Class 04
Class 04
• Remember to fill out Week Four Class Notes (on ACORN) and upload after class
• Clear skies I hope so a little telescope time
• Test #1 – two weeks today
• All online
• Can write in class or at home
• Will clarify next week what topics are covered
• Open book – BUT, a lot of questions so little time to do any searching –
therefore please study
• Quick review
• Quiz on last week
• No Astronews – telescope instead
• Light and Telescopes – Ch 5&6
Acadia University is located in Mi’kma’ki, the unceded ancestral territory of the Mi’kmaq nation.
ANNOUNCEMENT
One of your fellow students in PHYS 1513 has requested the services of a note taker.
This is an opportunity to help a fellow student by photocopying or emailing your
notes to them.
As this is a paid service, you will be compensated at the end of the term/course.
Good note takers attend class regularly and can capture the essence of their lectures
in a way that someone else can understand. If anyone is interested in providing this
service, please contact Gill in Accessible Learning Services at
accessible.learning@acadiau.ca
Retrograde Motion of a Planet beyond Earth’s Orbit. The letters on the diagram
show where Earth and Mars are at different times. By following the lines from each
Earth position through each corresponding Mars position, you can see how the
retrograde path of Mars looks against the background stars.
COMPLEXITY – OCCAM’S RAZOR?
Ptolemy’s Complicated Cosmological System. Each planet orbits around a small circle
called an epicycle. Each epicycle orbits on a larger circle called the deferent. This system is
not centered exactly on Earth but on an offset point called the equant. The Greeks needed
all this complexity to explain the actual motions in the sky because they believed that Earth
was stationary and that all sky motions had to be circular.
SUN AT THE CENTRE
Objects
orbiting
Jupiter
https://
www.cloudynights.com/
articles/cat/articles/the-
discoveries-of-galileo-–-part-
1-jupiter-r3277
MOON
Moon is not a perfect sphere
https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Galileo%27s_sketches_of_the_moon.png
VENUS
https://www.cloudynights.com/articles/cat/articles/the-discoveries-of-galileo-–-part-4-venus-r3292
SATURN
1616 sketch
1623 sketch
http://galileo.rice.edu/sci/observations/saturn.html
KEY OBSERVATIONS
Eccentricity characterizes
how elliptical an orbit is
Eccentricity - the ratio of the distance between the foci and the length of the
major axis
KEPLER’S LAWS - #2
Kepler’s Second Law: The Law of Equal Areas. The orbital speed of a planet traveling
around the Sun (the circular object inside the ellipse) varies in such a way that in equal
intervals of time (t), a line between the Sun and a planet sweeps out equal areas (A and B).
Note that the eccentricities of the planets’ orbits in our solar system are substantially less
than shown here.
KEPLER'S LAWS - #3
There is a relationship between
how long it takes a planet to go
once around its orbit (orbital
period - T) and the size of the
orbit (semi-major axis - a)
Astronauts in Free Fall. While in space, astronauts are falling freely, so they
experience “weightlessness.” Clockwise from top left: Tracy Caldwell Dyson (NASA),
Naoko Yamzaki (JAXA), Dorothy Metcalf-Lindenburger (NASA), and Stephanie Wilson
(NASA). (credit: NASA)
Shuttle is falling around the Earth (and everything aboard is in free fall)
FIGURE 3.10
Solar System Orbits. We see the orbits of typical comets and asteroids compared with
those of the planets Mercury, Venus, Earth, Mars, and Jupiter (black circles). Shown in
red are three comets: Halley, Kopff, and Encke. In blue are the four largest asteroids:
Ceres, Pallas, Vesta, and Hygeia.
KEPLER’S 2ND LAW AND ANGULAR MOMENTUM
Bigger
Smaller
Same
Smaller
Bigger
Same
SEASONS
Southern Summer. As captured with a fish-eye lens aboard the Atlantis Space Shuttle on
December 9, 1993, Earth hangs above the Hubble Space Telescope as it is repaired. The
reddish continent is Australia, its size and shape distorted by the special lens. Because the
seasons in the Southern Hemisphere are opposite those in the Northern Hemisphere, it is
summer in Australia on this December day. (credit: modification of work by NASA)
SUMMER AND WINTER
Seasons. We see Earth at different seasons as it circles the Sun. In June, the Northern
Hemisphere “leans into” the Sun, and those in the North experience summer and have
longer days. In December, during winter in the Northern Hemisphere, the Southern
Hemisphere “leans into” the Sun and is illuminated more directly. In spring and autumn, the
two hemispheres receive more equal shares of sunlight.
