Executive Summary
Executive Summary
Performance Appraisal is a crucial activity for organizations that are looking for growth
and profit maximization in this ever-increasing competitive environment. This project report is a
review based on theory as well as research and experience. The research report starts with the
background and explains its importance in the performance management system and also its
changed scenario. The essential components of an effective performance appraisal system consist
of understanding its foundations and the essential steps that lay the foundation. It is also
necessary to recognize the objectives and benefits of this system. For benefit realization it is
necessary to identify key result areas (KRAs) i.e. goal setting and monitor resulting performance
so that a meaningful relationship between performance, reward and development of required
skill through counseling if required, can be established. Finally lot of brainstorming is required
to be done to device a sound appraisal system by evaluating available techniques and
implementation processes. One must remember that performance appraisal is an inexact, human
process and it is quite a challenge to actually implement it successfully.
Performance appraisal system has gone through a sea change over a period of time. In the
beginning the process was non transparent and the employee was kept in dark about his
performance. No systematic exercise was done and the entire process was arbitrary. The current
processes of performance appraisal involve self-appraisal by the employee too.
Thus the system has gone through the phase of non-transparency to transparency. In the
transparent system of appraisals appraise is taken into confidence and the whole process is
interactive. Review process with employees is designed in such a way that employees become
aware of what is expected from them, receive timely feedback and recognition for their
achievements. Some of these relatively transparent methods are appraisal discussion-dialogue
method of appraisal, competency based appraisal system, potential appraisal, performance and
development planning. While new frontiers to performance appraisal include management by
objectives, 360 feedback and balanced scorecard. In this technology driven era appraisals too can
be done electronically like E Appraisal.
Finally, the repot is rounded up by presenting a case study on one of the top Indian BPO
companies and concluded further.
OBJECTIVES OF STUDY
A) Primary Objectives
1) To study the performance appraisal system.
2) To study the transformation of performance appraisal from traditional
To modern.
3) To get an insight into the relative importance of performance appraisal
In an organization.
4)
5)
6)
Secondary Objectives.
1) To observe the work environment in organization.
2) To get experience and expertise in making projects.
3) To enhance my communication skills.
4) To increase my confidence.
This project covers the definition and meaning of performance appraisal. It elucidates the
benefits and drawbacks of the traditional methods as well as recent advances in the field of
performance appraisal. The project throws light on the concern areas for different people
involved in the appraisal process and attempts to find out ways to overcome those problems.
Appraisees and appraising managers have both been given guidelines in evaluation
process and subsequently the review meeting. It emphasizes how this approach will help the
appraisees by giving them an apportunity to assess and correct areas that their supervisors feel
may have overlooked. Such incidences do happen due to personal likes and dislikes of superiors.
The system can help management to take informed decisions on pay hikes and career
enhancement for their employees.
LIMITATIONS OF STUDY
1) To get contacts of HR managers for interviews was difficult.
2) Getting the views and opinion of the interviewee (HR Manager) was difficult task.
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
The study of the topic performance Appraisal has been done through various Sources.
INTRODUCTION
Todays working culture demands a great deal of commitment and effort from the
employees, who in turn naturally expect a great deal more from their employers. The
development of much more participative style of management in many organizations is a positive
step towards meeting such heightened expectations. This participative style can be expressed in a
variety of practical ways. For eg. Work teams, quality circles, and of course regular performance
appraisals.
Appraising the performance of individuals and groups and organizations has been a
common practice in all societies. While in some instances, these appraisal processes are
structured and formally sanctioned, in other instances they are informal and integral part of daily
activities. Performance appraisal is the method of evaluating the behaviour of an employee at the
work place, normally including both quantitative and qualitative aspects of job performance.
Performance here refers to the level of accomplishments. In the sense that there are expectations
from every person in organizations, a certain level of output or performance is expected from all.
How an employee actually performs in the light of the expectations determines whether his
performance is exceptional, good, average or below that. It is always measured in term of results.
This process has very a high implication on various other HR functions, like recruitment,
training, manpower planning etc.
It is important that the employees are aware of their goals, how to achieve them, how
they are matching up to them, what should be done if they are not. There is not one right way of
doing the performance appraisals. The most appropriate route to be taken will depend upon the
current style and status of the organization. People do have a negative attitude about the
performance appraisals. Many have the complaints such as, its just yearly rollicking , or It
is like school report time or nothing comes out of it anyway A significant consideration in
choosing how to go about introducing or revising a performance appraisal scheme will be an
understanding of how much attitudes have been perpetuated and how they might be overcome.
People carry bad experiences with them for a long time, in this case, perhaps from job to job.
Much has to be done at the time of introducing or revising a performance appraisal scheme to
reassure those who will be involved that the intensions behind conducting the performance
appraisal are sincere and positive.
Performance Appraisal must be seen as an intrinsic part of a managers responsibilities,
not an unwelcome an time consuming addition to them. It is about improving performance and
ultimately the effectiveness all a part of the managers remit.
