid or clad 300 Series SS or 400 Series SS
40
Corrosion Resistance – High Temperature Corrosion
Sulfidic Corrosion Without Hydrogen Present
Preferred Materials –
• higher chromium alloy (refer Modified McConomy
Curve)
• solid or clad 300 Series SS or 400 Series SS
Sulfidic Corrosion With Hydrogen Present (H2/H2S) Effect of sulfur content on corrosion rates predicted by
modified McConomy curves in 290- to 400- °C temperature
Preferred Materials – range.
41
Corrosion Resistance – High Temperature Corrosion
Naphthenic Acids
Preferred Materials -
• A minimum of 2% to 2.5% Molybdenum in SS316 /
alloy.
• For severe conditions, Type 317L stainless steel or
other alloys with higher molybdenum.
Oxidation
Preferred Materials –
42
Corrosion Resistance – High Temperature Corrosion
Naphthenic Acids
Preferred Materials -
• A minimum of 2% to 2.5% Molybdnum in SS316 /
alloy.
• For severe conditions, Type 317L stainless steel or
other alloys with higher molybdenum.
Oxidation
Preferred Materials –
43
Corrosion Resistance – High Temperature Corrosion
Naphthenic Acids
Preferred Materials -
• A minimum of 2% to 2.5% Molybdnum in SS316 /
alloy.
• For severe conditions, Type 317L stainless steel or
other alloys with higher molybdenum.
Oxidation
Preferred Materials –
44
Other damage mechanisms
Pitting corrosion : is a localized form of corrosion by which cavities or
"holes" are produced in the material.
Increase in Molybdenum content in steel increases its pitting Dense pitting
resistance. inside pipe
Preferred Materials -
• Stabilised grades SS321/347 of Austenitic stainless steel by
Titanium (SS 321) or Niobium (SS 347).
• Low Carbon grade 304L or 316L ASS
45
Quick facts
Austenitic Stainless Steels are non magnetic
Stainless steel cracks in chloride but not carbon steel or Copper Alloys
46
Knowledge check
Knowledge check 5
What is present in SS 321 for Stabilisation?
Select the correct option and then click submit.
Niobium
Columbium
Titanium
Molybdenum
Knowledge check 6
Match the columns.
Select the correct option and then click submit.
300 series stainless steel heater tubes in an oil-burning furnace in the hydrocracker began to leak and the
furnace was brought down. What was the probable cause of the cracking?
Select correct option and then click Submit
As regards steel, its oxidation in air increases with increasing metal temperature and decreases with
increasing;
Select correct option and then click Submit
Moisture
Chromium content
Molybdenum content
Carbon content
Knowledge check 9
Carbon steel
Chromes
alloy steel FCCU reactor shell at hot wall portion This alloy is selected over CS due to high
1.25Cr 0.5Mo temperature strength and freedom from
graphitization.
Alloy steels For CDU /VDU /DCU piping based on temperature With increase in chromium content
5Cr-0.5Mo, and 9Cr-1Mo and Sulfur content, fractionator column, resistance to sulfidation increases. SS410,
equipment etc. SS316 are next superior metallurgies
In hydro processing unit before H2 injection point
Duplex SS For REAC tubes and header boxes Excellent resistance to ammonium
(type 2205 / 2507/ bisulfide (NH4HS) corrosion. Selection is
2207) done based in (NH4HS) concentration and
Reboilers, lean/rich exchangers, regenerators, and velocity.
piping. Sour water corrosion resistance.
Cooler condenser tubes in place of Cu alloy for process Due to better resistance to H2S/ ammonia
stream containing high H2S and /or ammonia corrosion than Cu alloys.
Duplex SS PTA – acetic acid service For better resistance in acetic acid attack
54
(type 2205 / 2507/ between 80 to120 Deg C.
Application of commonly used alloy materials
Alloy 600 Nickel alloy 600 weld overlay is done in DCU reactor For high temperature sulfur corrosion
protection
Alloy 400 (Monel) Cladding on top section of CDU column, net gas For resistance against HCL corrosion
scrubber column distributors & inlet piping.
Alloy 800 / 800H/HT Used in hydrogen hot header, outlet pigtail tubes. Good high temperature properties, creep
Thermowell in cold collector resistance.
Alloy 800 has got application in REAC also subjected Excellent ammonium bi sulfide corrosion
to severe corrosion due to NH4HS at temp. below resistance.