The Sun’s Path in the Sky for Different Seasons. On June 21, the Sun rises north of east and sets north of west.
For observers in the Northern Hemisphere of Earth, the Sun spends about 15 hours above the horizon in the United
States, meaning more hours of daylight. On December 21, the Sun rises south of east and sets south of west. It
spends 9 hours above the horizon in the United States, which means fewer hours of daylight and more hours of
night in northern lands (and a strong need for people to hold celebrations to cheer themselves up). On March 21
and September 21, the Sun spends equal amounts of time above and below the horizon in both hemispheres.
Northern hemisphere – longest daylight hours in late June
Southern hemisphere – longest daylight hours in late December
TIME - NOT ALL DAYS ARE EQUAL
Difference Between a Sidereal Day and a Solar Day. This is a top view, looking down as Earth orbits the Sun.
Because Earth moves around the Sun (roughly 1° per day), after one complete rotation of Earth relative to the
stars, we do not see the Sun in the same position.
Solar day – time interval from noon to noon – where noon is defined to be that moment when the sun is at its
highest point in the sky – culmination
Or, the time taken for the sun to reappear in the same point in the sky
SOLAR DAY - The time it takes for the Sun to return to the same place in our sky after
the Earth has rotated once
Sidereal day - time taken for a star (other then the sun) to reappear at the same point in the sky.
Solar day is longer than a sidereal day by about 4 minutes
Our clocks and watches are based on mean solar time – because the earths orbit is slightly eccentric, the length
of a solar day varies over the year!
LOCAL INDIGENOUS KNOWLEDGE
Moon used as a timekeeper
Phases of the Moon. The appearance of the Moon changes over the course of a complete monthly cycle. The
pictures of the Moon on the white circle show the perspective from space, with the Sun off to the right in a fixed
position. The outer images show how the Moon appears to you in the sky from each point in the orbit. Imagine
yourself standing on Earth, facing the Moon at each stage. In the position “New,” for example, you are facing the
Moon from the right side of Earth in the middle of the day. (Note that the distance of the Moon from Earth is not to
scale in this diagram: the Moon is roughly 30 Earth-diameters away from us.) (credit: modification of work by NASA)
MOON IS TIDALLY LOCKED TO EARTH
The Moon without and with Rotation.
In this figure, we stuck a white arrow into
a fixed point on the Moon to keep track of
its sides.
(a) If the Moon did not rotate as it orbited
Earth, it would present all of its sides
to our view; hence the white arrow
would point directly toward Earth only
in the bottom position on the
diagram.
(b) Actually, the Moon rotates in the
same period that it revolves, so we
always see the same side (the white
arrow keeps pointing to Earth).
Pull of the Moon. The Moon’s differential attraction is shown on different parts of Earth.
(Note that the differences have been exaggerated for educational purposes.)
This is because the force of gravity depends upon distance
Stronger on the side of the earth closest to the moon
Weaker on the side of the earth farthest from the moon
TIDES
Tidal Bulges in an “Ideal” Ocean. Differences in gravity cause tidal forces that push
water in the direction of tidal bulges on Earth.
Why two high tides?
Recall that the earth is also in orbit with the moon
Earth and moon orbit the barycentre (centre of mass) of the earth-moon system
For the earth, that point is about 4700 km from the centre of the earth – still inside the
earth which has a radius of about 6400 km
VARIATION IN THE TIDES
Geometry of a Total Solar Eclipse. Note that our diagram is not to scale. The Moon
blocks the Sun during new moon phase as seen from some parts of Earth and casts a
shadow on our planet.
Geometry of a Lunar Eclipse. The Moon is shown moving through the different parts
of Earth’s shadow during a total lunar eclipse. Note that the distance the Moon moves
in its orbit during the eclipse has been exaggerated here for clarity.
WHY NOT EVERY MONTH?
https://earthsky.org/space/why-is-the-moons-orbit-tilted-collisionless-encounters
QUIZ
STRETCH
Hubble Space Telescope (HST). This artist’s impression shows the Hubble above
Earth, with the rectangular solar panels that provide it with power seen to the left and
right.
MEASURING STARLIGHT
This spectacular image shows many more stars than we can see with
our eyes
It is a time exposure photograph
HOW BRIGHT IS THAT STAR?
Hipparchus – 150 BC
Developed a brightness scale for stars
Brightest stars – 1st magnitude
Next brightest – 2nd magnitude
…
Just visible – 6th magnitude
Modern astronomers retain the magnitude scale
It has the following features:
a) Brighter objects have smaller magnitude numbers
b) It is a logarithmic scale – a magnitude 1 star is 100 times
brighter than a magnitude 6 star – factor of 100 change in
brightness for a change in magnitude of 5
MAGNITUDE SCALE IS BACKWARDS!