MEANING :
Performance in a job is a matter, which needs to be considered both in terms of
results achieved and behaviour demonstrated. Results required in relation to quantity,
quality or timing can be established in most espects if a large number of jobs. Comparing
results reached to results required is essential in evaluating the performance. Reviewing
results in the context of actions and behaviour is nessessary to develop a full
understanding of individual performance. In determining what actions have lad to
success or the lack of it, this aspect of examining performance will represent a
significant element in forming plans for the future, so that strengths can be built upon and
weekness addressed. There are, of course, certain jobs or features of certain jobs, where it
is not always possible to state a required result or standard that clearly. In this instances
considering behaviour assumes a greater significance when appraising the performance.
The manager for the home for the elderly, for example would be able to show
ability in controlling budgets in a tangible manner by keeping within certain financial
guidelines. The most important part of such job however, whould concern the health and
well being of residents. Apart from being difficult to measure, these aspects could be
some what beyond the manager s control, and it would be unfair to make an assessment
on the amount of medicines used or the mortality rate. Therefore t follows that the
manager s actions in promoting the good health and wll being of the residents are the
most relevant factor in evaluating performance, rather than the results.
The concept of performance appraisal can be explained with the analogy illustrated
below:
Head
Shaft
Ring
The head of the key represents the uniqueness of the employee. No two
Employees are alike.
The ring represents the managementn requirement the job content.
The shaft represents the communication between the employee and the
Company, the transmission of the task and the response from the performer.
IMPROVING PERFORMANCE:
Building a climate of success involves taking specific steps to improve the performance
of individuals or teams. Because managers depend on that performance, they have a major and
continuing responsibility to take whatever action is necessary to improve it. This is an entirely
natural process of management and whenever anyone complete a task or project good managers
will consciously or unconsciously consider the following points:
How well was that done?
Could it have been better?
Was the right person selected for the job?
In what ways, if any, does the person need to improve?
What guidance or help can be provided to this person to ensure that
Better results are achieved next time?
EXERCISING LEADERSHIP:
There are many ways of defining leadership. Basically, however it is about getting things
done through people. Leaders point out the way and ensure that everyone gets there. Leadership
is about encouraging and inspiring individuals and teams to give their best to achieve a desired
result. Managers as leaders have to achieve the task. That is why they and their teams exist. The
leaders role is to ensure that the teams purpose is fulfilled. If it is not, the result is frustration,
disharmony, criticisms and, eventually perhaps disintegration of the group.
OBJECTIVES OF PERFORMANCE APPRAISAL
Performance appraisal is potentially useful for managers in many ways. At base however
there are two fundamental reasons for developing such systems.
D) Influencing skill :
Maintains a good relation with customers even when their needs cant all be met.
Actively involves others in decision- making and wins co operation.
Uses contacts appropriately to obtain information and help.
It is assertive for self and/or on teams behalf without damaging relationships.
E) Critical thinking :
Readily spots trends and patterns in job-related quantitative and qualitative data.
Tests the quality of available information and draws logical conclusions from it.
Can analyze varied major problems and at the same time identify
Appropriate actions.
I) Strategic perspective :
Understands key organizational aims, values and strategies.
Anticipates how trends and events in different areas of the business and environment will
affect them.
Actively encourages and supports people when they offer different perspective and
opinions.
workforce management applications are available through a hosted application service that
reduces costs and resources required to deploy these applications.
To take a workforce management initiative seriously, you must fully assess the following
segments within your organization:
employee effectiveness through more efficient systems has made this topic a part of the strategy
and planning conversations in executive and regular management meetings. Improving the
maturity and prioritization in your organization will be critical to advance the value and
potential of your workforce.
of
the most
difficult aspects in the performance
appraisal
process has to do with
biases. A bias is defined as a
prejudice
Many different kinds of bias can show up during the performance appraisal process.
Here are five common ones:
1. Contrast This occurs when the manager compares an employees performance to other
employees instead of the company standard. When employees are ranked in comparison,
someone must end up at the bottom, even if they are exceeding the company standard.
The problem isnt the employee its the goal or standard that has been set.
2. Halo An employee is rated highly in all areas because of one thing they do really well.
Ive seen this happen with sales people. She hits the numbers and senior leadership loves
it. But behind the scenes, she creates havoc and doesnt have the respect of her coworkers.
3. Horn On the flip side, an employee is rated as a poor performer because of one thing
they dont do well. For example, the administrative assistant who is great at everything
but filing. It piles up because he puts it off resulting in the company hiring a temp to
get the filing caught up. In all other areas, hes a rock star.
4. Leniency A manager gives everyone on their team a satisfactory rating. Unfortunately,
Ive seen this occur a lot when a manager has a large span of control coupled with a
common review date. The manager has dozens of reviews to work on and a heart full of
good intentions. But somewhere around review number 17, the manager gets burned out
and starts giving everyone a satisfactory response. Because it doesnt require any written
supporting statements.