60 Deg C
55
Application of commonly used alloy materials
ALLOY APPLICATION CONSIDERATION
HH Alloys furnace-tube supports and Hangers More resistant to ash corrosion by
(25Cr 15Ni to 50Cr 50Ni) vanadium and sodium contaminants in the
fuel occurs. Attention must be given to
strength requirement.
HP modified alloy 25Cr Reformer catalyst tube in HGU Hydrogen attack, creep and oxidation
35Ni No Ti resistance are important factors
Or Incoloy 800H
20Cr 32Ni
35Cr45Ni Naphtha Cracker Unit Heater Radiant Section Hydrogen attack, creep and oxidation
resistance are important factors
Cu-alloy Overheard condensing system for CDU & VDU : For cooling water corrosion.
(Admiralty brass) cooler condensers – Admiralty brass.
Cu alloy Cooler/ condensers tube sheet Higher strength and excellent cooling water
(Naval brass) corrosion resistance
56
Application of commonly used alloy materials
ALLOY APPLICATION CONSIDERATION
Haste alloy PTA – oxidation section Better resistant to HBr attack
(C-276)
Purification section For Erosion resistance
Alloy C-276 Aggressive corrosion occurring in hydro processing Excellent resistance to ammonium
(haste alloy) reactor effluent streams and in units handling bisulfide (NH4HS) corrosion. Selection is
alkaline sour water. done based in (NH4HS) concentration and
velocity. Other material like Titanium /
It is also used for stream containing dilute sulphuric duplex SS are also used.
acid.
Ti alloy PTA – acetic acid service For better resistance in acetic acid attack
(Gr-2) above 120 Deg C.
57
Knowledge check
Knowledge check 10
304L
316H
410S
2205
Knowledge check 11
For Hydrogen sulphide plus hydrogen service what is the preferred metallurgy ?
None of above
Submit
Knowledge check 12
APH
Acid service
Caustic service
Submit
Knowledge check 12
Reformer tubes
Acid service
Caustic service
Submit
Application of commonly used alloy materials
63
Course summary
Selection of a material for a particular service is often done by considering
the loading and aggressive environments encountered. 1
While taking the assessment, you will not be able to access any other part of the course.
The assessment has 10 questions. Note that some questions could have more than one
answer.
Begin Assessment
65
QUESTION 1
Which material is used for making tank required for storing concentrated Sulphuric acid?
Carbon Steel
Nickel alloy
Submit
QUESTION 2
Titanium alloys
35 Cr/25 Ni alloys
50Cr 50 Ni alloys
Submit
QUESTION 3
Pitting resistance
Creep strength
None of above
Submit
QUESTION 4
For Concentrated hydrochloric acid storage we require tank made of which material?
Carbon steel
Nickel alloy
Submit
QUESTION 5
titanium
Niobium
Low carbon
all of above
Submit
QUESTION 6
High hardness
Low hardness
Low pH
None of above
Submit
QUESTION 7
Which curve is used to check suitability for high temperature H2S corrosion (200 to 500 OC) ?
API 941
McConomy curve
None of above
Submit
QUESTION 8
Submit
Question 9
Hardness is primarily an issue with SSC. Typical low strength carbon steels should be controlled to produce
weld hardness less than ________.
Select correct option and then click Submit
225 BHN
237 BHN
200 BHN
240 BHN
Question 10
Caustic embrittlement is a form of stress corrosion cracking characterized by surface-initiated cracks that
occur in piping and equipment exposed to caustic, primarily adjacent to non-PWHT welds. Which of the
following materials is the most resistant to embrittlement?
Select correct option and then click Submit
Carbon steel
400 Series SS
QUESTION 11
Which is the most common method for increasing oxidation resistance of a material
Alloying
Heat treatment
Nitriding
Quenching
Submit
Question 12
Which of the following is a major component of stainless steel contributing to its passivity?
Nickel
Chromium
Molybdenum
Vanadium
Question 13
Carbon Steels
Alloy Steels
Stainless Steels
Carbon Steels
Alloy Steels
Question 15
Carbon steel
Material which is not susceptible to Polythionic Acid Stress Corrosion Cracking (PASCC)?
Carbon Steel
300 Series SS
Alloy 600/600H
Alloy 800/800H
Question 17
Martensitic
Austenitic
Duplex
Ferritic
Question 18
SS405
SS316
Austenitic Ni alloys
B&C
Question 19
Austenitic
Ferritic
Martensitic
Cementite
Question 20
Carbon steel
Inconel
Print
Restart Exit Course
certificate
86