Two stars that appear to be equally bright when viewed from earth are not
necessarily the same
They could be at different distances from us!
We now know that in general, stars are at different distances from us
Absolute magnitude takes the distance into account
A STAR APPEARS DIMMER AS WE MOVE AWAY FROM IT
Inverse Square Law for Light. As light radiates away from its source, it spreads out in
such a way that the energy per unit area (the amount of energy passing through one of
the small squares) decreases as the square of the distance from its source.
I(r)
We know the exact mathematical form for this
I – power per square meter
At 2, the intensity would be ¼ of what it is at 1
Po – total power from the star
At 3, the intensity would be 1/9 of what it is at 1 r – distance from the star
ABSOLUTE MAGNITUDE
The absolute magnitude of a star is its apparent magnitude IF it was 32.6 light years away
For example, if we were 32.6 ly from the Sun, it would have an apparent magnitude of 4.8 – a
relatively dim star
100 W bulb – absolute magnitude of 66.3
The difference between the light bulb and the Sun is 61.5 magnitudes
Recall that for every 5 magnitudes, intensity changes by 100
Therefore, Sun is like a lightbulb!!!!!!!!!
CBSKY4: Reference Manual, Noah and Noah -
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/235091689_CBSKY4_Reference_Manual
PARALLAX
We know what an AU is (radar measurement and Keplers’ Law) and we can measure the parallax angle
We then have a right-angled triangle where we know all three angles and one side. This allows us to
determine d, the distance to the star!
Space based telescopes can measure parallax to as small as 0.001 arcsec, which corresponds to 1000
parsecs
Not very far – Milky way is about 30 000 parsecs across
But it is an important start on the “distance ladder”
APPARENT TO ABSOLUTE MAGNITUDE
Apparent magnitude is relatively easy to measure – how bright does a
star appear to us here on earth?
Distance – get using parallax
Absolute magnitude – we can now calculate this
Let m be the apparent magnitude, M be the absolute magnitude and d
be the distance in parsecs
Then
Telescope
Key Ideas
a) Telescope has a much larger opening than our eye whose pupil is typically about 5 mm in diameter. Large
telescopes have collecting areas up to 10 m
• Light collected proportional to area of aperture – telescope/eye – (10 m)2/(.005 m )2 = 4 million times as much light!!!!
b) That light gets focused down onto our eye or a “camera” that has a size comparable to our retina
• A lot of light on a similar area – lets us see much dimmer objects
If we use a camera, we can also do long exposures which allow us to gather even more light
Telescopes are not magnifiers – they are light collectors
REFRACTION
Formation of an Image by a Simple Lens. Parallel rays from a distant source are bent
by the convex lens so that they all come together in a single place (the focus) to form
an image.
TELESCOPE DESIGNS
Refracting and Reflecting Telescopes. Light enters a refracting telescope through a lens at the upper end, which
focuses the light near the bottom of the telescope. An eyepiece then magnifies the image so that it can be viewed by the
eye, or a detector like a photographic plate can be placed at the focus. The upper end of a reflecting telescope is open,
and the light passes through to the mirror located at the bottom of the telescope. The mirror then focuses the light at the
top end, where it can be detected. Alternatively, as in this sketch, a second mirror may reflect the light to a position outside
the telescope structure, where an observer can have easier access to it. Professional astronomers’ telescopes are more
complicated than this, but they follow the same principles of reflection and refraction.
REFRACTORS
World’s Largest Refractor. The Yerkes
40-inch (1-meter) telescope.
Focus Arrangements for Reflecting Telescopes. Reflecting telescopes have different options for
where the light is brought to a focus. With prime focus, light is detected where it comes to a focus after
reflecting from the primary mirror. With Newtonian focus, light is reflected by a small secondary mirror off
to one side, where it can be detected (see also Figure 6.5). Most large professional telescopes have a
Cassegrain focus in which light is reflected by the secondary mirror down through a hole in the primary
mirror to an observing station below the telescope.
A BIG MIRROR
Large Telescope Mirror. This image shows one of the primary mirrors of the European
Southern Observatory’s Very Large Telescope, named Yepun, just after it was recoated
with aluminum. The mirror is a little over 8 meters in diameter. (credit: ESO/G.