5. Regency The employees most recent behavior becomes the primary focus of the
review. This can go both ways. A poor performer does something terrific and their past
performance is forgotten. Or an excellent performer makes a mistake and it weighs down
the rest of the review.
INDUSTRY PROFILE
of
bounds.
India is
now the world's favored market for BPO companies, among other
competitors, such as, Australia, China, Philippines and Ireland. The BPO
boom in India is credited to cheap labor costs and India's huge talent pool of skilled,
English-speaking professionals. Research by the National Association of Software
Services and Companies (NASSCOM) has revealed that quality orientation among
leading BPO companies, 24/7 services, India's unique geographic location and the
investor friendly tax structure in India have all made the BPO industry in India very
popular.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
Data entry and data processing: Data entry from paper, books,
images, e-books, yellow pages, web sites, business cards, printed documents, software
applications, receipts, bills, catalogs and mailing lists.
7.
8.
9.
payroll
processing, medical billing, insurance claim forms processing and medical forms
processing.
10. Online research: Internet search, product research, market research, surveys, analysis,
web research and mailing list research.
WNS Group
Wipro Spectramind
Daksh e-Services
Convergys
HCL Technologiess
Zenta
First Source
MphasiS
EXL
Tracmail
GTL Ltd
vCustomer
HTMT
24/7 Customer
Sutherland Technologies.
BPO IN INDIA
BPO benefits i.e. benefits accrued as a result of outsourcing are numerous.
BPO or outsourcing is advantageous as it links to shareholder value. Business Process
Outsourcing is about optimizing business performance to attain value creation. There
has been a tremendous upsurge in BPO and outsourcing industry in many developing
countries like India because of their(BPO)expertise in reducing, costs ,while
increasing,service,quality.
Another great BPO benefit is that it helps companies to focus on core areas.
Companies generally outsource processes to reallocate accountability and control
costs. Thus the management is in a better position to focus on core areas, and not
keep itself engrossed in other areas. Outsourcing also helps companies to avoid
capital expenditures, which is in particular important in non-core areas that may need
new systems and up gradation. By and large, companies only want to spend money on
core
Reduction in costs is another BPO benefit. BPO provides quantifiable benefits
through improved efficiencies, lower overhead, reduced payroll and benefit expenses,
and fewer capital investments. Other BPO benefits include assurance of best
practices, skills, and technology. It is important to note that BPO provides access to
proprietary workflow systems, process reengineering skills, and innovative staffing
and delivery models, coupled with world-class technology delivered by experts.
Productivity Improvements
Cost Savings
Improved HR
Focus on Core Competency
BPO Advantages- At a Glance
Increase in Capabilities
research and development, firms can reduce the cost of developing a new drug,
currently estimated at between $600 million and $900 million by as much as $200
million if development work is outsourced to India. In the US/UK 67-72% of costs
incurred by call centers are directly linked to man power costs whereas call centers in
India spend only 33-40% of costs on man power. This includes spending on training,
benefits and other incentives for labor.
4) Focus on Core Competency : Business Process Outsourcing gives tremendous help to
the companies to concentrate more on the core areas of their business. The most
important factor behind the growth in the BPO market world wide today is an increase
in the number of enterprises that are reviewing their internal operations in an attempt to
fully understand their true core competencies. In the process they are able to focus more
on their core competencies. Business Process Outsourcing gives more freedom to the
management to focus more time, energy, and resources on building the company's core
businesses. It is because the BPOs assume full responsibility for managing the day-today back-office operations. Once outsourcing of certain processes take place it becomes
easier for the company to compare and evaluate the efficiency and effectiveness of
services that are being delivered from outside and inside. This decision-making process
often includes an evaluation of the cost of owning technology - with its associated
support costs, that are not core to the enterprise (HR is one such example). This trend is
leading to an increased keenness to outsource processes that are considered non-core,
yet critical activities. These critical activities include claims administration, HR
services and payment services.
5) BPO Advantages- At a Glance :
Cost reductions- Cost reduction is done through process improvements, reengineering
and use of technologies that reduce and bring administrative and other costs under
control.
Concentration on core business- With the day-to-day back office operations taken care
of, the management is free to concentrate more on the core business of the company.
Outside expertise- Company is saved from the hassles of recruiting and training
personnel. BPOs ensure that experts from another company provide the needed guidance
and
skills.
Cater to changing customer demands- It is another great advantage of out sourcing the
business processes. Many BPOs provide the management with flexible and scalable
services to meet the customers' changing requirements, and to support company
acquisitions,consolidations,andjointventures.
Revenue increase- As stated above, by outsourcing non-core processes, companies can
concentrate on increasing their sales and market share, develop new products; spread out
into new markets and increase customer service and satisfactions.
WIPRO BPO
Winning by Applying Thought
RESEARCH
AND SURVEY