Huedepohl)
MOUNTS
Power of Adaptive Optics (AO). One of the clearest pictures of Jupiter ever taken from
the ground, this image was produced with adaptive optics using an 8-meter-diameter
telescope at the Very Large Telescope in Chile. AO uses infrared wavelengths to remove
atmospheric blurring, resulting in a much clearer image. (credit: modification of work by
ESO, F.Marchis, M.Wong (UC Berkeley); E.Marchetti, P.Amico, S.Tordo (ESO))
LIGHT IS A WAVE
c =f 𝜆
HAS DIFFERENT FREQUENCIES AND WAVELENGTHS
Electromagnetic spectrum
Visible spectrum is a tiny piece of the full spectrum
Objects in the universe emit across the full spectrum
MINIMIZE ATMOSPHERIC EFFECTS
High and Dry Site. Cerro Paranal, a mountain summit 2.7 kilometers above sea level in Chile’s
Atacama Desert, is the site of the European Southern Observatory’s Very Large Telescope. This
photograph shows the four 8-meter telescope buildings on the site and vividly illustrates that
astronomers prefer high, dry sites for their instruments. The 4.1-meter Visible and Infrared Survey
Telescope for Astronomy (VISTA) can be seen in the distance on the next mountain peak. (credit: ESO)
COMING SOON
Radiation and Earth’s Atmosphere. This figure shows the bands of the electromagnetic spectrum
and how well Earth’s atmosphere transmits them. Note that high-frequency waves from space do
not make it to the surface and must therefore be observed from space. Some infrared and
microwaves are absorbed by water and thus are best observed from high altitudes. Low-frequency
radio waves are blocked by Earth’s ionosphere. (credit: modification of work by STScI/JHU/NASA)
RADIO TELESCOPES
Robert C. Byrd Green Bank Telescope. This fully steerable radio telescope in West
Virginia went into operation in August 2000. Its dish is about 100 meters across. (credit:
modification of work by “b3nscott”/Flickr)
NO LONGER WITH US
Very Long Baseline Array. This map shows the distribution of 10 antennas that
constitute an array of radio telescopes stretching across the United States and its
territories.
FALSE COLOUR IMAGES
Radio Image. This image has been constructed of radio observations at the Very Large
Array of a galaxy called Cygnus A. Colors have been added to help the eye sort out regions
of different radio intensities. Red regions are the most intense, blue the least. The visible
galaxy would be a small dot in the center of the image. The radio image reveals jets of
expelled material (more than 160,000 light-years long) on either side of the galaxy. (credit:
NRAO/AUI)
SPACE TELESCOPES
Chandra X-Ray Satellite. Chandra, the world’s most powerful X-ray telescope, was
developed by NASA and launched in July 1999. (credit: modification of work by NASA)
WAY BACK IN TIME
Hubble Ultra-Deep Field (HUDF). The Hubble Space Telescope has provided an
image of a specific region of space built from data collected between September 24,
2003, and January 16, 2004. These data allow us to search for galaxies that existed
approximately 13 billion years ago. (credit: modification of work by NASA)
LATEST ONE!
James Webb Space Telescope (JWST). This image shows some of the mirrors of the
JWST as they underwent cryogenic testing. The mirrors were exposed to extreme
temperatures in order to gather accurate measurements on changes in their shape as
they heated and cooled. (credit: NASA/MSFC/David Higginbotham/Emmett Given)
Launched!
Successor to the Hubble Space Telescope
DETECTORS
Infrared Eyes. Infrared waves can penetrate places in the universe from which light is
blocked, as shown in this infrared image where the plastic bag blocks visible light but
not infrared. (credit: NASA/JPL-Caltech/R. Hurt (SSC))
While the atmosphere is not transparent to IR (greenhouse effect), interstellar gas and
dust is
IR telescopes allow us to image further than visible in the plane of the Milky Way
INFRARED TELESCOPE
Observations from the Spitzer Space Telescope (SST). These infrared images—a region of star formation, the
remnant of an exploded star, and a region where an old star is losing its outer shell—show just a few of the observations
made and transmitted back to Earth from the SST. Since our eyes are not sensitive to infrared rays, we don’t perceive
colors from them. The colors in these images have been selected by astronomers to highlight details like the composition
or temperature in these regions. (credit “Flame nebula”: modification of work by NASA (X-ray:
NASA/CXC/PSU/K.Getman, E.Feigelson, M.Kuhn & the MYStIX team; Infrared:NASA/JPL-Caltech); credit “Cassiopeia
A”: modification of work by NASA/JPL-Caltech; credit “Helix nebula”: modification of work by NASA/JPL-Caltech)
ALL WAVELENGTHS IS BEST
Orion Region at Different Wavelengths. The same part of the sky looks different when observed with instruments
that are sensitive to different bands of the spectrum.
(a) Visible light: this shows part of the Orion region as the human eye sees it, with dotted lines added to show the
figure of the mythical hunter, Orion.
(b) X-rays: here, the view emphasizes the point-like X-ray sources nearby. The colors are artificial, changing from
yellow to white to blue with increasing energy of the X-rays. The bright, hot stars in Orion are still seen in this
image, but so are many other objects located at very different distances, including other stars, star corpses, and
galaxies at the edge of the observable universe.
(c) Infrared radiation: here, we mainly see the glowing dust in this region. (credit a: modification of work by Howard
McCallon/NASA/IRAS; credit b: modification of work by Howard McCallon/NASA/IRAS; credit c: modification of
work by Michael F. Corcoran)
STRETCH
We can use prisms (and other gadgets that disperse light) to determine what
colours are/are not in a light source
Dispersion – colour/frequency/wavelength dependent bending of a light beam
SPECTROSCOPY
Prism Spectrometer. The light from the telescope is focused on a slit. A prism (or
grating) disperses the light into a spectrum, which is then photographed or recorded
electronically.
TWO TYPES OF LIGHT
Radiation Laws Illustrated. This graph shows in arbitrary units how many photons are given off
at each wavelength for objects at four different temperatures. The wavelengths corresponding to
visible light are shown by the colored bands. Note that at hotter temperatures, more energy (in
the form of photons) is emitted at all wavelengths. The higher the temperature, the shorter the
wavelength at which the peak amount of energy is radiated (this is known as Wien’s law).
KEY POINT – we can determine the temperature of a hot object by looking at its spectrum!!!
81
BEAUTIFUL STAR FIELD IMAGE
Continuous Spectrum and Line Spectra from Different Elements. Each type of glowing gas (each element)
produces its own unique pattern of lines, so the composition of a gas can be identified by its spectrum. The spectra of
sodium, hydrogen, calcium, and mercury gases are shown here.
KEY POINT – we can identify what chemicals, and their relative abundances, by studying the spectrum a gas emits
84
EMISSION PHYSICS
An excited atom will transition back to a lower energy state by
emitting a photon (light particle)
Every element has its own unique set of energy levels (due to quantum
physics) and therefore its own unique emission spectrum
You may recall doing flame tests in chemistry lab – uses this idea
Copyright © 2016 by Nelson Education Ltd.
85
Copyright © 2016 by Nelson Education Ltd.
86
DUMBBELL NEBULA
ACADIA OBSERVATORY IMAGE
Planetary nebula
Cloud of gas around an
old red giant star
Core of star radiates
ultraviolet radiation (high
energy)
Ionizes the gas
Red outer shell – nitrogen
Blue inner region -
oxygen
87
ABSORPTION OF LIGHT BY GAS
An atom can absorb light at the same wavelength that it can emit
light
http://faculty.virginia.edu/skrutskie/images/light_absorption.jpg
Visible Spectrum of the Sun. Our star’s spectrum is crossed by dark lines produced by atoms in
the solar atmosphere that absorb light at certain wavelengths. (credit: modification of work by
Nigel Sharp, NOAO/National Solar Observatory at Kitt Peak/AURA, and the National Science
Foundation)
Key point – We can determine the chemical composition of the outer layers of a star from the
absorption spectrum
SUMMARY
1) We can determine the temperature of a hot object by looking at its blackbody spectrum
2) We can determine the chemical composition of glowing gas by looking at its emission
spectrum
3) We can determine the chemical composition of the outer layers of a star from its absorption
spectrum
1) and 3) are actually done at the same time
DOPPLER SHIFT
Doppler Effect.
(a) A source, S, makes waves whose numbered crests (1, 2, 3, and 4) wash over a stationary observer.
(b) The source S now moves toward observer A and away from observer C. Wave crest 1 was emitted when the source was
at position S4, crest 2 at position S2, and so forth. Observer A sees waves compressed by this motion and sees a
blueshift (if the waves are light). Observer C sees the waves stretched out by the motion and sees a redshift. Observer B,
whose line of sight is perpendicular to the source’s motion, sees no change in the waves (and feels left out).
KEY IDEA – by looking at the doppler shift of a spectrum, we can determine if a star is moving towards us or away form us
and how fast it is doing so
https://www.falstad.com/ripple/
SUMMARY - WHAT WE CAN LEARN FROM THE LIGHT FROM A STAR